1991 Hong Kong legislative election explained

Election Name:1991 Hong Kong legislative election
Country:Hong Kong
Flag Image:Flag of Hong Kong 1959.svg
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Previous Mps:List of Legislative Council of Hong Kong members 1988–91
Previous Election:1988 Hong Kong legislative election
Previous Year:1988
Next Mps:List of Legislative Council of Hong Kong members elected in 1995
Next Election:1995 Hong Kong legislative election
Next Year:1995
Seats For Election:39 (of the 60) seats to the Legislative Council
Majority Seats:31
Elected Mps:members elected
Election Date:12 & 15 September 1991
Registered:1,916,925
Turnout:750,467 (39.15%)
Leader1:Martin Lee
Party1:United Democrats of Hong Kong
Alliance1:Pro-democracy camp
Leaders Seat1:Hong Kong Island East
Seats1:14
Seat Change1:12
Popular Vote1:618,209
Percentage1:45.15%
Leader2:Hu Fa-kuang
Party2:Liberal Democratic Federation of Hong Kong
Alliance2:Conservative bloc (Hong Kong)
Leaders Seat2:Appointed
(before election)
Seats2:3
Seat Change2:3
Popular Vote2:70,697
Percentage2:5.16%
Leader3:Anthony Cheung
Party3:Meeting Point
Alliance3:Pro-democracy camp
Leaders Seat3:Did not stand
Seats3:2
Seat Change3:2
Popular Vote3:98,588
Percentage3:7.20%
Leader4:Chan Yat-sen
Party4:Federation for the Stability of Hong Kong
Alliance4:Conservative bloc (Hong Kong)
Leaders Seat4:Did not stand
Seats4:2
Seat Change4:2
Popular Vote4:30,871
Percentage4:2.25%
Leader5:Leong Che-hung
Party5:Hong Kong Democratic Foundation
Alliance5:Pro-democracy camp
Leaders Seat5:Medical
Seats5:2
Seat Change5:1
Popular Vote5:19,806
Percentage5:1.45%
Leader6:Vincent Lo
Party6:Business and Professionals Federation of Hong Kong
Alliance6:Conservative bloc (Hong Kong)
Leaders Seat6:Did not stand
Seats6:2
Seat Change6:1
Popular Vote6:N/A
Percentage6:N/A
Leader7:Frederick Fung
Party7:Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood
Alliance7:Pro-democracy camp
Leaders Seat7:Kowloon West
Seats7:1
Popular Vote7:60,770
Percentage7:4.44%
Leader8:Lee Chark-tim
Party8:Hong Kong Federation of Trade Unions
Alliance8:Pro-Beijing camp
Leaders Seat8:Did not stand
Seats8:1
Popular Vote8:44,894
Percentage8:3.28%
Leader9:Lo Tak-shing
Party9:New Hong Kong Alliance
Alliance9:Pro-Beijing camp
Leaders Seat9:Did not stand
Seats9:1
Seat Change9:1
Popular Vote9:11,934
Percentage9:0.87%
Map Size:400px

The 1991 Hong Kong Legislative Council election was held for members of the Legislative Council of Hong Kong (LegCo). The election of the members of functional constituencies was held on 12 September 1991 and the election of geographical constituency seats was held on 15 September respectively. It was the first ever direct election of the Legislative Council in Hong Kong history. There were 18 members from directly elected geographical constituencies, 21 members from functional constituencies, 17 members appointed by the Governor, and 3 official members.

A coalition of the United Democrats and the Meeting Point, together with other smaller parties, groups and independents in the pro-democracy camp had a landslide victory, getting 16 of the 18 geographical constituency seats. Two-seat constituency two vote system was used with two seats to be filled in each constituency. The voting system helped the pro-democracy coalition win with landslide success and faced criticisms. In the end, the government prescribed simple plurality in the next election.

