Lawrence Oates Explained

Lawrence Oates
Birth Name:	Lawrence Edward Grace Oates
Birth Date:	1880 3, df=yes
Birth Place:	Putney, Surrey, England
Death Place:	Ross Ice Shelf, Antarctica
Death Cause:	Hypothermia^[1]
Other Names:	Titus Oates
Education:	Eton College
Occupation:	Cavalry officer, explorer

Lawrence Edward Grace "Titus" Oates (17 March 188017 March 1912)^[2] was a British army officer, and later an Antarctic explorer, who died from hypothermia^[3] during the Terra Nova Expedition when he walked from his tent into a blizzard. His death, which occurred on his 32nd birthday, is seen as an act of self-sacrifice when, aware that the gangrene and frostbite from which he was suffering was compromising his three companions' chances of survival, he chose certain death for himself to relieve them of the burden of caring for him.

Early life

Oates was born in Putney, Surrey, in 1880, the elder son of William Edward Oates, FRGS, and Caroline Annie, daughter of Joshua Buckton, of West Lea, Meanwood, Leeds. The Oates family were wealthy landed gentry, having had land at Dewsbury and Leeds since the 16th century; William Oates moved the family to Gestingthorpe, Essex in 1891^[4] after becoming Lord of the manor of Over Hall at Gestingthorpe.^{[5] [6]} His sister Lillian, a year older,^[7] married the Irish baritone and actor Frederick Ranalow.^[8] An uncle was the naturalist and African explorer Frank Oates.

Oates lived in Putney from 18851891. He was one of the first pupils to attend the nearby Willington School. He went on to Eton College but left after less than two years owing to ill health.^[6] He then attended an army "crammer", South Lynn School, Eastbourne.^[9] His father died of typhoid fever in Madeira in 1896.

Military career

In 1898, Oates was commissioned into the 3rd (Militia) Battalion of the West Yorkshire Regiment. He saw active service during the Second Boer War as a junior officer in the 6th (Inniskilling) Dragoons, having been transferred to that cavalry regiment as a second lieutenant in May 1900. He took part in operations in the Transvaal, the Orange River Colony, and Cape Colony. In March 1901 a gunshot wound shattered his left thigh bone, leaving it an inch shorter than the right. Twice called upon to surrender in that engagement, he replied, "We came to fight, not to surrender."^[6] He was recommended for the Victoria Cross for his actions and was brought to public attention.^[10]

He was promoted to lieutenant in 1902, and left Cape Town for England after peace was signed in South Africa.^[11] He was mentioned in despatches by Lord Kitchener in his final despatch dated 23 June 1902. He was promoted to captain in 1906, and served in Ireland, Egypt, and India. He was often referred to by the nickname "Titus Oates", after the historical figure.^[12]

Terra Nova expedition

Preparation

In 1910, he applied to join Robert Falcon Scott's expedition to the South Pole—the Terra Nova expedition—and was accepted mainly on the strength of his experience with horses and, to a lesser extent, his ability to make a financial contribution of £1,000 towards the expedition. Nicknamed "the soldier"^[13] by his fellow expedition members, his role was to look after the 19 ponies that Scott intended to use for sledge hauling during the initial food depot-laying stage and the first half of the trip to the South Pole. Scott eventually selected him as one of the five-man party who would travel the final distance to the Pole.^[14] Belgrave Edward Sutton Ninnis, a fellow polar explorer who accompanied Douglas Mawson on the Australasian Antarctic Expedition, described Oates in his diary as "distinguished, simple-minded." Ninnis also expressed concern that Oates was the wrong man for the job.^[15]

From the beginning of the voyage, Oates was initially not a popular member onboard the Terra Nova. According to Ninnis, testimonials from crew members onboard indicated that during the voyage out "he [Oates] did not, by general affectation, increase his popularity with the fellows on board" and that "....[if] Oates gets unpopular with the other fellows, his life, cooped up with them in the hut on McMurdo Sound, will certainly not be a bed of roses." and that "....unless he pulls himself together a bit, he will find himself "returned, not wanted."^[15] Oates also clashed with Scott many times on issues of management of the expedition. "Their natures jarred on one another", expedition member Frank Debenham recalled.^[16] When he first saw the ponies that Scott had brought on the expedition, Oates was horrified at the £5 animals, which he said were too old for the job and "a wretched load of crocks."^[17] He later said: "Scott's ignorance about marching with animals is colossal."^[18] He also wrote in his diary "Myself, I dislike Scott intensely and would chuck the whole thing if it were not that we are a British expedition ... He is not straight, it is himself first, the rest nowhere ..."^[18] However, he also wrote that his harsh words were often a product of the hard conditions. Scott, less harshly, called Oates "the cheery old pessimist", adding: "the Soldier takes a gloomy view of everything, but I've come to see that this is a characteristic of him."^[13]

