Handbag Party Explained

Handbag Party [1] was a group of Hong Kong female senior officials in the late British colonial government and early Chinese administration, led by then-Chief Secretary Anson Chan. The clique was named after they dressed like then British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher with handbags in hand,[2] and sang for the departing Governor Sir Murray MacLehose in a 1982 farewell dinner. Media described them as "with small handbags but strong audacity and in high-ranking positions".[3]

Soon after the handover, rumoured disagreement between Chan and the inaugural Chief Executive Tung Chee-hwa diminished the power of the Handbag Party. Following the introduction of the Principal Officials Accountability System, most of the members were not promoted to appointed minister-level principal officials and remained as permanent secretary only.[4] As Chan retired early in 2001, others either followed suit or remained in the government of Tung and later of Donald Tsang.

List of members

The clique was led by Anson Chan and with Lily Yam as the number two. Members include:[5]

!!Position in 1982!Highest position!After retirement
Anson ChanDeputy Director of Social WelfareChief Secretary (1993–2001)Member of Legislative Council (2007–2008)
Margaret ChanGovernment-employed doctorDirector of Health (1994–2003)Director-General of World Health Organization (2006–2017), member of Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference
Cheung Man-yeeRadio Television Hong Kong Controller (Broadcasting Services - Radio)Director of Broadcasting (1986–1999)Representative to Tokyo (1999–2002)
Katherine FokSecretary of Standing Commission on Civil Service Salaries and Conditions of ServiceHealth Secretary (1994–1999)Retired
Rita LauAdministrative Officer at Government SecretariatCommerce Secretary (2008–2011)Chairman of Public Service Commission (2014–2023)
Sandra Birch LeeAdministrative Officer at Government SecretariatPermanent Secretary for Food and Health (2007–2011)Retired
Shelley LeeAdministrative Officer at Government SecretariatPermanent Secretary for Home Affairs (2002–2005)Retired
Lily YamDeputy Commissioner of Independent Commission Against CorruptionEnvironment Secretary (2000–2002)Retired
Carrie YauAdministrative Officer at Government SecretariatPermanent Secretary for Home Affairs (2007–2010)Executive Director of Vocational Training Council (2013–2021)
Irene Yau (丘李賜恩)Information OfficerDirector of Information Services (1987–1997)Retired
Helen Yu (余黎青萍)Deputy Hong Kong Commissioner in LondonDirector of Regional Services (1998–2000)Member of Independent Police Complaints Council
Denise YueAdministrative Officer at Government SecretariatCivil Service Secretary (2006–2012)Retired
Other members said to be part of the Handbag Party include Elizabeth Margaret Bosher, former minister, Elizabeth Wong, former Health Secretary, and Baroness Dunn, former Senior Member of Executive Council and Legislative Council.[6]

Carrie Lam, who would become Chief Executive, was also claimed to be a part of the group, but it was denied by Lam herself and Chan, who described her successor as "unaligned".[7]

Aftermath

With CY Leung selected as the new Chief Executive, the last prominent member of the Handbag Party left the administration in 2012. Some of the members leaned towards liberal in 2019, with Yue and Chan calling for an independent enquiry over the large-scale protests, which was rejected by the Lam ministry.[8] According to media reports, the group still met often despite their retirement.[9]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 陳 . 芳葆 . 2007 . From colony to SAR: the rise and decline of "handbag party" in Hong Kong . Hong Kong Shue Yan University.
  2. Web site: 【Power to the Ladies】古典手袋黨 . 2023-11-18 . LifeStyle Journal.
  3. Web site: 2023-05-31 . 手袋黨|食衛局前常秘李淑儀沽薄扶林豪宅賺逾3,700萬 . 2023-11-17 . Finance730 . zh-HK.
  4. Web site: 2005-12-06 . 手袋黨成員全為女高官 . 2023-11-18 . Apple Daily.
  5. Book: 黃, 海 . 香港社會階層分析 . 商務印書館(香港)有限公司 . 2017 . 9789620772184 . 271–2.
  6. Web site: 【非凡人物】除了能力還有氣質!緬懷香港「手袋黨」的優雅! . 2023-11-17 . BusinessFocus . zh-Hant-HK.
  7. Web site: 2020-08-18 . 回顧公僕生涯 林鄭月娥:無「馬房」也不是「手袋黨」 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210317161918/https://news.rthk.hk/rthk/ch/component/k2/1544367-20200818.htm . 2021-03-17 . RTHK . zh-hk .
  8. Web site: 沙半山 . 2019-07-23 . 【元朗黑夜】任關佩英等36前高官再發聯署信 促設獨立委員會 . 2023-11-17 . 香港01 . zh-HK.
  9. Web site: 2023-03-24 . 手袋黨怒罵《毒舌大狀》 . 2023-11-17 . Bastille Post.