List of United States representatives expelled, censured, or reprimanded explained

The United States Constitution (Article 1, Section 5)[1] gives the House of Representatives the power to expel any member by a two-thirds vote. Expulsion of a Representative is rare: only six members of the House have been expelled in its history. Three of those six were expelled in 1861 for joining the Confederate States of America.[2]

There are also less severe measures with which the House is authorized to discipline members. Censure and reprimand are procedures in which the House may vote to express formal disapproval of a member's conduct. Only a simple majority vote is required. Members who are censured must stand in the well of the House chamber to receive a reading of the censure resolution.[2] A reprimand was once considered synonymous with censure, but in 1976 the House defined a reprimand as a less severe punishment. Members who are reprimanded are not required to stand in the well of the House and have the resolution read to them.

Representatives can also be censured by their state legislatures and state party.

Expelled representatives

YearRepresentativePartyStateVote countclass=unsortableReason
1861DemocraticMissouri94–45Supporting Confederate rebellion.[3]
Kentucky
1980Pennsylvania376–30Convicted of bribery in the Abscam scandal.[4]
2002Ohio420–1 (with 9 "present")[5] Convicted on ten counts including bribery, conspiracy to defraud the United States, corruption, obstruction of justice, tax evasion, and racketeering.[6]
2023RepublicanNew York311–114 (with 2 "present")Findings of fraud and misuse of campaign funds by the House Ethics Committee.[7]

Censured representatives

YearRepresentativePartyStateVote countclass=unsortableReason
1832National RepublicanOhio93–44[8] Insulting the Speaker of the House.
1842WhigOhio125–69Introducing an anti-slavery resolution deemed to be incendiary, and violation of the gag rule prohibiting discussion of slavery.
1856DemocraticSouth Carolina106–96Assisting in the caning of Charles Sumner.
1864DemocraticMaryland98–20Making statements in support of the Confederate rebellion.
DemocraticOhio80–70
1866DemocraticNew York72–30Insulting the House with a resolution containing unparliamentary language.
1866Unconditional UnionistKentucky89–30Assaulting Rep. Josiah Grinnell on the floor of the House.
1867DemocraticNew York77–33Using unparliamentary language.
1868DemocraticNew York114–39Using unparliamentary language.
1869DemocraticIdaho TerritoryUsing unparliamentary language.
1870RepublicanSouth Carolina187–0Selling military academy appointments.
RepublicanNorth Carolina170–0
RepublicanTennessee158–0
1873RepublicanMassachusetts182–36Involvement in the Crédit Mobilier of America scandal.
DemocraticNew York174–32
1875DemocraticKentucky161–79Using unparliamentary language.
1890DemocraticIndiana126–104Using unparliamentary language.
1921DemocraticTexas293–0Using unparliamentary language.
1979DemocraticMichigan414–0Payroll fraud and mail fraud.
1979DemocraticPennsylvaniaBribery
1980DemocraticCaliforniavoice voteImproper use of campaign funds.
1983RepublicanIllinois420–3Engaging in sexual conduct with a House page.
DemocraticMassachusetts421–3
2010DemocraticNew York333–79Improper solicitation of funds, making inaccurate financial disclosure statements, and failure to pay taxes.
2021RepublicanArizona223–207 (with 1 "present")Posted an anime video on social media depicting himself committing violence against Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and President Joe Biden.[9] [10]
2023DemocraticCalifornia213–209 (with 6 "present")Making allegations regarding Russian collusion in the 2016 U.S. presidential election and the first impeachment of Donald Trump.[11] [12]
2023DemocraticMichigan234–188 (with 4 "present")Comments related to the 2023 Israel–Hamas war.[13]
2023DemocraticNew York214–191 (with 5 "present")Pulling the fire alarm in one of the Capitol office buildings under non-emergency circumstances.[14]

Reprimanded representatives

YearRepresentativePartyStateVote countclass=unsortableReason
1976DemocraticFlorida381–3 (with 5 "present")Use of office for personal gain.[15]
1978DemocraticCalifornia328–41 (with 29 "present")Role in South Korean influence-buying scandal.[16] [17]
1978DemocraticCaliforniaVoice voteRole in South Korean influence-buying scandal.[18]
1978DemocraticCaliforniaVoice voteRole in South Korean influence-buying scandal.
1984RepublicanIdaho354–52 (with 6 "present")False statements on a financial disclosure form.[19]
1987DemocraticPennsylvania324–68 (with 20 "present")Allowed another person to cast his vote, and misused House funds.[20]
1990DemocraticMassachusetts408–18Used office to fix 33 parking tickets on behalf of a friend and wrote a misleading memorandum on behalf of the friend to shorten his probation for criminal convictions.[21]
1995RepublicanCaliforniaVoice voteCriticism of President Bill Clinton as having "[given] aid and comfort to the enemy" during the Vietnam war in a floor speech. Dornan's remarks were stricken from the official record and he was banned from speaking on the House floor for 24 hours.[22]
1997RepublicanGeorgia395–28 Use of a tax-exempt organization for political purposes, and providing false information to the House Ethics Committee.[23]
2009RepublicanSouth Carolina240–179 (with 5 "present")Making an outburst towards President Barack Obama during a speech to a joint session of Congress.[24] [25]
2012DemocraticCaliforniaVoice voteCompelling her congressional office staff to work for her 2010 election campaign and perform personal errands; also fined $10,000.[26] [27]
2020RepublicanArizonaVoice votePermitting his office to misuse taxpayer funds and various violations of campaign finance reporting requirements, federal law and House rules.[28]

