| Menace II Society | |
| Director: | The Hughes Brothers |
| Screenplay: | Tyger Williams |
| Producer: | Darin Scott |
| Starring: |
|
| Cinematography: | Lisa Rinzler |
| Editing: | Christopher Koefoed |
| Music: | QD III |
| Distributor: | New Line Cinema[1] |
| Runtime: | 97 minutes |
| Country: | United States |
| Language: | English |
| Budget: | $3.5 million |
| Gross: | $30 million[2] |
Menace II Society (pronounced Menace to Society) is a 1993 American teen crime drama film directed by the Hughes Brothers[3] in their directorial debut. Set in the Watts and Crenshaw neighborhoods of Los Angeles, the film follows the life of Caine Lawson (Tyrin Turner) and his close friends. It gained notoriety for its scenes of violence, profanity, and drug-related content, and also received critical acclaim for the performances of Turner, Jada Pinkett (in her film debut), and Larenz Tate, the direction, and its realistic portrayal of urban violence and powerful underlying messages.
Kaydee "Caine" Lawson and his best friend Kevin "O-Dog" Anderson enter a liquor store to buy some malt liquor, where a Korean cashier and his wife suspiciously rush them to buy their drinks and leave. As they walk out, the cashier provokingly tells O-Dog "I feel sorry for your mother," enraging the latter and causing him to kill both the cashier and his wife. O-Dog then confiscates the surveillance tape, robs the cashier's wallet and the cash register, and flees with Caine. Caine recounts that his father Tat, a drug dealer, was killed in an unsuccessful drug deal when Caine was 10, and his heroin-addicted mother Karen died of an overdose soon afterwards. This led to his maternal grandparents raising him in the crime-ridden Jordan Downs housing projects.
Following several years of struggling in class, Caine, himself a low-level drug dealer, finally completes high school. On graduation night, Caine and his cousin Harold attend a party, where O-Dog flaunts the surveillance tape to a group of their closest friends, much to Caine's dismay. Later, the cousins are carjacked en route from the party, with Caine suffering a shoulder wound and Harold being murdered. After learning the carjackers' whereabouts, Caine, O-Dog, and their friend A-Wax, an OG, locate and execute them, avenging Harold's death.
Sometime later, Caine visits Ronnie, the girlfriend of his childhood mentor and Tat's business partner Pernell, who is serving life in prison. He bonds with Ronnie’s young son, Anthony, and ensures she has sufficient finances. That night, tasked by their colleague Chauncey, Caine and O-Dog attempt car theft but are arrested. As he is still underage, O-Dog is released with a warning, but Caine is detained as his fingerprints match those on a beer bottle he dropped during the liquor store murders. During an interrogation, a detective tries tricking Caine by changing the questions multiple times, but Caine is soon released due to insufficient evidence. Caine is given advice by his religious grandfather and Sharif's father, a teacher at a local high school to change his ways and warn him about being jailed or killed. Caine's friends Stacy, a teenage father, and Sharif, a devout Muslim, also try to keep Caine out of trouble by convincing Caine to accompany them to Kansas, but fail. Caine, nevertheless, ignores all advice.
Influenced by his late parents’ lifestyle of drugs and crime, Caine purchases and begins cooking a large quantity of crack cocaine, soon becoming a hustler. He also encounters and eventually has sexual intercourse with a local girl named Ilena. One night, he and Sharif are stopped and assaulted by cops, who then dump them in a Hispanic neighborhood. However, the sympathetic Hispanic gang members surprisingly take them to a hospital rather than further assault them as the police anticipated. During his hospitalization, Ronnie invites him to accompany her to her new secretarial job in Atlanta. Initially hesitant, he ultimately agrees. At a party, Caine rescues Ronnie from Chauncey's drunken sexual advances and starts pistol-whipping him, prompting Stacy and Sharif to restrain him. Unbeknownst to Caine and O-Dog, a humiliated Chauncey retaliates by sending his copy of the surveillance tape to the police. Ilena phones Caine about her pregnancy, but he denies paternity and rejects her.
Ronnie and Caine visit Pernell in prison, where Caine is gripped by the sight of his incarcerated mentor. Hoping Caine can be a more positive role model for Anthony, Pernell encourages him to relocate to Atlanta. Afterwards, Caine returns home when he is approached by Ilena's cousin outside his house. An argument about Ilena and her pregnancy ensues, resulting in Caine brutally stomping on Ilena's cousin in front of his onlooking neighbors. Caine's grandfather soon comes outside to stop Caine and bring him inside. Having had enough of Caine's violent and trouble-prone behavior, Caine's grandfather tells Caine he can no longer stay in their house and wants him out by the evening, dismissing Caine's plea to stay until he leaves for Atlanta. Learning from their friend Doc of Chauncey's betrayal, a now-wanted Caine and O-Dog seek refuge at Ronnie's and other friends' houses. O-Dog vows revenge on Chauncey while Ilena's cousin gathers his friends to seek revenge on Caine.
