Hell You Talmbout Explained
| Hell You Talmbout |
| Cover: | Wondaland Records - Hell You Talmbout.png |
| Border: | yes |
| Type: | single |
| Artist: | Janelle Monáe and various artists |
| Recorded: | 2015 |
| Label: | Wondaland |
| Chronology: | Janelle Monáe |
| Prev Title: | Yoga |
| Prev Year: | 2015 |
| Next Title: | Pressure Off |
| Next Year: | 2015 |
"Hell You Talmbout"[1] is a 2015 protest song by Janelle Monáe and the members of her Wondaland artist collective, including Deep Cotton, George 2.0, Jidenna, Roman GianArthur, and St. Beauty.
The song lists the names of various African American people who died as a result of encounters with law enforcement or racial violence, and implores listeners to say the names of the dead. Wondaland and Monáe subsequently released the instrumental track of the song, so that listeners could make their own versions.[2] [3] [4] [5]
Reception
The song received favourable reviews, and many spoke positively about the message of the song. Fast Company described it as "simple yet unquestionably powerful", stating that it will force listeners to remember those who have been murdered.[6] Stereogum called it "less a song and more of a chant, with some gospel overtones", and emphasized that it is both "simple" and "effective".[7] USA Today declared it the "song of the week", praising the song's "simple but stark approach" of only listing names rather than describing circumstances, and attributing this to a desire to avoid "arguments that can quickly turn divisive and bitter",[8] while National Public Radio called it "visceral" and "blistering".[9]
Malcolm Gladwell's audiobook Talking to Strangers, a reflection on the psychology surrounding the arrest and death of Sandra Bland, uses "Hell You Talmbout" as a theme song: "I was almost finished with my book when I first heard [Hell You Talmbout], and I thought, 'I cannot publish Talking to Strangers without it.'"[10]
Other versions
- Transgender rights advocate Vita Elizabeth Cleveland recorded an answer song, "Hell Y'all Ain't Talmbout", which focuses on the names of murdered African-American trans women.[11]
- David Byrne and his band performed "Hell You Talmbout" as the final encore each night on his American Utopia Tour.[12] [13] Byrne said, "This is one of the most moving political songs that I'd ever heard" and chose it because it "...ends the show on the vibe of, 'This is where we are at in 2018.'"[14] A version of it appears on the American Utopia on Broadway album, as well as the Spike Lee-directed film of the concert, during which, several family members of the deceased mentioned hold up photographs of them. During the applause, additional tributes are shown to those who have lost their lives since the song came out, prominently Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, and George Floyd, as well as additional tributes to those not mentioned in the song "and too many more". Floyd and Taylor's names were added when the show returned to Broadway in 2021.
- In late September 2021, Monáe released a 17-minute version of the song entitled "Say Her Name (Hell You Talmbout)". The updated version featured the names of 61 Black women and girls who were murdered at the hands of police brutality. Among the vocalists that contributed to the new version the song are Beyoncé Knowles, Alicia Keys, Tierra Whack, Zoë Kravitz, Brittany Howard and Chloe x Halle.[15]
Notes
- The word "talmbout" is a contraction of "talking about".
- Web site: Eric. Torres. Janelle Monáe and Wondaland Records Share Protest Song "Hell You Talmbout". Pitchfork. 13 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Trevor. Anderson. Hailee Steinfeld Finds 'Love' on Billboard + Twitter Top Tracks. Billboard. 20 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Web site: Jay. Nordlinger. This is CNN, &c.. National Review. 11 June 2014. 31 August 2015.
- Web site: Elias. Leight. Janelle Monae Asks Listeners To Record Personal Versions Of "Hell You Talmbout". The Fader. 28 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Web site: KC. Ifeanyi. Janelle Monáe's Protest Song Is A Heart-Rending Roll Call Of Injustices. Fast Company. 20 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Web site: Tom. Breihan. Janelle Monáe, Jidenna, St. Beauty, Deep Cotton & Roman GianArthur – "Hell You Talmbout". Stereogum. 13 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Web site: Brian. Mansfield. Song of the week: Monáe's 'Hell You Talmbout'. USA Today. 20 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Web site: Katie. Presley. Janelle Monáe Releases Visceral Protest Song, 'Hell You Talmbout'. NPR. 18 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- Book: Gladwell, Malcolm. Talking to Strangers. Little, Brown and Co.. 2019. 9780316478526. New York. 3.
- Web site: Sunnivie. Brydum. WATCH: In Wake of Trans Murders, Janet Mock Teaches Us Why We Must #SayHerName. The Advocate. 25 August 2015. 31 August 2015.
- News: Sodomsky . Sam . 2018-03-13 . David Byrne Shares New Video, Covers Janelle Monáe: Watch . Pitchfork . Chicago . 2018-10-08 .
- Exposito . Suzy . Phull . Hardeep . Appleford . Syeve . 2018-04-16 . Coachella 2018: The 18 Best Things We Saw at Weekend One . Rolling Stone. NYC . 2018-10-08 .
- News: Schlanger. Talia. 2018-08-29 . David Byrne Digs For Wonder . NPR World Cafe . Philadelphia. 2018-10-08 .
- Web site: Cho . Regina . Janelle Monáe shares powerful new track "Say Her Name (Hell You Talmbout)" . Revolt Magazine . 5 October 2021.
External links
