High-frequency Active Auroral Research Program explained

High-frequency Active Auroral Research Program Research Station
Established:1993
Research Field:Ionosphere
City:Gakona, Alaska, United States
Operating Agency:University of Alaska Fairbanks
Website:https://haarp.gi.alaska.edu/

The High-frequency Active Auroral Research Program (HAARP) is a University of Alaska Fairbanks program which researches the ionosphere – the highest, ionized part of Earth's atmosphere.

The most prominent instrument at HAARP is the Ionospheric Research Instrument (IRI), a high-power radio frequency transmitter facility operating in the high frequency (HF) band. The IRI is used to temporarily excite a limited area of the ionosphere. Other instruments, such as a VHF and a UHF radar, a fluxgate magnetometer, a digisonde (an ionospheric sounding device), and an induction magnetometer, are used to study the physical processes that occur in the excited region.

Initially HAARP was jointly funded by the U.S. Air Force, the U.S. Navy, the University of Alaska Fairbanks, and the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA).[1] It was designed and built by BAE Advanced Technologies. Its original purpose was to analyze the ionosphere and investigate the potential for developing ionospheric enhancement technology for radio communications and surveillance.[2] Since 2015 it has been operated by the University of Alaska Fairbanks.[3]

Work on the HAARP facility began in 1993. The current working IRI was completed in 2007; its prime contractor was BAE Systems Advanced Technologies. As of 2008, HAARP had incurred around $250 million in tax-funded construction and operating costs. In May 2014, it was announced that the HAARP program would be permanently shut down later in the year.[4] After discussions between the parties, ownership of the facility was transferred to the University of Alaska Fairbanks in August 2015.[5]

HAARP is a target of conspiracy theorists, who claim that it is capable of weather manipulation. Commentators and scientists say that advocates of this and other conspiracy theories are wrong,[6] as claims made fall well outside the abilities of the facility, if not the scope of natural science.

History

The High-frequency Active Auroral Research Program began in 1990. Ted Stevens, Republican U.S. senator from Alaska, helped win approval for the facility,[7] and construction began in 1993.

In early May 2013, HAARP was temporarily shut down, awaiting a change between contractors to operate the facility. In July 2013, HAARP program manager James Keeney said, "Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) is expected on site as a client to finish up some research in fall 2013 and winter 2014."[8] [9] The temporary shutdown was described as being due to "a contractor regime change." Ahtna, Incorporated, the Alaska Native corporation serving the region of Alaska where the HAARP site is located, was reportedly in talks to take over the facility administration contract from Marsh Creek, LLC.[10]

In May 2014, the Air Force announced that the HAARP program would be shut down later in 2014.[11] While experiments ended in the summer of 2014, the complete shutdown and dismantling of the facility was postponed until at least May 2015.[12] In mid-August 2015 control of the facility and its equipment was turned over to the University of Alaska Fairbanks, which is making the facilities available for researchers on a pay-per-use basis.[13]

Project overview

HAARP began operating in 1999 as a 6 × 8 (= 48) antenna array at 0.96 MW, expanding in 2007 to a 12 × 15 (=180) array of 180 antennas with 360 radio transmitters at 9.6 MW. It covers 14 ha near Gakona, about 250 km northeast of Anchorage. Its beam direction is anywhere within 30° of zenith.[14] The HAARP project directs a 3.6 MW signal, in the 2.8–10 MHz region of the HF band, into the ionosphere. The signal may be pulsed or continuous. Effects of the transmission and any recovery period can be examined using associated instrumentation, including VHF and UHF radars, HF receivers, and optical cameras. According to the HAARP team, this will advance the study of basic natural processes that occur in the ionosphere under the natural but much stronger influence of solar interaction. HAARP also enables studies of how the natural ionosphere affects radio signals.

The insights gleaned at HAARP will enable scientists to develop methods to mitigate these effects to improve the reliability or performance of communication and navigation systems which would have a wide range of both civilian and military uses, such as an increased accuracy of GPS navigation and advances in underwater and underground research and applications. This may lead, among other things, to improved methods for submarine communication or an ability to remotely sense and map the mineral content of the terrestrial subsurface, and perhaps underground complexes, of regions or countries. The current facility lacks range to be used in regions like the oil-rich Middle East, according to one of the researchers involved, but the technology could be put on a mobile platform.[15]

The project was originally funded by the Office of Naval Research and jointly managed by the ONR and Air Force Research Laboratory, with principal involvement of the University of Alaska Fairbanks. Many other US universities and educational institutions were involved in the development of the project and its instruments, namely the University of Alaska Fairbanks, Stanford University, Penn State University (ARL), Boston College, UCLA, Clemson University, Dartmouth College, Cornell University, Johns Hopkins University, University of Maryland, College Park, University of Massachusetts Amherst, MIT, Polytechnic Institute of New York University, Virginia Tech and the University of Tulsa. The project's specifications were developed by the universities, who continued to play a major role in the design of future research efforts.

