| Season Number: | 2 |
| Starring: | Tyson Beckford Nicole Trunfio Jenny Shimizu Perou Catherine Malandrino Marlon Stoltzman |
| Num Episodes: | 13 |
| Network: | Bravo |
Make Me a Supermodel season 2, premiered on March 4, 2009, is the second season of Make Me a Supermodel. It was broadcast on Bravo.
The new season started with higher than expected ratings after a much publicized campaign on blog sites, bus stops, and shopping malls. A casting special aired prior to the second season opener, featuring many models being photographed, critiqued on the runway, and sent away until only the final choices for the season remained. The casting special premiered in February 2009.
Major changes were made the second season, including viewer voting taken out, with the judges deciding who's eliminated and the winner of the entire show. The number of contestants was also increased from 14 to 16 and reduced the final 4 to only 3 finalists in the finale episode. The judging panel was also completely revamped. Former model Jenny Shimizu, along with fashion photographer Perou, one of the judges in the original British version, French fashion designer Catherine Malandrino and international model scout Marlon Stoltzman all joined as judges. Beckford was no longer a judge, and instead became the sole host of the show and the mentor of the male competitors. Australian model Nicole Trunfio replaced Niki Taylor and became the mentor of the female competitors. Lastly, every week, the featured photographer would choose a model they felt worked the photo shoot the best, and that winning model and their pick would get to go on a casting.
The winner of the competition, chosen by the viewers, would receive: a fashion pictorial in Cosmopolitan magazine, a cash prize of $100,000 from Maybelline New York, and a one-year contract with New York Model Management.
The winner of the competition was 18-year-old Branden Rickman from Central Point, Oregon, making him the youngest and first male model to win the show.
(ages stated are at time of contest)
| Contestant | Age | Hometown | Outcome | Place | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ken Thompson | 24 | Winterville, North Carolina | Episode 1 | 16 | |
| Chris Cohen | 22 | Libertyville, Illinois | Episode 2 | 15 | |
| Karen Kelly | 22 | Ocean Springs, Mississippi | Episode 3 | 14 | |
| Shawn Nishikawa | 30 | Seattle, Washington | Episode 4 | 13 | |
| CJ Kirkham | 18 | San Ramon, California | Episode 5 | 12 | |
| Gabriel Zadok Everett | 22 | Charlotte, North Carolina | Episode 6 | 11 | |
| Laury Prudent | 23 | Episode 7 | 9-10 | ||
| Kerryn Johns | 24 | Russellville, Arkansas | |||
| Colin Steers | 21 | Charlottesville, Virginia | Episode 8 | 8 | |
| Amanda Crop | 21 | Banks, Oregon | Episode 9 | 7 | |
| Jordan Condra | 21 | Tucson, Arizona | Episode 10 | 6 | |
| Salome Steinmann | 19 | Altamont, Tennessee | Episode 11 | 5 | |
| Mountaha Ayoub | 23 | Londrina, Brazil | Episode 12 | 4 | |
| Jonathan Waud | 26 | Southampton, United Kingdom | Episode 13 | 3 | |
| Sandhurst Tacama Miggins | 22 | Tobago, Trinidad and Tobago | 2 | ||
| Branden Rickman | 18 | Central Point, Oregon | 1 | ||
| Model | Episodes | Episode Title | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | |||
| 1 | Branden | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | HIGH | SAFE | LOW | SAFE | LOW | LOW | HIGH | HIGH | LOW | WINNER | 13 - Finale |
| 2 | Sandhurst | HIGH | SAFE | HIGH | HIGH | LOW | WIN | HIGH | HIGH | WIN | HIGH | LOW | WIN | OUT | |
| 3 | Jonathan | SAFE | HIGH | HIGH | WIN | HIGH | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | HIGH | LOW | WIN | HIGH | OUT | |
| 4 | Mountaha | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | LOW | HIGH | SAFE | HIGH | HIGH | WIN | HIGH | OUT | ||
| 5 | Salome | HIGH | SAFE | LOW | SAFE | SAFE | HIGH | WIN | SAFE | LOW | LOW | OUT | |||
| 6 | Jordan | WIN | HIGH | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | HIGH | HIGH | SAFE | LOW | OUT | ||||
| 7 | Amanda | SAFE | SAFE | HIGH | LOW | SAFE | SAFE | LOW | LOW | OUT | |||||
| 8 | Colin | LOW | LOW | SAFE | LOW | SAFE | SAFE | LOW | OUT | ||||||
| 9-10 | Kerryn | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | OUT | 7 - Ready to Rumble | ||||||
| Laury | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | HIGH | SAFE | LOW | OUT | ||||||||
| 11 | Gabriel | SAFE | LOW | LOW | SAFE | LOW | OUT | ||||||||
| 12 | CJ | SAFE | LOW | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | |||||||||
| 13 | Shawn | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | ||||||||||
| 14 | Karen | SAFE | SAFE | OUT | |||||||||||
| 15 | Chris | LOW | OUT | ||||||||||||
| 16 | Ken | OUT | |||||||||||||
Cornflower Blue background and WIN means that the model won the overall week challenge, with the photo shoot and runway combined.
Light Blue background and HIGH means the model had one of the highest scores for that challenge.
Orange background and LOW means the model was in the bottom three and was given another chance by the judges to stay in the competition.
Dark Orange background and LOW means the model was in the bottom two and was given another chance by the judges to stay in the competition.
