Iowa's 4th congressional district explained

State:Iowa
District Number:4
Image Caption:Interactive map of district boundaries since January 3, 2023
Representative:Randy Feenstra
Party:Republican
Residence:Hull
Percent Urban:50.58
Percent Rural:49.42
Population:794,584
Population Year:2022
Median Income:$68,755[1]
Percent White:82.6
Percent Hispanic:9.6
Percent Black:2.0
Percent Asian:1.9
Percent More Than One Race:3.0
Percent Other Race:0.9
Cpvi:R+16[2]

Iowa's 4th congressional district is a congressional district in the U.S. state of Iowa that covers the western border of the state, including Sioux City and Council Bluffs. Up north, it extends eastwards into Ames, Boone, Fort Dodge, and Marshalltown. It has been represented by Republican Randy Feenstra since 2021, who defeated longtime incumbent Steve King in 2020. With a Cook Partisan Voting Index rating of R+16, it is the most Republican district in Iowa, a state with an all-Republican congressional delegation.[2]

History

Since the 1880s, there have been major changes in the location or nature of Iowa's 4th Congressional District. From 1886 until 1941, the district was made up of largely rural counties in northeastern Iowa, including the easternmost five counties in the northernmost two rows[3] (and, during the 1930s, Buchanan and Delaware counties from the third row).[4] During that era, the district included areas from Mason City east to the Mississippi River.

In 1941, Iowa's 5th Congressional District (made up of rural counties in southern Iowa) was renumbered as Iowa's 4th Congressional District, and counties in the old 4th District were placed in the 3rd District and the 2nd District.[5] (In 1942, 4th District incumbent, Henry O. Talle, would defeat the 2nd District incumbent William S. Jacobsen in the new 2nd Congressional District). From 1941 until 1960 the 4th Congressional District included the central five counties of each of the two southernmost tiers, plus four counties between Des Moines and Iowa City (Mahaska, Keokuk, Jasper and Poweshiek).[5] 5th District incumbent Republican U.S. Representative Karl M. LeCompte was reelected in the reconfigured 4th District in 1942, and was reelected in the next seven races. In 1958, when LeCompte did not run for reelection, Democrat Steven V. Carter defeated Republican John Kyl. A recurrence of cancer would claim Carter's life before the end of his only term, and Kyl won the special election and next general election. In 1961 the 4th Congressional District was expanded to include five central Iowa counties - Warren, Marion, Marshall, Tama and Benton[6] - but retained its rural character. Kyl held this seat until he was swept out in the massive Democratic landslide of 1964. However, he regained his old seat in 1966, and was reelected two more times.

The rural character of the district was changed when most of its territory was merged with the Des Moines-based 5th District of Democratic incumbent Neal Smith after the 1970 census. Polk County (home to Des Moines and most of its suburbs) was added, while most of the rural counties were taken out.[7] Smith defeated Kyl in the 1972 congressional election. The district became even less rural in 1981, when Story County (home of Ames) was added, and other rural counties were taken out.[8] The district was significantly altered after the 1990 census, when it was reconfigured to take in the southwest quadrant of the state from Des Moines to Council Bluffs. Smith was reelected in 1992, but defeated in 1994 by Republican Greg Ganske.

The 2001 remap made the 4th district a north-central Iowa district. It could not be said to be the successor of any of the previous districts. It was a primarily rural district, though it included Ames and Mason City. It did not include any of the state's nine largest cities, and only four of the twenty largest Iowa cities.[9] The plan went into effect in 2003 for the 108th U.S. Congress.[10] The 5th's incumbent congressman, Tom Latham, had his home in Alexander drawn into the 4th, and was elected from this district five times.

For the 2012 elections, the Iowa Legislature passed a plan that went into effect in 2013 for the 113th U.S. Congress. The district now covers the northwest corner of the state, and essentially merged the northern half of the old 5th District with the western third of the old 4th. The new map placed Latham and 5th District incumbent Steve King in the same district. Although the new 4th was geographically more Latham's district, he opted to move to the redrawn 3rd District, leaving King to take the seat. The current 4th district is by far the most conservative in Iowa - it was the only one of the state's four districts to be won by Mitt Romney in 2012, and Donald Trump carried it by over 25 points in 2016. Additionally, King was the only Republican House member from Iowa during the 116th Congress, although he faced a close race in 2018 due to his long history of controversial comments.

In June 2020, Steve King was defeated in the Republican House primary by challenger Randy Feenstra.

