HM Prison Dartmoor explained

Prison Name:	HMP Dartmoor
Location:	Princetown, Devon
Classification:	Adult Male/Category C
Population:	640
Populationdate:	January 2016
Opened:	1809
Closed:	2024
Managed By:	HM Prison Services
Governor:	Steve Mead ^[1]

HM Prison Dartmoor is a Category C men's prison, located in Princetown, high on Dartmoor in the English county of Devon. Its high granite walls dominate this area of the moor. The prison is owned by the Duchy of Cornwall, and is operated by His Majesty's Prison Service.

Dartmoor Prison was given Grade II heritage listing in 1987.^[2]

History

POW prison

In 1805, the United Kingdom was at war with Napoleonic France, a conflict during which thousands of prisoners were taken and confined in prison "hulks" or derelict ships. This was considered unsafe, partially due to the proximity of the Royal Naval dockyard at Devonport (then called Plymouth Dock), and as living conditions were appalling in the extreme, a prisoner of war depot was planned in the remote isolation of Dartmoor.

The prison was designed by Daniel Asher Alexander. Construction by local labour started in 1806, taking three years to complete. In 1809, the first French prisoners arrived and the prison was full by the end of the year.^[3]

From the spring of 1813 until March 1815, about 6,500 American sailors from the War of 1812 were imprisoned at Dartmoor in poor conditions (food was bad and the roofs leaked).^[4] These were either naval prisoners or impressed American seamen discharged from British vessels. Whilst the British were in overall charge of the prison, the prisoners created their own governance and culture. They had courts which meted out punishments, a market, a theatre and a gambling room. About 1,000 of the prisoners were Black.^[5] A recent examination of the General Entry Book of American Prisoners of War at Dartmoor, by Nicholas Guyatt, found "Eight Hundred and Twenty - Nine Sailors of Colour had been entered into the register by the end of October 1814."^[6]

Escapes

Unlike many detention facilities of the period, Dartmoor Prison was purpose built in an isolated location, ringed by high stone walls, and manned by hundreds of armed militia sentries. In addition a rope ran around the entire circumference of the prison, linked to a series of bells, which quickly spread an alarm. Even if a determined prisoner made it beyond the walls, he would still have to traverse ten miles on foot, over wild moorland and bogs, an area frequently beset with fog and chilling winds, to reach the nearest town.^[7] Local residents turning in an escapee could expect a reward of a guinea.^[8] Yet, despite these daunting odds, scholar Nicholas Guyatt has tallied a total of twenty-four American POWs successfully making their way to freedom.^[9]

DisorderAlthough the war ended with the Treaty of Ghent on 24 December 1814, American prisoners of war remained in Dartmoor because the British government refused to let them go on parole or take any steps until the treaty was ratified by the United States Senate on 17 February 1815. It took several weeks for the American agent to secure ships for their transportation home, and the men grew very impatient. On 4 April, a food contractor attempted to work off some damaged hardtack on them in place of soft bread and was forced to yield by their insurrection. The commandant, Captain T. G. Shortland, suspected them of a design to break out of the gaol. This was the reverse of the truth in general, as they would lose their chance of going on the ships, but a few had made threats of the sort, and the commandant was very uneasy.

At about 6:00 pm on 6 April, Shortland discovered a hole from one of the five prisons to the barrack yard near the gun racks. Some prisoners were outside the fence, noisily pelting each other with turf, and many more were near the breach (and the gambling tables), though the signal for return to prisons had sounded. Shortland was convinced of a plot and rang the alarm bell to collect the officers and have the guards ready. This precaution brought back a crowd just going to quarters. Just then a prisoner broke a gate chain with an iron bar and a number of the prisoners pressed through to the prison market square. After attempts at persuasion, Shortland ordered a charge which drove some of the prisoners in. Those near the gate, however, hooted at and taunted the soldiery, who fired a volley over their heads. The crowd yelled louder and threw stones, and the soldiers, probably without orders fired a direct volley which killed and wounded a large number. Then they continued firing at the prisoners, many of whom were now struggling to get back inside the blocks.

