The All-Star Teams for the now defunct British Ice Hockey Superleague were voted for by members of The British Ice Hockey Writers Association (now known as Ice Hockey Journalists UK) to honour the best players at the end of each season.
NB: Only one All-Star team was elected in the 1996/97 season.
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Stevie Lyle | Cardiff Devils | ||
| Defence | Kip Noble |  | Cardiff Devils | |
| Defence | Garth Premak | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Paul Adey | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Ivan Matulik |  | Cardiff Devils | |
| Forward | Vezio Sacratini | | Cardiff Devils |
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Rob Dopson | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Scott Young | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Kris Miller |  | Manchester Storm | |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Mark Montanari | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Forward | Craig Woodcroft | | Manchester Storm |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Mark Bernard | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Defence | Kip Noble | | Cardiff Devils | |
| Defence | Shayne McCosh | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Tony Hand | Sheffield Steelers | ||
| Forward | Steve Thornton | | Cardiff Devils | |
| Forward | Sam Groleau | | Ayr Scottish Eagles |
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Frank Pietrangelo | | Manchester Storm | |
| Defence | Kip Noble | | Cardiff Devils | |
| Defence | Troy Neumeier | | Manchester Storm | |
| Forward | Greg Hadden | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Paul Adey | | Nottingham Panthers |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Trevor Robins | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Defence | Kris Miller | | Manchester Storm | |
| Defence | Rob Stewart | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Ivan Matulik | | Cardiff Devils | |
| Forward | Jeff Tomlinson | | Manchester Storm | |
| Forward | Jeff Jablonski | | Manchester Storm |
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Geoff Sarjeant | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Claudio Scremin | | London Knights | |
| Defence | Rob Stewart | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Kevin Riehl | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Rob Kenny | | London Knights |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Brian Greer | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Defence | Shayne McCosh | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Neal Martin | | London Knights | |
| Forward | Teeder Wynne | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Mikko Koivunoro |  | Newcastle Riverkings | |
| Forward | Steve Thornton | | Cardiff Devils |
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Trevor Robbins | | London Knights | |
| Defence | Shayne McCosh | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Jim Paek | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | David Longstaff | Sheffield Steelers | ||
| Forward | P.C. Drouin | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Tony Hand | Ayr Scottish Eagles |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Mike Torchia | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Neal Martin | | London Knights | |
| Defence | Adam Smith | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Greg Bullock | | Manchester Storm | |
| Forward | Steve Thornton | | Cardiff Devils | |
| Forward | Kory Karlander | | Belfast Giants |
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Mike Bales | | Belfast Giants | |
| Defence | Johan Silfwerplatz |  | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Rob Stewart | | Belfast Giants | |
| Forward | Kevin Riehl | | Belfast Giants | |
| Forward | Sean Berens | | Belfast Giants | |
| Forward | Jason Ruff | | Belfast Giants |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Joaquin Gage | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Alan Schuler | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Defence | Maurizio Mansi | | London Knights | |
| Forward | P.C. Drouin | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | | Ayr Scottish Eagles | |
| Forward | Scott Allison | | Sheffield Steelers |
First Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Joel Laing | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Robby Sandrock | | Belfast Giants | |
| Defence | Marc Laniel | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Lee Jinman | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Dan Ceman | | Bracknell Bees | |
| Forward | Paxton Schulte | | Belfast Giants |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Goaltender | Ryan Bach | | Belfast Giants | |
| Defence | Dion Darling | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Defence | Jim Paek | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Greg Hadden | | Nottingham Panthers | |
| Forward | Rhett Gordon | | Sheffield Steelers | |
| Forward | Kevin Riehl | | Belfast Giants |