According to HAARP's original management, the project strove for openness, and all activities were logged and publicly available, a practice which continues under the University of Alaska Fairbanks. Scientists without security clearances, even foreign nationals, were routinely allowed on site, which also continues today. HAARP hosts an open house annually, during which time any civilian can tour the entire facility. In addition, scientific results obtained using HAARP are routinely published in major research journals (such as Geophysical Research Letters and Journal of Geophysical Research), written both by university scientists (American and foreign) and by U.S. Department of Defense research lab scientists.

Research

HAARP's main goal is basic science research in the uppermost portion of the atmosphere, termed the ionosphere. Essentially a transition between the atmosphere and the magnetosphere, the ionosphere is where the atmosphere is thin enough that the Sun's X-rays and UV rays can reach it, but thick enough that there are enough molecules present to absorb those rays. Consequently, the ionosphere consists of a rapid increase in density of free electrons, beginning at 70 km, reaching a peak at ~300 km, and then falling off again as the atmosphere disappears entirely by ~1,000 km. Various aspects of HAARP can study all of the main layers of the ionosphere.

The profile of the ionosphere is highly variable, changing constantly on timescales of minutes, hours, days, seasons, and years. This profile becomes even more complex near Earth's magnetic poles, where the nearly vertical alignment and intensity of Earth's magnetic field can cause physical effects like the aurora.

The ionosphere is traditionally very difficult to measure. Balloons cannot reach it because the air is too thin, but satellites cannot orbit there because the air is too thick. Hence, most experiments on the ionosphere give only small pieces of information. HAARP approaches the study of the ionosphere by following in the footsteps of an ionospheric heater called EISCAT near Tromsø, Norway. There, scientists pioneered exploration of the ionosphere by perturbing it with radio waves in the 2–10 MHz range, and studying how the ionosphere reacts. HAARP performs the same functions but with more power and a more flexible and agile HF beam.

Some of the main capabilities of HAARP include:

  1. Generating very low frequency (VLF) radio waves by modulated heating of the auroral electrojet, useful because generating VLF waves ordinarily requires gigantic antennas
  2. Generating artificial airglow, which is typically subvisual but routinely detectable.  Under certain geophysical conditions and transmitter configurations, it can be bright enough to observe with the unaided eye.[16] [17]
  3. Generating extremely low frequency (ELF) waves in the 0.1 Hz range. These are next to impossible to produce any other way, because the length of an antenna is dictated by the wavelength of the signal it emits or receives.
  4. Generating whistler-mode VLF signals that enter the magnetosphere and propagate to the other hemisphere, interacting with Van Allen radiation belt particles along the way
  5. VLF remote sensing of the heated ionosphere

Research at the HAARP has included:

  1. Plasma line observations
  2. Stimulated electron emission observations. That is, HAARP stimulates plasma waves, which creates radio waves that are received on the ground. The spectrum depends on charge density, ion mass, magnetic field strength, etc.
  3. Gyro frequency heating research
  4. Spread F observations (blurring of ionospheric echoes of radio waves due to irregularities in electron density in the F layer)
  5. High-velocity trace runs
  6. Airglow observations[18]
  7. Heating induced scintillation observations
  8. VLF and ELF generation observations[19]
  9. Radio observations of meteors
  10. Polar mesospheric summer echoes (PMSE) have been studied, probing the mesosphere using the IRI as a powerful radar, and with a 28 MHz radar and two VHF radars at 49 MHz and 139 MHz. The presence of multiple radars spanning both HF and VHF bands allows scientists to make comparative measurements that may someday lead to an understanding of the processes that form these elusive phenomena.
  11. Research into extraterrestrial HF radar echos: the Lunar Echo experiment (2008).[20] [21]
  12. Testing of spread spectrum Transmitters (2009)
  13. Meteor shower impacts on the ionosphere
  14. Response and recovery of the ionosphere from solar flares and geomagnetic storms
  15. The effect of ionospheric disturbances on GPS satellite signal quality
  16. Producing high density plasma clouds in Earth's upper atmosphere[22]
  17. The magnetic zenith effect, that airglow excited by heated electrons becomes much stronger when at the magnetic zenith (the direction of magnetic field). ~100 Rayleighs in O(1 S) 557.7 nm and O(1 D) 630 nm, the main spectral lines in aurora airglows.[23] [24]

