| In a Special Place – The Piano Demos for This Is the Sea | |
| Type: | Compilation album |
| Artist: | The Waterboys |
| Cover: | The Waterboys In a Special Place The Piano Demos for This Is the Sea.jpg |
| Released: | 2011 |
| Length: | 51:00 |
| Label: | Chrysalis (Europe) Capitol (US) |
| Producer: |
|
| Prev Title: | Book of Lightning |
| Prev Year: | 2007 |
| Next Title: | An Appointment with Mr Yeats |
| Next Year: | 2011 |
In a Special Place – The Piano Demos for This Is the Sea is a compilation album by Scottish-Irish folk rock band The Waterboys. It was released in 2011 by Chrysalis (UK and Europe) and Capitol (US). The album reached No. 196 in the UK Top 200 Albums Chart.[1]
In a Special Place is a selection of thirteen demos recorded by Scott in the spring of 1985. For the band's third studio album, This Is the Sea, Scott wrote up to 50 tracks and booked himself into Park Gates Studio, Hastings, England, with engineer and producer John Brand, to record "simple piano/vocal demos" that would assist him in reviewing the songs and choosing which ones to develop further. The last two tracks on the compilation are considered by Scott to be "extras". The demo of "Old England" was recorded at Wallinger's home studio, with Scott on vocal, piano and guitar, and Wallinger on snare drum and synth bass. The final track, "Trumpets", is a remix by Don Jackson of the original This Is the Sea recording.[2]
Upon its release, Ian Abrahams of Record Collector considered the demos to "delineate an intensity and artistic passion that's palpable and inspiring". Speaking of the demos of songs that were later recorded for This Is the Sea, James Christopher Monger of AllMusic noted their "sense of hopeful cynicism, youthful altruism, and righteous indignation rings true". For those that were not included on This Is the Sea, he commented: "The[se] tracks are cut from the same vivacious cloth, and whether it's just Scott on piano trying to lock up with a drum machine, or Scott solo, it's hard not to get swept up in all the potential grandeur."
Zachary Houle of PopMatters felt the material would have been better placed on an expanded edition of This Is the Sea, rather than a separate release. He commented: "As an "album" in and of itself, In a Special Place doesn't really hold up, because even the tracks featuring completely unreleased material tends to be fragmented and incomplete." He concluded the album was "more of an academic implementation than an actual collection of material that truly means something."[3]
Production
Other