Israel–Pakistan relations explained

The State of Israel and the Islamic Republic of Pakistan have never had formal diplomatic relations. In 1947, Pakistan voted against the United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine, and currently does not recognize Israeli sovereignty. Despite the Pakistani position on the Arab–Israeli conflict, there have been multiple instances of the two countries closely cooperating during events such as the Soviet–Afghan War and the Black September conflict. With regard to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, Pakistan supports the Palestinian Arabs and endorses the two-state solution. The Pakistani government has maintained that it will not pursue a normalized relationship with Israel until the establishment of an independent Palestinian state within the pre-1967 borders and with East Jerusalem as the Palestinians' capital city.^[1] Nevertheless, with Turkey serving as their middle ground, Israel and Pakistan have used their embassies and consulates-general in the cities of Ankara and Istanbul to communicate and exchange necessary information with each other.^[2] In 2010, the Pakistani newspaper Dawn reported that Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence, following up on reports received in Washington, had gone through Ankara to pass on newly discovered information to Israel's Mossad about an upcoming terrorist attack in Mumbai, India, where a Jewish cultural centre was listed as a major target;^[3] this information first surfaced on WikiLeaks one year after the 2008 Mumbai attacks were carried out by Lashkar-e-Taiba, a Pakistan-based terrorist organization.^[4]

In 2018, Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, while on an official visit to India, stated that Israel is not an enemy of Pakistan and that Pakistan "should not behave like an enemy" towards Israel.^{[5] [6]}

Following the success of the Abraham Accords in 2020, erstwhile Pakistani prime minister Imran Khan disclosed that the United States and "at least one other country" had been mounting increased diplomatic pressure on his administration to normalize ties with Israel. He did not reveal the countries' names and did not say whether or not they were from the Muslim world, but explained that "the pressure is because of Israel's deep impact in the United States,"^[7] and that "Israel’s lobby is the most powerful, and that’s why America’s whole Middle East policy is controlled by Israel."^[8] Khan's administration later reiterated that Pakistan would not establish any official bilateral relationship with Israel until a "viable, independent, and contiguous" country is created for and accepted by the Palestinians.^{[9] [10]}

Background

Earlier, Muhammad Ali Jinnah played pivotal role in the awareness struggle on the Palestine issue in the Subcontinent. In post Khilafat Movement scenario, All India Muslim League (AIML) kept staunch support to Palestine and rights of the Arabs. The decade of 1930's witnessed significant developments on Palestine under leadership of Muhammad Ali Jinnah. League, under Jinnah, not only broadened its basis among the masses but also took up Palestine issue through various measures inside and outside India. Jinnah and Allama Muhammad Iqbal put Palestine issue on top of agenda list of the meetings and sessions and opined that 'Balfour Declaration was unjust'.^{[11] [12]} When the Lahore Resolution was passed in March 1940 by the AIML, Jinnah also permitted a resolution on the status of Palestine to be moved, whereby support for the Palestinian cause was reaffirmed.^{[13] [14]} Just a few days after partition, Jinnah announced to send a delegation to Cairo under Abdur Rehman Siddiqui to participate in Inter-Parliamentary World Congress on Palestine to be held in last week of August 1947. Furthermore, Zafrullah Khan was sent to represent Pakistan in the United Nations. He attended deliberations of UN Ad Hoc Committee over Palestine and vividly declared Balfour Declaration as illegitimate and clearly rejected partition of Palestine that Pakistan would not accept that unjust plan.

On October 12, 1945, Muhammad Ali Jinnah said,^{[15] [16]}

History

Following the Israeli Declaration of Independence in May 1948, David Ben-Gurion attempted to contact Muhammad Ali Jinnah via a telegram to establish diplomatic ties, but received no particular response.^{[17] [18]} By 1949, Israel's Foreign Ministry believed that it was possible to open an Israeli legation in the Karachi Federal Capital Territory of Pakistan, or to begin conducting trade openly.^[19] Initial contact between Pakistani diplomats in London and representatives of Israel along with various Jewish organizations was made in early 1950.^[19] The Pakistani government was asked to issue passage permits to India for a few hundred Jews who wished to leave Afghanistan and emigrate to Israel.^[19] The government rejected the request and the Afghan Jews left through Iran.^{[19] [11]}

In 1952, Pakistani foreign minister Muhammad Zafarullah Khan promoted hardline state policies against Israel, and advocated for Pakistan's unwavering support for the Palestinians in the Arab–Israeli conflict.^[19] Thus, Khan's policy laid the groundwork for Pakistan's strategic ties with the Arab world.^[19]

Political tension

Pakistani attitudes towards Israel

See also: Antisemitism in Pakistan. During the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, Israel's diplomatic mission in Washington received information that Pakistan was trying to provide military assistance to the Palestinians alongside rumours that a Pakistani military battalion would be sent to Palestine to fight the Israelis. Pakistan had apparently bought 250,000 rifles in Czechoslovakia that were meant for the Arabs, and a later discovery revealed that Pakistan had bought three military-grade aircraft in Italy for the Egyptians.^{[20] [19]}

The Pakistan Air Force sent a group of its fighter pilots to engage the Israelis in combat during the 1967 Six-Day War and the 1973 Yom Kippur War, greatly bolstering the Palestinians who were suffering repeated defeats to the Israel Defense Forces. A Pakistani fighter pilot, Saiful Azam, had shot down at least four Israeli fighter planes during the Six-Day War.^[21] After the Yom Kippur War, Pakistan and the PLO signed an agreement for training PLO officers in Pakistani military institutions.^[22] During the 1982 Israel-Lebanon War, irregular Pakistani volunteers served in the PLO and 50 were taken prisoner during the Siege of Beirut.

