Indo-Scythians Explained

Conventional Long Name:Indo-Scythian kingdom
Common Name:Indo-Scythian kingdom
Era:Antiquity
Government Type:Monarchy
Year Start: 150 BCE
Year End:400 CE
P1:Greco-Bactrian kingdom
P2:Indo-Greek kingdom
P3:Maurya Empire
S1:Kushan Empire
S2:Sassanid Empire
S4:Indo-Parthians
S5:Paratarajas
S6:Gupta Empire
Image Map Caption:Territories and expansion of the Indo-Scythians at their greatest extent, including territories of the Northern Satraps and Western Satraps.
Common Languages:Saka,[1]
Greek,
Pali (Kharoshthi script),
Sanskrit,
Prakrit (Brahmi script)
Title Leader:King
Leader1:Maues
Year Leader1:85–60 BCE
Leader2:Hajatria
Year Leader2:10 CE
Stat Year1:20 est.[2]
Stat Area1:2600000

The Indo-Scythians (also called Indo-Sakas) were a group of nomadic people of Iranic Scythian origin who migrated from Central Asia southward into the northwestern Indian subcontinent: the present-day South Asian regions of Afghanistan, Pakistan, Eastern Iran and northern India. The migrations persisted from the middle of the second century BCE to the fourth century CE.

The first Saka king in India was Maues/Moga (first century BCE) who established Saka power in Gandhara, the Indus Valley, and other regions. The Indo-Scythians extended their supremacy over the north-western subcontinent, conquering the Indo-Greeks and other local peoples. They were apparently subjugated by the Kushan Empire's Kujula Kadphises or Kanishka. The Saka continued to govern as satrapies, forming the Northern Satraps and Western Satraps. The power of the Saka rulers began to decline during the 2nd century CE after the Indo-Scythians were defeated by the Satavahana emperor Gautamiputra Satakarni.[3] [4] Indo-Scythian rule in the northwestern subcontinent ended when the last Western Satrap, Rudrasimha III, was defeated by the Gupta emperor Chandragupta II in 395 CE.[5] [6]

The invasion of the northern Indian subcontinent by Scythian tribes from Central Asia, often referred to as the Indo-Scythian invasion, played a significant role in the history of the subcontinent and nearby regions. The Indo-Scythian war was triggered by the nomadic flight of Central Asians from conflict with tribes such as the Xiongnu in the second century CE, which had lasting effects on Bactria, Kabul and the Indian subcontinent and Rome and Parthia in the west. Ancient Roman historians, including Arrian[7] and Claudius Ptolemy, have mentioned that the ancient Sakas ("Sakai") were nomadic people.[8] The first rulers of the Indo-Scythian kingdom were Maues (c. 85–60 BCE) and Vonones (c. 75–65 BCE).[9]

Origins

The ancestors of the Indo-Scythians are thought to have been Saka (Scythian) tribes.

One group of Indo-European speakers that makes an early appearance on the Xinjiang stage is the Saka (Ch. Sai). Saka is more a generic term than a name for a specific state or ethnic group; Saka tribes were part of a cultural continuum of early nomads across Siberia and the Central Eurasian steppe lands from Xinjiang to the Black Sea. Like the Scythians whom Herodotus describes in book four of his History (Saka is an Iranian word equivalent to the Greek Scythes, and many scholars refer to them together as Saka-Scythian), Sakas were Iranian-speaking horse nomads who deployed chariots in battle, sacrificed horses, and buried their dead in barrows or mound tombs called kurgans.[10]
The Saka of western India spoke the Saka language (also known as Khotanese), first documented in the Tarim Basin.[11]

Achaemenid period (6th-4th century BCE)

During the Achaemenid conquest of the Indus Valley BCE, the Achaemenid army was not Persian and the Saka probably participated in the invasion of northwest India. The Achaemenid army was composed of a number of ethnic groups who were part of the Achaemenid Empire. The army included Bactrians, Saka, Parthians, and Sogdians.[12] Herodotus listed the ethnicities of the Achaemenid army, which included Ionians (Greeks) and Ethiopians.[13] [12] These groups were probably included in the Achaemenid army which invaded India.[12]

