National Labour Party (Ireland) Explained

Country:the Republic of Ireland
National Labour Party
Native Name:Páirtí Náisiúnta an Lucht Oibre
Native Name Lang:ga
Leader1 Title:Leaders
Leader1 Name:William O'Brien,
James Everett
Foundation:1944
Dissolution:1950
Affiliation1 Title:Union Affiliation
Affiliation1:Irish Transport and General Workers' Union
Ideology:Social democracy
Anti-communism
Split:Labour Party
Merged:Labour Party
Chairperson:Thomas Foran
General Secretary:Seamus O'Farrell (1947)

The National Labour Party ([1]) was an Irish political party active between 1944 and 1950. It was founded in 1944 from a rebel faction of the Labour Party, inspired by the intransigence of the incumbent leadership of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union (ITGWU) against the majority of the party on the basis that communists had infiltrated Labour at the turn of the 1940s.[2]

History

The split in the Labour Party was preceded by divisions in the broader labour movement, specifically the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union under William O'Brien and the Workers' Union of Ireland under James Larkin.[3] Larkin had rejoined the party in 1941, and two years later, he was nominated by the Dublin North-East branch of the Labour Party to contest the 1943 general election. The Administrative Council of the national party, with ITGWU members in the majority, refused to ratify this nomination. However, the Dublin party and Dublin-based candidates supported Larkin, as did Labour leader William Norton, and eventually Larkin was a victorious Labour candidate.[4] When the ITGWU faction sought the expulsion of Dublin officials as revenge, it was routed. Two weeks later, the ITGWU disaffiliated from the Labour Party. Five of the eight TDs sponsored by the union resigned from the parliamentary party to form the National Labour Party in January 1944,[5] led by William O'Brien and James Everett. Senator Thomas Foran was appointed chairman of the party.[6] Foran was still recognised by other Labour senators as Leader of the Labour Party in the Seanad.[7]

There was much bitterness between the two parties. The ITGWU claimed that communists had infiltrated the Labour Party. The ITGWU attacked "Larkinite and Communist Party elements" which it claimed had taken over the Labour Party. The split and the anti-communist assault put Labour on the defensive. Alfred O'Rahilly in The Communist Front and the Attack on Irish Labour widened the assault to include the influence of British-based unions and communists in the ITUC. The National Labour Party juxtaposed itself against this by emphasising its commitment to Catholic Social Teaching.[8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] Presiding at a meeting of the provisional executive of the party in March 1944, Thomas Foran expressed its "unqualified support" of Irish neutrality and condemned a declaration of the Communist Party of Ireland "expressing approval of the attempt to force this country to abandon neutrality."[14] Senator Michael Colgan, a National Labour candidate speaking of the party in May 1944, claimed that "they had broken away from the Irish Labour Party because it was not Irish, nor did it fulful the expectations that an Irish labour party should have for the people."[15] Speaking after Mass, Cork general election candidate P.J O'Brien claimed that "with the dissolution of the Communist Party of Ireland, these people (communists) are endeavouring to get a foothold on the Irish Labour Party."[16]

Speaking at a National Labour delegate conference in October 1944, Everett stated that the Labour Party's attitude to Peadar Cowan's new openly communist organisation "The Vanguard" demonstrated how "helplessly the party leaders were caught in the Communist web" and "the individuals running the Vanguard were the same people who crashed into the party in 1942, founded the notorious Dublin Central branch and caused the party constitution to be torn up."[17]

The Catholic press supported the ITGWU's allegations, which were founded on James Larkin's communist activities in groups like the Irish Worker League. The number of communists in the movement had increased since 1941, when the Communist Party of Ireland had disbanded and its members had joined the Labour movement.[18] Based on conservative labour support, the National Labour Party won four seats in the 1944 election. At a meeting in Rathdowney, Labour politician William Davin criticised the new party in the aftermath of the election, referring to them as "disruptionist" and told his audience that he strongly resented being called a communist by "certain persons who did not bother to go to church or chapel either on Sundays or weekdays."[19] In response, National Labour stated that "Mr Davin and his colleagues short-circuited any kind of unbiased inquisition by setting up a tribunal of their own on which those very people charged with complicity in the Communist fusion sat as the judges and assessors." Continuing, they said that "Mr Davin is not a Communist; no one in the National Labour Party either thought or said that he was."[20] A failed attempt by the Labour Party to end the split occurred in May 1944.[21] In June 1944, the Donegal News wrote that "Mr. Norton and his colleagues may well reflect that the advent of a National Labour Party puts an end to future Labour hopes of a come-back".[22]

