List of paintings by Henry Ossawa Tanner explained

This is a list of works by painter Henry Ossawa Tanner.

He used a variety of techniques and his works included paintings with elements of genre, American realist, French academic, oriental, impressionist and symbolist styles.[1] See Tanner's symbolist elements

Tanner's teachers included Thomas Eakins (American realism, photography), Thomas Hovenden (American realism), Benjamin Constant (orientalist paintings and portraits, French academic) and Jean-Paul Laurens (history painting, French academic).[2] [3]

His friends and colleagues included Hermon MacNeil (sculptor), Hermann Dudley Murphy (landscapes), Paul Gauguin (synthetism), Myron G. Barlow (genre painting), Charles Hovey Pepper (Japanese style woodblocks). Charles Filiger (symbolist), Armand Séguin (Post-Impressionism), Jan Verkade (Post-Impressionism, Christian symbolist), Paul Sérusier (abstract art), and Gustave Loiseau (Post-Impressionism).[2] [4] [5]

He was inspirational to young artists studying in France, including Hale Woodruff and Romare Bearden.[2]

Early years, 1859-1890

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
187011 years oldDrawing was part of Tanner's childhood in elementary school. However, he did not consider himself gifted.[6] Barnyard FowlAttributed to Tanner online.[7] In doubt, considering Tanner decided to paint in 1872.
1875-187616–17 years oldIn 1872 he saw a painter painting a landscape in a park and was inspired to paint.[8] Tanner saw paintings at Earle's Galleries in Philadelphia. He spent summers in Atlantic City.In 1872 (age 13) he decides to become a marine painter. "Tanner's first known painting" was Harbor Scene.[9] This painting completed with no art education.Harbor ScenePrivate collection. Oil on canvas board glued to Masonite. 14 x 20" (35.56 x 50.8 cm)
undatedTanner sketches a shipwreck, impresses artist Henry Price, who takes him in to teach him for about a year.[10] This impressionist painting is not that sketch but came later.The WreckSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.205. Oil on panel, 9 1/4 x 12 1/8 in. (23.5 x 30.8 cm.)
circa 1876-1879[11] about 17–20 years oldAttending Philadelphia Academy, beginning 1879, and through 1885 (not continuously but periodically)SeascapeImpressionism, family collection of Rae Alexander-Mintner
1876-187917–20 years oldSeascape JettyPrivate collection. Oil on canvas. 12 x 17" (30.48 x 43.18 cm)
187920 years oldTanner exposed to paintings at Earle's Galleries in Philadelphia. Spends summers in Atlantic City.An early painting, done while learning, "probably derived from another artist's work".Ship in a StormPrivate collection. Oil on academy board 10'/16 x 6"(25.56 x 15.24 cm)
187920 years oldPainting likely made before he entered the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts.[12] FaunaHampton University Museum. Oil on canvas. 38 3/8″ x 29 3/4″
[13] 21 years oldAfter the StormFormerly in the Evans-Tibbs Collection.
1880[14] 21 years olduntitledTelfair Museums, 1998.29. Oil on canvas, 15 1/8 × 25 3/16 inches (38.4 × 64 cm)
[15] 21 years oldStudent work made while Tanner was attending the Philadelphia Academy. The second photo is of the same lion, done at a later date.Pomp at the zooPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 20 x 16 in.
21–22 years oldIn a biographical article, Tanner wrote of his experience of owning and painting a sheep while at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts.[16] Study of a sheep's head. Tanner switched his interest from marine painting to painting animals.[17] Head of a SheepPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, on board, 10 1/2x10 in. (267x254 mm)
1881[18] 22 years oldIn the 1880-1881 period, Tanner lived in Philadelphia with his parents, as he tried to start life as a painter.Boy and Sheep Under a TreePrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 17 3/8 x 27 in.
undatedFeeding Sheep
1881-1882[19] 22–23 years oldPortrait of a girl; "My Sister Sara" is written on lower right. Tanner had a sister Sarah Elizabeth Tanner who was 9 years old in 1882.[20] Sister Sara Done while Tanner was at the Philadelphia Academy.Private collection. Oil on canvas, 16 x 13 in.
23 years oldTanner can be identified by his signature in these works.Historical painting for magazine, not used. Three other paintings illustrated the article, called The Witch Hunt, by Louise Stockton, in Our Continent magazine, August 30, 1882, pages 233–235.[21] The Witch Hunt
1882[22] 23 years oldTanner can be identified by his signature in these works.Historical painting for magazine, illustrating the article, called The Witch Hunt, by Louise Stockton, in Our Continent magazine, August 30, 1882, pages 233–235.[23] Waiting for the LordHistorical Society of Pennsylvania. Gouache on board, 13'/2 X 12”.
23 years oldTanner can be identified by his signature in these works.Historical painting for magazine, illustrating the article, called The Witch Hunt, by Louise Stockton, in Our Continent magazine, August 30, 1882, pages 233–235.Gathering Faggots and At the Well
1884[24] Painting of elk attacked by wolves; has been pointed out as symbolizing racist attacks on him while studying at the Philadelphia Academy of Art.Battle of LifeLost
[25] 26 years oldShepherdess herding sheepuntitledPrivate collection. Oil on panel, 13 x 9 1/2 in.
[26] [27] 26 years oldLandscape done near the end of his time studying at the Philadelphia Academy. Installed at the Green Room, White House.[28] Sand Dunes at Sunset, Atlantic City or Back from the BeachWhite House Historical Association, 995.1759.1. Oil on canvas, 30 3/16 x 59 7/16 in.
1885-1886[29] 26–27 years oldTanner spent time studying the nude form at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Art. Painting was a study for a planned painting of a mythological scene of Androcles with a lion.Study for AndroclesPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 31' x 18"
1886[30] 27 years oldTanner had been painting lions since at least 1880. He abandoned his project for Androcles and the lion as beyond his current abilities, but continued painting lions in works such as this.Lion Licking Its Paw or After DinnerAllentown Art Museum, 1962.5. Oil on canvas, 30 x 36" (76.2 x 91.44 cm)[31]
1888[32] 29 years oldTanner grew up in Pennsylvania near the house of Nicolas Wynkoop, who built it in 1739. That house would later be owned by "abolitionist" Judge Henry Wynkoop, who freed his slaves.[33] Some of Judge Henry Wynkoop's slaves chose to remain with his family after receiving freedom on his death; a tree became their cemetery marker.[34] [35] Picture of a different Wynkoop house in Harlem, Manhattan, New York City dated with signature 1888. Tanner may have painted this as a symbol with civil rights in mind.Wynkoop House, Old HaarlemNew Britain Museum of American Art, 1984.86. Oil on canvas, 18 1/2 x 13 1/4 in. American realism
[36] 29 years olduntitled landscape (Female figure with basket and trail leading to houses)Hearne Fine Art. Oil on canvas, framed size: 21" x 17"
1887-1888[37] 28–29 years oldTanner made illustrations for Harper's Young People.He illustrated for Kate Upson Clark, her story "Old Win-ne-wan's Star" in Harper's Young People, printed as wood engraving January 10, 1888.It Must Be My Very Star, Come Down to Brooklyn, After All
1882-1888[38] While still living in Philadelphia, Tanner did a religious artwork. This was years before The Thankful Poor and Daniel in the Lion's Den (1896). His teacher may have been sending students' work in to magazines.Joachim, father of Mary, maternal grandfather of JesusJoachim Leaving the TempleThe Baltimore Museum of Art, 2008.111. Opaque watercolor and graphite, inscribed with a stylus, on paper, 558 × 392 mm. (21 15/16 × 15 7/16 in.)
[39] 30 years oldTanner visits Highlands, North Carolina, with the idea that he could make money with his camera and pay for the trip.[40] Painting likely of the Cumberland Mountains.[41] Mountain Landscape, Highlands North CarolinaDoris Ulman Galleries, Berea College Art Department, Kentucky, 140.O.95. Oil on canvas. 23" x 36"[42]
[43] 30 years oldvisits Highlands, NCMountain Landscape, Highlands, North CarolinaSmithsonian American Art Museum. Watercolor, pencil, and colored pencil on paper mounted on paperboard, 10 7/8 x 15 in. (27.5 x 38.1 cm)
[44] 30 years oldvisits Highlands, N.C.Highlands, N.C.Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.26. Watercolor and pencil on paper, 10 7/8 x 15 in.
1889 [45] 30 years oldvisits Highlands, NCWaterfall, North CarolinaThe Charleston Renaissance Gallery. Oil on canvas 21 5/8 x 14 inches
1889[46] [47] 30 years oldSimilarity: Tanner painted a work titled "Scrub Pine Land", exhibited in 1894 and unknown today, painted in Florida.[48] untitled landscapeRobert W. Woodruff Library, Atlanta University Center, Oil on canvas, 33 1/2 x 27 1/4 in.
undated, [49] 30–31 years oldGeorgia LandscapeMorris Museum of Art, Augusta, Georgia. Oil on canvas, 17 3/4 x 32 1/4 in.
undated[50] Painting signature has "Henry" spelled out, which is unusual.African American figures?untitledPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 9 x 13 in.

Paris, 1891-1896

Tanner set out for Rome by way of Liverpool and Paris on the ship City of Chester on 4 January 1891.[51] He found Paris to his liking and discovered the Académie Julian, where he began his studies in France.[52] After two years in France, he discovered the existence of the Paris Salon and set a goal to get his artwork accepted.[52] It may have been the summer after he came to France and not two years; he tried to enter a painting in the 1893 Salon.

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
1891[53] 32 years oldBeginning January 1891, attending school at the Academie Julian in ParisPainted in France while attending school. The figure between the two dogs in the background is a pentimento of a gypsy boy, a street performer. Tanner painted the petit savoyard (young Gypsy street performer) into the picture, but later removed it, creating the shadowy image.A Horse and Two Dogs in a LandscapeWoodrow Wilson Middle School Collection, Philadelphia.[54] American realism or French academic
1891[55] 32 years oldBeginning January 1891, attending school at the Academie Julian in ParisPainted in France while attending school. Appears to be imitating the painting Anguish by August Friedrich Schenck. Tanner's painting is retitled, and painted in a more impressionist style.Behold! The Lamb of GodPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 13.12 x 18.12 in. (33.3 x 46 cm.)
undated[56] Attended Philadelphia Academy of Fine Art about 1879–1885. Struggled to make living as artist. Beginning January 1891, attended school at the Academie Julian in ParisPlace and time painted unknown. Clearly imitating Briton Riviere's Daniel's Answer to the Kinguntitled. Online labeled Daniel in the Lion's DenPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 29 1/2 x 43 in.[57]
189132 years oldFirst year in France. Summering on west coast of Brittany.Portrait of a woman apparently from the French West Indies. Her dress marks her as not being of the peasant class. This image is a rare Tanner portrait, one of about 7 known images he painted of a colored person. Impressionist techniques being used in this image.Woman from the West Indies, 1891, Brittany, France.[58] Impressionism
Tanner arrived in France in January 1891. Night scene of a couple standing in the rain in Paris.Steet Scene, Paris[59] Colby College Museum of Art, 1972.052. Waterville, Maine.[60] Pastel on paper, 13 × 9 3/4 in. (33 × 24.8 cm.)
1891[61] 32 years oldTanner arrived in France in January 1891. Summered in Brittany at Pont-Aven and Concarneau. Bois d'Amour is near Pont-Aven. Concarneau is about 15 km from Pont-Aven.Woman and child walking on a path in the woods.Bois d'Amour
undated[62] Tanner had the opportunity to paint this at any time after 1890.Painting came up for auction in 2023 in Bordeaux, France.Brittany, mother and her child on the roadBretagne, mère et son enfant sur la route Private collection. 35 x 55.5 cm
189132 years oldSummers in Brittany, spends time at ConcarneauConcarneau
[63] 32–34 years oldTanner studied at the Académie Julian from 1891 to 1893.Study at the Académie Julian, where instruction centered around making images of nude models.Half-Length Study of a Negro ManDetroit Institute of Arts. Charcoal and pastel on cream laid paper, 19 1/2 x 9 3/8 in. (24.6 x 23.9 cm).[64]
Assuming this is part of his artist's studies in the Académie Julian, it would date from his arrival in 1891 until he left in 1893Portrait of a Young Girl[65] Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.46. Conte crayon, pencil and pastel on paper, 8 7⁄8 x 6 1⁄4 in. (22.5 x 16.0 cm)
undated[66] possibly Assuming this is part of his artist's studies in the Académie Julian, it would date from his arrival in 1891 until he left in 1893. Painting in French art gallery ProanticEtude d'Un Homme Barbuor Study Of A Bearded ManPrivate collection. Charcoal on paper, 25.5 x 20 cm.
189233 years oldSummer 1892 in Brittany. Spring 1893, Paris. Possibly, early summer 1893, Brittany. Spring/Summer 1893 returned to United States.[67] Attended World's Columbian ExpositionStudy begun in Brittany in 1892 for painting The Bagpipe Lesson, finished by May 1893.Study for the Bagpipe Lesson[68] Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.42. Oil on paperboard, 5 x 5 15/16 in.
189334 years oldSummer 1892 in Brittany. Spring 1893, Paris. Possibly, early summer 1893, Brittany. Spring/Summer 1893 returned to United States.First attempt to get a painting into the Paris Salon, in 1893; it was rejected but later accepted in 1895.[69] Painted with an American painter's eye, not with symbolism or impressionism. Displayed at World's Columbian Exposition, in the exposition catalog.The Bagpipe LessonHampton University Museum. Oil on canvas, 45 x 68 3/4" (114.3 x 174.63 cm) American Realism or French Academic
[70] 34 years oldSummer 1892 in Brittany. Spring 1893, Paris. Possibly, early summer 1893, Brittany. Spring/Summer 1893 returned to United States.Tanner moving toward impressionism in this work.The Edge of the Forest Bois d’AmourRosenfeld Fine Arts. Oil on wood panel, 7"/4 X 101/2" (18.42 x 26.67 cm)
[71] Tanner painted African Americans (women and children) in what was probably Philadelphia in the late 19th century.Feeding ChickensPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 14 x 24". Sold at New Orleans Auction Galleries.[72]
1894[73] 35 years oldSeveral trips to Florida. One trip in 1878.[74] Jacksonville & Enterprise, Florida in 1889.[75] Tallahassee, Florida in 1894.[76] Tanner exhibited at Earle's in 1894, including "Scrub-Pine Land," "Orange Grove" and "Young Orange Trees".[77] FloridaPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 18 x 22 in.
1894[78] 35 years oldIn 1894 Tanner exhibited paintings titled Lake Monroe and Evening on the St. Johns at Earle's Galleries. The location of either painting is unknown.The date is in the lower right corner.untitled landscapeDuSable Museum of African American History
1893-189434–35 years oldSummer 1892 in Brittany. Spring 1893, Paris. Possibly, early summer 1893, Brittany. Spring/Summer 1893 returned to United States. Return to Paris in fall of 1894.[79] Submitted to Paris Salon in spring 1894 as The Music Lesson[80] Date on painting 1893. Early name in newspapers was The First Lesson.[81] Painted to show multiple light sources. Brushwork style links to The Thankful Poor and Spinning by Firelight.The Banjo Lesson or La Lecon de Musique (The Music Lesson) Hampton University Museum. Oil on canvas, 49 x 35/2" (124.46 x 90.17 cm). American Realism blended with Impressionism[82] [83]
189435 years oldThe final painting was exhibited in the spring of 1894.The Thankful PoorArt Bridges. Oil on canvas, height: 90.1 cm (35.5 in); width: 112.4 cm (44.2 in). American Realism blended with Impressionism
1894[84] 35 years oldSpinning by Firelight or The Boyhood of George Washington GrayYale University Art Gallery, 1996.58.1. Oil on canvas, 44 1/4 x 66 1/4. American Realism blended with Impressionism
1894[85] 35 years oldTanner returned to France from the United States in September 1894.Crossing the Atlantic or Return HomeSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.28. Watercolor and pencil on paper mounted on paperboard, 9 7/8 x 13 1/2 in. (25.2 x 34.2 cm)
1894[86] 35 years oldTanner returned to France from the United States in September 1894.This image in France would have been painted after his return.Pont-Aven DuSable Museum. Oil on canvas, 23.5 x 19.75 inches
189536 years oldTanner made at least three studies for The Young Sabot Maker before his final painting.Study for the Young Sabot MakerSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.208. Oil on canvas, 16 1/4 x 13 in. (41.3 x 33.0 cm.)
1895[87] 36 years oldEntry in Paris Salon, 1895.The Young Sabot MakerThe Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art. Oil on canvas, height: 120.3 cm (47.3 in); width: 89.8 cm (35.3 in). American Realism, French Academic
1895[88] 36 years oldBoy holding a binioù (Breton bagpipe). Dates to visit to Pont-Aven, Brittany in 1894.The Bagpipe PlayerPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 21 1/2 x 18 1/2 in.[89]
[90] 36 years oldEarly exploration of biblical subjectThe Annunciation to the ShepherdsThe Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art. Oil on canvas, height: 120.3 cm (47.3 in); width: 89.8 cm (35.3 in). American Realism, French Academic
1895[91] 36 years oldLiving in ParisEarly entry into Tanner's chosen field of Christian artworkAdoration of the Golden Calf[92] Hampton University Museum. Oil on canvas, 33 x 41 cm. (13 x 16.1 in.)
1895[93] 36 years oldLiving in ParisIn the 1895 Paris Salon, he exhibited "pastel of New Jersey coast by moonlight".[94] [95] Under matting, this painting had "Paris 1895." Possibly depicts a buoy particular to "Quai d'Issy on the Seine River."Marshes in New JerseySmithsonian American Art Museum, 1894.149.3. pastel and pencil on paper mounted on paperboard, sheet: 9 1⁄2 x 12 1⁄2 in.
undatedAfter Daniel in the Lion's Den, Rodman Wanamaker sponsored trips to Palestine/Egypt (January- April 1897, October 1898 - March 1899) to give Tanner the places' look.Two paintings that are intended to be oriental, but don't have the same look as those found in the 1897, 1898–99, 1908 and 1912 trips. Question to be answered: could these predate Tanner's trips to the Middle East?
1896[96] 37 years oldLiving in ParisView of the Seine, Looking Toward Notre DamePrivate collection. Formerly held by Michael Rosenfeld Gallery. Oil on canvas, 14 7/8 x 20 1/8.
189637 years oldLiving in ParisEntered Daniel in the Lion's Den in the 1896 Paris Salon, his third year in the event. This is a photo of that version, which is now lost. Tanner repainted the picture later, in a horizontal layout.Daniel in the Lion's DenLocation unknown.
189637 years oldLiving in ParisLes Invalides, a complex that includes Napoleon's tomb and the Hôtel des Invalides (a home for disabled military veterans)[97] Les InvalidesTerra Foundation for American Art, Daniel J. Terra Collection. Oil on canvas, height: 33.3 cm (13.1 in); width: 41 cm (16.1 in)
1896[98] 37 years oldSigned reverse of painting: To Mrs. Crane / Souvenir of the Sands of NJ / H.O. Tanner / 1896 (verso)Sands of New Jersey or Souvenir of the Sands of NJPrivate collection. Oil on panel 4 3/4 by inches (12 by 15.9 cm)
1896[99] [100] 37 years oldLiving in ParisWon a gold medal at Paris Salon 1897, bought by French Government, brought honor to Tanner that he no longer had to submit paintings to a committee before entering them in the Salon.[101] Raising of Lazarus or Resurrection of LazarusMusée d'Orsay, RF 1980 173. Oil on canvas, 37 x 48 in. (94.7 x 120.5 cm.)