Finally the captain, a lieutenant and the hospital surgeon (the other officers being at dinner) succeeded in stopping the shooting and started caring for the wounded – about 60, 30 seriously, besides seven killed outright. The affair was examined by a joint commission, Charles King for the United States and F. S. Larpent for Great Britain, which exonerated Shortland, justified the initial shooting and blamed the subsequent deaths on unknown culprits. Following these findings, Shortland was rewarded with a promotion. Despite being labelled "The Dartmoor Massacre", the British government paid compensation to the American families of those killed and pensioned the disabled.

A memorial has been erected to the 271 POWs (mostly seamen) who are buried in the prison grounds.^[10] By July 1815 at least 270 Americans and 1,200 French prisoners had died.^[11]

Closure and reopening

After all American and French prisoners had been released, paroled and repatriated, the gaol on Dartmoor was left unused for 35 years until 1850. Work then began to rebuild and recommission the prison for civilian convicts. It reopened in 1851. The POW remains that had been originally buried on the moor were exhumed and re-interred in two cemeteries behind the prison when the prison farm was established in about 1852.During the First World War in 1917, criminals were removed from the gaol when it was converted into a Home Office Work Centre for conscientious objectors granted release from other prisons. The cells were left unlocked, inmates wore their own clothes and could go outside to visit the village in their off-duty time.^[3]

Notoriety

In 1920, the prison began housing UK criminals. It would develop a reputation for housing some of Britain's most serious offenders that included murderers, gangsters, thieves, spies, and robbers such as Jack “the Hat” McVitie, Jack “Spot” Comer, John George Haigh, and Frank Mitchell.^[12] Numerous escape attempts have been made by inmates to get out of the prison and onto the moors, leading to massive manhunts by the police and prison service.^[13] Instances of disobedience included a model prisoner attacking a popular guard with a razor blade and rough treatment by prisoners of a prisoner being removed to solitary.

MutinyThe prison's tough conditions eventually led to its worst outbreak of violence on 24 January 1932. The cause of the riots is generally attributed to prisoners' perceptions of poor quality of the food, not generally but on specific days prior to the disturbance when it was suspected it had been tampered with.^[14] At the parade later that day, 50 prisoners refused orders, and the rest were marched back to their cells but refused to enter. At this point, the prison governor and his staff fled to an unused part of the prison and secured themselves there. The prisoners then released those held in solitary. There was extensive damage to property, and a prisoner was shot by one of the staff, but no prison staff were injured.^[14] According to the du Parcq report into the riot: "Reinforcements arrived, and within fifteen minutes these 'vicious brutes', who for some two hours had terrorized well-armed prison staff, and effectively controlled the prison, had surrendered and been locked up again".^[14]

Notable prisoners

• Michael Davitt
• Peter Hammond, founder of Hammond, Louisiana, US
• Fred Longden
• John Rodker
• Moondyne Joe
• Thomas William Jones, Baron Maelor
• John Boyle O'Reilly
• Arthur Owens
• Éamon de Valera^[15]
• F. Digby Hardy
• John Williams
• Frank Mitchell^[15]
• Reginald Horace Blyth
• Darkie Hutton
• John George Haigh
• Bruno Tolentino, who eventually was deported to Brazil where the major part of his oeuvre was published. "A Balada do Cárcere" (1996) is a poetic recollection of the time spent in Dartmoor.^[16]
• Fahad Mihyi, Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine terrorist behind the 1978 London bus attack^[17]
• Aravindan Balakrishnan^[18]

Modern operations

Dartmoor continues to suffer from its age, in 2001 a Board of Visitors report condemned sanitation, as well as highlighting a list of urgent repairs needed.^[19] A year later, the prison was converted to a Category C prison for less violent offenders. In 2002, the Prison Reform Trust warned that the prison may be breaching the Human Rights Act 1998 due to severe overcrowding at the jail.^[20] A year later, however, the Chief Inspector of Prisons declared that the prison had made substantial improvements to its management and regime.^[21]