Research conducted at the HAARP facility has allowed the US military to perfect communications with its fleet of submarines by sending radio signals over long distances.[25] [26]

Instrumentation and operation

The main instrument at HAARP is the Ionospheric Research Instrument (IRI). This is a high-power, high-frequency phased array radio transmitter with a set of 180 antennas, disposed in an array of 12×15 units that occupy a rectangle of about NaNacres.[27] [28] The IRI is used to temporarily energize a small portion of the ionosphere. The study of these disturbed volumes yields important information for understanding natural ionospheric processes.

During active ionospheric research, the signal generated by the transmitter system is delivered to the antenna array and transmitted in an upward direction. At an altitude between 70and (depending on operating frequency), the signal is partially absorbed in a small volume several tens of kilometers in diameter and a few meters thick over the IRI. The intensity of the HF signal in the ionosphere is less than 3 μW/cm2, tens of thousands of times less than the Sun's natural electromagnetic radiation reaching the Earth and hundreds of times less than even the normal random variations in intensity of the Sun's natural ultraviolet (UV) energy which creates the ionosphere. The small effects that are produced can be observed with the sensitive scientific instruments installed at the HAARP facility. These observations can provide information about the dynamics of plasmas and insight into the processes of solar-terrestrial interactions.[29]

Each antenna element consists of a crossed dipole that can be polarized for linear, ordinary mode (O-mode), or extraordinary mode (X-mode) transmission and reception.[30] [31] Each part of the two section crossed dipoles is individually fed from a specially designed, custom-built transmitter that operates at very low distortion levels. The effective radiated power (ERP) of the IRI is limited by more than a factor of 10 at its lower operating frequencies. Much of this is due to higher antenna losses and a less efficient antenna pattern.

The IRI can transmit between 2.7 and 10 MHz, a frequency range that lies above the AM radio broadcast band and well below Citizens' Band frequency allocations. HAARP is licensed to transmit only in certain segments of this frequency range. When the IRI is transmitting, the bandwidth of the transmitted signal is 100 kHz or less. The IRI can transmit in continuous waves (CW) or in pulses as short as 10 microseconds (μs). CW transmission is generally used for ionospheric modification, while transmission in short pulses frequently repeated is used as a radar system. Researchers can run experiments that use both modes of transmission, first modifying the ionosphere for a predetermined amount of time, then measuring the decay of modification effects with pulsed transmissions.

There are other geophysical instruments for research located at the HAARP facility. Some of them are:

The facility is powered by a set of five 2500 kilowatt generators being driven by EMD 20-645-E4 diesel locomotive engines.

Site

The project site is north of Gakona, Alaska just west of Wrangell-Saint Elias National Park. An environmental impact statement led to permission for an array of up to 180 antennas to be erected.[32] HAARP was constructed at the previous site of an over-the-horizon radar (OTH) installation. A large structure, built to house the OTH now houses the HAARP control room, kitchen and offices. Several other small structures house various instruments.

The HAARP site was constructed in three distinct phases:[33]

  1. The Developmental Prototype (DP) had 18 antenna elements, organized in three columns by six rows. It was fed with a total of 360 kilowatts (kW) combined transmitter output power. The DP transmitted just enough power for the most basic of ionospheric testing.
  2. The Filled Developmental Prototype (FDP) had 48 antenna units arrayed in six columns by eight rows, with 960 kW of transmitter power. It was fairly comparable to other ionospheric heating facilities. This was used for a number of successful scientific experiments and ionospheric exploration campaigns over the years.
  3. The Final IRI (FIRI) is the final build of the IRI. It has 180 antenna units, organized in 15 columns by 12 rows, yielding a theoretical maximum gain of 31 dB. A total of 3.6 MW of transmitter power will feed it, but the power is focused in the upward direction by the geometry of the large phased array of antennas which allow the antennas to work together in controlling the direction., all the antennas were in place, the final phase was completed and the antenna array was undergoing testing aimed at fine-tuning its performance to comply with safety requirements required by regulatory agencies. The facility officially began full operations in its final status of 3.6MW transmitter power in the summer of 2007, yielding a maximum effective radiated power (ERP) of 5.1gigawatts or 97.1dBW. However, the site typically operates at a fraction of that power due to the lower antenna gain exhibited at frequencies used in standard operation.[34]