First trip to the Middle East, 1897

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
[102] 38 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and EgyptA Mosque in CairoPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 9 1/2 x 13 in.
1897[103] [104] 38 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and EgyptMosque of QaitbeyInterior of a Mosque, CairoMuseum of Fine Arts, Boston, 2005.92. Oil on canvas, height: 52.1 cm (20.5 in) Edit this at Wikidata; width: 66 cm (25.9 in)
189738 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and EgyptCairo boatman[105] Private collection. Oil on panel, 32 x 51 cm-12.5 x 20 in.
1897[106] 38 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and EgyptCairo boatmanPrivate collection. Oil on panel, 8 1/2 x 13 in.
1897-189938–40 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and Egypt, second trip October 1898 - March 1899Seated Arab[107] Private collection. Oil on wood, 331x235 mm; 13x9 1/4 inches.
[108] 38 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and Egypt, second trip October 1898 - March 1899Study of an ArabPrivate collection. Oil on board 33 x 24 cm (13 x 9 1/2 in.)
February 1897[109] 38 years oldJanuary- April 1897, trip to Palestine and EgyptReverse of image had "Cairo Feb 1897". Front has Paris, Oct 1898untitled (A Water Carrier)Private collection. oil on panel, 10 by 8 inches (25.4 by 20.3 cm)
undatedpossibly January- April 1897, trip to Palestine and Egypt; January–April 1897, trip to Palestine and EgyptPainting not dated; based on subject and realisim-style, the painting might be placed on his 1st or 2nd trip to the Near East.untitled (Arab Musician)[110] Private collection. oil on canvas board, artist's name on verso, 9" x 11", frame 13 3/4" x 15 3/4"
[111] 38 years oldIn January–April 1897, Tanner went on a trip to Palestine and Egypt. He was sponsored to increase his knowledge of biblical scenery.The final painting is lost, but this study survives.Study for the Jew's Wailing Place or The Wailing WallMuseum of Art, Rhode Island School of Design. Oil on canvas 25 1/2 x 19 1/4" (64.77 x 48.9 cm)
[112] 38 years oldIn January–April 1897, Tanner went on a trip to Palestine and Egypt. He was sponsored to increase his knowledge of biblical scenery.He had painted lions before in a zoo setting; these he placed in a desert.Lion DrinkingPrivate collection. Oil on cardboard, height: 23.5 cm (9.2 in); width: 37.5 cm (14.7 in)
[113] 38–39 years oldIn January–April 1897, Tanner went on a trip to Palestine and Egypt. He was sponsored to increase his knowledge of biblical scenery.He had painted lions before in a zoo setting; these he placed in a desert.Lions in the Desert or Still Hunt[114] Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.184. Oil on canvas mounted on plywood 15 1/2 x 29 3/8" (39.37 x 74.61 cm)
Undated; probably [115] 38–39 years oldLikely painted during his first (January- April 1897) or second (Oct 98-March 99) trip to the Middle East.The CanyonSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.183. Oil on canvas, 16 x 13 in. (40.6 x33.0 cm.)
[116] 38 years oldTanner stopped in Venice in the spring of 1897, after visit to Palestine and Egypt.VeniceOil on canvas on plywood, 274x228 mm; 10 7/8x9 inches.
undatedPortrait of Isaac[117] Charcoal on paper, 22" x 18".

Mature period, 1897-1908

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
August–September 1897[118] [119] [120] 38 years oldIn Kansas City, Kansas, seeing his familyTanner painted this about August–September 1897 after visiting the Near East. The subject is his father, Benjamin Tucker Tanner.Bishop Benjamin Tucker TannerPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 13 X 9 3/4" (33.02 x 23.49 cm)
August–September 189738 years oldIn Kansas City, Kansas, seeing his familyTanner painted an image of his father that is dated. The image of his mother Sarah Elizabeth Tanner without date has the same red background and is the same size.Portrait of the Artist's MotherNational Museum of American Art, Smithsonian Institution. Oil on plywood, 13 X 9 3/4".
August–September 1897[121] [122] 38 years oldIn Kansas City, Kansas, seeing his family in summer/fall, 1897Portrait of Sarah Elizabeth TannerPortrait of the artist's motherPhiladelphia Museum of Art, EW1993-61-1. Oil on canvas, 29 1/4 x 39 1/2" (74.29 x 100.33 cm)
[123] 38 years oldAfter his trip to the Middle East in the spring of 1897, Tanner visited his parents in Kansas City, Kansas in August/September. Return to Paris in September.Kansas City, KansasSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.30. Watercolor and pencil on paper mounted on paperboard, sheet: 9 7⁄8 x 13 7⁄8 in.
1898[124] [125] 39 years oldVisits U.S. in August 1897 after return to Paris from Holy Land. Returns to Paris September 1897 from US. Announces, that after he returns to Paris, he will paint an Eastern type Virgin Mary dressed in clothes from the Holy Land.[126] Tanner probably did not use Jessie McCauley Olssen (his future wife) for the girl.[127] Entry in 1898 Paris Salon.[128] The Virgin Mary is visited by the archangel Gabriel, who delivers the Annunciation of the Lord, the announcement that she would bear Jesus. The AnnunciationPhiladelphia Museum of Art, W1899-1-1. 57 x 71 1/4 in (1,448.82 mm x 1,811.27 mm)
[129] 39 years oldHenry Ossawa Tanner meets Jessie Macauley Olssen in the summer of 1898.Portrait of Jessie Jessie Macauley Olssen, Tanner's wife[130] Portrait of the Artist's WifeSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.211. Oil on fiberboard, 22 3/8 x 18 7/8 in. (56.8 x 47.9 cm.)
1898[131] [132] 39 years oldEntry in the 1900 Paris Salon and later at Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts's 70th Annual Exhibition (1901), the Minneapolis Society of Fine Arts exhibition (1902) and the Lewis and Clark Centennial Exposition in Portland, Oregon (1905).[133] [134] Mary with infant Jesus (under the blanket and halo.) Mary or La Sainte-MarieLa Salle University Art Museum, 84-P-298. Oil on canvas, 34 1/8 x 42 5/8 in. (86.7 x 108.3 cm).
[135] 40 years oldHead of a Girl in Jerusalem (The Artist's Wife)Formerly in Evans-Tibbs collection. Oil on artists board.
1899[136] Reworked 1918–1920.[137] 40 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. Began recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt.Thought to be the study used for Nicodemus in Nicodemus Visiting Jesus. This image was reworked in 1918-1920 and may have changed the look of the subject.Head of a Jew in Palestine.Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.189. Oil on canvas, 24 x 21 1⁄4 in. (61 x 53.9 cm).
38–40 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. No date; this should date to one of his first two Mideast Trips.Head of a Woman in Jerusalem[138] Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.194. Oil on canvas mounted on cardboard, 17 7⁄8 x 13 5⁄8 in. (45.4 x 34.6 cm.)
[139] 38–40 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. No date; this should date to one of his first two Mideast Trips.A View of PalestineFrances Lehman Loeb Art Center, Vassar College, 1946.3.3. Oil on canvas, 22 1/2 x 37 in.
[140] 39 years oldExhibited in May 1899 at the Pennsylvania Museum and School of Art and January 1901 at the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts.And He Vanished Out of Their Sightor And He Disappeared Out of Their SightLocation unknown (possibly lost). Oil on canvas, 25 3/4 x 32 in. Photo in collections of Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts and the Smithsonian Archives of American Art.[141]
1899[142] 40 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99.The painting illustrate the biblical story of Nicodemus a Pharisee who visited Jesus to talk to him. 1899 Paris Salon entry.Nicodemus Visiting Jesus. or Nicodemus or Nicodemus Coming to Christ[143] Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, 1900.1. Oil on canvas, 33.11/16 × 39.5 in (85.5 × 100.3 cm).
1899[144] 40 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. Began recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt.A very similar version (At the Gates) was painted in 1927-1927.Flight Into Egypt.Amistad Research Center, ARC.HTANN.1900.01. Oil on panel, circa 1926–27. 610x483 mm; 24x19 in. Impressionism
1899[145] 40 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. Began recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt.Exhibited 1899 at the Carnegie Institute, along with Judas.[146] Flight Into Egypt.Detroit Institute of Arts, 69.452. Oil on canvas. Unframed: 19 3/4 × 25 1/2 inches (50.2 × 64.8 cm). Impressionism
40 years oldPublished in the June 1900 issue of the Brush and Pencil journal or magazine.[147] Scene at Czernay la VilleThe LaundressImpressionism
[148] Still Life With Apples[149] Georgia Museum of Art, University of Georgia, GMOA 2011.604. Oil on canvas.[150]
40 years oldTanner displayed a work at the Carnegie Institute, now lost.[151] Judas.Painted over to make the 1924 painting Two Disciples at the TombOnly one known photo of the painting, may still be in copyright.
[152] 41 years oldDisplayed at the annual exhibition of the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts, 1900, along with Nicodemus and Hills Near Jerusalem. Painting of the death of Judas. Also exhibited 1908 at his solo exhibition.And He Went Out and Hanged Himselfor Death of Judas[153] Location unknown, possibly lost.
Date based on that of final painting40 years oldStudy painting, used in Christ Among the DoctorsScribes[154] or Study for Christ Among the DoctorsPrivate collection. Oil on [base not identified], 21 ¾" by 18"
40–41 years oldChrist Among the Doctors or Christ in the Temple[155] Location unknown.
[156] 40 years oldThe lost painting Christ in the Temple may be glimpsed in this photo from 1900.Picture of Tanner in his studio painting Christ in the Temple also called Christ Among the DoctorsPhoto from the journal Brush and Pencil, volume 6, issue 3, June 1900, article titled: "Henry O. Tanner, Painter", pages 97–107.
[157] 41–46 years old"Jesus meditating as he waits for his crown of thorns and purple robe, in which he would be mocked as the 'King of the Jews.'"The Savior.Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.191. Oil on canvas mounted to plywood. 29 1⁄8 x 21 3⁄4 in. (73.9 x 55.3 cm)[158]
[159] 41 years oldThe Seine, Evening.Norton Museum of Art[160] Oil on canvas, 10 1/8 x 8 in. (25.7 x 20.3 cm)
[161] 41 years olduntitledor Parisian Street ScenePrivate collection. Oil on panel, 5 3/4 x 7 in.
[162] 41 years olduntitled. (View of the Seine)Private collection. Oil on plywood, 11,5 x 16,5 cm. (4.5 x 6.5 in.)
[163] 41 years oldThis painting has been called a work of symbolism. Similar to symbolist painting by Franz von Stuck, Sin. Tanner has decapitated Salome with shadow. The blue, sometimes a spiritual color is unpleasant here, speaking of sin, judgement.Painting of Salome with the head of John the Baptist at her feet. Donated to Smithsonian by Jesse Tanner (Henry O. Tanner's son). Painted on the opposite side of the canvas as Moses and the Burning Bush (abandoned).[164] SalomeSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1893.95.207A. Oil on canvas, 45 7/8 x 35 1/4 in.
41 years oldTanner painted a portrait of his wife Jessie Macauley Olssen.[165] [166] Jessie Macauley OlssenPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 13 x 9.5 in. (33 x 24.1 cm.)
41 years oldJohn Olssen, father of Tanner's wife Jessie.[167] John OlssenOil on canvas, left 73 x 54 cm - 28.7 x 21.2 in.
[168] 41 years oldTanner did nude portraits as studies at both the Academy of Fine Arts in Philadelphia and the Academie Julian in Paris. This was published in 1900; its creation date is unknown.Study around the idea, "And Mary pondered all these things in her heart."StudyLocation unknown. Charcoal on paper.
undated, possibly [169] [170] untitled (nocturnal landscape)Johnson Museum of Art, Cornell University, 79.029.002. Oil on canvas, 26 1/4 x 19 3/4 inches (66.7 x 50.2 cm).
undated[171] American artists in Paris hold separate year-end exposition, December 1901.[172] In a 1901 exposition, Tanner entered a work, "woman's head In the firelight". May have no connection to Smithsonian's "Profile of a Woman's head."Profile of a Woman's Head.Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.201. Oil on wood, 14 1⁄8 x 11 3⁄4 in. (35.8 x 30.0 cm.)
[173] [174] 43 years oldDisplayed at 1902 Salon,[175] but did not get a good reception in French press. Tanner painted The Pilgrims of Emmaus over it.He painted himself into the picture, with his wife's sister, Elna Olssen Charles, playing piano.[176] La Musique or The Cello Lesson or The Duo or Chamber MusicLost painting. Tanner painted over it, with the painting Pilgrims of Emmaus.[177]
[178] 43 years oldBishop Joseph Crane Hartzell and his wife (Jennie Culver[179]) were instrumental in Tanner's success. They bought his collection of paintings in 1891, to finance his trip to Europe.Portrait of Bishop Joseph Crane HartzellHampton University Museum. Oil on canvas, 47 xX 36" (119.38 x 91.44 cm).
[180] 43 years oldParis, view from the right bank of the Seine looking west toward the twin towers of the Palais du Trocadéro.The SeineNational Gallery of Art, 1971.57.1. Oil on canvas, 22.8 x 33 cm (9 x 13 in.)
[181] 42–44 years oldLondon landscapeLow Tide, Cannon Street BridgePhiladelphia Museum of Art, 2005–86–1. Oil on canvas board, 14 × 20 inches (35.6 × 50.8 cm)
Printed September 1902 in the Ladies Home Journal, part of a series of four mothers, "Mothers of the Bible", Sarah, Hagar, Rachel, and Mary.[182] Tanner wrote the text to accompany the painting. Sarah from Mothers of the Bible series.[183] Painting lost.
[184] 43 years oldPrinted October 1902 in the Ladies Home Journal, part of a series of four mothers, "Mothers of the Bible", Sarah, Hagar, Rachel, and Mary."And Abraham rose up early in the morning, and took bread, and a bottle of water, and gave it unto Hagar. . . .and sent her away; and she departed and wandered in the wilderness of Beer-sheba--GENESIS XXI, 14." Hagar from Mothers of the Bible series. Painting lost.
43–44 years oldPrinted November 1902 in the Ladies Home Journal, part of a series of four mothers, "Mothers of the Bible", Sarah, Hagar, Rachel, and Mary.Tanner wrote the text to accompany the painting. Jacob asks Rachel to marry, her father watching.Rachel from Mothers of the Bible series.Painting lost.
43–44 years oldPrinted January 1903 in the Ladies Home Journal,[185] part of a series of four mothers, "Mothers of the Bible", Sarah, Hagar, Rachel, and Mary.Tanner used his wife Jessie as the model for "many of his studies" for the series, including Mary.[186] Mary from Mothers of the Bible series.Painting lost.
[187] 43–44 years oldThe museum RMN-Grand Palais (Orsay Museum) dates this 1903–1904.[188] Christ and His Disciples on the Road to BethanyRMN-Grand Palais, Musée d'Orsay, RF 1980 174. Oil on canvas, 373/83 X 47 '3/16" (95 x 121.5 cm) or H. 66.0; L. 96.0 cm.
43–44 years oldA work of religion centering on Gospel of John (10:14—16). Also a work of racial equality in that Tanner "saw the theme of the good shepherd in terms of racial and social equality, as did his father." Important to him, Tanner would paint the Good Shepherd theme at least 15 times.The Good Shephard.[189] Zimmerli Art Museum at Rutgers University, 1988.0063. Oil on canvas, height: 770 mm (30.31 in); width: 920 mm (36.22 in)
43–49 years oldTanner went to the Holy Land in 1898-1899 and to Granada in Dec 1902.[190] Both places affect this image: the mount of Temptation was painted before this work. In Granada, Tanner encountered El Greco's work and it affected the way he painted people. This painting study is on the back of Salome.Study for Moses and the Burning Bush.Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.207B. Oil on canvas. 29 1⁄8 x 21 3⁄4 in. (73.9 x 55.3 cm)[191] "Moses and the Burning Bush" at exhibitions in 1908.
190344 years oldTanner took his wife Jessie to Granada, where they lived from January–March 1903Interior Scene or The Stairwell, Granada[192] Private collection. Oil on canvas, 22 3/4" (58 cm) x 21 3/4" (55 cm)
undated[193] Place of image not known. While the place might be Palestine or North Africa, it might also be Granada.Village ScenePrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 12 x 15.75 in.
1904[194] [195] 45 years oldEntered into the 1906 Paris Salon.[196] Tanner encounters the paintings of El Greco in Granada and begins to paint people in an "elongated figure style"."drawn from the Gospel of John (19:25—27)..." Mary, (Jesus' mother in front) and the disciple "whom he loved". The blonde woman is prob. Mary Magdalene; the woman behind the disciple prob Mary the wife of Cleophas.Return of the Holy Women or Le Retour de la Sainte Femme or Return of the Holy WomanCedar Rapids Museum of Art, 23.1. Oil on canvas, 46 1/2 x 35 in. (116.84 x 88.9 cm).
1904[197] 45 years oldPainting was covered up, placed underneath the canvas of Daniel in the Lion's Den (1907-1918 version) and rediscovered in 1976. Tanner had been receiving strong criticism during this period in the press.Draws on scripture: Job 2:7—13 "So went Satan forth from the presence of the Lord, and smote Job with sore boils from the sole of his foot unto his crown... Now when Job's three friends heard of all this evil that was come upon him, they came every one from his own place...So they sat down with him upon the ground seven days and seven nights..." King James VersionJob and his Three Friends Private collection. Oil on canvas, 41 x 493/4" (104.14 x 126.37 cm)
1905[198] 46 years oldThe Virgin Mary in MeditationPrivate collection, Paris. Oil on board, 12 x inches.
46 years oldLuke Chapter 10. While Christ is at the home of Mary and Martha, Mary focuses on him. Martha focuses on less important things (elsewhere).[199]

