Fradkin tensor explained

The Fradkin tensor, or Jauch-Hill-Fradkin tensor, named after Josef-Maria Jauch and Edward Lee Hill[1] and David M. Fradkin,[2] is a conservation law used in the treatment of the isotropic multidimensional harmonic oscillator in classical mechanics. For the treatment of the quantum harmonic oscillator in quantum mechanics, it is replaced by the tensor-valued Fradkin operator.

The Fradkin tensor provides enough conserved quantities to make the oscillator's equations of motion maximally superintegrable.[3] This implies that to determine the trajectory of the system, no differential equations need to be solved, only algebraic ones.

Similarly to the Laplace–Runge–Lenz vector in the Kepler problem, the Fradkin tensor arises from a hidden symmetry of the harmonic oscillator.

Definition

Suppose the Hamiltonian of a harmonic oscillator is given by

H=

\vecp2
2m

+

1
2

m\omega2\vecx2

with

\vecp

,

m

,

\omega

, and

\vecx

,

then the Fradkin tensor (up to an arbitrary normalisation) is defined as

Fij=

pipj
2m

+

1
2

m\omega2xixj.

In particular,

H

is given by the trace:

H=\operatorname{Tr}(F)

. The Fradkin Tensor is a thus a symmetric matrix, and for an

n

-dimensional harmonic oscillator has

\tfrac{n(n+1)}{2}-1

independent entries, for example 5 in 3 dimensions.

Properties

\vecL=\vecx x \vecp

:

FijLj=0

xiFijxj=E\vecx2-

\vecL2
2m
.

SU(3)

, the three-dimensional special unitary group in 3 dimensions, with the relationships

\begin{align}\{Li,Lj\}&=\varepsilonijkLk\\ \{Li,Fjk\}&=\varepsilonijnFnk+\varepsiloniknFjn\\ \{Fij,Fkl\}&=

\omega2
4

\left(\deltaik\varepsilonjln+\deltail\varepsilonjkn+\deltajk\varepsiloniln+\deltajl\varepsilonikn\right)Ln,\end{align}

where

\{,\}

is the Poisson bracket,

\delta

is the Kronecker delta, and

\varepsilon

is the Levi-Civita symbol.

Proof of conservation

In Hamiltonian mechanics, the time evolution of any function

A

defined on phase space is given by
dA
dt

=\{A,H\}=\sumk\left(

\partialA
\partialxk
\partialH
\partialpk

-

\partialA
\partialpk
\partialH
\partialxk

\right)+

\partialA
\partialt
,

so for the Fradkin tensor of the harmonic oscillator,

dFij
dt

=

1
2

\omega2\sumk((xj\deltaik+xi\deltajk)pk-(pj\deltaik+pi\deltajk)xk)=0.

.

The Fradkin tensor is the conserved quantity associated to the transformation

xi\toxi'=xi+

12
\omega

-1\varepsilonjk\left(

x

j\deltaik+

x

k\deltaij\right)

by Noether's theorem.[4]

Quantum mechanics

In quantum mechanics, position and momentum are replaced by the position- and momentum operators and the Poisson brackets by the commutator. As such the Hamiltonian becomes the Hamiltonian operator, angular momentum the angular momentum operator, and the Fradkin tensor the Fradkin operator. All of the above properties continue to hold after making these replacements.

References

  1. Jauch . Josef-Maria . Hill . Edward Lee . On the Problem of Degeneracy in Quantum Mechanics . Physical Review . 1 April 1940 . 57 . 7 . 641–645 . 10.1103/PhysRev.57.641.
  2. Fradkin . David M. . Existence of the Dynamic Symmetries

    O4

    and

    SU3

    for All Classical Central Potential Problems . Progress of Theoretical Physics . 1 May 1967 . 37 . 5 . 798–812 . 10.1143/PTP.37.798.
  3. Miller . W. . Post . S. . Winternitz . P. . Classical and quantum superintegrability with applications . J. Phys. A: Math. Theor . 2013 . 46 . 423001 . 10.1088/1751-8113/46/42/423001. 1309.2694 .
  4. Lévy-Leblond . Jean-Marc . Conservation Laws for Gauge-Variant Lagrangians in Classical Mechanics . American Journal of Physics . 1 May 1971 . 39 . 5 . 502–506 . 10.1119/1.1986202.