Some scholars (including Michael Witzel)[14] and Christopher I. Beckwith[15] suggested that the Shakyathe clan of Gautama Buddhawere originally Scythians from Central Asia, and the Indian ethnonym Śākya has the same origin as "Scythian".[12] This would explain the strong Saka support of Buddhism in India.[15]

The Persians, the Saka and the Greeks may have participated in the later campaigns of Chandragupta Maurya to gain the throne of Magadha BCE. The Mudrarakshasa says that after Alexander the Great's death, Chandragupta Maurya used a Shaka-Yavana-Kamboja-Parasika-Bahlika alliance in his campaign to take the throne in Magadha and found the Maurya Empire.[16] [17] The Saka were the Scythians; the Yavanas were the Greeks, and the Parasikas were the Persians.[18] [19]

Yuezhi expansion (2nd century BCE)

During the second century BCE, a nomadic movement began among the Central Asian tribes. Recorded in the annals of the Han dynasty and other Chinese records, the movement began after the Yuezhi tribe was defeated by the Xiongnu and fled west; this created a domino effect, displacing other central Asian tribes in their path.[20]

According to these ancient sources, Modu Shanyu of the Xiongnu tribe of Mongolia attacked the Yuezhi (possibly related to the Tocharians, who lived in the eastern Tarim Basin) and evicted them from their homeland between the Qilian Shan and Dunhuang BCE.[21] Leaving a few people behind, most of the population moved west to the Ili River region. They displaced the Saka, who migrated south into Ferghana and Sogdiana. According to the Chinese historical chronicles (who call the Saka "Sai" 塞): "[The Yuezhi] attacked the king of the Sai, who moved a considerable distance to the south and the Yuezhi then occupied his lands."[22] [23]

Sometime after 155 BCE, the Yuezhi were again defeated by an alliance of the Wusun and the Xiongnu. They were forced to move south, again displacing the Scythians (who migrated south towards Bactria and present-day Afghanistan and south-west towards Parthia. A tribe known to ancient Greek scholars as the Sacaraucae (probably from the Old Persian Sakaravaka, "nomadic Saka") and an allied people, the Massagetae, came into conflict with the Parthian Empire in Parthia between 138 and 124 BCE. The Sacaraucae-Massagetae alliance won several battles and killed the Parthian kings Phraates II and Artabanus I. The Yuezhi tribes migrated east into Bactria after their defeat, from which they conquered northern India to establish the Kushan Empire.[24]

Settlement in Sakastan

The Saka settled in Drangiana, a region of southern Afghanistan, western Pakistan and southern Iran which was then named Sakastan or Sistan.[25] The mixed Scythian hordes who migrated to Drangiana and the surrounding regions later spread into north and south-west India via the lower Indus valley. They spread into Sovira, Gujarat, Rajasthan and north India, including kingdoms on the Indian mainland.

The Arsacid emperor Mithridates II (c. 123–88/87 BCE) pursued an aggressive military policy in Central Asia and added a number of provinces to the Parthian Empire.[26] This included western Bactria, which he seized from the Indo-Scythians.[27]

Following military pressure from the Yuezhi (predecessors of the Kushana), some Indo-Scythians moved from Bactria to Lake Helmond (or Hāmūn) and settled in or near Drangiana (Sigal). The region came to be known as "Sakistana of the Skythian Sakai "[28] towards the end of the first century BCE.[29]

The presence of the Saka in Sakastan in the first century BCE is mentioned by Isidore of Charax in "The Parthian Stations". According to Isidore, they were bordered by Greek cities on the east (Alexandria of the Caucasus and Alexandria of the Arachosians) and the Parthian-controlled territory of Arachosia on the south:

