Fragging Explained

Fragging is the deliberate or attempted killing of a soldier, usually a superior, by a fellow soldier. U.S. military personnel coined the word during the Vietnam War, when such killings were most often committed or attempted with a fragmentation grenade,[1] to make it appear that the killing was accidental or during combat with the enemy. The term fragging now encompasses any deliberate killing of military colleagues.[2] [3]

The high number of fragging incidents in the latter years of the Vietnam War was symptomatic of the unpopularity of the war with the American public and the breakdown of discipline in the U.S. Armed Forces. Documented and suspected fragging incidents using explosives totaled 904 from 1969 to 1972, while hundreds of fragging incidents using firearms took place, but were hard to quantify as they were indistinguishable from combat deaths and poorly documented.

Fragging should not be confused with the unintentional killing and/or wounding of comrades and/or allied personnel; such incidents are referred to as friendly fire.

Motivation

Soldiers have killed colleagues since the beginning of armed conflict, with many documented instances throughout history. However, the practice of fragging seems to have been relatively uncommon in the U.S. military until the Vietnam War. The prevalence of fragging was partially based on the ready availability of explosive weapons such as fragmentation hand grenades. Grenades were untraceable to an owner and left no ballistic evidence. M18 Claymore mines and other explosives were also occasionally used in fragging, as were firearms, although the term, as defined by the military during the Vietnam War, applied only to the use of explosives to kill fellow soldiers.[4] [5] Most fragging incidents were in the Army and Marine Corps. Fragging was rare among Navy and Air Force personnel, who had less access to grenades and weapons than did soldiers and Marines.

The first known incidents of fragging in South Vietnam took place in 1966, but events in 1968 appear to have catalyzed an increase in fragging. After the Tet Offensive in January and February 1968, the Vietnam War became increasingly unpopular in the United States and among American soldiers in Vietnam, many of them conscripts. Secondly, racial tensions between white and black soldiers and marines increased after the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. in April 1968. With troops reluctant to risk their lives in what was perceived as a lost war, fragging was seen by some enlisted men "as the most effective way to discourage their superiors from showing enthusiasm for combat".

Morale plummeted among soldiers and marines. In 1971, a USMC colonel declared in the Armed Forces Journal that "The morale, discipline, and battle worthiness of the U.S. Armed Forces are, with a few salient exceptions, lower and worse than at any time in this century and possibly in the history of the United States."[6] [7]

The U.S. military reflected social problems and issues in the U.S. such as racism, drug abuse, and resentment toward authoritarian leaders. As the U.S. began to withdraw its military forces from Vietnam, some American enlisted men and young officers lost their sense of purpose for being in Vietnam, and the hierarchical relationship between enlisted men and their officers deteriorated. The resentment directed from enlisted men toward older officers was exacerbated by generational gaps, as well as different perceptions of how the military should conduct itself. Enforcement of military regulations, especially if done overzealously, led to complaints and sometimes threats of physical violence directed toward officers.

A number of factors may have influenced the incidence of fragging. The demand for manpower for the war in Vietnam caused the armed forces to lower their standards for inducting both officers and enlisted men. The rapid rotation of personnel, especially of officers who served (on average) less than six months in command roles, decreased the stability and cohesion of military units. Most important of all, perhaps, was the loss of purpose in fighting the war, as it became apparent to all that the United States was withdrawing from the war without having achieved any sort of victory. Morale and discipline deteriorated.

Most fragging was perpetrated by enlisted men against officers. Enlisted men, in the words of one company commander, "feared they would get stuck with a lieutenant or platoon sergeant who would want to carry out all kinds of crazy John Wayne tactics, who would use their lives in an effort to win the war single-handedly, win the big medal, and get his picture in the hometown paper". Harassment of subordinates by a superior was another frequent motive. The stereotypical fragging incident was of "an aggressive career officer being assaulted by disillusioned subordinates". Several fragging incidents resulted from alleged racism between black and white soldiers. Attempts by officers to control drug use caused others. Most known fragging incidents were carried out by soldiers in support units rather than soldiers in combat units.

Soldiers sometimes used non-lethal smoke and tear-gas grenades to warn superiors that they were in more serious danger if they did not change their behavior. A few instances occurred—and many more were rumored—in which enlisted men pooled their money for "bounties" on particular officers or non-commissioned officers to reward soldiers for fragging them.

