Man-eating plant explained

Man-eating plant
Region:	Africa and Central America
Details:	Lives in African and Central-American forests
First Attested:	1874

A man-eating plant is a legendary carnivorous plant large enough to kill and consume a human or other large animal. Various such myths and fictional tales exist around the world.

The Madagascar tree

The earliest known report of a man-eating plant originated as a literary fabrication written by journalist Edmund Spencer for the New York World.^[1] Spencer's article first appeared in the daily edition of the New York World on 26 April 1874, and appeared again in the weekly edition of the newspaper two days later.^[2] In the article, a letter was published by a purported German explorer named "Karl Leche" (also spelled as Karl or Carl Liche in later accounts), who provided a report of encountering a human sacrifice performed by the "Mkodo tribe" of Madagascar:^[3] This story was picked up by many other newspapers of the day, which included the South Australian Register of 27 October 1874,^[4] where it gained even greater notoriety.^[5] Describing the tree, the account related:

The slender delicate palpi, with the fury of starved serpents, quivered a moment over her head, then as if instinct with demoniac intelligence fastened upon her in sudden coils round and round her neck and arms; then while her awful screams and yet more awful laughter rose wildly to be instantly strangled down again into a gurgling moan, the tendrils one after another, like great green serpents, with brutal energy and infernal rapidity, rose, retracted themselves, and wrapped her about in fold after fold, ever tightening with cruel swiftness and savage tenacity of anacondas fastening upon their prey.^[6]

The hoax was given further publicity by Madagascar: Land of the Man-eating Tree, a book by Chase Osborn, who had been a Governor of Michigan. Osborn claimed that both the tribes and missionaries on Madagascar knew about the hideous tree, repeated the above Liche account, and acknowledged "I do not know whether this tigerish tree really exists or whether the bloodcurdling stories about it are pure myth. It is enough for my purpose if its story focuses your interest upon one of the least known spots of the world."^[7]

In his 1955 book, Salamanders and other Wonders, science author Willy Ley determined that the Mkodo tribe, Carl Liche, and the Madagascar man-eating tree all appeared to be fabrications: "The facts are pretty clear by now. Of course the man eating tree does not exist. There is no such tribe."^[8]

Yateveo

In James W. Buel's Sea and Land (1889),^[9] the Yateveo plant is described as being native to Africa and South America, so named for producing a hissing sound similar to the Spanish phrase Spanish; Castilian: ya te veo, and having poisonous "spines" that resemble "many huge serpents in an angry discussion, occasionally darting from side to side as if striking at an imaginary foe" which seize and pierce any creature coming within reach.^[10]

The vampire vine

William Thomas Stead, editor of Review of Reviews, published a brief article in October 1891 that discussed a story found in Lucifer magazine, describing a plant in Nicaragua called by the natives the devil's snare. This plant had the capability "to drain the blood of any living thing which comes within its death-dealing touch." According to the article:

Mr. Dunstan, naturalist, who has recently returned from Central America, where he spent nearly two years in the study of the flora and the fauna of the country, relates the finding of a singular growth in one of the swamps which surround the great lakes of Nicaragua. He was engaged in hunting for botanical and entomological specimens, when he heard his dog cry out, as if in agony, from a distance. Running to the spot whence the animal's cries came. Mr. Dunstan found him enveloped in a perfect network of what seemed to be a fine rope-like tissue of roots and fibers... The native servants who accompanied Mr. Dunstan manifested the greatest horror of the vine, which they call "the devil's snare", and were full of stories of its death-dealing powers. He was able to discover very little about the nature of the plant, owing to the difficulty of handling it, for its grasp can only be torn away with the loss of skin and even of flesh; but, as near as Mr. Dunstan could ascertain, its power of suction is contained in a number of infinitesimal mouths or little suckers, which, ordinarily closed, open for the reception of food. If the substance is animal, the blood is drawn off and the carcass or refuse then dropped.^[11]

An investigation of Stead's review determined no such article was published in the October issue of Lucifer, and concluded that the story in Review of Reviews appeared to be a fabrication by the editor.^[12] The story in fact appeared in the September issue,^[13] preceded by a longer version in an 1889 newspaper describing Dunstan as a "well-known naturalist" from New Orleans.^[14]

