| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Backsliding" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Garcia | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Barracuda" (with Heart, Jerry Cantrell, Dave Navarro, Duff McKagan, Rufus Wainwright and Gretchen Wilson) | Ann Wilson, Nancy Wilson, Michael Derosier, Roger Fisher | Live in Atlantic City | 2019 |
| "Because He Lives" | Bill Gaither, Gloria Gaither | My Savior | 2021 |
| "Before He Cheats" | Josh Kear, Chris Tompkins | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Blessed Assurance" | Fanny Crosby, Phoebe Knapp | My Savior | 2021 |
| "Blown Away" | Josh Kear, Chris Tompkins | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "The Bullet" | Marc Beeson, Andy Albert, Allen Shamblin | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Burn" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Garcia, Ashley Gorley | Denim & Rhinestones | 2022 | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Can't Stop Lovin' You" (with Aerosmith) | Steven Tyler, Marti Frederiksen | Music from Another Dimension! | 2012 |
| "The Champion" (featuring Ludacris) | Underwood, Christopher Bridges, Brett James, Chris DeStefano | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Change" | Katrina Elam, Josh Kear, Chris Tompkins | Play On | 2009 |
| "Chaser" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Mike Elizondo | Storyteller | 2015 |
| "Choctaw County Affair" | Jason White |
| "Church Bells" | Hillary Lindsey, Zach Crowell, Brett James |
| "Clock Don't Stop" | Chris DeStefano, Hillary Lindsey, Blair Daly |
| "Cowboy Casanova" | Underwood, Mike Elizondo, Brett James | Play On | 2009 |
| "Crazy Angels" | Underwood, David Garcia, Lydia Vaughan | Denin & Rhinestone | 2022 |
| "Crazy Dreams" | Underwood, George Barry Dean, Troy Verges | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Cry Pretty" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Lori McKenna, Liz Rose | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Cupid's Got a Shotgun" | Underwood, Chris Tompkins, Josh Kear | Blown Away | 2012 | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Damage" | Underwood, David Garcia, Hillary Lindsey | Denim & Rhinestones (Deluxe Edition) | 2023 |
| "Denim & Rhinestones" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Josh Kear, David Garcia | Denim & Rhinestones | 2022 |
| "Dirty Laundry" | Hillary Lindsey, Zach Crowell, Ashley Gorley | Storyteller | 2015 |
| "Do-Re-Mi" (with Ariane Rinehart, Michael Nigro, Ella Watts-Gorman, Joe West, Sophia Caruso, Grace Rundhaug & Peyton Ell) | Rodgers and Hammerstein | | 2013 |
| "Do-Re-Mi" (Reprise) (with Stephen Moyer, Ariane Rinehart, Michael Nigro, Ella Watts-Gorman, Joe West, Sophia Caruso, Grace Rundhaug & Peyton Ell) |
| "Do You Hear What I Hear" | Gloria Shayne Baker, Noël Regney | Carnival Ride (Walmart Holiday Edition Bonus Disc) | 2008 |
| "Do You Think About Me" | Cary Barlowe, Hillary Lindsey, Shane Stevens | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "Don't Forget to Remember Me" | Morgane Hayes, Kelley Lovelace, Ashley Gorley | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Drinking Alone" | Underwood, David Garcia, Brett James | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Drunk and Hungover" | Hillary Lindsey, Jordan Reynolds, Nicolle Galyon | Denim & Rhinestones (Deluxe Edition) | 2023 | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Faster" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Garcia | Denim & Rhinestone | 2022 |
| "Favorite Time of Year" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Chris DeStefano | My Gift (Amazon Music Bonus Track) | 2020 |
| "The Fighter" (with Keith Urban) | Keith Urban, Busbee | Ripcord | 2016 |
| "The First Noel" | Traditional | Carnival Ride (Walmart Holiday Edition Bonus Disc) | 2008 |
| "Flat on the Floor" | Ashley Monroe, Brett James | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Forever Changed" | Tom Douglas, James T. Slater, Hillary Lindsey | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "Forever Country" (as Artists of Then, Now & Forever) | Bill Danoff, Taffy Nivert, John Denver, Willie Nelson, Dolly Parton | | 2016 | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Garden" | Underwood, David Garcia, Josh Miller | Denim & Rhinestone | 2022 |
