Line 18 (São Paulo Metro) Explained

São Paulo Metro Line 18 (Bronze)
Logo Alt:São Paulo Metro logo
Status:Cancelled
Locale:[1]
End:Estrada dos Alvarengas
Stations:19
Daily Ridership:314,000 (estimated)
Owner: Government of the State of São Paulo
Operator:Vem ABC
Character:Elevated
Gauge:None (monorail)

Line 18 (Bronze) (Portuguese: Linha 18–Bronze) was a project of the São Paulo Metro. It would link São Paulo to the southeast portion of the Greater São Paulo, ending in São Bernardo do Campo. The line was expected to be the first São Paulo Metro Line to go beyond the city limits.[2]

Background

Preliminary studies for a city passenger rail transportation system in São Paulo were sketched as of 1888,[3] and later some of them included the so-called ABC region. One of them cited a suspension railway as an alternative for the city and its neighborhoods in the 1960s, inspired on Wuppertal Suspension Railway and SAFEGE models, including a suggestion to link ABC to Parque Dom Pedro II through Tamanduateí River.[4] São Paulo Metro was established as a company in 1968 and started its revenue service in 1974.[5] Its justification was based upon the fast growth of the city of São Paulo, and its car fleet as well, with all the problems emerging due to that. The original plan suggested the construction of four lines, all of them enclosed within the city's limits, although predicting transfer stations to the commuter rail system and the buses. The southeasternmost station of the system was predicted to be settled near Via Anchieta (and bearing such name), a state road linking São Paulo to Santos passing by the ABC region.[6] Although commuter rail services exist between the ABC region and the city of São Paulo since the end of the 19th century, through São Paulo Railway and its successors, the fast growth of the area observed in the 2nd half of the 20th century and the unavailability of such services in some cities (notably São Bernardo do Campo and Diadema) demanded further transport options to the region. At first the government didn't see any rationale to establish a metro line in the area, choosing to install a trolley bus service linking São Paulo to São Bernardo do Campo through Diadema.[7] Such initiatives led to the establishment of São Mateus–Jabaquara Metropolitan Corridor, one of the first bus rapid transit systems in Brazil.

The São Paulo secretariat of Metropolitan Transportation started to issue plans for the future transport expansion in 1997, aiming to anticipate and get prepared for the demands of its citizens on this matter. Those reports are known as Integrated Urban Transport Plans (Plano Integrado de Transporte Urbano – PITU).[8] PITU 2025 claimed for the need to a metro branch linking ABC to São Paulo, more specifically employing either a light rail or guided bus technology.[9]

Project

The original project predicted an 18 stops' line linking the current Tamanduateí station (already served by São Paulo Metro and CPTM commuter rail service as well) to Alvarengas station, a future terminal station to be located near the city road bearing the same name.[10] However parts of such path overlaps the current São Mateus–Jabaquara metropolitan corridor, which would demand the extinction of such service between São Bernardo and Ferrazópolis. As this corridor is operated through a concession, it would imply breaking that contract thus exposing the state government to a termination fee. Such risk endangered the whole project[11] and the solution sought was to truncate the proposed line to end at São Bernardo station and eventually at Djalma Dutra station.

The government procurement for the establishment of the line has been established in 2014 and states it will be constructed as a public–private partnership. The system is expected to be concluded in 2018.[12] Stations Rudge Ramos and Mauá are shown as Praça Regina Matiello and Instituto Mauá, respectively, in some local news sources,[13] [14] although the most recent metro company documents still don't mention them bearing such names.[15]

In July 2014, Malaysian rail company Scomi Rail announced that it had been selected as the monorail technology provider for the winning consortium of the Public Private Partnership Project (PPP), Consorcio ABC Integrado. This would be Scomi's third project in Brazil after Line 17-Gold and the Manaus Monorail.[16] The line will operate the Scomi SUTRA monorail systems designed by Scomi Rail.

In July 2020, more than a year after the cancelling of the project, Chinese company BYD presented a proposal to the State Secretary of Regional Development, along with the Chairman of the Greater ABC Intermunicipal Dealership, Gabriel Maranhão, Mayor of Rio Grande da Serra, to "rescue" the monorail line.[17]

Controversy

The monorail alternative for line 18 was contested, as it is not employed on current metro branches but appointed as the most suitable construction for this project, as well as for lines 15-Silver (formerly Line 2-Green expansion) and 17-Gold. Positive arguments are the cheaper, faster construction and decreasing the need for resumption; listed setbacks are visual pollution, difficulty to be evacuated in case of emergency, its relative small capacity and incapability to be upgraded.[18] In downtown São Bernardo do Campo, some real estate owners tried to settle a civil action to change the proposed right-of-way, as it may adversely affect high-end apartment buildings recently erected there, through aesthetic concerns and planned resumptions.[19] On 3 July 2019, Governor João Doria, along with Vice Governor, Rodrigo Garcia, and Secretary of Metropolitan Transportations, Alexandre Baldy, announced that the Line would be cancelled and replaced by a BRT system, already rumored months before.[20]

