CSIRO explained

Agency Name:Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)
Motto:We imagine. We collaborate. We innovate.
Headquarters:Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia
Formed:1916
Preceding1:Advisory Council of Science and Industry (1916–1920)
Preceding2:Institute of Science and Industry (1920–1926)
Preceding3:CSIR (1926–1949)
Jurisdiction:Australia
Employees:5,565 (2017)[1]
Minister1 Pfo:Minister for Industry, Science and Technology
Chief1 Name:Kathryn Fagg[2]
Chief1 Position:Chair
Chief2 Name:Doug Hilton
Chief2 Position:CE

The Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) is an Australian Government agency responsible for scientific research.

CSIRO works with leading organisations around the world. From its headquarters in Canberra, CSIRO maintains more than 50 sites across Australia and in France, Chile and the United States, employing about 5,500 people.

Federally funded scientific research in Australia began in 1916; the Advisory Council of Science and Industry was established in that year, but was hampered by insufficient available finance. In 1926, the research effort was reinvigorated by establishment of the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), which strengthened national science leadership and increased research funding. CSIR grew rapidly and achieved significant early successes. In 1949, further legislated changes included renaming the organisation as CSIRO.[3]

Notable developments by CSIRO have included the invention of atomic absorption spectroscopy, essential components of the early Wi-Fi technology, development of the first commercially successful polymer banknote, the invention of the insect repellent in Aerogard and the introduction of a series of biological controls into Australia, such as the introduction of myxomatosis and rabbit calicivirus for the control of rabbit populations.

Structure

CSIRO is governed by a board appointed by the Australian Government, currently chaired by Kathryn Fagg. There are eight directors inclusive of the chief executive, presently Doug Hilton, who are responsible for management of the organisation.[4] [5]

Research and focus areas

CSIRO is structured into Research Business Units, National Facilities and Collections, and Services.[6]

Research Business Units

As at 2023, CSIRO's research areas are identified as "Impact science" and organised into the following Business Units:

National facilities and collections

National facilities

CSIRO manages national research facilities and scientific infrastructure on behalf of the nation to assist with the delivery of research. The national facilities and specialised laboratories are available to both international and Australian users from industry and research. As at 2019, the following National Facilities are listed:

Collections

CSIRO manages a number of collections of animal and plant specimens that contribute to national and international biological knowledge. The National Collections contribute to taxonomic, genetic, agricultural and ecological research. As at 2019, CSIRO's Collections are listed as the following:

Services

In 2019, CSIRO Services are itemised as follows:

Other services are noted as including education, publishing, infrastructure technologies, Small and Medium Enterprise engagement and CSIRO Futures.

History

Evolution of the organisation

A precursor to CSIRO, the Advisory Council of Science and Industry, was established in 1916 on the initiative of prime minister Billy Hughes. However, the advisory council struggled with insufficient funding during the First World War. In 1920 the council was renamed the Commonwealth Institute of Science and Industry, and was led by George Handley Knibbs (1921–26), but continued to struggle financially.[10]

Implementing the 1923 Imperial Conference's call for colonies to broaden their economic base, in 1926 the Australian Parliament modified the principal Act for national scientific research (the Institute of Science and Industry Act 1920)[11] by passing The Science and Industry Research Act 1926.[12] The same conference led to the creation of the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research in New Zealand.

The new Act replaced the institute with the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). With encouragement from prime minister Stanley Bruce, strengthened national science leadership and increased research funding, CSIR grew rapidly and achieved significant early successes. The council was structured to represent the federal structure of government in Australia, and had state-level committees and a central council. In addition to an improved structure, CSIR benefited from strong bureaucratic management under George Julius, David Rivett, and Arnold Richardson. Research focused on primary and secondary industries. Early in its existence, CSIR established divisions studying animal health and animal nutrition. After the Great Depression, research was extended into manufacturing and other secondary industries.[13]

In 1949 the Act was changed again,[14] and the entity name amended to the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation. The amendment enlarged and reconstituted the organisation and its administrative structure. Under Ian Clunies Ross as chairman, CSIRO pursued new areas such as radio astronomy and industrial chemistry. CSIRO still operates under the provisions of the 1949 Act in a wide range of scientific inquiry.[13]

Participation by women in CSIRO research was severely limited by the Australian government policy, in place until 1966, forcing women public servants out of their jobs when they married.[15] Even unmarried women were considered a poor investment because they might eventually marry. Single women such as Helen Newton Turner nevertheless made major contributions.

