Maharlika Wealth Fund Explained

Maharlika Investment Corporation
Type:State-owned
Foundation:July 18, 2023
Founder:19th Congress under the administration of President Bongbong Marcos
Key People:Ralph Recto (Chairperson)
Rafael Consing, Jr. (President and CEO)
Industry:Finance
Services:Sovereign wealth fund management
Owner:Government of the Philippines

The Maharlika Wealth Fund (MWF), also known as the Maharlika Investment Fund (MIF), is a sovereign wealth fund for the Philippines which is managed by the Maharlika Investment Corporation (MIC).[1] The MIF is the Philippines' first sovereign wealth fund. It will be allocated across a variety of assets, including foreign currencies, fixed-income instruments, domestic and foreign corporate bonds, commercial real estate, and infrastructure projects.The MIF is expected to generate returns that support the government's economic goals, as outlined in the Medium-Term Fiscal Framework, the eight-point Socioeconomic Agenda, and the Philippine Development Plan.

Background

Implementing law

Legislative process

Short Title:Maharlika Investment Fund Act of 2023
Legislature:Congress of the Philippines
Long Title:An Act Establishing the Maharlika Investment Fund, Providing for the Management, Investment, and Use of the Proceeds of The Fund, and Appropriating Funds Therefore
Citation:Republic Act No. 11954
Territorial Extent:Philippines
Signed By:Bongbong Marcos
Date Signed:July 18, 2023
Enacted By:House of Representatives of the Philippines
Date Passed:December 15, 2022
Enacted By2:Senate of the Philippines
Date Passed2:May 31, 2023
Bill Citation:H. No. 6608, 19th Cong. 1st Sess.
Bill Date:December 12, 2022
1St Reading:December 12, 2022
2Nd Reading:December 15, 2022
3Rd Reading:December 15, 2022
3Rd Reading For:279
3Rd Reading Against:6
3Rd Reading Abstention:0
Bill Citation2:S. No. 2020, 19th Cong., 1st Sess.
2Nd Reading2:May 30, 2023
3Rd Reading2:May 30, 2023
3Rd Reading2 For:19
3Rd Reading2 Against:1
3Rd Reading2 Abstention:1
3Rd Reading2 Absent:3
Status:in force

In late November 2022, seven lawmakers in the Philippine House of Representatives, including Martin Romualdez and Sandro Marcos, filed House Bill No. 6398, proposing the creation of a sovereign wealth fund for the Philippines to be known as the Maharlika Wealth Fund (MWF), inspired from South Korea's sovereign wealth fund. The fund, if established, would be managed by the Maharlika Investments Corporation (MIC).[2] [3] President Bongbong Marcos has backed the establishment of a sovereign wealth fund, believing that it would be advantageous for the country.[4] [5]

After President Marcos certified the bill as urgent, it was passed on its third reading in the lower house, with 279 lawmakers voting in favor of passing the bill.[6] Only six lawmakers voted against: Gabriel Bordado (Camarines Sur3rd), Arlene Brosas (Gabriela), France Castro (ACT Teachers), Mujiv Hataman (BasilanLone), Edcel Lagman (Albay1st), and Raoul Manuel (Kabataan).[7] [8] From filing to approval, it took the House of Representatives 17 days to deliberate on the bill.[9]

On May 24, 2023, Marcos certified the creation of the Maharlika investment fund as urgent to the Senate.[10] On May 31, 2023, the upper house had approved the third and final reading with a total of 19 senators voting in favor, one negative (Risa Hontiveros) and one abstention (Nancy Binay).[11] It would need President Marcos' signature before it becomes law.[12]

A bill that is certified as urgent allows lawmakers to bypass the constitutional rule requiring bills to be passed on three readings on separate days. The president's certification of urgency is typically made to respond to public calamities or emergencies.[13] In February 2023, a petition was filed to the Supreme Court requesting to nullify Marcos's certification of urgency, arguing that it is unconstitutional because no public calamity or emergency was expressly stated in Marcos's letter to the House. This was later dismissed by the Court in May, citing that the petitioners "failed to present to Court any fact establishing the existence of an actual case or controversy ripe for adjudication".[14]

