Mesha Stele Explained

Mesha Stele
Material:Basalt
Writing:Moabite language
Discovered:1868–70
Location:Louvre
Id:AO 5066

The Mesha Stele, also known as the Moabite Stone, is a stele dated around 840 BCE containing a significant Canaanite inscription in the name of King Mesha of Moab (a kingdom located in modern Jordan). Mesha tells how Chemosh, the god of Moab, had been angry with his people and had allowed them to be subjugated to the Kingdom of Israel, but at length, Chemosh returned and assisted Mesha to throw off the yoke of Israel and restore the lands of Moab. Mesha also describes his many building projects. It is written in a variant of the Phoenician alphabet, closely related to the Paleo-Hebrew script.[1]

The stone was discovered intact by Frederick Augustus Klein, an Anglican missionary, at the site of ancient Dibon (now Dhiban, Jordan), in August 1868. A "squeeze" (a papier-mâché impression) had been obtained by a local Arab on behalf of Charles Simon Clermont-Ganneau, an archaeologist based in the French consulate in Jerusalem. The next year, the stele was smashed into several fragments by the Bani Hamida tribe, seen as an act of defiance against the Ottoman authorities who had pressured the Bedouins to hand over the stele so that it could be given to Germany. Clermont-Ganneau later managed to acquire the fragments and piece them together thanks to the impression made before the stele's destruction.[2]

The Mesha Stele, the first major epigraphic Canaanite inscription found in the Southern Levant,[3] the longest Iron Age inscription ever found in the region, constitutes the major evidence for the Moabite language, and is a "corner-stone of Semitic epigraphy", and history.[4] The stele, whose story parallels, with some differences, an episode in the Bible's Books of Kings (–27), provides invaluable information on the Moabite language and the political relationship between Moab and Israel at one moment in the 9th century BCE. It is the most extensive inscription ever recovered that refers to the kingdom of Israel (the "House of Omri");[5] it bears the earliest certain extrabiblical reference to the Israelite God Yahweh.[5] It is also one of four known contemporaneous inscriptions containing the name of Israel, the others being the Merneptah Stele, the Tel Dan Stele, and one of the Kurkh Monoliths.[6] [7] Its authenticity has been disputed over the years, and some biblical minimalists suggest the text was not historical, but a biblical allegory. The stele itself is regarded as genuine and historical by the vast majority of biblical archaeologists today.[8]

The stele has been part of the collection of the Louvre Museum in Paris, France, since 1873. Jordan has been demanding its return to its place of origin since 2014.[9]

Description and discovery

The stele is a smoothed block of basalt about a meter tall, 60 cm wide, and 60 cm thick, bearing a surviving inscription of 34 lines.

Frederick Klein, an Anglican missionary, discovered the stone intact in August 1868 at the site of ancient Dibon (now Dhiban, Jordan). Klein was led to it by Sattam Al-Fayez, son of Fendi Al-Fayez, the emir of the Bani Sakher.[10] although neither of them could read the text.[11] At that time, amateur explorers and archaeologists were scouring the Levant for evidence proving the historicity of the Bible. News of the finding set off a race between France, Britain, and Germany to acquire the piece.

A "squeeze" (a papier-mâché impression) of the full stele had been obtained just before its destruction. Ginsberg's translation of the official report, "Über die Auffindung der Moabitischen Inschrift",[12] stated that Charles Simon Clermont-Ganneau, an archaeologist based in the French consulate in Jerusalem, sent an Arab named Yacoub Caravacca to obtain the squeeze as he "did not want to venture to undertake the very costly [and dangerous] journey" himself. Caravacca was injured by the local Bedouin while obtaining the squeeze, and one of his two accompanying horsemen protected the squeeze by tearing it still damp from the stone in seven fragments before escaping.

In November 1869, the stele was broken by the local Bedouins, the Bani Hamida, after the Ottoman government became involved in the ownership dispute. The previous year the Bani Hamida had been defeated by an expedition to Balqa led by Mehmed Rashid Pasha, the head of Syria vilayet. Knowing that a demand to give up the stone to the German Consulate had been ordered by the Ottomans and finding that the ruler of Salt was about to put pressure upon them, they heated the stele in a bonfire, threw cold water upon it and broke it to pieces with boulders.

On 8 February 1870, George Grove of the Palestine Exploration Fund announced the find of the stele in a letter to The Times, attributing the discovery to Charles Warren. On 17 February 1870, the 24-year-old Clermont-Ganneau published the first detailed announcement of the stele in the Revue de l’Instruction Publique.[13] This was followed a month later by a note from F. A. Klein published in The Pall Mall Gazette describing his discovery of the stele in August 1868:

Pieces of the original stele containing most of the inscription, 613 letters out of about a thousand, were later recovered and pieced together. Of the existing stele fragments, the top right fragment contains 150 letters, the bottom right fragment includes 358 letters, the middle right contains 38, and the rest contains 67 letters. The remainder of the stele was reconstructed by Ganneau from the squeeze obtained by Caravacca.