In March 2008, staff at the prison passed a vote of no confidence in the governor Serena Watts, claiming they felt bullied by managers and unsafe.^[22]

Dartmoor is now a Category C prison, which means it houses mainly non-violent offenders and white-collar criminals. It also holds people with convictions for sexual offences, but it is designated as a support site only for these individuals and as such does not offer treatment programmes for them.^[23]

Dartmoor operates cell accommodation on six wings. Education is available at the prison (full and part-time), and ranges from basic educational skills to Open University courses. Vocational training includes electronics, brickwork and carpentry courses up to City & Guilds and NVQ level, Painting and Decorating courses, industrial cleaning and desktop publishing. Full-time employment is also available in catering, farming, gardening, laundry, textiles, Braille, contract services, furniture manufacturing and polishing. Employment is supported with NVQ or City & Guilds vocational qualifications.^[24] All courses and qualifications at Dartmoor are operated by South Gloucestershire and Stroud College and Cornwall College.

The "Dartmoor Jailbreak" is a yearly event, in which members of the public "escape" from the prison and must travel as far as possible in four days, without directly paying for transport. By doing so they raise money for charity.^[25]

In September 2013, it was announced that discussions would commence with the Duchy of Cornwall about the long-term future of HMP Dartmoor.^[26] In January 2014 it was stated on the BBC news website that the notice period with the Duchy for closing is 10 years.^[27] In November 2015 the Ministry of Justice confirmed that, as part of a major programme to replace older prisons, it would not renew its lease on the prison.^[28]

It was announced in October 2019 that HMP Dartmoor would close in 2023,^[29] but in December 2021 it was confirmed that, following negotiations with the Duchy, it would remain open beyond 2023 and for the foreseeable future.^[30]

In 2023, 96 inmates of the prison had to be evacuated due to the presence of radon gas, caused by the decay of uranium in the prison bedrock and walls. No adverse health effects related to radon poisoning have been recorded at the prison.^[31]

In 2024, 100s of prisoners were transferred to other prisons due to the presence of unsafe levels of radon gas throughout the prison and in cells. in total 689 prisoners were required to be moved. By the summer of 2024, any remaining prisoners were ordered to be transferred out and the prison closed. However, it is unclear when or even if the prison will ever be operational again.

Dartmoor Prison Museum

The Dartmoor Prison Museum, located in the old dairy buildings, focuses on the history of HMP Dartmoor. Exhibits include the prison's role in housing prisoners of war from the Napoleonic Wars and the War of 1812, manacles and weapons, memorabilia, clothing and uniforms, famous prisoners, and the changed focus of the prison. It also sells (2015) garden ornaments and other items made in the prison concrete and carpentry shops by prisoners engaged in educational courses.

There are also displays and information on less well known aspects of the prison such as the incarceration of conscientious objectors during World War One.

