No haste, be patient explained
The policy of "No haste, be patient" is an economic policy to discourage Taiwan's business community from investing in China, proposed by President Lee Teng-hui of the Republic of China (ROC) on September 14, 1996, at the National Operators' Conference (NOC) during his presidency.[1] [2]
Under the Lee Teng-hui Administration
It can be seen that as early as 1987, Sun Yun-Suan put forward a similar view to No haste, be patient in an interview with World Magazine.[3]
In the 1990s, then President Lee Teng-hui and then the Chief Executive Hau Pei-tsun issued three major injunctions in response to Formosa Plastics Group' large-scale investment in the Haicang Project in mainland China.[4] If Formosa Plastics signed an agreement with China on the Haicang Plan,[5] the government would stop the trading of Formosa Plastics' stocks, order the relevant banks to freeze the funds of Formosa Plastics Group, and restrict the departure of Formosa Plastics Group's top executives from the country, among other three major prohibitions. Formosa Plastics enterprises to survive, only to bear the pain of giving up investment.[6]
Before 2000 A.D., in addition to the idea of "No haste, be patient" for investment in the mainland, there was also the "bold westward advancement" advocated by Hsu Hsin-Liang,[7] who was once the chairman of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), and the "strong westward advancement" of the DPP,[8] which came out of debates; the bold westward advancement school believed that Taiwanese businessmen, by moving westward on a large scale, would be able to exert a considerable amount of influence on the mainland,[9] and thus become a guarantee of security for Taiwan, while the no haste, be patient school believed that relying on the labor force and the market of the mainland would hinder the autonomy and the multiple security of Taiwan and that Taiwanese businessmen, on the contrary,[10] would easily become the spokespersons for the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in Taiwan, and that over-expansion in the westward direction would make the spokespersons too strong in terms of politics and economics and would result in asymmetric influences.[11]
At the end of 1994, the renminbi was devalued by 45%,[12] mainland China attracted a large number of investments from various countries,[13] and the funds of East Asian countries began to bleed out.[14]
On August 14, 1996, Lee Teng-hui in the National Assembly (Republic of China) in response to the National People's Congress delegates to the State of the Nation's proposal, pointed out that "mainland China as the hinterland of the construction of Asia--Pacific Regional Operations Center of the argument must be reviewed."[15] On September 14 of the same year, Lee Teng-hui put forward the idea of " no haste, be patient ", and then clearly defined: "high-tech, more than 50 million U.S. dollars, infrastructure" three kinds of investment should be "no haste, be patient", so that Taiwan will not lose its R & D, and will not lose its R & D.[16] "to avoid the loss of Taiwan's R&D advantage and excessive blood loss of capital. Upon publication of this policy, it was questioned by the industrial and commercial sectors and triggered a debate on "how to strike a balance between national and social security and corporate interests."[17]
During his tenure as chief executive, Mr. Hsiao followed Lee Teng-hui's direction of no haste, be patience as the main axis of cross-strait policy.[18] In 1998, he emphasized that the prerequisites for reviewing and adjusting the policy of "no haste, be patient" was that "the Chinese Communist Party eliminates its hostility towards us, ends the coexistence of hostilities, respects the reciprocal division of power across the Taiwan Strait,[19] treats us on an equal footing and in a reciprocal manner, ceases to block our space for international activities, and that the rights and interests of Taiwanese businessmen's investments are safeguarded by the agreement definitively and that it does not affect Taiwan's economic stability and development".[20]
Under the Chen Shui Bian Administration
In 2000, after Chen Shui-bian was elected president, the world economic downturn coincided with the intensification of voices from the industrial sector calling for a relaxation of the "no haste, be patient" policy,[21] and Chen Shui-bian changed the "no haste, be patient" policy to "active openness, effective management.[22] On January 1, 2006, in his New Year's Day speech, Chen Shui-bian changed the propaganda from "active openness and effective management" to "active management and effective openness".[23]
