J. R. Clynes Explained

Honorific-Prefix:The Right Honourable
J. R. Clynes
Office:Home Secretary
Term Start:8 June 1929
Term End:26 August 1931
Primeminister:Ramsay MacDonald
Predecessor:Sir William Joynson-Hicks
Successor:Sir Herbert Samuel
Office1:Lord Privy Seal
Term Start1:22 January 1924
Term End1:6 November 1924
Primeminister1:Ramsay MacDonald
Predecessor1:Robert Cecil
Successor1:James Gascoyne-Cecil
Office2:Deputy Leader of the Labour Party
Term Start2:21 November 1922
Term End2:25 October 1932
Predecessor2:Office established
Successor2:Clement Attlee
Office3:Leader of the Labour Party
3Blankname3:Chief Whip
3Namedata3:Arthur Henderson
Term Start3:14 February 1921
Term End3:21 November 1922
Predecessor3:William Adamson
Successor3:Ramsay MacDonald
Office4:Minister of Food Control
Term Start4:18 July 1918
Term End4:10 January 1919
Primeminister4:David Lloyd George
Predecessor4:David Alfred Thomas
Successor4:George Henry Roberts
Office5:Parliamentary Secretary of the Ministry of Food Control
Term Start5:2 July 1917
Term End5:18 July 1918
Primeminister5:David Lloyd George
Predecessor5:Charles Bathurst
Successor5:Waldorf Astor
Parliament6:United Kingdom
Constituency Mp6:Manchester Platting
Prior Term6:Manchester North East (1906–1918)
Term Start6:14 November 1935
Term End6:5 July 1945
Predecessor6:Alan Chorlton
Successor6:Hugh Delargy
Term Start7:8 February 1906
Term End7:27 October 1931
Predecessor7:James Fergusson
Successor7:Alan Chorlton
Birth Date:27 March 1869
Birth Place:Oldham, Lancashire, England
Death Place:London, England
Party:Labour Party
Children:2
Signature:Clynes_signature.svg

John Robert Clynes (27 March 1869 – 23 October 1949) was a British trade unionist and Labour Party politician. He was a Member of Parliament (MP) for 35 years, and as Leader of the Labour Party (1921–1922), led the party in its breakthrough at the 1922 general election.

He was the first Englishman to serve as leader of the Labour Party.

Early life

The son of an Irish labourer named Patrick Clynes, he was born in Oldham, Lancashire, and began working in a local cotton mill when he was ten years old.[1] Aged sixteen, he wrote a series of articles about child labour in the textile industry, and the following year he helped form the Piercers' Union. He was mainly self-educated, although he went to night school after his day's work in the mill. His first book was a dictionary and then, by careful saving of coppers, he bought a Bible, William Shakespeare's plays, and Francis Bacon's essays.[1] Later in life, he would amaze colleagues in meetings and in parliamentary debates by quoting verbatim from the Bible, Shakespeare, John Milton and John Ruskin.[2] He married Mary Elizabeth Harper, a mill worker, in 1893.

Trade union and political involvement

In 1892, Clynes became an organiser for the Lancashire Gasworkers' Union and came in contact with the Fabian Society. Having joined the Independent Labour Party, he attended the 1900 conference where the Labour Representation Committee was formed; this committee soon afterwards became the Labour Party.

Clynes stood for the new party in the 1906 general election and was elected to Parliament for Manchester North East,[3] becoming one of Labour's bright stars. In 1910, he became the party's deputy chairman.

Parliamentary career

During the First World War, Clynes was a supporter of British military involvement (in which he differed from Ramsay MacDonald), and, in 1917, became Parliamentary Secretary of the Ministry of Food Control in the Lloyd George coalition government. The next year, he was appointed Minister of Food Control and, at the 1918 general election, he was returned to Parliament for the Manchester Platting constituency.[4]

In August 1917, three months before the Balfour Declaration, the Labour Party issued a statement in support of a Jewish state in Palestine. Clynes spoke in favor of a Jewish state.[5]

Clynes became leader of the party in 1921 and led it through its major breakthrough in the 1922 general election. Before that election, Labour only had fifty-two seats in Parliament but, as a result of the election, Labour's total number of seats rose to 142. He was held in considerable respect and affection in the Labour Party and, although lacking the charisma of MacDonald, was a wily operator who believed all resources available should be used to advance the material of the working classes.[6]

