Medal theft explained

Medal theft is the theft of awards for military action, civil service, and achievements in science or sports. Medals and similar awards are stolen for resale, private collection or ransom; some are destroyed for gold bullion. While not common in developed nations, reported instances have drawn wide press coverage, considering notability and public exposure of the victims of the crime.

Thefts by nation

Australia

In 1985, Olympic medals belonging to swimmer John Konrads were stolen from his home. The medals were recovered in 2009.^[1]

In 2003, Lauren Burns' Olympic gold medal was stolen.^[2]

Canada

In December 1979, a medal awarded to Milton Fowler Gregg in 1918, the Victoria Cross, was donated to the Royal Canadian Regiment Museum in London, Ontario, but was stolen from the museum shortly afterwards.^[3]

On January 15, 2009, about 30 valuable medals belonging to a Chilliwack, British Columbia Odd Fellows lodge were stolen.^[4] Five of the medals later turned up during a narcotics raid.^[5]

India

In 2004, Rabindranath Tagore's 1913 Nobel prize medal was stolen.^[6] In 2016, a local singer accused of sheltering the thieves was arrested, but the medal could not be recovered. Interrogation revealed that a Bangladeshi national, along with two Europeans, were involved in the theft.^{[7] [8]} Two replicas, one in gold and one in silver were later presented to Viswa Bharati University by the Swedish government.^[9]

In February 2017, Kailash Satyarthi's 2014 Nobel prize medal was stolen.^[10]

Russian Empire, Soviet Union, Russia, Belarus and Ukraine

Peacetime theft of medals prior to 1980s was quite rare. A well known case occurred on the day of the Decembrist revolt, December 14, 1825. Military governor of Saint Petersburg, Count Miloradovich, was fatally wounded by Pyotr Kakhovsky. The dying Miloradovich was taken to a safe place; when a surgeon arrived there, Miloradovich laid stripped of his military decorations. The marauders remained unidentified.

A black market in Soviet military artifacts boomed in 1980s. The first publicly known case occurred in 1983: retired admiral Georgy Kholostyakov and his wife were murdered at their home by Gennady and Inna Kalinina, with the sole purpose of obtaining the admiral's medals (which included the Golden Star and Order of the Bath). The prosecution, allegedly supervised by Yuri Andropov, connected Kalinins to another murder and 38 other cases of medal theft. Gennady Kalinin was sentenced to death, Inna Kalinina to 15 years.^[11] Violent robberies against veterans remain quite rare: in most cases the thieves impersonate social workers, policemen, museum workers and thus obtain access to old veterans' homes without violence.

A massive theft from the Central Armed Forces Museum was identified in 1994 and remains unsolved.^[11] In November 2006 Russian government agency requested Sotheby's to halt an upcoming sale of 11 Soviet military awards presumed to be stolen.^[12] The medals were later returned to Russia through Interpol. The Central Armed Forces Museum admitted that the medals could have been stolen from them.

December 23, 1999, thieves stole the collection of Michel da Vincha, a French citizen and notable collector living in Moscow, which included rare awards of the Russian Empire. Although the police soon recovered the stolen treasures, they were still not returned to Da Vincha.^[13]

According to Trud, there were two surges in medal thefts in 2000s. The latest one occurred in the first half of 2008, apparently continues as of August 2008 and has not been analyzed completely yet. Victims range from World War II heroes like Yekaterina Demina, the only female Marine of that war,^[14] to symphony conductor Veronica Dudarova.^[15] A concurrent crime wave was reported in Minsk^[16] and Vitebsk,^[17] Belarus. The previous crime wave peaked between 2003 and 2006;^[11] most public cases include:

• In 2004 Moscow prosecution detained someone Yury Tikhonov who faced indictment for multiple counts of medal theft, including robbing fighter ace Anton Yakimenko.^[18] The alleged thief visited war veterans in Russia and Belarus disguised as a photographer, and quietly replaced their genuine medals with fakes. Prosecution asserted that a large number of similar crimes remained unknown to the victims due to the quality of counterfeit medals.^[19] In 2006 Tikhonov's modus operandi was repeated in Ukraine by a 30-year-old psychology student, also using photography and counterfeit replicas. The unidentified thief was caught in Rivne Oblast and indicted in 15 counts of theft.^[20]
• An Order of the British Empire was stolen from its owner, educator Elena Nemirovskaya, in July 2004. Nemirovskaya, Teodor Shanin and Mstislav Rostropovich were the three living Russian recipients of OBE, and Nemirovskaya's award was the only one physically present in Russia.^[21]
• In 2005 Moscow prosecution indicted Alexander Karmanov in multiple cases of fraud. According to prosecution, in 1993 Karmanov, a seasoned convict who already served a total of 17 years in prison, organized a properly licensed military "museum" - to circumvent the law prohibiting trading in state awards. Karmanov, presenting himself as a legitimate museum worker, fraudulently obtained awards issued to late Ivan Kozhedub, Sergey Gorshkov and other military figures.^[22]
• In the middle of 2006 two men robbed the family of the late Hero of the Soviet Union, WWII bomber pilot Yegor Chalov (1919-1983) in Novgorod. September 10, 2007 Hero of the Soviet Union, former intelligence officer Nikolay Kuznetsov,^[23] also from Novgorod Oblast, was robbed of his medals. Both cases appear to be connected by a common sales channel. Perpetrators in Yegor Chalov case were apprehended and eventually sentenced to 4 years each; the stolen medals are presumed gone without trace.^[24] Medals stolen from Kuznetsov were recovered through Moscow journalists, apparently in the course of the same operation.^[25]