Literature and film

• "The Man-Eating Tree" (1881) by Phil Robinson (included in his book Under the Punkah) describes a "man-eating tree" found in Nubia.^[15]
• Indian writer Malladi Venkata Krishna Murthy's biological thriller Nattalostunnayi Jagratta features a man-eating tree in Madagascar.
• "The Flowering of the Strange Orchid" (1894) by H. G. Wells (originally published in Pall Mall Budget, August 2 and 9, 1894), about an orchid capable of sedating and draining the blood of a human.^[16]
• "The Purple Terror" (1899) by Fred M. White features parasitic vines with purple blossoms known as the "Devil's Poppy" that seize and poison animals.^[17]
• "Spanish Revenge" (1906) features a "Yateveo" in Mexico, resembling a large cactus with many long thorny arms, which attacks a Texan traveler.^[18]
• Two stories of comic strip Dick Tracy (Mr Crime and Lt Teevo) feature man-eating plants
• The film Maneater of Hydra (1967) features a mad scientist (Cameron Mitchell) who develops hybrid carnivorous and vampiric plants.
• In Get Smarts "Whats it all about Algie?" (1970) KAOS agent Algernon De Grasse (John Van Dreelen) tries to kill Maxwell Smart with a man-eating tree
• In Conan the Buccaneer (1971), a black Amazon tribe uses a grove of man-eating trees called "Kulamtu" as a particularly cruel method of execution.^[19]
• Enemy Mine, a 1985 film, depicting two crash survivors living on a inhospitable planet, containing animal-eating plants.
• The Little Shop of Horrors, a 1960 film directed by Roger Corman, about a man-eating plant. There was also musical, another movie and an animated series loosely based on the movie, that also featured a man-eating plant.
  • Little Shop of Horrors (musical), a 1982 musical based on the 1960 film
  • Little Shop of Horrors (film), a 1986 film adaptation of the musical, directed by Frank Oz
  • Little Shop, a 1991 animated TV series spin-off from the 1986 film created by Frank Oz.
• "The Sagebrush Kid" (2008) by Annie Proulx (a short story in Fine Just the Way It Is) features a sagebrush which grows to consume animals and humans after being "raised" and fed by a childless Wyoming couple.^{[20] [21]}
• Shades of Grey: The Road to High Saffron (2012) by Jasper Fforde features a carnivorous yateveo tree. A "Peril Infoganda" video was released via YouTube to promote the novel, titled "How Not To Be Eaten By a Yateveo" ^{[22] [23]} The yateveo lore returned in the 2024 sequel, Red Side Story.
• Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, by J. K. Rowling, included a constrictor plant, known as "Devil's Snare" which entangles and crushes anything that exhibits movement within reach of its tendrils. Devil's Snare apparently does not consume its prey, as on at least one occasion the victim is discovered still whole after being killed by the plant.
• The Day of the Triffids, by John Wyndham, features as central antagonists the eponymous Triffid, a carnivorous plant capable of locomotion, that catches and eats people.
• The Hunger of Septopus (Septopus er Khide) by Satyajit Ray features a carnivorous plant with seven trunks and a mouth, that is indigenous to Nicaragua and was brought back and eventually nurtured in Kolkata.
• The Life of Pi, by Yann Martel, published 2001, includes a carnivorous tree on a floating island.
• The Ruins, story by Scott Smith, directed by Carter Smith, is a 2008 movie about a vine plant that kills and consumes humans.
• The Woman Eater (1958) is a British horror film based on the popular legend described above of a tribe that sacrifices women to a carnivorous tree, which is acquired by a mad scientist who must keep it fed while trying to find out its secrets.
• Hothouse is a 1962 science fiction novel by Brian Aldiss. It describes a far future Earth dominated by plant life, with many plant species omnivorous.
• In the episode "Tree People" (season 6, episode 9) of the TV series Grimm, a Kinoshimobe, or servant of a tree, appears. Kinoshimobes, who have a symbiotic relationship with Jubokko trees, are humanoid elementals made of plant materials with chlorophyll for blood. They ensnare their victims with vines before using one of their vines to stab them to death. They can make vines shoot out from their hands as well as from their feet. They are slow-moving, but strong creatures, able to lift a fully grown man.

See also

• • • Jubokko – Yōkai tree in Japanese folklore said to live on human blood
    • Puya chilensis – Bromeliad rumored to be capable of killing birds and sheep

Further reading

• Book: Michell . John . Rickard . Bob . The Rough Guide to Unexplained Phenomena . 2nd . . 2007 . 978-1-84353-708-3. registration . 319–321 .
• Miller. T. S.. Lives of the Monster Plants: The Revenge of the Vegetable in the Age of Animal Studies. Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts. 23. 3. 2012. 460–479.