Related facilities

In the United States, there have been two related ionospheric heating facilities: the HIPAS, near Fairbanks, Alaska, which was dismantled in 2009, and one at the Arecibo Observatory[35] in Puerto Rico, which collapsed in 2020. The European Incoherent Scatter Scientific Association (EISCAT) operates an ionospheric heating facility capable of transmitting over 1 GW effective radiated power (ERP), near Tromsø, Norway.[36] The Sura Ionospheric Heating Facility, in Vasilsursk, Russia, near Nizhniy Novgorod, is capable of transmitting 190 MW ERP.

Conspiracy theories

HAARP is the subject of numerous conspiracy theories. Various individuals have speculated about hidden motivations and capabilities of the project. For example, Rosalie Bertell warned in 1996 about the deployment of HAARP as a military weapon.[37] Michel Chossudovsky stated in a book published by the Committee on Monetary and Economic Reform that "recent scientific evidence suggests that HAARP is fully operational and has the capability of triggering floods, hurricanes, droughts and earthquakes."[38] Over time, HAARP has been blamed for generating such catastrophes, as well as thunderstorms, in Iran, Pakistan, Haiti, Turkey, Greece and the Philippines, and even major power outages, the downing of TWA Flight 800, Gulf War syndrome, and chronic fatigue syndrome.[39] [40]

Allegations include the following:

In 1995, Elisabeth Rehn, Finnish Member of the European Parliament, tabled a motion for a resolution on the potential use of military-related resources for environmental strategies. The proposal is referred to the Committee on Foreign Affairs, Security and Defense Policy for substantive consideration. Magda Aelvoet, Belgian MEP and President of the Green Group, becomes convinced that HAARP is a secret weapon system.[45] [46] In 1998, the two MEPs, convinced by Begich's theory that HAARP poses a threat to the environment, decided to write a report in which they interviewed only two people — Begich and Rosalie Bertell, head of a Canadian association which also supports the conspiracy theory of chemtrails — the invited representatives of the United States and NATO did not respond. It is on the basis of these two testimonies alone, in which Begich is described as a doctor without having any qualification, that a report by the European Parliament's Committee on Foreign Affairs, Security and Defense Policy relating to the environment, security and foreign policy takes up these assertions and adopts a resolution indicating that "HAARP (High Frequency Active Auroral Research Project) by virtue of its far-reaching impact on the environment to be a global concern and (the European Parliament) calls for its legal, ecological and ethical implications to be examined by an international independent body before any further research and testing."[47]

Two Georgia men arrested on drug charges in November 2016 were reportedly plotting domestic terrorism based on conspiracy theories about HAARP. The Coffee County Sheriff's Office said the men possessed a "massive arsenal" that included AR-15 rifles, Glock handguns, a Remington rifle and thousands of rounds of ammunition. According to police, the men wanted to destroy HAARP because they believed the facility manipulates the weather, controls minds and even traps the souls of people. Police say the men confessed that "God told them to go and blow this machine up that kept souls, so souls could be released."[48] [49]

Stanford University professor Umran Inan told Popular Science that weather-control conspiracy theories were "completely uninformed," explaining that "there's absolutely nothing we can do to disturb the Earth's [weather] systems. Even though the power HAARP radiates is very large, it's minuscule compared with the power of a lightning flash—and there are 50 to 100 lightning flashes every second. HAARP's intensity is very small."[50] Computer scientist David Naiditch characterizes HAARP as "a magnet for conspiracy theorists," saying that HAARP attracts their attention because, "its purpose seems deeply mysterious to the scientifically uninformed."[51] Journalist Sharon Weinberger called HAARP "the Moby Dick of conspiracy theories," and said the popularity of conspiracy theories often overshadows the benefits HAARP may provide to the scientific community.[52] [53] Austin Baird writing in the Alaska Dispatch said, "What makes HAARP susceptible to conspiracy criticism is simple. The facility doesn't open its doors in the same way as other federally funded research facilities around the country, and it doesn't go to great efforts to explain the importance of its research to the public."[39] In 2016, in response to these claims, the University of Alaska Fairbanks Geophysical Institute, which manages the facility, announced that HAARP will host an annual open house in August, allowing visitors to tour the complex.[54]