Beyond is Sacastana of the Scythian Sacae, which is also Paraetacena, 63 schoeni. There are the city of Barda and the city of Min and the city of Palacenti and the city of Sigal; in that place is the royal residence of the Sacae; and nearby is the city of Alexandria (Alexandria Arachosia), and six villages.[30]

Kingdoms

Pamirs to Taxila

From petroglyphs left by Saka soldiers at river crossings in Chilas and on the Sacred Rock of Hunza in Pakistan, Ahmad Hassan Dani and have established the route across the Karakoram mountains used by Maues (the first Indo-Scythian king) to capture Taxila from Indo-Greek King Apollodotus II.[31]

The first-century CE Periplus of the Erythraean Sea describes the Scythian territories:

Beyond this region (Gedrosia), the continent making a wide curve from the east across the depths of the bays, there follows the coast district of Scythia, which lies above toward the north; the whole marshy; from which flows down the river Sinthus, the greatest of all the rivers that flow into the Erythraean Sea, bringing down an enormous volume of water (...) This river has seven mouths, very shallow and marshy, so that they are not navigable, except the one in the middle; at which by the shore, is the market-town, Barbaricum. Before it there lies a small island, and inland behind it is the metropolis of Scythia, Minnagara; it is subject to Parthian princes who are constantly driving each other out ...[32]

The Indo-Scythians established a kingdom in the northwest near Taxila, with two satraps: one at Mathura in the east, and the other at Surastrene (Gujarat) in the southwest.[33]

Gandhara and Punjab

The presence of the Scythians in modern Pakistan and north-western India during the first century BCE was contemporaneous with the Indo-Greek kingdoms there, and they apparently initially recognized the power of the local Greek rulers. Maues first conquered Gandhara and Taxila in present-day Afghanistan and Pakistan BCE, but his kingdom disintegrated after his death. In the east, the Indian king Vikrama retook Ujjain from the Indo-Scythians and celebrated his victory by establishing the Vikrama era in 58 BCE. Indo-Greek kings again ruled and prospered after Maues, as indicated by the profusion of coins from Kings Apollodotus II and Hippostratos. In 55 BCE, under Azes I, the Indo-Scythians took control of northwestern India with their victory over Hippostratos.

Sculpture

Excavations organized by John Marshall found several stone sculptures in the early Saka layer (layer number four, corresponding to the period of Azes I, in which a number of his coins were found). Several of them are toilet trays roughly imitative of finer Hellenistic examples found in earlier layers.

Bimaran casket

See main article: Bimaran casket.

Azes is connected to the Bimaran casket, one of the earliest representations of the Buddha. The reliquary was used for the dedication of a stupa in Bamiran, near Jalalabad in Afghanistan, and placed inside the stupa with several coins of Azes. This may have happened during the reign of Azes (60–20 BCE), or slightly later. The Indo-Scythians were connected with Buddhism.

Mathura region

See main article: Northern Satraps.

In northern India, the Indo-Scythians conquered the Mathura region BCE. Some of their satraps were Hagamasha and Hagana, who were followed by Rajuvula.

The Mathura lion capital, an Indo-Scythian sandstone capital which dates to the first century CE, describes in Kharoshthi script the gift of a stupa with a relic of the Buddha by Nadasi Kasa (Rajuvula's queen). The capital also mentions the genealogy of several Indo-Scythian Mathura satraps. Rajuvula apparently eliminated Strato II (the last Indo-Greek king) CE and took Sagala, his capital city.

Coinage of the period, such as that of Rajuvula, tends to be crude. It is also debased; the silver content becomes lower and bronze content higher, an alloying technique suggesting a lack of wealth.