| "Get Out of This Town" | Gordie Sampson, Steve McEwan, Hillary Lindsey | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Ghost Story" | David Garcia, Hillary Lindsey, Josh Kear | Denim & Rhinestones | 2022 |
| "Ghosts on the Stereo" | Hillary Lindsey, Tom Douglas, Andrew Dorff | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "The Girl You Think I Am" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Hodges | Storyteller | 2015 |
| "Give Her That" | Underwood, David Garcia, Lydia Vaughn | Denim & Rhinestones (Deluxe Edition) | 2023 |
| "Good Girl" | Underwood, Chris DeStefano, Ashley Gorley | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "Good in Goodbye" | Underwood, Ryan Tedder, Hillary Lindsey |
| "Great Is Thy Faithfulness" (feat. CeCe Winans) | Thomas Chisholm, William M. Runyan | My Savior | 2021 |
|
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "I Ain't in Checotah Anymore" | Underwood, Trey Bruce, Angelo Petraglia | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "I Just Can't Live a Lie" | Steve Robson, Wayne Hector |
| "I Know You Won't" | Wendell Mobley, Neil Thrasher, Steven McEwan | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "I Surrender All" | Judson W. Van DeVenter, Winfield S. Weeden | My Savior | 2021 |
| "I Told You So" (also re-released as a duet with Randy Travis) | Randy Travis | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "I Wanna Remember" (with Needtobreathe) | Bear Rinehart, Jordan Reynolds, Parker Welling | Into the Mystery | 2021 |
| "If I Didn't Love You" (with Jason Aldean) | Tully Kennedy, John Morgan, Kurt Allison, Bernardis Hughes | Macon, Georgia |
| "I'll Be Home for Christmas" (with Elvis Presley) | Walter Kent, Kim Gannon, Buck Ram | Christmas Duets | 2008 |
| "I'll Stand by You" | Chrissie Hynde, Tom Kelly, Billy Steinberg | Idol Gives Back | 2007 |
| "Independence Day" | Gretchen Peters | | 2005 |
| "Inside Your Heaven" | Andreas Carlsson, Pelle Nyhlén, Savan Kotecha | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Is It Still Over?" (with Randy Travis) | Ken Bell, Larry Henley | Anniversary Celebration | 2011 |
| "It Had to Be You" (with Tony Bennett) | Isham Jones, Gus Kahn | Duets II | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Last Name" | Underwood, Luke Laird, Hillary Lindsey | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Leave Love Alone" | Gordie Sampson, Troy Verges, Hillary Lindsey | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "Lessons Learned" | Diane Warren | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Let There Be Peace" | Underwood, Brett James, David Garcia | My Gift | 2020 |
| "Like I'll Never Love You Again" | Hillary Lindsey, Lori McKenna, Liz Rose | Storyteller | 2015 |
| "The Little Drummer Boy" (feat. Isaiah Fisher) | Harry Simeone, Katherine Kennicott Davis, Henry Onorati | My Gift | 2020 |
| "Little Girl Don't Grow Up Too Fast" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Chris DeStefano | Storyteller - Target exclusive edition | 2015 |
| "Little Toy Guns" | Underwood, Chris DeStefano, Hillary Lindsey | Greatest Hits: Decade #1 | 2014 |
| "The Lonely Goatherd" (with Ariane Rinehart, Michael Nigro, Ella Watts-Gorman, Joe West, Sophia Caruso, Grace Rundhaug, Peyton Ella) | Rodgers & Hammerstein | The Sound of Music: Music from the NBC Television Event | 2013 |
| "Look at Me" | Jim Collins, Paul Overstreet | Play On | 2009 |
| "Love Wins" | Underwood, David Garcia, Brett James | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Low" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Garcia | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "See You Again" | Underwood, David Hodges, Hillary Lindsey | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "She Don't Know" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Garcia | Denim & Rhinestone | 2022 |
| "Silent Night" | Franz Xaver Gruber, Joseph Mohr | My Gift | 2020 |
| "Sixteen Going on Seventeen" (Reprise) (with Ariane Rinehart) | Rodgers & Hammerstein | The Sound of Music: Music from the NBC Television Event | 2013 |