Visiting the site in 1872, Henry B. Tristram was convinced that the stele could not have been exposed for long and believed that it had probably been utilized as building material by the Roman era until thrown down in the Galilee earthquake of 1837.[14]

Text

Original

The inscription, known as KAI 181 is pictured to the right, and presented here after Compston, 1919, to be read right to left.:[15]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Stèle de Mecha. 2021-09-11. Musée du Louvre. 830. en.
  2. Web site: David . Ariel . 13 September 2018 . When God Wasn't So Great: What Yahweh's First Appearance Tells About Early Judaism . 11 October 2018 . Haaretz.com.
  3. Book: Meyers. Eric M.. Research. American Schools of Oriental. The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East. 1997. Oxford University Press. 978-0-19-511218-4. 39. Moabite Stone. the Moabite Stone and as the Mesha Stone / Inscription, was the first (1868) of the major epigraphic documents discovered in either Cis- or Transjordan and couched in a language closely related to Hebrew.
  4. Book: Katz. Ronald. The Structure of Ancient Arguments: Rhetoric and Its Near Eastern Origin. 1986. Shapolsky / Steinmatzky. New York. 9780933503342. 76.
  5. Book: Niehr, Herbert . 1995 . The Rise of YHWH in Judahite and Israelite Religion: Methodological and Religio-Historical Aspects . https://books.google.com/books?id=bua2dMa9fJ4C&pg=PA57 . Edelman . Diana Vikander . The Triumph of Elohim: From Yahwisms to Judaisms . . . 57 . 978-9053565032 . 33819403 . The Meša inscription (ca. 850 BCE) clearly states that YHWH was the supreme god of Israel and of the Transjordanian territory occupied by Israel under the Omrides..
  6. Maeir. Aren M. . 2013 . Israel and Judah . 3523–3527 . The Encyclopedia of Ancient History . New York . Blackwell. The earliest certain mention of the ethnonym Israel occurs in a victory inscription of the Egyptian king MERENPTAH, his well-known 'Israel Stela (ca. 1210 BCE); recently, a possible earlier reference has been identified in a text from the reign of Rameses II (see RAMESES I–XI). Thereafter, no reference to either Judah or Israel appears until the ninth century. The pharaoh Sheshonq I (biblical Shishak; see SHESHONQ I–VI) mentions neither entity by name in the inscription recording his campaign in the southern Levant during the late tenth century. In the ninth century, Israelite kings, and possibly a Judaean king, are mentioned in several sources: the Aramaean stele from Tel Dan, inscriptions of SHALMANESER III of Assyria, and the stela of Mesha of Moab. From the early eighth century onward, the kingdoms of Israel and Judah are both mentioned somewhat regularly in Assyrian and subsequently Babylonian sources, and from this point on there is relatively good agreement between the biblical accounts on the one hand and the archaeological evidence and extra-biblical texts on the other..
  7. Fleming. Daniel E.. 1998-01-01. Mari and the possibilities of Biblical memory. 23282083. Revue d'Assyriologie et d'archéologie orientale. 92. 1. 41–78. The Assyrian royal annals, along with the Mesha and Dan inscriptions, show a thriving northern state called Israël in the mid—9th century, and the continuity of settlement back to the early Iron Age suggests that the establishment of a sedentary identity should be associated with this population, whatever their origin. In the mid—14th century, the Amarna letters mention no Israël, nor any of the biblical tribes, while the Merneptah Stele places someone called Israël in hill-country Palestine toward the end of the Late Bronze Age. The language and material culture of emergent Israël show strong local continuity, in contrast to the distinctly foreign character of early Philistine material culture..
  8. Book: Gottwald, Norman Karol. The Politics of Ancient Israel. 2001-01-01. Westminster John Knox Press. 9780664219772. 194. In fact, the conduct of the military operations and the ritual slaughter of captives is so remarkably similar to the style and ideology of biblical accounts of 'holy war' that many interpreters were at first inclined to regard the Mesha Stele as a forgery, but on paleographic grounds, its authenticity is now undisputed..
  9. Web site: Centre planning protest to demand return of Mesha Stele from Louvre. Jordan Times. 19 April 2023. 12 April 2016.
  10. Book: Walsh, William. The Moabite Stone. PORTEOUS AND GIBBS, PRINTERS 16 WICKLOW STREET.. 1872. LONDON : HAMILTON AND CO.; J. NISBET AND CO.. 8, 12.
  11. Lemaire . André . André Lemaire . May–June 1994 . "House of David" Restored in Moabite Inscription . live . . 20 . 3 . . . 0098-9444 . https://web.archive.org/web/20120331134523/http://www.cojs.org/pdf/house_of_david.pdf . 31 March 2012 .
  12. http://menadoc.bibliothek.uni-halle.de/dmg/periodical/titleinfo/21524 Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, Bd. 24 (1870)
  13. http://www.biblicalstudies.org.uk/pdf/pefqs/1869-71_169.pdf "The Moabite Stone, With An Illustration"
  14. Book: Tristram, Henry B.. Henry Baker Tristram. The Land of Moab. Cambridge University Press. 1873. London. 134–135.
  15. Compston, H.F.B. The Inscription on the Stele of Mesha, MacMillan, 1919 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Inscription_on_the_Stele_of_M%C3%A9%C5%A1a%CA%BF/The_Moabite_Text_in_Ph%C5%93nician_Script