HRAC classification explained

The Herbicide Resistance Action Committee (HRAC) classifies herbicides by their mode of action (MoA) to provide a uniform way for farmers and growers to identify the agents they use and better manage pesticide resistance around the world.[1] [2] It is run by CropLife International[3] in conjunction with the Weed Science Society of America (WSSA).

Resistance overview

A weed that develops resistance to one herbicide typically has resistance to other herbicides with the same mode of action (MoA), so herbicides with different MoAs, or different resistance groups, are needed. Preventative weed resistance management rotates herbicide types to prevent selective breeding of resistance to the same mode of action. By rotating MoAs, successive generations gain no advantage from any resistant mutations of the last generation.[4] Cross-resistant and multiply resistant weeds resist multiple MoAs,[5] and are particularly difficult to control.

There is limited evidence of resistance undoing other resistances. For example, prosulfocarb and trifluralin: their inverse mechanisms of resistance contradict, and so by evolving to one the weed loses resistance to the other, at least by metabolic resistance. Prosulfocarb requires a weed to metabolise it very slowly to survive; trifluralin on the other hand must be metabolised quickly before it can deal damage to the weed.[6]

Naming types

The HRAC give a letter based class to each active constituent herbicide. The Australian HRAC code is separately assigned, though is often the same as the global code. In 2021, alternative numeric classes were added, to make codes globally more consistent. This set of classification changes also added or moved a few herbicides that had been misclassified, and reduced regional concerns that using the English alphabet could be an impediment for international growers.[4]

Herbicides that act through multiple modes have multiple classifications, corresponding to each MoA.[7] For example, Quinmerac is classified as Group 4/29 (O/L) because it is both an Auxin mimic (Group 4 or O) and inhibits cellulose synthesis (Group 29 or L).

Groups

HRAC Classification Groups[8] [9]
HRAC (AUS)HRAC (Global)HRAC (Numeric)class=unsortable Mode of actionclass=unsortable Example herbicidesclass=unsortable Example chemical families
A A 1 Inhibits acetyl coa carboxylase Aryloxyphenoxy-propionates, Cyclohexanediones, Phenylpyrazolines
B B 2 Inhibits acetolactate synthase Imidazolinones, Pyrimidinyl benzoates, Sulfonylureas, Triazolopyrimidines
C C1 / C2 5 Inhibits photosynthesis at PSII - serine 264 binders Triazines, Amides, Phenlcarbamates, Pyridazinones, Triazinones, Triazolinones, Uracil, Ureas
C C3 6 Inhibits photosynthesis at PSII - histidine 215 binders/uncouplers Benzothiadiazinones, Nitriles
- C2 7 Isoproturon[10] Urea
D K1 3 inhibits microtubule assembly Dinitroanilines, Benzoic acids, Pyridines, Phosphoroamidates, Benzoic acids[11]
E K2 23 Inhibits microtubule organisation Carbamates
F F1 12 Inhibits phytoene desaturase Phenyl ethers, N-Phenyl heterocycles
G E 14 Inhibits protoporphyrinogen oxidase N-Phenyl-imides. Diphenyl ethers, N-Phenyl-oxadiazolones, Phenylpyrazoles
H F2 27 Inhibits hydroxyphenyl pyruvate dioxygenase Soxazoles, Pyrazoles, Triketones
I O 4 6-Arylpicolinates, 6-Chloropicolinates, Benzoates, Phenoxy-carboxylates, Pyridyloxy-carboxylates, Quinoline-carboxylates
J K3 / N 15 Inhibits very long chain fatty acid synthesis Thiocarbamates, Benzofurans
J - Unknown Chlorocarbonic acids
K K3 15 Inhibits very long chain fatty acid synthesis α-Chloroacetamides, Isoxazolines
K - Unknown Acetamide
L D 22 PS I electron diversion Pyridinium
M G 9 Inhibits enolpyruvil shikimate phosphate synthase Glycine
N H 10 Phosphinic acid
O L 29 inhibition of cellulose synthesis Nitrile, Benzamide, Alkylazine
P P 19 Auxin transport inhibitor Aryl-carboxylates
Q F3 / F4 13 Inhibits deoxy-d-xylulose phosphate synthesis Isoxazolidinone
Q - - Unknown Triazole
R I 18 Inhibits dihydropteroate synthase carbamate
- - 28 Inhibition of dihydroorotate dehydrogenase
T Q / Z 30 Inhibits fatty acid thioesterase Benzyl-ether
Z R 31 Inhibits serine-threonine protein phosphatase Other
Z Z - Unknown Arylaminopropionic acid, Others
- M 24 Uncouplers Dinitrophenol
- S / F3 32 Inhibition of Solanesyl Diphosphate Synthase Diphenyl ether
- T 33 Inhibition of Homogentisate Solanesyltransferase Phenoxypyridazine

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Appendix 7. Classification of Herbicides According to Mode of Action . . November 20, 2024 .
  2. Web site: HRAC MoA Classification Update Webinar Training 6th May 2022 . European Weed Research Society . November 20, 2024 .
  3. Sievernich . Bernd . Belvaux . Xavier . Hunt . Barrie . February 2024 . Bundesbehörden Und Einrichtungen Im Geschäftsbereich Des Bundesministeriums Für Ernährung Und Landwirtschaft (BMEL) . HRAC Europe – Partner on Weed Resistance Management . Julius-Kühn-Archiv . en . 478 . 31 . 94 . 10.5073/20240109-073031-0.
  4. Web site: Fact sheet HRAC Mode of Action Updates . Weed Science Society of America . 20 September 2024.
  5. Web site: Overview . Herbicide Resistance Action Committee . 20 September 2024 . en.
  6. Busi . Roberto . Goggin . Danica E . Onofri . Andrea . Boutsalis . Peter . Preston . Christopher . Powles . Stephen B . Beckie . Hugh J . Loss of trifluralin metabolic resistance in Lolium rigidum plants exposed to prosulfocarb recurrent selection . Pest Management Science . December 2020 . 76 . 12 . 3926–3934 . 10.1002/ps.5993. 32638493 .
  7. Oršolić . Davor . Pehar . Vesna . Šmuc . Tomislav . Stepanić . Višnja . 2021-06-01 . Comprehensive machine learning based study of the chemical space of herbicides . Scientific Reports . en . 11 . 1 . 11479 . 10.1038/s41598-021-90690-w . 2045-2322 . 8169684 . 34075109.
  8. Web site: Australia Herbicide Classification Lookup . Herbicide Resistance Action Committee . 20 September 2024 . en.
  9. Web site: 2024 HRAC GLOBAL HERBICIDE MOA CLASSIFICATION MASTER LIST . Herbicide Resistance Action Committee . en.
  10. Web site: Pesticide Properties Database . sitem.herts.ac.uk.
  11. Web site: 2008 Herbicide Mode of Action Table . weedscience.org.