Midland Metropolitan University Hospital Explained

Midland Metropolitan University Hospital
Org/Group:Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust
Location:Smethwick
Region:West Midlands
State:England
Country:UK
Healthcare:NHS
Type:District General
Emergency:Planned
Map Type:West Midlands

Midland Metropolitan University Hospital is a new acute general hospital being built on a 16acres site in Grove Lane at Smethwick near Birmingham. The hospital was designed by a team led by HKS and including Edward Williams Architects and Sonnemann Toon Architects. Already behind its original target completion date of October 2018, it was being built by Carillion. However, the company went into liquidation in January 2018, causing the PFI contract to be terminated. This, plus later materials and manpower shortages, delayed the hospital's completion further. As of October 2023, the hospital is planned to open in autumn 2024.

History

Project inception

The Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust was granted a compulsory purchase order to buy the land at Grove Lane, which had previously been used for industrial purposes by GKN, in January 2011.[1] [2] The hospital was designed by a team led by HKS.[3] Edward Williams Architects is the architectural design lead and Sonnemann Toon Architects the architectural clinic lead.[4] [5]

The new hospital will have 670 beds and 15 operating theatre suites.[6] The total capital cost was forecast to be £297 million of which £100 million would be provided by HM Treasury with the remainder privately financed.[7] Work on site started in January 2016 and construction was due to be completed in October 2018, but the project became delayed, with completion initially rescheduled for 2019.[8]

Carillion liquidation, resulting and other delays

Until January 2018, it was being built by Carillion who were also to provide hard facilities management and life-cycle maintenance services.[9] On 15 January 2018, Carillion went into liquidation, partly due to its problems with the hospital contract, and delaying the project still further;[10] [11] 70 Carillion staff lost their jobs.[12] On 26 March 2018, it was reported that the project had been costing over £17m more than Carillion had officially reported.[13]

In March 2018, Skanska negotiated to take over the hospital's construction,[14] with the project 18 months late and likely to cost an additional £125 million.[15] In May 2018, Sandwell and West Birmingham NHS Trust had yet to confirm Skanska to complete the project, and with the unfinished site deteriorating, completion was likely to be pushed back an additional two years, to 2022.[16] In June 2018, a consortium of banks financing the project withdrew their support, and HM Treasury cancelled the PFI contract for construction of the hospital, leaving it with a lengthy search for new investment and pushing the completion date back to at least 2022.[17] [18]

In the meantime, the NHS trust started tendering for an interim contractor to deliver a £13m programme of works to protect the site until a replacement construction contractor is appointed;[19] the OJEU notice for the £13m early works contract was published on 9 August 2018;[20] in October 2018, this work was awarded to Balfour Beatty.[21]

In August 2018, market testing with contractors showed there was little appetite to bid under a private finance model, and that a PF2 bid would be over £100m more expensive and take six months longer. As a result, the NHS trust sought direct government funding to complete the project,[22] and on 16 August 2018, the government announced it would provide funding to complete the hospital.[23] In November 2018, it was reported that the NHS Trust was struggling to find a contractor to complete the hospital, with the possibility that the hospital might be delayed beyond 2022.[24] In January 2019, firms - some previously involved with the project - were formally invited to apply for shortlisting to complete the half-finished hospital; the successful bidder was expected to start in October 2019 and complete the project in late 2021.[25] A wrangle over proposed changes to local authority boundaries threatened to delay the contractor appointment,[26] with Balfour Beatty reportedly the sole bidder for the project.[27] In September 2019, it was reported that Balfour Beatty was still awaiting approval to start work, possibly in December 2019, with completion scheduled for the summer of 2022.[28] The £267m contract was finally signed, and work was expected to start, in December 2019.[29]

A delayed National Audit Office report into the government's handling of the Midland Metropolitan and the Royal Liverpool University Hospital was published in January 2020. The report warned of possible further significant cost increases, and blamed Carillion for pricing the jobs too low to meet specifications. The two projects were expected to cost more than 40% more than their original budgets, and to be completed between three and five years late. However, due to effective risk transfer to the contractor, the total cost to the taxpayer would be very similar to the original plan.[30]