Mary sitting with Christ, in a possible study for Christ in the Home of Mary and Martha.

Christ at the Home of Mary.Norton Museum of Art. Pastel and watercolor on paper, 11 1/2 x 9 1/2" (29.2 x 24.1 cm)
[200] 46 years oldDisplayed January 1907, Société Internationale de Peinture et Sculpture. Paris.Christ sits at the table with Mary, while Martha serves dinner. Shadowy figure in background (pentimento) speculated to be Judas (who had criticized Mary for wasting money on perfume, spread on Christ's feet.)[201] Possibly deliberate mixing of biblical stories.Christ in the home of Mary and MarthaCarnegie Museum of Art, 07.3. Oil on canvas, 51 ½ × 41 ½ in130.81 × 105.41 cm.[202]
1905-1906[203] 46–47 years oldTanner enters into the 19th Annual exhibition of American paintings at the Art Institute of Chicago.Gospel of John (20:2-6). Peter and John peering into Jesus' tomb, their faces lit by unearthly light. Highlight of Tanner's career, winning Harris Prize, top prize among top competitors.The Two Disciples at the Tomb Art Institute of Chicago, 1906.300. Oil on canvas, 51 x 41 5/8” (129.54 x 105.73 cm)
1905[204] or 1906[205] 46 or 47 years oldTanner's next major picture after The Two Disciples at the Tomb One of two entries for 1906 in the Paris Salon.[206] Wins silver (second place medal) at Paris Salon bought by French government[207] Tanner "designated hors concours" (top honor, his paintings are beyond competition). This work is painted over the top of another Tanner painting, The Cello Lesson.The Disciples at Emmaus, or The Pilgrims of Emmaus[208] Musée d‘Orsay, Paris. Oil on canvas, 73 1/2 x 83 1/2".
1905[209] 46 years oldExhibited 1905 at Chicago Art Institute. and his solo exhibition in 1908.Tanner's rendition of Abraham's Oak which traditionally marks the place where Abraham entertained three angels or where he pitched his tent.Abraham's Oak or Abraham's Oak Near HebronSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.185. Oil on canvas, 21 3/4 x 28 3/4" (54.4 x 72.8 cm).
[210] 46 years oldEntry into the 1905 Paris Salon, one of two entries[211] Displayed at the annual exhibition at the Chicago Art Institute, along with Abraham's Oak Near Hebron.The Good SamaritanLocation unknown (possibly lost).
190546 years oldearlier version of this was 1901 Paris Salon entry.Multiple versions. Original dates back to 1900 titled "Night," owned by Atherton Curtis. This version owned by Robert C. Ogden was made in 1905. A third version, Fishermen's Return dates to about 1919.[212] A fourth version Fisherman's return was made about 1926. A fifth version, Fishermen returning at night was painted about 1930.[213] [214] Return of the FishermanHerbert F. Johnson Museum of Art, Cornell University.
190546 years oldEntered in 1905 Paris Salon, (1 of two entries) won a medal.[215] Christ Washing the Feet of the Disciples.Location unknown (possibly lost)
190546 years oldThe Carnegie Institute announced it would purchase this work.[216] Judas Covenanting with the High Priests.Location unknown (possibly lost).
190748 years oldTanner was unable to enter work in the Paris Salon, due to eye-strain injury.[217]
18 June 1907[218] [219] 48 years oldPortrait of Jesse Tanner, Henry and Jessie Tanner's son. Portrait of Jesse When He Was Four Years OldOil on panel, 12.9 x 9.4 in. (33 x 24 cm.)
1907-1912[220] 48–53 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. Second of two entries in 1910 Paris Salon (along with the Three Marys.Continued recurring (started 1899) theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt.Flight Into Egypt or La fuite en EgypteCincinnati Art Museum, 2002.47. Oil on canvas. Measurements:canvas 19 1/2 x 25 3/8 in. (49.6 x 64.4 cm).
[221] 48 years oldTanner had a history of painting boats. He combined this with his religious art to illustrate a scene from the bible, the miracle of Jesus walking on water. Jesus is represented here as an indistinct presence on the water. The light is the dim of night, the moon reflecting on the water.The Disciples See Christ Walking on the WaterDes Moines Art Center, 1921.1. Oil on canvas, 51 1/2 x 42 in.
[222] 48 years oldMoonlight HebronMilwaukee Art Museum, M1920.1. Oil on canvas, 25 11/16 × 31 7/8 in. (65.25 × 80.96 cm).
Painting with man and woman walking hand-in- hand. Study for Flight to EgyptSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.44. Pencil and pastel on paper, 8 1⁄4 x 11 1⁄8 in. (21.0 x 28.2 cm)
date unknown, before 1908Peter After the Denial[223] Lost painting.

Art period including trips to Algeria (1908) and Morocco (1912)

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
[224] [225] 49 years oldPainted over three years (1906–1908). Entered in Paris Salon, May 1908.[226] [227] "Then shall the kingdom of heaven be likened unto ten virgins, which took their lamps, and went forth to meet the bridegroom. And five of them were wise, and five were foolish."Not all the wise virgins are walking...one is on the far left, her lamp on the ground, and she trying to light another's lamp.[228] The Wise and Foolish Virgins or Behold, The Bridegroom Cometh or Les vierges sages et les vierges follesLocation unknown, possibly lost. 10 ft x 15 ft. Exhibited 1908, 1909, 1921.
[229] or [230] 49 years oldMary sits sewing, her son Jesus sleeping under a halo (far left). If made 1908–09, this would have been part of Tanner's first American exposition of his religious artworks.[231] MaryWeatherspoon Art Museum, 2002.18. Oil on canvas, 31 1/2 x 25"
undatedPossibly 1908 versionTanner had paintings on this theme from 1908 to 1911, 1922–1924, and a version for sale in 1935.[232] The painting's name is on the back of the photo at the Smithsonian.The Hiding of Moses[233] Location unknown. Photo of painting in Smithsonian Archives of American Art.
[234] 49 years oldHills of JerusalemPrivate collection. Was in the Michael Rosenfeld Gallery of New York.
49 years oldRuth and NaomiLost painting.
49 years oldTanner displayed a work called Nicodemus in 1908 and 1909 at exhibitions. Photo of the artwork from a 1909 catalog for the Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition of 1909, held in Seattle.[235] NicodemusLocation unknown.
[236] 51 years oldTanner traveled to Morocco, in March–June 1912, to Algiers in 1908, to "the Near East" Oct 98-March 99, and to Palestine and Egypt with stops on the way home in Naples, Rome, Pisa, Florence, and Venice January–April 1897.Gate in TangiersHarvey B. Gantt Center for African-American Arts+Culture. Formerly owned by Vivian and John Hewitt Jr.
undated[237] Tanner traveled to Morocco, in March–June 1912, to Algiers in 1908, to "the Near East" Oct 98-March 99, and to Palestine and Egypt with stops on the way home in Naples, Rome, Pisa, Florence, and Venice January–April 1897.Gate of TangierHoward University, 65.1.P. Oil on board, 23 1/4 × 19 in. (59.1 × 48.3 cm)
49 years oldTanner went to the Near East for the third time in 1908.[238] The trip took him to Constantine, Algeria. A different version of In Constantine.Tanner used watercolors on this trip.Middle Eastern City ScapePrivate collection. Watercolor on paper, H 15 1/2", W 11".[239]
49 years oldTanner went to the Near East for the third time in 1908. The trip took him to Constantine, Algeria.Tanner used watercolors on this trip. This version hung in Fernanda and Rodman Wanamaker's apartment in Philadelphia. The picture includes a woman in western clothing (such as one might wear in Paris or New York).In ConstantinePrivate collection. Watercolor and gouache on paper, 17 3/4 X 13" (45.09 x 33.02 cm).
[240]

49 years old

Tanner went to the Near East for the third time in 1908.Entrance to the customs house in TangierMichael Rosenfeld Gallery. Oil on panel, 22 1/2 x 24 inches.
or [241] Visits Algeria in February — March 1908; visits Morocco in March — June 1912Impressionist landscape. 1908. Another version of Flight into Egypt of which Tanner painted more than 15 versions. Joseph, Mary and Jesus flee to Egypt.Flight into Egypt: Palace of Justice, Tangier[242] or Palace of Justice, Tangier.Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1970.67. Oil on canvas. 25 5/8 X 31 7/8 (65.09 x 80.96 cm)
[243] [244] Christ and the Disciples before the Last Supper or Christ with the Canonite woman and her daughter[245] Spelman College Museum of Fine Art Oil on canvas, 26 x 33 in.
49 years oldTanner went to the Near East for the third time in 1908. The trip took him to Constantine, Algeria. Tanner holds an exhibition of his religious paintings in 1908 at the American Art Gallery in New York.[246] It was his first solo exhibition after he grew famous.[247] A Jerusalem Type[248] [249] Private collection. Oil on canvas, 18 1/8 x 15 1/8 in. (46 x 38.4 cm.)
49–53 years oldVisits Algeria in February — March 1908; visits Morocco in March — June 1912Painting of woman in style of postcards from Tunisia, Morocco and Algeria. This dress-style represents European fantasy, as women were kept covered in public in North Africa as in other Muslim areas.[250] [251] unnamed image of a woman.Private collection. Watercolor and Pencil on Paper. Measure 14"in H x 7 1/2"in W and 20 1/2"in[252]
49–53 years oldVisits Algeria in February — March 1908; visits Morocco in March — June 1912Impressionist landscape. Undated. "suggestions of trees, hills, and a faintly discernible human figure."[253] Scene of AlgiersSmithsonian American Art Museum. Oil on paperboard, 8 1⁄4 x 10 5⁄8 in. (21.0 x 27.0 cm.)
[254] 53 years oldVisits Algeria in February — March 1908; visits Morocco in March — June 1912Impressionist landscape. Undated. Has elements of Flight Into Egypt: a man, woman and donkey. Algiers or Old Buildings Near Ka-hak[255] Private collection. Oil on canvas, 31 3/4 x 25 1/2 in.
undated[256] unsigned. Attributed to Tanner at auction.Mary and Mary Magdalene with Jesus, the crosses in the background, a crown of thorns by their side.Jesus Taken Down From the Cross[257] or Sorrow at the CrucifixionPrivate collection. Oil on Canvas. Size: 23 x 31 in.
[258] 50 years old"The Return of the Holy Woman," with Calvary in the distance, is even more sensitive than the rest. It is so intensely silent.Return of the Holy Woman or Return of the Holy Women or Return from the Cross[259] Location unknown.
[260] 51 years oldMary with her baby Jesus (sleeping under a halo by her feet.)MaryFormerly in Michael Rosenfeld Gallery. Oil on canvas, 28 3/4 x 23 5/8 in.
[261] 51 years oldSelf-PortraitSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.34. Pencil and conte crayon on paper, 8 1⁄2 x 8 3⁄8
1910[262] 51 years oldTanner takes photos of his wife Jessie and son Jesse in costume.makes painting from photo study. Religious work showing Jesus studying scripture with Mary.Christ and His Mother Studying the ScripturesDallas Museum of Art, 5000380. Oil and canvas; height: 123.8 cm (48.7 in); width: 101.6 cm (40 in)
[263] 50–51 years oldThe Visitation or Mary Visiting ElizabethKalamazoo Institute of Arts, 2005.11. Oil on canvas, 37 1/2 x 42 1/2 in.
[264] 50–51 years oldDivine light illuminates Mary and infant Jesus, Joseph looks from shadows. Jesus has halo, Marys veil glows. Light also comes through the doorway, from outside.[265] The Holy FamilyMuskegon Museum of Art, 1911.1. Oil on canvas, height: 88.9 cm (35 in); width: 108.5 cm (42 3/4 in)
51 years oldStill life with fruitMichael Rosenfeld Gallery.
[266] 51 years olduntitled landscape (Snowcapped Mountains Above Habitat)Hearne Fine Art. Oil on Board, framed Size: 20" x 23" x 2 1/4"
[267] 51 years oldTanner was elected president of the artists' colony Artistique de Picardie at Le Touquet in 1913. The colony centers on his summer home there.Evening scene at Le Touquet, Paris-Plage, Pas-de-Calais.Le TouquetDes Moines Art Center. Oil on canvas, 51 X 42”. or 28 3/4 x 36 1/4 in. (73 x 92.1 cm.)[268] Accession Number 1941.5
[269] [270] 51 years oldReligious work showing cloudlike angels appearing before the shepherds in the dim light of night. Angels in the image possibly include spokesman angel, angels in a choir, trumpeting angels and calvalry angels.[271] Angels Appearing before the ShepherdsSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.195. Oil and canvas; 25 3/4 x 31 7/8 in.
51 years oldReligious work showing Jesus and His Disciples on the Sea of Galilee.The Disciples on the Sea of GalileePrivate collection. Oil on artist's board, 10 x 14" (25.4 x 35.56 cm)
[272] 51 years oldReligious work showing Jesus' Disciples on the Sea of Galilee.Christ and His Disciples on the Sea of Galilee.jpgToledo Museum of Art, 1913.127. Oil on canvas, 21 7/8 X 26 1/2"
[273] 51 years oldOne of two entries in Paris Salon, 1910.[274] The second entry is Flight to Egypt.Religious work illustrating Gospel of Mark (16:1—4), showing Mary Magdalene, Mary, mother of James, and Mary Salomé (or Mary of Clopas) as they discover that the stone has been rolled away from the entrance of Christ's tomb.Three Marys or Les trois Marie approachant du tombeauCarl Van Vechten Gallery of Fine Arts, Fisk University, Nashville. Oil on canvas, 42 x 50" (106.68 x 127 cm)
Undated. [275] 51 years oldMary Washing the Feet of Christ or Mary Magdalene Washing the Feet of Christ[276] Private collection. Oil on panel, 20 x 25 cm. (7.9 x 9.8 in).[277]
[278] 51 years oldHead of ChristPrivate collection. Etching on cream laid paper, 76x44 mm; 3x1 3/4 inches
undatedprobably 1911[279]