In 1947, National Labour criticised Labour's renewed calls for unity and that "failure to maintain unity within the Party occurred in 1943 when some members of the Administrative Council of the Party allowed themselves to be frightened or fooled into handing over control to a self-styled Dublin Executive, from whom they took their orders." They also stated that "those who wrecked the Labour Party four years ago, and had previously, by their policy of intrigue sought to make it their mouthpiece for Communist propaganda, cannot be permitted to continue their activities under cover of a democratic political organisation." National Labour also condemned the alleged influence of British trade unions in the Labour Party.[23] Seamus O'Farrell was General Secretary of the National Labour Party that year.[24]

National Labour won five seats in the 1948 election. After the election, the National Labour Party entered the First Inter-Party Government, against the wishes of the ITGWU. The party was in government with four other parties, including the Labour Party. National Labour was represented at cabinet level by James Everett, now its leader, as Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. Co-operation in government, the retirement of O'Brien and the death of Larkin removed the causes of animosity from the labour movement.[25] [26] In 1950, the National Labour Party folded back into Labour. In 1951, James Ryan of Fianna Fáil criticised National Labour's decision to re-join Labour.[27]

List of National Labour candidates

ElectionConstituency Candidate1st Pref. votes%
1944 general electionKerry NorthDan Spring8,42924.7
KilkennyJames Pattison6.23921.7
WexfordJohn O'Leary6,86415.9
WicklowJames Everett4,99219.2
1948 general electionCarlow–KilkennyJames Pattison4,70710.3
Cork BoroughJames Hickey4,50710.0
Dublin North-CentralGeorge Walker2711.1
Dublin North-EastFrank Robbins4761.1
Seán O'Moore4401.0
Kerry NorthDan Spring5,87716.3
WexfordJohn O'Leary5,51313.1
WicklowJames Everett4,83418.3

General election results

ElectionSeats won±PositionFirst Pref votes%GovernmentLeader
194445th32,7322.7%OppositionJames Everett
194816th34,0152.6%Coalition (FG-LP-CnP-CnT-NLP)James Everett

Sources

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Agus tá na torthaí istigh…olltoghchán eile!. 2021-09-23. Cathal . Mac Coille. 6 February 2016 . Cathal Mac Coille. 2019-12-10. https://web.archive.org/web/20191210202950/https://tuairisc.ie/agus-ta-na-torthai-istigholltoghchan-eile/. live.
  2. Barberis, McHugh and Tyldesley (2005).
  3. Manning (1972).
  4. Book: O'Connor, Emmet. Big Jim Larkin: Hero Or Wrecker?. 2015. University College Dublin Press. 978-1-906359-93-5. en.
  5. Web site: Move To End Labour Split. 2022-01-01. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  6. Web site: Appointments in New Labour Party. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  7. Web site: Labour's Seanad Position. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  8. Book: Gallagher, Michael. Political Parties in the Republic of Ireland. 1985. Manchester University Press. 978-0-7190-1797-1. en.
  9. Book: Patterson, Henry. Ireland Since 1939. 2007-08-02. Penguin UK. 978-0-14-192688-9. en.
  10. Web site: Everett, James Dictionary of Irish Biography. 2021-11-13. www.dib.ie.
  11. Book: O'Connor, Emmet. A Labour History of Ireland, 1824-1960. 1992. Gill and Macmillan. 978-0-7171-1619-5. en.
  12. Book: Drisceoil. Donal Ó. Politics and the Irish Working Class, 1830–1945. Lane. F.. 2005-09-30. Springer. 978-0-230-50377-9. en.
  13. Book: Rouse. Paul. Making the Difference?: The Irish Labour Party 1912–2012. Daly. Paul. O'Brien. Ronan. 2012-04-30. Gill & Macmillan Ltd. 978-1-84889-970-4. en.
  14. Web site: Communist Statement Condemned. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  15. Web site: New Party's Appeal. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  16. News: 22 May 1944. Cork Candidate on Alleged Deal. 3. Cork Examiner.
  17. Web site: Labour Leaders Challenged. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  18. http://www.workersrepublic.org/Pages/Ireland/Communism/cpihistory3.html The Communist Party of Ireland A Critical History, Part 3
  19. Web site: Mr Davin Attacks New Party. 2021-11-21. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  20. Web site: Reply to Labour TD's Statement. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  21. Web site: Labour Party Bid to End Split Fails. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  22. Web site: Donegal News. 2022-01-01. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  23. Web site: National Labour Branch's Reply To Mr. Norton. 2021-11-22. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.
  24. Web site: CONGRESS CRITICS OF Labour Party. 2021-11-22. www.irishnewsarchive.com.
  25. Web site: Duibhir. Séan Ó. 2021-09-02. A short history of small Irish political parties with big impacts. . en.
  26. Web site: 2013-02-25. The first coalition—60 years on. 2021-11-22. History Ireland.
  27. Web site: National Labour Joined Party They Called Communistic. 2022-01-01. archive.irishnewsarchive.com.