| "Smoke Break" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Chris DeStefano | Storyteller | 2015 |
| "So Long, Farewell" (Reprise) (with Stephen Moyer, Ariane Rinehart, Michael Nigro, Ella Watts-Gorman, Joe West, Sophia Caruso, Grace Rundhaug & Peyton Ell) | Rodgers & Hammerstein | The Sound of Music: Music from the NBC Television Event | 2013 |
| "So Small" | Underwood, Luke Laird, Hillary Lindsey | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Softly and Tenderly" | Will Lamartine Thompson | My Savoir | 2021 |
| "Some Hearts" | Diane Warren | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Someday When I Stop Loving You" | Hillary Lindsey, Steve McEwan, Gordie Sampson | Play On | 2009 |
| "Somethin' Bad" (with Miranda Lambert) | Chris DeStefano, Brett James, Priscilla Renea | Platinum | 2014 |
| "Something Good" (with Stephen Moyer) | Richard Rodgers | The Sound of Music: Music from the NBC Television Event | 2013 |
| "Something in the Water" | Underwood, Chris DeStefano, Brett James | Greatest Hits: Decade #1 | 2014 |
| "Sometimes You Leave" | Chris Tompkins, Kara DioGuardi, Shridhar Solanki | Carnival Ride - MusicPass Bonus Tracks | 2007 |
| "Songs Like This" | Marty Dodson, Jerry Flowers, Tom Shapiro | Play On | 2009 |
| "The Sound of Music" | Rodgers & Hammerstein | The Sound of Music: Music from the NBC Television Event | 2013 |
| "Southbound" | Underwood, David Garcia, Josh Miller | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "Spinning Bottles" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Garcia |
| "Starts with Goodbye" | Hillary Lindsey, Angelo Petraglia | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Still Woman Enough" (with Loretta Lynn and Reba McEntire) | Loretta Lynn, Patsy Lynn Russell | Still Woman Enough | 2021 |
| "Stretchy Pants" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Chris DeStefano | | 2021 |
| "Sweet Baby Jesus" | Underwood, Brett James, David Garcia | My Gift | 2020 | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Take Me Out" | Underwood, David Garcia, Hillary Lindsey | Denim & Rhinestone (Deluxe Edition) | 2023 |
| "Tears of Gold" (with David Bisbal) | Cameron Forbes Lewis, Paul John Harris, Matti Schwartz, Mauricio Rengifo, Andrés Torres | En Tus Planes | 2020 |
| "Temporary Home" | Underwood, Luke Laird, Zac Maloy | Play On | 2009 |
| "That Song That We Used to Make Love To" | Hillary Lindsey, Jason Evigan | Cry Pretty | 2018 |
| "That's Where It Is" | Melissa Peirce, Steve Robson, Greg Becker | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Thank God For Hometowns" | Luke Laird, Ashley Gorley, Hillary Lindsey | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "There's a Place for Us" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, David Hodges | The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader | 2010 |
| "This Side of Heaven" (with The Swon Brothers) | Blake Bollinger, Ryan Lafferty, Ben Stennis | The Swon Brothers | 2014 |
| "This Time" | Hillary Lindsey, Steve McEwan, Gordie Sampson | Play On | 2009 |
| "Twisted" | Brett James, Hillary Lindsey, Luke Laird | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Two Black Cadillacs" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Josh Kear | Blown Away | 2012 | |
| Song | Writer | Album | Year |
|---|
| "Wanted Woman" | Underwood, David Garcia, Josh Miller | Denim & Rhinestone | 2022 |
| "Wasted" | Troy Verges, Marv Green, Hillary Lindsey | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "We're Young and Beautiful" | Rivers Rutherford, Steve McEwan |
| "What Can I Say" (featuring Sons of Sylvia) | Underwood, David Hodges, Steve McEwan | Play On | 2009 |
| "What Child Is This?" | William Chatterton Dix | Carnival Ride (Walmart Holiday Edition Bonus Disc) | 2008 |
| "What I Never Knew I Always Wanted" | Underwood, Hillary Lindsey, Brett James | Storyteller | 2015 |
| "Wheel of the World" | Hillary Lindsey, Aimee Mayo, Chris Lindsey | Carnival Ride | 2007 |
| "Whenever You Remember" | Dianne Warren | Some Hearts | 2005 |
| "Who Are You" | Robert John "Mutt" Lange | Blown Away | 2012 |
| "Wine After Whiskey" | Underwood, Tom Shapiro, Dave Berg | |