Since 1949, CSIRO has expanded its activities to almost every field of primary, secondary and tertiary industry, including the environment, human nutrition, conservation, urban and rural planning, and water.[13] It works with leading organisations around the world and maintains more than 50 sites across Australia and in France, Chile and the United States of America, employing about 5500 people.[16] [17]

Inventions

Notable inventions and breakthroughs by CSIRO include:[18]

Historic research

CSIRO had a pioneering role in the scientific discovery of the universe through radio "eyes". A team led by Paul Wild built and operated (from 1948) the world's first solar radiospectrograph, and from 1967 the 3adj=midNaNadj=mid radioheliograph at Culgoora in New South Wales. For three decades, the Division of Radiophysics had a world-leading role in solar research, attracting prominent solar physicists from around the world.[23]

CSIRO owned the first computer in Australia, CSIRAC, built as part of a project began in the Sydney Radiophysics Laboratory in 1947. The CSIR Mk 1 ran its first program in 1949, the fifth electronic computer in the world. It was over 1,000 times faster than the mechanical calculators available at the time. It was decommissioned in 1955 and recommissioned in Melbourne as CSIRAC in 1956 as a general purpose computing machine used by over 700 projects until 1964.[24] The CSIRAC is the only surviving first-generation computer in the world.[25]

Between 1965 and 1985, George Bornemissza of CSIRO's Division of Entomology founded and led the Australian Dung Beetle Project. Bornemissza, upon settling in Australia from Hungary in 1951, noticed that the pastureland was covered in dry cattle dung pads which did not seem to be recycled into the soil and caused areas of rank pasture which were unpalatable to the cattle. He proposed that the reason for this was that native Australian dung beetles, which had co-evolved alongside the marsupials (which produce dung very different in its composition from cattle), were not adapted to utilise cattle dung for their nutrition and breeding since cattle had only relatively recently been introduced to the continent in the 1880s. The Australian Dung Beetle Project sought, therefore, to introduce species of dung beetle from South Africa and Europe (which had co-evolved alongside bovids) in order to improve the fertility and quality of cattle pastures. Twenty-three species were successfully introduced throughout the duration of the project and also had the effect of reducing the pestilent bush fly population by 90%.[26]

Domain name

CSIRO was the first Australian organisation to start using the Internet[27] and was able to register the second-level domain csiro.au (as opposed to csiro.org.au or csiro.com.au). Guidelines were introduced in 1996 to regulate the use of the .au domain.

Governance and management

When CSIR was formed in 1926, it was led initially by an executive committee of three people, two of whom were designated as the chairman and the chief executive. Since then the roles and responsibilities of the chair and chief executive have changed many times. From 1927 to 1986 the head of CSIR (and from 1949, CSIRO)[13] was the chairman, who was responsible for the management of the organisation, supported by the chief executive. From 1 July 1959 to 4 December 1986 CSIRO had no chief executive; the chairman undertook both functions.[28]

In 1986, when the Australian Government changed the structure of CSIRO to include a board of non-executive members plus the chief executive to lead CSIRO, the roles changed. The chief executive is now responsible for management of the organisation in accordance with the strategy, plans and policies approved by the CSIRO Board which, led by the chair of the board, is responsible to the Australian Government for the overall strategy, governance and performance of CSIRO.[28]

As with its governance structure, the priorities and structure of CSIRO, and the teams and facilities that implement its research, have changed as Australia's scientific challenges have evolved.[29]

Numerous CSIRO scientists have gone onto distinguished careers in the university sector. Several have been appointed to the role of Vice-Chancellor/President. They include: Sir George Currie (UNZ 1952–62, Western Australia 1945–52), Paul Wellings CBE (Wollongong 2012–21, Lancaster 2002–12), Michael Barber AO (Flinders 2008–14), Mark Smith CBE (Southampton 2019–ff, Lancaster 2012–19), Annabelle Duncan (UNE 2014–19), Attila Brungs (UNSW 2021–ff, UTS 2014–21), Alex Zelinsky AO (Newcastle (2018–ff), Andrew Parfitt (UTS 2021–ff), Chris Moran (UNE 2023–ff).

