Media censorship and disinformation during the Gezi Park protests explained

The 2013 Gezi Park protests in Turkey saw massive amounts of censorship and disinformation by the mainstream media, especially by those supporting Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and his Justice and Development Party (AKP).[1] A poll done by Istanbul Bilgi University in the first week of the protests showed that 84% of the demonstrators cited the lack of media coverage as a reason to join the protests, higher than the 56% of protesters who referred to the destruction of Gezi Park.[2]

Censorship during protests

History

Censorship is a common issue in Turkey. Since 2011, the AKP has increasingly levied restrictions on freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and internet use,[3] and television content,[4] as well as the right to free assembly.[5] It has also developed links with media groups, and used administrative and legal measures (including, in one case, a $2.5 billion tax fine) against critical media groups and critical journalists: "over the last decade the AKP has built an informal, powerful, coalition of party-affiliated businessmen and media outlets whose livelihoods depend on the political order that Erdoğan is constructing. Those who resist do so at their own risk."[6]

Televisions

[On the afternoon of Friday, May 31, 2013] CNN Turk was broadcasting a food show, featuring the "flavors of Niğde." Other major Turkish news channels were showing a dance contest and a roundtable on study-abroad programs. It was a classic case of the revolution not being televised. The whole country seemed to be experiencing a cognitive disconnect, with Twitter saying one thing, the government saying another, and the television off on another planet.

Newspapers

Social media

As a result of the lack of mainstream media coverage, social media played a key role in keeping people informed, with Twitter hashtags #OccupyGezi and #DirenGeziParki ("Resist, Gezi Park") being adopted.[16] [17] [18] In the 12 hours from 4 pm 31 May, there were more than 2 million tweets for the 3 leading hashtags, with 88% in Turkish and 90% of geolocated tweets coming from Turkey. Erdoğan said in a speech that "There is now a menace which is called Twitter. The best examples of lies can be found there. To me, social media is the worst menace to society."[19] A December 2012 Pew Research Center study showed 35% of Turks using social networking sites.[20]

Sixteen people in İzmir and thirteen people in Adana were detained for posting provocative messages on Twitter[21] but were released later.[22] Sabah wrote that some of those people were arrested for tweets about actions like "We've burned Bank Asya", "We destroyed the Körfez cram school", "We've burned the FEM cram school".[23]

There were reports that the 3G signal in some areas had been turned off; in response, some shops and offices removed security from their Wifi networks.[24] [25] Rumours of censorship led to increasing use of virtual private networks (VPNs) during the protests.[26]

According to The Economist, "Mr Erdogan's perceived enemies" have been "inundated with menacing tweets." These include a correspondent covering the protests being called a "dirty Armenian" and "a slut" by pro-government supporters.[27]

Reactions to censorship

Pressure on journalists

Disinformation during protests

The 2013 protests in Turkey witnessed a large amount of disinformation being spread by pro-AKP, conservative, and Islamist media, also dubbed as Yandaş Medya ("Slanted Media"). Leading newspapers said to be spreading disinformation were Yeni Şafak, Yeni Akit, Daily Sabah, Star, Takvim, Bugün, Akşam, Zaman, Türkiye, Milli Gazete, Güneş, and Milat, among others. Leading TV channels spreading disinformation were Kanal 7, 24, Ülke TV, TRT, Samanyolu, ATV, TGRT, Sky Turk 360, TV Net, TV8, Beyaz TV, Kanaltürk, and Kanal A. Leading internet portals said to be spreading disinformation were Haber 7, Habervaktim, En Son Haber, and Rotahaber.

Turkish public broadcasting service TRT aired footage of people burning the Turkish flag. The footage was originally aired in 2010 but featured doctored dates, implying the current demonstrations were somehow secessionist in nature.[48]

Takvim newspaper devoted its front page to a fake "interview" with CNN's Christiane Amanpour, in which Amanpour supposedly confesses that CNN's coverage of the protests was motivated by "the express interest of destabilizing Turkey for international business interests". The paper included a small disclaimer on the 14th page, saying "This interview is not real, but what you will read here is real."[60] Takvim newspaper also sued Amanpour.[61]