Pink background and LOW means the model had one of the lowest scores for that challenge, but was not in the bottom.
Tomato background and OUT means the model was in the bottom three, but was not given another chance by the judges, and was sent home.
Yellow Green background and OUT means the model was a runner-up for the competition.
Lime Green background and WINNER means this model won the entire competition, and was chosen by the judges to become a Supermodel.
| Episode | Episode Title | Original Air Date | Summary | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Casting | "Meet the Models" | February 7, 2009 | The Season 2 cast of models is spotlighted. | |
| 1 | "Let the Games Begin" | March 4, 2009 | Sixteen aspiring models arrive in New York City to compete for $100,000, a modeling contract and a fashion pictorial in Cosmopolitan magazine. | |
| 2 | "Eye Candy" | March 11, 2009 | The models must use candy as their inspiration for their next photo shoot. | |
| 3 | "High Wire Act" | March 18, 2009 | The models head back to high school to test their wire work as they capture an authentic sports moment. | |
| 4 | "Mirror, Mirror on the Wall" | March 25, 2009 | The models learn their prize for winning the photo shoot is a trip to Montreal and the opportunity to walk in Montreal Fashion Week. | |
| 5 | "Menage a Models" | April 1, 2009 | The remaining models compete in a military-themed challenge; photographer Kelly Klein serves as a guest judge. | |
| 6 | "Take a Deep Breath" | April 8, 2009 | The models compete in an underwater photo shoot with photographer Howard Schatz; guest judge Alexandre Herchcovitch. | |
| 7 | "Ready to Rumble" | April 22, 2009 | The models flash back to the 1960s with photographer Roxanne Lowit; stylist Rebecca Weinberg serves as a guest judge. | |
| 8 | "The Simple Life" | April 29, 2009 | The models head to the country for a photo shoot with photographer Aliya Naumoff; supermodel Maggie Rizer returns as a guest judge. | |
| 9 | "Naked Ambition" | May 6, 2009 | The seven remaining models carefully choose their accessories for a revealing photo shoot with Bill Diodato. | |
| 10 | "Rocking and Rolling" | May 13, 2009 | The models display music producer Dallas Austin's fashion line and take part in a photo shoot with Patrik Andersson. | |
| 11 | "Beach Blondes" | May 20, 2009 | The models have an outdoor winter photo shoot in New York City; the models wear fashions from the design team The Blonds. | |
| 12 | "Blowin' Up" | May 27, 2009 | The final four models participate in an explosive session with photographer Clay Patrick McBride, then hit the catwalk in tuxedos and evening gowns by designer Catherine Malandrino. | |
| 13 | "Finale" | June 3, 2009 | The final three models take part in two major photo shoots and a catwalk challenge; family members accompany the models to a SoHo art gallery; the judges make a decision. |
The models work in pairs regardless of gender, modeling sleepwear outside, in a suspended Plexiglas box.
Featured photographer - Perou
Winner - Salome
Winner's pick - CJ
The models act out as various types of candy. Contestants were assigned to represent either pixie sticks, lollipops, chocolate, gumballs, candy canes, rock candy, or sprinkles.
Featured photographer - Suza Scalora
Winner - Jordan
Winner's pick - Mountaha
The models are suspended by wires and have to pull off sports action shots, in groups.
Featured photographer - Justin Steele
Winner - Amanda
Winner's pick - Kerryn
The photo shoot is all about reflections; the models have to pose with mirrors and evoke different emotions.
Featured photographer - Indira Cesarine
Winners - Amanda & Branden
Winner's pick - Mountaha & Colin
The photo shoot was all about capturing a sexual fantasy. The models were portraying military personnel sneaking off to engage in illicit erotic encounters. The models posed in groups of three.
Featured photographer - Joshua Kogan
Winner - Jonathan
Winner's pick - Gabriel
The models were challenged to pose underwater, entangled in nets.
Featured photographer - Howard Schatz
Winner - Jordan
Winner's pick - Salome
The models were paired in a 60s themed, mod photo shoot, where they had to emulate the essence of night life and having a good time.
Featured photographer - Roxanne Lowit
Winner - Salome
Winner's pick - Mountaha
The models were sent to a ranch, where they had to pose with farm animals.
Featured photographer - Aliya Naumoff
Winner - Sandhurst
Winner's pick - Branden
The models posed nude, working with one chosen accessory.
Featured photographer - Bill Diodato
Winner - Salome
Winner's pick - Jordan
The models were pictured wearing Rowdy clothing, and had to embody the punk, grunge and urban aspects of the brand.
Featured photographer - Patrik Andersson
Winner - Salome
Winner's pick - Mountaha
The models had to capture a hot swimsuit shot in cold weather, while posing with various dead animals from the sea. Sports Illustrated model Jessica Gomes was brought in to individually give the models advice, prior to their shoots.
Featured photographer - Markus Klinko and Indrani, Stylist GK Reid
Winner - Salome
Winner's pick - Mountaha
The models had one chance to capture a shot embodying the "rocker" look, while flames exploded around them in a warehouse at night.
Featured photographer - Clay Patrick McBride
Winner - Sandhurst
Winner's pick - None: All models worked as informal models for Bloomingdale's. As a group prize, each model was rewarded a $2000 shopping spree, while Sandhurst won an additional $2000 for his spree.
Featured photographer - Timothy Greenfield-Sanders
Winner - None.