MacDonald had resigned as Labour leader in 1914, due to his wartime pacifism,[7] and at the 1918 general election, he lost his seat. He did not return to the House of Commons for another four years. By that stage, MacDonald's pacifism had been forgiven. When the occupant of the Labour leadership had to be decided on through a vote of Labour parliamentarians, MacDonald narrowly defeated Clynes. Clynes was a critic of government policy towards the Irish population in the years after 1918, and attacked 'a recurring system of coercion' which had left Ireland "more angry and embittered . . . than ever'[8]

Governmental office

When MacDonald became Prime Minister he made Clynes the party's leader in the Commons until the government was defeated in 1924. During the second MacDonald government of 1929–1931, Clynes served as Home Secretary. In that role, Clynes gained literary prominence when he explained in the Commons his refusal to grant a visa[9] to the Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky, then living in exile in Turkey, who had been invited by the Independent Labour Party to give a lecture in Britain. Clynes had then been immortalised by the scathing criticism of his concept of the right to asylum, voiced by Trotsky in the last chapter of his autobiography My Life, entitled "The planet without visa".[10]

In 1931, Clynes sided with Arthur Henderson and George Lansbury, against MacDonald's support for austerity measures to deal with the Great Depression. Clynes split with MacDonald when the latter left Labour to form a National Government. In the 1931 election, Clynes was one of the casualties, losing his Manchester Platting seat. Nevertheless, he regained this constituency in 1935, and then remained in the House of Commons until his retirement ten years later, at the 1945 general election.

Retirement and death

After retiring, Clynes was living in very straitened circumstances, with no other income than trade union pension of £6 per week. This pension debarred him from the Commons Ex-Members Fund. Doctors' and nursing fees in respect of his invalid wife had hit him heavily.[11] MPs opened a fund to help and raised about £1,000.[12] Thus, after a lifetime spent in advancing the material conditions of the people, he died in relative poverty in October 1949.[6] His wife died a month later.

Honours

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. News: Mr J.R. Clynes to Leave the House . . 21 May 1942. 30 March 2016 . British Newspaper Archive. subscription .
  2. Tony Judge, 'J.R. Clynes: A Political Life' (2016) Ch1
  3. Book: Craig , F. W. S. . F. W. S. Craig . British parliamentary election results 1885–1918 . 1974 . 2nd . 1989 . Parliamentary Research Services . Chichester . 0-900178-27-2 . 142.
  4. Book: Craig , F. W. S. . F. W. S. Craig . British parliamentary election results 1918–1949 . 1969 . 3rd . 1983 . Parliamentary Research Services . Chichester . 0-900178-06-X . 191.
  5. Web site: Vaughan . James . 2023-11-08 . Israel, Palestine and the Labour party history that has made Keir Starmer's position so difficult . 2024-05-24 . The Conversation . en-US.
  6. Tony Judge, 'J.R. Clynes: A Political Life' (2016)
  7. [David Marquand|Marquand, David]
  8. Jon Lawrence 'Forging a Peaceable Kingdom: War, Violence and Fear of Brutalisation in Post-First World War Britain', JMH (2003), p.582
  9. Web site: M. TROTSKY. (Hansard, 18 July 1929) . 18 July 1929. In regard to what is called "the right of asylum," this country has the right to grant asylum to any person whom it thinks fit to admit as a political refugee. On the other hand, no alien has the right to claim admission to this country if it would be contrary to the interests of this country to receive him.. . 17 August 2012.
  10. Book: Trotsky, Leon . http://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1930/mylife/ch45.htm. My Life. Chapter 45: The Planet Without a Visa. My Life (Leon Trotsky autobiography). Leon Trotsky. 1930. The pious Mr. Clynes ought at least to have known that democracy, in a sense, inherited the right of asylum from the Christian church, which, in turn, inherited it, with much besides, from paganism. It was enough for a pursued criminal to make his way into a temple, sometimes enough even to touch only the ring of the door, to be safe from persecution. Thus the church understood the right of asylum as the right of the persecuted to an asylum, and not as an arbitrary exercise of will on the part of pagan or Christian priests.. marxists.org . 17 August 2012.
  11. News: J.R. Clynes Left £9816 . The Courier. Dundee . 7 February 1950. 30 March 2016 . British Newspaper Archive. subscription .
  12. News: MR. J.R. Clynes Taken To Hospital . . 31 August 1949. 30 March 2016 . British Newspaper Archive. subscription .
  13. Web site: Honorary Freemen of the Borough.
  14. Web site: John Robert Clynes.
  15. Web site: J.r. Clynes Memoirs 1869 1924).
  16. Web site: From mill boy to minister; an intimate account of the life of the Rt. Honourable J.R. Clynes, M.P.