Naming Commission Explained

Agency Name:The Naming Commission
Type:Commission
Jurisdiction:Department of Defense
Budget:$2 million (total for life of commission)
Chief1 Name:Michelle Howard
Chief1 Position:Chair
Chief2 Name:Ty Seidule
Chief2 Position:Vice Chair
Agency Type:Federal commission
Keydocument1:National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021

The Commission on the Naming of Items of the Department of Defense that Commemorate the Confederate States of America or Any Person Who Served Voluntarily with the Confederate States of America, more commonly referred to as the Naming Commission, was a United States government commission created by the United States Congress in 2021 to create a list of military assets with names associated with the Confederate States of America and recommendations for their removal.[1]

In the summer of 2020, the George Floyd protests and resulting removal of Confederate monuments drew attention to the U.S. Army installations named for Confederate soldiers. These installations and other defense property were generally named in the early to mid-20th century at the height of the Jim Crow era to court support from Southerners.[2] [3]

In response, lawmakers added a provision for a renaming commission to the William M. (Mac) Thornberry National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 (NDAA). Enacted on January 1, 2021, the law was passed over President Donald Trump's veto.[4] The law required the commission to develop a list that could be used to "remove all names, symbols, displays, monuments, and paraphernalia that honor or commemorate the Confederate States of America or any person who served voluntarily with the Confederate States of America from all assets of the Department of Defense."[5] The law required the Secretary of Defense to implement the plan within three years of its enactment.

In summer and fall 2022, the commission delivered its report and recommendations to Congress in three parts. It disbanded on October 1, 2022, after fulfilling its duties to Congress.[1]

On October 6, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin declared in a memo that he concurred with all the commission's recommendations and was committed to implementing them as soon as possible, within legal constraints.[6] On 5 January 2023, William A. LaPlante, U.S. under secretary of defense for acquisition and sustainment (USD (A&S)), directed the Department to implement all of the commission's recommendations.[7]

Legislative history

On June 9, 2020, Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) announced that she had "filed an amendment to the annual defense bill last week to rename all bases named for Confederate generals."[8] On June 11, 2020, Reps. Anthony Brown (D-MD) and Don Bacon (R-NE) introduced H.R.7155, National Commission on Modernizing Military Installation Designations Act.[9] [10] The bill received support from 30 total co-sponsors, including 3 Republicans.

The Senate Armed Services Committee (SASC) completed its markup of the FY2021 NDAA on June 11, 2020, and the bill reported out by committee included Warren's provision.[11] Warren's provision to direct the renaming of the bases was altered to an approach that used a commission after Sen. Martha McSally (R-AZ) indicated her support to remove the names.[12] Sens. Mike Rounds (R-SD) and Joni Ernst (R-IA) publicly said that they supported the amendment to change base names.

During consideration of the FY2021 NDAA by the House Armed Services Committee (HASC) on July 1, 2020, Brown offered an amendment, which was co-led with Bacon, to directly require the Secretary of Defense to rename any defense property that is named after any person who served in the political or military leadership of any armed rebellion against the United States.[13] [14] The amendment offered by Brown passed by a vote of 33–23, with Republicans Bacon and Paul Mitchell (R-MI) joining in support.[15] The committee unanimously voted to report the NDAA favorably to the House.[16]

At a July 9, 2020, hearing in HASC, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark Milley said, "I personally think that the original decisions to name those bases after Confederate bases were political decisions back in the 1910s and '20s....The American Civil War was fought, and it was an act of rebellion. It was an act of treason at the time against the Union. Against the stars and stripes. Against the U.S. Constitution. And those officers turned their backs on their oath."[17]

On November 18, 2020, Speaker Nancy Pelosi named the House Democratic members of the conference committee for the NDAA and in doing so stated that "this summer, the House and Senate on a bipartisan basis passed NDAAs with provisions to begin the process of changing the names of military bases and infrastructure named after individuals who served in the Confederacy. It is imperative that the conference report include provisions that secure this essential priority. Our bases should reflect our highest ideals as Americans."[18]