Opposition to the impatient former DPP non-district legislator Lin Cho-shui said:[24] Bian as an "anti-western" savior is very strange, because until 2005 before Bian was the Western faction, he came to power, announced the opening of the small three links, amended the cross-strait relations between the people's regulations, narrowing the restrictions on the Chinese people to come to Taiwan, easing the restrictions on investment in mainland China,[25] the end of 2004, formally passed the "positive opening up" program[26] ......However, his plan was hampered by cross-strait tensions and the delay in opening up the Three Direct Links, which was criticized by the Kuomintang as "locking up the country", thus creating a stereotype of anti-Three Direct Links and anti-cross-strait exchanges among the public,[27] and was finally taken by the losers of the M-shaped society as the savior of economic nationalism. However, he also said that the westward movement will make the income distribution in Taiwan more uneven, but the problem cannot be solved without haste and impatience.[28]
Estimation
Positively
- In 2020, a Taiwan poll showed that 68.1% of the public affirmed that Lee Teng-hui had adopted a policy of caution and patience to avoid the rapid loss of Taiwan's industries.[29]
The negative side
- Media personality Zhao Shaokang believes that: the effect of using political power to intervene in the economy is limited, rather than banning it, it is better to cooperate with mainland Chinese companies or even go further to find ways to dominate.[30]
- Li Ao satirized, quit the urgent use of forbearance is completely a kind of ostrich policy,[31] "can not order, but also do not receive orders"; he believes that businessmen are smarter than politicians,[32] so Taiwan's businessmen will be in a hurry to enter the market in mainland China to get into the card position, to grasp the business opportunities; "(Taiwan) should take advantage of the opportunity to take advantage of the problem, there is nothing to endure or not to endure. There are benefits, only endure. No benefits, endure what?"[33]
Else
- On January 29, 2007, Lee Teng-hui was said in an exclusive interview with Taiwan Next Magazine that he was not advocating that Taiwan could not have a relationship with mainland China and was very concerned that there was no communication platform across the Taiwan Strait at all.[34] He criticized: that the economy was originally a two-way street, but the DPP turned it into a one-way street, "the whole of Taiwan is like a bucket of water, the water has been flowing out, did not come back, how do the people live?" [35] He also criticized the DPP: "Policies have changed and changed, active openness has changed to active management, simply outrageous!"[36] [37]
- On June 29, 2010, the government of the Republic of China signed the Cross-Strait Economic Cooperation Framework Agreement (ECFA) in Chongqing,[38] President Ma Ying-jeou and Executive Yuan Liu Shao-Hsuan regarded it as an important policy to strengthen Taiwan's economic development, and the "Caveat Emptor" policy can be said to be terminated for the time being, but only after the outbreak of the Sunflower Student Movement cross-strait exchanges came to an abrupt end.[39]
A lost or apocryphal story
" no haste, be patient " was originally a motto given by Emperor Kangxi to his fourth son, Yinzhen (who later ascended the throne as Emperor Yongzheng).[40] In 1996, Lee Teng-hui in the "National Operators Conference" speech for the first time with the words "quit haste and use patience" to describe his view of the Republic of China mainland China should be the economic policy,[41] because organizers of HD would like to invest in mainland China dissatisfied with Lee Teng-hui not going to go, so he changed his mind and attended the night before informing the secretary Su Zhicheng draft,[42] Su Zhicheng rushed home overnight to catch up on the draft, according to the boss's conversation, he picked up the desk of the idiom reference book and copied "Do not be in a hurry, to have patience" into the article. Because it was done in a hurry, there was no verification of the source. Therefore, the use of " no haste, be patient " was an accidental work of Su Zhicheng.[43]
References
- Web site: presidentlee . 李登輝與戒急用忍 . Lee Teng-hui and the no haste, be patient . 2023-12-23 . 財團法人李登輝基金會 . zh-TW.
- Web site: 台湾经济为何与大陆脱不了钩 . Why Taiwan's economy can't disconnect from the mainland . 2023-12-23 . bj.crntt.com.
- Web site: 关于孙运璿 . About Sun Yunsuan . 2023-12-20 . www.sysmm.org.
- Web site: YuKun . Bai . 民进党反制惠台措施后座力会很猛烈 . The backlash of the DPP's countermeasures to benefit Taiwan will be fierce - Straits Feihong Mobile Edition . 2023-12-15 . www.itaiwannews.cn.
- Web site: 2011-04-06 . 台塑如何错失良机?王永庆"海沧计划"破局内幕 . How did Formosa Plastics miss the opportunity? The inside story of Wang Yongqing’s “Haicang Plan” breaking through . 2023-12-20 . LivingTek Commerce CO.,LTD . zh-TW.
- Web site: [纪事]王永庆"海沧计划"破局内幕-文学100 . [Chronicle] The inside story of Wang Yongqing's "Haicang Project" breaking through - Literature 100 . 2023-12-20 . www.wenxue100.com.
