I Talk to the Wind explained

I Talk to the Wind
Artist:King Crimson
Album:In the Court of the Crimson King
Recorded:29 July 1969
Genre:
Composer:Ian McDonald
Lyricist:Peter Sinfield
Label:Atlantic
Producer:King Crimson

"I Talk to the Wind" is the second track from the British progressive rock band King Crimson's debut album, In the Court of the Crimson King (1969).

Starting immediately after the cacophony that ends "21st Century Schizoid Man", the mood of this song is a stark contrast; it is serene, simple and peaceful. Ian McDonald's flute begins the song, and is one of the lead instruments throughout.[3] He also plays a classical-inspired solo in the middle of the song as a "C" section and a longer one at the end as a coda.

An earlier demo version of this song may be found on the now out-of-print LP A Young Person's Guide to King Crimson, which featured Robert Fripp (guitar), Peter Giles (bass), Michael Giles (drums), and Ian McDonald (flute), along with Judy Dyble (formerly of Fairport Convention) on vocals.[4] This version was more up-tempo and lighter in instrumentation. The Young Person's Guide recording and another demo of the same song were recorded in 1968 by Giles, Giles and Fripp. However, the song did not actually appear on a Giles, Giles and Fripp record until The Brondesbury Tapes (1968) was released on CD in 2002.[5] There are actually two recordings of "I Talk to the Wind" on this CD; one features vocals by Judy Dyble, and the other features vocals by Peter Giles.

Personnel

Opus III version

I Talk to the Wind
Cover:Opus III-I Talk to the Wind.jpg
Type:single
Artist:Opus III
Album:Mind Fruit
B-Side:Sea People
Released:[6]
Studio:
  • Fluffy Trees
  • PWL
  • The Bunker
Genre:
Length:4:06
Label:PWL International
Producer:Opus III
Prev Title:It's a Fine Day
Prev Year:1992
Next Title:When You Made the Mountain
Next Year:1994

In 1992, the song was covered by English electronic music group Opus III, whose lead vocalist was Kirsty Hawkshaw. It was released in June 1992 by PWL International as the follow-up to their successful "It's a Fine Day" and the second single from their debut album, Mind Fruit (1992). The single peaked at number six in Finland, number 52 in the United Kingdom and number 162 in Australia. The accompanying music video for "I Talk to the Wind" is similar to the video for "It's a Fine Day", featuring Hawkshaw with her head shaved and dressed in a silvery bodysuit with silver boots and silver make-up.

Critical reception

AllMusic editor MacKenzie Wilson felt the group's "crafty version" of King Crimson's "I Talk to the Wind" "composes a dreamy synthetic wave." He also noted Kirsty Hawkshaw's "dove-like vocals transcended into freewheeling soundscapes".[7] Randy Clark from Cashbox wrote that her "childlike and breathy voice blows through this dance track like a gentle breeze."[8] Dave Simpson from Melody Maker viewed it as "another sublime reinvention".[9] Andy Beevers from Music Week opined that the song is similar in style to "It's a Fine Day", "but is nowhere as special."[10] Roger Morton from NME praised it as "excellent".[11] Siân Pattenden from Smash Hits gave it two out of five, remarking that "the flutes whisper along merrily with the bubbly syntheramic background".[12]

Track listings

  1. "I Talk to the Wind" (edit) – 4:06
  2. "Sea People" – 6:00
  1. "I Talk to the Wind" (extended mix) – 6:11
  2. "Sea People" – 5:33
  1. "I Talk to the Wind" (edit) – 4:06
  2. "I Talk to the Wind" (12-inch extended mix) – 6:11
  3. "Sea People" – 6:00

Charts

Chart (1992)Peak
position
Australia (ARIA)162
Europe (Eurochart Hot 100)[13] 88
Finland (IFPI)[14] 6
UK Singles (OCC)52
UK Dance (Music Week)[15] 48

Notes and References

  1. Web site: I Talk to the Wind – King Crimson Song Info. Unterberger. Richie. AllMusic. 27 April 2019.
  2. Web site: The 100 Best Classic Progressive Rock Songs: Part 3, 60–41. Murphy. Sean. 28 March 2017. PopMatters. 27 April 2019.
  3. Web site: From the Court to Foreigner – The Story of Ian McDonald. 2 July 2015. The Music Court.
  4. Web site: Young Person's Guide to King Crimson (I Talk to the Wind). 2 July 2015. Judy Dyble.
  5. Web site: Giles, Giles & Fripp. 2 July 2015. All Music. Eder. Bruce.
  6. New Releases: Singles. Music Week. 17. 13 June 1992.
  7. Web site: MacKenzie. Wilson. Opus III – Mind Fruit. AllMusic. 18 March 2020.
  8. Randy . Clark . Music Reviews: Singles . . 31 October 1992 . 5 . 1 November 2020 .
  9. Dave. Simpson. Albums. Melody Maker. 18 July 1992. 30. 20 February 2023.
  10. Andy . Beevers . Dance . . 13 June 1992 . 6 . 2 October 2020.
  11. Roger. Morton. Long Play. NME. 18 July 1992. 34. 20 February 2023.
  12. Siân . Pattenden . New Singles . . 10 June 1992 . 55 . 6 October 2020 . Siân Pattenden.
  13. Eurochart Hot 100 . . 18 July 1992 . 17 . 30 September 2020.
  14. Top 10 Sales in Europe. Music & Media. 9. 29. 14. 18 July 1992. 22 February 2020.
  15. Top 60 Dance Singles . . 27 June 1992 . 22 . 29 September 2020.