The relationship between Pakistan and Israel continued to be ridden with hostilities following these direct engagements, and when Mossad was unable to stop Pakistan's nuclear weapons program from making major developments, a plan to bomb Pakistani nuclear facilities in a similar fashion to Operation Opera was authorized. Israel subsequently made contact with India in an effort to gain support and secure a launching point for Israel's aircraft. However, India refused to allow Israeli aircraft to station on its soil, whereas Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) agency had discovered the plan and prepared suicidal one-way retaliatory measures to bomb strategic sites in Israel.^{[23] [24]}

According to Time Magazine, French intellectual Bernard-Henri Lévy said that Daniel Pearl, a Jewish American journalist, was assassinated by elements with backing from Pakistan's ISI over his alleged role in attempting to gather information linking a continued relationship between the ISI and the Taliban.^[25] According to other reports from BBC and Time, Pakistani militants murdered him because of their belief that Pearl was an Israeli Mossad agent who had infiltrated Pakistan under the cover of being an American journalist.^{[26] [27]} Pakistan's religiously-oriented political parties such as Jamaat-e-Islami and militant groups such as Lashkar-e-Taiba fiercely oppose any relationship with Israel, and have repeatedly called for the destruction of Israel due to its standing as an alleged sworn enemy of Pakistan.^{[28] [29]} Currently, as Pakistan refuses to recognize Israel until a viable solution is reached with Palestine, all Pakistani citizens are unable to travel to Israel, with Pakistani passports bearing an inscription outlining the invalidity of the passport for this purpose.^{[30] [31] [32]}

Tashbih Sayyed was a well-known Pakistani-American scholar and Zionist who openly expressed his support for relations between Israel and Pakistan in many of his columns and writings throughout his journalistic career.^[33]

Israeli attitudes towards Pakistan

In the 1980s, Israel was said to have planned, with or without Indian assistance, a possible attack on Pakistan's nuclear facilities^{[23] [24]} that would be reminiscent of the Israeli attack previously carried out on an Iraqi nuclear reactor in 1981. Using satellite imagery and intelligence information, Israel reportedly built a full-scale mock-up of the Kahuta nuclear facility in the Negev desert region where Israeli pilots in F-16 and F-15 squadrons practiced mock attacks.

According to The Asian Age, British journalists Adrian Levy and Catherine Scott-Clark stated in their book Deception: Pakistan, the US and the Global Weapons Conspiracy that the Israeli Air Force was to launch an air attack on Pakistan's nuclear facility in Kahuta sometime during the mid-1980s from an airfield in Jamnagar, Gujarat, India. The book claims that "in March 1984, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi signed off (on) the Israeli-led operation bringing India, Pakistan and Israel to within a hair's breadth of a nuclear conflagration".^[34] Israel's plan met with disapproval from some Indian officials on the grounds that Israel would not face any major consequences after the strike while India would surely face full-scale retaliation—possibly nuclear—from Pakistan for its involvement in the Israeli attack. The plan was discouraged out of the fear of a fourth Indo-Pakistani war starting as a consequence of this operation, and was shelved indefinitely after Indira Gandhi was assassinated in 1984.

A paper published in the U.S. Air Force Air University system—India Thwarts Israeli Destruction of Pakistan's "Islamic Bomb"—also confirmed this plan's existence. It stated that "Israeli interest in destroying Pakistan's Kahuta reactor to scuttle the 'Islamic bomb' was blocked by India's refusal to grant landing and refuelling rights to Israeli warplanes in 1982." India's refusal to cooperate forced Israel—which on its part wanted the attack to be a joint Indian-Israeli strike to avoid being held solely responsible—to drop the plan.^[35]

In October 2015, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu cancelled his booking at a dine-in hotel in New York City, due to the fact that Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif was dining in at the same time to avoid a confrontation over what Sharif stated to be "Israel's naked brutality in Palestine".^[36] In October 2019, Israeli-American travel vlogger and internet personality Alyne Tamir visited Pakistan for the first time.^[37] She had applied for a visa alongside her Arab-Israeli fiancé Naseir Yassin (of "Nas Daily" fame) earlier though it had been rejected, presumably due to their Israeli nationality.^[38]

Intelligence cooperation

Despite their hostilities, both countries are reported to have directorates to deal with each other at an intelligence level.^[39] The history of Israeli–Pakistani intelligence cooperation dates back to at least the early 1980s, when Pakistani President Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq directed the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) to establish contact with Israel's Mossad.^[40] Intelligence offices were set up at both countries' embassies in Washington, where the ISI, MI6, CIA and Mossad ran a decade-long anti-Soviet operation in Afghanistan, codenamed Operation Cyclone.^[41] During this operation, Israel supplied Soviet-made weaponry (seized from Palestinian militants) to the Afghan mujahideen, who were waging guerrilla warfare against the Soviet military following its invasion of Afghanistan. Pakistan and Israel cooperated very closely during the entirety of the conflict and the Pakistani military—which was covertly engaging Soviet aircraft (by posing as an Afghan rebel force) and providing the mujahideen with funds and weapons—received a generous amount of Israeli armaments and aid as a result.^[41]