The Mathura lion capital inscriptions attest that Mathura came under Saka control. The inscriptions refer to Kharahostes and Queen Ayasia, the "chief queen of the Indo-Scythian ruler of Mathura, satrap Rajuvula." Kharahostes was the son of Arta, as attested by his own coins.[34] Arta was the brother of King Maues.[35]

The Indo-Scythian satraps of Mathura are sometimes called the Northern Satraps to distinguish them from the Western Satraps ruling in Gujarat and Malwa. After Rajuvula, several successors are known to have ruled as vassals of the Kushans. They include the "Great Satrap" Kharapallana and the satrap Vanaspara, who are known from an inscription discovered in Sarnath and dated to the third year of Kanishka (c. 130 CE), when they pledged allegiance to the Kushans.[36]

Pataliputra

The Yuga Purana describes an invasion of Pataliputra by the Scythians during the first century BCE, after seven kings ruled in succession in Saketa following the retreat of the Yavanas. According to the Yuga Purana, the Saka king killed one-fourth of the population before he was slain by the Kalinga king Shata and a group of Sabalas.[37]

Kushan and Indo-Parthian conquests

After Azes' death, Indo-Scythian rule in northwestern India ended with the rise of the Indo-Parthian ruler Gondophares late in the first century BCE. For the following decades, A number of minor Scythian leaders maintained themselves in local strongholds on the fringes of the loose Indo-Parthian empire over the next few decades, some paying allegiance to Gondophares I and his successors.

Indo-Parthian rule was gradually replaced with that of the Kushans, one of the five Yuezhi tribes who lived in Bactria for over a century and expanded into India during the late first century CE. The Kushans regained northwestern India CE and the Mathura region, where they prospered for several centuries.

Western Satraps

See main article: Western Satraps.

Indo-Scythians continued to hold the Sistan region until the reign of Bahram II (276–293 CE), and held several areas of India well into the first millennium; Kathiawar and Gujarat were under Western Satrap rule until the fifth century. Rudradaman I's exploits are inscribed in the Junagadh rock inscription. During his campaigns, Rudradaman conqured the Yaudheyas and defeated the Satavahana Empire. The Western Satraps were conquered by the Gupta emperor Chandragupta II (also known as Vikramaditya).

Coinage

Indo-Scythian coinage is generally of high quality, although the coins of Rajuvula deteriorate near the disintegration of Indo-Scythian rule CE. A fairly high-quality, stereotypical coinage was continued by the Western Satraps until the fourth century.

Indo-Scythian coinage is generally realistic, artistically between Indo-Greek and Kushan coinage. It has been suggested that its coinage benefited from the help of Greek coin-makers.Indo-Scythian coins continue Indo-Greek tradition by using the Greek alphabet on the obverse and Kharoshthi script on the reverse. A portrait of the king is absent, with depictions of the king on a horse (sometimes on a camel) or sitting cross-legged on a cushion instead. The reverse of their coins typically show Greek gods.

Buddhist symbolism is present in Indo-Scythian coinage. The Indo-Scythians adopted the Indo-Greek practice (since Menander I) of depicting gods forming the vitarka mudra with their right hand (like Zeus on the coins of Maues or Azes II), the Buddhist lion on the coins of those two kings, or the triratana symbol on the coins of Zeionises.

Art

See main article: Indo-Scythian art.

Other than coins, few works of art are known to indisputably represent Indo-Scythians. Several Gandharan sculptures show foreigners in soft tunics, sometimes wearing the pointed hat typical of the Scythians. Kushan men seem to wear thick, rigid tunics, and are generally represented more simplistically.[38]

Buner reliefs

Indo-Scythian soldiers in military attire are sometimes represented in Buddhist friezes in Gandharan art, particularly in the Buner reliefs. They are depicted in loose tunics with trousers, with heavy, straight swords. They wear pointed hoods or the Scythian cap; this distinguishes them from the Indo-Parthians, who wore a simple fillet over their bushy hair,[39] and which is worn by Indo-Scythian rulers on their coins. With their right hand, some form the karana mudra to ward off evil spirits. In Gandhara, such friezes were used to decorate the pedestals of Buddhist stupas. They are contemporary with other friezes representing people in Greek attire, hinting at an intermixing of Indo-Scythians and Indo-Greeks. In another relief, the same type of soldiers are playing musical instruments and dancing; in Gandharan art, Indo-Scythians are typically depicted as reveling devotees.