See also

Notes and References

  1. News: Orhan Kemal Cengiz . Shameful Examples Emerge Of Press Censorship in Turkey . . 3 July 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  2. News: Pelin Turgut . As Turkey's Protests Continue, Attention Falls on Failures of Turkish Media . . 6 June 2013 . 2015-05-05.
  3. News: Turkey's Glow Dims as Government Limits Free Speech . The New York Times . Dan . Bilefsky . Sebnem . Arsu . 4 January 2012.
  4. News: Sibel Utku Bila . In Erdogan's Turkey, Censorship Finds Fertile Ground . . 2013-01-13 . 2014-02-18.
  5. News: Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan Sets Deadline for EU Admission . . Spiegel.de . 2012-10-31 . 2014-02-18.
  6. News: Why Turkish Protesting . 22 September 2013 . . . 13 February 2014.
  7. Web site: Alfonso . Fernando . CNN-Turk airs penguin documentary during Istanbul riots . The Daily Dot . 2013-06-02 . 26 June 2013.
  8. Web site: Fleishman . Cooper . CNN-Turk airs penguin documentary during Istanbul riots . dailydot.com . June 2, 2013 . June 3, 2013.
  9. News: New York Times. 1 June 2013. Police Retreat as Protests Expand Through Turkey.
  10. News: Wall Street Journal. 3 June 2013. Amid Turkey Unrest, Social Media Becomes a Battleground.
  11. Web site: 'NTV haber burnunun dibinde'. tr . 'NTV news is right under your nose'. Haber.sol.org.tr . 26 June 2013. 2013-06-03.
  12. Web site: Eylemler sonuç verdi! NTV insafa geldi! . tr . Actions yielded results! NTV has come to its senses!. Gazeteciler.com . 26 June 2013 . https://web.archive.org/web/20130709005942/http://www.gazeteciler.com/gundem/eylemler-sonuc-verdi-ntv-insafa-geldi-66959h.html . 9 July 2013 . dead.
  13. BBC, 5 June 2013, Turkey protests resume in Istanbul after apology
  14. News: Hurriyet Daily News. 13 June 2013. Doğuş Media CEO takes leave amid media criticism.
  15. Web site: Al birini Vur ötekine! 7 "müsvedde" medya gazetesinde tek başlık! . Take one and hit the other! A single headline in 7 "draft" media newspapers!. Yesilgazete.org . 2013-01-24 . 2014-02-18. tr.
  16. News: Turkish Weekly. 1 June 2013. ‘Occupy Taksim’ grows in spite of crackdown. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20130915032134/http://www.turkishweekly.net/news/151041/-occupy-taksim-grows-in-spite-of-crackdown.html . 2013-09-15.
  17. News: Protesters #OccupyGezi to save Istanbul park. Al Jazeera. 31 May 2013. 1 June 2013. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20130601073350/http://stream.aljazeera.com/story/201305302148-0022796. 1 June 2013.
  18. News: Ünlüler Gezi Parkı ile ilgili Twitter'da neler söyledi?. What did celebrities say about Gezi Park on Twitter?. tr. Radikal. 31 May 2013. 1 June 2013.
  19. News: Costanze. Letsch. Turkish protests: Prime Minister blames opposition. The Guardian. 2 June 2013. London. 2 June 2013.
  20. Web site: Pew Research Center. 12 December 2012. Social Networking Popular Across Globe.
  21. News: İzmir'de 'halkı isyana teşvik' baskınları: 16 gözaltı. Raids in Izmir for 'inciting people to revolt': 16 detained. tr. 4 June 2013. Radikal.
  22. News: Twitter gözaltıları serbest bırakıldı. Twitter detainees released. tr. 11 June 2013. 17 June 2013.
  23. News: Twitter tutuklamalarının sebebi belli oldu. Reason for Twitter arrests revealed. tr. Sabah. 6 June 2013. 17 June 2013.
  24. News: Barbera . Pablo . Metzger . Megan . Tucker . Joshua A. . 2013-06-01 . A breakout role for Twitter in the Taksim Square protests?. Al Jazeera . 2021-10-31.
  25. News: Naidoo . Kumi . The last tree or the final straw?. Al Jazeera. 2013-06-01. 2021-10-31.
  26. News: 2013-06-04 . Turkish protesters using encryption software to evade censors. . 2021-10-31.
  27. News: Erdogan cracks down. The Economist. 2 October 2015. 2013-06-22.
  28. Web site: Statement regarding BBC and NTV, Turkey. bbc.co.uk. 14 June 2013. 14 June 2013.
  29. News: Zeynep Erekli . CNN International must pull its name franchise from CNN Turk @TeamCNN . Change.org . 2013-06-10.
