Monkey brains explained

Monkey brains is a supposed dish consisting of, at least partially, the brain of some species of monkey or ape.

While animal brains have been consumed in various cuisines (e.g. eggs and brains or fried brain sandwiches), there is debate about whether monkey brains have actually been consumed. In Western popular culture its consumption is repeatedly portrayed and debated, often in the context of portraying exotic cultures as exceptionally cruel, callous, and/or strange.

Consumption

Initial confusion over a translated term for the edible monkey-head mushroom (Hericium erinaceus) may have played a part in the belief that monkey brains were used in Asian cuisine. Known as hóu tóu gū in Chinese (simplified: 猴头菇; traditional: 猴頭菇; lit. "monkey head mushroom")[1] the mushroom received its moniker owing to the superficial resemblance it bears to the fur of certain primates found in Asia, such as macaques.

Actual monkey brains were historically part of the Manchu Han Imperial banquet of the Qing Empire held during the 17th century,[2] where they may have been eaten directly from the skull.[3]

One modern account published in 1958 from travel writer Leila Hadley details a meal in a restaurant in Macao near Hong Kong where monkey brains were eaten from a freshly killed monkey's skull.[4] The writer Albert Podell claims to have eaten live monkey brains in Hong Kong in 1966, which he describes in his book Around The World in 50 Years.[5] There is skepticism as to how common the practice remains today.[6] Official Chinese policy on the procurement of certain wildlife species in the 21st century makes the serving of monkey brains illegal, with sentences of up to 10 years in prison for violators.[7]

Beyond Asia and into Africa, naturalist Angela Meder has described in Gorilla Journal a cultural practice of the Anaang people of southeastern Nigeria and southwestern Cameroon whereby a new tribal chief would consume the brain of a hunted gorilla while another senior member of the tribe consumed the heart. According to this account, the practice occurred only in the specific instance of a new chiefdom, as the killing of gorillas would otherwise be forbidden.[8]

Health risks

Consuming the brain and other nervous system tissues of some animals is considered hazardous to human health,[9] possibly resulting in transmissible encephalopathies such as Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease.[10] [11]

In fiction

A fictional depiction of the consumption of monkey brains is shown in the 1978 mondo film Faces of Death, directed by John Alan Schwartz. The scene depicts an Eastern-themed restaurant with patrons seated around a table watching a belly dance. A narrator explains that these are tourists who have come to this location to consume "the house specialty."[12] The proprietor signals for a server to bring out a monkey, which is then secured inside a pen built into the table. The tourists are given hammers, and they proceed to hit the monkey on the head until it is killed. The server then cuts open the skull and removes the monkey's brains onto a plate for the patrons to sample. In actuality no monkey was harmed in the making of the scene,[13] as the hammers were made of foam and the 'monkey's head' was a prop filled with gelatin, red food coloring, and cauliflower to simulate brain matter.[14]

Additional depictions in the decade following the release of Faces of Death contain scenes which reference the practice of eating monkey brains, including one from the 1984 film Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom,[15] the 1981 Japanese crime film Sailor Suit and Machine Gun,[16] as well as dialogue from the 1985 comedy Clue.[17] In addition to their shock value, what these scenes have in common are their representations of Orientalism, which according to author Sophia Rose Arjana, work as cinematic tropes used to "conflate bizarre and vulgarized representations of the Far East".[18]

