New York–Penn League Explained

Sport:Baseball
Classification:Class A Short Season
Country:United States
Champion:Brooklyn Cyclones (2019)
Most Champs:Oneonta Yankees (12)

The New York–Penn League (NYPL) was a Minor League Baseball league that operated in the northeastern United States from 1939 to 2020. Classified as a Class A Short Season league, its season started in June, after major-league teams signed their amateur draft picks to professional contracts, and ended in early September.

In 2019, its last season of operation, the NYPL had 14 teams from eight different states. In addition to New York and Pennsylvania, from which the league drew its name, the NYPL also had clubs in Maryland, Massachusetts, Ohio, Vermont, West Virginia, and Connecticut.

The Brooklyn Cyclones were the last NYPL champions, defeating the Lowell Spinners, two games to one, in 2019. The Oneonta Yankees/Tigers won 12 championships, the most among all teams in the league, followed by the Auburn Mets/Twins/Phillies/Doubledays (8) and Jamestown Falcons/Expos (7).

History

The New York–Penn League was founded in 1939 as the Pennsylvania–Ontario–New York League, generally shortened to PONY League, in a hotel in Batavia, New York. The original teams included the Batavia Clippers, Bradford Bees, Hamilton Red Wings, Jamestown Jaguars, Niagara Falls Rainbows, and Olean Oilers; all were based in or near Western New York. The Oilers, a Brooklyn Dodgers affiliate, won both the regular season and playoff championships. Batavia was the last remaining charter city in the league when it ceased operations after the 2020 season.

The Hamilton Red Wings folded early in the 1956 season, and with no more teams in Ontario, the circuit became the New York–Penn League in 1957. The league crossed back into Canada with the formation of the St. Catharines Blue Jays in 1986. They were joined by the Hamilton Redbirds in 1987 and the Welland Pirates in 1989, but all three clubs had moved back to the United States by 2000.

The New York–Penn circuit was originally a Class D league (the minors' lowest classification through 1962). It was a full-season Class A league from 1963 through 1966, and became a short-season Class A league in 1967.

The start of the 2020 season was postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic before being cancelled on June 30.[1] [2]

In popular media

Good Enough to Dream is a memoir by renowned baseball writer Roger Kahn, published in 1985. The book chronicles Kahn's experience as the owner of the Utica Blue Sox during the 1983 season. Good Enough to Dream was the recipient of the Casey Award in 1985.

Clubbie is a 2021 memoir by Greg Larson that recounts his experiences as a clubhouse attendant (or "clubbie") for the Aberdeen IronBirds during the 2012 and 2013 seasons. The book's depiction of players' financial struggles[3] is widely credited with inspiring changes to long-standing minor league compensation structures.[4] [5]

Disbanding

On December 9, 2020, Major League Baseball (MLB) announced its list of 120 teams invited to be a part of the minors after restructuring for the 2021 season. As first reported in 2019,[6] the NYPL ceased operations. The Aberdeen IronBirds, Brooklyn Cyclones, and Hudson Valley Renegades joined the new High-A East, becoming the new High-A affiliates of the Baltimore Orioles, New York Mets, and New York Yankees respectively. The Mahoning Valley Scrappers, State College Spikes, West Virginia Black Bears, and Williamsport Crosscutters moved to the new MLB Draft League for players wishing to showcase themselves to MLB teams in advance of the annual draft. The Tri-City ValleyCats moved to the independent Frontier League,[7] while the Batavia Muckdogs and Auburn Doubledays joined the Perfect Game Collegiate Baseball League.[8] [9] On February 25, 2021, the Vermont Lake Monsters announced that they would join the Futures Collegiate Baseball League (FCBL) under new ownership,[10] and the Norwich Sea Unicorns joined the FCBL in late April.[11] The Staten Island Yankees folded,[12] while the Lowell Spinners were left without future plans[13] and eventually folded.

