| Severo Quiñones Court | |
|---|---|
| Chief Justice José Severo Quiñones (1900–1909) | |
| Hernández Santiago Court | |
| Chief Justice José Hernández Santiago (1909–1922) | |
| del Toro Cuebas Court | |
| Chief Justice Emilio del Toro Cuebas (1922–1943) | |
| Travieso Nieva Court | |
| Chief Justice Martín Travieso Nieva (1944–1948) | |
| de Jesús Sánchez Court | |
| Chief Justice Angel de Jesús Sánchez (1948–1951) | |
| Todd Borrás Court | |
| Chief Justice Roberto Todd Borrás (1951–1952) | |
| Snyder Court | |
| Chief Justice A. Cecil Snyder (1953–1957) | |
| Sifre Dávila Court | |
| Chief Justice Jaime Sifre Dávila (1957) | |
| Negrón Fernández Court | |
| Chief Justice Luis Negrón Fernández (1957–1972) | |
| Pérez Pimentel Court | |
| Chief Justice Pedro Pérez Pimentel (1973–1974) | |
| Trías Monge Court | |
| Chief Justice José Trías Monge (1974–1985) | |
| Pons Núñez Court | |
| Chief Justice Víctor Pons Núñez (1985–1992) | |
| Andréu García Court | |
| Chief Justice José Andréu García (1992–2003) | |
| Naveira Merly Court | |
| Chief Justice Miriam Naveira Merly (2003–2004) | |
| Hernández Denton Court | |
| Chief Justice Federico Hernández Denton (2004–2014) | |
| Fiol Matta Court | |
| Chief Justice Liana Fiol Matta (2014–2016) | |
| Oronoz Rodríguez Court | |
| Chief Justice Maite Oronoz Rodríguez (2016–) | |