John H. Shaffer Explained

Office:United States
4th Federal Aviation Administrator
Term Start:March 24, 1969
Term End:March 14, 1973
Predecessor:William F. McKee
Successor:Alexander Butterfield
Birth Name:John Hixon Shaffer
Birth Date:25 February 1919
Birth Place:Everett, Pennsylvania
Death Place:Frederick, Maryland
Alma Mater:United States Military Academy (1943)
Air Force Institute of Technology (1945)
Columbia University
Spouse:Joan Van Week (m. 1943)
Appointer:Richard Nixon

John Hixon Shaffer (February 25, 1919 – September 14, 1997) was an administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration from March 24, 1969 until March 14, 1973.[1] [2]

Shaffer was the administrator during an en-masse calling-in-sick strike by air traffic controllers in 1969.[3] He threatened to fire controllers who didn't return to work within 24 hours, calling them "ill-advised". In the summer, Shaffer testified to a congressional committee that air traffic controllers were neither overworked nor underpaid.[4] Shaffer's testimony increased pressure on controllers to return to their jobs. Celebrity lawyer F. Lee Bailey of the Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization (PATCO) stated, "This guy Shaffer has got to go."[5] The FAA and Shaffer were both later attacked by the PATCO for continuing to operate the air traffic system despite the low number of controllers.

On December 3, 1970, he testified to Congress about aviation safety.[6]

Following his retirement from the FAA, Shaffer was involved in a debate over the use of microwave landing systems in civil aviation and which country's industry should be awarded a contract for construction of the equipment: the US, UK, or Germany. Shaffer himself agreed with British assessments that the American manufactured MLS system was inferior and poorly tested.[7]

McDonnell Douglas DC-10 accidents

On June 12, 1972, American Airlines Flight 96 safely performed an emergency landing in Detroit, Michigan, after a cargo door broke off the planea McDonnell Douglas DC-10while in the air.[8] Shaffer reached a "gentleman's agreement" with Jackson McGowen, the director of McDonnell Douglas, in which the FAA issued a voluntary, confidential service bulletin, rather than a legally enforced, publicized airworthiness directive, to fix the DC-10's safety issues.[9]

On March 3, 1974, Turkish Airlines Flight 981also a DC-10crashed in France after losing a cargo door in a manner similar to Flight 96. All 346 people on board died, making it the deadliest crash in aviation history at the time. The plane had not received the change suggested by the service bulletin.[10]

Shaffer, who left the FAA before Flight 981 crashed, defended the administration's actions. He argued that the change might not have been made even under an airworthiness directive, because the FAA trusted manufacturers to self-certify fixes and did not verify compliance. The US Senate held a hearing on the DC-10's safety, and in its conclusions criticized the FAA for weak enforcement and secretive proceedings.

Awards

Notes and References

  1. Book: Hearings . 1969 . . 92 . en . John Hixon Shaffer, Born, February 25, 1919, in Everett, Pa..
  2. Web site: December 1, 1997 . John H. Shaffer . October 31, 2023 . Aviation Week Network.
  3. News: Lindsey . Robert . Robert Lindsey (journalist) . 1970-03-27 . Traffic Disputes and Wide Storms Snarl Airports . en-US . . 2023-10-31 . 0362-4331.
  4. June 1, 1970 . Unfriendly Skies . Root & Branch . 1 . 6–7 . libcom.org.
  5. News: April 6, 1970 . One Man's Slow-Motion Aerial Act . en-US . . live . October 31, 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160731091237/http://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,943943,00.html . July 31, 2016 . 0040-781X.
  6. Web site: December 3, 1970 . Statement of John H. Shaffer [...] Respecting Aviation Safety ]. dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100527182926/http://testimony.ost.dot.gov/test/pasttest/70test/Shaffer1.PDF . May 27, 2010 . October 31, 2023.
  7. News: May 1, 1978 . A New MLS, But Whose? . en-US . . live . subscription . October 31, 2023 . https://web.archive.org/web/20070930073835/http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,919565-1,00.html . September 30, 2007 . 0040-781X.
  8. Aircraft Accident Report: American Airlines, Inc. McDonnell Douglas DC-10-10, N103AA. Near Windsor, Ontario, Canada. 12 June 1972. . . February 28, 1973 . NTSB/AAR-73-02 . July 22, 2024.
  9. Book: The DC-10 Case: A Study in Applied Ethics, Technology, and Society . . 1992 . 978-0-7914-1087-5 . Fielder . John H. . Albany . 127–130 . Birsch . Douglas.
  10. News: Witkin . Richard . 1974-03-27 . CHANGE ON DC‐10 CALLED OPTIONAL . 2024-07-22 . . 9 . en-US . 0362-4331.
  11. Web site: NAA Wright Brothers Memorial Trophy . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20120217174319/http://www.aeroclub.org/awards/wright.htm . February 17, 2012 . October 31, 2023 . Aero Club of Washington.