Claims Conference Explained

Claims Conference
Full Name:	Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany
Purpose:	"negotiates for and disburses funds to individuals and organizations and seeks the return of Jewish property stolen during the Holocaust"^[1]
Headquarters:	New York City
Region:	Worldwide
Leader Title:	President
Leader Name:	Gideon Taylor
Affiliations:	World Jewish Restitution Organization, International Commission on Holocaust Era Insurance Claims
Website:	https://www.claimscon.org/

The Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, or Claims Conference, represents the world's Jews in negotiating for compensation and restitution for victims of Nazi persecution and their heirs. According to Section 2(1)(3) of the Property Law of Germany, the Claims Conference is a legal successor with respect to the claims not filed on time by Jewish persons. This fact was reasserted in decisions of some lawsuits which attempted to redefine the Claims Conference as a "trustee" of these assets. These lawsuits were dismissed.^[2] The Claims Conference administers compensation funds, recovers unclaimed Jewish property, and allocates funds to institutions that provide social welfare services to Holocaust survivors and preserve the memory and lessons of the Holocaust. Julius Berman has led the organization as chairman of the board, and currently president, .^{[3] [4]}

History

The organization was founded in 1951 as a result of negotiations between 23 American Jewish organizations and the government of West Germany under Chancellor Konrad Adenauer.^{[5] [6]}

Compensation programs

As of 2012, the Claims Conference had administered the following programs, which provide direct payments to Jewish victims of Nazi persecution. Programs were negotiated with the German government and are subject to eligibility criteria determined by the German government. The Conference continually negotiates to expand and liberalize eligibility criteria in order to include additional victims in the programs. In 1978, after 25 years of payments, the total Federal Republic of Germany compensation payments amounted to 53 billion Deutsch Marks.^[7] Payments from some programs continue to this day.

• The Article 2 Fund, a lifetime pension for certain persons who were incarcerated in concentration camps, ghettos, or forced labor battalions, or who were forced to go into hiding. Eligibility criteria have been negotiated continually with Germany, and include limits on income, established by the German government.^[8]
• The Central and Eastern European Fund, a pension program similar to the Article 2 Fund, which distributes payments to survivors located in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union (FSU).^[9]
• Hardship Fund, a one-time payment for Jewish victims of Nazism who emigrated from Soviet bloc countries and meet certain eligibility criteria established by the German government.^{[10] [11]}
• Holocaust Victims Compensation Fund, a one-time payment for Jewish victims of Nazism who fled from the Nazis. Comparable to the Hardship Fund but for current residents of the Former Soviet Union. Application deadline has expired.^[12]
• The Child Survivor Fund is a one-time payment intended to acknowledge the suffering of Holocaust survivors who endured unimaginable trauma in their childhoods. This fund is open to Jewish Nazi victims who were persecuted as Jews and were born January 1, 1928, or later.^[13]
• The Spouse of Holocaust Survivor Fund is a fund to compensate the spouses of deceased recipients of the Claims Conference's Article 2 or Central and Eastern European (CEEF) pension funds.^[14]
• Romanian Survivor Relief Program - in 2018 the Claims Conference announced the availability of funds from the Caritatea Foundation in Romania to be distributed to Jewish Nazi victims who lived under the Romanian regime anytime between 1937 and 1944 and currently live outside of Romania and Israel. The Caritatea Foundation was created by the Federation of Jewish Communities in Romania and the World Jewish Restitution Organization (WJRO). These funds are from the restitution of communal properties wrongfully taken from Jewish communities of Romania during and after World War II.^[15]
• Program for Former Slave and Forced Laborers, a one-time payment for persons "compelled to perform work in a concentration camp...a ghetto, or a similar place of incarceration under comparable conditions." Application deadline has expired.^[16]
• Fund for Victims of Medical Experiments and Other Injuries: Application deadline has expired.^[17]
• Fund for the Vaccination of Holocaust Survivors^[18]

International Holocaust Survivors Night (IHSN)

Every year since 2017 the Claims Conference has hosted International Holocaust Survivors Night on the third night of Chanukah to honor Jewish survivors of the Shoah. Events have been hosted in Jerusalem, Berlin, the New York/New Jersey metro area, Paris and Moscow.^{[19] [20]}

Criticism

On May 19, 2006, The Jewish Chronicle revealed that the Claims Conference highest-paid official, executive vice-president Gideon Taylor, was awarded $437,811 (£240,000) in salary and pension (2004 numbers). An advisor to British survivors in compensation claims in the 1990s, Dr Pinto-Duschinsky, commented: "It is wrong for the executive vice-president to earn annually the same as the compensation for several hundred former slave laborers. The moral authority of the leading Jewish organizations is gravely weakened by excessively high salaries for top officials."^[21]

One of the most outspoken critics of the Claims Conference is Isi Leibler, the former chairman of the Governing Board of the World Jewish Congress, who cites allegations of incompetence, impropriety and cover-ups as well as the absence of an independent review board, bureaucratization and a domination by a small clique.^{[22] [23]}

In an article of The Jerusalem Post he says that "the richest Jewish foundation in the world, has still failed to provide adequate financial assistance to elderly and sick Holocaust survivors who live in abject poverty in the twilight of their lives. An organization which boasts that it currently holds in trust $900 million in assets, yet fails to rectify such a condition, must be held accountable for one of the greatest scandals in contemporary Jewish life."^[22]

The priorities of the organization have also been criticized. Among the critics is the Claims Conference own treasurer, Roman Kent, a Holocaust survivor, who told The Jewish Chronicle: "Survivors are suffering. Our only priority should be the survivors, and everything else should be secondary. We are spending money for thousands of projects, but the health of the survivors can't wait. They are dying daily." [...] "I'm not saying that these are bad programs, but they can wait – or else they should be the responsibility of the world Jewish community, not the Claims Conference.^[24]