Chairs

Name Background Term start Term end Duration Notes
1 Mechanical engineer 1 April 1926 31 December 1945
2 Chemist 1 January 1946 18 May 1949 Acting chair to 31 March 1946
3 Veterinary scientist 19 May 1949 20 June 1959
4 Physicist 1 July 1959 22 May 1970 Executive chair
5 Chemist 26 May 1970 24 March 1977 Executive chair
6 Physicist 25 March 1977 13 December 1978 Executive chair
7 Astronomer 14 December 1978 24 September 1985 Executive chair
8 Chemist 25 September 1985 4 December 1986 Executive chair
9 Politician 5 December 1986 4 December 1991
10 Botanist 5 December 1991 4 December 1996
11 Corporate executive 5 December 1996 5 November 2001
12 Corporate executive 6 November 2001 31 December 2006
13 Corporate executive 1 January 2007 29 May 2007
14 Immunologist 28 June 2007 27 June 2010
15 Corporate executive 28 June 2010 14 October 2015
16 Corporate executive 15 October 2015 14 October 2021
17 Corporate executive 15 October 2021 incumbent

Chief executives

Name Background Term start Term end Duration Notes
1 Chemist 1 January 1927 31 December 1945
2 Agricultural scientist 1 January 1946 18 May 1949
3 Physicist 19 May 1949 13 December 1956
4 Chemist 1 January 1957 30 June 1959
5 Chemist 5 December 1986 4 March 1990 Acting to 4 March 1987
6 Immunologist 5 March 1990 4 March 1995
7 Physicist 5 March 1995 3 January 1996 Acting to 20 July 1995
8 Public servant 3 January 1996 7 February 2000 Died in office
Metallurgical engineer 7 February 2000 14 January 2001 Acting chief executive
9 Metallurgist 15 January 2001 31 December 2008
10 Geologist 1 January 2009 19 November 2014
11 Physicist 1 January 2015 30 June 2023
12 Molecular biologist 1 July 2023 incumbent

Controversies

Total Wellbeing Diet

In 2005 the CSIRO gained worldwide attention, including some criticism, for promoting a high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet of their own creation called Total Wellbeing Diet.[30] The CSIRO published the diet in a book which sold over half a million copies in Australia and over 100,000 overseas.[31] The diet was criticised in an editorial by Nature for giving scientific credence to a "fashionable" diet sponsored by meat and dairy industries.[32] [33]

802.11 patent

In the early 1990s, CSIRO radio astronomy scientists John O'Sullivan, Graham Daniels, Terence Percival, Diethelm Ostry and John Deane undertook research directed to finding a way to make wireless networks work as fast as wired networks within confined spaces such as office buildings. The technique they developed, involving a particular combination of forward error correction, frequency-domain interleaving, and multi-carrier modulation, became the subject of, which was granted on 23 January 1996.

In 1997 Macquarie University professor David Skellern and his colleague Neil Weste established the company Radiata, Inc., which took a nonexclusive licence to the CSIRO patent for the purpose of developing commercially viable integrated circuit devices implementing the patented technology.[34]

During this period, the IEEE 802.11 Working Group was developing the 802.11a wireless LAN standard. CSIRO did not participate directly in the standards process, however David Skellern was an active participant as secretary of the Working Group, and representative of Radiata.[35] In 1998 it became apparent that the CSIRO patent would be pertinent to the standard. In response to a request from Victor Hayes of Lucent Technologies, who was chair of the 802.11 Working Group, CSIRO confirmed its commitment to make non-exclusive licenses available to implementers of the standard on reasonable and non-discriminatory terms.[36]

In 1999, Cisco Systems, Inc. and Broadcom Corporation each invested A$4 million in Radiata, representing an 11% stake for each investor and valuing the company at around A$36 million.[34] In September 2000, Radiata demonstrated a chip set complying with the recently finalised IEEE 802.11a Wi-Fi standard, and capable of handling transmission rates of up to 54 Mbit/s, at a major international exhibition.[34]

In November 2000, Cisco acquired Radiata in exchange for US$295 million in Cisco common stock with the intention of incorporating the Radiata Baseband Processor and Radio chips into its Aironet family of wireless LAN products.[37] Cisco subsequently took a large write-down on the Radiata acquisition, following the 2001 telecoms crash,[38] and in 2004 it shut down its internal development of wireless chipsets based on the Radiata technology in order to focus on software development and emerging new technologies.[39]

Controversy over the CSIRO patent arose in 2006 after the organisation won an injunction against Buffalo Technology in an infringement suit filed in Federal Court in the Eastern District of Texas.[40] The injunction was subsequently suspended on appeal, with the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit finding that the judge in Texas should have allowed a trial to proceed on Buffalo's challenge to the validity of the CSIRO patent.[41] In 2007, CSIRO declined to provide an assurance to the IEEE that it would not sue companies which refused to take a license for use in 802.11n-compliant devices, while at the same time continuing to defend legal challenges to the validity of the patent brought by Intel, Dell, Microsoft, Hewlett-Packard and Netgear.[42]