Stone palettes

A number of stone palettes in Gandhara are considered representative of Indo-Scythian art. The palettes, which combine Greek and Iranian influences, often have a simple, archaic style. Stone palettes have only been found in archaeological layers corresponding to Indo-Greek, Indo-Scythian and Indo-Parthian rule, and are unknown in the preceding Mauryan layers or the succeeding Kushan layers.[40]

The palettes often depict people in Greek dress in mythological scenes; a few have Parthian dress (headbands over bushy hair, crossed-over jacket on a bare chest, jewelry, belt, baggy trousers), and fewer have Indo-Scythian dress (Phrygian hat, tunic and straight trousers). A palette found in Sirkap, now in the New Delhi Museum, shows a winged Indo-Scythian horseman riding a winged deer and being attacked by a lion.

Buddhism

The Indo-Scythians seem to have supported Buddhism, with many of their practices continuing those of the Indo-Greeks.They had an active role in the dissemination of Buddhism beyond India.

Royal dedications

Several Indo-Scythian kings after Azes made Buddhist dedications in their name on plaques or reliquaries:

Butkara Stupa

Excavations at the Butkara Stupa in Swat by an Italian archaeological team have yielded Buddhist sculptures thought to belong to the Indo-Scythian period. An Indo-Corinthian capital of a Buddhist devotee in foliage has been found which had a reliquary and coins of Azes buried at its base, dating the sculpture to BCE.[45] A contemporary pilaster of a Buddhist devotee in Greek dress has been found at the same spot, again suggesting a mingling of the populations. Reliefs at the same location show Indo-Scythians, with characteristic tunics and pointed hoods, with reliefs of standing Buddhas.[46]

In Indian literature

See main article: Indo-Scythians in Indian literature. The Indo-Scythians were named "Shaka" in India, a variation of the name "Saka" used by the Persians for Scythians. Shakas are mentioned in the Purāṇas, the Manusmṛti, the Rāmāyaṇa, the Mahābhārata, the Mahābhāṣya, the Bṛhat Saṃhitā by Varāhamihira, the Kāvyamīmāṃsā, the Bṛhatkathāmañjarīi, and the Kathāsaritsāgara. They are described as part of a group of other warlike tribes from the northwest.

There are references to the warring mleccha hordes of Sakas, Yavanas, Kambojas and Pahlavas in the Balakanda of the Ramayana. H. C. Raychadhury saw in these verses the struggles between the Hindus and the invading hordes of mleccha barbarians from the northwest beginning in the second century BCE, and fixed the date of the Ramayana around (or after) the 2nd century CE.[47]

The Mahabharata also alludes to the invasion of mixed hordes from the northwest, with prophetic verses that "...the Mlechha (barbaric) kings of the Shakas, Yavanas, Kambojas, Bahlikas ... shall rule the earth un-righteously in Kali Yuga ..."

Sai-Wang hordes

A portion of Central Asian Scythians under Sai-Wang reportedly moved south, crossed the Pamir Mountains and entered Chipin (or Kipin) after crossing the Xuandu (懸度, Hanging Pass) above the valley of Kanda in Swat.[48] Chipin has been identified by Pelliot, Bagchi, Raychaudhury and others as Kashmir,[49] but other scholars identify it as Kafiristan.[50] [51] Sai-Wang established his kingdom in Kipin. Konow interprets the Sai-Wang as the Śaka Murunda of Indian literature; murunda is synonymous with wang (king, master or lord).[52] Bagchi interprets Wang as the king of the Scythians, but distinguishes the Sai Sakas from the Murunda Sakas.[53] The Sai Scythians may have been Kamboja Scythians; the Sai-Wang were part of the Parama Kamboja kingdom of Transoxiana, and returned after being evicted from their ancestral land. Maues might have belonged to this group of Scythians who migrated from the Sai country (Central Asia) to Chipin.[54]

