Joaquim Barbosa Explained

Honorific-Prefix:His Excellency
Joaquim Barbosa
Office:Justice of the Supreme Federal Court
Term Start:June 25, 2003
Term End:July 31, 2014
Appointer:Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva
Predecessor:Moreira Alves[1]
Successor:Edson Fachin
Office1:56th President of the Supreme Federal Court
Term Start1:November 22, 2012
Term End1:July 31, 2014
Vicepresident1:Ricardo Lewandowski
Predecessor1:Ayres Britto
Successor1:Ricardo Lewandowski
Birth Name:Joaquim Benedito Barbosa Gomes
Birth Date:October 7, 1954
Birth Place:Paracatu, Minas Gerais, Brazil
Party:PSB (2018–present)
Children:Felipe
Alma Mater:University of Brasília[2]
Panthéon-Assas University

Joaquim Benedito Barbosa Gomes (pronounced as /pt/; born October 7, 1954) is a former Justice of the Supreme Federal Court in Brazil. He served as the president of the court (Chief Justice) between 2012 and 2014.

Barbosa studied law at University of Brasília (1979) and holds a master's degree (1990) and a doctorate (1993) from Panthéon-Assas University.[3] He is a Doctor Honoris Causa of Hebrew University (2015).[4]

In 2013, he was elected by Time magazine as one of the 100 most influential people in the world.[5]

Early life and education

Barbosa is the oldest son of a bricklayer father and a housewife mother.[6] He started his education in the Brazilian public school system in his hometown, later completed in Brasília.[7]

He worked as a cleaner and typesetter before attending law school at the University of Brasília[8]

Barbosa studied law at University of Brasília (1979). He holds a Master (1990) and a Doctor (1993) of Laws from DEA - Droit Public Interne - Panthéon-Assas University.[3]

Early career

After graduating from the University of Brasila, Barbosa began working for the Brazilian diplomatic service, Itamaraty, as a chancery official.[9] His first assignment was to Helsinki, Finland.[9]

Barbosa was a member of the Federal Public Ministry and adjunct professor at Rio de Janeiro State University. He was also a visiting scholar at the Human Rights Institute at Columbia Law School, in New York City (1999 to 2000), and at UCLA School of Law (2002 to 2003).[10]

Along with his position at Itamaraty, he served as a public servant for some Brazilian departments, and lately as a public prosecutor of the Public Ministry.

Aside from his academic achievements, Minister Barbosa also became fluent in French, Spanish, English and German.[9]

Supreme Federal Court

Barbosa was appointed to the office by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on June 25, 2003, along with Ayres Britto and Cezar Peluso.

Justice

Among many other actions, he is the judge rapporteur for Criminal Action 470 [11] (also known as Mensalão scandal) and his further development, the Criminal Action 536 (also known as Mensalão mineiro).[12]

As of November 2012, he has 8,460 actions under his responsibility being processed by the Court.

Barbosa suffers from sacroiliitis, an inflammatory disease, which notably makes it uncomfortable for him to remain seated. Barbosa has often been noted for his practice of attending session while standing up.[13]

President

He took the office as the acting president of the court on November 17, 2012, because of the mandatory retirement of his colleague Ayres Britto, as he was the current vice-president of the Court.[14] However, he was already the President Elect of the Court as chosen by his fellows in October 2012, keeping the tradition the oldest member not served yet as president to be elected to that position.

Barbosa demonstrates unconditional defense in some questions. He is against the power of prosecutors to file administrative investigations. He argues about transfer the competency to hear cases on slave labor to federal court. Barbosa opposes also the privileged forum for authorities. His tenure start on November 22, 2012 was attended by President Dilma Rousseff, Senate President José Sarney, among many other celebrities.[15]

The welcoming speech has been delivered by Justice Luiz Fux.[16]

Key positions

Demonstrates unconditional defense in certain administrative matters. It is against the power of the prosecutor to file administrative inquiries, or to preside police investigations. It argues that transfer the jurisdiction to hear cases of slave labor for the federal Justice. Takes the view that dispatching with lawyers should be an exception, and never a routine, to the ministers of the Supreme. Restricts the most of your attention to parts of lawyers, understanding that this liberality of the judge can not lead to inequality. The minister's position, however, is criticized by lawyers and the Bar Association of Brazil (OAB), on the grounds that dispatching with the magistrates is a right of lawyers, conferred by Law 8.906 / 94, whose art. 7, section VIII precepts to be right lawyers, "go directly to the magistrates in the rooms and work offices, regardless of previously scheduled time or another condition, observing the arrival order".The Minister Barbosa says is also against the alleged preferential jurisdiction providing the parties with greater purchasing power ("jump the queue"). The minister's stance has also been criticized for OAB, on the grounds that sometimes emergency situations really justify the reversal of the judgment order. Barbosa opposes also the privileged forum for authorities.

Controversy

The Panama Papers revealed that the former Supreme Court judge[17] paid $335,000 in cash for a condo in Miami.[18] The judge denied any wrongdoing.

A Legal Consultant

Having presided over the nation's most significant political corruption trial as a jurist, Justice Barbosa has now retired from public service. However, he remains active in his role as a legal consultant.[19] Joaquim Barbosa, acclaimed by a Brazilian newsweekly as "the poor boy who transformed Brazil," remains a steadfast advocate for knowledge dissemination and education.

Notes and References

  1. VEJA magazine, ed. 1809, p. 94, (in Portuguese).
  2. O Estado de S. Paulo, November 23, 2012, p. A4
  3. http://www.correiodopovo.com.br/blogs/juremirmachado/?p=3319 Doctorate
  4. Web site: Director Receives Degree in Honor of Hebrew University 90th Celebration | Carl R. Woese Institute for Genomic Biology.
  5. Patrick Brock, "Revista 'Time' homenageia ministro Joaquim Barbosa em NY", Terra, April 24, 2013.
  6. VEJA magazine, ed. 2024, p. 57 (in Portuguese).
  7. http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/ministro/verMinistro.asp?periodo=stf&id=39 STF website curriculum vitae
  8. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/22/joaquim-barbosa-brazil-supreme-court-justice_n_2175962.html The Huffington Post
  9. News: A Blunt Chief Justice Unafraid to Upset Brazil's Status Quo. The New York Times. 24 August 2013. Romero. Simon.
  10. http://buscatextual.cnpq.br/buscatextual/visualizacv.do?id=K4781436A8 CV Lattes
  11. http://www.stf.jus.br/arquivo/cms/publicacaoBOInternet/anexo/Acervo_mjbarbosa.xls Spreadsheet with Min. Joaquim Barbosa actions pending
  12. http://www.dcomercio.com.br/index.php/politica/sub-menu-politica/100075-barbosa-agora-manda-ouvir-testemunhas-da-ap-536 Diário do Comércio website
  13. VEJA magazine, ed. 2290, p. 78 (in Portuguese).
  14. http://www.stf.jus.br/portal/cms/verNoticiaDetalhe.asp?idConteudo=224048 STF News
  15. O Estado de S. Paulo, November 23, 2012, p. A6.
  16. O Estado de S. Paulo, November 23, 2012, p. A8.
  17. Joaquim Barbosa é o primeiro destaque brasileiro no escândalo da Mossack Fonseca. by Paulo Nogueira in "Diario do Centro do Mundo" newspaper (2016)
  18. Web site: Nehamas. Nicholas. Brazil's former top judge hid price he paid for Miami condo. April 5, 2016. Miami Herald. April 3, 2016.
  19. Web site: Justice Joaquim Barbosa Bureau of Educational and Cultural Affairs . 2024-04-27 . eca.state.gov . en.