South Pole

Scott, Oates and 14 other members of the expedition set off from their Cape Evans base camp for the South Pole on 1 November 1911. At various pre-determined latitude points during the 895miles journey, the support members of the expedition were sent back by Scott in teams. On 4 January 1912, at latitude 87° 32' S, only the five-man polar party consisting of Scott, Edward Wilson, Henry Bowers, Edgar Evans and Oates remained to march the last 167miles to the Pole.

On 18 January 1912 they finally reached the Pole—only to discover a tent that Norwegian explorer Roald Amundsen and his four-man team had left behind at their Polheim camp, after beating them in the race to the Pole. Inside the tent was a note from Amundsen informing them that his party had reached the South Pole on 14 December 1911, beating Scott's party by 35 days.

Return

Scott's party faced extremely difficult conditions on the return journey, mainly due to the exceptionally adverse weather, poor food supply, injuries sustained from falls, and the effects of scurvy and frostbite. On 17 February 1912, near the foot of the Beardmore Glacier, Edgar Evans died, perhaps from a blow to the head suffered in a fall days earlier.^[19]

On 15 March, Oates told his companions that he could not go on and proposed that they leave him in his sleeping bag, which they refused to do. He managed a few more miles that day but his condition worsened that night.^[20]

Death

According to Scott's diary entry of 16 or 17 March (Scott was unsure of the date but thought 17 March correct), Oates had walked out of the tent the previous day into a blizzard to his death. Scott wrote in his diary: "We knew that poor Oates was walking to his death, but though we tried to dissuade him, we knew it was the act of a brave man and an English gentleman."^[21] According to Scott's diary, as Oates left the tent he said, "I am just going outside and may be some time."^{[22] [23]}

Scott, Wilson and Bowers continued onwards for a further towards the One Ton food depot that could save them but were halted at latitude 79° 40' S by a fierce blizzard on 20 March. Trapped in their tent and too weak and cold to continue, they died nine days later, 11miles short of their objective. Their frozen bodies were discovered by a search party on 12 November; Oates's body was never found. Near where he was presumed to have died, the search party erected a cairn and cross bearing the inscription: "Hereabouts died a very gallant gentleman, Captain L. E. G. Oates, of the Inniskilling Dragoons. In March 1912, returning from the Pole, he walked willingly to his death in a blizzard, to try and save his comrades, beset by hardships."^[24]

Legacy

Oates's act of self-sacrifice is often considered to be one of the most memorable examples of its kind in recent history, and his understated final words are often cited as a veritable example of the traditional characteristic of British people concerning the "stiff upper lip" attitude.^[25]

Oates's reindeer-skin sleeping bag was recovered and is now displayed in the museum of the Scott Polar Research Institute in Cambridge with other items from the expedition.

The Oates Museum at Gilbert White's House, Selborne, Hampshire focuses on the lives of Lawrence Oates and his uncle Frank.^[26]

The Royal Dragoon Guards, the successor to the 6th (Inniskilling) Dragoons, have a regimental day to remember Oates.^{[10] [27]} His Queen's South Africa Medal with bars and Polar Medal are held by the regimental museum in York.^[28] The then Inniskilling Dragoon Guards were reportedly given £20,000 to help purchase the medals by Sir Jack Hayward.^[29]

In 1913 his brother officers erected a brass memorial plaque to him in the parish church of St Mary the Virgin in Gestingthorpe, Essex, which his mother, Caroline, faithfully polished weekly for the rest of her life. The church is opposite his family home of Gestingthorpe Hall.

A painting of Oates walking out to his death, A Very Gallant Gentleman, by John Charles Dollman, hangs in the Cavalry Club in London.^{[30] [31]} It was commissioned by officers of the Inniskilling Dragoons in 1913. It was exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1914.^[32] A preparatory sketch is in the Scott Polar Research Institute,^[33] at the University of Cambridge, having been sold by Christie's, on behalf of a private owner, for £40,000 in 2014.^[34]

In May 1914 a memorial to Oates was placed in the cloister of the newly built School Library at Eton College, itself part of the Boer War Memorial Buildings. It was executed by Kathleen Scott, the widow of the expedition's leader.^[6]

