Male prostitution in the arts explained

The male prostitute or hustler is a frequent stereotype in literature and movies in the West from the 1960s on, and especially in movies and books with a gay perspective in which he may be considered a stock character. He also appears occasionally in popular music, some contemporary fashion advertising, and the visual arts.

Stereotypes

The most common stereotype of the hustler is as a sexy but tragic figure. This stereotype reveals both a fascination with the hustler as a sexual object and sadness or disdain with his situation and life-style. This stereotyped male hustler is often an underaged or teenage "street kid" or "runaway" forced to leave home because of his sexual orientation or because of sexual abuse. He is often portrayed as a drug addict or thief.

The plotline frequently focuses on the crisis of leaving the trade or the street ("one last trick"), or on making enough money for an important use (a medical treatment, a gift). The climax often has one of two possible outcomes: the hustler either abandons the trade and re-integrates into society, or he meets a tragic end. This tragic image of the hustler can be contrasted with the stereotype of the female hooker with a heart of gold: instead of being portrayed as someone in control and contented, the hustler is lost, homeless, broke or exploited.

In movies and books that take the point of view of the client or of a boy/girlfriend who loves the hustler, the hustler is often depicted as an impossible love object who will only bring hurt or frustration. The lover may grow jealous of and disturbed by the hustler's work; occasionally the loving boy/girlfriend will be drawn into the lifestyle of their hustler boyfriend. Older clients who fall in love with hustlers are frequently prey to emotional (and sometimes physical) pain; this is especially true in the case of "rough trade" (where the hustler identifies as straight), and this depiction has been reinforced by several famous incidents of violence against clients (such as the deaths of Pier Paolo Pasolini and Rudolph Moshammer).

In contrast to the previous depictions, the male prostitute has also sometimes been portrayed as an idealized rebel living outside the law and free of bourgeois conventions. This almost Nietzschean image of the hustler as moral and sexual outlaw owes much to the writings of Jean Genet, William S. Burroughs and John Rechy (among others).

While less frequent in cinema and novels, the male prostitute with exclusively female clients (the "gigolo" or "escort") is generally depicted in a less tragic manner than the gay hustler (the gigolo is portrayed as older, athletic, well-dressed, etc.), and films like American Gigolo have done much to paint the character as a sophisticated seducer. This portrayal has also led to cinematic satire (the Deuce Bigalow films).

The portrayal of the client or "john" of male prostitution in popular culture is far less codified than that of the hustler and runs the gamut from the lonely married man, the self-hating in-the-closet guy, the exploitative or endearing businessman, and even the serial killer.

The diversity of these stereotypes reveals much about each author's or director's personal view of love, sexuality, power and morality.

These stereotypes may have a basis in fact, but they should not be taken as true in all cases.

The same issues that surround male prostitution (including the financial security and social status of the young "kept" lover, the older lover's obsessions and insecurities with regards to his or her youthful love-object, the sexual freedom or moral indifference of the hustler, etc.) often appear in movies and literature that portray amorous or sexual relationships—without prostitution—between an older man or woman and a younger male lover; for example, in Pasolini's novel and movie Theorem, Harold Prince's film Something For Everyone (1970) and Bill Condon's film Gods and Monsters (1998).

In literature

The following novels, memoirs, and plays feature male hustlers as major characters.