U.S. Forces in Vietnam

Known U.S. fragging incidents using explosives in Vietnam[8]
1969197019711972
Army9620922228
Marine Corps30+50+30+5
Suspected306211131
Total156+321+363+64
Deaths4638123
Note: Statistics were not kept before 1969.

According to author George Lepre, the total number of known and suspected fragging cases using explosives in Vietnam from 1969 to 1972 totalled nearly 900, with 99 deaths and many injuries. This total is incomplete, as some cases were not reported, nor were statistics kept before 1969 (although several incidents from 1966 to 1968 are known). Most of the victims or intended victims were officers or non-commissioned officers. The number of fraggings increased in 1970 and 1971 even though the U.S. military was withdrawing and the number of U.S. military personnel in Vietnam was declining.

An earlier calculation by authors Richard A. Gabriel and Paul L. Savage, estimated that up to 1,017 fragging incidents may have taken place in Vietnam, causing 86 deaths and 714 injuries of U.S. military personnel, the majority officers and NCOs.[9]

By the end of the war at least 450 officers were killed in fraggings, while the U.S. military reported at least 600 U.S. soldiers killed in fragging incidents with another 1,400 dying under mysterious circumstances.[10] [11]

Fragging statistics include only incidents involving explosives, most commonly grenades. Several hundred murders of U.S. soldiers by firearms occurred in Vietnam but most were of enlisted men killing other enlisted men of nearly equal rank. Fewer than ten officers are known to have been murdered by firearms. However, rumors and claims abound of the deliberate killing of officers and non-commissioned officers by enlisted men under battlefield conditions. The frequency and number of these fraggings, indistinguishable from combat deaths, cannot be quantified.

Response

The U.S. military's responses to fragging incidents included greater restrictions on access to weapons, especially grenades, for soldiers in non-combat units and post-fragging "lockdowns" in which a whole unit was isolated until after an investigation. For example, in May 1971, the U.S. Army in Vietnam temporarily halted the issuance of grenades to nearly all units and soldiers in Vietnam, inventoried stocks of weapons, and searched soldiers' quarters, confiscating weapons, ammunition, grenades, and knives. This, however, failed to reduce fragging incidents as soldiers could easily obtain weapons in a flourishing black market among nearby Vietnamese communities. The U.S. military also attempted to diminish adverse publicity concerning fragging and the security measures it was taking to reduce it.

Only a few fraggers were identified and prosecuted. It was often difficult to distinguish between fragging and enemy action. A grenade thrown into a foxhole or tent could be a fragging, or the action of an enemy infiltrator or saboteur. Enlisted men were often close-mouthed in fragging investigations, refusing to inform on their colleagues out of fear or solidarity. Sentences for fragging convictions were severe—but the few men convicted often served fairly brief prison sentences. Ten fraggers were convicted of murder and served sentences from ten months to forty years with a mean (average) prison time of about nine years.

Influence

In the Vietnam War, the threat of fragging caused many officers and NCOs to go armed in rear areas and to change their sleeping arrangements as fragging often consisted of throwing a grenade into a tent where the target was sleeping. For fear of being fragged, some leaders turned a blind eye to drug use and other indiscipline among the men in their charge. Fragging, the threat of fragging, and investigations of fragging sometimes disrupted or delayed tactical combat operations. Officers were sometimes forced to negotiate with their enlisted men to obtain their consent before undertaking dangerous patrols.

The breakdown of discipline, including fragging, was an important influence on the U.S. change to an all-volunteer military in place of conscription. The last conscript was inducted into the army in 1973.[12] [13] The volunteer military moderated some of the coercive methods of discipline previously used to maintain order in military ranks.

Coalition forces in Afghanistan

During the war in Afghanistan (2001–2021) hundreds of coalition soldiers were intentionally killed by Islamic Republic of Afghanistan forces. Increases in insider attacks against coalition forces were noted after high-profile provocations such as the 2012 Afghanistan Quran burning protests and the Kandahar massacre.[14] [15]

In 2012, according to NATO, 51 coalition service members died due to the deliberate actions by members of the Afghan forces. Another 65 NATO soldiers were killed in insider attacks between 2007 and 2011.[16] The increase in so called "green-on-blue attacks" prompted U.S. officials to revamp the screening process of potential Afghan recruits as Afghan military leadership identified "hundreds" of Afghan soldiers within their ranks who were linked to the Taliban insurgency or harbored anti-American views.[17] [18] [19]