Conference negotiations over the provisions were tense and threatened a failure to pass the NDAA for the first time in its 60-year history.[19] [20] On November 20, 2020, the Congressional Black Caucus adopted a formal position that the final conference report for the NDAA "must include a provision mandating the redesignation of Department of Defense property honoring the Confederacy."[21]

On December 2, 2020, the conference committee reported out the conference report, which receded to the Senate language without amendment and incorporated the text as section 370 in the final bill.[22] The House of Representatives agreed to the conference report by a vote of 335–78 on December 8, 2020, and the Senate followed suit on December 11, 2020, passing it 84–13.[23] On December 23, 2020, President Trump vetoed the legislation, saying, "These locations have taken on significance to the American story and those who have helped write it that far transcends their namesakes...I have been clear in my opposition to politically motivated attempts like this to wash away history and to dishonor the immense progress our country has fought for in realizing our founding principles."[24]

On December 28, 2020, in the last vote of the 116th Congress in the House of Representatives, the House voted to override President Trump's veto by 322–87, including 109 Republicans and 1 Independent who voted yea.[25] On January 1, 2021, in the last vote of the 116th Congress, the Senate voted to override President Trump's veto by 81–13, passing the commission into law.[26] The passage of the FY2021 NDAA was the 60th consecutive time that such legislation had been passed and is the only instance in which it was enacted over the objection of the president.

Activities of the commission

The commission is chartered with five primary activities:

  1. Assessing the cost of renaming or removing names, symbols, displays, monuments, or paraphernalia that commemorate the Confederate States of America or any person who served voluntarily with the Confederate States of America.
  2. Developing procedures and criteria to assess whether an existing name, symbol, monument, display, or paraphernalia commemorates the Confederate States of America or person who served voluntarily with the Confederate States of America.
  3. Recommending procedures for renaming assets of the Department of Defense to prevent commemoration of the Confederate States of America or any person who served voluntarily with the Confederate States of America.
  4. Developing a plan to remove names, symbols, displays, monuments, or paraphernalia that commemorate the Confederate States of America or any person who served voluntarily with the Confederate States of America from assets of the Department of Defense, within the timeline established by this Act.
  5. Including in the plan procedures and criteria for collecting and incorporating local sensitivities associated with naming or renaming of assets of the Department of Defense.

The commission was authorized $2 million to conduct its work,[27] and had to brief the House and Senate Armed Services Committees on its progress by October 1, 2021, and then present a final briefing and written report to the armed services committees by October 1, 2022.[28] The commission met biweekly and briefed the Secretary of Defense on its progress and recommendations. The commission's focus throughout the summer and fall of 2021 comprised visiting the nine Army installations named for those who voluntarily served in the Confederacy.[29] The commission met with installation leadership to gauge their level of planning and their local assessments.

The commission expanded their investigation of military assets to include assets with names that commemorate other Civil War era events or places to see if the name has a connection to the Confederacy. Examples given are USS Antietam (CG-54) and Fort Belvoir.

Until December 1, 2021, the commission had collected suggestions from the general public for possible replacement names for the military assets that the Department of Defense may finally decide to rename.[30] After receiving thousands of suggestions, the commission posted a list of 90 names in March 2022 that it plans to consider as possible replacement names for the nine Army installations before the list is further narrowed to produce the list of finalists.[31]

In March 2022, the commission determined that Fort Belvoir does not meet the criteria provided in the 2021 National Defense Authorization Act for a renaming recommendation but the commission recommends that the Department of Defense conduct its own naming review of the post, based on results of the commission's historical research.[32] At end of the same month, the commission posted a list of 758 Defense Department items at U.S. military installations in the United States, Germany and Japan with ties to the Confederacy. Many of the items on the list are streets, signs, paintings and buildings.[33] [34] Included on the list, Arlington National Cemetery has a memorial dedicated to Confederate war dead which includes "highly sanitized depictions of slavery".[35]