- Web site: 戒急用忍 . no haste, be patient . 2023-12-15 . www.factpedia.org . zh.
- Web site: "大胆西进"衰?"新戒急用忍"兴?郭正亮退离对民进党两岸论述及路线之影响 - 海峡飞虹移动版 . The decline of "boldly advancing westward"? The rise of "new caution, urgency, and patience"? The impact of Guo Zhengliang's retreat on the cross-strait discussion and line of the DPP - Straits Feihong Mobile Edition . 2023-12-20 . www.itaiwannews.cn.
- Web site: 从两岸"三通"走向"新四通", 深化两岸融合发展正当其时(两岸观察)_新闻频道_中国青年网 . It is time to move from the "three direct links" across the Taiwan Strait to the "new four direct links" and deepen cross-strait integrated development (Cross-Strait Observation)_News Channel_China Youth Network . 2023-12-20 . news.youth.cn.
- News: 2001-11-06 . 台灣將為戒急用忍政策鬆綁 . Taiwan will loosen restrictions on its "no haste, be patient" policy . zh-hant .
- Web site: "台独"从不是民进党建党初衷-中新网 . "Taiwan independence" was never the original intention of the DPP when it was founded-China News . 2023-12-20 . www.chinanews.com.cn.
- Web site: 1994年人民幣曾經貶值33% . In 1994, the RMB devalued by 33%– Strategy . 2023-12-15 . zh-TW.
- Web site: Guo . Li . 百家跨国公司看中国 . Hundreds of multinational companies look at China . 2023-12-15 . m.21jingji.com.
- Web site: Jianli . Liu . 新中国利用外资70年:历程、效应与主要经验 . 70 years of foreign investment utilization in New China: history, effects and main experiences . 2023-12-20 . chinawto.mofcom.gov.cn.
- Web site: 1996年12月 - 台湾大事记 - 资料频道 . December 1996 - Major Events in Taiwan - Information Channel . 2023-12-20 . zl.huaxia.com.
- Web site: 2020-07-30 . 曾提戒急用忍!李登輝縱橫政壇近半世紀 盤點經典名言 . I once warned you to be patient in haste! Lee Teng-hui has dominated politics for nearly half a century and takes stock of classic quotes . 2023-12-20 . Yahoo News . zh-Hant-TW.
- Web site: 2020-07-31 . 李登輝「戒急用忍」遠見遭質疑 20年後台積電、聯電兩樣情 . Lee Teng-hui's foresight of "no haste, be patient" has been questioned. The situation of Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd. and UMC in the past 20 years . 2023-12-20 . Yahoo Finance . zh-Hant-TW.
- News: 2001-05-08 . 萧万长赴京促两岸共同市场 . zh-hans . Xiao Wanchang went to Beijing to promote the cross-strait common market . 2023-12-20.
- Web site: 萧万长将向台湾当局申请大陆行 . Xiao Wanchang will apply to the Taiwan authorities for a trip to the mainland . 2023-12-20 . lianghui.china.com.cn.
- Web site: 台湾问题与新时代 . Taiwan Issue and the New Era . 2023-12-20 . www.mfa.gov.cn.
- Web site: 台湾经济为何与大陆脱不了钩 . Why Taiwan’s economy cannot be decoupled from mainland China . 2023-12-15 . bj.crntt.com.
- Web site: Zhang . Shuhui . 2009-06-19 . 中國「以華盛頓遏制台北」的策略(1995.6~2008.3)-基於博弗雷「間接戰略」理論的分析。 . China's Strategy of “Containing Taipei Through Washington”(1995.6~2008.3)-An Analysis based on Beaufre's “Indirect Strategy” Theory. .
- Web site: Heman . Zhao . 台湾政局变化对海外侨社的影响 . The Impact of Taiwan's Political Changes on Overseas Communities . 2023-11-05 . qwgzyj.gqb.gov.cn.
- Web site: 央视网 . CCTV.com . 2023-12-20 . news.cctv.com.
- Web site: 台湾民主自治同盟 . Taiwan Democratic Self-Government Alliance . 2023-12-20 . www.taimeng.org.cn.
- Web site: 解读陈水扁执政六年来台湾当局两岸经贸政策_新闻中心_新浪网 . Interpretation of Taiwan authorities’ cross-strait economic and trade policies during Chen Shui-bian’s six years in office_News Center_Sina.com . 2023-12-20 . news.sina.com.cn.