Background

See also: Sino-British Joint Declaration and 1988 Hong Kong electoral reform. After the Sino-British Joint Declaration signed in December 1984 stated the sovereignty of Hong Kong would be transferred from the United Kingdom to the People's Republic of China, the pace of the democratisation towards a government of high autonomy towards 1997 became a major political debate. The Hong Kong government denied the demand of the pro-democracy groups of introducing direct elections in the 1988 Legislative Council elections, due to the main opposition from Beijing and the conservative business and professional elites. As a result, the electoral methods of the functional constituencies being elected by different business and professional sectors and the Electoral Colleges being elected by the District Boards and the two municipal councils (Urban Council and Regional Council) remained in the 1988 elections but it was promised by the government that direct elections would be introduced in the 1991 elections.

Overview

The Hong Kong government's assumed the two-seat constituencies would produce a mixture of liberal, rural conservative and business representatives as well as some members of the "United Front" organisations which supported by Beijing, as the voters would cast their ballots for prominent individuals rather than a "party" label.[1] However, the two-seat and two-vote system benefited the pro-democracy coalition in the end.

The election was largely affected by the events in May and June 1989 in China when the Tiananmen Square protest was bloodily cracked down by the Beijing government. The events sparked the great fear among the Hong Kong population who closely concerned or enthusiastically supported the student movement. The pro-democracy groups supported the student protests by forming the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of Patriotic Democratic Movements in China in May 1989. After the crackdown, the liberal leaders, Martin Lee and Szeto Wah had been labelled as "subversives" by the Beijing government and expelled form the Hong Kong Basic Law Drafting Committee. In 1990, members of the three major pro-democracy groups, the Meeting Point, the Hong Kong Affairs Society and the Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood came together under the banner of the United Democrats of Hong Kong, which self-proclaimed as the first political party in Hong Kong.

The pro-democracy liberals won a landslide in the geographical constituency direct elections. The United Democrats led by Martin Lee became the largest party, by winning 12 of the 18 seats in the geographical constituencies. Two other seats went to its ally Meeting Point headed by Anthony Cheung. Frederick Fung, Chairman of the ADPL won a seat in Kowloon West. Of the remaining seats, one went to a liberal independent Emily Lau, one to an independent incumbent Andrew Wong and the other to an incumbent rural conservative Tai Chin-wah.[1]

The conservative Liberal Democratic Federation of Hong Kong, newly founded in 1990 mainly by business and professional groups favouring collaboration with Beijing, polled only 5.1% of the vote. None of its candidates were elected in the direct elections. The pro-Beijing "united front" organisations received only 7.9% of the vote and were also very easily defeated. Chan Yuen-han, the Hong Kong Federation of Trade Unions (FTU) candidate in Kowloon Central polled about 11,000 votes fewer than the second place United Democrat, Dr. Conrad Lam and was about 23,000 votes behind the winner, United Democrat Lau Chin-shek. In Island East, Cheng Kai-nam who had the support of a pro-Beijing group, Hong Kong Citizen Forum, polled 29,902 against the United Democrats' leader Martin Lee, who received 76,831 votes.[1]

The advantage of the liberals was balanced with the functional constituency indirectly elected by the limited electorates of the business and professional sectors as well as the appointed members by the government. the Chief Secretary Sir David Ford said on television that the elections should be seen in the context of a 50% registration rate, of whom perhaps only 50% might turn out at the polls therefore the majority who were not represented would be reserved by appointing members who might be thought to represent those who had not registered or had not voted.[1]