The Lawrence Oates school in Meanwood, Leeds (closed 1992), was named after him. On the 100th anniversary of his death, a blue plaque was unveiled in his honour at Meanwood Park, Leeds.^[35]

On 17 March 2007, The Putney Society unveiled a blue plaque at the site of Oates's childhood home of 263 Upper Richmond Road, Putney, London. The current address is 307 Upper Richmond Road.^[36]

In the media

• In the 1948 film Scott of the Antarctic, Oates was played by Derek Bond. The film does not accurately portray the interpersonal difficulties in the expedition and concentrates on the heroics of the people involved.
• In The Last Place on Earth, a 1985 Central Television seven-part serial telling of both the Amundsen and Scott treks to the South Pole, the character of Oates is played by Richard Morant.
• A biography by Michael Smith, I am Just Going Outside: Captain Oates – Antarctic Tragedy, (Spellmount Publishers 2002) claimed that a 20-year-old Oates fathered a daughter after raping an 11-year-old Scots girl named Ettie McKendrick.^{[37] [38]}
• Brenda Clough's 2001 science fiction novella "May Be Some Time" has Oates transported to the year 2045, where he is healed via advanced medicine. This novella formed the basis for her later novel Revise the World, which also centred on Oates.^[39]
• In Geraldine McCaughrean's 2005 book The White Darkness, a teenage girl, Symone Wates, has an obsession with Captain Titus Oates; she even creates an imaginary friend of him.
• In Frank Capra's 1931 film Dirigible, depicting an American expedition to the South Pole in the 1930s, a fictional character played by Roscoe Karns incurs injuries similar to those of the real-life Oates, and chooses to sacrifice himself in a manner clearly inspired by the circumstances of Oates's death.
• The 1985 villanelle "Antarctica" by Derek Mahon details the last moments and sacrifice of Oates. It uses the quotation "I am just going outside and may be some time" as the basis of one of the refrains, and modulates it to "He is just going outside and may be some time".
• Terry Pratchett uses Captain Oates's last words at least three times in his Discworld Series in similar situations. These include #11, Reaper Man, in which the words "I am just going out. I may be some time" are spoken by Windle Poons; #13, Small Gods, in which the line "I'm just going out. I may be some time" is spoken by Brutha; and #16, Soul Music, in which the line "I may be some time" is spoken by the character Death.^{[40] [41]}
• In Tom Stoppard's 1972 play Jumpers, Stoppard describes two fictional British astronauts named "Oates" and "Captain Scott" whose lunar landing craft is damaged when setting down on the Moon, such that the rockets appear to have only enough lift to carry one of the astronauts off the surface. Stoppard has Scott and Oates fight to be the one to get back in the landing craft. Scott wins the fight and closes the hatch to the craft with the words "I am going up now. I may be gone for some time."^[42]
• He is a character in Beryl Bainbridge's novel The Birthday Boys (1991) in which Bainbridge writes about the ill-fated expedition from the point of view of Scott and the four men he took to the Pole.
• In Margaret Atwood's 2009 novel The Year of the Flood the character Adam One makes reference to "Saint Laurence 'Titus' Oates of the Scott Expedition" in a speech made to the followers of the God's Gardeners eco-fanatic religious group. One of the characters is also named after Oates.
• Spanish heavy metal band WarCry song "Capitán Lawrence" of El Sello De Los Tiempos album tells of his sacrifice to save his comrades.
• In China Miéville's SF novel Embassytown (2011), several human characters 'take the Oates Road' when they walk out in the alien city that surrounds them, where they hope to die. Oates-like brave polar explorers are also mentioned earlier in the novel when humans trade with the aliens.
• In the 1991 episode of Red Dwarf, "White Hole", and in Rob Grant's Red Dwarf novel Backwards, Kryten attempts to persuade Rimmer to make a sacrifice (specifically, turning himself, as a hologram, off so that the power-deprived ship will have more energy, allowing the remaining crew to live for an additional four months) in the manner of Captain Oates, to which Rimmer replies, "Captain Oates was a prat! If that'd been me, I'd've stayed in the tent, whacked Scott over the head with a frozen husky, and then eaten him." Before adding: "How do we know that Oates went out for this legendary walk? From the only surviving document: Scott's diary. And he's hardly likely to have written down, "February the First, bludgeoned Oates to death while he slept, then scoffed him along with the last packet of instant mash." How's that going to look when he gets rescued, eh? No, much better to say, "Oates made the supreme sacrifice", while you're dabbing up his gravy with the last piece of crusty bread."^[43]
• The Lee and Herring series Fist of Fun featured a recurring sketch which portrayed Oates's sacrifice not as heroism, but as an act of passive-aggression. This behaviour would continue in other situations, such as Oates at a dinner party (in full Antarctic expedition gear) refusing the last roast potato in a way obviously designed to elicit sympathy.
• In the original version of the 1999 BBC Robbie the Reindeer holiday special Hooves of Fire, Robbie quotes Oates' last recorded words when telling Blitzen that he's leaving Santa Claus' sleigh team, similarly opting to leave on foot from the North Pole. The line is changed in CBS' American dub of the special.
• In the song "Héroes de la Antártida" by the Spanish pop group Mecano on their album Descanso Dominical.
• Australian post-rock band We Lost The Sea has a song titled "A Gallant Gentleman" off their 2015 album Departure Songs. The song pays homage to Oates's sacrifice.^[44]
• In "A Beautiful Mind", the third episode of the seventh series of Peep Show, Mark likens Jeremy's expedition to read Wuthering Heights on their balcony to Oates's death. "There goes the Captain Oates of having to read a relatively short book." Later in "The Love Bunker", Super Hans tells two people he refers to as "Hall and Oates" being sent out from a bunker back into the paintball war, "You're just going for a walk. And it may be some time." They are almost immediately heard being shot repeatedly with paintballs.
• In Monty Python’s Flying Circus, Season 2, Episode 10, Terry Jones portrays Oates in the low budget film, Scott of the Sahara, in which he saves the expedition from a giant electric penguin.
• In the radio version of The Mighty Boosh episode Tundra, Howard tries to emulate Oates by walking out into a blizzard. However, as Vince notes, he has one leg shorter than the other and keeps walking around in circles.