In April 2009, Hewlett-Packard broke ranks with the rest of the industry becoming the first to reach a settlement of its dispute with CSIRO.[43] This agreement was followed quickly by settlements with Microsoft, Fujitsu and Asus[44] and then Dell, Intel, Nintendo, Toshiba, Netgear, Buffalo, D-Link, Belkin, SMC, Accton, and 3Com.[45] [46]

The controversy grew after CSIRO sued US carriers AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile in 2010, with the organisation being accused of being "Australia's biggest patent troll", a wrathful "patent bully", and of imposing a "WiFi tax" on American innovation.[47] [48] [49]

Further fuel was added to the controversy after a settlement with the carriers, worth around $229 million, was announced in March 2012.[50] [51] Encouraged in part by an announcement by the Australian Minister for Tertiary Education, Skills Science and Research, Senator Chris Evans,[52] an article in Ars Technica portrayed CSIRO as a shadowy organisation responsible for US consumers being compelled to make "a multimillion dollar donation" on the basis of a questionable patent claiming "decades old" technology.[53] The resulting debate became so heated that the author was compelled to follow up with a defence of the original article.[54] An alternative view was also published on The Register, challenging a number of the assertions made in the Ars Technica piece.[55]

Total income to CSIRO from the patent is currently estimated at nearly $430 million.[56] On 14 June 2012, the CSIRO inventors received the European Patent Office (EPO) European Inventor Award (EIA), in the category of "Non-European Countries".[57]

Genetically modified wheat trials

On 14 July 2011, Greenpeace activists vandalised a crop of GM wheat, circumventing the scientific trials being undertaken. Greenpeace was forced to pay reparations to CSIRO of $280,000 for the criminal damage, and were accused by the sentencing judge, Justice Hilary Penfold, of cynically using junior members of the organisation with good standing to avoid custodial sentences, while the offenders were given 9-month suspended sentences.[58] [59]

Following the attack Greenpeace criticised CSIRO for a close relationship with industry that had led to an increase in genetically modified crops, even though a core aim of CSIRO is Cooperative Research "working hand in hand with industry [to] build partnerships and engage with industry to generate impact".[60] [61]

Climate change censorship: Clive Spash

On 25 November 2009, a debate was held in the Australian Senate concerning the alleged involvement of the CSIRO and the Labor government in censorship. The debate was called for by opposition parties after evidence came to light that a paper critical of carbon emissions trading was being suppressed.[62] At the time, the Labor government was trying to get such a scheme through the Senate. After the debate, the Science Minister, Kim Carr, was forced to release the paper, but when doing so in the Senate he also delivered a letter from the CEO of the CSIRO, Megan Clark, which attacked the report's author and threatened him with unspecified punishment.[63] The author of the paper, Clive Spash, was cited in the press as having been bullied and harassed,[64] and later gave a radio interview about this.[65] In the midst of the affair, CSIRO management had considered releasing the paper with edits that Nature reported would be "tiny".[66] Spash claimed the changes actually demanded amounted to censorship and resigned. He later posted on his website a document detailing the text that CSIRO management demanded be deleted;[67] by itself, this document forms a coherent set of statements criticising emissions trading without any additional wording needed. In subsequent Senate Estimates hearings during 2010, Senator Carr and Clark went on record claiming the paper was originally stopped from publication solely due to its low quality not meeting CSIRO standards.[68] At the time of its attempted suppression, the paper had been accepted for publication in an academic journal, New Political Economy, which in 2010 had been ranked by the Australian Research Council as an 'A class' publication.[69] In an ABC radio interview, Spash called for a Senate enquiry into the affair and the role played by senior management and the Science Minister.[70] After these events, the Sydney Morning Herald reported that "Questions are being raised about the closeness of BHP Billiton and the CSIRO under its chief executive, Megan Clark".[71] After his resignation, an unedited version of the paper was released by Spash as a discussion paper,[72] and later published as an academic journal article.[73]

CSIRO–Novartis–DataTrace scandal

On 11 April 2013, the Sydney Morning Herald ran a story on how CSIRO had "duped" the Swiss-based pharmaceutical giant Novartis into purchasing an anti-counterfeit technology for its vials of injectable Voltaren. The invention was marketed by a small Australian company called DataTrace DNA as a method of identifying fake vials, on the basis that a unique tracer code developed by CSIRO was embedded in the product. However, the code sold to Novartis for more than A$2M was apparently not unique, and was based on a "cheap tracer ... bought in bulk from a Chinese distributor". Novartis was contractually bound not to reverse-engineer the tracer to verify its uniqueness. The Sydney Morning Herald report alleges that this was done with the knowledge of key CSIRO personnel.[74]