General results

|-!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:center;" rowspan=2 colspan=3 |Political affiliation !style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;" colspan=4 |Geographical constituencies!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;" colspan=4 |Functional constituencies!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;" rowspan=2 |Total
seats|-!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|Votes!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|%!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|Candidates!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|Seats!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|Votes!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|%!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|Candidates!style="background-color:#E9E9E9;text-align:right;"|Seats|-|rowspan=5 style="background-color:LightGreen;border-bottom-style:hidden;"|| width=1px style="background-color: "||style="text-align:left;"|United Democrats of Hong Kong |618,209|45.15|14|12|15,208|66.46|3|2|14|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"|Meeting Point |98,588|7.20|3|2|−|−|−|−|2|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"|Hong Kong Democratic Foundation|19,806|1.45|1|0|487|2.13|2|2|2|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"|Hong Kong Association for Democracy and People's Livelihood |60,770|4.44|3|1|−|−|−|−|1|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"|Independents and others |46,515|3.40|1|1|−|−|−|−|1|-style="background-color:LightGreen"|colspan=3 style="text-align:left;"|Total for Liberals|843,888|61.63|22|16|15,695|68.59|5|4|20|-|rowspan=3 style="background-color:LightBlue;border-bottom-style:hidden;" || width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"| Liberal Democratic Federation of Hong Kong|69,832|5.10|5|0|1,118|4.89|5|3|3|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"| Business and Professionals Federation of Hong Kong|−|−|−|−|968|4.23|3|2|2|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"| Federation for the Stability of Hong Kong|30,871|2.25|1|1|10|0.04|2|1|2|-|-style="background-color:LightBlue"|colspan=3 style="text-align:left;"|Total for Conservatives|100,703|7.35|6|1|2,096|9.16|10|6|7|-|rowspan=4 style="background-color:Pink"| | width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"|Hong Kong Federation of Trade Unions |44,894|3.28|1|0|–|–|1|1|1|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||style="text-align:left;"| New Hong Kong Alliance|11,934|0.87|2|0|136|0.59|2|1|1|-| width=1px style="background-color:" ||style="text-align:left;"| Hong Kong Citizen Forum|29,902|2.18|1|0|−|−|−|−|0|-|style="background-color:#9E5238"||style="text-align:left;"| Kwun Tong Man Chung Friendship Promotion Association|21,225|1.55|1|0|−|−|−|−|0|-|-style="background-color:Pink"|colspan=3 style="text-align:left;"|Total for pro-Beijing|107,955|7.88|5|0|136|0.59|3|2|2|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||colspan=2 style="text-align:left;"| Hong Kong and Kowloon Trades Union Council|3,393|0.25|1|0|−|−|1|1|1|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||colspan=2 style="text-align:left;"| Hong Kong Civic Association|14,145|1.03|1|0|−|−|−|−|0|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||colspan=2 style="text-align:left;"| Reform Club of Hong Kong|8,257|0.60|1|0|−|−|−|−|0|-| width=1px style="background-color:#CC0000" ||colspan=2 style="text-align:left;"| October Review|3,431|0.25|1|0|−|−|−|−|0|-| width=1px style="background-color: " ||colspan=2 style="text-align:left;"|Independents and others |287,561|21.00|17|1|4,957|21.66|21|8|9|-|style="text-align:left;background-color:#E9E9E9" colspan="3"|Total (turnout 39.15%)|width="30" style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|1,369,333|style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|100.00|width="75" style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|54|width="30" style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|18|width="30" style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|22,884|style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|100.00|width="75" style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|40|style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|21|width="30" style="text-align:right;background-color:#E9E9E9"|39 |}Note: There were also 18 members appointed by the Governor and 3 Ex-Officio members.