Members

The eight-person commission comprises four representatives appointed by the United States Secretary of Defense and one appointee each by the chairmen and ranking members of the Senate Committee on Armed Services and House Committee on Armed Services.[27]

On January 8, 2021, Christopher C. Miller - the acting Defense Secretary for the outgoing Trump administration - appointed the four DoD representatives: "Sean McLean, a White House associate director; Joshua Whitehouse, the White House liaison to the Defense Department who has been involved in some of the post-election purges at the Pentagon; Ann T. Johnston, acting Assistant Secretary of Defense for Legislative Affairs; and Earl G. Matthews, an Army National Guard colonel who previously served as principal deputy general counsel for the Army and on Trump's National Security Council."

On January 29, 2021, following the inauguration of Joe Biden on January 20, the new administration halted all appointments that had not yet completed paperwork. This affected the Secretary of Defense's four appointees to the commission.[36] On February 12, 2021, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin announced new appointments to the position,[37] followed immediately after by the Democratic chairmen and ranking Republicans on the House and Senate Armed Services Committees.[38]

On March 2, it was announced that Smithsonian Secretary Lonnie Bunch had to withdraw from the commission for personal reasons prior to the swearing-in ceremony.[39] Eight days later, Congressman Smith replaced Bunch with former Obama administration official Lawrence Romo.[40]

Michelle Howard is the chair of the committee with Ty Seidule being the vice-chair.[41] U.S. Army Major General Deborah Kotulich has served as the chief of staff of the Army Support Team to the Naming Commission since November 2021.[42]

PhotoMemberTitleAppointed byNotes
Michelle HowardAdmiral, U.S. Navy, retiredSecretary of Defense Lloyd AustinCommittee chair. Before retirement from active service in 2017, Howard became the highest ranking woman in United States Armed Forces history and the third African-American to achieve the rank of four-star admiral.
Ty SeiduleBrigadier General, U.S. Army, retiredSecretary of Defense Lloyd AustinCommittee vice-chair. Emeritus Professor of History at the United States Military Academy, and author of the 2021 book Robert E. Lee and Me: A Southerner's Reckoning with the Myth of the Lost Cause
Robert NellerGeneral, U.S. Marine Corps, retiredSecretary of Defense Lloyd AustinRetired as the 37th Commandant of the Marine Corps.
Kori SchakeDirector of Foreign & Defense Policy Studies, American Enterprise InstituteSecretary of Defense Lloyd AustinHas held senior positions in both the Defense and State Departments and advised the 2008 presidential campaign of John McCain.
Thomas P. BostickLieutenant General, U.S. Army, retiredChairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee Jack Reed (D-RI)The first African American graduate of West Point to serve as Chief of Engineers of the U.S. Army and Commanding General of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Jerry BuchananOklahoma businessman, Sergeant, U.S. Army, retiredRanking Member of the Senate Armed Services Committee James Inhofe (R-OK)An alternate member of the Oklahoma State Election Board, former chairman of the Tulsa County Republican Party, and retired U.S. Army drill sergeant[43]
Lawrence RomoLieutenant Colonel, U.S. Air Force, retiredChairman of the House Armed Services Committee Adam Smith (D-WA)Former director of the Selective Service System during the Obama Administration. Currently national commander of the American GI Forum.
Austin ScottCongressman (R-GA-8)Ranking Member of the House Armed Services Committee Mike Rogers (R-AL)A member of the House Armed Services Committee from a district with several military installations in a state with two bases named after Confederate generals: Fort Benning (now Fort Moore) and Fort Gordon (now Fort Eisenhower).[44] In 2001, Scott was the first Republican in the Georgia House of Representatives to work with Democrats to remove the Confederate battle emblem from the state's flag.

