The MTV2 Award was first presented at the MTV Video Music Awards in 2001. The category recognized the best videos to have premiered and/or got their start on MTV's sister channel, MTV2. Much like the Viewer's Choice award, the MTV2 Award was also fan-voted. Until 2005, the award was considered to be one of the main awards of the night, even being presented on the main show; in 2006, though, the MTV2 Award was relegated to being handed out during a commercial break of the MTV2 simulcast of the VMAs. The following year, as the VMAs were revamped, the MTV2 Award was eliminated and subsequently never brought back.
| Year | Winner | Other nominees | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mudvayne – "Dig" | |||
| Dashboard Confessional – "Screaming Infidelities" | |||
| AFI – "Girl's Not Grey" | |||
| Yellowcard – "Ocean Avenue" | |||
| Fall Out Boy – "Sugar, We're Goin Down" | |||
| Thirty Seconds to Mars – "The Kill" |