Evidence of joint invasions

The Scythian groups who invaded India and established kingdoms included, in addition to the Saka, allied tribes such as the Medii, Xanthii, and Massagetae. These peoples were absorbed into mainstream Indian society.[55]

The Shakas were from the trans-Hemodos region—the Shakadvipa of the Puranas or the Scythia of classical writings. At the beginning of the first century CE, Isidore of Charax notes their presence in Sistan. The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea (c. 70–80 CE) documents a Scythian district in the lower Indus Valley, with Minnagra its capital. Ptolemy (c. 140 CE) also documents an Indo-Scythia in south-western India which consisted of the Patalene and Surastrene (Saurashtra) territories. The second-century BCE Scythian invasion of India was probably carried out jointly by the Saka, Pahlavas, Kambojas, Paradas, Rishikas and other allied tribes from the northwest.[56]

Dynasties and rulers

See main article: List of Indo-Scythian dynasties and rulers.

Descendants

Tadeusz Sulimirski notes that the Saka also invaded parts of northern India.[57] Indian linguist Weer Rajendra Rishi[58] has identified linguistic affinities between Indian and Central Asian languages, which also suggests a Saka influence in northern India.[57] [59]

See also

Sources

External links

Notes and References

  1. Book: Diringer, David . The Alphabet: A Key to the History of Mankind . 1953 . Hutchinson's Scientific and Technical Publications . Second and revised . London . 350 . en . 1948.
  2. Taagepera. Rein. Size and Duration of Empires: Growth-Decline Curves, 600 B.C. to 600 A.D. Social Science History. 1979. 3. 3/4. 115–138. 10.2307/1170959. 1170959.
  3. World history from Early Times to AD 2000 by B. V. Rao, p. 97
  4. A Brief History of India, by Alain Daniélou p. 136
  5. India in a Globalised World by Sagarika Dutt, p. 24
  6. Ancient India by Ramesh Chandra Majumdar, p. 234
  7. Web site: Arrian: Anabasis Alexandri: Book VIII (Indica); Section V. Ancient History Sourcebooks. Fordham University. 2019-01-21.
  8. [Ptolemy]
  9. Book: 2023-01-28. Suchandra Ghosh. The Encyclopedia of Empire . 2016-01-11. 10.1002/9781118455074.wbeoe067. Nigel Dalziel, John M MacKenzie. 978-1-118-45507-4. en. Oxford, UK. 1–2. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Indo-Scythian (Saka) Kingdom. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781118455074.wbeoe067.
  10. Millward (2007), p. 13.
  11. Book: Diringer . David . Alphabet A Key To The History Of Mankind . 1948 . 350 .
  12. Book: Beckwith . Christopher I. . Greek Buddha: Pyrrho's Encounter with Early Buddhism in Central Asia . 2015 . Princeton University Press . 9781400866328 . 5 . en.
  13. Herodotus VII 65
  14. Book: Attwood . Jayarava . Possible Iranian Origins for the Śākyas and Aspects of Buddhism . en. 47–69.
  15. Book: Beckwith . Christopher I. . Greek Buddha: Pyrrho's Encounter with Early Buddhism in Central Asia . 2015 . Princeton University Press . 9781400866328 . 1–21 . en.
  16. Book: Mookerji . Radhakumud . Chandragupta Maurya and His Times . 1966 . Motilal Banarsidass . 9788120804050 . 27 . en.
    Book: Mookerji, Radha Kumud . The Foundation of the Mauryan Empire . K. A. Nilakanta Sastri . A Comprehensive History of India, Volume 2: Mauryas and Satavahanas . 1957 . Orient Longmans . 4 . https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.532644/page/n5. : "The Mudrarakshasa further informs us that his Himalayan alliance gave Chandragupta a composite army ... Among these are mentioned the following : Sakas, Yavanas (probably Greeks), Kiratas, Kambojas, Parasikas and Bahlikas."
  17. D. B. Spooner . 1915 . The Zoroastrian Period of Indian History . . 47 . 3 . 416–417 . 10.1017/S0035869X00048437 . 25189338 . 162867863 .