WikiLeaks, in a disclosed United States diplomatic cable, revealed that around early 2008, Pakistan's ISI had secretly passed on vital intelligence and data to Israel's Mossad. The ISI had intercepted information alluding to a possible major attack by terrorists in Mumbai, India that Israeli citizens may be targeted in. This turned out to be a valid report as on 26 November 2008, the notorious Mumbai terrorist attacks were carried out by Lashkar-e-Taiba, a terrorist group which had, among other targets, attacked a Jewish centre known as the Nariman House.^[42] Following these attacks, It was reported that Pakistani Lieutenant-General Ahmad Shuja Pasha was in direct contact with Israel's Mossad.^[43]

During the Cold War, Israel was part of the United States-led Western Bloc to which non-aligned Pakistan was allied, whereas non-aligned India was allied to the Soviet Union-led Eastern Bloc. Consequently, India supported the Soviets in Afghanistan as well as the pro-Soviet Afghan leader Mohammad Najibullah. American-allied Pakistan and Israel strongly opposed the Soviet invasion, and Israel and the United States ran arms and funds to and through Pakistan in support of the Afghan mujahideen. Israel had captured the Soviet armaments from Palestinian and other Arab groups (who were all supported by the Soviet Union) from previous conflicts.^[41]

Normalization of ties

Discussions on Diplomatic ties

Some Israeli leaders believe that diplomatic relations with Pakistan should be established as the latter could possibly serve as a bridge or mediator between Israel and the Muslim world, including the Arab states.^[44] Although the governments of Israel and Pakistan do not officially have diplomatic relations with each other, there have been a number of instances of close contact and cooperation between the two states.^[45] According to the Pakistani news outlet Daily Jang, there are continuous reports that many top Pakistani leaders and representatives have visited Israel. Former Foreign Minister of Pakistan Khurshid Kasuri supported the establishment of diplomatic ties between Pakistan and Israel.^[46] Former Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf has openly spoken for the immediate pursuit of close diplomatic relations with Israel as soon as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict reaches a viable solution. He expressed that Pakistan will full-heartedly recognize Israel and come forward for open relations when a two-state solution that gives equal opportunities to the Palestinians and Israelis is achieved and peace is restored. He is the first Pakistani to be interviewed by American-Israeli Haaretz writer Danna Harman in London.^[47] In 2016, a Pakistani Ph.D. scholar and writer, Malik Shah Rukh, started the Israel–Pakistan Friendship Group, which campaigns for a diplomatic relationship between the two nations. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, on an official visit to India in 2017, responded to speculations that Israel's engagement in pursuing closer ties with India was to bolster its position against Pakistan, stating "We [Israel] are not an enemy of Pakistan and Pakistan should not be our enemy either." Following this, in 2018, widespread news (especially in Israeli media outlets) had begun to surface about an Israeli passenger aircraft stopping and staying in Pakistan for a day—stirring rumours that Israeli diplomats had made a covert official visit to Pakistan. There have been increased calls in Pakistan for pursuit of relations with Israel in light of what some Pakistanis view as the Arab world's naked abandonment of Pakistan—which had diplomatically, financially and militarily supported the Arabs against Israel during the Arab-Israeli wars—in regards to the Kashmir conflict with India.^{[48] [49] [50]}

Alleged Military links

Britain's Department for Business, Innovation and Skills revealed in 2013 that Israel had exported military technology to Pakistan. It was also reported that Israel sought to purchase British military equipment such as electronic warfare systems and military-grade aircraft parts that were meant for the Pakistanis.^[51] Israel and Pakistan both immediately denied the report and called the revelations "misleading".^[52] It was unknown why Israel was possibly exporting military equipment to Pakistan covertly, but speculations were made that could be to bolster Pakistan's fight against insurgents and terrorists waging wars inside the country.

Sports ties

Israel and Pakistan have not participated in any sports together with the exception of a single football match in which they played against each other at the 1960 AFC Asian Cup qualifiers. During the 2002 Wimbledon Open, Israeli tennis player Amir Hadad teamed up with Pakistani tennis player Aisam-ul-Haq Qureshi to play in the 3rd round doubles together. The duo would later break news headlines as the first open Israeli-Pakistani partnership anywhere, which was positively received in both Israel and Pakistan alike albeit criticized by Pakistan's conservative religious parties.^[53]

Dan Kiesel, an Israeli Jew with German citizenship, served as the Pakistan national cricket team's trainer and physiotherapist while living in Lahore.^[54] During his time in Lahore, which he described as "a beautiful city", Kiesel said he never hid his identity as an Israeli Jew and that he never faced any problems or feel threatened as a result of this.^[54]