52 years old

Tanner has a family with a young child, living in France. Possibly from that era, early 1900s-1910s.Impressionist landscape of life in Paris.The Man Who Rented BoatsSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.203. Oil on canvas mounted on plywood, 9 1⁄4 x 12 3⁄8 in. (23.5 x 31.4 cm.)
[280] 53 years oldReturn at night from the marketClark Atlanta University Art Collection, GA, X.041. Oil on canvas, 25 3/4 x 20 5/8
[281] 53 years oldWork that was in private collection, sold in October 2000 at auction for $560,000. At the time, it was a record for Tanner's paintings.[282] Unidentified painting attributed at auction to Henry Ossawa Tanner.[283] Jesus sits at an "altar table", surrounded by "shrouded women", a chalice in his hand, a crown of thorns on his head.untitledPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 54 x 79 in.
[284] 53 years oldTanner painted himself into the painting (far right beside the sitting woman.)[285] Both of the women in the painting were also portraits of people Tanner knew.[286] Newspaper photo of painting, Boston Evening Transcript, Jun 24, 1914[287] The painting was exhibited in 1913 in Chicago and New York, was a Paris Salon entry for 1914, and in 1915 won a gold medal at the Panama-Pacific Exposition in San Francisco.[288] Later displayed at the Carnegie Institute (1921), a solo exhibition at the Des Moines, Association of Fine Arts (1921), a solo exhibition at Grand Central Art Galleries, New York (1924), and at the Chicago Art Institute in 1928.Christ in the Home of LazarusLocation unknown (possibly lost).[289]
undatedTanner painted Atherton Curtis and his wife into this version.[290] Photo of painting from page 190 of Henry Ossawa Tanner, edited by Dewey F. Mosby.Christ in the Home of LazarusLocation unknown (possibly lost). The painting Portrait of Mr. Atherton Curtis and his Wife was rumored to be the remains of this painting, cut down to just the portrait.[291]
undated[292] Tanner meets Atherton and Louise Curtis in 1897; Tanner and Jessie go to live in the Curtis' artist colony in 1902. Lifelong friendship.[293]
[294] 53 years oldCoastal Landscape, FranceMichael Rosenfeld Gallery. Oil on gessoed panel, 9.25" x 13"
1912[295] A View of FezHigh Museum of Art, 2003.91. Oil on panel, 9 in (22.8 cm); width: 12.5 in (31.7 cm)
[296] 53 years oldVisits Morocco in March–June 1912Moonrise by Casbah or Morocco[297] Private collection. Oil on linen canvas, 1912. 540x724 mm; 21 1/2x28 1/2 inches.
[298] 53 years oldVisits Morocco in March–June 1912Moonrise, TangierRuth and Elmer Wellin Museum of Art, Hamilton College. Oil on plywood, 19½ x 23½ in. (49.5 x 59.7 cm)
[299] 50 years oldVisits Morocco in March–June 1912Street Scene, Tangier (Crenelated Architecture)Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.196B. Oil on paperboard, 10 5⁄8 x 13 3⁄4 in. (27.0 x 34.9 cm.)
[300] 53 years oldVisits Morocco in March–June 1912Near East Scene or Mosque in TangierDes Moines Art Center. Oil and casein on canvas, 28 3/4 X 23 '/2" (73.03 x 59.69 cm).
[301] 53 years oldVisits Morocco in March–June 1912Moroccan Man [302] Private collection. Oil on panel, 13 x 9 1/4 in.
Undated.Tanner traveled to Morocco, in March–June 1912, to Algiers in 1908.Image with horseshoe arch or keyhole arch. Light from low sun; light bounces from building-top to make line of light on ground; building-reflected light casts man's shadow.untitled[303] Private collection. Oil on wood panel, 6 x 9 in.
53–55 years oldVisits Morocco in March–June 1912Sunlight, TangierMilwaukee Art Museum. Oil on cardboard panel, 10 3/4 X 13 3/4" (27.31 x 34.93 cm).
53 years oldVisits Morocco in March — June 1912Paints the entrance to the Casbah or the historic city area and fortress many times.[304] Gateway, TangierSt. Louis Museum of Art, 33:2005. Oil on canvas, 18 7/16 × 15 5/16 in. (46.8 × 38.9 cm).
[305] 53 years oldVisits Morocco in March — June 1912"[Tanner] made numerous small oil sketches that he brought back to his studio in France, where he developed them into larger paintings on canvas..."Doorway in TangierPhiladelphia Museum of Art, 2004–117–1. Oil on canvas 14 × 10 3/4 inches (35.6 × 27.3 cm)
[306] or 51 or 53 years oldVisits Morocco in March — June 1912Entrance to the Casbah[307] Gateway, TangierSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.190. oil on plywood, 22 1⁄2 x 19 in. (57.2 x 48.3 cm.)
53 years oldVisits Morocco in March — June 1912Street Scene, Tangier or Man Leading a Donkey in Front of the Palaise de Justice, Tangier or Man Leading a Calf[308] Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.196A. Oil on paperboard, 10 5⁄8 x 13 3⁄4 in. (27.0 x 34.9 cm.)[309]
[310] 51 years oldVisits MoroccoStreet in TangierSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.209. Oil on fiberboard, 13 5⁄8 x 10 1⁄2 in. (34.5 x 26.7 cm)
[311] [312] 53 years oldSpends time in Morocco, in the city of Tangiers in March–June.Street Scene, TangiersMuseum of Fine Arts, Boston, 2011.1840. Oil on panel, 19 1/4 x 23 1/2 in. (48.9 x 59.7 cm).
1912[313] 53 years oldSpends time in Morocco, in the city of Tangiers in March–June.Entrance to the CasbahArt Museum of Greater Lafayette. Oil on paper mounted on canvas,32 x 26 in. (81.2 cm x 67.3 cm.)
[314] 53 years oldSpends time in Morocco, in the city of Tangiers in March–June 1912.Midday, TangiersCummer Museum. Oil on canvas, 24 ⅛ x 20 in.
53 years oldSpends time in Morocco, in the city of Tangiers in March–June 1912.Woman in traditional clothing, carrying water pitcher, in front of entrance to Casbah, Tangiers.Untitled.[315] Private collection. Gouache on paper, H 13 1/2" W 10 1/2"
[316] 54 years oldSpends time in Morocco, in the city of Tangiers in March–June 1912.Moonlight: Walls of TangiersLos Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA), 48.32.46. Oil on canvas 25 7/8 x 21 1/4 in. (65.72 x 54.1 cm)
undatedPossibly

54 years old

Attributed to Tanner online.[317] untitled, Muslim man with horse. Possibly the work exhibited in 1913 under the title The Sultan's Stables.[318] Private collection.

Years 1913-1918, World War I

1914 was the year that Tanner returned to the Paris Salon after "several years of absence," bringing his 1912 painting Christ in the House of Lazarus and Mary.[287] He had remarked in 1910 "that he would not exhibit in the salon again as they had stuck his picture into a corner which everyone knows is almost an insult."[319] French artists were upset over a U.S. tariff on their paintings, and said to be taking revenge in the Salon.[319]

He did not exhibit at the Salon in 1907, due to eye strain, but in 1908 entered The Wise and Foolish Virgins which he worked on in 1906, 1907 and finished in 1908. Newspapers don't record a Salon entry for 1909; but he focused his 1908 energy on a one-man exhibition of his artwork in New York, and the 1909 papers continued to talk about that event. Tanner may have avoided displaying at the Salon 1910, 1911, 1912, and 1913.[287] [319]

He began to display there again in 1914; however, that year marked the beginning of World War I, which further disrupted both his painting and his display at the Salon. Also in 1914, his mother died.

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
[320] [321] 54–55 years oldTanner painted the Miraculous catch of fish, in which Jesus tells the disciples to try one more cast of the net, at which they are rewarded with a great catch.The Miraculous Haul of FishesNational Academy of Design. Oil on canvas, 38 × 47 1/2 in.
[322] [323] 54 years oldFishermen at SeaGiven by Jesse O. Tanner (Henry's son) to Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.215. Oil on canvas, 46 x 35 1/4 in. (116.9 cm x 89.5 cm.)
54 years oldLandscape in MoonlightHampton University Museum.[324]
[325] 55 years old1914 was the year his mother died, World War I broke out, and it wasn't safe for his family in France. They left for England.Mary was one of two Salon entries for 1914, along with Christ in the Home of Lazarus.[326] MarySmithsonian American Art Museum, 1991.102. Oil on canvas, 45 1⁄2 x 34 3⁄4 in. (115.5 x 88.2 cm.)
[327] 55 years oldTanner began using a "new pallet of colors and a freer technique." In Impressionist tradition, a study of light on a still scene.LandscapeSheldon Ross Gallery, Birmingham, Michigan. Oil on artist's board, 10 x 13" (25.4 x 33.2 cm.)
1914[328] 55 years oldMoonlight PathPrivate collection. Oil on board, 6 1/4 by 6 3/4 in (16 by 17.2 cm.)
1910-191451–54 years oldAbout 1910 Tanner takes photo study of wife Jessie and son Jesseby about 1914 has made paintings from photo studyChrist Learning to ReadDes Moines Art Center. Oil on canvas, 52 x 41” (132.08 x 104.14 cm)
1914[329] 55 years oldWorld War I breaks out. Henry takes his wife Jessie and son Jesse to England to escape the violence. They enroll Jesse in school there.Portrait of Jesse Tanner, son of Henry Ossawa Tanner and Jessie M. Tanner. Dated March 1914, bottom left corner.Portrait of Jesse TannerPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 46 x 38 cm.
[330] 55 years oldWorld War I broke out. Tanner's mother died in August 1914. He had difficulty painting."Tanner painted very few works between late 1914 and the latter part of 1918" This is one of very few paintings made in the "early years of the war."War Scene, Etaples, France, a studyClark Atlanta University Collection of Afro-American Art. Oil on cardboard, 143/4 x 18"(37.47 x 45.72 cm)
[331] 57–63 years oldAfter Tanner took a second trip to the Holy Land in 1898-99 he began using a recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt. Tanner might have thought of Christian metaphor for the painting: even in darkness, the path [to God] is visible.[332] Flight Into EgyptSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.202. Oil on wood, 16 7/8 x 16 7/8 in. (43.0 x 43.0 cm)
[333] [334] [335] 58 years oldOne of several paintings titled The Good Shepherd, "based generally on the Gospel of John (10:14—16)" and the 23rd Psalm. "I am the good shepherd, and know my sheep, and am known of mine. As the Father knoweth me, even so know I the Father: and I lay down my life for the sheep. And other sheep I have, which are not of this fold: them also I must bring, and they shall hear my voice; and there shall be one fold, and one shepherd." — Gospel of John (10:14—16)

"The Lord is my Shepherd; I shall not want." — 23rd Psalm

The Good ShepherdNew Orleans Museum of Art, 30.3. Oil on canvas, 29/4 X 33 1/4" (74.3 x 84.46 cm)
date unknown, before 1931One of the four paintings photographed by the Harmon Foundation, exhibited by them in 1931.[336] The Good Shepherd
1916[337] or [338] 57 years oldFisherman's Devotions, ÉtaplesPrivate collection. Oil on panel, height: 33 cm (12.9 in); width: 22.9 cm (9 in).
[339] 57 years oldOne of the four paintings photographed by the Harmon Foundation, exhibited by them in 1931.[340] Flight Into EgyptSmithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture, 2015.2.3. Oil on wood panel, H x W: 16 5/8 × 22 in. (42.2 × 55.9 cm).
1917[341] 58 years oldThe Good ShepherdCrystal Bridges Museum of American Art, 2019.5. Oil on canvas, height: 64.8 cm (25.5 in) Edit this at Wikidata; width: 81.3 cm (32 in)
191758 years oldThe Study for Shepherd With Herd was estimated as made in 1917.[342] The final painting is undated.[343] Study for Shepherd With Herd or The Good ShepherdPrivate collection. Oil on wood panel, circa 1917. 210x273 mm; 8 1/4x10 3/4 inches.
undated[344] LandscapeNorth Carolina Museum of Art, G.77.4.1. Oil on cardboard, 13 5/16 x 10 1/8 in. (33.8 x 25.7 cm)
1917[345] 58 years oldprobably from photo and personal memory, painted after deathPortrait commissioned by the Iowa Federation of Colored Women's Clubs, through J. S. Carpenter. Portrait of Booker T. WashingtonState Historical Society of Iowa. Oil on canvas, 313/4 X 25 5/8” (80.65 x 65.09 cm).
[346] 57–58 years oldStudy of an American SoldierTelfair Museums, 1979.20.4. Hard charcoal and lead pencil on paper, 16 7/8 × 13 5/8 inches (42.9 × 34.6 cm)
1918[347] 59 years oldTanner served with the Red Cross during part of World War I. Domremy, birthplace of Joan of Arc. Soldiers visible, identifiable by their helmets.House of Joan of Arc or DomrémyPrivate collection. Oil on wood panel, height: 20 x 24 in. (50.8 x 60.9 cm.)
191859 years oldTanner served with the Red Cross during part of World War I. "American Red Cross Canteen, Toul, France, World War I" American Red Cross, Washington D.C. Oil on canvas, 143/16 X 16 5/16" (36.04 x 41.43 cm).
191859 years oldTanner served with the Red Cross during part of World War I. "American Red Cross Canteen at the Front" American Red Cross, Washington D.C. Oil on canvas, 48 X 61”.
191859 years oldTanner served with the Red Cross during part of World War I. "Intersection of Roads at Neufchateau, World War I" American Red Cross, Washington D.C. Oil on canvas, 25 5/8 X 31 7/8" (65.09 x 80.96 cm).
191858 years oldTanner painted this at about the time he did the Red Cross paintings. Neufchateau or Old House, Neufchateau, VosgesPrivate collection. Displayed by Museum of Fine Arts, Houston, EX.2008.HC.010. Oil on canvas, 28 x 32 in.[348]
[349] [350] 59 years oldÉtaples and the Canche River at Duskor untitled (Dusk Scene of a Flooded River and Nearby Town)Hood Museum of Art, Dartmouth. Oil on paperboard, 10 3/4 × 13 7/8 in. (27.3 × 35.2 cm)formerly Michael Rosenfeld Gallery
[351] 59 years oldThe good shepherdNational Gallery of Art, 2014.136.159. Oil on canvas on particle board, 60.33 × 48.26 cm (23 3/4 × 19 in.) Formerly in the Evans-Tibbs collection.
1919[352] 60 years oldTanner's son Jesse was about 16 years old in 1919.Portrait of Jesse Ossawa TannerPrivate collection. Charcoal on paper, 48 x 30 cm - 18.8 x 11.8 in.
undated[353] possibly Tanner's son Jesse was about 16 years old in 1919.Portrait of Jesse Tanner in profile, the artist's sonPrivate collection. Oil on paper, 9 3/8 x 11 in.
1919[354] [355] 60 years oldWorld War I ended November 11, 1918.The painting has a date which looks like July 13, 1914. However, it is for the "Celebration of the Dead, held on July 13, 1919, in Paris to honor those who died defending France during World War I." With the war over, Tanner could return to his chosen work.The Arch or The Arch of TriumphBrooklyn Museum, 32.10. Oil on canvas, 39 1/4 x 38 3/16 in. (99.7 x 97 cm)