See also

• Oates Coast

Notes

Sources

• Smith, Michael I Am Just Going Outside.
• Scott's Last Expedition Vols I and II Smith, Elder & Co 1913 (Vol I is Scott's diary)
• Preston, Diana: A First Rate Tragedy.
• Huntford, Roland: The Last Place on Earth.
• Scott, Robert Falcon: Scott's Last Expedition: The Journals.
• McCaughrean, Geraldine: The White Darkness.
• Limb, Sue & Cordingley, Patrick: Captain Oates: Soldier and Explorer.
• Goldsmith, Jeremy: British Army officers' records; Career Soldiers in the Family Tree Magazine (London) of June 2007, which shows Oates's Record of Service (with a birth date of 16 March 1880).

Notes and References

1. https://www.coolantarctica.com/Antarctica%20fact%20file/History/biography/oates_lawrence.php “Oates, Lawrence Edward Grace - Captain (1880-1912) - Biographical notes”
2. 10.1093/ref:odnb/35275. Oates, Lawrence Edward Grace. Pottle. Potts.
3. https://www.coolantarctica.com/Antarctica%20fact%20file/History/biography/oates_lawrence.php “Oates, Lawrence Edward Grace - Captain (1880-1912) - Biographical notes”
4. Encyclopaedia of the Antarctic, vol. I: A-K, ed. Beau Riffenburgh, Routledge, 2007, p. 683
5. Burke's Landed Gentry, 17th edition, ed. L. G. Pine, 1952, pp. 1913-1914, Oates formerly of Gestingthorpe Hall pedigree
6. Article by Andrew Robinson in Eton College News and Events Lent 2012
7. Web site: 1881 British Census Household Record . Familysearch.org . 8 October 2011.
8. Web site: Surrey - Godalming, Charterhouse School - World War 2 . Roll of Honour . 27 April 2017.
9. The Times Correspondence relating to Henry van Esse Scott, founder of South Lynn July 1927
10. News: How the last words of Titus Oates still inspire his regiment . BBC News . 9 July 2012.
11. The Army in South Africa - Troops returning home. 10 June 1902 . 14 . 36790.
12. Book: Huntford, Roland . Roland Huntford. Scott and Amundsen. Atheneum. 1984. 978-0-6897-0-656-1. 345.
13. Book: Scott . Robert F . Journals: Captain Scott's Last Expedition . 2008 . Oxford University Press . 9780199536801 . 303, 125.
14. Book: Stafford . Ed . Epic Expeditions: 25 Great Explorations Into the Unknown . 2021 . Aurum . 18.
15. Book: Ninnis . B.E.S. . Mornement . Allan . Riffenburgh . Beau . Mertz & I...The Antarctic Diary of Belgrave Edward Sutton Ninnis . 2014 . The Erskine Press . Eccles, Norwich, England, U.K. . 978-1-85297-116-8 . 69.
16. I Am Just Going Outside: Captain Oates - Antarctic Tragedy, Michael Smith, 2002
17. News: Antarctic mission: Who was Captain Lawrence Oates?. BBC News. Dhruti Shah. 10 March 2012. 10 March 2012.
18. Web site: King . Gilbert . Sacrifice Amid the Ice: Facing Facts on the Scott Expedition . Smithsonian Magazine . 16 September 2021.
19. Web site: Online Reader – Project Gutenberg . Gutenberg.org . 8 October 2011.
20. Book: Shadows of death – Time-Life Books. 1992. Time-Life Books. 9780809477197. 27 April 2017.
21. Web site: British history in depth: The Race to the South Pole. BBC. 3 March 2011. We knew that Oates was walking to his death... it was the act of a brave man and an English gentleman..
22. Scott, Captain R.F. Scott's Last Expedition: The Journals of Captain R.F. Scott. Pan Books, 2003, p.462.