See also

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Schreiber. Mark. Debunking Strange Asian Myths: Part II. The Japan Times. The Japan Times Ltd.. 9 September 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180710135859/https://www.japantimes.co.jp/community/2002/08/08/issues/debunking-strange-asian-myths-part-ii/. 10 July 2018. 8 August 2002.
  2. Gayley. Holly. The Compassionate Treatment of Animals. Journal of Religious Ethics. 1 March 2017. 45. 1. 42. 10.1111/jore.12167. en. 1467-9795.
  3. Gayley. Holly. 1076-9005. Reimagining Buddhist Ethics on the Tibetan Plateau. Journal of Buddhist Ethics. 20. 2013. 264. 26874914. Each dish is described in excruciating detail, including the infamous case of eating live monkey brains right out of the skull.. 24 April 2018. 25 April 2018. https://web.archive.org/web/20180425114446/https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a5c0/42fb9382e07232fcb962f77082370b607ec8.pdf. dead.
  4. Book: Hadley . Leila . Leila Hadley . Hong Kong and the Wickedest City . 42 . Give Me the World . 2003. 1958 . Seal Press . First Seal Press paperback . New York . 1-58005-091-3.
  5. Book: Podell . Albert . Around the World in 50 Years . 2016 . T. Dunne Books . 978-1-250-09422-3 . 1005205618 . English.
  6. Web site: Adams . Cecil . In Asia, do people scoop the brains out of a monkey's skull and eat them? . The Straight Dope . 6 March 2021 . 9 March 2001.
  7. Li. Peter J.. Enforcing Wildlife Protection in China. China Information. 22 July 2016. 21. 1. 76–77, 80. 10.1177/0920203x07075082. 49221536. en. 22 August 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20160429121854/http://animallawconference.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/2015/09/Enforcing-Wildlife-Protection-in-China.pdf. 29 April 2016. dead.
  8. Gorillas in African Culture and Medicine . June 1999 . 18 . Meder . Angela . 3 . Gorilla Journal . 22 September 2014 . 1 September 2016 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160901052446/http://www.berggorilla.org/fileadmin/user_upload/pdf/journal/journal-en/gorilla-journal-18-english.pdf . dead .
  9. Legg. N.J.. Thomson. Alexa. Multiple Sclerosis and the Eating of Sheep's Brains. The Lancet. February 1972. 299. 7746. 387. 10.1016/s0140-6736(72)92892-9.
  10. Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease after Eating Ovine Brains?. New England Journal of Medicine. 24 April 1975. 292. 17. 927. 10.1056/NEJM197504242921721. 1090830. 0028-4793. Alter. M.. Frank. Y.. Doyne. H.. Webster. D. D..
  11. Berger. Joseph R. Weisman. Erick. Weisman. Beverly. Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease and Eating Squirrel Brains. The Lancet. August 1997. 350. 9078. 642. 10.1016/s0140-6736(05)63333-8. 9288058. 42158648.
  12. 10 November 1978 . Faces of Death . Faces of Death . Motion picture . Aquarius Releasing. John Alan Schwartz, director (credited as 'Conan LeCilaire').. Written by John Alan Schwartz (credited as 'Alan Black'). Cinematography by Michael Golden. Edited by James Roy. Music by Gene Kauer. Produced by William B. James, Herbie Lee and Rosilyn T. Scott.. 9780788609329. 432163437. Feeling that the foreigners were comfortable within his domain, the waiter signals for the house specialty..
  13. Book: Carter. David Ray. Cline. John. Weiner. Robert J.. From the Arthouse to the Grindhouse: Highbrow and Lowbrow Transgression in Cinema's First Century. 2010. Scarecrow Press. It's Only A Movie? Reality as Transgression in Exploitation Cinema. 9780810876552. 659730064. 307. https://books.google.com/books?id=VKhqh3HFH8AC&pg=PA307. en.
  14. Web site: Open The Skull: The Faces Of Death Guy Looks Back. Hickey, Brian. https://web.archive.org/web/20180424194241/https://deadspin.com/5855402/cut-back-to-a-wide-shot-open-the-skull-the-faces-of-death-guy-looks-back. 24 April 2018. Deadspin. 2012.
  15. Rodewald. Lucas Alan. Misrepresentation at the Movies: Film, Pedagogy, and Postcolonial Theory in the Secondary English Classroom. The Adventures of Teaching Indiana Jones in the World of the Other. Iowa State University. Document No. 10126564. 22–34. 2016. Masters. ProQuest Dissertations Publishing. Ames, Iowa. https://www.proquest.com/docview/1797613897/.
  16. Shinji Sōmai, director.. Sailor Suit and Machine Gun . Sailor Suit and Machine Gun (film). 1981. Motion picture. Written by Yōzō Tanaka. Produced by Kei Ijichi. Arrow Films . 1274168469.
  17. 13 December 1985 . Clue. Clue (film) . Motion picture . Paramount / PolyGram. Jonathan Lynn, director.. Story by John Landis and Jonathan Lynn. Screenplay by Jonathan Lynn. Cinematography by Victor J. Kemper. Edited by David Bretherton and Richard Haines. Music by John Morris. Produced by Debra Hill.. 9780792166214 . 1004377222. Monkey's brains, though popular in Cantonese cuisine, are not often to be found in Washington, D.C..
  18. Book: Arjana. Sophia Rose. Muslims in the Western Imagination. 2015. Oxford University Press. 9780199324927. 142–145. The Monsters of Orientalism. 899007876. https://books.google.com/books?id=gHWbBQAAQBAJ&pg=PA143. en.

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Monkey brains".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.