After the war until death, 1919-1937

DateTanner's approximate ageEvents of Tanner's lifeDescriptionArtwork nameDetailsPicture
undated per museum1919 per note60 years oldTanner wrote a note in painting's crossbar, executing work in 1917, retouching and completing it in July 1919.Multiple versions. Original dates back to 1900 titled "Night," (lost) owned by Atherton Curtis. A second version owned by Robert C. Ogden Return of the Fisherman was made in 1905. This third version dates to about 1919. A fourth version Fisherman's return was made about 1926. A fifth version, Fishermen returning at night was painted about 1930. The Fisherman's Return[356] Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.212. Oil on canvas, 25 1⁄2 x 19 1⁄4 in. (64.8 x 49.0 cm.)
[357] Landscape of the countryside near Nice, FranceCountryside Around Nice, FrancePrivate collection. Oil on plywood, 165x189 mm; 6 1/2x7 3/4 inches
Undated[358] Stamped in the lower right corner with the contact information of Henry's son Jesse. Likely French countryside as Tanner had painted other French countryside scenes in this manner.untitledSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.188B. Oil on wood panel, 9 1/2 x 13 in. (24.0 x 33.0 cm.)
[359] 61–65 years oldFleeing Sodom and Gomorrha; the woman who looks back (Lot's wife) turns into a pillar of salt.Sodom and GomorrhaFormerly in the Michael Rosenfeld Gallery, New York City. Oil on canvas, 41 1/2 x 36 1/2 in. (104.4 x 92 cm.)
Undated.One of the four paintings photographed by the Harmon Foundation, exhibited by them in 1931.[360] Sodom and Gomorrah[361] Private collection.
1920s[362] Tanner painted Jesus' appearance his dispicles on the Road to Emmaus. The disciples met Christ on the road and invited him to eat with them. Tanner painted a moment before the disciples recognized him.[363] Invitation to Christ to Enter by his Disciples at EmmausPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 19 ½ x 23 1/8 in. (49.5 x 58.7 cm.)
1920-1925[364] 61–66 years oldRecurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt (started theme about 1899).Flight Into EgyptPrivate collection. Was held by Michael Rose Fine Art; oil on linen canvas, circa 1920-25 23 1/4 x 37 inches, 590 x 952 mm.
192162 years oldAfter Tanner took a second trip to the Holy Land in 1898-99 he began using a recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for EgyptFlight Into EgyptMuseum of Fine Arts Houston, 50.10. Oil on panel, 20 × 24 in. (50.8 × 61.0 cm)
1921[365] 62 years oldAt least 2 versions were made around the theme of Moses' mother hiding him in the bullrushes. The first made galleries from 1908 to 1911, the latter from 1922 to 1924.[366] Moses in the Bullrushes or The Hiding of MosesSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.197. Oil on wood panel, 22 3⁄8 x 15 1⁄8 in. (56.8 x 38.5 cm)
1922[367] 63 years oldThe version at the Newark museum shows a shepard caring for his lost sheep, "a theme based on Matthew's account (18:12—14).""How think ye? if a man have an hundred sheep, and one of them be gone astray, doth he not leave the ninety and nine, and goeth into the mountains, and seeketh that which is gone astray? And if so be that he find it, verily I say unto you, he rejoiceth more of that sheep, than of the ninety and nine which went not astray. Even so it is not the will of your Father which is in heaven, that one of these little ones should perish. —Matthew (18:12—14)The Good Shepherd or The Lost SheepThe Newark Museum. Oil on canvas, 32 x 24” (81.28 x 60.96 cm)
[368] 63 years oldVirgin and ChildWadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art, Hartford. Oil on canvas 32 x 25" (81.28 x 63.5 cm)
undated[369] Tanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. Began recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt.Recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt. Study dated 1916–1922.Flight into EgyptOil on artist board, 17 1/2 x 20 1/2
192364 years oldRecurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt. Here, Mary (carrying Jesus) and Joseph quietly follow the guard (carrying the light).[370] Flight Into Egypt or The Futile GuardMetropolitan Museum of Art, 2001.402a.[371] Oil on canvas, 29 x 26 in. (73.7 x 66 cm)
1923[372] 64 years oldThe Sleeping Disciplesor Christ in the Garden of GethsemanePrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 28 x 23" (71.12 x 58.42)
1923[373] [374] 64 years oldTanner receives the Walter Leighton Clark prize for this painting in 1930.[375] Painting has 1923 date in lower right corner. Formerly owned by J. J. Haverty.Etaples Fisher FolkHigh Museum of Art, 36.16. Tempera and oil on canvas, 47 5/16 x 38 5/16 inches.
1923[376] 64 years oldTanner began reinterpreting the story of Jesus and Nicodemus, which he painted in 1899. This is a study for Nicodemus Visiting Jesus (1927)Christ and Nicodemus (early study)Private collection. Oil on thick cardstock, circa 1923. 267x345 mm; 10 1/2x13 5/8 inches.
1927[377] 68 years oldCommissioned 1924, finished 1927.[378] Tanner began reinterpreting the story of Jesus and Nicodemus, which he painted in 1899. The latter is Nicodemus Visiting Jesus (1927)Nicodemus Visiting Jesus or Nicodemus Coming to Christ or Nicodemus Before ChristPrivate collection. Oil on canvas laid down on board, 61 1/4 x 71 in. (155.6 x 180.3 mm)
1924[379] 65 years old(John 20:4—6): John kneels at Jesus' tomb, Peter in the background. Tanner painted this over the circa 1899 painting Judas. Displayed October 1925 at 24th Carnegie Institute International Exhibition.[380] This work was painted over the top of the 1899 painting Judas.Two disciples at the tombMichael Rosenfeld Gallery. Oil on board 51 1/2 X 43 1/4" (130.81 x 109.86 cm)
1925[381] 66 years oldThree wise men on their camels, traveling to see Jesus at Christmas.[382] The Three Wise MenPrivate collection. Oil on canvas, 25 x 35 in. (63.5 X 88.9 cm)
1926-1927[383] 67–68 years oldTanner took a second trip to the Holy Land, in 1898–99. Began recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt.Bought originally by James Joseph Haverty, along with The Road to EmmausAt the Gates
or Flight Into Egypt.
See: 1899 version.
Oil on panel, circa 1926–27. 610x483 mm; 24x19 inches
undated[384] Recurring theme of Joseph and Mary fleeing for Egypt (began about 1899).Departure Into Egypt or At the InnSmithsonian American Art Museum. Oil on wood, 21 3⁄8 x 18 1⁄4 in. (54.4 x 46.4 cm)
1926[385] 67 years oldMultiple versions. Original dates back to 1900 titled "Night," (lost) owned by Atherton Curtis. A second version owned by Robert C. Ogden Return of the Fisherman was made in 1905. A third version The Fishermen's Return was painted about 1919. This fourth version was made about 1926. A fifth version, Fishermen returning at night was painted about 1930.Fishermen's ReturnHarmon and Harriet Kelley Foundation for the Arts. Oil on canvas, 25 3/16 x 19 5/8 in.
[386] 68 years oldExhibited Art Institute of Chicago, 1927.The Poor Ye Have With You AlwaysPrivate collection. Oil on canvas.
[387] untitled (Moonlight Landscape)DuSable Museum of African American History, Chicago.
1929-1930[388] [389] 70–71 years oldThe two cities of Sodom and Gomorrah are engulfed in God's wrath. "The painting's abstraction and simplicity of form evoke a sense of interaction between the physical and spiritual worlds." In this version, Lot and his daughters are nearly invisible, at the lower right.Formerly owned by J. J. Haverty.Destruction of Sodom and GomorrahHigh Museum of Art, 49.32. Tempera and varnish on cardboard, 20 3/8 x 36 in.
[390] 71 years oldHand of Henry O. TannerSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.35. Conte crayon on paper, 10 5⁄8 x 14 in. (27.0 x 35.5 cm)
71 years oldThe Lost Sheep or The Good ShepherdMenil Collection, Houston. Oil and tempera on paperboard. 10 5/8 x 8 1/8" (26.99 x 20.64 cm)
193071 years oldTanner painted the theme of The Good Shepherd more than 15 times.[391] The Good Shephard[392] Private collection. Tempera and oil glazes on canvas, 91,4 x 76,2 cm (36 x 30 in)[393]
undated[394] Countryside Landscape or Paysage de CampagnePrivate collection.
undated[395] Landscape of a Middle-Eastern/North African city, with domes and minarets. Could date from 1897 to 1912 if from the period he visited Middle East, or later if painting from memory.Distant View of a CityPrivate collection. Oil on canvas laid on masonite, 21 x 16 1/2 in (53.3 x 41.9 cm)
[396] [397] or [398] 71 or 77 years oldTanner painted the theme of The Good Shepherd more than 15 times. He painted this at Etaples, Paris, 43 Rue de Fleurus, 6.The Good Shephard (Atlas Mountains, Morocco)Smithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.198. Oil on canvas (or fiberboard), 29 7⁄8 x 36 in. (75.8 x 91.3 cm)
[399] 71 years oldHe Healed the SickSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.199. Oil on panel, 16 1/4 x 21 1/2 in. (41.3 x 54.5 cm).
[400] 71 years oldHe Healed the SickPrivate collection. Oil on board 9 1/4 by 13 inches (23.5 by 33 cm)
[401] 71 years oldLandscape of French countrysideHaystacksSmithsonian American Art Museum, 1983.95.214. Oil on canvas, 26 1/4 x 21 in. (66.7 x 53.3 cm.)
undated[402] Landscape of trees bending in the wind. French name at gallery, probably painted in France.Arbres Sous Le VentBill Hodges Gallery. Oil on Panel 10 ⅜ x 13 ¾ in. (26.35 x 34.9 cm)
by 1935[403] Tanner painted the theme of Flight into Egypt more than 15 times.Flight into EgyptPrivate collection. Oil on panel, 24 x 28 in. (60.96 x 71.12 cm.)
(?)[404] Study for Mary, Return from the CrucifixionPrivate collection.
[405] 75–76 years oldMary and Joseph, after Jesus is crucified.Return from the CrossColby College Museum of Art.[406] Oil and tempura on board, 39 7/8 x 29 7/8 in. (101.3 x 75.9 cm)
1936[407] 77 years oldMary and Joseph, fleeing with Jesus for EgyptFlight into EgyptHoward University, 50.5.P. Oil on board, 19 × 23 1/2 in. (48.3 × 59.7 cm)
1936[408] 77 years oldTanner's final completed and signed painting. He passes away on 25 May 1936.Mary and Joseph in foreground, after Jesus is crucified.Return from the CrucifixionHoward University Gallery of Art. Oil and tempura on plywood, 20 x 23 1/2 in.

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Henry Ossawa Tanner: Race, Religion, and Visual Mysticism . Baker . Kelly Jeannette . 10 September 2003 . Florida State University . 14, 21-22 . Benjamin-Constant and Laurens were both widely known for their genre, historical, and biblical scenes, which relied on the realism and “sharp” colors of “French academic painting.” These two artists as well as Thomas Eakins likely influenced Tanner's artistic style that initially relied on realism... the artist painted black genre paintings... genre scenes of Brittany peasants.
  2. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 20–21, 59, 90. 93.
  3. Thomas Hovenden: American Painter of Hearth and Homeland. Michael . Schantz . October–November 2005 . American Art Review . [note: reprinted in Resource Library on April 22, 2009, with permission of the author and the Woodmere Art Museum, which was granted to TFAO on April 1, 2009] . https://web.archive.org/web/20110616203009/https://tfaoi.org/aa/8aa/8aa547.htm . 16 June 2011.
  4. Web site: Smithsonian Archives of American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner papers, 1860s-1978, bulk 1890-1937 311: Photographs of Artwork, circa 1920s . [note: image download number 54] To my dear Henry Tanner Charles H. Pepper Paris '99.
  5. Web site: Smithsonian Archives of American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner papers, 1860s-1978, bulk 1890-1937: Henry Tanner and family dining outdoors, 1907 or 1908 . [note: image download numbers 1 and 2] Jesse Tanner, Mrs. Tanner, Barlow, Henry Tanner.
  6. Book: Mathews, Marcia M . Henry Ossawa Tanner, American artist . 1969 . University of Chicago Press . Chicago . 12.
  7. Web site: wahooart.com . "Barnyard Fowl, (painting)".
  8. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner, American artist . Mathews, Marcia M . 1969 . University of Chicago Press . Chicago . 13–14 .
  9. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 64–67.
  10. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner, American artist . Mathews, Marcia M . 1969 . University of Chicago Press . Chicago . 15 .
  11. News: Philadelphia Tribune . Some art has a story to tell . Kriston Capps . 19 June 2022. Rae Alexander-Minter, grandniece of the great 19th-century realist painter Henry Ossawa Tanner...An original oil painting, “Seascape — Jetty” (circa 1876-79), hangs in Alexander-Minter's living room, an example of Tanner's idyllic landscapes.
  12. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 68–69.
  13. Book: McElroy, Guy C . African-American artists, 1880-1987: selections from the Evans-Tibbs Collection . University of Washington Press . Seattle . 1989 . 1: The Foundations for Change 1880-1920 . 22–31 . https://archive.org/details/africanamericana0000mcel/page/22/mode/2up.
  14. Web site: Telfair Museums . Untitled ARTISTHenry Ossawa Tanner (American, 1859 - 1937) .
  15. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 169.
  16. The World's Work . Story of an artist's life I. . Tanner . Henry Ossawa. July 1909 . 18 . 3 . 11665. While a flock of sheep is the personification of peace, docility, and all that is quietude, from my (unscientific) study, I have come to the conclusion that one sheep has none of the qualities of a flock of sheep, no, not one, except, it may be, their stupidity. One sheep is not “sheepish”; no, he is the most stubborn, balky, run-away, befuddled animal you can imagine. I have had other animals to serve as models, but never an animal that furnished so many alarms by day and night as that “peaceful” sheep. He was escaping from his stable (stable, by courtesy), breaking his tether, trespassing in neighbors’ gardens, and eating down the very things they prized the most; or he was the very contradiction of all activity, refusing to be led to pasture and causing a giggling crowd to collect as if by magic. To the question of those on the outside who could not see what was going on, it was: “Oh! it's Henry Tanner's sheep.”.
  17. Web site: Sale 2581 - Lot 1 Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) Head of a Sheep . Swann Auction Galleries.
  18. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 170.
  19. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 171.
  20. Web site: Family Search . Sarah Elizabeth Tanner. Sarah Elizabeth Tanner 24 June 1873 – 29 October 1901.
  21. Continent; an illustrated weekly magazine . Albion W. Tourgée . Our Continent Publishing Company . Philadelphia . 233–235 . 30 August 1882 . In the Days of Witchcraft . Louise Stockton . [note:]The magazine story was written by the "author of Dorothea," which it doesn't name. That person was Louise Stockton. .
  22. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . 76–79. Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9.
  23. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Art, Faith, Race, and Legacy . Naurice Frank Woods Jr. . Taylor & Francis . 2017 . 9781315279480 .
  24. Book: A history of African-American artists : from 1792 to the present . Bearden, Romare . Henderson, Harry (Harry Brinton) . 1993 . New York . 84. Pantheon Books. 9780394570167 .
  25. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner American, 1859-1937 Untitled (Shepherdess), c. 1885 . Dolan Maxwell .
  26. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 172.
  27. Web site: White House Historical Association . Treasures of the White House: Sand Dunes at Sunset, Atlantic City 995.1759.1 .
  28. News: Philaladelphia Inquirer . A Landmark's Future . Russ . Valerie . 17 November 2022 . The painting of wind-whipped dunes under a hazy sunset hangs today in the Green Room at the White House. It was the first painting by a Black artist to be part of the White House's permanent collection. .
  29. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . 80–82. Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9.
  30. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . 71–73. Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9 . he began a historical scene of Androcles and the lion (see cat. no. 12). Tanner abandoned it as beyond his talent, and apparently returned to simpler presentations such as Lion Licking Its Paw.
  31. Web site: Allentown Art Museum . Lion Licking Paw .
  32. Web site: Wynkoop House, Old Haarlem . New Britain Museum of American Art.
  33. Web site: New Britain Museum of American Art . Basic Detail Report: Wynkoop House, Old Haarlem . Recent research, however, has demonstrated that subjects such as “Wynkoop House” were important to the core of Tanner's symbolic civil-rights messages...Tanner emphasized the tree in the foreground of “Wynkoop House”....
  34. Further Notes on Henry Wynkoop . Buck's County Historical Society . Buck's County Historical Society Journal . Fall 1976 . Geyer . Virginia B . With the help of several slaves, Wynkoop produced the finest champagne and cider in his cellars, the cider finding a ready market in Philadelphia. Without the help of slaves during Wynkoop's many absences, a farm as large as Vredens Berg would have been difficult to operate. He treated his slaves so well that although he gave them their freedom, most of them remained on the farm, and according to legend were buried under a tree near the Vredens Berg mansion..
  35. News: Phillyburbs.com . LaVO: The story of Bucks County Judge Henry Wynkoop, the 'good tall judge' and key figure in American Revolution . LaVO . Carl . 15 February 2021 . Wynkoop freed his nine slaves at his death on March 25, 1816. That was 36 years after Pennsylvania abolished slavery by freezing the slave population and giving slave holders a grace period to free captives — a process called manumission. Wynkoop's thoughts on the matter are unknown. His freed slaves remained with the family..
  36. Web site: Hearne Fine Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner .
  37. Web site: Swann Auction Galleries . Sale 2359 - Lot 1 Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) It Must Be My Very Star, Come Down to Brooklyn, After All..
  38. Web site: Baltimore Museum of Art . Joachim Leaving the Temple .
  39. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 176.
  40. The World's Work . Story of an artist's life I. . Tanner . Henry Ossawa. July 1909 . 18 . 3 . 11666. I at last secured an order to photograph a small cottage, and in twenty-four hours I had the money in my “inside pocket.” I made photos of the whole immediate region, a most lovely country, and, as no photographer had ever visited it before, they were a success, and my hard times — very hard times — vanished as the mountain mists before the sun..
  41. A Missing Question Mark, The Unknown Henry Ossawa Tanner . Will South . Nineteenth-Century Arwork Worldwide . 8 . 2 . Autumn 2009. Fig. 3. Henry Ossawa Tanner, Mountain Landscape, Highlands, North Carolina (Cumberland Foothills).
  42. Web site: Doris Ulman Galleries . Mountain Landscape, Highlands, North Carolina. 30 June 2014.
  43. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 178.
  44. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 179.
  45. Web site: Charleston Renaissance Gallery . Waterfall, North Carolina, c. 1889 .
  46. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 177.
  47. Web site: WikiArt . Untitled Landscape .
  48. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 39, 126.
  49. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 180.
  50. Web site: invaluable.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 297: Henry Ossawa Tanner, American, 1859-1937, Landscape with Figures, 9" x 13", oil on canvas .
  51. The World's Work . Story of an artist's life I. . Tanner . Henry Ossawa. July 1909 . 18 . 3 . 11666.
  52. The World's Work . Story of an artist's life II. Recognition . Tanner . Henry Ossawa. July 1909 . 18 . 3 . 11770. As I now look back, it seems curious to me that I should have been able to arrive at thirty years of age with two years of that time in Paris and never to have heard of the Salon or, having heard of it, not to have at all realized its importance in the Art world... What a surprise awaited me in the court of that old palais! Hundreds of statues that appeared to me nearly all of them fairer than the “Venus de Milo” and upstairs the paintings — thousands of them — and nearly all of them much more to my taste than were the old masters of the Louvre... Here was something to work for, to get a picture here. This now furnished a definite impetus to my work in Paris — to be able to make a picture that should be admitted here — could I do it?.
  53. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 102–103.
  54. News: The Island Packet . Hilton Head Island, South Carolina . Art Collection Found in Schools. 8 July 2004 . 6 .
  55. Web site: Past Auctin . Behold! The Lamb of God (1891) . Artnet.com .
  56. Web site: 1stDibs.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner DANIEL IN THE LIONS' DEN BY HENRY OSSAWA TANNER after Briton Riviere.
  57. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner Daniel in the Lions' Den.
  58. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 41: Henry Ossawa Tanner, (American, 1859-1937), Woman from the French West Indies, c. 1891. The artist arrived in Paris, France at this time and spent the summers on the west coast in Brittany. There, he adopted a predominately green palette with an emphasis on vertical brushstrokes as can be seen in the Woman from the French West Indies...we are looking at an image of a light-skinned woman from one of the islands of the French West Indies-Martinique, Guadeloupe or Dominica. This claim is supported by her costume and headdress. .
  59. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Street Scene, Paris, ca. 1890 . artsy.net .
  60. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Street Scene, Paris, c. 1890s . Colby College Museum of Art.
  61. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 104–105.
  62. News: La Gazette Drouot . Henry Tanner, un Américain en Bretagne . 24 May 2023 . Caroline . Legrand .
  63. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 98–101 . students learned to analyze and observe form and light by working from professional models..
  64. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 182.
  65. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Portrait of a Young Girl .
  66. Web site: Proantic.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner (Pittsburgh 1859 - 1937) - Etude d'Un Homme Barbu . Henry Ossawa Tanner (Pittsburgh 1859 - 1937) - Study Of A Bearded Man . fr.
  67. Book: Mosby, Dewey F. . Henry Ossawa Tanner . 1991 . 38, 90. Tanner began studies in 1893 for another picture of Breton life, The Young Sabot Maker... in the first part of 1893, Henry came down with typhoid fever... [quoting Tanner:] 'When I was well enough to travel, I returned to Philadelphia for a convalescence'... .
  68. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 183.
  69. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 39, 90, 110–113.
  70. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 106–107.
  71. Web site: Live Auctions . Henry O. Tanner, N.A. (US/French, 1859-1937) . Feeding Chickens, African-American Township, Philadelphia Pennsylvania" is an historically significant and rare African American scene by Tanner to be offered at auction..
  72. Web site: Winter Estates Auction: December 4-6, 2015 . 19 November 2015 . Published on Nov 19, 2015, page 279, [Item] 1187 Henry Ossawa Tanner, N.A. (American French, 1859-1937), "Feeding Chickens, African-American Township-Philadelphia, Pennsylvania", ca. 1890s, oil on canvas, abraded signature and date lower left, 14" x 24"..
  73. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 184.
  74. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 35.
  75. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 36.
  76. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 38.
  77. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 39.
  78. Web site: Untitled Henry Ossawa Tanner 1894 . artsandculture.google.com .
  79. News: Art Notes . The Philadelphia Inquirer . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 23 September 1894 . 12. H. O. Tanner, the colored artist of this city, whose picture, "The Bagpipe Lesson," was exhibited at the Academy during the last exhibition, sailed for Paris yesterday. He expects to remain abroad about three years..
  80. News: Art Notes . The Philadelphia Inquirer . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 29 April 1894 . 11. Mr. Tanner has just sent his "Banjo Lesson" which was exhibited at Earles' some time ago, to the Paris Salon. He will go to Paris himself some time in the fall, and will remain there two or three years..
  81. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 116–120.
  82. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 116–120 . Especially in the background, the brushwork of The Banjo Lesson is much looser, and strokes of color are more assertive ... Tanner used this technique in two other large figure pieces (cat. nos. 28 [''The Thankful Poor''], 29 [''Spinning by Firelight'']) painted during his Philadelphia stay, but he abandoned it after his return to France; the effect is distinctive enough to suggest the definitive changes both in Tanner's location and in his artistic direction.
  83. Web site: ARTISTSARTISTS HENRY OSSAWA TANNER AMERICAN PAINTER. [about the Thankful Poor]