United Kingdom

The most famous stolen military medal in the United Kingdom is the Chelengk awarded by the Ottoman Empire to Lord Nelson. It was stolen from the National Maritime Museum in 1951 and has never been recovered.

In 1985, Kay Miller's Nobel medal for ‘International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War’ was stolen and recovered.

In 2000, a gold medal was stolen from Matthew Pinsent, British rowing champion, at Heathrow.

In 2006, more than £23,000 (US$45,970) worth of football medals stolen from the home of then Liverpool F.C. goalkeeper Jerzy Dudek were found in the possession of businessman Martin Roche.^[26]

On February 6, 2008, several medals from World War I were stolen from a home in Knoll Hill, Aldington, Kent.^[27]

In October 2012 the Olympic medals of Hannah Macleod and Alex Partridge were stolen at the Mahiki nightclub. Macleod's medal was returned in the mail, but Partridge's medal is still missing.^[28]

The Nobel Peace Prize medal won by one of the founding fathers of the modern Labour Party, Arthur Henderson, has been stolen in a £150,000 raid at the Lord Mayor's office in Newcastle on 3 April 2013.

United States

A large collection of medals, trophies and lithographs were stolen from the International Swimming Hall of Fame in 2004. The bulk of the collection was sold off on eBay by the thief. Most of the items were returned in 2005 after the museum discovered the theft. The 1912 Olympic wreath and gold medal of Belle Moore are still at large.^[29]

In 2007, the 1939 Nobel Prize medal in physics, awarded to professor Ernest Lawrence was stolen but recovered.^{[30] [31]}

New Zealand

December 2, 2007, thieves stole 11 war medals from the QEII Army Memorial Museum in New Zealand.^[32] Stolen medals were recovered in February 2008 after paying the bounty, reportedly to the thieves themselves. Three unidentified persons appeared in courts as suspects.^[33]

External links

• Enhanced security for poet medals
• Medal theft spree continues in Oz
• TV3 attacked for re-enactment of medal thief interview (+audio)