This project resurfaced again during the 2022 United Nations Climate Change Conference, known as "COP 27", sparking conspiracies as well as many fantasies, and speaking also about geo-engineering.[55] [56]

Following the recent 2023 earthquakes in Turkey and Syria, this project, including that of "Blue Beam", has also been accused of having caused earthquakes, giving rise to numerous conspiracy theories.[57] [58]

On January 11, 2024, far-right conspiracy theorist and Trump ally Laura Loomer, in a Twitter post, suggested that presidential candidate Nikki Haley was using HAARP to conjure up a mid-January blizzard in Iowa in order to hurt fellow candidate Donald Trump's chances in the Iowa caucuses.[59]

Following the widespread visibility of the aurora borealis over much of the Northern Hemisphere in May, 2024, conspiracy theorists promoted HAARP as the true cause of the event.[60]

In popular culture

HAARP gave rise to a live album by the rock band Muse and became the theme of novels like La Route de Gakona by .[61]

HAARP is the key plot point in Breaking Point of Tom Clancy's Net Force (2000), where it is used to induce group madness.[62]

The HAARP facility appears in the 2004 video game X-Men Legends. In the game, the X-Men track the Brotherhood of Mutants to HAARP.[63] The facility is significantly different from its real life counterpart, with snowy valleys around it and vast icy tunnels below.[64] It is guarded by an extensive security force, including armed guards and tanks. The X-Men eventually locate the Brotherhood and learn that sensitive information,[65] including the location of Magneto's imprisonment,[66] [67] is kept in the HAARP computers.

Season 1, episode 11, of the UPN TV series Seven Days was titled "HAARP Attack". It was broadcast on January 27, 1999.[68]

The HAARP facility is briefly mentioned in the lore of the game Project Zomboid, a zombie survival game set in a fictionalised Knox County, Kentucky in 1993. HAARP is mentioned in the collectable home VHS tape "conspiracy crap???", equating it to other "lies" the US Military has made regarding UFOs and the Philadelphia Experiment.[69]

In December 2023, an in-game map inspired and named after HAARP was added to Team Fortress 2.