    Here the influence of Impressionism is evident in both the softening and loosening of the brushstrokes used to render certain items including the wall and tablecloth as well as the importance of light which streams through the window casting a glow on the figures and their meal

    .
  84. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 189.
  85. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Crossing the Atlantic (Return Home) .
  86. Web site: art.newcity.com . Revealing the Deep Legacy of Black American Painters: A Review of "Masterworks Collection Series I: Paintings" at the DuSable Museum . 19 May 2016 . Chris Miller .
  87. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner . Mosby, Dewey F. . 1991. Philadelphia Museum of Art . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 128–131.
  88. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner . Mosby, Dewey F. . 1991. Philadelphia Museum of Art . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 114–115.
  89. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit . Anna O. Marley . University of California Press . 193 . Introduction Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit . Anna O. Marley .
  90. Web site: Mutual Art . Sale 2169 - Lot 1 . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) The Annunciation to the Shepherds. Oil on canvas, circa 1895. 325x400 mm; 12 3/4x15 7/8 inches. Signed in oil on the verso. Provenance: private collection, Chevy Chase, MD..
  91. News: Asbury Park Press . Asbury Park, New Jersey . American Art at Auction . 14 February 2009 . 29 . Other notables include a pair of oils on canvas by Henry Ossawa Tanner, the father of modern African- American art. These works, "The Annunciation to the Shepherds" ($60,000 to $90,000 estimate) and "Adoration of the Golden Calf' ($40,000 to $60,000), both circa 1895, reflect the artist's early exploration of Biblical subjects..
  92. Web site: artnet.com . Past Auction .
  93. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Marshes in New Jersey .
  94. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 39 . 1895 May. Paris, Salon. Intérieur Bretagne [Brittany Interior], Le Jeune Sabotier [The Young Sabot Maker], pastel of New Jersey coast by moonlight. .
  95. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 93 . His efforts were rewarded again by the Salon jury - The Young Sabot Maker, Brittany Interior, and a pastel called New Jersey Coast by Moonlight were exhibited, but did not attract the attention of the critics. The latter work is probably the picture now titled Marshes in New Jersey and inscribed "Paris 1895" (Washington, D.C., National Museum of Art). .
  96. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 197.
  97. Web site: Terra Foundation for American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) Les Invalides, Paris, 1896.
  98. Web site: Sotheby's . 56 Henry Ossawa Tanner .
  99. Web site: Musée d'Orsay . La Résurrection de Lazare .
  100. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 195.
  101. News: St. Louis Post-Dispatch . St. Louis, Missouri . 13 July 1902 . 5 . How Two Negro Boys Won Victories For Harvard.
  102. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 200.
  103. Web site: Museum of Fine Arts, Boston . Interior of a Mosque, Cairo . ...in Cairo, Tanner visited numerous mosques, many as yet unidentified: as Tanner put it, “the number of mosques is so great that to remember the names in one day or so is next to impossible.” Despite Tanner's uncertainty, the location of Interior of a Mosque, Cairo has been identified as the madrasa of Sultan Qaitbey, a Mamluk-dynasty complex originally containing a mosque, a school, and a mausoleum, built between 1472 and 1475..
  104. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 201 . Interior of a Mosque, Cairo, 1897. Oil on canvas, 20 1/2 x 26 in..
  105. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner – Les Bords du Nil (Caire),, 1890 .
  106. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner Cairo, 1897 .
  107. Web site: Swann Auction Galleries . Sale 2122 - Lot 1 Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) Seated Arab. .
  108. Web site: Smithsonian . Conversations Considered . Henry Ossawa Tanner 1859–1937, United States Study of an Arab 1897 Oil on board 33 x 24 cm (13 x 9 1/2 in.) Collection of Camille O. and William H. Cosby Jr. Photograph by Frank Stewart.
  109. Web site: Sotheby's . Henry Ossawa Tanner Untitled (A Water Carrier) .
  110. Web site: Kaminsky Fine Art, Auctions, Appraisals . LOT #557: Henry Ossawa Tanner, Arab Musician . [note pasted to back of frame:] Purchased by my mother while in France while on the "Grand Tour" Painted by Henry Ossawa Tanner.
  111. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 158–159.
  112. Web site: Christies . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Lion Drinking .
  113. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 160–161.
  114. Helen Cole . Brush and Pencil . Brush and Pencil Publishing Companey . Henry O. Tanner, Painter . Chicago . June 1900 . 6 . 3 . 99, 106 . [Discusses artwork illustrated in the article; process of elimination and context pairs this quote with the picture:] The picture reproduced is the "Still Hunt," which was seen in Chicago last year [1899]...Even those who did not grasp the significance of his "Annunciation," shown at the same time, admired the vigor and strength of handling in this..
  115. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . The Canyon .
  116. Web site: Swann Auction Galleries . Venice .
  117. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner portrait of Isaac .
  118. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 140–141 . Perhaps to celebrate his recent Salon triumph, in the summer of 1897 Tanner visited his parents in Kansas City...During this stay he painted the two small, bust-length portraits of his parents, showing them against dark red backgrounds..
  119. News: The Inter Ocean . H. O. Tanner's Paintings . Chicago, Illinois . 15 August 1897 . 30 . Henry O. Tanner...reached this country from Paris about two weeks ago and is now in Philadelphia, visiting his family...Tanner's next Salon picture will be "The Annunciation." His plan is to make the Virgin Mary very Eastern in type, or not unlike some of the women one might see in Jerusalem today. He brought back from his trip to the Holy Land materials for costumes that will doubtless be useful...He will commence a large painting for the Paris exposition of 1900 after finishing "The Annunciation." Mr. Tanner will return to the French capital, where he has lived for the last three years, about the middle of September..
  120. News: The Inter Ocean . Chicago, Illinois . No Color Line in Paris . 20 August 1897 . 1 . No Color Line in Paris.
    Henry O. Tanner, the Famous Colored Painter Will Return to That City.