Final franchises

DivisionTeamMLB AffiliationCityStadiumCapacity2021 League
McNamaraAberdeen IronBirdsBaltimore OriolesAberdeen, MarylandLeidos Field at Ripken Stadium6,300High-A East
Brooklyn CyclonesNew York MetsBrooklyn, New YorkMCU Park7,000High-A East
Hudson Valley RenegadesTampa Bay RaysFishkill, New York
(Poughkeepsie/Newburgh area)
Dutchess Stadium4,494High-A East
Staten Island YankeesNew York YankeesStaten Island, New YorkRichmond County Bank Ballpark7,171Folded[14]
(Replacement team would play in the Atlantic League in 2022)
PinckneyAuburn DoubledaysWashington NationalsAuburn, New YorkFalcon Park2,800Perfect Game League
(Collegiate baseball)
Batavia MuckdogsMiami MarlinsBatavia, New YorkDwyer Stadium2,600Perfect Game League
(Collegiate baseball)
Mahoning Valley ScrappersCleveland IndiansNiles, Ohio
(Youngstown area)
Eastwood Field6,000MLB Draft League
(Collegiate baseball)
State College SpikesSt. Louis CardinalsUniversity Park, PennsylvaniaMedlar Field at Lubrano Park5,570MLB Draft League
(Collegiate baseball)
West Virginia Black Bears Pittsburgh PiratesGranville, West Virginia
(Morgantown area)
Monongalia County Ballpark2,500MLB Draft League
(Collegiate baseball)
Williamsport CrosscuttersPhiladelphia PhilliesWilliamsport, PennsylvaniaBB&T Ballpark at Historic Bowman Field2,366MLB Draft League
(Collegiate baseball)
StedlerLowell SpinnersBoston Red SoxLowell, MassachusettsEdward A. LeLacheur Park4,767Folded[15] [16]
Norwich Sea Unicorns Detroit TigersNorwich, ConnecticutSenator Thomas J. Dodd Memorial Stadium6,270Futures Collegiate Baseball League
(Collegiate baseball)
Tri-City ValleyCatsHouston AstrosTroy, New York
(Capital District)
Joseph L. Bruno Stadium4,500Frontier League
Vermont Lake MonstersOakland AthleticsBurlington, VermontCentennial Field4,400Futures Collegiate Baseball League
(Collegiate baseball)

Champions

See main article: List of New York–Penn League champions.

League champions were determined by different means during the New York–Penn League's 82-year run from 1939 to 2020. For a few seasons in the 1960s and 1970s, no playoffs were held and the league champions were simply the regular season pennant winners. Most seasons, however, ended with playoffs to determine a league champion.[17]

The Oneonta Tigers won 12 championships, the most among all teams in the league, followed by the Auburn Mets/Twins/Phillies/Doubledays (8) and Jamestown Falcons/Expos (7).[17]

Teams

Cities represented

Connecticut

2010–2020 (16 seasons)

Maryland

2002–2020 (19 seasons)

Massachusetts

1996–2020 (25 seasons)

1989–2001 (13 seasons)

New Jersey

1994–2005 (12 seasons)

New York

1958–1980, 1982–2020 (62 seasons)

1939–1953, 1957–1959, 1961–2020 (78 seasons)

1964–1966 (3 seasons)

2001–2020 (20 seasons)

1951–1960, 1968–1969 (12 seasons)

1957–1961, 1973–1995 (28 seasons)

1994–2020 (26 seasons)

1958–1973, 1977–1993 (33 seasons)

1993 (1 season)

1939–1957, 1962–1973, 1977–2014 (67 seasons)

1942–1957 (16 seasons)

1977–1988 (12 seasons)

1942–1950 (9 seasons)

1968–1979, 1983–1987 (17 seasons)

1939–1940, 1970–1979, 1982–1985, 1989–1993 (21 seasons)

1939–1959, 1961–1966 (27 seasons)

1966–2009 (44 seasons)

2000 (1 season)

1999–2020 (22 seasons)