In a 2006 investigative report, it was claimed the organization, while having $1.7 billion in its accounts, finances welfare assistance for only 9,000 survivors while "tens of millions of dollars each year" are spent on management expenses.^[25]

Amidst this mounting criticism, the office of Germany's independent federal auditor announced it was considering an investigation of the Claims Conference in June 2008.^[26]

In 2023 Claims Conference launched an international investigation into Holocaust denialism. They pushed the claim a large percentage of Dutch youth dismissed the Holocaust. However, investigators and reporters noticed the research was done shoddily and the results seemed made-up.^[27]

Money stolen from Claims Conference

On November 9, 2010, the US Attorney's Office announced an indictment against 11 employees of the Claims Conference and several other individuals for fraud and embezzlement of over $42 million from the Claims Conference. The Claims Conference management alerted the Federal Bureau of Investigation as soon as it discovered the fraud in 2009, and continues to cooperate with the FBI. On October 19, 2012, The Forward reported that the fraud had grown to $57 million.In 2013, an 8-year jail sentence was handed down to Art. 2 funds director Semen Domnitser.^{[28] [29]}

Notable people

• Stuart E. Eizenstat, Chief Negotiator Ambassador
• Nahum Goldmann, lead negotiator against Germany in 1951

See also

• Bona vacantia
• International Commission on Holocaust Era Insurance Claims
• Reparations Agreement between Israel and West Germany
• World Jewish Congress

External links

• • Rachel Blumenthal Lectures on the Creation of the Claims Conference

Notes and References

1. https://www.claimscon.org/about/ "About Us." Claims Conference. 20 February 2023.
2. https://www.law.com/newyorklawjournal/almID/1202752141019/Saving-NaziStolen-Properties-to-Help-Holocaust-Survivors/?mcode=0&curindex=0&curpage=ALL/&slreturn=20211018183948Saving "Nazi-Stolen Properties to Help Holocaust Survivors"
3. Web site: Claims Conference Board of Directors Charts Future Course at Annual Meeting. Claims Conference. July 14, 2014. en-US. 2020-03-29.
4. Boigon, Molly (June 24, 2020). "Claims Conference executive who led during fraud scandal to serve as new chairman". The Forward. Retrieved 2020-09-26.
5. Web site: German Holocaust Reparations . 2023-02-21 . Jewish Virtual Library.
6. Web site: Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany . 2023-02-21 . Jewish Virtual Library.
7. Sagi, Nina (1980). German Reparations: A history of negotiations. Jerusalem: The Magnes Press, The Hebrew University. p. 196. .
8. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2015-01-29 . Article 2 Fund . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
9. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2011-10-27 . Central and Eastern European Fund . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
10. "Germans to compensate survivors who fled". Australian Jewish News. January 23, 2012. Retrieved 2020-09-26.
11. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2015-01-28 . Hardship Fund . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
12. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2011-09-15 . Holocaust Victim Compensation Fund (HVCF) . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
13. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2015-02-03 . Child Survivor Fund . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
14. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2020-01-01 . Spouse of Holocaust Survivor Fund . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
15. Web site: yitz . 2018-06-06 . New Fund for Holocaust Survivors from Romania . 2023-02-21 . WJRO . en-US.
16. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2011-11-09 . Slave and Forced Laborers . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
17. Web site: Conference . Claims . 2011-11-10 . Fund for Victims of Medical Experiments and Other Injuries . 2023-02-21 . Claims Conference . en-US.
18. Web site: Conference. Claims. 2021-03-24. Claims Conference Secures $13.5 Million in Funding to Get Holocaust Survivors to Vaccine Sites. 2021-09-06. Claims Conference. en-US.
19. "International Holocaust Survivors Night 2018". Claims Conference. December 2018. Retrieved 2020-09-26.
20. Schaeffer, Jeffrey; Charlton, Angela (December 23, 2019). "From New York to Moscow, Holocaust survivors share memories". Associated Press. apnews.com. Retrieved 2020-09-26.
21. Web site: The man on the left earns $437,811 a year handling Shoah claims. So why are so many survivors pleading poverty?. Jenni. Frazer. Simon. Rocker. The Jewish Chronicle. 2006-05-19. 2016-08-05.
22. Isi Leibler (May 8, 2007). "Now, the 'March of the Living' scandal". Jerusalem Post. Retrieved 2020-09-26.
23. Isi Leibler. "At the expense of survivors. Candidly Speaking from Jerusalem". November 8, 2010, Available: http://wordfromjerusalem.com/?p=2513
24. Web site: Claims Conference seeks to block documentary. Haviv Rettig Gur. The Jerusalem Post. 2008-04-28. 2016-08-05.
25. http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/1,7340,L-3338282,00.html "Where did the Shoah money go?"
26. Web site: Germany mulls probe of Jewish group overseeing Holocaust restitution . https://web.archive.org/web/20091208163153/http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/993266.html . 2009-12-08 . Haaretz . June 17, 2008.
27. https://www.volkskrant.nl/nieuws-achtergrond/holocaustonderzoek-rammelt-aan-alle-kanten-steekproef-niet-representatief-percentages-lukraak-opgeteld~b5fa22ba
28. Web site: Claims Conference chief knew of $57m Holocaust fraud probe earlier. Nathan. Guttman. The Forward. 2013-05-22. 2016-08-05.
29. Web site: Former Holocaust Claims Conference Director Sentenced to Eight Years in Prison for $57.3 Million Fraud on Organization That Makes Reparations to Victims of Nazi Persecution. US Attorney's Office. 2013-11-04. 2016-08-05.