Year Title Author Notes
1894 Flowers of Asphalt According to Crane biographer John Berryman Crane began writing Flowers of Asphalt after being approached by a young male prostitute in the street.[1] The work was said to be longer than any of Crane's other works but he abandoned it at the urging of Hamlin Garland, who was horrified by the subject matter. The manuscript does not survive.[2]
1908 Swoosh: Tales of Privateers and Pirates D Watt The phrase "Cap'n's Rent Boy" first used.
1924 Kyra Kyralina
(Chira Chiralina)
1943 Our Lady of the Flowers
(Notre Dame des fleurs)
1948 The City and the Pillar Lead character Jim Willard supports himself as a hustler and a "kept boy".
1949 The Thief's Journal
(Journal du voleur)
Jean Genet
1951 From Here to Eternity In Jones's original manuscript, Private Angelo Maggio acknowledges acting as trade, allowing gay men to perform oral sex on him for money to supplement his Army pay. The publisher forced the excision of these passages. A new edition of the book with the previously censored passages restored is due out from e-book publisher Open Road.[3]
1957 Last Exit to Brooklyn
1963 The Basketball Diaries
1963 City of Night
1965 Midnight Cowboy
1967 Numbers
1968 My Father and Myself
1978 Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof Zoo Christiane's boyfriend Detlef works as a hustler to earn money to buy heroin.
1989 Enchanted Boy Richie McMullen Memoir of a boy's journey from "abuse to prostitution" in 1950s England.
1990 Enchanted Youth Richie McMullen Continuation of McMullen's journey from "prostitution to love" in 1958.
1990 Closer
1991 Close to the Knives First of Wojnarowicz's memoirs of his passage from abused kid to Times Square hustler to artist in New York's East Village underground.
1992 Memories That Smell Like Gasoline Second volume of Wojnarowicz's memoirs.
1994 American Studies Mark Merlis Story of a john coming to terms with his life while recovering in a hospital after being bashed by a hustler.
1994 User
1994 Martin and John One or both of the characters are hustlers in several of the parallel narrative scenes.
1994 Los novios búlgaros Story of a Bulgarian hustler in Madrid in the 1990s.
Mysterious Skin
1995 L'Enfant ébloui "Rachid O" Semi-autobiographic novel about a hustler in Morocco.
1996 Wonder Bread and Ecstasy:
The Life and Death of Joey Stefano
Joey Stefano was a gay porn star of the 1990s.
1996 Seven Miles A Second David Wojnarowicz (writer)
James Romberger (artist)
Vertigo Comics version of Wojnarowicz's memoirs and diary.
1996 Boy Culture Matthew Rettenmund Includes an index to the sex passages (by preference).
1996 Brutal First novel by artist Aiden Shaw, a former prostitute and porn star.
1996 Kept Boy Comedy novel.
1997 Quand je suis devenu fou Christophe Donner Narrator falls for a hustler in an Amsterdam brothel.
1997 Diary of a Hustler "Joey"
1997 After Nirvana Lee Williams
1998 Tipping the Velvet A young woman in Victorian London is solicited by a man for sex and begins renting, but dressed only as a man for male clients, never letting them know she is a woman.
1998 The Queen of Hearts: A Transsexual Romance Brad Clayton
1999 Assuming the Position: A Memoir of Hustling Rick Whitaker
1999 Suburban Hustler: Stories of a Hi-Tech Callboy Aaron Lawrence
2000 Sarah Pseudo-autobiographical story of a boy hustler whose mother was a truckstop prostitute. The author was revealed to be a fictional creation in 2006.
2001 A Thousand and One Night Stands: The Life of Jon Vincent H. A. Carson
2001 Can't Buy Me Love Chris Kenry Young man drifts into the world of escorting with humorous results.
2002 Sex Workers As Virtual Boyfriends Joseph Itiel
2002 Chicken: Self-Portrait of a Young Man for Rent
2003 Escapades of a Gay Traveler: Sexual, Cultural, and Spiritual Encounters Joseph Itiel
2004
2005 Setting the Lawn on Fire: A Novel Mack Friedman
2006 Red Carpets and Other Banana Skins Touches briefly on his past as a rent boy.
2008 Shuck Fictionalized memoir of a New York City hustler who dreams of becoming a writer.
2008 Murder Most Fab Main character Johnny started life out as a high-class gigolo.
2016 What Belongs to You Details the ethically ambiguous relations and transactions between Greenwell's unnamed protagonist and a young Bulgarian hustler, Mitko.