Timeline

• 1948—Various news outlets report that first contact between Pakistan and Israel were made in the early days of Pakistan's independence in August 1947, when Israeli Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion sent a secret message via telegram to Muhammad Ali Jinnah (the founder of Pakistan) asking him to recognize Israel when it declares independence, which happened in 1948. Jinnah reportedly did not give any particular response to Israel, possibly due to his severely deteriorating health and succumbed to his illnesses later that year.
• 1949—Philippine Airlines became the only carrier to establish a direct air link between Karachi and Tel Aviv as a sector on their Manila–London service,^[55] however it is not known whether they had traffic rights between the two which would allow passengers and cargo to be flown on the route.
• 1950—Initial contact between the Pakistani ambassador in London and representatives of Israel and Jewish organizations was made in early 1950 in an attempt to open legations in Karachi or at least conduct trade openly.
• 1953—A meeting took place in New York between Pakistani diplomat Zafrullah Khan and Israeli diplomat Abba Eban on January 14 to discuss Israeli–Pakistani relations.^[20]
• 1980s—During the Soviet–Afghan War (1979-1989), the CIA, MI6, ISI and Mossad ran a covert operation named Operation Cyclone in Afghanistan to combat the Soviet invasion. During the operation Israel and Pakistan had high-level contact through their intelligence agencies, including various military dealings. Israel also supported Pakistan by providing seized Soviet-made weapons from Palestinian insurgents to Pakistan during this period.^[40]
• 1981—After Israel's attack on Iraq's Osirak nuclear reactor, a similar plan to attack Pakistan's Kahuta nuclear facility with the help of India was foiled when Pakistani intelligence discovered the plan and foiled it by taking preventative measures, including plans for retaliatory airstrikes on critical facilities in Israel.^{[56] [34]}
• 1993—Former Prime Minister of Pakistan Benazir Bhutto, along with her then-Director-General of the Pakistani military, Pervez Musharraf had intensified the ISI's liaison with Mossad in 1993. Bhutto is said to have had a secret meeting in New York with a senior Israeli emissary, who flew to the U.S. during her visit to Washington, D.C. in 1995.
• 1998—After Pakistan publicly conducted its first series of nuclear weapons testing a few days after India, then-Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif sent a secret courier to his Israeli counterpart Benjamin Netanyahu, assuring Israel that Pakistan will not share its nuclear technology with Iran to aide in their nuclear program.
• 2001—Pakistan's ISI passed intelligence about the nuclear ambitions of Iran and Libya, whose program allegedly had the help of Pakistani scientists.^[57]
• 2003—Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf raised the debate of possible diplomatic relations with Israel.^[58]
• 2004—Pakistan postponed a UN Food and Agriculture Organisation meeting scheduled in Islamabad for March, which would have also been attended by Israel's minister for agriculture Israel Katz. It would have been the first visit by an Israeli minister to Pakistan. Pakistan's foreign ministry insisted that while Katz may have been a member of the UN delegation, he was not issued an invitation by Pakistan. However, Katz stated he had been invited to Pakistan and was looking forward to the visit. According to Katz, relations between the two sides had improved since they were collaborating with the United States in the War on Terror.^[59]
• 2005—The foreign ministers of the two countries, Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri and Silvan Shalom, held official talks for the first time, in Istanbul on 1 September.^[60] Before the meeting, Musharraf had met Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas and Saudi Arabian King Abdullah, both of whom supported the talks.^[60] Shalom hailed the talks as having a "tremendous significance" in regards to not only Israel's relations with Pakistan, but with the Muslim world. Describing it as a "historic meeting", he was optimistic about establishing a "full diplomatic relationship with Pakistan as we would like it with all Muslim and Arab countries".^[60] However, following the meeting, Musharraf said Pakistan would not recognize the State of Israel until an independent Palestinian state is established^[61] —in Musharraf's words: "Pakistan will eventually recognize Israel".^[62] On 15 September, Israeli media reported that Musharraf and Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon had a cordial but informal interaction during the World Summit at the UN Headquarters.^[63]
• 2005—On 17 September, Pervez Musharraf was invited to address the American Jewish Congress in New York at a dinner hosted by Jack Rosen in his honour. The event came in the backdrop of Pakistan's decision to "engage Israel" following the latter's pullout from Gaza and the West Bank.^[64] Musharraf was given a standing ovation by Jewish Americans,^[64] and talked about his doctrine of Enlightened Moderation while adding that Pakistan wanted to pursue formal bilateral ties with Israel. He also said that "Pakistan has no direct conflict with Israel, and we are not a threat to Israel's security. We believe Israel represents no threat to Pakistan's national security. But our people have deep sympathy for the Palestinian people, and their legitimate desire for a state".^{[64] [65]} Visibly moved by the reception, he added that he did not expect a Pakistani leader "to be greeted by this community with this sort of ovation".^[64]
• 2010—According to unconfirmed "leaked" American diplomatic cables, the head of Pakistan's ISI, Lieutenant-General Ahmad Shuja Pasha passed on intelligence of the discovery of potential terrorist attacks in Mumbai, India to Israel through Washington. According to the cable, "He had been in direct touch with the Israelis on possible threats against Israeli targets in India." A few weeks before the cable was written, Israel had issued a travel advisory warning of possible attacks against Jewish sites in India.^{[42] [66]}
• 2011—Israel was alleged to have exported British military technology to Pakistan.^{[51] [52]}
• 2012—British-Pakistani MP Sajid Javid made a speech which was very positively received by the Jewish Chronicle, the oldest continuously published Jewish newspaper in the world.^[67] Known for his pro-Israel views, Javid was tipped as the future prime minister, to which a guest reportedly replied: "Of Britain, or Israel?"^[68]
• 2015—An Arab-Israeli scientist, Ramzi Suleiman, attended a scientific conference sponsored by the Pakistan Academy of Sciences and held in Lahore, Pakistan.^[69]
• 2016—A Pakistani PhD scholar and writer, Malik Shah Rukh, started the Israel-Pakistan Friendship Group, which campaigns for a diplomatic relationship between the two nations.
• 2017—During an official visit to India, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu dismissed suggestions that his country's partnership with India is a threat to Pakistan, saying, "We (Israel) are not enemies of Pakistan and Pakistan should not be our enemy either."^[70]
• 2018—It was speculated by Israel's largest newspaper that an Israeli business jet landed and stayed in Islamabad for ten hours. According to the details, the private aircraft had departed Tel Aviv with a brief stopover in Amman, where it assigned itself a new call sign en route to Islamabad. The alleged trip happened a day before Benjamin Netanyahu's state visit to Oman.^[71] There was further talk that this could have been the first visit to Pakistan by Benjamin Netanyahu or high-ranking Israeli officials.^[72] Responding to the media frenzy, Pakistani government officials rejected the veracity of the report and denied that any such visit took place.^[71] However, a pilot and three staff members at Nur Khan Airbase privately confirmed to the Middle East Eye that they had seen the aircraft and witnessed a vehicle receive a delegation at the steps of the plane.^[73]
• 2020—Following the U.S.-brokered normalization agreement and establishment of diplomatic ties between the UAE and Israel, with Muslim nations Bahrain and Sudan also following suit, Pakistani prime minister Imran Khan dismissed any possibility of his country doing the same, stating that "Pakistan will never recognize Israel until Palestinians are given their right of a just settlement."^[74] According to Khan, this was also in line with the stated position of Pakistan's founder, Jinnah.^[74] In a later interview, Khan hinted that there had been "pressure" on Pakistan from some quarters in the United States and certain Muslim countries with whom Pakistan enjoyed "good relations" (speculatively Saudi Arabia)^[75] to recognise Israel, however Pakistan would maintain its position.^[76] In a television interview with Israel's i24 News, Pakistani journalist Mubasher Lucman supported the idea of Pakistan having diplomatic ties with Israel albeit without the involvement of any third party, remarks which earned him domestic backlash and criticism.^{[77] [78]}
• 2020—A political aide of prime minister Imran Khan, Zulfi Bukhari, was alleged to have visited Tel Aviv, Israel, using his British passport aboard a Pakistani military jet which landed in Amman in November. Bukhari reportedly met with Mossad's chief Yossi Cohen to deliver a message from Khan and Pakistan's army chief, general Qamar Javed Bajwa. Bukhari strongly refuted the reports. However, the Israeli newspaper Haaretz maintained its claim regarding the trip.^[79]
• 2022—A 15-member delegation including Pakistan Television (PTV) journalist Ahmed Qureshi, Pakistani Jewish citizen Fishel Benkhald, and a group of Pakistani-Americans visited Israel to participate in an interfaith harmony dialogue. The trip was sponsored by the non-governmental organisation Sharaka to facilitate engagement between Muslims and Jews. The delegation met Israeli president Isaac Herzog and diplomat Dani Dayan among others. Qureshi claimed that former prime minister Imran Khan had been willing to establish contacts with Israel, and that the delegation's trip had also been approved by his government.^{[80] [81]} Israeli president Herzog later publicly acknowledged the meeting at the World Economic Forum: "And I must say this was an amazing experience. We haven't had a group of Pakistani leaders in Israel in such scope. And that all stems from the Abraham Accords, meaning Jews and Muslims can dwell together in the region...".^[82]
• 2023—Pakistan strongly supports Palestinians in Gaza after Israel–Hamas war breaks out. "The first lesson of the Gaza war is that the so-called recognition of Israel debate or discussion in Pakistan has been buried, and rightly so," Senator Mushahid Hussain, the defense committee chair of the upper house of the Pakistani parliament, said in an interview with the media.^[83]