Most of the attackers in these incidents were members of the special Afghan Local Police (ALP) units, who operated as a local tribal force and were known to have ties to the Taliban.[20] [21] They were are also known to use drugs and were sometimes reported for abusing civilians.[22]

The Long War Journal reported on such attacks, counting 155 since 2008 to June 11, 2017, resulting in 152 Coalition dead and 193 wounded.[23] ANA fighters sometimes fled to the Taliban, which posted videos 'welcoming' the fleeing fighters. NATO commanders initially stated that an estimated 90% of the attacks were due to cultural differences and personal enmity, while the Afghan government disagreed and blamed the problem on "infiltration by foreign spy agencies", including those of "neighboring countries".

To reduce insider attacks, joint operations between U.S. and Afghan forces were reduced and coalition soldiers were reminded to be respectful.[14]

Notable incidents

Vietnam War (U.S. forces)

Vietnam War (Australian forces)

Middle East peacekeeping

The Troubles

War in Afghanistan

Iraq War (U.S. forces)

Royal Navy

Russo-Ukrainian War

See also

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Frag. June 21, 2021. www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com.
  2. Book: William Darryl Henderson . Chambers . John Whiteclay . The Oxford companion to American military history . 1999 . Oxford University Press . 978-0-19-507198-6 . 279 . en.
  3. Web site: William Darryl Henderson . Fragging Encyclopedia.com . www.encyclopedia.com.
  4. Book: Lepre, George. Fragging: Why U.S. Soldiers Assaulted their Officers in Vietnam. 2011. Texas Tech University Press. Lubbock.
  5. Web site: Brush. Peter. The Hard Truth About Fragging. Historynet. May 25, 2014. 2010.
  6. Heinl, Jr., Col. Robert D. (1971), "The Collapse of the Armed Forces", Armed Forces Journal, June 7, 1971
  7. Web site: Robert Debs Heinl, Jr.. United States Naval Institute. August 11, 2022.
  8. Book: Levy. Guenter. America in Vietnam. 1978. Oxford University Press. New York.
  9. Gabriel, Richard A. and Savage, Paul L. (1978), Crisis in Command, New York: Hill & Wang, p. 183
  10. News: War-zone massacre an uncommon event . Gregg . Zoroya . Alan . Gomez . USA Today . May 11, 2009 . August 31, 2021.
  11. News: 'Fragging' attack on 101st Airborne echoes back to Vietnam . Wehrman . Jessica . June 12, 2011 . SouthCoastToday.
  12. News: Military draft system stopped . The Bulletin . Bend, Ore . UPI . January 27, 1973 . 1.
  13. News: Military draft ended by Laird . The Times-News . Hendersonville, NC . Associated Press . January 27, 1973 . 1 .
  14. Book: Coll, Steve . Directorate S: The C.I.A. and America's Secret Wars in Afghanistan and Pakistan . . 2019 . 978-0-14-313250-9 . 586–624 . Steve Coll.
  15. News: Three foreign soldiers killed by Afghan forces . Kimball . Jack . March 26, 2012 . Reuters.
  16. Long . Austin . 2013 . 'Green on Blue': Insider Attacks in Afghanistan . Survival . 55 . 3 . 167–182 . Routledge . 10.1080/00396338.2013.802860. 154338272 .
  17. https://www.ibtimes.com/what-green-blue-attack-killing-us-major-general-harold-greene-just-third-insider-attack-1649920 What Is A 'Green-On-Blue' Attack? Killing Of US Major General Harold Greene Is Just Third Insider Attack In 2014
  18. https://thedefensepost.com/2019/01/02/afghanistan-guards-open-fire-nato-advisors-herat/ Afghan forces open fire on NATO advisors at base in Herat
  19. News: Inside-the-wire attacks double in Afghanistan . Andrew Tilghman . Army Times . August 14, 2012 . August 16, 2012 .
  20. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/18/world/asia/two-americans-killed-by-afghan-recruit-in-green-on-blue-assault.html Two Americans Killed by Afghan Recruit
  21. Web site: NATO restricts Afghan operations after 'green-on-blue' killings, anti-Islam film. Barbara Starr. Holly Yan. September 18, 2012. CNN. December 8, 2015.