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Linha 18 vai gerar 1000 empregos diretos . Diário do Grande ABC website . January 30, 2014 . March 11, 2014 . Portuguese . Line 18 will generate 1,000 direct jobs .
  2. News: O Estado de S. Paulo . February 3, 2012 . March 15, 2014 . Portuguese . Governo quer terceirizar o monotrilho do ABC . Government wants to outsource ABC monorail . C8 . Ribeiro . Bruno .
  3. News: O Estado de S. Paulo . Portuguese . January 25, 2013 . March 13, 2014 . Em 1888, engenheiro alemão tentou – sem sucesso – fazer monotrilho no centro . In 1888, a German engineer tried – unsuccessfully – to build a monorail downtown . H4 .
  4. News: January 2, 1966 . O Estado de S. Paulo . March 13, 2014 . Portuguese . Preconizado o metro aéreo como solução para a Capital . Predicting elevated metro as a solution for the capital . 20 .
  5. Web site: São Paulo Metro website . About Us . March 12, 2014 .
  6. News: November 21, 1968 . March 12, 2014 . O Estado de S. Paulo . Portuguese . Passageiros, o metro já vai partir . 90 . Passengers, the metro will depart . de Siqueira . Ethevaldo Mello .
  7. News: Portuguese . Obras de trólebus no ABC começam este ano . O Estado de S. Paulo . November 30, 1984 . March 12, 2014 . 36 . Trolley bus works start this year .
  8. Web site: Metropolitan Transportation Secretary website . March 14, 2014 . August 9, 2009 . PITU Presentations . https://web.archive.org/web/20131121112847/http://www.stm.sp.gov.br/index.php/pitu2020-english-327 . November 21, 2013 . dead .
  9. Web site: São Paulo Secretariat of Metropolitan Transportation . Portuguese . PITU 2025 . 196 . March 17, 2014 . December 2006 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150924110455/http://www.stm.sp.gov.br/images/stories/Pitus/Pitu2025/Pdf/Pitu_2025_08.pdf . September 24, 2015 . dead .
  10. Web site: São Paulo Metro website . Portuguese . March 17, 2014 . Estudo de Impacto Ambiental – Linha 18 . Environmental impact assessment – Line 18 . 1 . May 15, 2012 .
  11. Web site: Diário do Grande ABC website . June 23, 2013 . March 17, 2014 . Portuguese . Linha 18 – Bronze até o Alvarenga tem chance de ficar só no papel . Line 18 – Bronze to Alvarenga in risk to remain as a project . Rocha . Rafael .
  12. Web site: Diário do Grande ABC website . portuguese . January 29, 2014 . March 17, 2014 . Rocha . Raphael . Alckmin planeja divulgar vencedor da Linha 18 no 1º semestre . Alckmin plans to announce line 18 winner up to the 1st half-year .
  13. Web site: Portuguese . viatrolebus.com.br . March 19, 2014 . Confira detalhes da Linha 18 – Bronze, que teve edital de obras lançado nesta quarta (29) . January 29, 2014 . Check out details from line 18 – Bronze, whose procurement has been issued on this Wednesday 29 . Lobo . Renato .
  14. Web site: terra.com.br . March 19, 2014 . A evolução das obras do metro e CPTM . Evolution of Metro and CPTM works . Portuguese .
  15. Web site: São Paulo Metro website . Portuguese . Desapropriações – Linha 18 Bronze . Resumptions – Line 18 Bronze . March 19, 2014 .
  16. Web site: Scomi . 15 April 2015 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150125012236/http://www.scomigroup.com/weboffice/files/news/7162014_81220AM_MNR_SEB%20Line%2018%2015072014.pdf . January 25, 2015 . dead .
  17. Web site: Grupo chinês tem projeto para resgate de Metrô na Linha 18. Diário do Grande ABC. pt. Daniel. Tossato. 7 July 2020. 7 July 2020.
  18. News: O Estado de S. Paulo . March 19, 2012 . March 14, 2014 . Portuguese . O monotrilho é uma boa ou má opção para SP? . Is monorail a good or bad option for São Paulo? . Brancatelli . Rodrigo . Cavaleiro . Carolina . Müller . Marcos . C6 .
  19. Web site: g1.com.br . Moradores querem ação judicial contra traçado de monotrilho no ABC . March 17, 2014 . July 8, 2013 . Santiago . Tatiana . Portuguese . Homeowners want civil action against ABC monorail path .
  20. Web site: Governo de SP anuncia BRT para ligar ABC à Linha 2-Verde do Metrô. G1. pt. Giba. Bergamin. 3 July 2019. 3 July 2019.