In theater

Year Title Author Character Originated by Notes
1940 Pal Joey
1964 Entertaining Mr Sloane Mr Sloane
1965 Balm in Gilead Franny
Rake
Franny is a transvestite prostitute.
1968 The Boys in the Band "Cowboy" La Tourneaux reprised the role in the 1970 film version.
2005 Trafficking in Broken Hearts Edwin Sanchez

In cinema

Films with a hustler as a main character

Year Title Country Director Character Actor Notes
1961 The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone Paolo di Leo Karen Stone is introduced to a young Italian man, Paolo (Warren Beatty), who is actually a highly paid professional gigolo. Karen and Paolo begin an affair, but it soon becomes obvious that Paolo is in it only for personal gain.
1961 Breakfast at Tiffany's Paul "Fred" Varjak Varjak is maintained by a rich woman, Mrs. Failenson, who leaves him $300 after every sexual encounter. After falling in love with Holly Golightly (Audrey Hepburn), Varjak cuts off the relationship. Failenson offers $1000 for a "paid vacation with your girl" and cynically suggests that a union (of gigolos) could "get all the fringe benefits" – but Varjak persists in giving up this way of life.
1965 My Hustler Andy Warhol
Chuck Wein
Paul IMDb
1968 Flesh Joe Dallesandro hustles to buy drugs for himself and his wife.
1969 Entertaining Mr Sloane Mr Sloane Adapted from the play by Joe Orton.
1969 Midnight Cowboy Joe Buck Hustler Buck forms an unlikely friendship with junky Rico "Ratso" Rizzo. Academy Award winner for Best Picture.
1970 The Boys in the Band "Cowboy" Featured in rejected ads for the film under the tagline: "Today is Harold's birthday. This is his present."
1978 Schöner Gigolo, armer Gigolo (Just a Gigolo) Paul Ambrosius von Przygodski An aristocratic Prussian officer returns from World War I to find the world he once knew gone. To make ends meet, he becomes a gigolo. The film was panned by critics and viewers alike. IMDb
1978 El Lugar Sin Limites Manuela Roberto CoboIMDb
1978 El Diputado
(The Deputy)
Eloy de la Iglesia Teenage hustler used by the secret police for blackmail falls for the victim. IMDb
1980 American Gigolo Julian Kaye High-class gigolo is framed for murder.
1982 Forty Deuce Conniving hustler Bacon (who won an Obie for the original 1981 off-off Broadway production) tries to cover-up the overdose death of another kid. IMDb
1983 L'homme blessé
(The Wounded Man)
Henri Winner of a César Award for Best Direction. IMDb
1983 Un ragazzo come tanti
(A boy like many others)
Gianni Minello IMDb
1987 Revolutions Happen Like Refrains in a Song Nick Deocampo IMDb
1987 Less than Zero Julian A young man resorts to performing sexual favors for affluent gay men in order to fund his heroin addiction.
1988 The Everlasting Secret Family Michael Thornhill Homosexuality and prostitution amidst a secret brotherhood. IMDb
1988 Macho Dancer Pol
Noel
Macho dancers in Manila.
1988 Cop James B. Harris Based on the novel by James Ellroy. IMDb
1989 Loverboy Randy Bodek Pizza boy becomes an escort. IMDb
1990 Via Appia Jochen Hick IMDb
1991 My Own Private Idaho Mike Waters
Scott Favor
1991 J'embrasse pas
(I don't kiss)
Manuel Blanc A boy from the provinces ends up as a hustler in Paris.
1991 Where the Day Takes You Balthazar Getty A young man living on the streets finds temporary refuge with a client.
1992 Film (Fill 'em) Sky Gilbert Story of a male hustler and his roommate. IMDb
1992 Street Kid (Gossenkind) Peter Kern Axel Glitter Max Kellermann A young hustler in Düsseldorf. IMDb
1992 Being at Home with Claude Jean Beaudin Him (Yves)Roy Dupuis IMDb
1992 The Living End Luke Mike Dytri HIV+ street hustler.
1992 Die Blaue Stunde
(The Blue Hour)
Germany
Switzerland
Marcel Gisler Theo Andreas Herder IMDb
1993 Smukke dreng
(Pretty Boy)
Carsten Sønder IMDb
1993 Hatachi no binetsu
(Slight Fever of a 20-Year-Old)
Japan Ryosuke Hasiguchi One teenage hustler in love with another.
1994 Post Cards from America Steve McLean Three chapters in David Wojnarowicz's life. IMDb
1994 Super 8½ Semi-autobiographical.
1994 Sibak (Midnight Dancers) Mel Chionglo Three brothers in Manila, working as "Macho Dancers" in a gay bar. IMDb
1995 The Basketball Diaries Scott Kalvert Based on the book by Jim Carroll.
1995 Dupe Od Mramora (Marble Ass) Zelimir Zilnik Transvestite prostitutes in Serbia. IMDb
1995 Tattoo Boy Arizona
Sam
Amanda Tirey
C.J. Barkus
IMDb
1996 The Toilers and the Wayfarers Keith FroelichMatt Klemp
Andrew Woodhouse
Runaway hustlers in Minneapolis. IMDb
1996 Hustler White Monti
1996 The Unveiling Rodney Evans IMDb
1996 "Tapin du soir", included in L'Amour est à réinventer One of ten collected short films about life in France in the time of AIDS.
1996 Skin & Bone Everett Lewis Harry
Billy
Dean
B. Wyatt
Garret Scullin
Alan Boyce
Three Los Angeles hustlers in different stages of their careers.
1996 johns Scott Silvers Donner
John
1997 Private Shows Blaine Hopkins
Stephen Winter
IMDb
1997 Mandragora Marek Miroslav CaslavkaIMDb
1997 A River Made to Drown In James Meredino
1997 Star Maps Carlos Amado IMDb
1998 From the Edge of the City
(Apo tin akri tis polis)
IMDb
1998 Hard John Huckert IMDb