See also

• International recognition of Israel
• International recognition of Palestine
• Pakistanis in Israel
• History of the Jews in Pakistan
• Israel-Palestine relations
• Pakistan–Palestine relations

Further reading

• Why Israel and Pakistan can never be allies
• Americans Have Cuba, but for One Pakistani Woman, Israel Is the Forbidden Destination
• P. R. Kumaraswamy, "Beyond the Veil: Israel-Pakistan Relations", Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies, Tel Aviv University, Memorandum no. 55, March 2000
• Burzine Waghmar, "Jinnah's Jews: a Jeremiad", Studies on Israel, CSS 5, ed. Mahendra Gaur, FPRC, New Delhi, 2015, pp. 213-235
• Moshe Yegar, "Pakistan and Israel", Jewish Political Studies Review 19:3–4 (Fall 2007)
• P. R. Kumaraswamy, "The Strangely Parallel Careers of Israel and Pakistan", Middle East Quarterly, June 1997, pp. 31–39
• Rashid Ahmad Khan, "Pakistan's Policy Towards Arab–Israel Conflict (1948–1973)", PhD thesis, University of Punjab, Feb 1991.
• Book: Karsh . Efraim . Efraim Karsh . Israel in the International Arena . Israel: The First Hundred Years . IV . 2007 . Taylor & Francis . 978-0714649603 . 249–267.
• Paul Rockower, "Dancing in the Dark: Pulling the Veil off Israel–Pakistan Relations", Moshe Ma'oz (ed.), Sussex, 2010, p. 186–214.
• Pakistan in contact with Israel over recovery of 16 missing persons: Sartaj Aziz
• Web site: Pakistan Israel Friendship Group. 6 January 2018. Israel Pakistan Friendship Group. https://web.archive.org/web/20180114132156/http://www.israelpakistan.com/. 14 January 2018. 6 January 2018. bot: unknown.