Seats summary

Result breakdown

Geographical Constituencies

ConstituencyCandidatesAffiliation Votes %
Hong Kong Island EastMartin Lee Chu-ming76,831 74.6
Man Sai-cheong43,615 42.3
Cheng Kai-nam29,902 29.0
Chan Ying-lun19,806 19.2
Diana Leung Wai-tung15,230 14.8
Jennifer Chow Kit-bing5,805 5.6
Hong Kong Island WestYeung Sum45,108 65.4
Huang Chen-ya31,052 45.0
David Chan Yuk-cheung29,413 42.6
Alexander Chang Yau-hung12,145 17.6
Ronnie Wong Man-chiu6,113 8.9
Winnie Cheung Wai-sun5,821 8.4
Kowloon EastSzeto Wah57,921 70.3
Li Wah-ming49,64360.2
Hau Shui-puibgcolor=#804000 KTMCA21,225 25.8
Poon Chi-fai16,625 20.2
Chan Cheongbgcolor=Red October Review3,431 4.2
Li Ting-kit3,393 4.1
Philip Li Koi-hop (LDF)865 1.0
Kowloon CentralLau Chin-shek68,48962.2
Conrad Lam Kui-shing56,08451.0
Chan Yuen-han44,894 40.8
Peter Chan Chi-kwan14,145 12.9
Cecilia Yeung Lai-yin8,257 7.5
John Dragon Young (HKAS/UDHK)6,273 5.7
Justin Cheung Chung-ming2,158 2.0
Kowloon WestFrederick Fung Kin-kee36,50852.5
James To Kun-sun26,35237.9
Desmond Lee Yu-tai (HKCA/UDHK)21,471 30.9
Kingsley Sit Ho-yin18,634 26.8
Law Cheung-kwok17,145 24.7
Ng Kin-sun6,098 8.8
New Territories EastEmily Lau Wai-hing46,51548.1
Andrew Wong Wang-fat39,806 41.2
Tony Kan Chung-nin37,126 38.4
Lau Kong-wah26,659 27.6
Johnston Wong Hong-chung26,156 27.1
Choi Man-hing348 0.4
Eric Leung Ka-ching306 0.3
New Territories SouthLee Wing-tat52,192 56.9
Albert Chan Wai-yip42,16445.9
Leung Yiu-chung (NWSC)38,568 42.0
Yeung Fuk-kwong (PHKS)30,095 32.8
New Territories WestNg Ming-yum42,31951.9
Tai Chin-wah30,87137.9
Zachary Wong Wai-yin27,243 33.4
Tang Siu-tong23,38928.7
Tso Shiu-wai20,018 24.6
New Territories NorthFung Chi-wood23,26749.9
Tik Chi-yuen21,70246.5
Cheung Hon-chung16,22134.8
Johnny Wong Chi-keung15,350 32.9
Ronald Chow Mei-tak7,117 15.3
Tong Wai-man1,449 3.1

Functional Constituencies

ConstituencyCandidatesAffiliation Votes%
First CommercialJames David McGregor48753.9
Paul Cheng Ming-fun416 46.1
Second CommercialPhilip Wong Yu-hongUncontested
First IndustrialStephen Cheong Kam-chuenUncontested
Second IndustrialNgai Shiu-kit21656.5
Szeto Fai166 43.5
EngineeringSamuel Wong Ping-wai1,33489.8
Hogan Tang Ka-fat151 10.2
Architectural, Surveying
and Planning
Edward Ho Sing-tin55253.7
Francis Lau Shiu-kwan246 23.9
Kan Fook-yee136 13.2
Charles Nicholas Brooke94 9.1
Real Estate and ConstructionRonald Joseph ArculliUncontested
TeachingCheung Man-kwong15,19389.8
Ho King-on886 5.2
Walter Wou Tchong-hong836 4.9
TourismHoward Young33840.7
Harold Wu Tan318 38.3
Ronnie Yuen Ka-chai175 21.1
AccountancyPeter Wong Hong-yuenUncontested
LegalSimon Ip Sik-on54277.4
John William Miller158 22.6
Social ServicesHui Yin-fatUncontested
Health CareMichael Ho Mun-kaUncontested
MedicalLeong Che-hungUncontested
FinanceDavid Li Kwok-poUncontested
Financial ServicesChim Pui-chung28147.6
Alex Wong Po-hang200 33.9
Cham Yau-tong59 10.0
Peter Chan Po-fun 36 6.1
Chum Ting-pong9 1.5
Wong Wun-wing5 0.8
Labour (2 seats)Pang Chun-hoiUncontested
Tam Yiu-chungUncontested
Urban CouncilElsie TuUncontested
Regional CouncilGilbert Leung Kam-ho2040.0
Chow Yick-hay15 30.0
Lam Wai-keung10 20.0
Chau Chun-wing5 10.0
RuralLau Wong-fatUncontested

Bibliography

Notes and References

  1. An Overview of the Hong Kong Legislative Council Elections of 1991. Asian Journal of Public Administration. Ian. Scott. 13. 2. 1991. 11–37. 10.1080/02598272.1991.10800247.