    "After Alexander's death, when Chandragupta marched on Magada, it was with largely the Persian army that he won the throne of India. The testimony of the Mudrarakshasa is explicit on this point, and we have no reason to doubt its accuracy in matter[s] of this kind."

  18. Book: Shashi . Shyam Singh . Encyclopaedia Indica: Mauryas . 1999 . Anmol Publications . 9788170418597 . 134 . en.

    "Among those who helped Chandragupta in his struggle against the Nandas, were the Sakas (Scythians), Yavanas (Greeks), and Parasikas (Persians)"

  19. Book: Mookerji . Radhakumud . Chandragupta Maurya and His Times . 1966 . Motilal Banarsidass . 9788120804050 . 210 . en.
  20. Book: Grousset, Rene . The Empire of the Steppes . Rutgers University Press . 1970 . 978-0-8135-1304-1 . 32 .
  21. Shiji, chap. 123 translated in: Burton Watson (1993), p. 234.
  22. Han Shu 61 4B Original tex: 西擊塞王。塞王南走遠徙,月氏居其地。
  23. The Yuezhi Migration and Sogdia . Craig Benjamin. Transoxiana Webfestschrift Series I: Eran Ud Aneran . October 2003.
  24. Book: Lena Jonson. Tajikistan in the New Central Asia: Geopolitics, Great Power Rivalry and Radical Islam. 3 October 2006. I.B.Tauris. 978-1-84511-293-6. 25.
  25. Book: https://books.google.com/books?id=y7IHmyKcPtYC&pg=PA1231 . Bailey, H.W. . 1996. Chapter 34: Khotanese Saka Literature . Ehsan Yarshater . The Cambridge History of Iran, Vol III: The Seleucid, Parthian, and Sasanian Periods, Part 2 . reprint . Cambridge University Press. 14 April 1983. 978-0521246934. 1230–1231.
  26. Justin XL.II.2
  27. Olbrycht, Marek Jan (2010). "The early reign of Mithradates II the Great in Parthia". 1. Anabasis: 144–158
  28. Isodor of Charax, Sathmoi Parthikoi, 18.
  29. Political History of Ancient India, 1996, p 693.
  30. Web site: The Parthian Stations . Parthia.com . 2012-03-14. 18. https://web.archive.org/web/20230520182018/https://www.parthia.com/doc/parthian_stations.htm. 20 May 2023. live.
  31. Book: History of Civilizations of Central Asia, Volume 2. 191–207. Ahmad Hasan Dani. Motilal Banarsidass Publ..
  32. Web site: Periplus of the Erythraean Sea, 38 . Fordham.edu . 2012-03-14.
  33. The dynastic art of the Kushans, John Rosenfield, p 130
  34. Kshatrapasa pra Kharaostasa Artasa putrasa. See: Political History of Ancient India, 1996, p 398, H. C. Raychaudhury, B. N. Mukerjee; Ancient India, 1956, pp 220–221, R. K. Mukerjee
  35. Ancient India, pp 220–221, R. k. Mukerjee; Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum, Vol II, Part 1, p 36, D S Konow
  36. Source: "A Catalogue of the Indian Coins in the British Museum. Andhras etc ..." Rapson, p ciii
  37. Web site: A gap in Puranic history . Boloji.com . 2004-03-14 . 2012-03-14 . https://web.archive.org/web/20100114183336/http://boloji.com/history/027.htm . 14 January 2010 . dead .
  38. Francine Tissot, Gandhara, p. 74
  39. Wilcox and McBride (1986), p. 12.