  30. News: Turkish journalists fired over coverage of Gezi Park protests . https://ghostarchive.org/archive/20220512/https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/turkish-journalists-fired-over-coverage-of-gezi-park-protests-8727133.html . 2022-05-12 . subscription . live . The Independent . 2013-07-23 . 2014-02-18 . London.
  31. News: BBC Turkish reporter Selin Girit intimidated by Turkey . Avrupa Times . 2013-06-25 . 2014-02-18.
  32. News: NTV Tarih, Popular History Magazine, Closed . Bianet . 1 July 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  33. Web site: Yaşarken Yazılan Tarih . History Written While Living. tr. yasarkenyazilantarih.com . 2014-02-18.
  34. News: Yaşarken Yazılan Tarih . History Written While Living. tr. . 31 October 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  35. News: Hurriyet Daily News. 12 June 2013. TV watchdog fines live streaming of Gezi protests for ‘harming development of children, youth’.
  36. News: Radikal. 14 June 2013. RTÜK, Hayat TV hakkındaki kapatma kararını geri çekti. RTÜK withdrew its decision to close Hayat TV. tr.
  37. News: Eskişehir governor threatens journalist over reports on Gezi protester's murder . . 2011-09-13 . 2014-02-18.
  38. News: Aydın Doğan yazarlarını yine uyarmalıdır . Aydin Dogan should warn its writers again. tr. Mehmet Barlas . . 20 September 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  39. News: Yavuz Baydar . Shooting the Arbiter in Turkey: How Sabah Fired Its Ombudsman . . 25 July 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  40. News: Başörtülü anneye saldırının görüntü kayıtları mercek altında haberi . . 2013-06-14 . 2014-02-18.
  41. News: Istanbul Governor says he didn't see any video of attack on woman by Gezi protesters . . 12 July 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  42. News: Sığındıkları camide içki içtiler! . They drank alcohol in the mosque where they took shelter!. tr. . 3 June 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  43. News: PM Erdoğan repeats previously denied reports of protesters entering mosque with shoes on . . 9 June 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  44. News: Yasemin Çongar . Turkish Muezzin Who Couldn't Lie Is Exiled . . 2013-09-23 . 2014-02-18.
  45. News: Mirac gecesinde sokakları karıştırma planı. Plan to stir up the streets on the night of Miraj. tr . . 3 June 2013 . 2014-02-18.
  46. Web site: Ajanslar eyleme sponsor. Piri Medya. 3 June 2013. Yeni Şafak. 2 October 2015.
  47. Web site: BUNLAR CIA’nın ÇOCUKLARI - Mustafa Durdu. THESE ARE THE CHILDREN OF THE CIA - Mustafa Durdu. Haber Vatkim. tr. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20141225145410/http://www.habervaktim.com/yazar/59624/bunlar-cianin-cocuklari.html . December 25, 2014.
  48. News: TRT'nin bayrak yaktılar videosu yalan çıktı!. TRT's flag burning video turned out to be a lie!. tr. 5 June 2013. Ulusalkanal.
  49. Web site: Gezi Parkı olaylarının perde arkası. Behind the scenes of Gezi Park events. June 6, 2013. Sabah. tr.
  50. Web site: Is Turkey, After Gezi Protests, On Path to Democratization? - Al-Monitor: the Pulse of the Middle East. Al-Monitor. 2 October 2015. 2013-09-19.
  51. Web site: Houston'dan ölüm emri. Houston death warrant. tr. Piri Medya. 5 June 2013. Yeni Şafak. 2 October 2015.
  52. Web site: Göstericilerin köprüden attığı komiser öldü. Police chief thrown off bridge by protesters dies. Rotahaber. June 6, 2013. tr. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20130609082504/http://haber.rotahaber.com/gostericilerin-kopruden-attigi-komiser-oldu_374167.html. June 9, 2013.
  53. Web site: Komiser Mustafa Sarı'nın ailesi: Atılmadı düştü, iddialar spekülasyon. Commissioner Mustafa Sarı's family: He was not thrown, he fell, the allegations are speculation. tr. 6 October 2013. Radikal. 2 October 2015.
  54. Web site: Turkish actor threatened over his Gezi Park support - LOCAL. Hurriyet Daily News. 2 October 2015.
  55. Web site: Hurriyet Daily News. 12 June 2013. Turkish politicians slam foreign media coverage of the Gezi Park protests.