On July 5, 2023, the copy of the bill was transmitted to Malacañang for President Marcos's signature.[15] On July 18, he signed the bill into law as Republic Act No. 11954.[16]

GSIS and SSS funding

Initially, the Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) and the Social Security System (SSS) were obliged to contribute funds to the MIF under the proposed bill establishing the fund. The two institutions were later dropped as mandatory contributors.[17] However, both the boards of the GSIS and SSS would be permitted to contribute if they approve such a move.[18] [19]

Reception to the proposal

Economist Michael Batu said the fund, if managed properly, can help raise money to help the government's programs and achieve development goals.[20] Global Source economist Romeo Bernardo, on the other hand, believes that the proposal is poorly timed and that a sovereign wealth fund would just add to the Philippines' current financial and fiscal risks and raised concern for potential mismanagement, mentioning the 1Malaysia Development Berhad scandal.[21]

A group consisting of 12 organizations, namely the Foundation For Economic Freedom, Competitive Currency Forum, Filipina CEO Circle, Financial Executives Institute of the Philippines, Institute of Corporate Directors, Integrity Initiative, Inc., Makati Business Club, Management Association of the Philippines, Movement for Good Governance, Philippine Women's Economic Network, UP School of Economics Alumni Association and Women's Business Council Philippines, Inc., made a collective statement against the proposal. The group believes that there is no gap or "missing institution" in the Philippine economy that necessitates the creation of a sovereign wealth fund and prescribes the government to focus on the management of the country's fiscal deficit and public debt to avoid impediments to the delivery of public services and to prevent a downgrade of the Philippines' sovereign investment credit rating. It also notes that the Philippine economy has no commodity-based surpluses or surpluses from external trade from state-owned enterprises. It also opposed the idea of the GSIS and SSS contributing to the fund.

The Philippine Stock Exchange has made its support of the proposal, stating that the "primary mission is to facilitate the flow of capital into more productive and beneficial channels and as a result, contribute to efficient capital formation for the country".[22]

The legislation also met criticisms. Critics see it as a plunder fund as, according to tax expert Raymond Abrea, the fund is "prone to corruption and money laundering".[23] Economists remain skeptical about the bill as it contains provisions that could affect the independent functions of government financial institutions and the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas.[24] In June 2023, University of the Philippines School of Economics faculty members issued a paper stating that the fund "violates fundamental principles of economics and finance and poses serious risks to the economy and the public sector – notwithstanding its proponents' good intentions". They emphasized its unclear purpose even after deliberations at the bicameral Congress, possible encroachment on the budget process, risks to public funds, moral-hazard risks, possible contradiction to other economic plans given its vagueness, red flags in governance structure, and unlikely substantial growth to finance projects as crucial points to consider.[25]

Establishment

On October 12, 2023, President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. ordered the suspension of the implementing rules and regulations (IRR) of the laws setting up the Maharlika Investment Fund, claiming that he wanted to further study it "to ensure that the purpose of the fund will be realized for the country's development with safeguards in place for transparency and accountability."[26] On November 6, 2023, President Marcos Jr. announced that the IIR for the Maharlika Fund has been finalized, and he emphasized that they are pushing to have it operational before year-end.[27] The revised IRR was published by the Official Gazette on November 10, 2023.[28]

Rafael Consing Jr. was sworn in as the Maharlika Investment Corporation's president and CEO on November 24, 2023.[29] Four directors were sworn in on December 20, including Vicky Castillo Tan, Andrew Jerome Gan, German Lichauco, and Roman Felipe Reyes.[30]

On January 1, 2024, the Maharlika Investment Corporation held its inaugural board meeting. Rafael D. Consing, Jr., President, discussed the Fund’s capitalization and identified some potential sectors that may be tapped by the MIF.[31]

On April 18, 2024, Maharlika Investment Corporation unveiled its official logo which principally honors the Flag of the Philippines and the Philippine eagle. The design reflects the themes of rebirth and renewal inspired by "Bagong Pilipinas.”[32]

Legal challenges

On September 18, 2023, Senate Minority Leader Koko Pimentel, representative Ferdinand Gaite (Bayan Muna), and former representatives Neri Colmenares and Carlos Isagani Zarate (Bayan Muna) filed a 56-page petition before the Supreme Court to ask the declaration of Maharlika Investment Fund Act of 2023 as unconstitutional. They claimed that it "entrusts hundreds of billions in public funds to unknown fund managers and an amorphous nine-member Board of Directors."[33]

Controversies

Basic Salary of Staff and the MIC President and CEO, Rafael D. Consing, Jr.