Notes and References

1. Spencer . Edmund . Somers . Frederick Maxwell . [{{GBurl|id=T_ZYAAAAYAAJ|p=109}} Wonderful Stories: The Man-eating Tree ]. August 1888 . Current Literature . 1 . 2 . 109,154–155.
2. News: New York World. 2013-07-01. Crinoida Dajeeana, The Man-eating Tree of Madagascar. Spencer, Edmund. April 26–28, 1874 .
3. News: San Francisco Chronicle. 2007-10-26. The Dirt: Myths about man-eating plants - something to chew on. Ron Sullivan and Joe Eaton. October 27, 2007.
4. News: South Australian Register. 2013-07-01. Man-eating Tree of Madagascar. Spencer, Edmund. October 27, 1874.
5. News: Answering a Question About a Tale of Human Sacrifice to a Tree. Pollak. Michael. 2014-08-15. The New York Times. 0362-4331. 2016-09-16.
6. Web site: Tyson . Peter . A Forest Full of Frights, part 2 . The Wilds of Madagascar . Nova Online .
7. Book: Osborn, Chase Salmon . Madagascar: Land of the Man-eating Tree . 1924 . Republic Publishing Company . New York, N.Y. . 3-9.
8. Book: Ley, Willy. [{{GBurl|id=XukeAAAAMAAJ}} Salamanders and Other Wonders: Still More Adventures of a Romantic Naturalist]. 1955. Viking Press. 178–182.
9. Book: [{{GBurl|id=hI4TAAAAYAAJ}} Literature and the Sea: Proceedings of a Conference Held at the Marine Science Center, Newport, Oregon, May 8, 1976]. Oregon State University, Sea Grant College Program. 1976. Richard Astro.
10. Book: Buel, James William . 1887 . Sea and Land: An Illustrated History of the Wonderful and Curious Things of Nature existing before and since the Deluge . Historical Publishing Company . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 475–477.
11. October 1891 . [{{GBurl|id=4Ch3NPZiYvkC}} The Vampire Vine ]. Review of Reviews . IV . 22 . 391 . Stead, William . London: Mobray House . 30 September 2013.
12. March 1892 . [{{GBurl|id=UkbnAAAAMAAJ|q=vampire+vine+lucifer|p=93}} A Cannibal Plant ]. The Western Druggist . XIV . 3 . 93 . Chicago: G. P. Englehard & Co. . 30 September 2013.
13. Besant . Annie . 15 September 1891 . [{{GBurl|id=4C7YAAAAMAAJ|p=20}} A Curious Story ]. . London, England . 9 . 49 . 20.
14. News: Special Telegram . A Blood-Sucking Plant . 9 December 1889 . The Times . Philadelphia, PA . 5196 . 2 . Newspapers.com.
15. Book: Robinson, Phil . Philip Stewart Robinson . Under the Punkah . 3 . 1881 . Sampson Low, Marston, Searle, & Rivington. London, England. 1–13 . The Man-eating Tree.
16. Book: Wells, H. G. . The Stolen Bacillus and Other Incidents . 1904 . 1895 . MacMillan and Co. . New York, N.Y. . 17-35 . Internet Archive.
17. White . Fred M. . The Purple Terror . September 1899 . . 18 . 105 . 243–251 . Internet Archive.
18. News: Staff writer . Spanish Revenge . 1 September 1906 . Kansas City Gazette . Gazette Printing and Publishing . Kansas City, Kansas . 48 . 8 . 7.
19. Book: Sprague de Camp. Lyon. Lyon Sprague de Camp. Carter. Lin. Conan the Buccaneer. 16 The Devouring Tree. New York. Lancer Books. 1971.
20. Web site: Fine Just the Way It Is: Annie Proulx (review). Maunder. Patricia. 21 January 2009. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 18 March 2010.
21. News: True Grit . Ron Carlson . Ron Carlson . 7 September 2008. New York Times. 18 March 2010.
22. Book: Fforde, Jasper . Jasper Fforde . [{{GBurl|id=aSlaRRPEyqkC|q=shades+of+grey}} Shades of Grey: The Road to High Saffron ]. 2009 . Hodder & Stoughton . London, England. 978-1-84894-584-5.
23. Fforde, Jasper (Publisher) . Shades of Grey - Infoganda 3 - Yateveo. Feb 8, 2010 . YouTube video . Fforde, Jasper.