Statewide races since 2000

Election results from statewide races:

OfficeYearDistrict resultWinner
StatewideNationwide
President2000George W. Bush 49% – Al Gore 48%GoreBush
2004George W. Bush 51% – John Kerry 48%Bush
2008Barack Obama 53% – John McCain 45%ObamaObama
2012Mitt Romney 53% – Barack Obama 45%
2016Donald Trump 61% – Hillary Clinton 34%TrumpTrump
2020Donald Trump 63% – Joe Biden 36%Biden

List of members representing the district

MemberPartyTermCong
ress
Electoral historyLocation
District created March 4, 1863
align=left
Josiah B. Grinnell
Republicannowrap March 4, 1863 –
March 3, 1867
Elected in 1862.
Re-elected in 1864.
Lost renomination.
1863–1873
align=left
William Loughridge
Republicannowrap March 4, 1867 –
March 3, 1871
Elected in 1866.
Re-elected in 1868.
Lost renomination.
align=left
Madison M. Walden
Republicannowrap March 4, 1871 –
March 3, 1873
Elected in 1870.
Lost renomination.
align=left
Henry O. Pratt
Republicannowrap March 4, 1873 –
March 3, 1877
Elected in 1872.
Re-elected in 1874.
Retired.
1873–1883
align=left
Nathaniel C. Deering
Republicannowrap March 4, 1877 –
March 3, 1883
Elected in 1876.
Re-elected in 1878.
Re-elected in 1880.
Retired.
align=left
Luman H. Weller
Greenbacknowrap March 4, 1883 –
March 3, 1885
Elected in 1882.
Lost re-election.
1883–1887
Allamakee, Chickasaw, Clayton, Fayette, Floyd, Howard, Mitchell, and Winneshiek counties

William E. Fuller
RepublicanMarch 4, 1885 –
March 3, 1889
Elected in 1884.
Re-elected in 1886.
Lost renomination.
1887–1933
Allamakee, Cerro Gordo, Chickasaw, Clayton, Fayette, Floyd, Howard, Mitchell, Winneshiek, and Worth counties
align=left
Joseph H. Sweney
Republicannowrap March 4, 1889 –
March 3, 1891
Elected in 1888.
Lost re-election.
align=left
Walter H. Butler
Democraticnowrap March 4, 1891 –
March 3, 1893
Elected in 1890.
Lost re-election.
align=left
Thomas Updegraff
Republicannowrap March 4, 1893 –
March 3, 1899
Elected in 1892.
Re-elected in 1894.
Re-elected in 1896.
Lost renomination.
align=left
Gilbert N. Haugen
Republicannowrap March 4, 1899 –
March 3, 1933
Elected in 1898.
Re-elected in 1900.
Re-elected in 1902.
Re-elected in 1904.
Re-elected in 1906.
Re-elected in 1908.
Re-elected in 1910.
Re-elected in 1912.
Re-elected in 1914.
Re-elected in 1916.
Re-elected in 1918.
Re-elected in 1920.
Re-elected in 1922.
Re-elected in 1924.
Re-elected in 1926.
Re-elected in 1928.
Re-elected in 1930.
Lost re-election.
align=left
Fred Biermann
Democraticnowrap March 4, 1933 –
January 3, 1939
Elected in 1932.
Re-elected in 1934.
Re-elected in 1936.
Lost re-election.
1933–1943
align=left
Henry O. Talle
Republicannowrap January 3, 1939 –
January 3, 1943
Elected in 1938.
Re-elected in 1940.
Redistricted to the .
align=left
Karl M. LeCompte
Republicannowrap January 3, 1943 –
January 3, 1959
Redistricted from the and re-elected in 1942.
Re-elected in 1944.
Re-elected in 1946.
Re-elected in 1948.
Re-elected in 1950.
Re-elected in 1952.
Re-elected in 1954.
Re-elected in 1956.
Retired.
1943–1963
align=left
Steven V. Carter
Democraticnowrap January 3, 1959 –
November 4, 1959
Elected in 1958.
Died.
Vacantnowrap November 4, 1959 –
December 15, 1959

John H. Kyl
RepublicanDecember 15, 1959 –
January 3, 1965
Elected to finish Carter's term.
Re-elected in 1960.
Re-elected in 1962.
Lost re-election.
1963–1973
align=left
Bert Bandstra
Democraticnowrap January 3, 1965 –
January 3, 1967
Elected in 1964.
Lost re-election.
align=left
John H. Kyl
Republicannowrap January 3, 1967 –
January 3, 1973
Elected in 1966.
Re-elected in 1968.
Re-elected in 1970.
Lost re-election.

Neal E. Smith
DemocraticJanuary 3, 1973 –
January 3, 1995
Redistricted from the and re-elected in 1972.
Re-elected in 1974.
Re-elected in 1976.
Re-elected in 1978.
Re-elected in 1980.
Re-elected in 1982.
Re-elected in 1984.
Re-elected in 1986.
Re-elected in 1988.
Re-elected in 1990.
Re-elected in 1992.
Lost re-election.
1973–1983
1983–1993
1993–2003
align=left
Greg Ganske
Republicannowrap January 3, 1995 –
January 3, 2003
Elected in 1994.
Re-elected in 1996.
Re-elected in 1998.
Re-elected in 2000.
Redistricted to the but retired to run for U.S. Senator.
align=left
Tom Latham
Republicannowrap January 3, 2003 –
January 3, 2013
Redistricted from the and re-elected in 2002.
Re-elected in 2004.
Re-elected in 2006.
Re-elected in 2008.
Re-elected in 2010.
Redistricted to the .
2003–2013
align=left
Steve King
Republicannowrap January 3, 2013 –
January 3, 2021
Redistricted from the and re-elected in 2012.
Re-elected in 2014.
Re-elected in 2016.
Re-elected in 2018.
Lost renomination.
2013–2023

