valign=top | - 1997
- 1998
- 1999
- Antoine Carr, Wichita State
- Joe Carter, Wichita State
- Melody Howard, Missouri State
- Holli Hyche, Indiana State
- Glen McCullough, Bradley* * *
- 2000
- 2001
- 2003
- 2004
| valign=top | | valign=top | - 2005
- 2006
- 2007
- 2008
- 2009
- 2010
- 2011
- *, Indiana State
- 2012
- *, Creighton
- *, Southern Illinois
- * *, Evansville
| valign=top | | valign=top | - 2013
- *, Creighton
- Jim Bain, * * *, Missouri Valley Conference
- Nancy Stefani, * * *, Drake
- 2014
- *, Illinois State
- Bob King, * * *, Indiana State
- Marty Perline, * * *, Wichita State
- 2015
- , Indiana State
- , Illinois State
- Joe Mitch
- , Missouri Valley Conference
- 2016
- , Illinois State
- , Loyola
- 2017
- , Illinois State
- Dr. Mary Jo Wynn**, Missouri State
- 2018
- Darren Brooks, Southern Illinois
- Christian Goy, Illinois State
- Mary Ellen Hill, Bradley
- Lois Patton
- , Evansville
- *, Missouri State
- 2019
- , Iowa State
- * *, Bradley
| valign=top | | valign=top | - 2020
- , Evansville
- 2021
- 2022
- , Bradley
- 2023
- 2024
- UIC
- , Illinois State
| |