See also

Further reading

Patents

Videos

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 15 June 2007 . HAARP Fact Sheet . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20091007235012/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/factSheet.html . 7 October 2009 . 27 September 2009 . HAARP.
  2. Web site: Purpose and Objectives of the HAARP Program . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20091001114140/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/prpeis.html . 1 October 2009 . 27 September 2009 . HAARP.
  3. Web site: About HAARP . 5 February 2022 . University of Alaska Fairbanks . en-US.
  4. Web site: Air Force prepares to dismantle HAARP ahead of summer shutdown . Dermot . Cole . 2014-05-14 . Anchorage Daily News . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20140517010257/http://www.adn.com/2014/05/14/3470442/air-force-prepares-to-dismantle.html . 17 May 2014.
  5. News: Rozell . Ned . 6 September 2015 . Under new management, Alaska's HAARP facility open for business again . en-US . Alaska Dispatch News . 10 September 2015.
  6. Web site: Washington . District of Columbia 1800 I. Street NW . Dc 20006 . Turkey-Syria earthquakes were natural disasters, not geoengineered . 2023-02-26 . politifact.com . en-US.
  7. US ionospheric research facility to close. 16 May 2014. 18 August 2014. Nature. Weinberger. Sharon. 10.1038/nature.2014.15243. 124572280.
  8. Web site: HAARP Facility Shuts Down. ARRL. 16 July 2013.
  9. Web site: Byrd. Deborah. Crazy weather? You can't blame HAARP anymore. 16 July 2013. EarthSky, 16 July 2013. 17 July 2013.
  10. News: Anderson. Ben. Alaska's controversial HAARP facility closed – will it come back online?. 18 July 2013. Alaska Dispatch. 18 July 2013. 14 July 2014. https://web.archive.org/web/20140714064246/http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/20130717/alaska-s-controversial-haarp-facility-closed-will-it-come-back-online. dead.
  11. News: Bye-Bye to the Home of a Favorite Internet Conspiracy Theory . Geoff . Brumfiel . 10 June 2014 . NPR . 2014-06-11.
  12. News: HAARP closure postponed until 2015 . Dermot . Cole . 2 July 2014 . Alaska Dispatch News . 2015-06-03.
  13. Future Operations of HAARP with the UAF's Geophysical Institute . AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts. 2015 . AE22A–07 . McCoy . Robert. American Geophysical Union Fall Meeting 2015 . 10 September 2015. 2015AGUFMAE22A..07M.
  14. Pedersen . Todd . 2015-12-01 . HAARP, the most powerful ionosphere heater on Earth . Physics Today . en . 68 . 12 . 72–73 . 10.1063/PT.3.3032 . 0031-9228.
  15. David . Hambling . 12 January 2010 . Pentagon scientists target Iran's nuclear mole-men . . 18 December 2018 . www.wired.com.
  16. Pedersen . Todd R. . Gerken . Elizabeth A. . February 2005 . Creation of visible artificial optical emissions in the aurora by high-power radio waves . Nature . en . 433 . 7025 . 498–500 . 10.1038/nature03243 . 1476-4687.
  17. Hysell. D. L.. Miceli. R. J.. Kendall. E. A.. Schlatter. N. M.. Varney. R. H.. Watkins. B. J.. Pedersen. T. R.. Bernhardt. P. A.. Huba. J. D.. 2014. Heater-induced ionization inferred from spectrometric airglow measurements. Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics. 119. 3. 2038–2045. 10.1002/2013JA019663. 2169-9402. 2014JGRA..119.2038H. 129590018 . free.
  18. Kendall. Elizabeth. Marshall. Robert. Parris. Richard Todd. Bhatt. Asti. Coster. Anthea. Pedersen. Todd. Bernhardt. Paul. Selcher. Craig. 2010. Decameter structure in heater-induced airglow at the High frequency Active Auroral Research Program facility. Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics. 115. A8. n/a. 10.1029/2009JA015043. 2156-2202. 2010JGRA..115.8306K. free.
  19. M. B. . Cohen . U. S. . Inan . M. A. . Golkowski. Geometric modulation: A more effective method of steerable ELF/VLF wave generation with continuous HF heating of the lower ionosphere. Geophysical Research Letters . 35 . L12101 . 10.1029/2008GL034061 . free . June 2008. n/a . 2008GeoRL..3512101C .
  20. Reeve, W.D.. The Lunar Echo Experiment (Part 1). Radio User. 2008. 8. 56–58. 1748-8117. 3.
  21. Reeve, W.D.. The Lunar Echo Experiment (Part 2). Radio User. 2008. 9. 56–57. 1748-8117. 3.
  22. NRL Scientists Produce Densest Artificial Ionospheric Plasma Clouds Using HAARP . U.S. Naval Research Lab . 2013-02-25 . 5 April 2013 . Using the 3.6-megawatt high-frequency (HF) HAARP transmitter, the plasma clouds, or balls of plasma, are being studied for use as artificial mirrors at altitudes 50 kilometers below the natural ionosphere and are to be used for reflection of HF radar and communications signals. Past attempts to produce electron density enhancements have yielded densities of 4×10⁵ electrons per cubic centimeter (cm3) using HF radio transmissions near the second, third, and fourth harmonics of the electron cyclotron frequency. This frequency near 1.44 MHz is the rate that electrons gyrate around the Earth's magnetic field. The NRL group succeeded in producing artificial plasma clouds with densities exceeding 9×10⁵ electrons cm3 using HAARP transmission at the sixth harmonic of the electron cyclotron frequency. . https://web.archive.org/web/20130302065739/http://www.nrl.navy.mil/media/news-releases/2013/nrl-scientists-produce-densest-artificial-ionospheric-plasma-clouds-using-haarp . 2 March 2013 . dead .