    Kansas City, Mo., August 19—Special Telegram—Henry O. Tanner, the negro artist, a son of Bishop Benjamin T. Tanner, who is spending his vacation in Kansas City, Kan., with his parents, is making preparation for his return to Paris early in September, to resume his work with his brush. Mr. Tanner likes Paris, because of the companionship of artists, and he will probably spend the rest of his lifetime there; still, he glories in the fact that he is an American citizen, and he will retain that title as long as he lives. During his stay at home he has been painting portraits of his parents. When be returns to Paris he will begin working on another biblical painting, "The Annunciation," which he hopes will surpass his "Raising of Lazarus," which made him famous as an artist..
  121. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 142–143 . While visiting his parents in Kansas City, Kansas, in 1897, Tanner painted a large portrait of his mother, Sarah Elizabeth Miller Tanner...seated in an armchair, in profile against a background of carefully balanced geometric shapes....
  122. Web site: Philadelphia Museum of Art . Portrait of the Artist's Mother .
  123. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Kansas City, Kansas .
  124. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 205.
  125. Web site: Philadelphia Museum of Art . The Annunciation .
  126. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 162 . The young Jewish peasant sit[s] on the edge of a couch, wearing the common striped cotton of the Eastern women of the poorer class, a costume which they have kept to the present day, no halo or celestial attributes about her, and only the flood of golden light to herald the approach of the angel..
  127. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 162–165.
  128. Book: Société des artistes français. Salon . L. Baschet . Catalogue illustré du Salon de 1898 . 1879 . 1918 TANNER (H.-O.), boulevard Saint-Jacques, 51. — L'Annonciation . Paris .
  129. Book: A history of African-American artists : from 1792 to the present . Bearden, Romare . Henderson, Harry (Harry Brinton) . 96. 1993 . New York . Pantheon Books. 9780394570167 . During the summer of 1898, just after the success of The Annunciation, Tanner met a young opera singer of Swedish-Scottish descent from San Francisco, Jessie MacCauley Olssen, who had been studying music in Germany with her sister..
  130. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Portrait of the Artist's Wife .
  131. Web site: La Salle University Art Museum . Mary (La Sainte-Marie) .
  132. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 174–175.
  133. Henry Ossawa Tanner's "La Sainte-Marie" . Daniel Burke . Smithsonian Studies in American Art . Spring 1988 . 2 . 2 . 65–73 . The University of Chicago Press on behalf of the Smithsonian American Art Museum . 10.1086/smitstudamerart.2.2.3108951 . 3108951 . 194080163 . The large tabernacle frame in which the painting was first exhibited at the spring Salon of 1900 still bears a label with its entry number (1252), and another label indicating Tanner's previous Salon medal.
  134. Book: Catalogue illustré de Salon de 1900 . 1879 . Paris . L. Baschet . 1252 Tanner (H.-O.), boulevard Saint-Jacques, 51. — La Sainte-Marie [note 1252 is the painting's entry numner or identity within the Salon] .
  135. News: Camden Show Celebrates Century of Black Art. Courier-Post . Camden, New Jersey . 22 March 1992 . 81. The most interesting is Tanner's portrait of his wife, Head of a Girl in Jerusalem. The gold-orange coloring and characterful expression point to Tanner's mature work..
  136. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 168–171.
  137. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 212.
  138. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Head of a woman in Jerusalem .
  139. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 209.
  140. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 130–131.
  141. Web site: Smithsonian Archives of American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner papers, 1860s-1978, bulk 1890-1937 311: Photographs of Artwork, circa 1920s . [note: image downloads numbers 38, 39, 40, 41].
  142. Web site: Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Art . Nicodemus. 28 December 2014.
  143. News: An Afro-American Artist. Times Union . Brooklyn, New York . 13 September 1902 . 15 .
  144. Web site: Amistad Research Center . Flight from Jerusalem .
  145. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 32.
  146. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 41.
  147. Helen Cole . Brush and Pencil . Brush and Pencil Publishing Companey . Henry O. Tanner, Painter . Chicago . June 1900 . 6 . 3 . 104 . The landscape reproduced is some of Mr. Tanner's summer's work at Czernay la Ville, an hour's ride from Paris, and proves that if he had chosen to remain simply a landscape painter, as he began, he would have achieved more than ordinary success. This spot, famous as the home of Voltaire in his later years, and from which he addressed so many of his charming letters to women, seems to have inspired Mr. Tanner to do some extremely good work, both in landscapes and biblical compositions..
  148. Web site: Google Arts and Culture . Still Life with Apples Henry Ossawa Tanner1890/1899 .
  149. Web site: Georgia Museum of Art . Art at Home: Apple Collage . Henry O. Tanner (American, 1859 – 1937), “Still Life with Apples,” 1890s. Oil on canvas. Georgia Museum of Art, University of Georgia; The Larry D. and Brenda A. Thompson Collection of African American Art. GMOA 2011.604.
  150. Web site: UGA Today, University of Georgia . Georgia Museum of Art receives collection by African-American artists . 11 January 2012 . Larry D. and Brenda A. Thompson donated an extensive collection of African American artwork to the Georgia Museum of Art. It includes Henry O. Tanner's "Still Life with Apples .
  151. Web site: Henry Tanner's Judas: The Lost Disciple . 7 November 2018 . Smithsonian .
  152. News: The Opera and the Academy of Fine Arts Exhibition in Philadelphia . Fannie G. Thompson . The Topeka Daily Capital . Topeka, Kansas . 11 February 1900 . 13 .
  153. News: An Afro-American Artist. Times Union . Brooklyn, New York . 13 September 1902 . 15 . The Death of Judas" is a weird and uncanny subject and is quaintly original in its conception. The first impression is that of smiling landscape with a sweep of the grey-green foliage of olive trees. Suddenly one becomes conscious of the figure of the traitorous disciple hanging to a tree in the dim gray wood, while a couple of peasants with horrified expressions gaze upon the ghastly object..
  154. Web site: invaluable.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 510: Henry Ossawa Tanner, American, 1859-1937, 4 Scribes, 21 ¾" by 18" o/c, signed upper left, blacklights very nicely, no repairs made o....
  155. Helen Cole . Brush and Pencil . Brush and Pencil Publishing Companey . Henry O. Tanner, Painter . Chicago . June 1900 . 6 . 3 . 102–103 . The picture upon which Mr. Tanner is now working will be the largest one he has yet painted, and is perhaps the most ambitious in many respects. The subject is "Christ in the Temple.".
  156. Helen Cole . Brush and Pencil . Brush and Pencil Publishing Companey . Henry O. Tanner, Painter . Chicago . June 1900 . 6 . 3 . 103 .
  157. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 214.
  158. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . The Savior .
  159. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 213.
  160. Web site: Norton Museum of Art . Christ at the Home of Mary .
  161. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner American, 1859-1937 Parisian Street Scene, c. 1900 . Dolan Maxwell .
  162. Web site: artnet.fr . Enchère passée .
  163. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 216.
  164. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 158.
  165. Web site: Hodges Gallery . Portrait of Tanner's Wife, Jessie Macauley Olssen . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) Portrait of Tanner's Wife, Jessie Macauley Olssen Oil on Canvas 13 x 9 1/2 in. (33 x 24.1 cm).
  166. Web site: artnet.com . Portrait of Tanner's Wife, Jessie Macauley Olssen .
  167. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Two works: PORTRAIT OF JOHN OLSSON, FATHER OF HIS WIFE JESSIE . Mutual Art .
  168. Helen Cole . Brush and Pencil . Brush and Pencil Publishing Companey . Henry O. Tanner, Painter . Chicago . June 1900 . 6 . 3 . 106 . [Note: Near this picture is the following text, which could possibly be about the picture, from its inclusion nearby to it. However, the picture is titled ''Study''.] .
  169. Web site: useum.org . Untitled (Nocturnal Landscape) 1901 .
  170. Web site: Cornell University . Untitled (Nocturnal Landscape) .
  171. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Profile of a Woman's Head .
  172. News: Chicago Tribune . Chicago, Illinois . Gossip of Paris: American Artists Open Exposition at Which Well-Known PaintersAve Sculptors Show their work. 1 December 1901 . 34 . Henry O. Tanner, whose Daniel in the Lions' Den will be remembered, exhibits a woman's head In the firelight, a strong study..
  173. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit . Anna O. Marley . University of California Press . 34–35 . Introduction Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit . Anna O. Marley. Although this painting was long thought to be lost, Tanner in fact painted over La Musique, a portrait of his wife playing the cello, with his Emmaus (1905). The later painting was so well received that it was purchased by the French government. .
  174. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 152–153.
  175. Book: Société des artistes français. Salon . Ludovic Basket . L. Baschet . Catalogue illustré du Salon de 1902 . 1902 . 147 . 1545 TANNER (H.-O.), boulevard Saint-Jacques, 51. — La musique . Paris .
  176. News: Times Union . Brooklyn, New York . 13 September 1902 . An Afro-American Artist. 15 . He is now busy on his picture intended for the coming Salon. In this he has made quite a new departure. The canvas is called "The Duo." There are two feminine figures, both portraits from life. The principal one is represented as performing on the violoncello. The model was a handsome young woman, the artist's wife, and the one seated at the piano is his sister-in-law, Miss Olsson, a pretty young girl. The painting is a very attractive one, the salon with its elegant appointments and the two musicians in their sombre black gowns. Nor must the violoncello, with its rich coloring be forgotten; it is a treasure over two hundred year old..
  177. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 35.
  178. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 63, 144–145 . To raise funds for his trip, Mrs. Hartzell suggested an exhibition of Tanner's work in her hometown of Cincinnati...When, despite this critical interest, nothing sold from the exhibition, Bishop and Mrs. Hartzell bought the entire collection for a sum sufficient to permit Tanner to travel to Europe..
  179. Web site: Joseph Crane Hartzell . familysearch.org.
  180. Web site: National Gallery of Art . The Seine, c.1902 . December 2023 .
  181. Web site: Philadelphia Museum of Art . Low Tide, Cannon Street Bridge .
  182. Book: Leja, Michael . Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . 11: Reproduction Troubles, Tanner's "Mothers of the Bible" for the Ladies' Home Journal. University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 147–156.
  183. Ladies' Home Journal . Mothers of the Bible: I. Sarah. September 1902 . 9 .
  184. Ladies' Home Journal . October 1902. 13 . Mothers of the Bible: II. Hagar .
  185. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 202.
  186. Book: A history of African-American artists : from 1792 to the present . Bearden, Romare . Henderson, Harry (Harry Brinton) . 1993 . New York . 97. Pantheon Books. 9780394570167 .
  187. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 182–183.
  188. Web site: Le Christ et ses disciples sur la route de Béthanie .
  189. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 180–181.
  190. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 45, 56, 166. December 31, 1902,...resided in Granada for several months... Tanner seems to have adopted the elongated figure style of El Greco...can be seen in Salomé (fig. 48) and in an unfinished work on its verso, Moses and the Burning Bush...We spent six months painting around Jerusalem and the Dead Sea...Here it was that I made a study of the Mount of Temptation from which I afterward painted ‘Moses and the Burning Bush.’.
  191. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Study for Moses and the Burning Bush .
  192. Web site: Invaluable.com . Lot 104: HENRY O TANNER 'THE STAIRWELL, GRANADA' OIL CANVAS .
  193. Web site: invaluable.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 77: Henry Ossawa Tanner Village Scene O/C.
  194. Web site: 125 Masteworks From the Collection . Cedar Rapids Museum of Art.
  195. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 184–186.
  196. News: The Buffalo Times . Buffalo, New York . 10 June 1906 . 19 . An American Negro Who Leads France in Art . Tanner has had paintings on the Salon line for a number of years. This season he is represented by two — The Pilgrim of Emmaus and The Return of the Holy Woman. .
  197. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 187–189.
  198. Web site: Invaluable.com . Lot 121: Henry Ossawa Tanner, 1859–1937, Virgin Mary in Meditation, Oil on board, 12 x 9-1/2 inches .
  199. Web site: Mary and Marth - Bible Story . www.biblestudytools.com. 9 September 2021. The Bible Story of Mary and Martha comes from Chapter 10 of the Gospel of Luke...Mary and Martha are two sisters with incredibly different focuses. While Mary soaks in the moments with Jesus, Martha can't think past the cooking and cleaning..
  200. Web site: Carnegie Museum of Art . Christ at the Home of Mary and Martha .
  201. Book: A history of African-American artists : from 1792 to the present . Bearden, Romare . Henderson, Harry (Harry Brinton) . 1993 . New York . 98. Pantheon Books. 9780394570167 .
  202. News: To Turn Institute Into University . Pittsburgh Post-Gazette . Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania . 17 June 1907 . 5.
  203. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 192–194. The painting, "The Two Disciples at the Tomb," has carried off honors from an exhibition of unusual merit. The 350 pictures hung are all from artists of acknowledged ability. Quite a number have won prizes at other shows, while still a larger number had previously appeared at the walls of the exacting salons of Paris. .
  204. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 219.
  205. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 192–194. Fig. 71 Henry O. Tanner, The Disciples at Emmaus, 1906, oil on canvas, 73'/2 X 83'/2", Musée d‘Orsay, Paris.
  206. Book: Société des artistes français. Salon . Ludovic Basket. L. Baschet . Catalogue illustré du Salon de 1906 . 1906 . 1573 Tanner (H.-O.). — Le pèlerin d'Emmaus.
    1574 — Le retour de la Sainte Femme . Paris .
  207. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 43. 1906 May. Paris, Salon. Les Pélerins d’Emmaus [The Disciples at Emmaus]., Le Retour de la Sainte Femme [Return of the Holy Women]; former awarded second-class medal and purchased by French government. Tanner designated hors concours.
  208. News: An American Negro Who Leads France In Art. The Buffalo Times . Buffalo, New York . 10 June 1906 . 19 .
  209. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Abraham's Oak .
  210. News: Mr. Stone Reviews Paintings. The Topeka Daily Capital . Topeka, Kansas . 6 November 1905 . 4 . Henry O. Tanner...whose painting of 'David in the Lion's Den', was exhibited at the St. Louis exposition, is represented by two excellent canvases, 'The good Samaritan' and 'Abraham's Oak Near Hebron'....
  211. Book: Société des artistes français. Salon . Ludovic Basket. L. Baschet . Catalogue illustré du Salon de 1905 . 1905 . 1782 TANNER (H.-O.), rue Notre-Dame-des-Champs, 70 bis. — Le bon Samaritain
    1783 — Le Christ lavant les pieds de ses disciples. Paris .
  212. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Baade . Brian . Kerr-Allison . Amber . Giaccai . Jennifer . 12 Pursuit of the Ideal Effect: The Materials and Techniques of Henry Ossawa Tanner. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 159–160.
  213. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 195–197.
  214. Book: A history of African-American artists: from 1792 to the present . Bearden . Romare . Henderson . Harry . 1993 . New York . Pantheon Books. 9780394570167 . [plate] VIII.
  215. News: The Philadelphia Inquirer . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 19 Nov 1905 . Jury is judging Academy pictures . 31 . This year he forwards to Philadelphia the canvas already on exhibition at Carnegie Institute, and another, "Christ Washing the Feet of the Disciples," which received a medal in the spring salon in Paris. The picture shows six of the disciples seated with more or less regularity and one, standing by a door to the right, while at the left Christ kneels before the basin of water and holds the wet cloth in his hand..
  216. The Brush and Pencil . 17 . 1. January 1906 . 23 . Items from the art museums . Announcement has been made of the purchase of five paintings by the Fine Arts Committee of the Carnegie Institute, which will form part of the permanent exhibit...and Henry O. Tanner, formerly of Pittsburg, and now of Paris...'Judas Covenanting With the High Priests'....
  217. News: Pittsburgh Post-Gazette . Bishop Tanner Here . Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania . 8 June 1907 . 3 .
  218. Web site: Mutual Art . Portrait of Jessie when he was four years old .
  219. Web site: Michael Rosenfeld Gallery . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Selected Works . Portrait of Jesse When He was Four Years Old, June 18, 1907, oil on panel 13 x 9 1/4 inches / 33.0 x 23.5 cm signed.
  220. Web site: Cincinnati Art Museum . Flight into Egypt .
  221. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 222.
  222. Web site: Google Arts & Culture . Moonlight Hebron .
  223. News: Son of Colored Bishop Wins Honors in France . The Tacoma Daily Ledger . Tacoma, Washington . 13 September 1908 . 32 . He has painted among other important works "Peter After the Denial"....
  224. News: Tanner Paintings Here . The New York Times . New York, New York . 6 December 1908 . 49. At last year's Salon Mr. Tanner was represented by his "Behold, the Bridegroom Cometh," a canvas on which he has worked during the better part of three years...a large-sized canvas...15 feet long by 10 feet high, and containing twelve life-size figures. 'In this picture," said Mr. Tanner, I have endeavored to give a new interpretation of the parable of the wise and foolish virgins. I have tried to put in a more modern touch, to be less literal in my interpretation than the old masters who handled the same subject. Another result which I have also sought is to have the clothes of each one of the wise virgins represent, in a way, different religious beliefs, in spite of the fact that they all wear the conventional garments usually seen in such pictures.'.
  225. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . 18–19, 155–157. Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9 . Tanner set the price of his enormous picture The Wise and Foolish Virgins (see fig. 50) at $15,000 because it was "the result of three years work... during part of 1906 and all of 1907, Tanner tackled the most ambitious undertaking of his career — The Wise and Foolish Virgins (fig. 50), also known as Behold! The Bridegroom Cometh..
  226. Book: Catalogue illustré du salon de 1908 . Société des Artistes Français . Ludovic Basket . Paris . Entry 1745 and page 147. [note: There are two different Paris Salon Catalogs in 1908; on the title pages, one is by the ''Société nationale des beaux-arts'' and the other by the ''Société des Artistes Français''. Tanner is found in the latter catalog.] 1745 Tanner (H.), H. C., rue Notre-Dame-Des-Champs, 70 bis. — Les vierges sages et les vierges folles. .
  227. Book: Société des artistes français. Salon . Ludovic Basket. L. Baschet . Catalogue illustré du Salon de 1898 . 1879. 147 . [image of painting:] Tanner (H.). H. C. "Les vierges sages et les vierges folles" Wise and foolish virgins. Paris .
  228. The World's Work . Story of an artist's life II. Recognition . Tanner . Henry Ossawa. July 1909 . 18 . 3 . 11774. in “Behold! the Bridegroom Cometh’ I hoped to take off the hard edge too often given to that parable; how generally the wise virgins are made good but cold and unlovable; how I attempted to show that they were sympathetic for their sisters in distress, and that this sympathy was one of their beauties, in a marked degree, by the figure on the left on her knees — with her own lamp “bright burning” at her side — trying to bring to life the smoking lamp of her friend — in fact, interpreting the whole parable in keeping with our knowledge of the goodness of God and what He considers goodness in us. .
  229. Web site: Weatherspoon Art Museum . Mary .
  230. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . 203. Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9.
  231. News: Henry O. Tanner's Great Success in Religious Painting. The Winnipeg Tribune . Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada . 13 February 1909 . 18.
  232. Book: Mosby, Dewey F. . Henry Ossawa Tanner . 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 19, 45, 47, 49, 51, 284.
  233. Web site: Smithsonian Archives of American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner papers, 1860s-1978, bulk 1890-1937 Box 3, Folder 11: Photographs of Artwork, circa 1920s. [note: images 36 and 37. Image 36 is the front of the photo. Image 37 is the back of the photo. The title is on back of photo.] The Hiding of Moses.
  234. Web site: At ADAA Art Show, Amid Scattered Sales and Rare Henry Ossawa Tanner Presentation . juddtully.net . A pair of Corot-like beauties, Edge of the Forest (Bois d’Amour), circa 1893 and just 7 ½ by 10 ½ inches in scale, and Hills of Jerusalem (circa 1908), executed in oil on board, sold for approximately $125,000 each..
  235. Web site: Seattle Public Library, Catalogue of Fine Arts Gallery and Exhibit of Arts and Crafts, California Building, 1909 Page 41 . Catalogue of Fine Arts Gallery and Exhibit of Arts and Crafts, California Building, 1909...Creator Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition (1909 : Seattle, Wash.)...Date 1909.
  236. News: New York Times . Vivian Hewitt, Who Amassed a Major Collection of Black Art, Dies at 102 . 22 June 2022 . Henry Ossawa Tanner's “Gate in Tangiers” (circa 1910) is among the acknowledged masterworks in the Hewitts’ collection.Credit...The Harvey B. Gantt Center for African-American Arts + Culture . Risen . Clay .
  237. Web site: Howard University . Gate of Tangier .
  238. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 208–209.
  239. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner – Middle Eastern City Scape – Watercolor On Paper.
  240. Web site: The Art Show: Henry Ossawa Tanner Takes the Spotlight at Michael Rosenfeld Gallery . culturetype.com . 2 March 2019 .