1998 In the Flesh US Ben Taylor Oliver Beck Dane Ritter
1998 L'École de la Chair Quentin Vincent Martinez IMDb
1999 Speedway Junky Nickolas Perry Johnny A young man with dreams of becoming a stock car racer drifts into the world of prostitution in Las Vegas.
1999 Mauvaise passe Pierre Pierre (Daniel Auteuil) leaves his family and flees to London to work on a novel. There he meets Tom (Stuart Townsend), a male escort, who leads Pierre into his underground world of sex and money.
2000 Km. 0 Spain Miguel Jesús Cabrero A gigolo who services female clients.
2000 Nincsen nekem vágyam semmi
(This I Wish and Nothing More)
Brúnó
Ringó
Ervin Nagy
Roland Rába
Closted bisexual Brúnó unknown by his girlfriend works as a male prostitute for male clients with her homosexual brother, Ringó.
2000 L.I.E. US Gary Paul Dano
Billy Kay
A Long Island teenager discovers his best friend (Kay) is a hustler.
2001 Circuit Hector A hustler who's terrified of growing old.
2001 Jet Boy Dave SchultzBranden Nadon A teenage hustler finds a father figure who does not want to exploit him.
2001 Vagón fumador (Smokers Only) Argentina Leonardo BrzezickiAndrés A suicidal woman and a male prostitute fall in love. IMDb
2002 AKA Benjamin
2002 Sonny Sonny Raised by his mother to be a gigolo. IMDb
2003 Mr. Smith Gets a Hustler Ian McCrudden IMDb
2003 The Roman Spring of Mrs. Stone Robert Allan Ackerman Paolo di Leo It was a TV film and remake of the 1961 film of the same name.
2003 200 American Richard LeMay New York businessman falls for Australian hustler. IMDb
2003 Un fils (A son) North-African hustler in France. IMDb
2003 Gan (Garden) Israel Ruthie Shatz
Adi Barash
Two young gay prostitutes in Tel Aviv. IMDb
2003 Twist Dodge Gay-themed re-telling of Dickens' Oliver Twist.
2003 Bulgarian Lovers (Los Novios búlgaros) Spain Kyril Dritan Biba IMDb
2004 Yeladim Tovim (Good Boy) Israel Yair Hochner Menni
Tal
Daniel Efrat
Yuval Raz
Two Tel Aviv rent boys. IMDb
2004 Eighteen Richard Bell IMDb
2004 Trenton "Trent" Meyer Hip-hop promoter becomes an escort after getting into debt with a gangster.
2004 Ethan Mao Ethan Mao, Remigio Jun Hee Lee, Jerry Hernandez An Asian gay teen is kicked out of his house and forced to become a hustler for money. Soon, he meets Remigio, a teen hustler and drug dealer, and the two become friends.
2004 Sugar John Palmer Butch Coming of age story.
2004 Mysterious Skin Neil McCormick Based on Scott Heim's book.
2004 My Hustler Boyfriend Peter Pizzi Short included in video program at Newfest 2005. IMDb
2005 Dirty Little Sins
2005 Boy Wonder Kery Isabel Ramierez Luis Color video short (12 min) about a man living a double life as "straight male" provider and transvestite prostitute. Included in MIX NYC November 2006.
2005 The Wedding Date Claire Kilner Nick Mercer Woman hires male escort to pose as her boyfriend.
2005 Transamerica Duncan Tucker Toby Wilkins Pre-operative M2F transsexual discovers she has a son (Zegers) who is hustling in New York.
2005 Breakfast on Pluto Based on the novel by Patrick McCabe. Transvestite flees Ireland for London during the 1970s and becomes a prostitute.
2006 Boy Culture Based on the novel.
2006 Can't Buy Me Love Short film from Newfest 2006. IMDb
2006 In The Blood Lou Peterson Gay supernatural thriller featuring a young man dating a Latino hustler. IMDb
2006 Boys Briefs 4 Six short films about guys who hustle: Boy (Welby Ings); Gigolo (Bastian Schweitzer); Build (Greg Atkins); Into the Night (Tony Krawitz); Gold (Armen Kazazian); Rock Bottom (Mary Feuer). review
2006 Happy Hookers Ashish Sawhny The lives of three male sex workers in India. Short film from Newfest 2007.
2006 Into It Jeff Maccubbin Two hustlers dealing with drugs and relationships. Film from Newfest 2007.
2007 Before I Forget Jacques Nolot An aging hustler reflects on his life. IMDb
2008 Strictly Sexual Joel Viertel Two women hire two unemployed construction workers as sex slaves.
2008 Cliente (A French Gigolo; The Client) Patrick/Marco A female television anchor falls in love with an internet escort. IMDb
2009 Lucky Bastard Denny Dale DymkoskiDenny is a hustler and meth addict who exploits a man who's fallen in love with him. Lucky Bastard was an Official Selection at Outfest 2009.[4]
2009 Complices (Accomplices) Frédéric MermoudVincent Bouvier Two detectives try to solve Victor's murder. Victor appears only in flashbacks.
2010 Strapped Joseph Graham (director)Hustler Ben BonenfantA nameless hustler encounters a series of gay men as he searches for the exit to a client's apartment building.[5]
2013 Aleksandr's Price Aleksandr Ivanov A boy named Aleksandr becomes a prostitute in NY, after the death of his mother. IMDb
2016 Romantic Noy (Not Romantic) Rajib Chowdhury Shekhar Shaheb Bhattacharya A boy named Shekhar becomes a prostitute in Kolkata and he entertains women with his body. At a stage he becomes addicted in drugs.
2022Good Luck to You, Leo GrandeUnited StatesSophie HydeLeo GrandeDaryl McCormackRetired widow Nancy Stokes (Emma Thompson) hires a good-looking young sex worker called Leo Grande, in the hope of enjoying a night of pleasure and self-discovery after an unfulfilling married life.