  23. Pedersen . T. R. . McCarrick . M. . Gerken . E. . Selcher . C. . Sentman . D. . Carlson . H. C. . Gurevich . A. . February 2003 . Magnetic zenith enhancement of HF radio‐induced airglow production at HAARP . Geophysical Research Letters . en . 30 . 4 . 10.1029/2002GL016096 . 0094-8276.
  24. Kosch . M. J. . Pedersen . T. . Mishin . E. . Oyama . S. . Hughes . J. . Senior . A. . Watkins . B. . Bristow . B. . June 2007 . Coordinated optical and radar observations of ionospheric pumping for a frequency pass through the second electron gyroharmonic at HAARP . Journal of Geophysical Research: Space Physics . en . 112 . A6 . 10.1029/2006JA012146 . 0148-0227.
  25. Book: History and applications of HAARP technologies: the High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program. Bailey. Patrick. Worthington. Nancy. IECEC-97 Proceedings of the Thirty-Second Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference (Cat. No.97CH6203). 1317–1322 vol.2. 27 July 1997. IEEE. 10.1109/IECEC.1997.661959. 0-7803-4515-0. 108467419.
  26. ELF and VLF radio waves. Barr. R.. Llanwyn Jones. D.. Rodger. C.J.. 2000. Journal of Atmospheric and Solar-Terrestrial Physics. 62. 10.1016/S1364-6826(00)00121-8. 17–18. 1689–1718. 2000JASTP..62.1689B.
  27. Book: Chapter 2 . Opportunities for High-Power, High-Frequency Transmitters to Advance Ionospheric / Thermospheric Research . Report of a Workshop . 2014 . National Academies Press . National Academy of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine . 10.17226/18620 . 978-0-309-29859-9 . https://www.nap.edu/read/18620/chapter/2 . 8 February 2017.
  28. Streep, Abe . July 2008 . Ionospheric manipulation made easy . . 273 . 1 . 61–63 . 8 February 2017.
  29. Technical Information . 12 April 2007 . HAARP . . 27 September 2009 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20091002090806/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/tech.html . 2 October 2009.
  30. The HAARP Antenna Array . HAARP . . 27 September 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20070415111323/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/ant3.html . 15 April 2007.
  31. Details of the HAARP Antenna Design . HAARP . . 27 September 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20070513135131/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/ant2.html . 13 May 2007.
  32. Web site: 17 May 2007 . The HAARP IRI As Described in the EIS . 27 September 2009 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20090925144409/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/iriEis.html . 25 September 2009.
  33. Web site: Phases of Completion of the IRI . HAARP . https://web.archive.org/web/20070501131817/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/phases.html . 1 May 2007 .
  34. Web site: 10 May 2010 . HAARP IRI Performance Calculator . 10 May 2010 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20100419223036/http://www.haarp.alaska.edu/haarp/calciri.html . 19 April 2010.
  35. http://www.naic.edu/general_int/gen_wshops/AGRP%20workshop%20report5.pdf Link text
  36. Web site: B. Isham . C. La Hoz . M. T. Rietveld . F. T. Djuth . T. Hagfors . T. Grydeland . October 2000 . High Latitude HF-Induced Plasma Turbulence . The First S-RAMP Conference . 27 September 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20111108050251/http://www.kurasc.kyoto-u.ac.jp/s-ramp/abstract/s19.txt . 8 November 2011 .
  37. , Background on the HAARP Project. Global Policy Forum, 5 November 1996
  38. , Climate Manipulation as a War Weapon, p181-182. In,Meltdown : Money, Debt and Wealth of Nations : how Zero Inflation Policy is Leading the World's Monetary and Economic Systems to Collapse : an Anthology from the First Decade of Economic Reform
  39. News: Baird. Austin. HAARP conspiracies: Guide to most far-out theories behind government research in Alaska. 21 February 2022. Alaska Dispatch. 20 September 2011.
  40. News: Flock. Elizabeth. Conspiracy Theorists Say Obama Engineered Hurricane Sandy. 8 December 2012. U.S. News & World Report. 29 October 2012.
  41. Shachtman. Noah. Strange New Air Force Facility Energizes Ionosphere, Fans Conspiracy Flames. Wired Magazine. 17 April 2011. 20 July 2009.
  42. Web site: About us - Dr. Nick Begich. 2 June 2011. https://web.archive.org/web/20110518105035/http://www.earthpulse.com/src/category.asp?catid=13. 18 May 2011. dead.
  43. Web site: EU clashes with US over atmosphere tests. physicsworld.com. 27 February 1998. IOP Publishing, 27 February 1998. 10 May 2020.