Items with Confederate names

Below is a list of U.S. military assets that may be affected by the NDAA:

Army

Navy

Air Force

List of recommended base replacement names of March 2022

The commission published in March 2022 the following list of 90 names it considered for use in renaming the nine army bases:

Base renaming recommendations of May 24, 2022

Recommendations:[60] [61]

Notes

Other

External links

Final Report to Congress:

Notes and References

  1. Web site: The Naming Commission. 2021-09-02. The Naming Commission. en-US. https://web.archive.org/web/20210902200452/https://www.thenamingcommission.gov/. September 2, 2021.
  2. Web site: Naming of U.S. Army Posts . 2021-08-07 . U.S. Army Center of Military History.
  3. News: Horton . Alex . June 11, 2020 . Trump won't rename Army posts that honor Confederates. Here's why they're named after traitors. . Washington Post . August 7, 2021.
  4. Web site: Kheel . Rebecca . January 8, 2021 . Pentagon appoints commissioners to scrub Confederate base names . February 12, 2021 . TheHill . en.
  5. Web site: January 1, 2021 . H.R.6395 - 116th Congress (2019-2020): National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 . February 12, 2021 . U.S. Congress.
  6. Web site: Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III Directs Implementation of the Naming Commission's . 2023-02-10 . U.S. Department of Defense . en-US.
  7. Web site: Pentagon Press Secretary Air Force Brig. Gen. Pat Ryder Holds an On-Camera Press Briefing. U.S. Department of Defense.
  8. senwarren . 1270448087220314113 . As a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, I filed an amendment to the annual defense bill last week to rename all bases named for Confederate generals. . Elizabeth . Warren . Elizabeth Warren . June 9, 2020 . 2021-08-07.
  9. Web site: 2020-06-11. Brown - Bacon Introduce Bipartisan Legislation to Rename Military Installations Honoring Confederate Leaders. 2021-08-07. U.S. Representative Anthony Brown. en . https://web.archive.org/web/20200611205028/https://anthonybrown.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=963 . 2020-06-11 .
  10. Web site: Brown. Anthony G.. 2020-06-11. H.R.7155 - 116th Congress (2019-2020): National Commission on Modernizing Military Installation Designations Act. 2021-08-07. United States Congress.
  11. SASC Completes Markup of Fiscal Year 2021 National Defense Authorization Act . 2021-08-07 . . June 11, 2020.
  12. Web site: Swanson. Ian. 2020-06-14. Cotton emerges as key figure in base renaming fight. 2021-08-07. TheHill. en.
  13. Web site: H.R. 6395 - National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 Committee Repository U.S. House of Representatives. 2021-08-07. docs.house.gov.
  14. Web site: Amendment 6 Revision 1, House Armed Services Committee Markup of FY2021 NDAA. August 7, 2021. House Repository.
  15. Web site: Vote on Amendment 6r1. August 7, 2021. House Repository.
  16. Web site: July 1, 2020. Final Passage, FY2021 NDAA. August 7, 2021. House Repository.
  17. Web site: 2020-10-14. The secret history of Confederate post names the Army never wanted you to see. 2021-08-07. Task & Purpose. en-US.
  18. Web site: 2020-11-18. Pelosi Names Conferees to National Defense Authorization Act Conference. 2021-08-07. Speaker Nancy Pelosi. en . https://web.archive.org/web/20210807205206/https://www.speaker.gov/newsroom/111820-0 . 2021-08-07 .
  19. Web site: Dem divide over Confederate bases threatens massive defense bill . 2021-08-07 . . Heather . Caygle . Connor . O'Brien . Sarah . Ferris . November 23, 2020.
  20. Web site: O'Brien . Connor . House Democrats consider slower timeline for renaming bases that honor Confederates . 2021-08-07 . . November 20, 2020.
