Arab–Israeli alliance explained

Type:Unofficial coalition
Purpose:Regional security
Arab–Israeli alliance
Vat Id:(for European organizations) -->
Region:Middle East
Membership: Israel
Bahrain
Egypt
Saudi Arabia[1]
United Arab Emirates[2]
Jordan
Morocco

The Arab–Israeli alliance,[3] sometimes called the Israeli–Sunni alliance,[4] [5] refers to an unofficial security coalition comprising Israel and various Arab countries. Originally formed in the interest of the Gulf Cooperation Council, it is primarily focused on deterring the political and military ambitions of Iran (see Iran–Saudi Arabia proxy conflict and Iran–Israel proxy conflict), and has been actively promoted by the United States since the February 2019 Warsaw conference.

History

The roots of the alliance started in the 2000s, due to the decreasing importance of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict as a wedge issue and mutual tensions with Iran.[6] By 2016, GCC states had sought strengthened economic and security cooperation with Israel, which is involved in its own proxy conflict with Iran.[7] The de facto coalition emerged by November 2017,[8] upon warming ties between Israel and the Gulf States and received broad media attention in light of the February 2019 Warsaw Conference, "This week's global summit in Warsaw will test the main pillar of the Trump administration's policy in the Middle East: The belief that Israel and key Arab states can form an alliance against Iran, even when peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians seem more distant than ever."[9]

The Trump administration tried to launch a "Middle East Strategic Alliance" (also known as the "Arab NATO") including the GCC states, Egypt, Jordan, and possibly Morocco. In April 2019 Egypt announced that it would not participate. The pact has not been announced as of 11 January 2021. "The late 2020 UAE, Bahrain, and Morocco agreements to normalize relations with Israel could have constituted an alternative, insofar as the UAE and Bahrain normalization decisions were related, at least in part, to countering Iran."[10] In 2020, as part of the Abraham Accords, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Sudan,[11] and Morocco[12] signed normalization agreements with Israel. The Marshall Center analysed the Abraham Accords in October 2020, including the involvement of the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain, but before Sudan and Morocco took action; the Marshall Center described that the Abraham Accords "strengthens the informal anti-Iran alliance in the region".[13]

According to authors Yoel Gozansky an Iran expert at the Institute for National Security Studies, a Tel Aviv think tank, and professor Clive Jones, a Middle East security specialist:"Our approach lies in understanding Israel's ties with many of the Gulf monarchies, notably Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Bahrain, not as some formal alliance but rather as a manifestation of a Tacit Security Regime. This regime allows for the evolution of ties between Israel and the Gulf monarchies to be explored and analyzed while allowing us to be mindful that these relations have rarely been linear, let alone underpinned by any shared normative values."[14]

In an anniversary analysis of the Abraham Accords, Haaretz said that the accords were premised on the idea of an "Israel-Sunni" anti-Iran coalition and that normalization would help but that "it's very doubtful there ever was such a coalition, and the accords did nothing to create or solidify one."[15] In March 2022, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman said reconciliation talks with Iran would continue and "We look at Israel as a potential ally but before that it should solve its problems with the Palestinians."[16]

Negev Summit (2022)

See main article: Negev Summit. A summit at Sde Boker was hosted by Israeli foreign minister Yair Lapid on 27–28 March 2022. Attending were his American, Bahraini, Egyptian, Emirati and Moroccan counterparts.

US secretary of state Antony Blinken attended the first day and released a joint statement with minister Lapid, saying that "the US believes the JCPOA is the best way to put Iran back in the box." However, "when it comes to the most important element, we see eye-to-eye," Blinken said. "We are both committed, both determined that Iran will never acquire a nuclear weapon… Our commitment to the core principle that Iran can never acquire a nuclear weapon is unwavering. One way or another, we will continue to cooperate closely."[17] Comparing the Negev Summit to the Camp David Accords which "no one thought possible", Blinken called this the beginning of a "new dawn" for the region.

Foreign minister Nasser Bourita of Morocco relayed a message from King Mohammed VI to Blinken, saying that "when we reestablished the relations [with Israel], this is not an opportunistic move, it is a move of conviction," and promised more formal visits between the two countries’ officials, which will advance cooperation and ties further. Bourita said, "We are here today because we genuinely, sincerely, and deeply believe in peace."[18] Royal Air Morocco had opened direct flights to Tel Aviv earlier in the month.[19]

In response to the recent ISIL shooting in Hadera that killed two Israelis at a bus stop,[20] all participants condemned it. They decided to make the Negev summit a regular annual conference, and invite other regional partners, including the Palestinians, with Lapid saying, "We are today opening a door before all the peoples of the region, including the Palestinians, and offering them to replace the path of terror and destruction with a shared future of progress and success." And further, "What we are doing here is making history, building a new regional architecture based on progress, technology, religious tolerance, security and intelligence cooperation."[21] During the summit, the Bahraini foreign minister openly suggested discussing the establishment of a security-intelligence alliance, which he called a "mini-NATO", among all members of the summit countries.