In popular culture

• In the 1963 James Bond film From Russia with Love, the main villainous henchman, SPECTRE assassin Red Grant (played by Robert Shaw) is described as a psychopathic paranoid and a convicted murderer, who once escaped from Dartmoor Prison.
• The adventure story A Rogue by Compulsion. An Affair of the Secret Service (1915) by Victor Bridges begins with a dramatic escape from Dartmoor.^[32]
• In Mutiny on the Bounty (1935), Mr. Christian states to Captain Bligh that Seaman Burkitt chose service in the Royal Navy as an alternative to imprisonment at Dartmoor.
• In the John Galsworthy play, Escape, Dartmoor is the prison whence the hero, Captain Denman escapes. The stage production in 1927 starred Leslie Howard and the 1930 film version starred Sir Gerald du Maurier.
• The 1929 movie A Cottage on Dartmoor begins with an escapee from Dartmoor prison, and proceeds to a flashback as to how he came to be incarcerated.
• An escaped convict from Dartmoor figures in Nevil Shute's first novel Marazan, published in 1926.
• Decline and Fall, a novel by Evelyn Waugh, first published in 1928 makes thinly disguised references to Dartmoor Prison.
• Dartmoor Prison is mentioned in The Thirteen Problems, a short story collection written by Agatha Christie, and first published in 1932. Christie's The Sittaford Mystery (1931) is set on Dartmoor and features an escaped prisoner.
• Arthur Conan Doyle made reference to 'Princetown Prison' in four stories that he wrote between 1890 and 1903. In The Hound of the Baskervilles (1902), an escaped prisoner from Princetown serves as a red herring for Holmes and Watson.
• Dressed to Kill, a 1946 Sherlock Holmes film uses Dartmoor Prison in the plot as the supposed location where three music boxes were made that contain a secret code for a criminal gang.^[33]
• Mentioned in the Dermot Hegarty song Twenty One Years (1970).
• Referenced in Bob Miller's song, Twenty-One Years, more recently recorded by Daniel O'Donnell on his debut album.
• In the Tales of Old Dartmoor episode (recorded in 1956) of The Goons radio comedy series, Grytpype-Thynne arranges for the prison to put to sea to visit the Château d'If in France as part of a plan to find the treasure of the Count of Monte Cristo hid there. A cardboard replica is left in its place, which is left standing after the original Dartmoor Prison sinks with all hands at the end of the episode.
• In an episode of The Saint television series entitled "Escape Route" (1966), Simon Templar (Roger Moore) is sent to Dartmoor to uncover a planned escape.
• Comedy band The Barron Knights' 1978 UK No. 3 hit single "A Taste of Aggro", a medley of parodies, included a version of "The Smurf Song" featuring, in place of the Smurfs, a group of bank robbers from Catford who have escaped from Dartmoor Prison.^[34]
• Dartmoor is mentioned several times in the British comedy series You Rang, M'Lord?, especially in connection with the scheming butler, Alf Stokes, who mentions on multiple occasions that he will end up in Dartmoor.
• In 1988, the prison played host to a storyline in EastEnders, where Den Watts (played by Leslie Grantham) was being held on remand for arson. He was also joined for some of the storyline by Nick Cotton (played by John Altman), who was imprisoned for a different offence. The prison was called Dickens Hill.
• Dartmoor is frequently mentioned in the Agent Z series of comical children's books written by Mark Haddon.
• Dartmoor prison is implicated in the local Dartmoor 'Hairy hands' ghost story/legend.
• Dartmoor prison plays a central role in The Lively Lady, American author Kenneth Roberts' 1931 historical novel taking place during The War of 1812
• In the first episode of the second series of James May's Man Lab, James May and Oz Clarke were demonstrating map-reading skills by pretending to escape from Dartmoor prison and cross Dartmoor to their escape car^[35] (although they had to start their escape from outside the prison grounds as they were not allowed permission inside the prison).
• One of the intersecting story lines in Edward Marston's novel, Shadow of the Hangman (2013) involves two American seamen who escape during the 1815 riot.
• The prison and the American sailors imprisoned towards the end of the War of 1812 are central to Simon Mayo's 2018 novel Mad Blood Stirring.
• In The Voice of Terror (1942), Sherlock Holmes is angrily confronted in a tavern by an ex-convict who says he had been sent to Dartmoor Prison by Holmes.
• In John Buchan's third Richard Hannay novel Mr Standfast (1919), two passing references are made of Dartmoor as a place for conscientious objectors who are "quodded" (jailed) there.
• The narrator of the Hammond Innes novel Maddon's Rock is sentenced to (and escapes from) Dartmoor along with a co-conspirator after being wrongly convicted of mutiny.