Notes and References

1. News: Lord . Craig . Once Lost, Konrads Legacy Is Preserved . 1 May 2012 . ISHOF News/Events . Sep 20, 2011 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20120415091114/http://www.ishof.org/news/konrads.htm . 15 April 2012 .
2. News: Theft of medal leaves champion heartbroken. Berry. Jamie. December 18, 2003. The Age.
3. News: Staples. Michael. Hero's medal needs to be displayed here - soldier. The Daily Gleaner. 3 November 2012. A1–A2.
4. Web site: Break In at Odd Fellows Lodge. Dunlop. Cst. Lea-Anne. 2009-01-16. 2009-01-24.
5. News: Some stolen medals retrieved . January 24, 2009 . . . 2009-01-24 . Chilliwack . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20121106024008/http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/westcoastnews/story.html?id=eb4f0ecb-9ae9-4780-a3d6-0ddd3b9917b4&k=73912 . 2012-11-06 .
6. News: 8 detained for Tagore medal theft. March 26, 2004. The Tribune. Kolkata.
7. News: Tagore's Nobel medal theft: Baul singer arrested - Times of India. The Times of India. 25 November 2016 . 2019-03-31.
8. Web site: Tagore's Nobel Medal Theft: Folk Singer Arrested From Bengal. News18. 26 November 2016 . 2019-03-31.
9. Web site: National : Replicas replace Tagore's medal. The Hindu. 2005-05-08. 2019-04-11.
10. News: Noble medal theft. February 7, 2017. The Indian Express. New Delhi. Nandini. Rathi.
11. М. Lukanin. Kavalery chuzhih nagrad (М. Луканин Кавалеры чужих наград) Trud, May 27, 2008 http://www.trud.ru/issue/article.php?id=200805270940801
12. News: Sotheby's to Return Medals to Russia. Kommersant. December 13, 2006. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20110606092942/http://www.kommersant.com/p-9731/r_500/Sotheby_Soviet_orders/. June 6, 2011.
13. V. Shurygin. Antikvarny labirint (Влад Шурыгин. Антикварный лабиринт), Schit i Mech, №15/1079, April 2007 http://www.ormvd.ru/press/np/133/137/7324
14. V stolitse ograbili izvestnuyu razvedchitzu (В столице ограбили легендарную разведчицу), Izvestia, July 1, 2008 https://archive.today/20120802192902/http://www.izvestia.ru/news/news180046
15. Other recent, 2008, cases in Moscow alone include widow of fighter ace Fyodor Artemenko (January 23), family of Aleksandr Perov, an FSB officer killed in the Beslan school hostage crisis (April 28), an 85-year-old former nurse identified by first name only (August 15),an unidentified 85-year-old recipient of all three degrees of Order of Glory (July 16), an unidentified chief surgeon of the Central Clinic (June 06)
16. Crime reports by Minsk police department, 2008: June 22 July 11 August 28
17. V Vitebske uchastilis popytki krazhi ordenov i medalei (В Витебске участились попытки кражи орденов и медалей у ветеранов войны) Site of Polatsk city administration, February 8, 2008 Web site: / Новости / | Полоцкий район | Полоцк | Новости Полоцка | Новости Полоцкого района | Полоцкий райисполком . 2008-08-16 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20110706162836/http://polotsk.vitebsk-region.gov.by/ru/news/region?id=961 . 2011-07-06 .
18. V Moskve u generala ukrali zvezdu Geroya (В Москве у генерала мошенник украл звезду Героя Советского Союза) newsru.com, January 23, 2004 http://www.newsru.com/arch/crime/23jan2004/gold_z.html
19. S. Dyupin. Ordenonosets v osobo krupnyh rasmerah (C. Дюпин. "Орденоносец" в особо крупных размерах), Kommersant-Dengi, N. 15 (470), April 2004 Web site: Портал коллекционеров UUU.RU / Правовые вопросы / "Орденоносец" в особо крупных размерах . 2008-08-16 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20080918223930/http://text.uuu.ru/orders/Law/20040506153816Law.html . 2008-09-18 .
20. U Vladimira Shandruka vymanili orden Lenina (У Владимира Шандрука выманили орден Ленина) Gazeta po-ukrainski, November 16, 2006 http://www.gpu.ua/index.php?&id=139244&eid=252&lang=ru
21. Pochichen edinstvenny v Rossii orden Britanskoy Imperii (Похищен единственный в России Орден Британской империи) newsru.com, July 26, 2004 http://www.newsru.com/arch/crime/26jul2004/orden.html
22. E. Borodina, G. Voronkov. V tyurme ne bez udoda (E. Бородина, Г. Воронков. В тюрьме не без Удода), Moskovsky Komsomolets, July 5, 2005 https://archive.today/20120804124536/http://www.mk.ru/blogs/idmk/2005/07/05/mk-daily/57088/
23. Born 1922, full namesake but not a relative of better known intelligence officer Nikolai Ivanovich Kuznetsov (1911-1944)
24. V. Poletaev. Obidchikov geroya otpravili v tyurmy (В. Полетаев. Обидчиков героя отправили в тюрьму) Rossiyskaya Gazeta, February 5, 2008 http://www.rg.ru/2008/02/05/prigovor.html
25. Razvedchiku Kuznetsovu vozvratili ukradennye u nego nagrady (Разведчику Николаю Кузнецову возвратили украденные у него награды) Ruslevel.ru, December 12, 2007 Web site: Разведчику Николаю Кузнецову возвратили украденные у него награды . 2008-08-16 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20071229044911/http://www.newslevel.ru/news/322.html . 2007-12-29 .
26. News: Liverpool Medal Theft: Man Walks Free . https://archive.today/20120718122652/http://news.sky.com/home/article/13540793 . dead . 2012-07-18 . .
27. https://archive.today/20080106094011/http://www.kent.police.uk/Your%20Area/South%20Kent/South_Kent_news/Medal_theft.html Medals stolen in Aldington burglary
28. News: Hannah Macleod's stolen Olympic bronze medal returned. 27 October 2012. BBC. 26 October 2012.
29. News: Mogharabi. Shabnam. ISHOF memorabilia recovered. 1 May 2012. Pool & Spa News. March 14, 2005.
30. http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4176/is_20070526/ai_n19182677 Felony charge for student in Nobel medal theft
31. News: Ignoble Nobel medal theft sees prize recovered . Zaharov-Reutt . Alex . 8 March 2007 . iTWire . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20111002014932/http://www.itwire.com/content/view/10295/1066/ . 2011-10-02 .
32. Web site: New Zealand Museum Theft Heart ripped out of museum; rare George Crosses and an Albert Medal were among those stolen. December 3, 2007. Museum Security Network.
33. http://nz.news.yahoo.com/a/-/local/4936471/stolen-medals-museum-october Stolen medals due back at museum in October