Notes and References

1. Web site: Kaura . Vinay . 6 October 2020 . Pakistan's Israel dilemma . 24 September 2023 . . en.
2. Web site: Jamal . Umair . 28 December 2020 . Why Are Pakistani Leaders Revealing Their Secret Visits to Israel Now? . 4 January 2021 . . en-US.
3. Web site: 1 December 2010 . ISI chief met Israelis to stop India attack: WikiLeaks . 25 April 2020 . . en.
4. News: Ravid . Barak . 1 December 2010 . WikiLeaks: Pakistan Tipped Off Israel on Terror Threats in India . en . . 25 April 2020.
5. Web site: 20 January 2018 . Israel not enemy of Pakistan: Netanyahu . 24 September 2023 . . en.
6. Web site: Wajeeh . Muhammad . 19 January 2018 . Israel not an enemy of Pakistan: Netanyahu . 24 September 2023 . . en.
7. News: 17 November 2020 . U.S., Another Country 'Pressuring Pakistan to Recognize Israel,' Says PM Imran Khan . en . . 4 January 2021.
8. Web site: Harkov . Lahav . 16 November 2020 . Pakistan's PM Imran Khan pressured to recognize Israel . 4 January 2021 . . en-US.
9. Web site: Gul . Ayaz . 24 November 2020 . Pakistan: No Plans to Recognize Israel . 4 January 2021 . . en.
10. Web site: 3 September 2020 . One-sided deal imposed on the Palestinians will not work: PM Khan . 4 January 2021 . . en.
11. Qaisar . Shahzad . July–December 2018 . QUAID-I-AZAM MUHAMMAD ALI JINNAH AND PALESTINE QUESTION . Journal of Historical Studies . IV . II . 35–55 . 4 July 2020.
12. Web site: Iqbal And Jinnah On Palestine . Allamaiqbal.com . 2022-04-14.
13. Book: Muslim League Session 1940 & the Lahore Resolution: Documents. 1990. National Institute of Historical and Cultural Research. 978-969-415-022-2. 110. When Dr. Alam had finished, Mr. Jinnah announced that he would permit one resolution relating to Palestine to be moved in the open session....
14. Book: Syed Sharifuddin Pirzada. Sharifuddin Pirzada. The Pakistan Resolution and the Historic Lahore Session. 1968. Pakistan Publications. The All-India Muslim League views with grave concern the inordinate delay on the part of the British Government in coming to a settlement with the Arabs in Palestine, and places on record its considered opinion, in clear and unequivocal language, that no arrangements of a peacemeal character will be made in Palestine which are contrary in spirit and opposed to the pledges given to the Muslim world, and particularly to the Muslims in India, to secure their active assistance in the War of 1914–18....
15. Pirzada . Syed . Quaid-I-Azam and Islamic Solidarity . December 1976 . Pakistan Horizon . 29 . 4 . 60–72 . 41393325 . 4 July 2020.
16. https://web.archive.org/web/20170101234423/http://globetribune.info/2012/07/12/pakistan-and-israel-muhammad-ali-jinnah-and-the-jews/ Pakistan and Israel, Muhammad Ali Jinnah and the Jews
17. Web site: Today. Israel. Could Israel and Pakistan be Friends?. Israeltoday.co.il. 18 February 2013.
18. The Strangely Parallel Careers of Israel and Pakistan. July 4, 2012. P. R. Kumaraswamy. June 1997. IV. 2. The Middle East Quarterly. 31–39. Pakistan is like Israel, an ideological state. Take out the Judaism from Israel and it will fall like a house of cards. Take Islam out of Pakistan and make it a secular state; it would collapse. —Zia ul-Haq, Pakistan's ruler, December 1981.
19. Web site: Pakistan and Israel. Moshe Yegar. 2007. Dr. Moshe Yegar, Jewish Political Studies Review. Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20081010233850/http://www.jcpa.org/JCPA/Templates/ShowPage.asp?DRIT=5&DBID=1&LNGID=1&TMID=111&FID=625&PID=0&IID=1899&TTL=Pakistan_and_Israel . 2008-10-10.
20. Moshe Yegar, "Pakistan and Israel", Jewish Political Studies Review 19:3–4 (Fall 2007)
21. Web site: Have Jet — Will Travel: The Story of Saiful Azam, Fighter Pilot. 21 August 2013 . 13 August 2017.
22. Mushahid Hussain, "How Pakistan Views Israel and the Palestinians", Middle East International, September 1988, 21; P. R. Kumaraswamy, Beyond the Veil: Israel–Pakistan Relations (Tel Aviv: Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies, Tel Aviv University, 2000), 34
23. India Thwarts Israeli Destruction of Pakistan's "Islamic Bomb", McNair Paper Number 41, Radical Responses to Radical Regimes: Evaluating Preemptive Counter-Proliferation, May 1995
24. Web site: India Thwarts Israeli Destruction of Pakistan's "Islamic Bomb" . Institute of National Strategic Studies . May 1995 . July 4, 2012 . 24 December 2018 . https://web.archive.org/web/20181224210647/https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/ . dead .