23. Paul Simpson-Housley (1992) Antarctica: exploration, perception, and metaphor p. 36. Routledge, 1992. "I am just going outside and may be some time."
24. Book: Journals: Captain Scott's Last Expedition: Captain Scott's Last Expedition . Robert Falcon Scott . 454. 2006. Oxford University Press, UK . 9780199297528 .
25. Web site: Stiff Upper Lip, the Manson Family and the Paradise: TV picks. October 2012.
26. Web site: Home . Gilbert Whites House . 20 June 2014 . 27 April 2017.
27. Asquith, Stuart. Regiment Issue 34. Nexus Special Interests, 1999, p. 15.
28. Web site: "Polar medal now in regimental museum" The Evening Press 13 September 1999 . Archive.thisisyork.co.uk . 8 October 2011.
29. News: Colourful life of a British eccentric. Shropshire Star. 14 January 2015. Comment and Analysis article on Sir Jack Hayward by Mark Andrews, which misnumbers the regiment as the "5th".
30. Book: Jones . Max . The Last Great Quest: Captain Scott's Antarctic Sacrifice . 2004 . OUP Oxford . 978-0-19-162233-5 .
31. Book: Glinga . Werner . Legacy of Empire: A Journey Through British Society . 1986 . Manchester University Press . 978-0-7190-2272-2 . 29 . registration .
32. Book: The Boy's Own Annual 36th Annual Volume . 1913–1914 . Plate opposite page 41, part 11.
33. Web site: A Very Gallant Gentleman . . 19 January 2020 . en.
34. Web site: John Charles Dollman (1851-1934), 'A Very Gallant Gentleman' (Captain L.E.G. Oates walking out to his death in the blizzard, on Captain Scott's return journey from the South Pole, March 1912) . . 19 January 2020 . en.
35. News: Plaque to mark South Pole explorer Captain Oates - BBC News . BBC News . 17 March 2012 . 27 April 2017.
36. Web site: Blue Plaques Scheme. The Putney Society. 3 January 2018.
37. News: John Ezard . Antarctic hero Oates 'fathered child with girl of 12' . The Guardian. 14 October 2002 . 8 October 2011 . London.
38. News: Antarctic legend's secret scandal. 14 October 2002. BBC News. 7 August 2008.
39. https://www.sfsite.com/05a/rw319.htm Featured Review: Revise the World
40. Web site: Small Gods (Discworld #13)(38) by Terry Pratchett . Pratchett, Terry . 1992 . Gollancz . 24 December 2016.
41. Web site: Soul Music (Discworld #16)(3) by Terry Pratchett . Pratchett, Terry . 1994 . Gollancz . 24 December 2016.
42. Book: Purse, Nigel . Tom Stoppard's Plays: Patterns of Plenitude and Parsimony . Leiden . Brill . 2016 . 155 . 9789004318366 . The significance of the moon landing for interweaving the vehicle of the play into the ideas it discusses is two-fold. First of all, 'Millions of viewers saw the two astronauts struggling at the foot of the ladder until Oates was knocked to the ground by his commanding officer... Captain Scott has maintained radio silence since pulling up the ladder and closing the hatch with the remark, 'I am going up now. I may be gone for some time.' Apart from being an inverse pun on the famous scene on Scott's Antarctic journey in which Oates sacrifices himself with the words, 'I am just going outside and may be some time', it demonstrates the chaotic world of relativism in which the morality of one's actions depends upon one's point of view..
43. Web site: White Hole. IMDb.com. 6 August 2016.
44. Web site: We Lost The Sea – Departure Songs, an Analysis Of. 4 May 2016. 6 June 2017.