Saudi rapprochement with Iran and Israel–Hamas war (2023)

In 10 March 2023, Iran and Saudi Arabia announced the resumption of relations, following a deal brokered by China.[22] Under the agreement both countries agreed to respect the other's sovereignty and not interfere in the internal affairs of the other.[23] This triggered a chain reaction in which several Arab nations that had previously established diplomatic ties with Israel began to work towards establishing diplomatic relations with Iran, such as Bahrain and Sudan.[24] [25]

After the Israel–Hamas war began in October 2023, Saudi Arabia decided to halt normalization talks with Israel.[26] In January 2024, Prince Khalid bin Bandar Al Saud, the Saudi ambassador to the United Kingdom, said in a BBC interview that Saudi Arabia was still interested in peace and normalized relations with Israel following the war, on the condition of the creation of a Palestinian state.[27]

Military reapproachment

In June 2024, IDF Chief Herzi Halevi as well as CENTCOM chief and generals from Bahrain, Egypt the UAE, Jordan and Saudi Arabia met in secret in Bahrain in order to discuss regional security cooperation according to Axios.[28] [29]

Notes and References

  1. https://globalriskinsights.com/2019/01/the-solidifying-of-the-arab-israeli-alliance/ The solidifying Arab-Israeli Alliance
  2. Web site: Arab-Israeli Progress Seemed Impossible. That's Because of Old Assumptions.. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. 23 September 2020. 4 February 2021.
  3. Totten . Michael James . Michael Totten . 2016 . The New Arab–Israeli Alliance . World Affairs . 179 . 2 . 28–36 . 10.1177/0043820016673779 . 26369507 . 151328992.
  4. Web site: Lappin. Yaakov. Biden decision on weapons sales to Gulf states 'important test' for Israeli-Sunni alliance. JNS.org. 4 February 2021. 19 March 2021.
  5. Web site: Olson. Robert. Renewal of Turkey-Israel Relations Imminent. LobeLog. 13 June 2016. 19 March 2021.
  6. Entous. Adam. Donald Trump's New World Order. The New Yorker. 18 June 2018. 26 January 2021.
  7. News: Ramani. Samuel. Israel Is Strengthening Its Ties With The Gulf Monarchies. 14 September 2016. HuffPost. 12 September 2016.
  8. News: What's shaping the Israel-Saudi 'alliance'. Marcus. Jonathan. 24 November 2017. BBC News. 20 January 2020.
  9. Web site: https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/.premium-warsaw-summit-will-test-u-s-gamble-on-israeli-arab-pact-against-irantz. 13 February 2019. 4 February 2021.
  10. Web site: Iran's Foreign and Defense Policies . Congressional Research Service . 24 . 11 January 2021.
  11. Web site: Israel Urges U.S., Europe to Bolster Ties With Sudan, Citing Apparent Split With Iran. Haaretz. Barak. Ravid. 7 September 2016. 4 February 2021.
  12. Web site: Nahmias . Omri . Harkov . Lahav . Cashman . Greer Fay . 11 December 2020 . Morocco, Israel normalize ties as US recognizes Western Sahara . 4 February 2021 . The Jerusalem Post.
  13. News: Norlen. Tova. Sinai. Tamir. The Abraham Accords – Paradigm Shift or Realpolitik?. 23 March 2021. Marshall Center. October 2020.
  14. Book: Clive. Jones. Yoel. Gozansky. Fraternal Enemies: Israel and the Gulf Monarchies. April 2020. Oxford University Press. 978-0-19-752187-8.
  15. News: Abraham Accords a year on: Israel's biggest challenges remain. Pinkas. Alon. 13 August 2021. Haaretz.
  16. News: Alashray . Enas . Chmaytelli . Maher . 2022-03-03 . Israel can become a "potential ally" if Palestinian conflict resolved - Saudi crown prince . en . Reuters . Boyle . Jon . live . 2023-08-02 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221030162256/https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israel-can-become-potential-ally-if-palestinian-conflict-resolved-saudi-crown-2022-03-03/ . 30 October 2022.
  17. Web site: Harkov . Lahav . 27 March 2022 . Negev Summit: Israel, Arab states discuss regional defense alliance . 28 March 2022 . The Jerusalem Post . en-US.
  18. Web site: Kasraoui . Safaa . Negev Summit: Moroccan FM Vows Strengthened Cooperation with Israel . 28 March 2022 . Morocco World News . en.
  19. Web site: Aamari . Oussama . Moroccan FM Arrives in Israel for 'Historic' Negev Summit . 28 March 2022 . Morocco World News . en.
  20. News: 27 March 2022 . At least 2 Israelis killed by terrorists in Hadera shooting spree . en . Ynetnews . 28 March 2022.
  21. News: 28 March 2022 . Israel's Negev Summit wraps in unanimous condemnation of terror attack . en . Ynetnews . 28 March 2022.
  22. Web site: Gans . Jared . 2023-03-11 . Five things to know about the Iran-Saudi deal brokered by China . 2023-10-27 . The Hill . en-US.
  23. News: Wintour . Patrick . editor . Patrick Wintour Diplomatic . 2023-03-10 . Iran and Saudi Arabia agree to restore ties after China-brokered talks . en-GB . The Guardian . 2023-10-27 . 0261-3077.
  24. News: 2023-07-06 . Iran and Sudan look to restore diplomatic ties . en . Reuters . 2023-10-27.
  25. News: 2023-06-13 . Bahrain, Iran likely to restore diplomatic ties soon, US diplomat says . en . Reuters . 2023-10-27.
  26. Web site: Saudi Arabia wanted to 'de-risk' the Middle East. Instead it has to hit pause on normalization with Israel . 2023-10-27 . Fortune . en.
  27. Web site: 2024-01-09 . Saudi Arabia wants peace with Israel after Gaza war, envoy tells BBC . 2024-01-10 . The Jerusalem Post . en-US.
  28. News: Ravid . Barak . Scoop: U.S. holds meeting with Israeli and Arab generals amid Gaza war . Axios.
  29. Web site: 2024-06-12 . Under the radar: IDF chief meets with CENTCOM, Arab generals in Bahrain - report . 2024-06-13 . The Jerusalem Post JPost.com . en.