25. On the Trail of Daniel Pearl. Daren. Fonda. Time . 27 September 2003. content.time.com.
26. News: BBC News - SOUTH ASIA - Daniel Pearl: Seeker for dialogue. 26 April 2016.
27. The Odd Ordeal Of Daniel Pearl. Unmesh. Kher. Time . February 11, 2002. content.time.com.
28. Web site: Jamaat-e-Islami declares Israel, US the World's "top terrorists", Sana News. https://web.archive.org/web/20110724055848/http://www.sananews.net/english/2010/06/03/jamaat-e-islami-declares-israel-us-world-top-terrorists/. dead. July 24, 2011.
29. Web site: Protests Across Pakistan Against Israel's Commando Action On Gaza Flotilla. . The MEMRI Blog. 26 April 2016.
30. Web site: Pakistan K1 Visa Processing Times. https://web.archive.org/web/20110914044556/http://www.k1-fiancee-visa-law.com/k1-visa-processing-times/pakistan-k1-visa-processing-times/. dead. September 14, 2011.
31. http://canada-immigration-info.ca/faqs.htm Canada Immigration Info' - FAQs, Info' available as answer for the question "Are some passports better to have than others?"
32. Web site: Hubertus Hoffmann - Conflict Resolutions and World Security Solutions - worldsecuritynetwork.com. 26 April 2016. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20120323073616/http://www.worldsecuritynetwork.com/showArticle3.cfm?article_id=18511. 23 March 2012.
33. News: Tashbih Sayyed . Arutz Sheva.
34. Book: Deception: Pakistan, the US and the Global Weapons Conspiracy. Adrian. Levy. Catherine. Scott-Clark. 2007. 9781843545330. Atlantic Books.
35. Web site: Air University. www.airuniversity.af.edu. 2020-04-25.
36. Web site: Netanyahu refused to be in same restaurant as Sharif: report. 26 April 2016.
37. News: 'Pakistan went from terrorism to tourism,' says travel blogger Alyne Tamir. The Express Tribune. 14 October 2019. 28 November 2020. After starting it two years ago and having visited over 70 countries since then, the American-Israeli has finally arrived in Pakistan after getting her visa rejected the first time, when she had applied with her Facebook-famous fiance, Nas Daily..
38. Web site: Famous travel vlogger from Nas Daily is here in Pakistan!. National Courier. 9 October 2019. 28 November 2020. Danish. Hafeez. https://web.archive.org/web/20201128175314/https://www.natcour.com/news/2019/10/famous-travel-vlogger-from-nas-daily-is-here-in-pakistan/. 28 November 2020. live.
39. News: Is Pakistan like Israel or North Korea?. June 6, 2010. Ayesha Siddiqa. Ayesha Siddiqa. 1994. The Express Tribune. Pakistan has a love-hate relationship with Israel. While we abhor Tel Aviv, secretly powerful Pakistanis happily claim similarities between the two states starting with the fact that both Israel and Pakistan were created on the basis of a religious identity..
40. Charlie Wilson's War: The Extraordinary Story of How the Wildest Man in Congress and a Rogue CIA Agent Changed the History of Our Times, by George Crile, Grove Press, 2007, Chapter 10.
41. News: Pakistan got Israeli weapons during Afghan war . Daily Times Monitor . Pakistan . July 20, 2003 . July 4, 2012 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20030930073002/http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story_20-7-2003_pg1_4 . September 30, 2003 ., mirrored at Web site: Pakistan Got Israeli Weapons During Afghan War . Daily Times Monitor . 20 July 2003 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20030930073002/http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story_20-7-2003_pg1_4 . September 30, 2003.
42. News: Katz . Yaakov . WikiLeaks: Pakistan passed terror intel to Israel . Jerusalem Post . December 1, 2010 . 2010-12-02.
43. Web site: Linde. Steve. World's 50 most influential Jews. Jerusalem Post. 21 May 2010. 45. Bernard-Henri Lévy, Philosopher..
44. News: Bhutto wanted ties with Israel, sought Mossad protection . Israel Today . December 28, 2007 . July 4, 2012.
45. News: Pakistan-Israel in landmark talks . BBC News . September 1, 2005 . May 5, 2010 .
46. News: Kasuri's encounter with Israel's Shalom – an inside story . Muhsen Ali . 8 September 2015.
47. News: Relations with Israel could help Pakistan, says former president Musharraf . 10 February 2012 . Haaretz . 6 January 2012.
48. Web site: Deafening Arab States Silence Towards Kashmir's Muslims. 2020-01-16. Inside Arabia. en-US. 2020-04-25.
49. Web site: A Gulf red carpet for Modi and silence for Kashmir. Hadid. Samah. 2019-08-22. Asia Times. en-US. 2020-04-25.