After the approval of the Maharlika Investment Corporation board, controversy arose on the salary of its President and CEO, Rafael D. Consing, Jr. A basic pay of PHP 2.5 million per month (amounting to PHP 30 million per year) was requested by Consing Jr. which approached the overall compensation of BSP Governor Eli M. Remolona, Jr., which amounted to PHP 35.48 million in 2023. Deliberations on the salary of Consing Jr. have caused significant delay on operations as the proposed salary was rejected. Consing Jr. defended his proposed salary as necessary for the sovereign wealth fund to recruit appropriate staff and to be at-par with the private sector. Government officials countered that the MIC was under the supervision of the Governance Commission for GOCC as it is a government entity. In response, unnamed government officials have countered with a proposal suggesting a lesser initial salary with a gradual increase upon the accomplishment of investments by the MIC.[34]

Consing Jr. would further defend his position, saying that it will "bring in experience and technical expertise" as was needed by the MIC. An item of contention between Consing Jr. and government officials has been Republic Act No. 11954's lack of clarity on the pay of non-technical and highly technical staff. Non-technical staff were understood to have the pay equal to that of other government employees. Consing Jr. argued that highly technical staff should be paid in a way "comparable to the private sector."[35]

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 2023-07-18 . What is the Maharlika Investment Fund all about? . 2023-07-24 . PIA.
  2. News: Yu . Lance Spencer . November 29, 2022 . Romualdez, Sandro Marcos file bill creating PH sovereign wealth fund . . December 3, 2022.
  3. News: Cigaral . Ian Nicolas . December 3, 2022 . Does the P250-B Maharlika Wealth Fund make sense? . . December 3, 2022.
  4. News: Corrales . Julie M. . Aurelio . Nestor . December 13, 2022 . Marcos says Maharlika fund creation his idea . . December 15, 2022.
  5. Web site: Saaduddin . Jii . June 5, 2023 . Maharlika Fund: A Proposed Sovereign Wealth Fund For The Philippines — Davao Corporate . June 6, 2023.
  6. Maharlika Investment Fund bill approved, 90 percent of House members named co-authors . December 16, 2022 . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20230205212844/https://www.congress.gov.ph/press/details.php?pressid=12348 . February 5, 2023 . congress.gov.ph.
  7. News: de Leon . Dwight . December 15, 2022 . House passes Maharlika fund bill after Marcos certifies it as urgent . .
  8. News: Eriberto . T. says . December 18, 2022 . Why 6 House lawmakers voted no to the Maharlika Investment Fund bill . . June 2, 2023.
  9. News: Gregorio . Xave . November 15, 2022 . With Marcos certification, House hastily approves Maharlika Investment Fund . . June 2, 2023.
  10. News: Cayabyab . Marc Jayson . May 25, 2023 . Marcos certifies Maharlika fund bill as urgent . . June 2, 2023.
  11. News: Bacelonia . Wilnard . May 31, 2023 . MIF gets Senate nod, now under bicam scrutiny . en, tl . .
  12. News: May 31, 2023 . Maharlika bill now up for Marcos' signature . . https://web.archive.org/web/20230531085326/https://www.cnnphilippines.com/news/2023/5/31/house-adopts-senate-version-maharlika-bill.html . dead . May 31, 2023 . June 2, 2023.
  13. News: Makabayan bloc asks SC to nullify Marcos' certification of Maharlika fund as urgent . . https://web.archive.org/web/20230330042650/https://www.cnnphilippines.com/news/2023/2/13/makabayan-sc-petition-nullify-maharlika-fund-urgent-marcos.html . dead . March 30, 2023 . June 2, 2023.