  21. Web site: 2020-11-20. Congressional Black Caucus. 2021-08-07. Congressional Black Caucus. en.
  22. Web site: 2020-12-02. Smith and Thornberry Statement on FY21 NDAA. 2021-08-07. House Armed Services Committee - Democrats. en.
  23. Web site: Smith. Adam. 2021-01-01. Actions - H.R.6395 - 116th Congress (2019-2020): William M. (Mac) Thornberry National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021. 2021-08-07. www.congress.gov.
  24. Web site: Presidential Veto Message to the House of Representatives for H.R. 6395 – The White House . 2021-08-07 . trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov . December 23, 2020 . Donad J. . Trump.
  25. Web site: Washington. U. S. Capitol Room H154. p:225-7000. DC 20515-6601. 2020-12-28. Roll Call 253 Roll Call 253, Bill Number: H. R. 6395, 116th Congress, 2nd Session. 2021-08-07. Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives. en.
  26. Web site: U.S. Senate: U.S. Senate Roll Call Votes 116th Congress - 2nd Session. 2021-08-07. www.senate.gov.
  27. Web site: Beynon. Steve. December 4, 2020. Defense bill directs $2 million to form commission, plan renaming of military bases honoring Confederates. February 12, 2021. Stars and Stripes.
  28. News: Vergun. David. May 21, 2021. Naming Commission Chair Details Progress, Way Ahead. DOD News.
  29. Web site: Naming Commission Chair Details Progress, Way Ahead. 2021-08-07. U.S. Department of Defense. en-US.
  30. Web site: Recommend A Name . The Naming Commission . https://web.archive.org/web/20211128084623/https://www.thenamingcommission.gov/recommend-a-name . 2021-11-28 .
  31. Web site: Army Installations: Potential New Names (as of March 17, 2022) . The Naming Commission . https://web.archive.org/web/20220318073634/https://www.thenamingcommission.gov/names . 2022-03-18 .
  32. News: Commission: Fort Belvoir's name remains, for now . Paul . Lara . March 17, 2022 . InsideNoVa.
  33. Web site: DoD Inventory . The Naming Commission . https://web.archive.org/web/20220401094448/https://www.thenamingcommission.gov/inventory . April 1, 2022 . April 2, 2022 .
  34. News: More than 750 Defense Department items with names tied to the Confederacy listed for possible renaming . Corey . Dickstein. . March 31, 2022.
  35. Web site: Army Reviewing 'Confederate Memorial' Featuring Slaves at Arlington National Cemetery . July 9, 2020 . . Richard . Sisk.
  36. Web site: Kheel. Rebecca. January 29, 2021. Pentagon halts appointment of Trump loyalists to advisory boards. February 12, 2021. The Hill. en.
  37. Web site: February 12, 2021. Statement by Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin III on the Department's Representatives to the Congressionally-Mandated Commission on the Naming of Items in the Department of Defense That Commemorate the Confederate States of America. February 12, 2021. U.S. Department of Defense.
  38. Web site: Homan. Timothy R.. February 12, 2021. Pentagon, Congress appoint panel members to rename Confederate base names. February 13, 2021. The Hill. en.
  39. Web site: Commissioners tasked with scrubbing Confederate base names sworn-in at first meeting . Rebecca . Kheel . . March 2, 2021.
  40. News: Latino civil rights leader will help remove Confederate symbols, names from military bases . . March 10, 2021 . Suzanne . Gamboa.
  41. News: Commission chair: 'Hundreds' of military assets could have Confederate names removed . . May 21, 2021 . Rebecca . Kheel.
  42. Web site: Major General Deborah Kotulich – General Officer Management Office. www.gomo.army.mil.
  43. Web site: Secretary and Board. February 13, 2021. Oklahoma Election Board. en.