CSIRO has since conducted a full review of the allegations and found no evidence to support them.[75]

Alleged bullying, harassment and victimisation

Around 2008–2012, CSIRO fell under the spotlight for allegedly exhibiting a culture of workplace bullying and harassment.[76] Former CSIRO employees started to surface with experiences of workplace bullying and other unreasonable behaviour by current and former CSIRO staff members.[77] [78] CSIRO took the allegations seriously and responded to the articles on a number of occasions.[79] [80]

The shadow minister for innovation, industry, science and research, Sophie Mirabella, wrote to the government requesting it establish an inquiry. Mirabella said she is aware of as many as 100 cases of alleged workplace harassment. On 20 July 2012 Comcare issued CSIRO with an Improvement Notice with regard to handling and management of workplace misconduct/code of conduct type investigations and allegations.[81] On 24 June 2013 Mirabella advised the Australian House of Representatives that in relation to the worker's compensation claim for psychological injuries of ex-CSIRO employee, Martin Williams, which was vigorously defended by Comcare on the advice of the CSIRO, that CSIRO officers had provided false testimony on no less than 128 occasions under oath when the matter went before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.[82] Mirabella stated, "even in establishing the framework for this inquiry it is obvious there's an inappropriate 'hands on' approach by CSIRO."

In response to the allegations Clark commissioned Dennis Pearce,[83] who is assisted by an investigation team from HWL Ebsworth Lawyers,[84] to conduct an independent investigation into allegations of workplace bullying and other unreasonable behaviour.[85] Mirabella continued to question the independence of the investigation.[86] The first stage of the investigation published its findings at the end of July 2013, and the final stage was scheduled to be complete by February 2014.[87] Post the Pearce Report, CSIRO overhauled its relevant policies and put in place training and whistleblower procedures to address the situation.

CSIRO and climate change

In August 2015 the CSIRO discontinued its annual July and August survey, conducted over the previous five years, polling to create a long-term view of how Australians viewed global warming and their support for action. In the previous 2013 poll, 86 per cent agreed with the statement that climate change was occurring and only 7.6 per cent disagreed.[88]

On 11 February 2016, Dr Larry Marshall – a former venture capitalist with Southern Cross Venture Holdings, who had been appointed CEO of the CSIRO on 1 January 2015,[89] caused an international outcry after describing Australia's national climate change discussion as "more like religion than science," a week after announcing hundreds of job cuts to the organisation that will reduce the effectiveness of its climate research team.[90]

In "an open letter to the Australian Government and CSIRO", 2,800 of the leading climate scientists from 60 countries say the announcement of cuts to the CSIRO's Oceans and Atmosphere research program has alarmed the global climate research community. They say the decision shows a lack of insight and a misunderstanding of the importance of the depth and significance of Australian contributions to global and regional climate research.[91]

The CSIRO has been the target of successive funding cuts under the Morrison government, starting with cuts targeting climate science research initiated by Tony Abbott.[92] [93] [94]