  14. News: Torres-Tupas . Tetch . May 11, 2023 . SC junks petition vs. Maharlika Fund; Makabayan bloc appeals ruling . . June 2, 2023.
  15. News: MIF bill transmitted to Malacañang. Ruth Abbey. Gita-Carlos. Philippine News Agency. July 5, 2023. July 18, 2023.
  16. News: Marcos signs Maharlika law. Catherine S.. Valente. The Manila Times. July 18, 2023. July 18, 2023.
  17. News: Quismorio . Ellson . December 9, 2022 . GSIS, SSS dropped as Maharlika fund backers; BSP steps in . . December 15, 2022.
  18. News: Lalu . Gabriel Pabico . December 13, 2022 . GSIS and SSS may still invest in Maharlika fund if their boards will allow – lawmaker . . December 15, 2022.
  19. News: Gregorio . Xave . May 29, 2023 . Loophole in Maharlika bills lets SSS, GSIS invest in fund . . June 2, 2023.
  20. News: Gutierrez . Pia . December 5, 2022 . Economist: Maharlika fund can help govt complete projects if managed properly . en, tl . . December 5, 2022.
  21. News: Dumlao-Abadilla . Doris . December 5, 2022 . Economists, business groups oppose Maharlika Wealth Fund bill . . December 15, 2022.
  22. News: Ochave . Revin Mikhael . December 19, 2022 . PSE backs creation of Maharlika Investment Fund . . December 26, 2022.
  23. News: [OPINION] Peddling a plunder fund]. Dean. de la Paz. Rappler. July 11, 2023. July 18, 2023.
  24. News: Economists still skeptical about Maharlika fund after Congress approval. June 2, 2023. July 18, 2023. Kyle Aristophere. Atienza. BusinessWorld.
  25. Maharlika Investment Fund: Still Beyond Repair. Ma.Joy. Abrenica. Luzeta. Adorna. Patricia. Coseteng. Emmanuel. de Dios. Marian. de los Angeles. Noel. Del Castillo. Benjamin. Endriga. Laarni. Escresa. Jonna. Estudillo. Ernesto. Pernia. Ernesto Pernia. Jan Carlo. Punongbayan. Renato Jr.. Reside. Anthony. Sabarillo. Orville Jose. Solon. Gerard. Suanes. Elizabeth. Tan. Mariel Jances Nhayin. Yamashita. June 2023. Upse Discussion Papers. July 18, 2023.
  26. Web site: Yu. Lance Spencer. 2023-10-18 . Marcos suspends Maharlika fund implementation, says it needs further review . 2023-10-18 . Rappler . en-US.
  27. Web site: Gonzales . Anna Leah . November 6, 2023 . PBBM: Maharlika Fund IRR finalized . November 6, 2023 . Philippine News Agency . en-US.
  28. Web site: November 10, 2023 . Revised Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Maharlika Investment Fund Act of 2023 (Republic Act No. 11954) . November 14, 2023 . . en-US.
  29. News: Yu . Lance Spencer . Consing takes oath as Maharlika Investment Corporation president, CEO . 26 November 2023 . Rappler . 24 November 2023.
  30. Web site: Servallos . Neil Jayson . Four new Maharlika directors sworn in . 2023-12-21 . Philstar.com.
  31. News: Maharlika Investment Corporation holds inaugural board meeting, identifies potential sectors to tap. April 19, 2024 . . January 1, 2024.
  32. News: Cordero. Ted . Maharlika Investment Corporation unveils official logo. April 19, 2024 . GMA Integrated News. April 18, 2024.
  33. News: Maharlika Investment Fund challenge goes to Supreme Court. Julie M.. Aurelio. Tina G.. Santos. September 19, 2023. September 19, 2023. Philippine Daily Inquirer.
  34. News: Simeon . Louise Maureen . July 15, 2024 . Proposed P2.5 million salary delays Maharlika organizational structure . live . July 17, 2024 . The Philippine Star.
  35. News: Simeon . Louise Maureen . July 17, 2024 . ‘Salaries of Maharlika top posts should be at par with private sector’ . live . July 17, 2024 . The Philippine Star.