Other films that include hustlers

Documentary films

Year Title Country Director Notes
1967 Portrait of Jason US Interview with African-American gay hustler Jason Holliday.
1984 Streetwise US Seattle street boys struggle to get along without having to sell themselves for sex.
1992 Maybe I Can Give You Sex? Part I Philippines
Germany
Rune Layumas
Jurgen Bruning
Examine gender roles in the Philippines and the lives of macho dancers, bar boys, and their customers.
1992 Maybe I Can Give You Sex? Part II Philippines
Germany
Rune Layumas
1992 A Kind of Family Canada Andrew Koster Profile of the relationship of a gay city councilman and his straight, street-kid, hustler, drug-abusing, HIV+ foster son.
1993 Boys From Brazil Brazil Brazilian transvestite prostitutes.
1994 Not Angels But Angels Czechoslovakia About prostitution in Prague.
1996 Body Without Soul Czechoslovakia Teenage guys who prostitute in Prague.
2000 101 Rent Boys US Interviews with hustlers who work Santa Monica Boulevard.
2006 Hooks to the Left US Shot on a cell-phone camera, narrated journal of a New York hustler named Nail.
Short film (75 min) from Newfest 2007.
2009 Men for Sale Canada Film about male prostitutes in Montreal, Quebec.[6]

