Comparison of karate styles explained

The table contains a comparison of karate styles. Some of the distinguishing features are listed, such as lineage, general form of stances, the balance of hard and soft techniques, and the number and names of kata forms.

Background

The four major karate styles developed in Japan, especially in Okinawa are Shotokan, Wado-ryu, Shito-ryu, and Goju-ryu; many other styles of Karate are derived from these four.[1] The first three of these styles find their origins in the Shorin-Ryu style from Shuri, Okinawa, while Goju-ryu finds its origins in Naha. Shuri karate is rather different from Naha karate, drawing on different predecessor influences. Shito-ryu can be regarded as a blend of Shuri and Naha traditions as its kata incorporate both Shuri and Naha kata.[2]

The formal application within the four major karate styles are as follows:

Some later styles of karate have been derived from blending techniques from the four main branches, while others have added techniques from other martial arts. For example Kyokushin, which is an extremely hard style derived from Shotokan and Gōjū-ryū, involves much more breaking and full contact, knockdown sparring as a main part of training.[3]

Comparison of styles

StylesOriginDerived FromStancesRepresentative KataNumber of kataReferences
Chitō-ryūOkinawaShōrei-ryū or Naha-te, Shōrin-ryūboth elements exist but more soft than hardnaturalShi Ho Hai, Seisan, Ro Hai Sho, Niseishi, Bassai, Chinto, Sochin, Tenshin, Ro Hai Dai, Sanshiryu, Ryushan, Kusanku, Sanchin15 kata not including kihon and Bo kihon/kata
GenseiryūOkinawaShuri-te and possibly Tomari-te.both, but mostly softdeep/naturalTen-i no Kata, Chi-i no Kata, Jin-i no Kata, Sansai, (Koryu) Naifanchi, (Koryu) Bassai, (Koryu) Kusanku or Koshokun (dai)64
Gōjū-ryūOkinawaFujian White Crane and Naha-te.bothdeep/naturalSanchin, Tensho, Gekisai Dai/Sho, Seipai, Saifa, Suparinpei12
Gosoku-ryuJapanGōjū-ryū, Shotokanbothdeep (beginner), natural (advanced)Gosoku, Rikyu, Denko Getsu, Tamashi46 including weapons kata
Isshin-ryūOkinawaGōjū-ryū, Shōrin-ryū, Kobudōboth, fast & hardnaturalSeisan, Seiunchin, Naihanchi, Wansu, Chinto, Sanchin, Kusanku, Sunsu15 including weapons kata
KyokushinJapanShotokan, Gōjū-ryūextremely hardnaturalSokogi, Pinan + ura, 33
Motobu-ryūJapan and OkinawaShuri-te and Tomari-tebothnaturalNaihanchi (shodan and nidan), Shirokuma, Seisan, Passai, Ufukun, Motode (ichi and ni), Kasshindī (san, yon, go)11
Shindō jinen-ryūJapan and Okinawaprimarily Shuri-te like Shitō-ryū, but also Naha-te and Tomari-tebothdeep/naturalShimpa, Taisabaki 1-3, Sunakake no Kon More than 60 counting all kobudo kata
Shitō-ryūJapan and OkinawaShuri-te and Naha-tebothdeep/naturalPinan, Bassai Dai, Seienchin, Saifa, Rōhai, Nipaipo94
Shuri-te, Tomari-te, Chinese martial artsboth, primarily fast & softnaturalFukyu, Pinan, Naihanchi, passai, kanku, seisan 21
ShotokanJapan and OkinawaShōrin-ryū and Shōrei-ryū70% hard, 30% soft/fastdeep (formal) and naturalTaikyoku Shodan, 5 Heian, 3 Tekki, Bassai Dai and Sho, Jion, Empi, Kanku Dai and Sho, Hangetsu, Jitte, Gankaku, Sochin, Nijushiho, Chinte, Ji'in, Meikyo, Wankan, Unsu, Gojushiho Dai and Sho27
ShūkōkaiJapanGōjū-ryū & Shitō-ryū60% hard, 40% softnaturalPinan, Bassai Dai, Seienchin, Saifa, Rōhai44
Uechi-RyūFuzhou, Fujian Province & OkinawaHuzun Quan kung fu[4] Naha-tehalf-hard, half-softmainly naturalSanchin, Seisan, Sanseirui8
Wadō-ryūJapan and OkinawaShindō Yōshin-ryū Jujutsu, Tomari-te, Shotokan and Motobu-ryūboth, primarily softmainly naturalPrimary: Pinan, Kushanku, Naihanchi, Seishan, and Chintō. Secondary: Jion, Wanshu, Jitte, Rohai, Bassai, and Niseishi[5] 15
Shorin-ryu ShorinkanOkinawa90% Hard10% Soft Beginner deep and higher belts also deepPinan Nidan,Pinan Shodan, Naihanchi Shodan,Saifa/Jion, Annan, Basadai, Godusiosu8

See also

Sources

External links

Notes and References

  1. Book: . Farkas, Emil. Martial Arts. Traditions, History, People. Gallery Books. 1983. 49.
  2. Book: Clayton, Bruce D. . Shotokan's Secret, The Hidden Truth Behind Karate's Fighting Origins. Black Belt Communications LLC. 2004. 97 & 153.
  3. Kara-te. Special Collector's Edition: History, Masters, Traditions, Philosophy. Blitz Publications. 27, 39, 45 & 67.
  4. Web site: Huzun Quan 虎尊拳. 2021-02-27. www.taipinginstitute.com.
  5. Web site: Wado Ryu Kata.