  22. Web site: Brutality by Afghan Local Police Is Reported. September 13, 2011. The New York Times. December 8, 2015.
  23. Web site: Green-on-blue attacks in Afghanistan: the data. The Long War Journal. August 23, 2012 . December 8, 2015.
  24. Book: Regan, G.. More Military Blunders. Carlton Books. 2004. 1-84442-710-2.
  25. News: Karl XII:s död ger inte forskarna någon ro. Lindqvist. Herman. November 29, 2009. Aftonbladet.
  26. William Forbes Leith (1909), Memoirs of Scottish Catholics during the XVIIth and XVIIIth Centuries. Volume II From Commonwealth to Emancipation, Longman, Green, and Co. 39 Paternoster Row, London. pp. 336-337.
  27. Higginbotham, Don (1961). Daniel Morgan: Revolutionary Rifleman. University of North Carolina Press, p. 75.
  28. Book: Woodworth. Stephen. Jefferson Davis and His Generals. registration. 1990. University Press of Kansas. 0-7006-0567-3. 92.
  29. Paine, S.C.M. (2003). The Sino-Japanese War of 1894–1895: Perception, Power, and Primacy, Cambridge University Press. pp. 179–189.
  30. Regan, G. (2002) Backfire: A History of Friendly Fire from Ancient Warfare to the Present Day, Robson Books, p. 233
  31. MacLean, French L. The Fifth Field: The Story of the 96 American Soldiers Sentenced to Death and Executed in Europe and North Africa in World War II:, Atglen, PA: Schiffer Publishing, 2013. Pages 186-188. .
  32. News: 福島徳. 40年前にも山口の駐屯地で自衛官が銃乱射. 産経ニュース. ja. 株式会社産業経済新聞社. June 14, 2023. June 14, 2023.
  33. News: tysテレビ山口. 自衛官による銃乱射・40年前に山口でも・・・64式小銃乱射 4人を死傷させ山中に逃走. TBS NEWS DIG. ja. TBS・JNN NEWS DIG合同会社. June 14, 2023. June 14, 2023.
  34. New York Times: David France, "An Inconvenient Woman," May 28, 2000, accessed March 12, 2012
  35. News: Nidal Hasan sentenced to death for Fort Hood shooting rampage . Kenber . Billy . August 28, 2013 . The Washington Post.
  36. News: Suspicious Massacre and Airplane Crash Fuel Mistrust in Kazakhstan. Der Spiegel. Jan 17, 2013. Mar 2, 2024. Neef. Christian.
  37. News: 12 Victims Killed, 8 Wounded in Shooting at D.C. Navy Yard, Suspected Gunman Killed . NBC Washington . September 17, 2013 . September 23, 2013.
  38. News: Saad . Reem . Akour . Omar . July 17, 2017 . Jordanian soldier sentenced to life for killing 3 US troops . ABC News . AP News . July 17, 2017 . https://web.archive.org/web/20170717235136/https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/jordanian-soldier-convicted-killing-american-troops-48675771 . July 17, 2017.
  39. Web site: Russian soldier kills 8 colleagues in mass shooting at Siberian military base. October 25, 2019 . CNN. February 21, 2024.
  40. News: Associated Press . October 15, 2022 . Volunteer soldiers opened fire on other troops during training in Russia . NPR . October 15, 2022.
  41. Web site: October 15, 2022 . Russia military range shooting leaves 11 dead, 15 wounded . October 15, 2022 . AP NEWS . en.
  42. Web site: 【速報中】陸自射撃場発砲事件 2人死亡 18歳自衛官候補生逮捕 NHK . NHKニュース . June 14, 2023 . June 14, 2023 . NHK.
  43. News: Colonel Robert Heinl: The Collapse of the Armed Forces (1971) . Alpha History.
  44. Web site: Hamilton Gregory. May 25, 2018. Murder in Vietnam. June 2, 2021. HistoryNet. en-US.
  45. Web site: The Wall of Faces. January 27, 2021. Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund. en-US.
  46. News: Private guilty of murder, life sentence . The Age . Google News . August 28, 2017.
  47. News: February 27, 1971. Psychiatrist says soldier 'paranoid'. 7. Canberra Times . January 27, 2021.
  48. Web site: PTE Ferriday Murders. https://web.archive.org/web/20030319093911/http://home.iprimus.com.au/buckomp/FerridayMurdersWebdoc.htm. dead. March 19, 2003. home.iprimus.com.au. August 28, 2017.
  49. Web site: Michael McAleavey released after 27 years. . March 18, 2010. August 28, 2017.