  56. Web site: Kendi Gözlerimle Gördüm. I Saw It With My Own Eyes. tr. 13 June 2013. Habervaktim. 2 October 2015.
  57. Web site: ABD ajanı Gezi Parkı eyleminde...!. US agent at Gezi Park protest...!. tr. Rotahaber.
  58. Web site: Eylemcileri Migros Besliyor. Migros Feeds Protesters. tr. 14 June 2013. Habervaktim. 2 October 2015.
  59. Web site: Duran Adam Eylemi CIA Taktiği Çıktı!. Standing Man Action Turns Out to Be a CIA Tactic!. tr. Star.com.tr. 2 October 2015.
  60. News: 'Shame on you,' Amanpour reacts to Turkish daily that published fake interview . 18 June 2013 . 14 February 2014 . Hürriyet Daily News.
  61. News: Christiane Amanpour Slams Turkish Newspaper For Fake Interview . Huffington Post . Katherine . Fung . 18 June 2013.
  62. Web site: Başbakan Erdoğan'ın evine 3 bin kişiyle baskın. 3,000 people raid Prime Minister Erdoğan's house. tr. 21 June 2013. Haber7. 2 October 2015.
  63. Web site: Polis değilsen kıyafet alamazsın. If you're not a cop, you can't buy clothes.. tr. Piri Medya. 24 June 2013. Yeni Şafak. 2 October 2015.
  64. Web site: Sarısülük'le ilgili çok tartışılan fotoğraf!. The much discussed photo of Sarısülük!. tr. 27 June 2013. Haber7. 2 October 2015.
  65. News: Ethem Sarısülük'ün fotoğrafı kampta değil karakolda çekilmiş . Ethem Sarısülük's photo was taken at the police station, not in the camp. tr. 27 June 2013 . 14 February 2014 . . Dursun . Ayşegül.
  66. Web site: Gezi Parkı'na 600 pizza siparişi hangi ülkeden ödendi?. Which country paid for the 600 pizza orders for Gezi Park?. tr. 2 October 2015.
  67. Web site: Geziciler 30 Ağustos’ta Provokasyona Hazırlanıyor. Gezi Protesters Prepare for Provocation on August 30. tr. August 24, 2013. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20141225145414/http://www.habervaktim.com/haber/340105/geziciler-30-agustosta-provokasyona-hazirlaniyor.html . December 25, 2014.
  68. Web site: Chomsky accuses Turkish daily of fabricating parts of interview - LOCAL. 2 October 2015.
  69. News: Turkish Newspaper's Fake Chomsky Interview Lost in Translation. The Wall Street Journal. 5 September 2013. Peker. Emre.
  70. Web site: Turkish daily admits to making up parts of Chomsky interview, releases alleged text - LOCAL. 2 October 2015.
  71. Web site: Turkish daily apologizes for fabricated Chomsky interview - LOCAL. 2 October 2015. Hurriyet Daily News.
  72. Web site: Turkish officials blame protesters for failed Olympics bid. Thomas Seibert. 9 September 2013. 2 October 2015.
  73. Web site: Taş atmak 5 TOMA'nın önüne yatmak 10 TL. Throwing stones costs 5 TL and lying down in front of a TOMA costs 10 TL.. tr. Piri Medya. 27 September 2013. Yeni Şafak. 2 October 2015.
  74. Web site: Gezi'de kedi kanı içiyorlardı. They were drinking cat blood in Gezi. tr. Yurt Gazetesi. 29 September 2013. 2 October 2015.
  75. Web site: Trafik lobisinin işi mi?. Is it the work of the traffic lobby?. tr. 11 October 2013. MILLIYET HABER. 2 October 2015.
  76. Web site: Marmaray calm on second day after first day's storm of technical problems - LOCAL. 2 October 2015. Hurriyet Daily News.
  77. Web site: Marmaray'a gezi sabotajı. Marmaray travel sabotage. tr. 3 November 2013. turkiyegazetesi.com.tr. 2 October 2015.
  78. Web site: Mossad Gezi'si. takvim.com.tr. 2 October 2015. tr.
  79. News: Released footage shows no physical attack on headscarf-wearing woman during Gezi protests . 14 February 2014 . Turkish Weekly.
  80. News: Video casts doubt over alleged attack on headscarved woman . 14 February 2014 . The Daily Star.
  81. Web site: Pro-gov't media: Gezi protesters conspiring to use up İstanbul's water. 16 July 2014. TodaysZaman. 2 October 2015. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20150818200817/http://www.todayszaman.com/national_pro-govt-media-gezi-protesters-conspiring-to-use-up-istanbuls-water_353227.html. 18 August 2015.
  82. News: Tornistan: Turkey's summer of anti-government protests . Nabeelah . Shabbir . 2014-03-11 . 2014-07-07 . The Guardian.