  44. Web site: Baenen. Jeff. Ventura seeks out conspiracy theories at Alaska station. Juneau Empire. 17 October 2011. https://web.archive.org/web/20131214195544/http://juneauempire.com/stories/120309/sta_531557452.shtml. 14 December 2013. dead.
  45. Book: Croizé, Jean-Paul . Climat: la fausse menace ? . 2004 . Carnot . 978-2-84855-004-6 . Chatou . 129.
  46. Web site: 9 February 1998 . The HAARP Project and non-lethal weapons . 2023-06-27 . www.europarl.europa.eu.
  47. Web site: Theorin . Maj Britt . Report on the environment, security and foreign policy (Hughes procedure) - Committee on Foreign Affairs, Security and Defence Policy A4-0005/1999 . 2023-06-27 . www.europarl.europa.eu . en.
  48. News: Zak . Annie . Georgia men plotted attack on Alaska aurora research facility to 'release souls,' detective says . Anchorage Daily News . 2 January 2017.
  49. Web site: Buckets. Re-Essa. Suspected terrorists believe research facility controls minds, traps souls. WALB news. 2 January 2017. https://web.archive.org/web/20180829081226/http://www.walb.com/story/33541811/suspected-terrorists-believes-research-facility-controls-minds-traps-souls. 29 August 2018.
  50. Streep. Abe. The Military's Mystery Machine: The High-frequency Active Auroral Research Program, or HAARP, has been called a missile-defense tool and a mind-control device. The truth is a bit less ominous. 18 June 2008. Popular Science. 12 December 2012.
  51. Web site: Is baked Alaska half-baked?. Naiditch . David . Spring 2003 . Skeptic Magazine. 25 January 2010.
  52. Atmospheric physics: Heating up the heavens. Weinberger . Sharon . 23 April 2008. Nature. 452. 7190. 930–2. 10.1038/452930a. 18441549.
  53. The Strange Life and Times of HAARP. Weinberger. Sharon . 25 April 2008 . Wired Magazine. 21 January 2010.
  54. News: HAARP's new owner holds open house to prove facility 'is not capable of mind control'. Rosen. Yereth. Anchorage Daily News. 25 August 2016. 18 December 2018.
  55. Web site: 2022-11-08 . Truth or Fake - HAARP: Watch out for this conspiracy theory on climate change . 2023-06-27 . France 24 . en.
  56. Web site: La manipulation du climat peut-elle déclencher une nouvelle guerre froide?. 2023-06-27 . www.heidi.news . 18 October 2022 . fr.
  57. Web site: Cockerell . Isobel . 2023-02-17 . Turkey-Syria earthquake was made in Alaska, say conspiracists . 2023-06-27 . Coda Story . en-US.
  58. Web site: 2023-02-18 . 'This is so crazy': conspiracists blame US research unit for Turkey quake . 2023-06-27 . South China Morning Post . en.
  59. Web site: 2024-01-11 . 'Beyond the pale': Trump ally ridiculed for believing Nikki Haley can control the weather . 2024-01-12 . Raw Story . en.
  60. Web site: 2024-05-14 . Absurd Conspiracy Theory Claims HAARP Science Experiment Triggered Global Auroras . 2024-05-14 . Gizmodo . en.
  61. Web site: Rédaction . La . 2011-03-24 . HAARP : ce qu'il faut savoir avant de se mettre à fantasmer . 2023-06-27 . Conspiracy Watch L'Observatoire du conspirationnisme . fr-FR.
  62. Book: Clancy, Tom . Tom Clancy's Net force. Breaking point . Pieczenik . Steve R. . Perry . Steve . 2000 . Berkley Books . Copyright Paperback Collection (Library of Congress) . 978-0-425-17693-1 . Berkley . New York . ocm45155308.
  63. X-Men Legends. Raven Software. Activision. 2004. GameCube, PS2, Xbox. HAARP Facility Mission Briefing. HAARP Facility. English. Professor Xavier: 'With the aid of Cerebro, I've learned The Brotherhood is en route to Alaska. It appears their destination is the facility for the High Frequency Active Auroral Research Program - also known simply as HAARP.'.
  64. X-Men Legends. Raven Software. Activision. 2004. GameCube, PS2, Xbox. HAARP Facility. English.
  65. X-Men Legends. Raven Software. Activision. 2004. GameCube, PS2, Xbox. Conversation with Iceman after returning from the HAARP mission. X-Mansion. English. Iceman: 'Yeah, I guess there was a lot of equipment at the facility that had nothing to do with studying the Aurora Borealis...Professor X thinks the government might be using it as a hi-tech headquarters for storing sensitive information - stuff they don't want regular people to know about.'.
  66. X-Men Legends. Raven Software. Activision. 2004. GameCube, PS2, Xbox. Conversation after the boss battle with Toad. HAARP Facility. English. Toad: 'Okay, okay...look, Mystique wanted a location that was stored on the computers here.'.
  67. X-Men Legends. Raven Software. Activision. 2004. GameCube, PS2, Xbox. Conversation with Nightcrawler after the Nuclear Power Plant mission. X-Mansion. English. Nightcrawler: 'We're trying to discover how Mystique knew to go to the HAARP facility to find the location of Magneto's prison.'.
  68. Web site: Seven Days Season 1 Episodes. TV Guide. Fandom. 2023-06-21.
  69. Web site: Home VHS: conspiracy crap??? . 29 August 2023 . PZwiki.