External links

• Ministry of Justice pages on Dartmoor
• Dartmoor Prison Museum
• HMP Dartmoor - HM Inspectorate of Prisons Reports

Notes and References

1. Web site: Dartmoor Prison . 2 August 2022 .
2. Web site: Hm Dartmoor Prison, Dartmoor Forest . British Listed Buildings . 19 March 2016.
3. Web site: History of Dartmoor Prison.
4. Web site: Prisoners live in 'dilapidated' Dartmoor Prison where buckets used to catch rain. 3 November 2020.
5. 1812: War with America, Jon Latimer, Harvard University Press, 2007 p. 239
6. Guyatt, Nicholas The Hated Cage An American Tragedy in Britain's Most Terrifying Prison (Basic Books, New York, 2022), p.219
7. Guyatt, p.204
8. James, Trevor, Prisoners of War At Dartmoor, American and French Soldiers and Sailors in an English Prison During the Napoleonic Wars and the War of 1812, (McParland & Company, London, 2013), p.114
9. Guyatt, p.208
10. Web site: Monument Details . 2022-06-26 . www.uswarmemorials.org.
11. Book: Adkins . Roy . Adkins . Lesley . The War for All Oceans . London . Abacus . 2007 . 460 . 978-0-349-11916-8.
12. News: The most notorious prisoners of Dartmoor jail revealed. Plymouth Herald. 15 December 2017.
13. News: The most notorious escapes from Dartmoor Prison - from 'Rubber Bones' to the 'Mad Axeman'. Plymouth Herald. 14 February 2021. The prison population, the bleak location, and its reputation for its harsh regime made Dartmoor one of the UK's most feared prisons.News: Fascinating images of Dartmoor Prison riot sparked by porridge. Plymouth Herald. 17 February 2017.
14. Book: Fitzgerald, M. 1977. Prisoners in Revolt. Harmondsworth: Penguin . 123–126.
15. Web site: Dartmoor Prison Museum.
16. Web site: Bruno Tolentino . Vide Editorial . 11 December 2017 .
17. News: 'Terrorist' Helped Israeli Heal . Jewish Journal . 2003-05-09 . 2018-11-12 . Naomi Pfefferman.
18. Web site: Cult leader who imprisoned and raped women for 30 years dies in jail at 81. Daily Mirror . 8 April 2022 .
19. News: Dartmoor prison sanitation 'unacceptable' . BBC News . 14 November 2001.
20. News: Dartmoor breaches Human Rights . BBC News . 19 September 2002.
21. News: Prison praised for progress . BBC News . 15 July 2003.
22. News: Dartmoor prison staff 'bullied' . BBC News . 19 March 2008.
23. Web site: Action Plan: HMP Dartmoor. https://web.archive.org/web/20200528024338/https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/847257/hmp-dartmoor-action-plan-march-2018.pdf . 2020-05-28 . live. HM Prison & Probation Service. 7 August 2021.
24. Web site: Dartmoor Prison. 2 August 2022 .
25. Web site: Dartmoor Prison Break. www.dartmoorprisonbreak.com/. 3 March 2020.
26. News: Dartmoor Prison set to close in latest jail shake-up. Ford. Richard.
27. News: Drug use and cell sharing 'still issues at Dartmoor Prison'. BBC News. 6 January 2014.
28. Web site: Spending review: Nine new prisons to replace 'Victorian' jails. BBC News. 9 November 2015. 14 November 2015.
29. Web site: Government confirms Dartmoor Prison will close in 2023. Daily Mirror. 25 October 2019.
30. News: 2021-12-22. Dartmoor Prison to stay open 'beyond 2023'. en-GB. BBC News. 2021-12-28.
31. News: Latchem . Tom . Evans . Dan . Tidy . Rebecca . Prince William is Radiation Prison Landlord – Parts of UK's Oldest Jail Evacuated . 6 January 2024 . . 5 January 2024.
32. Book: Bridges, Victor . A Rogue by Compulsion. An Affair of the Secret Service . Project Gutenberg. 1915 . 27 December 2012 .
33. Book: Weaver, Tom. Universal horrors: the studio's classic films, 1931–1946. 2007. McFarland.
34. http://www.lyricsondemand.com/b/barronknightslyrics/atasteofaggrolyrics.html Barron Knights Lyrics: A Taste Of Aggro Lyrics
35. Web site: BBC Two – James May's Man Lab, Series 2, Episode 1. BBC. 26 October 2011.