2002–2020 (18 seasons)

1977–2001 (25 seasons)

1983–1998 (16 seasons)

1942–1961, 1963–1965 (23 seasons)

Ohio

1999–2020 (22 seasons)

Pennsylvania

1939–1942, 1944–1957 (18 seasons)

1954–1963, 1967, 1981–1993, 1995–1998 (28 seasons)

2006–2020 (15 seasons)

1968–1972, 1994–2020 (32 seasons)

1923–1933, 1936 (moved to Trenton July 2) (12 seasons)

Vermont

1994–2020 (27 seasons)

West Virginia

2015–2020 (6 seasons)

Ontario

1939–1942, 1946–1956, 1988–1992 (20 seasons)

1940–1942 (2 seasons)

1986–1999 (14 seasons)

1989–1994 (5 seasons)

Hall of Fame

See main article: New York–Penn League Hall of Fame. The New York–Penn League Hall of Fame was established in 2012 to honor league players, managers, and executives for their accomplishments or contributions to the league in playing or administrative roles. The Hall of Fame inducted its first class of seven men in 2012. New members were elected before the start of each season.[18]

Notes and References

  1. News: A Message From Pat O'Conner. Minor League Baseball. March 13, 2020. May 5, 2020.
  2. News: 2020 Minor League Baseball Season Shelved. Minor League Baseball. June 30, 2020. July 1, 2020.
  3. Web site: News . Mark Whicker Daily . 2021-07-08 . Whicker: Greg Larson’s ‘Clubbie’ shows baseball’s bleak heart, powerful grip . 2024-06-18 . Orange County Register . en-US.
  4. Web site: Leighton . Aram . 2021-05-30 . He Watched Minor Leaguers Struggle. His New Book Could Change the Game. . 2024-06-18 . Boardroom . en-US.
  5. Web site: Diunte . Nick . Greg Larson’s ‘Clubbie’ Exposes The Rough Finances Of Minor League Life . 2024-06-18 . Forbes . en.
  6. News: Rob Manfred's plan to destroy minor league baseball . Bill . Madden . Bill Madden (sportswriter) . . November 16, 2019 . November 17, 2019.
  7. Web site: Singelais. Mark. 2021-01-07. Tri-City ValleyCats join Frontier League for 2021 season. 2021-01-13. Times Union. en-US.
  8. Web site: Viquez. Marc. 2021-01-12. Baseball is Back in Batavia. 2021-01-13. Stadium Journey. en-US.
  9. News: Auburn finalizing agreement to join Perfect Game Collegiate Baseball League.
  10. Web site: Reichard. Kevin. 2021-02-25. Vermont Lake Monsters sold, will join Futures League. 2021-02-25. Ballpark Digest. en-US.
  11. News: Sea Unicorns join Futures League . . . April 27, 2021.
  12. Web site: Reichard. Kevin. 2020-12-03. Staten Island Yankees fold, will sue MLB. 2020-12-17. Ballpark Digest. en-US.
  13. News: Major League Baseball issues invites for minor-league affiliates; here are teams that didn't make cut . Gabe . Lacques . . December 10, 2020 . December 11, 2020.
  14. Web site: Staten Island Yankees fold, sue MLB, NY Yankees. New York Post. 3 December 2020 .
  15. News: Pro baseball at home of Lowell Spinners unlikely this season, mayor says. The Boston Globe. Michael. Silverman. February 25, 2021.
  16. News: Renovations coming to LeLacheur Park, but return of Spinners unlikely. Boston Herald. December 8, 2023. Mac. Cerullo.
  17. Web site: New York–Penn League Champions. New York–Penn League. Minor League Baseball. August 9, 2017. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20160531195604/http://www.milb.com/content/page.jsp?ymd=20140108&content_id=66405068&fext=.jsp&sid=l127&vkey=league2. 2016-05-31 .
  18. Web site: New York–Penn League Hall of Fame. New York–Penn League. Minor League Baseball. August 8, 2017.