In October 2021, the NHS Trust was told that the 2022 opening date was likely to be missed as a result of materials shortages and workforce availability delaying completion.[31] [32] In July 2022, the Trust said the hospital would open in spring 2024.[33] In October 2023, this date was pushed back to autumn 2024.[34]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: NHS granted permission to buy up land to build Midland Metropolitan Hospital. The Guardian. 11 January 2017. 27 October 2017.
  2. Web site: NHS granted permission to buy up land to build Midland Metropolitan Hospital. 25 January 2011. Birmingham Post. 19 September 2016.
  3. Web site: HKS to head Midlands super-hospital architect team. 9 October 2015. 19 September 2016.
  4. News: Architects ‘may struggle to get payment from Carillion’. Architects Journal. 2018-01-30. en.
  5. News: HKS to head Midlands super-hospital architect team. Building Design. 2018-01-30. en.
  6. Web site: Midland Metropolitan Hospital takes shape ahead of 2018 opening. 7 July 2016. Express & Star. 19 September 2016.
  7. News: Smethwick super hospital on way at last as Chancellor George Osborne agrees to £353m scheme. 15 July 2014. Express and Star. 15 July 2014.
  8. Web site: Midland Metropolitan Hospital opening delayed by six-month engineering setback. 24 May 2017. Express and Star. 6 October 2017.
  9. News: Carillion choice for Smethwick hospital. 24 August 2015. Express and Star. 12 August 2015.
  10. News: Matthews-King. Alex. Alarm in hospitals as NHS triggers emergency plans in 14 trusts after Carillion collapse. https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220514/https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/carillion-latest-nhs-contingency-plans-hospitals-triggered-contracts-trusts-liquidation-government-a8161881.html . 14 May 2022 . subscription . live. 21 January 2018. Independent. 16 January 2018.
  11. News: Davies. Rob. Clark. Tim. Campbell. Denis. Carillion collapse further delays building at two major hospitals. 21 January 2018. Guardian. 19 January 2018.
  12. News: Penfold. Simon. Carillion: More jobs go but 10,000 have now been saved. 9 April 2018. Express & Star. 9 April 2018.
  13. News: Price. David. Carillion understated hospital costs by £70m. 26 March 2018. Construction News. 26 March 2018.
  14. News: Morby. Aaron. Contractors lined-up for Carillion problem PFI hospitals. 12 March 2018. Construction Enquirer. 12 March 2018.
  15. News: Morby. Aaron. Carillion’s Midlands Pf2 hospital to cost extra £125m. 20 April 2018. Construction Enquirer. 20 April 2018.
  16. News: Morby. Aaron. Midlands hospital opening pushed back two years. 2 May 2018. Construction Enquirer. 2 May 2018.
  17. News: Plimmer . Gill . Treasury scrambles for investors for Carillion hospital project . 11 June 2018 . Financial Times . 10 June 2018.
  18. News: Penfold . Simon . Government may take over work on Midland Met Hospital if new PFI attempt fails . 28 June 2018 . Express & Star . 27 June 2018.
  19. News: Morby . Aaron . Plan to restart stalled Midlands hospital with new PF2 deal . 3 July 2018 . Construction Enquirer . 3 July 2018.
  20. News: Prior . Grant . Contract race starts to patch-up Carillion hospital . 9 August 2018 . Construction Enquirer . 9 August 2018.
  21. News: Morby . Aaron . Balfour bags stalled Midland Met hospital patch-up . 5 October 2018 . Construction Enquirer . 4 October 2018.
  22. News: Morby . Aaron . Trust cans PF2 plan for Carillion-hit hospital restart . 3 August 2018 . Construction Enquirer . 3 August 2018.
  23. News: Marshall . Jordan . Government confirms bailout for stalled Carillion hospital job . 16 August 2018 . Building . 16 August 2018.
  24. News: NHS trust struggling to find replacement to build post-Carillion Birmingham hospital . 1 November 2018 . National Health Executive . 1 November 2018.
  25. News: Morby . Aaron . Trust to split cost savings on Midland Met hospital job . 10 January 2019 . Construction Enquirer . 9 January 2019.
  26. News: Ing . Will . Work to restart Midland Met hospital already at risk of falling behind, boss admits . 29 April 2019 . Building . 8 April 2019.
  27. News: Morby . Aaron . Balfour Beatty set for Midland Met finishing deal . 30 April 2019 . Construction Enquirer . 30 April 2019.
  28. News: Morby . Aaron . Balfour sign-off to complete Midland Met hospital delayed . 6 September 2019 . Construction Enquirer . 6 September 2019.
  29. News: Prior . Grant . Balfour gets go-ahead to restart Midland Met hospital . 12 December 2019 . Construction Enquirer . 11 December 2019.
  30. News: Morby . Aaron . NAO raises alarm over cost of finishing Carillion hospitals . 17 January 2020 . Construction Enquirer . 17 January 2020.
  31. News: Guttridge . Richard . Midland Metropolitan University Hospital opening delayed yet again until 2023 . 14 October 2021 . BirminghamLive . 12 October 2021.
  32. News: Price . David . Midland Met set to miss 2022 opening date as material problems bite . 14 October 2021 . Construction News . 14 October 2021.
  33. News: Rogers . Dave . Birmingham hospital caught up in Carillion collapse set to open six years late . 4 July 2022 . Building . 4 July 2022.
  34. News: Leach . Harry . Sandwell super hospital opening delayed until autumn 2024 . . 3 October 2023 . 1 April 2024.