Trademark dispute with Cisco

In 2015, Cisco Systems filed a trademark infringement lawsuit against CSIRO, claiming that the colours and style of CSIRO's logo were too similar to Cisco's. An Australian court ruled in CSIRO's favor and ordered Cisco to pay CSIRO's court costs.[95]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Our People. CSIRO. 17 April 2018. 24 October 2017.
  2. Web site: Meet our Board Chair: Kathryn Fagg.
  3. Web site: SCIENCE AND INDUSTRY RESEARCH ACT 1949.
  4. Web site: 30 October 2023. CSIRO Board Members.
  5. Web site: 30 October 2023. CSIRO Executive Team.
  6. Web site: CSIRO Operating Model.
  7. Web site: Health and Biosecurity . CSIRO . 23 March 2020.
  8. Web site: Data 61. 23 March 2020.
  9. Web site: Cape Grim Air . 8 November 2022 . 4 November 2022 . https://web.archive.org/web/20221104232102/https://csiropedia.csiro.au/cape-grim-air-archive/ . dead .
  10. Book: Currie, George . The origins of CSIRO : science and the Commonwealth government 1901-1926 . 1966 . Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organization . 925648548.
  11. Science and Industry Research Act 1926 . 22 . 14 September 1920 . 18 April 2018 .
  12. Science and Industry Research Act 1926 . 20 . 21 June 1926 . 18 April 2018 .
  13. Web site: Our history . . April 2018 . CSIROpedia . CSIRO . 16 April 2018 .
  14. Science and Industry Research Act 1949 . 13 . 21 June 1926 . 18 April 2018 .
  15. Book: Carey, Jane . Taking to the Field . Monash University Publishing . 2023.
  16. Web site: International collaboration . CSIRO . 8 February 2019 .
  17. Web site: International collaboration – CSIRO . Csiro.au . 28 January 2016 . 4 January 2017.
  18. Web site: Daroczy . Jenna . September 11, 2015 . 10 of our best inventions . CSIRO.
  19. Web site: Ward . Colin . 2013-09-05 . Salvinia biocontrol . 2022-08-28 . CSIROpedia . en-AU.
  20. News: Swan. David. Titomic soars on ASX debut, plans facility with large-scale 3D printer. The Australian. 21 September 2017.
  21. Web site: CSIRO's WLAN patent. 29 January 2016.
  22. Web site: CSIRO Annual Report 2014-15 - Taking 3D laser mapping to the world . 55.
  23. Web site: Dr John Paul Wild . CSIRO . 16 May 2008 . 22 May 2012 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20150125053338/http://www.csiro.au/news/ps47j . 25 January 2015 .
  24. Web site: CSIRAC . . Department of Computer Science and Engineering . 8 May 2006 . Steven Pass . David Hornsby . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20150227165717/http://www.csse.unimelb.edu.au/dept/about/csirac/ . 27 February 2015 .
  25. Web site: Museum Victoria's CSIRAC information site. 26 April 2008 .
  26. Bornemissza G. F. . 1976 . The Australian dung beetle project 1965–1975 . Australian Meat Research Committee Review . 30 . 1–30 .
  27. Web site: History . . 16 April 2011 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20110412054848/https://www.aarnet.edu.au/about-us/history.aspx . 12 April 2011 .
  28. Web site: Chief Executives and Chairs . . April 2018 . CSIROpedia . CSIRO . 16 April 2018 .
  29. Web site: Organisational history . . April 2018 . CSIROpedia . CSIRO . 16 April 2018 .
  30. Web site: CSIRO Total Wellbeing Diet online – CSIRO . Csiro.au . 12 May 2016 . 4 January 2017.
  31. News: The town taking the CSIRO challenge . 6 December 2005 . 24 April 2006 . . https://web.archive.org/web/20051213020826/http://aca.ninemsn.com.au/stories/2006.asp . 13 December 2005.
  32. Web site: Peers turn up heat on CSIRO diet . The Age . 28 December 2005 . 21 June 2016.
  33. Web site: Nature Gags on CSIRO Diet . Australasian Science . 1 March 2006 . 21 June 2016.
  34. Web site: Matthews . Mark . Creating and Exploiting Intangible Networks: How Radiata was able to improve its odds of success in the risky process of innovating . Australian Government, Department of Education, Science and Training . 13 May 2012 . Bob Frater . 8–9 & 16 . November 2003.
  35. Web site: Skellern . David . Tentative Minutes of the IEEE P802.11 Full Working Group . Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers . 13 May 2012 . 5–9 July 1999.
  36. Web site: Cooper . Dennis . Letter to Mr V Hayes, Chair, IEEE P802.11 . 13 May 2012 . 4 December 1998.
  37. Web site: Press Release: Cisco Systems to Acquire Radiata, Inc. . Cisco Systems, Inc. . 13 May 2012 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20011124055012/http://newsroom.cisco.com/dlls/fspnisapi08cd.html . 24 November 2001 .
  38. News: Heskett . Ben . Cisco still confident after networking shock . 13 May 2012 . ZDNet . 9 May 2001.
  39. News: Reardon . Marguerite . Cisco retires wireless chipsets . 13 May 2012 . CNET News . 30 January 2004.