  241. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 244.
  242. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 210–211.
  243. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 224.
  244. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . 224. Berkeley . 2012.
  245. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 212–213.
  246. News: Two American Painters . The Sun . New York, New York . 18 December 1908 . 6 . We admired much more the vigorous presentment of the old bearded Jew in turban entitled "A Jerusalem Type".
  247. News: The Winnipeg Tribune . Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada . 13 February 1909 . Henry O. Tanner's Great Success in Religious Painting . When, after seventeen years of self-exile and continually increasing fame, he decided to give to the land of his birth an exhibition of the works he has produced it was with comparative difficulty that Mr, Tanner, like other artists whose works had passed from their ownership, was able to assemble a coherent and adequate collection. His was not one of those "one-man" exhibitions designed to dispose of the unsold pictures of the exhibitor, with scores of canvases exhumable from the studio dust for any emergency that shows the possibility of a dollar. None of his paintings that have been acquired by the French government could be made available, and he was compelled to depend upon the good will of his patrons in America, owners who, in the years past, have enhanced their galleries with his works and have treasured them with a careful guardianship, which the appeal of the artist alone could suffice to relax..
  248. Web site: invaluable.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 51: Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) A Jerusalem Type 18 1/8 x 15 1/8 in. (46 x 38.4 cm.) (Painted circa 1908.).
  249. News: The Winnipeg Tribune . Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada . 13 February 1909 . Henry O. Tanner's Great Success in Religious Painting.
  250. Washington Post . Colonial Postcards and Women as Props for War-Making . Sarah Sentilles . 5 October 2017. these photographers wanted to take pictures of Algerian women as they'd imagined them... But when they reached the country, they encountered women whose bodies could not be seen. Veiled from head to toe, with only their eyes visible...Though the photographs...were staged, they were captioned as if they documented life in Algeria...The images reveal not Algerian women but the colonial photographer's fantasies about them. .
  251. Web site: Photography and the Politics of Representing Algerian Women . the scholar Malek Alloula analyzed photographic postcards of Algerian women, which staged erotic images of the "off-limits" harem of the early twentieth century. In Alloula's collection The Colonial Harem, the author points out that the postcards no longer represent Algeria or the Algerian women, but the "Frenchman's phantasm of the Oriental female and her inaccessibility behind the veil in the forbidden harem". . binghamton.edu . June 18, 2012 . https://web.archive.org/web/20130128101930/http://www2.binghamton.edu/history/resources/journal-of-history/jennifer-abbate.html . January 28, 2013 . dead .
  252. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 261: Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) American . invaluable.com .
  253. Web site: Scene of Algiers . Smithsonian American Art Museum . 22 June 2023.
  254. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 241.
  255. Nineteenth-Century Art Worlwidwide . 12 . 1 . Spring 2013. Theresa Leininger-Miller . Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit .
  256. Web site: lot-art.com. LOT 1005 School Of Tanner.
  257. Web site: Christ Taken Down from the Cross (Date unknown) by Henry Ossawa Tanner - The Athenaeum - Image id 142146 . gonzalez-art-foundation.org/.
  258. News: The Colorado Statesman . Tanner's Exhibition. Denver, Colorado . 23 January 1909. 1 . "The Return of the Holy Woman," with Calvary in the distance, is even more sensitive than the rest. It is so intensely silent..
  259. Web site: Smithsonian Archives of American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner papers, 1860s-1978, bulk 1890-1937 311: Photographs of Artwork, circa 1920s . [note: image downloads numbers 13 and 14].
  260. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 230.
  261. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Self-Portrait .
  262. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 220–223.
  263. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 227.
  264. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 226.
  265. Web site: Muskegon Museum of Art . MMA Permanent Collections . Henry Ossawa Tanner American, 1859 –1937 The Holy Family, ca. 1910 Oil on canvas Muskegon Museum of Art. Hackley Picture Fund Purchase, 1911.1 .
  266. Web site: Hearne Fine Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner .
  267. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 21, 42, 204.
  268. Web site: Des Moines Art Center . Henry Ossawa Tanner (American, 1859–1937) Le Touquet, ca. 1910 .
  269. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 229.
  270. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Angels Appearing before the Shepherds .
  271. Web site: Paul Vincent Tillman. Angels Appearing Before the Shepherds and The Life of Moses. Luke 2:8-14 .
  272. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 218–219.
  273. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 216–217.
  274. Book: Catalogue illustré du salon de 1910 . Ludovic Basket . Paris . Entries 1747 and 1748 . [note: Catalog by the ''Société des Artistes Français'', not the ''Société nationale des beaux-arts''] 1747 TANNER (H.-O.), H. C., rue Notre-Dame-des-Champs, 70 bis. — Les trois Marie approchant du tombeau. 1748 — La fuite en Egypte. .
  275. Web site: museumsyndicate.com . Mary Washing The Feet Of Christ. https://web.archive.org/web/20100207204116/http://www.museumsyndicate.com/item.php?item=4517 . 7 February 2010.
  276. Web site: artnet.com . Past Auction .
  277. Web site: Michael Rosenfeld Gallery. 18 January 2019 . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Selected Works . https://web.archive.org/web/20190118224716/http://www.michaelrosenfeldart.com/artists/henry-ossawa-tanner-1859-1937 .
  278. Web site: Henry Ossawa TannerHead of Christ, Circa 1910 . Mutual Art .
  279. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 46 . [note: photo of Tanner's son Jesse in sailor costume holding boat in 1911].
  280. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 245.
  281. News: Tanner Painting Comes to Market . The Philadelphia Inquirer . Philadelphia, Pennsylvania . 14 October 2000 . 11 . But Tanner also painted religious themes. The work to be sold Tuesday falls into that category. The 54-by-79-inch oil on canvas depicts Jesus seated at an altar table with 16 shrouded women behind him; he holds a chalice and wears a crown of thorns. It is signed and dated "H.O. Tanner, Paris 12." .
  282. News: African American Art Soars . National Post . Toronto, Ontario, Canada . 13 March 2004 . 42 . In October, 2000, a recently discovered painting by Henry Ossawa Tanner, one of the first African-American artists to make a name in both the United States and Europe, sold for $560,000. .
  283. Web site: invaluable.com . Lot 100: Henry O. Tanner, American, 1859-1937, oil on canvas, 54" x 79", signed and dated "H. O. Tanner/Paris/12" verso, with letter of authentication by Dr. David Driskell. Estimate- .
  284. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 207.
  285. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 140 . Apparently Tanner painted only two self-portraits, once depicting himself as an onlooker in Chamber Music...shown at the Salon in 1902, and later as Lazarus in the large painting Christ at the Home of Lazarus..., his Salon entry of 1914..
  286. News: Boston Evening Transcript . Boston, Massachusetts . 24 June 1914 . 20 . Pittsburgh's Painter Takes Paris . The Lazarus...is a freely conceived and executed portrait of the artist himself; and those who should know confidently affirm that thet Mary and the Martha...are likewise portraits..
  287. News: Pittsburgh's Painter Takes Paris. Boston Evening Transcript . Boston, Massachusetts . 24 June 1914 . 20 .
  288. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 47, 49, 51, 53.
  289. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 190.
  290. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 140 . Tanner...painted a modest, possibly unfinished double portrait of his patrons Mr. and Mrs. Atherton Curtis... He later used this image in a curious painting in which he placed the Curtises with the figure of Christ in another version of Christ at the Home of Lazarus .
  291. News: Barbara Gold . The Baltimore Sun . Tanner: 'Nearly Forgotten' . Baltimore, Maryland . 31 August 1969 . section d page 3 . For a while his painting of "Mr. and Mrs. Atherton Curtis At Dinner" was a popular topic for Paris gossip. Tanner, so the rumors went, had included Jesus Christ eating at the table with the couple. They, or so the stories said anyway, considered sitting at the table with the Saviour sacrilegious and ordered the picture cut-down...
  292. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Portrait of Mr. and Mrs. Atherton Curtis with Still Life .
  293. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 19, 42, 97. Around this time [end of 1897] he met Atherton Curtis, a wealthy expatriate with a fortune derived from patent medicine who would become a lifelong friend and financial benefactor, ...1902 August—November. Henry and Jessie reside with patrons and friends Atherton and Louise Curtis at Mount Kisco, New York, in small community planned by Curtises...Tanner's good friend Atherton Curtis, who helped with educational expenses for his son, Jesse.
  294. Web site: Michael Rosenfeld Art . 21 May 1915 . Selected Works. https://web.archive.org/web/20150521164438/https://www.michaelrosenfeldart.com/artists/henry-ossawa-tanner-1859-1937 . 2015-05-21 . [Image 3].
  295. Web site: High Museum of Art . A View of Fez .
  296. Web site: Swann Galleries . Sale 2528 - Lot 1.
  297. Web site: Smithsonian Archives of American Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner papers, 1860s-1978, bulk 1890-1937 311: Photographs of Artwork, circa 1920s . [note: image downloads numbers 11, 12. 11 is the photo front and 12 is the back of the photo and has annotation written:] Morocco by H. O. Tanner, Paris. In private collection, Chicago..
  298. Web site: Innovative Approaches, Honored Traditions The Ruth and Elmer Wellin Museum of Art at Five Years Highlights from the Permanent Collection September 9 – December 10, 2017 curated by Katherine D. Alcauskas, Collection and Exhibitions Specialist .
  299. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Street Scene, Tangier (Crenelated Architecture) .
  300. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 231–234.
  301. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner Moroccan Man .
  302. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner Moroccan Man .
  303. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 40: Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) American. Invaluable.com .
  304. Web site: St. Louis Museum of Art . Gateway, Tangier . 22 June 2023.
  305. Web site: Philadelphia Museum of Art . Doorway in Tangier .
  306. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 238.
  307. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Gateway, Tangier.
  308. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 228–230.
  309. Web site: Street Scene, Tangier (Man Leading Calf) . Smithsonian American Art Museum .
  310. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Street in Tangier .
  311. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 242.
  312. Web site: Museum of Fine Arts, Boston . Street Scene, Tangiers .
  313. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 243.
  314. Web site: Cummer Museum . PERMANENT COLLECTION>Midday, Tangiers .
  315. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 122032: H.O. TANNER GOUACHE ON PAPER . invaluable.com . H.O. TANNER, GOUACHE ON PAPER, MIDDLE EASTERN CITYSCAPE, H 13 1/2" W 10 1/2":Henry Ossawa Tanner American 1859-1930; signed lower right; framed. Artist or Maker.
  316. Web site: Los Angeles County Museum of Art . Moonlight: Walls of Tangiers. 23 June 2023.
  317. Web site: artofthehorse.net . Meet The First Internationally Known African-American Painter & See His Equine Art. Shya Beth . 4 July 2017 .
  318. News: The New York Times . New York, New York . 13 Apr 1913. section 5, page 14 . News and Notes of the Art World: Paintings by Henry O. Tanner.
  319. News: Artists Allege Discrimination out of Revenge . The Montreal Star . Montreal, Quebec, Canada . 2 July 1910 . 3 .
  320. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 247.
  321. Web site: National Academy of Design . The Miraculous Haul of Fishes .
  322. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 246.
  323. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum. Fishermen at Sea .
  324. Web site: Hampton University Museum . Collection History . [Note: A photo on the page referenced shows ''The Banjo Lesson'' displayed between ''Landscape in Moonlight'' and ''Adoration of the Golden Calf''.] . 25 July 2023 .
  325. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Mary .
  326. News: Boston Evening Transcript . Boston, Massachusetts . 24 June 1914 . 20 . Pittsburgh's Painter Takes Paris. The "Mary" represents a woman with a Jewish—or is it an Indian?—cast of countenance, holding a tiny Oriental lamp, which serves dimly to light the canvas..
  327. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 240–241.
  328. Web site: Sotheby's . 189 Henry Ossawa Tanner 1859-1937.
  329. Web site: Mutual Art . Henry Ossawa Tanner – Portrait of Jesse Ossawa Tanner, 1914 .
  330. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 242, 252–255 .
  331. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 250.
  332. Web site: Flight to Egypt and The Life of Moses, Matthew 2:13-14 .
  333. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 251.
  334. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 260–263.
  335. Web site: New Orleans Museum of Art (NOMA) . Celestial Wonders: 10 Works of Art to Reflect Upon the Solar Eclipse. 18 August 2017. Henry Ossawa Tanner, The Good Shepherd, c. 1914, Oil on canvas, Museum Purchase, 30.3.
  336. Web site: National Archives . "The Good Shepherd". Collection H: Harmon Foundation CollectionSeries: Artworks by Negro Artists NAID: 559134 Local ID: H-HN-TAN-13 Photographs and other Graphic Materials 3 Images... Subjects and References People Tanner, Henry Ossawa, 1859-1937.
  337. Web site: Christie's . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) mar Devotions, Étaples.
  338. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 233.
  339. Web site: Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture . Flight Into Egypt .
  340. Web site: National Archives . "Flight into Egypt". Collection H: Harmon Foundation CollectionSeries: Artworks by Negro Artists NAID: 559133 Local ID: H-HN-TAN-7 Photographs and other Graphic Materials 3 Images... Subjects and References People Tanner, Henry Ossawa, 1859-1937.
  341. Web site: Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art . The Good Shepherd .
  342. Web site: Sale 2424 - Lot 6 . circa 1917.
  343. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Shepherd with herd .
  344. Web site: North Carolina Museum of Art . Landscape . 11 March 2021 .
  345. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 256–257.
  346. Web site: Telfair Museums . Study of an American Soldier .
  347. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 255.
  348. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 254.
  349. Web site: Hood Museum of Art, Dartmouth . Étaples and the Canche River at Dusk .
  350. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 253.
  351. Web site: National Gallery of Art . The Good Shepherd, c.1918 . 13 September 2023 .
  352. Web site: invaluable.com . Henry Ossawa Tanner Lot 64: Henry OSSAWA TANNER (1859-1937) - PORTRAIT DE JESSE, FILS DE L'ARTISTE, 1919 .
  353. Web site: Sold Portrait of artist's son, Henry Ossawa Tanner . 1st Dibs.com.
  354. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 258.
  355. Web site: Brooklyn Museum . The Arch Henry Ossawa Tanner.
  356. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Fisherman's Return .
  357. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Countryside Around Nice, France, circa 1920 . Mutual Art .
  358. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Untitled .
  359. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 261.
  360. Web site: National Archives . "Destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah". Collection H: Harmon Foundation CollectionSeries: Artworks by Negro Artists NAID: 559135 Local ID: H-HN-TAN-16 Photographs and other Graphic Materials 3 Images... Subjects and References People Tanner, Henry Ossawa, 1859-1937.
  361. Book: Mathews, Marcia M . Henry Ossawa Tanner, American artist . 1969 . University of Chicago Press . Chicago . vii, xvii, 2 .
  362. Web site: Christies . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Invitation to Christ to Enter by his Disciples at Emmaus.
  363. Web site: Emmaus . 3 June 2020 . Alice M. Rudy Price . Tanner has chosen the moment before recognition. .
  364. Web site: Michael Rose Fine Art. September 9, 2017 Swann to Offer Important Ossawa Tanner Painting in October Sale . 9 September 2017 .
  365. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Moses in the Bullrushes .
  366. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 45–51.
  367. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 262.
  368. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 266–267.
  369. Web site: Nadeaus Auction Gallery . Lot 150: Henry Ossawa Tanner 1859-1937 Flight into Egypt oil on artist board signed lower right: H.O. Tanner 17 1/2 x 20 1/2 Written ….
  370. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 268–270.
  371. Web site: Metropolitan Museum of Art . Flight into Egypt .
  372. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 263.
  373. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 264.
  374. Web site: High Museum of Art . Etaples Fisher Folk .
  375. News: Henry Ossawa Tanner 1859/1937. Detroit Free Press . 14 July 1991 . 284–285 .
  376. Web site: Swann Galleries . Sale 2290 - Lot 9.
  377. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 269.
  378. Web site: Christies . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1853-1936) Nicodemus Coming to Christ .
  379. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 271–273.
  380. News: Carnegie Galleries Set For Great International . The Pittsburgh Press . Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania . 11 October 1925 . 69 . Henry O. Tanner, "The Two Disciples at the Tomb".
  381. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 266.
  382. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner. 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art. 978-0-8478-1346-9. 274–275.
  383. Web site: Swann Galleries . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) At the Gates (Flight into Egypt). . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) At the Gates (Flight into Egypt). Oil on panel, circa 1926-27. 610x483 mm; 24x19 inches. Signed in oil, lower left. Provenance: Grand Central Art Galleries, New York; J. J. Haverty, Atlanta (1929)... He purchased At the Gates and The Road to Emmaus from the Grand Central Art Galleries, New York, NY in July 1929 for $1,250. Haverty was an important patron of Tanner's - he owned five paintings by Tanner. .
  384. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Departure into Egypt .
  385. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 267.
  386. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Art, Faith, Race, and Legacy . Naurice Frank Woods Jr. . 6 July 2017 . Taylor & Francis . 9781315279480 . Tanner replaced the inherent message of peasant piety in Thankful with a universal message of concern for the less fortunate through the lens of the faithful believer....Tanner painted a scene in The Poor Ye Have with You Always in which a man, likely a beggar, stands in front of the home of a woman with an outstretched hand...The woman, from her doorway, gazes at him as if contemplating her response to someone in obvious need....
  387. Web site: Untitled (Moonlight Landscape) Henry Ossawa Tanner1928/1936 . artsandculture.google.com/.
  388. Web site: High Museum of Art . Destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah .
  389. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 270.
  390. Web site: Hand of Henry O. Tanner . Smithsonian American Art Museum .
  391. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner . 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art . 978-0-8478-1346-9. 172.
  392. Web site: Art in the Christian Tradition . Title: Good Shepherd Date: 1930 Artist: Tanner, Henry Ossawa, 1859-1937.
  393. Web site: mutualart.com. Henry Ossawa Tanner The Good Shepherd, 1930.
  394. Web site: Lot 70: Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) - Paysage de Campagne . invaluable.com .
  395. Web site: Lot 104: Henry O. (Ossawa) Tanner American/French 1859–1937 . invaluable.com .
  396. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 271.
  397. Web site: Smithsonian . The Good Shephard (Atlas Mountains, Morocco) .
  398. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner . 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art . 978-0-8478-1346-9. 280–283.
  399. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . He Healed the Sick .
  400. Web site: Sotheby's . 88 Henry Ossawa Tanner – He Healed the Sick #11.
  401. Web site: Smithsonian American Art Museum . Haystacks .
  402. Web site: Bill Hodges Galleries . Arbres Sous Le Vent.
  403. Book: Mosby, Dewey F.. Henry Ossawa Tanner . 1991 . Philadelphia; New York . Philadelphia Museum of Art; Rizzoli International Publications . Philadelphia Museum of Art . 978-0-8478-1346-9. 284–286.
  404. Web site: Study for Mary, Return from the Crucifixion . Bill Hodges Gallery . Study for Mary, Return from the Crucifixion HHenry Ossawa Tanner (1859–1937) Study for Mary, Return from the Crucifixion Oil on Artist Board 13 ¾ x 10 ½ in. (34.9 x 26.7 cm (Sold).
  405. Web site: Bonham's . Lot 15 Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Return from the Cross 39 7/8 x 29 7/8in (101.3 x 75.9cm) . Henry Ossawa Tanner (1859-1937) Return from the Cross signed 'H.O. Tanner.' (lower right) oil and tempera on board 39 7/8 x 29 7/8 in Painted circa 1934-35. Footnotes Provenance The artist, Paris, France. Private collection, cousin-in-law of the above, by descent. By descent to the present owner, son of the above, January 1999..
  406. Web site: Henry Ossawa Tanner Return from the Cross, 1934-1935 . Colby Museum of Art .
  407. Web site: Howard University . Flight Into Egypt .
  408. Book: Henry Ossawa Tanner: Modern Spirit. Marley . Anna O. . University of California Press . Berkeley . 2012 . 274.