- Web site: 台湾问题︱_澎湃研究所_澎湃新闻-The Paper . Taiwan Issue︱_The Paper Research Institute_The Paper News-The Paper . 2023-12-20 . www.thepaper.cn.
- Web site: 推动直接"三通"开创两岸经济合作新局面 . Promoting the direct "Three Direct Links" to create a new situation for cross-strait economic cooperation. .
- Web site: 2021-02-12 . 台灣智庫民調:68.1%民眾肯定李登輝對大陸戒急用忍 . Taiwan Poll: 68.1% of people affirm Lee Teng-hui's cautionary approach to China Politics News United News . 2023-11-05 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210212091551/https://udn.com/news/story/6656/5080968 . 2021-02-12 .
- Web site: Guanyu . Zhu . 2022-01-03 . 「李登輝的戒急用忍真的害了台灣!」趙少康:經濟自此原地踏步 . Lee Teng-hui's "no haste, be patient" Has Really Harmed Taiwan! Chiu Siu-hong: Economy has remained stagnant since then - Windy Media . 2023-11-05 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220103205620/https://www.storm.mg/article/2902335 . 2022-01-03 .
- Web site: "台独"的渊源与实质(下)—兼论台湾问题的基本估计与中国统一的可能前景 . The Origin and Essence of "Taiwan Independence" (Part 2)—Also Discussing the Basic Estimates of the Taiwan Issue and the Possible Prospects of China's Unification - Free Essay Network . 2023-12-15 . m.lunwendata.com.
- Web site: 李敖的主张 . Li Ao's proposition . 2023-12-20 . www.sohu.com.
- Web site: 李登輝對不起台灣人民的十大不良影響=台灣政經亂象的十大禍源 . Lee Teng-hui's Ten Bad Influences on the People of Taiwan = Ten Major Causes of Taiwan's Political and Economic Chaos .
- Web site: 李登辉声称"我想访问大陆" 强调自己"从未搞过台独"..._新闻中心_新浪网 . Lee Teng-hui claimed that "I want to visit the mainland" and emphasized that he had "never engaged in Taiwan independence"..._News Center_Sina.com . 2023-12-20 . news.sina.com.cn.
- Web site: CCTV.com-李登辉开炮:民进党表现得很没有能力 . CCTV.com-Lee Teng-hui: The DPP appears to be very incompetent . 2023-12-20 . news.cctv.com.
- Web site: 兩岸觀察台灣蘋果日報創刊在即各媒體緊急迎戰 . Taiwan's Apple Daily to launch soon, media outlets rush to meet the challenge - Xinhua-Australia Newspaper . 2023-11-05 . www.waou.com.mo.
- Web site: 李登辉:我不是台独 "两国论"不是我原意 . Lee Teng-hui: I'm not a Taiwan independence "two-state theory" is not my original intention_Information_Phoenix New Media . 2023-11-05 . news.ifeng.com.
- Web site: 海峡两岸经济关系步入制度化合作——ECFA解读 . Cross-Strait economic relations have entered institutionalized cooperation—ECFA interpretation . 2023-12-15 . www.gov.cn.
- Web site: Siqi . Yan . 2015-03-19 . 台湾来鸿﹕318学运周年回顾与前瞻 . Taiwan Laihong: Review and Prospects of the 318 Student Movement Anniversary . 2023-12-15 . BBC News 中文 . zh-hans.
- Web site: 北大西门的两座古建筑——恩佑寺与恩慕寺残迹背后的故事 . The story behind the remnants of the two ancient buildings at the west gate of Peking University - Enyou Temple and Enmu Temple_Ancient Art_The Paper-The Paper . 2023-12-15 . m.thepaper.cn.
- Web site: 中共十五大与两岸关系 . The 15th National Congress of the Communist Party of China and Cross-Strait Relations . 2023-12-20 . www.modernchinastudies.org.
- Web site: 台湾苏志成是谁_百度知道 . Who is Taiwanese Su Zhicheng_Baidu knows . 2023-12-20 . zhidao.baidu.com.
- Web site: 2020-09-09 . 李登輝「戒急用忍」1996 . Lee Teng-hui「No Hurry, No Impatience」1996 . 2023-12-20 . Yahoo News . zh-Hant-TW.