  44. Web site: Shane. Leo III. February 12, 2021. Panelists selected, now work on renaming military sites honoring Confederate leaders will begin. February 13, 2021. Navy Times.
  45. News: New law requires West Point to rename dorm, roads and gate named for Confederate generals . . Chris . McKenna . January 8, 2021.
  46. Web site: A Tarnished Legacy: Confederate Battle Honors and the Army National Guard . August 3, 2020 . Angry Staff Officer.
  47. News: Guard battle streamers still honor Confederacy . . June 24, 2015 . Tom . Vanden Brook.
  48. Web site: Civil War Campaigns . U.S. Army Center of Military History.
  49. News: Commission: Blue-Gray Patch Stays, Confederate Campaign Streamers Go . August 9, 2022. National Guard Association of the United States.
  50. News: These Southern National Guard Units to Toss Confederate Battle Streamers . Steve . Beynon . March 16, 2023 . Military.com.
  51. Web site: What to rename the Army bases that honor Confederate soldiers . June 18, 2020 . . Ty . Seidule . Ty Seidule.
  52. Arlington National Cemetery Seeks Public Input on Confederate Memorial Removal . . Maggie . Roth . August 14, 2023.
  53. News: Senate Bill to Purge Confederate Names from U.S. Military Could Affect Two Navy Ships . Sam . LaGrone . June 12, 2020 . USNI News.
  54. News: Navy to rename USS Chancellorsville after former slave who stole Confederate steamer . Alex . Wilson . . February 28, 2023.
  55. News: Naming Commission Chair Details Progress, Way Ahead . May 21, 2021 . David . Vergun . Department of Defense.
  56. SECNAV Renames Pathfinder-class Oceanographic Survey Ship USNS Maury after Marie Tharp . March 8, 2023 . Department of the Navy.
  57. News: Naval Academy board chair calls to remove Confederate names from buildings . . Brian . Witte . June 11, 2020.
  58. News: Naval Academy buildings named after Confederate sailors could be renamed under defense act . . Heather . Mongilio . July 29, 2020.
  59. SECNAV Renames United States Naval Academy Superintendent's Quarters after Admiral Farragut . May 1, 2013 . Department of the Navy.
  60. Web site: Name Recommendations . The Naming Commission . 2022-05-24 . https://web.archive.org/web/20220318005313/https://www.thenamingcommission.gov/names . March 18, 2022 .
  61. Web site: 2022-05-24 . New names for Fort Bragg, 8 other Army bases recommended . 2022-05-25 . . en.
  62. News: Meron . Moges-Gerbi . May 12, 2023 . Georgia's Fort Benning drops Confederacy connection with new name in honor of a military couple . .
  63. Web site: Fort Liberty? No, let's choose one of our heroes for Fort Bragg's new name. Pitts. Myron B.. 2022-05-29. The Fayetteville Observer. 2022-06-14.
  64. Web site: Retired General: Fort Liberty the perfect new name for Fort Bragg. Anderson. Rodney. 2022-06-26. The Fayetteville Observer. 2022-07-22.
  65. Web site: 2023-03-28 . Guard Installation Officially Redesignated Fort Barfoot . 31 March 2023 . National Guard Association of the US.
  66. Web site: Georgia's Fort Gordon becomes last of 9 US Army posts to be renamed. Frazier . Aisha. ABC News. 27 October 2023. 27 October 2023.
  67. Web site: 2023-08-25 . Diversity celebrated as Fort AP Hill is renamed Fort Walker . 2023-08-28 . CBS 6 News Richmond WTVR . en.
  68. News: Fort Lee renamed in honor of 2 Black US Army trailblazers . Brittany . Gaddy . 2023-04-28 . WPVI-TV.
  69. News: VNG installation officially redesignated Fort Barfoot . Mike . Vrabel . 2023-03-24 . U.S. Army.
  70. News: Fort Rucker was named for a Confederate. The Army post will now be called Fort Novosel, for a Medal of Honor recipient who rescued thousands . Phil . Gast . . April 11, 2023.