  40. News: Moses . Asher . CSIRO wins landmark legal battle . 13 May 2012 . The Age . 15 November 2006.
  41. News: Venkatesan . Arun . Buffalo Allowed to sell wireless products again (for now) . 13 May 2012 . TechCrunch . 3 December 2008.
  42. News: Winterford . Brett . No backdown from CSIRO over Wi-Fi patents . 13 May 2012 . ZDNet . 2 October 2007.
  43. News: Moses . Asher . CSIRO cashes in on patent claim . The Sydney Morning Herald . 13 May 2012 . 1 April 2009.
  44. News: Duckett . Chris . Microsoft, Fujitsu, Asus settle with CSIRO . 13 May 2012 . ZDNet . 15 April 2009.
  45. News: Stevens . Tim . CSIRO's patent lawsuits conclude with the final 13 companies set . 13 May 2012 . Engadget . 22 April 2009.
  46. News: Flynn . David . CSIRO could scoop billions from Wi-Fi patent . 13 May 2012 . APC Magazine . 23 April 2009.
  47. News: Popper . Ben . Australia's Biggest Patent Troll Goes After AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile . 13 May 2012 . CBS News . 3 June 2010.
  48. News: Stevens . Tim . CSIRO's patent fight targets more victims: AT&T, Verizon Wireless, and T-Mobile . 13 May 2012 . Engadget . 21 May 2010.
  49. News: Masnick . Mike . CSIRO Wants To Expand Its WiFi Tax: Sues Mobile Operators . 13 May 2012 . TechDirt . 2 June 2010.
  50. News: Chirgwin . Richard . Champagne at CSIRO after WiFi patent settlement . 13 May 2012 . The Register . 1 April 2012.
  51. News: Brodkin . Jon . WiFi patent case results in $229 million payment to Australian government . 13 May 2012 . Ars Technica . 3 April 2012.
  52. Web site: Media Release: Aussie scientists bring home millions in wifi windfall . Australian Government . 13 May 2012 . 1 April 2012.
  53. News: Mullin . Joe . How the Aussie government "invented WiFi" and sued its way to $430 million . 13 May 2012 . Ars Technica . 5 April 2012.
  54. News: Mullin . Joe . Responses and clarifications on the CSIRO patent lawsuits . 13 May 2012 . Ars Technica . 6 April 2012.
  55. News: Chirgwin . Richard . CSIRO patent-trolls ALL OF AMERICA! . 10 April 2012. 13 May 2012 . The Register .
  56. News: CSIRO wins legal battle over wi-fi patent . 13 May 2012 . ABC News . 1 April 2012.
  57. Web site: EPO's European Inventor Award 2012 goes to outstanding inventors from Germany, France, Denmark and Australia . European Patent Office . 18 June 2012 . 14 June 2012.
  58. Web site: Greenpeace activists in costly GM protest. Sydney Morning Herald. 2 August 2012. 8 November 2013.
  59. Web site: GM crop destroyers given suspended sentences. Canberra Times. 19 November 2012. 8 November 2013. https://web.archive.org/web/20180205181420/http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/gm-crop-destroyers-given-suspended-sentences-20121119-29l66.html. 5 February 2018. dead.
  60. Web site: Working hand in hand with industry . 8 November 2013 . 22 April 2013 . CSIRO website . Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation . 16 December 2013 . https://web.archive.org/web/20131216091336/http://www.csiro.au/en/Portals/Partner/Industry.aspx . dead .
  61. Web site: Greenpeace calls on CSIRO to come clean on commercial relationships . 15 July 2011 . greenpeace.org .
  62. News: CSIRO bid to gag emissions trading scheme policy attack . Berkovic, N. . 2 November 2009 . The Australian . News Limited .
  63. News: CSIRO scientist faces punishment . Crystal, J. . 26 November 2009 . 9 News . Australia .
  64. News: Climate expert Clive Spash 'heavied' by CSIRO management . Berkovic, N. . 3 November 2009 . The Australian .
  65. Web site: The toxic workplace and bullying culture at CSIRO . Walsh, M. . 2012 . 2cc.net.au .
  66. Australian agency moves to calm climate row. Researcher will be allowed to publish his paper after making 'tiny' changes. . Pincock, S. . 13 November 2009 . Nature . 10.1038/news.2009.1083.
  67. Web site: An Orwellian guide to carbon emissions trading . Spash, C. . 2010 . clivespash.org .
  68. Australian Senate 2010. Senate Economics Legislation Committee Estimates. Canberra: Official Hansard (Wednesday, 10 February 2010)
  69. Web site: Archived copy . 11 December 2011 . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20111119133137/http://www.arc.gov.au/xls/ERA2010_journal_title_list.xls . 19 November 2011 .
  70. News: Dumped Professor calls for Senate inquiry . Colvin, M. . 2010 . Australian Broadcasting Corporation .
  71. News: CSIRO in bed with big coal . Manning, P. . 2010 . The Sydney Morning Herald.
  72. Web site: The Brave New World of Carbon Trading . Spash, C. L. . 2009 . Munich Personal Research Papers in Economics Archive (MPRA) . Munich University .