  50. Web site: Local news from Fermanagh, p. 26. https://web.archive.org/web/20120322140836/http://www.storyfinders.co.uk/directory/uploads/2f82bb5d-bf30-4ada-a490-b5c7da745f40/1990-2000.pdf. dead. March 22, 2012. April 17, 2020.
  51. News: May 11, 1992. Northern News. The Irish Emigrant. 275. https://web.archive.org/web/20120419081420/http://www.emigrant.ie/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=37018&Itemid=18. dead. July 26, 2020. April 19, 2012.
  52. Web site: May 23, 1992. War News - British Soldier Wounded in Landmine Attack. July 8, 2021. indianamemory.contentdm.oclc.org. The Irish People. en.
  53. Book: Latham, Richard. Deadly Beat: Inside the Royal Ulster Constabulary. Random House. 2012. 978-1-78057-755-5. en.
  54. Fortnight, Issues 302-312, p. 33
  55. News: May 1, 1993. Soldier, 19, is cleared of murder. October 13, 2020. The Independent. en.
  56. News: September 17, 2003. Army accused over soldier deaths. BBC News. March 8, 2014.
  57. Web site: January 22, 2012 . Afghan soldier 'killed French troops over US abuse video' . April 19, 2012 . Agence France-Presse (AFP) . DAWN.COM.
  58. News: Afghan soldier 'killed French troops over US abuse video'. June 24, 2012. The Telegraph. January 22, 2012. London.
  59. News: France Weighs Pullout After 4 of Its Soldiers Are Killed. Steven. Erlanger. Alissa J.. Rubin. January 20, 2012. February 26, 2012. New York Times.
  60. News: Soldier who killed U.S. general spent three years in Afghan army . Shalizi . Hamid . August 17, 2014 . Reuters.
  61. Ali M. Latifi (August 6, 2014). "Afghan soldier who killed U.S. general is identified". Los Angeles Times.
  62. http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,154220,00.html "Akbar Convicted of Murder"
  63. https://abcnews.go.com/WN/militarys-death-row/story?id=9075282 "Military's death row: Hasan Akbar case"
  64. News: von Zielbauer. Paul. February 21, 2009. After Guilty Plea Offer, G.I. Cleared of Iraq Deaths. The New York Times. February 23, 2009.
  65. News: Tracey Barnett: Women GIs in fear of the enemy in their army. Barnett, Tracey. June 25, 2008. The New Zealand Herald. October 14, 2011.
  66. http://www.salon.com/mwt/broadsheet/2008/06/27/lavena_johnson/index.html?source=refresh The tragic story of LaVena Johnson"
  67. News: DELACH LEONARD. MARY. July 19, 2015. 10 years later, a soldier's family still grieves and questions the Army's version of her death. St. Louis Public Radio. St. Louis Missouri. May 29, 2018.
  68. News: Sergeant gets life sentence for killing fellow U.S. soldiers . August 10, 2011 . Reuters.
  69. News: Army Sgt. Joseph Bozicevich found guilty of killing fellow soldiers in Iraq . The Associated Press.
  70. News: Johnson . Eric M. . May 16, 2013 . Soldier who killed fellow U.S. troops in Iraq gets life sentence . en . Reuters . May 29, 2022.
  71. News: Iraqi soldier kills 2 U.S. soldiers . September 7, 2010 . CNN.
  72. News: U.S. Soldier Charged with Killing Fellow Troops . October 20, 2010 . CBS.
  73. News: The Case Of US Army Specialist Neftaly Platero . October 5, 2022 . United States Patriot.
  74. News: Iraqi soldier shoots dead US troops . September 15, 2011 . Al Jazeera.
  75. News: HMS Astute nuclear submarine officer shot tackling gunman. BBC News . January 2, 2013. August 28, 2017.
  76. Web site: Sailor jailed for submarine murder. September 19, 2011. The Independent. en. December 8, 2019.
  77. Web site: Soldier opens fire, kills five guards at Ukraine military plant . September 19, 2022 . www.aljazeera.com . en.
  78. https://antikor.com.ua/articles/532047-rossijskij_voennyj_pereehal_na_tanke_svoego_komandira_v_otmestku_za_gibelj_tovarishchej_v_bojah_pod_kievom Российский военный переехал на танке своего командира в отместку за гибель товарищей в боях под Киевом
  79. Web site: Russian troops attack own commanding officer after suffering heavy losses . March 25, 2022 .