Excluded representatives-elect

YearRepresentative-electPartyStateDetails
1899Brigham Henry RobertsDemocraticUtahDenied seat for his practice of polygamy.
1919Victor L. BergerSocialistWisconsinDenied seat on basis of opposition to World War I and conviction under the Espionage Act; the Supreme Court later overturned the conviction.
1920Victor L. BergerSocialistWisconsinAfter being denied a seat the first time, Wisconsin's 5th congressional district reelected Berger in a special election, though Congress again refused to seat Berger, leaving the seat open until 1921.
1967Adam Clayton Powell Jr.DemocraticNew YorkMismanaging his committee's budget in previous Congress, excessive absenteeism, misuse of public funds.[29] Powell was reelected to the seat for one more term. This exclusion led to a Supreme Court case which held that the exclusion was unconstitutional and that Congress can only exclude members who do not met the minimum constitutional qualifications for membership.

See also

Federal politicians:

State and local politics:

Notes and References

  1. http://www.usconstitution.net/const.html#Article1 U.S. Constitution Online, Article 1
  2. http://www.rules.house.gov/Archives/rl31382.pdf CRS Report For Congress
  3. News: A LOOK BACK; Others Expelled From the House. July 25, 2002. The New York Times. December 1, 2023. A13. limited.
  4. News: Myers Expelled, 376-30. Babcock. Charles R.. October 3, 1980. December 2, 2023. The Washington Post.
  5. News: House Votes, With Lone Dissent From Condit, to Expel Traficant From Ranks. Mitchell. Alison. July 25, 2002. December 1, 2023. The New York Times. A13. limited.
  6. News: Traficant guilty of bribery, racketeering . CNN.com . November 12, 2007 . April 11, 2002 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20080411200051/http://archives.cnn.com/2002/LAW/04/11/traficant.trial/ . April 11, 2008 .
  7. News: Republican Rep. George Santos expelled from Congress after scathing fraud allegations. Tran. Kevin. December 1, 2023. December 1, 2023. USA Today.
  8. Web site: List of Individuals Expelled, Censured, or Reprimanded in the U.S. House of Representatives .
  9. Web site: List of Individuals Expelled, Censured, or Reprimanded in the U.S. House of Representatives US House of Representatives: History, Art & Archives. November 24, 2021. history.house.gov. en.
  10. Web site: 'Absolutely disgraceful': Anger as Paul Gosar shares anime clip showing him killing AOC . Bowden . John . November 18, 2021 . Independent . Independent . November 29, 2021.
  11. Web site: House votes to censure Rep. Adam Schiff over Trump investigations. Yilek. Caitlin. CBS News. June 21, 2023. June 21, 2023.
  12. Web site: House censures Adam Schiff for alleging collusion between Donald Trump, Russia . June 22, 2023 . USA TODAY . en-US.
  13. News: Grisales. Claudia. November 7, 2023. House votes to censure Rep. Rashida Tlaib for Israel-Hamas war comments. NPR. November 7, 2023.
  14. News: Ferek . Katy Stech . House Censures Rep. Jamaal Bowman for Pulling Fire Alarm Ahead of Critical Vote . December 7, 2023 . . December 7, 2023 . limited . live . https://archive.today/20231207163125/https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/house-censures-rep-jamaal-bowman-for-pulling-fire-alarm-ahead-of-critical-vote-06434b1b . December 7, 2023.
  15. David E. Rosenbaum, House Reprimands Sikes For Financial Misconduct, New York Times (July 30, 1976).
  16. Richard L. Lyons, House Censures Rep. Wilson of California, Washington Post (June 11, 1980).
  17. Charles R. Babcock, House Votes Reprimands for Roybal, McFall and Wilson, Washington Post (October 14, 1978).
  18. Adam Bernstein, 11-Term Rep. John J. McFall, Washington Post (March 15, 2006).
  19. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/98-1984/h793 TO ADOPT THE REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE ON STANDARDS OF OFFICIAL CONDUCT IN THE MATTER OF GEORGE V. HANSEN. (MOTION PASSED)
  20. Julie Johnson, House Votes to Reprimand Lawmaker for Misconduct, New York Times (December 19, 1987).
  21. Richard L. Berke, House, 408 to 18, Reprimands Rep. Frank for Ethics Violations, New York Times (July 27, 1990).
  22. News: REP. DORNAN REBUKED FOR FLOOR TIRADE . The Washington Post . Painin . Eric . January 26, 1995 . April 23, 2018.
  23. Adam Clymer, House, in 395-28 Vote, Reprimands Gingrich, New York Times (January 22, 1997).
  24. News: Carl Hulse. House Rebukes Wilson for Shouting 'You Lie'. New York Times. September 16, 2009.
  25. https://www.congress.gov/bill/111th-congress/house-resolution/744/text H.Res.744 – Raising a question of the privileges of the House
  26. John H. Cushman Jr., Democrat Reprimanded for Misusing Staff in Race, New York Times (August 1, 2012).
  27. John Breshnahan, House reprimands Richardson (August 2, 2012).
  28. News: Rep. Schweikert sanctioned in rare action on House floor . Roll Call . July 31, 2020 . July 31, 2020.
  29. http://www.upi.com/Audio/Year_in_Review/Events-of-1967/Elections/12303074818188-11/ "1967 Year In Review, UPI.com"