Randy Feenstra
RepublicanJanuary 3, 2021 –
present
Elected in 2020.
Re-elected in 2022.
2023–present:

Historical election results

Year[11] WinnerSecondPercentage
Party affiliationCandidateVotesParty affiliationCandidateVotes
1920RepublicanGilbert N. Haugen53,083DemocraticCarl Evans18,10475%–25%
192232,586A. M. Schanke24,53257%–43%
192450,850J. M. Berry20,63671%–29%
192630,611Frank E. Howard20,07660%–40%
192850,488Erwin Larson31,96861%–39%
193029,224Wilbur L. Peck20,23659%–41%
1932DemocraticFred Biermann62,598RepublicanGilbert N. Haugen42,20759%–41%
193449,504C. A. Benson43,79452%–46%
193656,308Henry O. Talle51,80551%–47%
1938RepublicanHenry O. Talle48,640DemocraticFred Biermann44,60152%–48%
194066,691Morgan J. McEnaney51,55856%–44%
1942Karl M. LeCompte52,258Thomas L. Curran28,74565%–35%
194459,658Harold J. Fleck49,09855%–45%
194643,753A. E. Augustine31,20358%–42%
194853,384Steven V. Carter49,89452%–48%
195051,16838,64957%–43%
195273,317Earl E. Glassburner44,90062%–38%
195449,608Herschel C. Loveless39,65256%–44%
195658,024Steven V. Carter56,40651%–49%
1958DemocraticSteven V. Carter42,479RepublicanJohn Henry Kyl39,23352%–48%
1960RepublicanJohn Henry Kyl65,016DemocraticC. Edwin Gilmour49,91857%–43%
196265,538Gene W. Glenn51,81056%–44%
1964DemocraticBert Bandstra85,518RepublicanJohn Henry Kyl73,89854%–46%
1966RepublicanJohn Henry Kyl65,259DemocraticBert Bandstra61,07452%–48%
196883,25971,13454%–46%
197059,396Roger Blobaum49,36955%–45%
1972DemocraticNeal Edward Smith123,431RepublicanJohn Henry Kyl85,15659%–41%
197491,755Chuck Dick53,75661%–35%
1976145,343Charles E. Minor65,01369%–31%
197888,52648,30865%–35%
1980117,896Donald C. Young100,33554%–36%
1982118,849Dave Readinger60,53466%–34%
1984136,922Robert R. Lockard88,71761%–39%
1986107,27149,64168%–32%
1988157,065Paul Lunde62,05672%–28%
1990127,812unopposed2,77898%–2%
1992158,610RepublicanPaul Lunde94,04562%–37%
1994RepublicanGreg Ganske111,935 DemocraticNeal Edward Smith98,82453%–46%
1996133,419 Connie McBurney119,790 52%–47%
1998129,942 Jon Dvorak67,550 65%–34%
2000169,267 Michael L. Huston101,112 61%–37%
2002Tom Latham115,430 John Norris90,784 55%–43%
2004181,294Paul W. Johnson116,121 61%–39%
2006120,512Selden Spencer89,99457%–43%
2008184,529Becky Greenwald119,92760%–39%
2010152,588Bill Maske74,30064%–31%
2012Steve King200,831Christie Vilsack168,32353%–45%
2014169,141Jim Mowrer104,87362%–38%
2016226,719Kim Weaver142,99361%–39%
2018157,275J. D. Scholten146,73750.3%–47.0%
2020Randy Feenstra237,369144,76162.0%–37.8%

2002

2022

See also

References

General
Specific

Notes and References

  1. Web site: My Congressional District. US Census Bureau. Center for New Media & Promotion (CNMP). www.census.gov.
  2. Web site: 2022 Cook PVI: District Map and List. 2023-01-10. Cook Political Report. July 12, 2022 . en.
  3. "The Congressional Districts," Waterloo Courier, 1886-04-14 at 4; Iowa's Official Register (1930).
  4. Iowa's Official Register, 1933-34, at 6.
  5. Iowa's Official Register, 1943-1944, at 15.
  6. "Another redrawing," Ames Daily Tribune, 1970-07-07 at 4.
  7. Iowa Official Register, 1973-74, at 30.
  8. Iowa Official Register, 1983-84, at 46.
  9. Iowa League of Cities,Population of Iowa Cities of 8,000 or More, accessed 2008-07-27.
  10. News: 2001 Iowa Redistricting Plan . 2001 . 2006-11-10 . https://web.archive.org/web/20061016022525/http://www.legis.state.ia.us/Redist/Redist.html . 2006-10-16 . dead .
  11. News: Election Statistics . 2005 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20070725184700/http://clerk.house.gov/member_info/electionInfo/index.html . 2007-07-25 .