50. Web site: Why have Saudi Arabia and the UAE failed to express support for Pakistan's position on Kashmir?. Hoodbhoy. Pervez. Scroll.in. en-US. 2020-04-25.
51. Web site: ISPR denies Israel arming Pakistan with hi-tech gear, says report baseless. Paktribune. 26 April 2016.
52. Web site: Israel denies exporting military equipment to Pakistan. Press Trust of India. 12 June 2013. 26 April 2016.
53. News: Sport. The Guardian . London . February 10, 2008 . May 5, 2010 .
54. News: Dan Kiesel: Our man in Pakistan . Haaretz . Ori Lewis . 12 July 2001. July 4, 2012.
55. Web site: Philippine Air Lines October 22, 1949 timetable, page 3 of 4.
56. Web site: Siddiqi . Shahid R. . How safe are Pakistan's nuclear assets . Dawn.com . https://web.archive.org/web/20101125165337/http://news.dawn.com/wps/wcm/connect/dawn-content-library/dawn/in-paper-magazine/encounter/how-safe-are-pakistans-nuclear-assets-420 . 25 November 2010 . 14 February 2010 . dead .
57. Journalist and author George Crile's book, Charlie Wilson's War (Grove Press, New York, 2003)
58. News: Musharraf opens debate on Israel relations . BBC News . 3 July 2003 . July 4, 2012 .
59. News: Pakistan denies Israel invitation. BBC. 20 January 2004. 28 November 2020.
60. News: Pakistan-Israel in landmark talks . BBC News . 1 September 2005 . July 4, 2012 .
61. News: Musharraf says Pakistan not to recognize Israel . September 2, 2005 . . People's Daily Online . July 4, 2012.
62. News: Musharraf: Pakistan will eventually recognize Israel . September 27, 2006 . ynetnews.com . July 4, 2012.
63. News: Sharon and Musharraf shake hands at UN: Israeli TV. Zee News. 15 September 2005. 28 November 2020.
64. News: U.S. Jews welcome Musharraf. yNet News. 18 September 2020. 26 November 2020. Attila. Somfalvi. https://web.archive.org/web/20180908195754/https://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3143577,00.html. 8 September 2018. live.
65. News: Musharraf to address Jews in New York. Dawn. 24 August 2005. 26 November 2020.
66. News: WikiLeaks: Pakistan tipped off Israel on terror threats in India . Barak Ravid . Reuters . Haaretz . 1 December 2010 . July 4, 2012.
67. Web site: Muslim Tory MP: After Britain, Israel is best . The Jewish Chronicle . Martin Bright . 2018-10-27.
68. News: Meet Sajid Javid, UK's top Muslim, pro-Israel politician, who just may become PM. Times of Israel. 13 May 2018. 26 November 2020. Robert. Philpot. Born to Pakistani immigrants, the new home secretary is a passionate Israel supporter who is lauded by the Jewish community for fighting anti-Semitism and BDS..
69. News: Khoury. Jack. Israeli lecturer takes part in Pakistan conference. 2 March 2015. Haaretz. Haaretz. 28 February 2015.
70. Web site: Israel not an enemy of Pakistan: Netanyahu - The Express Tribune. 19 January 2018.
71. News: Uproar over claim about Israeli jet landing in Islamabad. Dawn. 28 October 2018. 11 December 2020. Baqir Sajjad. Syed.
72. Web site: Did Israel's PM Netanyahu Secretly Visit Islamabad? How One Tweet Sparked Hysteria and a Political Crisis in Pakistan. October 31, 2018. Haaretz.
73. News: Airport staff say Israeli plane landed in Pakistan. Middle East Eye. 9 November 2018. 11 December 2020. Suddaf. Chaudry.
74. News: Pakistan will not recognise Israel: PM Khan. Al Jazeera . Aug 19, 2020.
75. News: Saudi Arabia is pressuring Pakistan to recognize Israel - report. Jerusalem Post. 19 November 2020. 11 December 2020. Zachary. Keyser.
76. News: PM says US pressuring Pakistan to recognise Israel: report. Dawn. 17 November 2020. 11 December 2020.
77. News: Pakistan 'should shake hands' with Israel, Mubashir Lucman tells Jewish TV channel. Daily Pakistan. 25 November 2020. 11 December 2020. Muhammad. Shanawer.
78. Web site: Pakistan recognizing Israel is dirty politics. But it's legitimate Opinion. 2021-01-04. Haaretz.com. en.
79. News: The Taliban Will Decide if Pakistan Recognizes Israel. Haaretz. 30 June 2021. 28 May 2022.
80. News: A Pakistani Group Visited Israel. Then Pakistan Erupted. Haaretz. 25 May 2022. 28 May 2022. Hamza Azhar. Salam.
81. News: Delegation went to Israel from US, not Pakistan: journalist. The News. 19 May 2022. 28 May 2022.
82. News: 'Great change': Israeli president says received delegation of Pakistani expats. Dawn. 29 May 2022. 1 June 2022.
83. News: Ayaz . Gul . Gaza Conflict Deals Blow to Pakistani Debate on Whether to Recognize Israel . VOA . 10 October 2023.