As Caine and Ronnie are preparing to depart, Ilena's cousin and his friends drive by Ronnie's house and engage in a drive-by shootout. During the shootout, Sharif is instantly killed, O-Dog shoots back at the attackers, and Caine gets fatally wounded while shielding Anthony. After the shootout, Stacy and Ronnie emerge from the house, respectively tending to Caine and Anthony. As Caine's life flashes before him, he recalls his grandfather asking him if he cares whether he lives or dies, and he realizes in his dying moment that he does, but it's too late.
Originally, rapper MC Ren was set to play A-Wax, but later turned down the role when he joined the Nation of Islam in late 1992. MC Eiht replaced MC Ren's role as A-Wax. Rappers Spice 1 and Tupac Shakur were initially set to play Caine and Sharif respectively, but they were later fired, with director Allen Hughes stating that Shakur was causing trouble on the set. Shakur was angry for not being told why Sharif would turn Muslim. When Shakur was cast in the role of Sharif who, as described in the film was "an ex-knucklehead turned Muslim", he did not agree with how the character was written. While many of his rap music contemporaries were portraying roles similar to their gangsta rap personas, Sharif would have required Shakur to portray the character as a stoic & pious Muslim. According to MC Eiht, who played A-Wax in the film:
Six months after the firing, Shakur assaulted Hughes, resulting in Shakur being found guilty of assault and battery.[4] [5] Nonetheless, after Tupac's death, Allen Hughes praised the actor, stating "If 'Pac had been in the movie he would've outshined everyone."[6]
Menace II Society received generally positive reviews from critics.[7] The film has an 85% approval score on Rotten Tomatoes based on 46 reviews, with an average rating of 7.40/10. The consensus reads, "Told with grit and verve by the Hughes brothers in their feature debut, Menace II Society is a gangland epic that breathes with authenticity while steeped in style."[8] Metacritic gave the film a weighted average score of 76 out of 100, based on 19 critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".[9]
Chicago Reader critic Jonathan Rosenbaum stated, "This is a powerful, convincing, and terrifying look at teenage crime in contemporary Watts."[10] Owen Gleiberman from Entertainment Weekly gave it a positive review, stating, "Menace II Society is bleak, brilliant, and unsparing."[11]
Emanuel Levy gave the film an A, saying it is "The most stunning feature debut in the new African American cinema, even more so than Boyz n the Hood to which the coming of age feature bears thematic resemblance."[12] The film was placed on both Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert's 10 best films of 1993 lists, with Ebert praising "the way the filmmakers tell Caine's story without making him seem either the hero or victim".[13] [14]
However, the film has also received some negative reviews. Geoff Andrew of Time Out stated, "Regrettably, the Hughes Brothers' first feature is a compendium of clichés."[15] Stephen Holden of The New York Times stated, "If Menace II Society is terrific on ambiance, it is considerably less successful in revealing character."[16] At the 1994 MTV Movie Awards, the film was awarded Best Movie, beating out the likes of Philadelphia, Jurassic Park and Schindler's List.[17] At the Independent Spirit Award, The film had nominated an for Best First Feature, but lost to El Mariachi (the first installment in the Robert Rodriguez's Mexico Trilogy).[18]
The film grossed $27.9 million in the United States and Canada but only $1.6 million internationally for a worldwide total of $29.5 million.[19] [2]
1993 Independent Spirit Awards
1994 MTV Movie Award
See main article: Menace II Society (soundtrack). A soundtrack containing hip hop music was released on May 26, 1993, by Jive Records. It peaked at #11 on the Billboard 200 and #1 on the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums.
The director's cut of Menace II Society was released on LaserDisc in January 1994 via The Criterion Collection.[20] [21]
Menace II Society was released on DVD in 1997 by New Line Home Video. The director's cut was released on DVD in 2009. This film was also included in "double feature" and "4 Film Favorites" DVD packages in the 2010s. There is one "double feature" package in DVD Region 1 that includes Juice (released in 2013), and another that includes New Jack City (released in 2016), in addition to Menace II Society. The "4 Film Favorites" DVD package, released in 2013 in Region 1, includes ATL, New Jack City, and Set It Off, in addition to Menace II Society.
In August 2021, Criterion announced that Menace II Society, alongside 5 other films, would be released as a part of its first 4K Ultra HD releases. Criterion indicated each title will be available in a 4K UHD+Blu-ray combo pack including a 4K UHD disc of the feature film as well as the film and special features on the companion Blu-ray. The titles were released in November 2021.[22]
In 2013, rapper and record producer Kanye West cited Menace II Society as one of his "most-watched" favorite films on an episode of the Bret Easton Ellis Podcast.[23]