  73. Spash, C. L. . 16 July 2010 . The brave new world of carbon trading . New Political Economy . 15 . 2 . 169–195 . 10.1080/13563460903556049 . 44071002 . Copy also available at The brave new world of carbon trading . New Political Economy . 15 . 2 . 169–195 . 10.1080/13563460903556049 . 2010 . Spash . Clive L. . 44071002 .
  74. News: How the CSIRO cheated a global drugs giant . 12 April 2012 . The Sydney Morning Herald . 11 April 2012.
  75. Web site: CSIRO review of issues raised about CSIRO's interactions with DataTrace . Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation . 11 August 2013 . 7 September 2013.
  76. [Linton Besser]
  77. [Linton Besser]
  78. [Linton Besser]
  79. Web site: Clark . Megan . 14 April 2013 . More than 85 years of growth, change and impact . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20141023033545/https://www.csiro.au/Portals/Media/More-than-85-years-growth-change-impact.aspx . 2014-10-23 . 2024-01-29 . CSIRO.
  80. Web site: Clark . Megan . 2 May 2013 . Chief Executive Megan Clark's update to staff re Fairfax articles . dead . https://web.archive.org/web/20131023235332/http://www.csiro.au/Portals/Media/Chief-Executive-Megan-Clarks-update-to-staff-re-Fairfax-articles.aspx . 2013-10-23 . 2024-01-29 . CSIRO.
  81. Web site: Improvement notice relating to EVE207221 page . www.comcare.gov.au . 27 January 2022 . https://archive.today/20130727093429/http://www.comcare.gov.au/about_us/access_to_information/disclosure_log/foi_requested_documents/improvement_notice_relating_to_eve207221 . 27 July 2013 . dead .
  82. "I am also reminded of the government's stubborn unwillingness to bring the CSIRO to account for a series of inaccurate and misleading statements that have been made to the Senate estimates committees, including the recent incomprehensible answer to question AL156 which says that no CSIRO employee provided false evidence under oath during cross-examination in the AAT case involving Martin Williams, when an analysis of the transcript of that case suggests that there are at least 100, and more precisely around 128, separate instances of CSIRO officers providing false evidence in the case."Sophie Mirabella MP (shadow minister for innovation, industry, science research and tertiary education). Australian House of Representatives – House Debate Monday 24 June 2013 at 6:33pm. "Intellectual Property Laws Amendment Bill 2013; Second Reading"
  83. Web site: Emeritus Prof. Dennis Pearce AO FAAL . Hwlebsworth.com.au . 4 January 2017 . https://web.archive.org/web/20130510115720/http://www.hwlebsworth.com.au/expertise/intellectual-property-and-trade-marks/features/our-team/item/479-emeritus-professor-dennis-pearce-ao.html . 10 May 2013 . dead .
  84. Web site: HWL Ebsworth appointed to CSIRO bullying enquiry. Asian Legal Business. Thomson Reuters. 27 July 2013.
  85. http://www.hwlebsworth.com.au/csiro-investigation.html Independent Investigator for Allegations of Workplace Bullying and Other Unreasonable Behaviour
  86. [Sophie Mirabella]
  87. "The investigator will provide his Phase 1 reports by 31 July 2013. It is likely that people will be told the outcome of the investigator's consideration of their submission at about this time. It is intended that Phase 2 will be completed by February 2014."Independent Investigator for Allegations of Workplace Bullying and Other Unreasonable Behaviour
  88. Web site: Climate change: CSIRO axes annual attitudes survey, delays 2014 results . Smh.com.au . 11 August 2015 . 4 January 2017.
  89. Web site: Executive Team – CSIRO . Csiro.au . 16 July 2015 . 4 January 2017.
  90. Web site: Climate politics 'more like religion', says CSIRO boss . reneweconomy.com.au . 11 February 2016 . 4 January 2017.
  91. Web site: The world's top scientists beg Malcolm Turnbull to allow CSIRO to continue its climate research . https://web.archive.org/web/20160213093520/http://www.businessinsider.com.au/the-worlds-top-scientists-beg-malcolm-turnbull-to-allow-csiro-to-continue-its-climate-research-2016-2 . dead . 13 February 2016 . Businessinsider.com.au . 4 January 2017.
  92. Web site: CSIRO funding cuts driven by 'pure ignorance', says staff association | Science | The Guardian. amp.theguardian.com. 4 May 2022.
  93. Web site: 'Jaw-dropping' CSIRO job cuts to 'gut' climate science unit. Sophie. Vorrath. 4 February 2016. reneweconomy.com.au. 4 May 2022.
  94. Web site: Climate science to be gutted as CSIRO swings jobs axe. amp.smh.com.au. 4 May 2022.
  95. News: Cisco loses logo lawsuit against WiFi inventor boffinhaus. Sharwood. Simon. 2015-04-10. The Register. 7 July 2022.