  40. "Let us remind that in Sirkap, stone palettes were found at all excavated levels. On the contrary, neither Bhir-Mound, the Maurya city preceding Sirkap on the Taxila site, nor Sirsukh, the Kushan city succeeding her, did deliver any stone palettes during their excavations", in "Les palettes du Gandhara", p89. "The terminal point after which such palettes are not manufactured anymore is probably located during the Kushan period. In effect, neither Mathura nor Taxila (although the Sirsukh had only been little excavated), nor Begram, nor Surkh Kotal, neither the great Kushan archaeological sites of Soviet Central Asia or Afghanistan have yielded such objects. Only four palettes have been found in Kushan-period archaeological sites. They come from secondary sites, such as Garav Kala and Ajvadz in Soviet Tajikistan and Jhukar, in the Indus Valley, and Dalverzin Tepe. They are rather roughly made." In "Les Palettes du Gandhara", Henri-Paul Francfort, p 91. (in French in the original)
  41. Ahmad Hasan Dani et al., History of Civilizations of Central Asia, 1999, p 201, Unesco
  42. Richard Salomon, "An Inscribed Silver Buddhist Reliquary of the Time of King Kharaosta and Prince Indravarman", Journal of the American Oriental Society, Vol. 116, No. 3 (July - September 1996), pp. 418-452
  43. "Afghanistan, carrefour en l'Est et l'Ouest" p.373. Also Senior 2003
  44. Des Indo-Grecs aux Sassanides, Rika Gyselen, Peeters Publishers, 2007, p.103 https://books.google.com/books?id=_TIU_jp93xUC&pg=PA103
  45. The Turin City Museum of Ancient Art Text and photographic reference: Terre Lontane O2
  46. Facenna, "Sculptures from the sacred area of Butkara I", plate CCCLXXI.
  47. Political History of Ancient India, 1996, pp 3–4.
  48. Serindia, Vol. I, 1980 edition, p. 8, M. A. Stein
  49. H. C. Raychaudhury, B. N. Mukerjee; Early History of North India, p 3, S. Chattopadhyava; India and Central Asia, p 126, P. C. Bagchi
  50. Epigraphia Indiaca XIV, p 291 S Konow; Greeks in Bactria and India, p 473, fn, W. W. Tarn; Yuan Chwang I, pp 259–60, Watters; Comprehensive History of India, Vol I, p 189, N. K. Sastri; History and Culture of Indian People, The Age of Imperial Unity, 122; History and Culture of Indian People, Classical Age, p 617, R. C. Majumdar, A. D. Pusalkar.
  51. Scholars like E. J. Rapson, L. Petech etc. also connect Kipin with Kapisha. Levi writes that before 600 CE, Kipin was Kashmir; after that, it was Kapisha. See discussion in The Classical Age, p 671.
  52. Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum, II. 1. XX f; cf: Early History of North India, pp 54, S Chattopadhyaya.
  53. India and Central Asia, 1955, p 124, P. C. Bagchi; Geographical Data in Early Puranas, 1972, p 47, M. R. Singh.
  54. Political History of Ancient India, 1996, fn 13, B. N. Mukerjee; Chilas, Islamabad, 1983, no 72, 78, 85, pp 98, 102, A. H. Dani
  55. History and Culture of Indian People, The Vedic Age, pp 286–87, 313–14.
  56. https://books.google.com/books?id=UmMnh1XKJjQC Intercourse Between India and the Western World
  57. Book: Sulimirski, Tadeusz . The Sarmatians . 73 of Ancient peoples and places . 113–114 . Tadeusz Sulimirski . Praeger . New York . 1970 . 9789080057272 . The evidence of both the ancient authors and the archaeological remains point to a massive migration of Sacian (Sakas)/Massagetan tribes from the Syr Daria Delta (Central Asia) by the middle of the second century B.C. Some of the Syr Darian tribes; they also invaded North India..
  58. http://rishi.anantdutta.in/obituary.html Indian Institute of Romani Studies
  59. Book: Rishi, Weer Rajendra . India & Russia: linguistic & cultural affinity . 95 . Weer Rajendra Rishi . Roma . 1982 .