On television

The following television programs feature a hustler as a main character:

Year Title Network Character Actor Notes
1977 Alexander Sequel to .
1986 The Children of Times Square Eric Roberts A teenage boy runs away to New York City and is immediately recruited by other boys for a man who wants him for sex. He escapes only to end up working for a drug dealer.
1993 Dafydd BBC Welsh boy/hustler goes to Amsterdam and meets a music teacher.
1997 Band of Gold Cherrie/Carl Daniel Edwards Turned to hustling to pay for his sex reassignment surgery. He was working as a cross dresser during his stint in the series.
2000–2005 Queer as Folk Pushed into hustling by his mother; adopted by Michael Novotny and Ben Bruchner.
2001–2008 Trailer Park Boys The character on the hit Canadian mockumentary television show is an ex-prostitute.
2005–2006 Desperate Housewives Survived on the streets as a hustler after being thrown out of his house by his mother Bree.
2006–2009 Dante's Cove Kevin Confessed to his boyfriend that he sometimes used to accept money for sex.
2009– Hung Ray Drecker An unhappy and financially strapped history teacher and basketball coach, who decides to turn his large penis into an opportunity to make money.
2011— Gigolos Reality television series following the lives of five male escorts who service female clients in Las Vegas.[7]
2005—2012 The Closer Rusty Beck The character first appeared in 2012. He survived on the streets as a hustler after his mother disappeared. Rusty later became a main character on the spin-off series Major Crimes.
2011—2019 Game of Thrones Olyvar Male prostitute employed by Littlefinger, used to spy on noblemen to gain favour with richer nobility / royalty.
2009—2015Glee Brody Weston Love interest of Rachel Barry (Lea Michele), whom she breaks up with upon learning he supports himself as a gigolo.
2013—2016 Masters of Sex Dale Male prostitute involved with Barton Scully (Beau Bridges), a closeted, married university official.[8]
2013—2019 Silicon Valley HBO Donald "Jared" Dunn One of the main protagonists, who used to work as a male prostitute after graduating from college.
2019—2021 Shrill Ruthie Trans woman working with Annie (Aidy Bryant), who is implied to have worked as a prostitute before her full transition, stating that there were various straight and gay men alike who "liked hitting that."
2013— Brooklyn Nine-Nine Fox (2013-2018)
NBC (2019-present)
Bill Hummertrout Winston Story Gigolo hired by Detective Jake Peralta (Andy Samberg) for several Halloween Heists as a distraction due to his resemblance to Charles Boyle (Joe Lo Truglio).

In photography

The following photographers, in their work, frequently use the image of the male prostitute:

See also

References

Notes and References

  1. Stephen Crane, by John Berryman, pub Methuen, 1950. Page not known
  2. Gay American History: Lesbians and Gay Men in the U.S.A., by Jonathan Ned Katz, pub Harper Colophon Books, New York, 1976,, 1985 edition p. 43
  3. Web site: Censored gay sex in From Here to Eternity restored for new edition. Benedicte. Page. 5 April 2011. the Guardian.
  4. News: Kay . Jeremy . La Mission, Dare bookend LA Outfest 2009 . ScreenDaily.com . 2009-06-02 . 2009-08-08.
  5. News: Joseph Graham's Dreamlike Tale of a Gay Hustler. Jeannette. Catsoulis. The New York Times . 23 September 2010.
  6. http://films.nfb.ca/men-for-sale/ NFB page on Men for Sale
  7. http://www.sho.com/site/gigolos/home.sho Gigolos on Showtime
  8. Web site: The Compelling Gay Story in "Masters Of Sex" . The Backlot . November 19, 2013 . November 19, 2013.