Fall of Barcelona explained

Conflict:Fall of Barcelona
Partof:Catalonia Offensive
Place:Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain
Result:Nationalist victory
Commander1:Vicente Rojo
Juan Hernández Saravia
Juan Modesto
José Riquelme
Manuel Tagüeña
Commander2:Francisco Franco
Fidel Dávila Arrondo
Luis Orgaz Yoldi
Gastone Gambara
José Solchaga
Juan Yagüe
Strength1:30,000?[1]
Strength2:120,000?[2]
Casualties1:unclear
Casualties2:unclear

The fall of Barcelona was the capture of Barcelona, until then in the Republican zone, by the Nationalists; it took place on January 26, 1939, during final phases of the Spanish Civil War. The event was part of the Catalan Offensive, which wiped out the Catalan enclave of the Republic. The offensive unfolded since late December 1938; the Republicans were offering some resistance, but they were not in position to mount any larger counter-offensive and there was no major battle fought either in western Catalonia or on approaches to Barcelona.

Initially Republican leaders intended to defend Barcelona, and the ultimate line of resistance was planned along the Llobregat. However, on January 20 and as contingency option the prime minister Juan Negrín ordered preparations to would-be evacuation. On January 23, when the supreme Republican military commander general Rojo informed the government that effective defence of the Llobregat was unlikely, the evacuation began. The central and the autonomous Catalan governments left Barcelona on January 23–24 and power vacuum started to emerge. Eventually Barcelona was declared an open city and apart from isolated skirmishes, there was no combat on the streets.

The fall of Barcelona preceded the fall of entire Catalonia, which took place in early February 1939. For the Republicans it marked the loss of vital industrial production and some 200,000 of troops; also, it enhanced the spirit of defeatism, already ruling among most segments of the population. However, the fall of Barcelona and the fall of Catalonia did not mark the end of the Republic. The government moved to the central-southern zone, initially to Madrid, and the war continued until April 1, 1939.

Catalonia offensive

Following 30 months of the civil war, in late 1938 the Republican-held part of Spain (one third of national territory) was inhabited by almost 9m population, compared to almost 15m in the Nationalist-held zone. The Republican part was divided into 2 separated zones. The larger one, some 130,000 km2 and almost 6,5m people, comprised southern part of the Mediterranean coast, part of New Castile, La Mancha and eastern Andalusia, with 10 provincial capitals. The smaller one, Catalonia except its western belt, already controlled by the Nationalists, was some 25,000 km2. Nominally it hosted some 2,5m people, yet including refugees the figure was probably higher; the area comprised 3 provincial capitals, Barcelona, Tarragona and Girona. Since October 1937 Barcelona hosted key Republican state structures, including the government, the president and the rump parliament; besides, it was home to the autonomous Catalan government and the exiled autonomous Basque government. Also, the supreme Republican military command was based in Barcelona.

In early November 1938 the Battle of the Ebro terminated with Nationalist troops regaining all territory lost since July. Though at that point there was some unclarity in their high command as to direction of future offensive,[3] later that month it was already agreed that the next target should be Catalonia, with the objective of overrunning the entire enclave.[4] Before December the first sketchy plan of the campaign was already in place,[5] worked down to details during the following weeks. The Nationalists were organized in 2 armies, North (commander Fidel Dávila, 19 divisions) and Levante (Luis Orgaz, 9 divisions), 28 divisions in total;[6] the overall command was with Francisco Franco. Official intendancy data listed 332,000 troops, including reserve units.[7] Initial plans envisioned start of the offensive around December 15, yet it was postponed a few times. It is not clear when the Nationalist general staff envisioned seizure of Barcelona or the end of the campaign.[8]

Republican troops in Catalonia were organized in Grupo de Ejércitos de la Region Oriental (GERO) under command of Juan Hernández Saravia; however, its operations were under direct supervision of overall commander of Republican army, general Vicente Rojo, who also resided in Barcelona. GERO was composed of 2 armies, East (Juan Perea Capulino, 9 divisions) and Ebro (Juan Modesto, 11 divisions), 20 divisions in total. Nationalist intelligence estimated that GERO numbered some 150,000 soldiers in 65 mixed brigades (comparable to regiment) or 260 battalions;[9] present-day historian offers similar estimates, with the overall strength of 220,000 troops and 140,000 in frontline combat units.[10] The Nationalists enjoyed great advantage in terms of armour and aviation, but it was massive especially in case of firepower: in terms of artillery pieces and mortars they outnumbered the Republicans 5:1.[11] Also, Republican divisions were mostly under strength. Geography favoured the defenders; numerous hilly ranges and mid-size rivers, high waters at this time of the year, formed natural obstacles.The Nationalist offensive in Catalonia commenced on December 23, 1938; the point closest to Barcelona, held by the Nationalists, was some 120 km away. Operations commenced in extreme western Republican salient projecting into Nationalist lines in-between the Segre and the Ebro. Most fightings took place along some 50-km long frontline in the county of Garrigues. Until the year-end the Nationalists overran the salient; it was only at this point that in first days of 1939 another offensive was launched north-east of Lleida, in the county of Noguera.[12] By January 5 the Republican front collapsed, and the Nationalists broke into operational space. Re-organised Republican troops were not in position to mount a counter-offensive and were capable merely of slowing down the enemy advance; it progressed in course of numerous minor engagements, but with no major battle fought. Though after 2 weeks of combat the Nationalists were still no closer than 110 km to Barcelona, their offensive was now progressing along some 150-km long frontline from Tremp at the Pyrenean foothills in the north to Tortosa on the Mediterranean coast in the south.

Barcelona, January 5 to 15

In the very first days of 1939 daily life in Barcelona did not differ much from the earlier wartime period. The Catalan industry, since the summer of 1936 on revolutionary footing, was in decline, yet contemporary scholar concludes that "industria de guerra catalana siguió funcionando relativamente bien hasta el mismísimo final del conflicto".[13] In late 1938 its output was some 40% of this from the pre-war period;[14] most factories kept operating, in some cases with production ongoing until mid-January.[15] Like everywhere in Republican zone, food was subject to rationing;[16] some authors claim that Barcelona dwellers until then lived rather comfortably,[17] but some claim that the city was suffering from hunger.[18] The annual inflation rate was some 260%,[19] but given there was little to buy and food was to large extent purchased on the black market anyway, monetary problems did not matter much. Municipal services kept operating and newspapers were being issued. Cinemas remained open, with screenings of pre-war foreign (e.g. Beloved Enemy with David Niven) or Spanish (e.g. Rinconcito madrileño with Luis Prendes) movies.[20]

The press were fairly accurately reporting frontline developments, yet contrary to facts they claimed that their own troops were doing well, remained in excellent spirits and kept inflicting heavy losses upon the enemy. Popular Front parties started publishing repeated calls for males to volunteer for either combat troops or fortification units,[21] though with at best moderate response on the part of the population.[22] To enhance the spirit of resistance, some newspapers published horror stories of hundreds of thousands people already murdered in political purges in the Nationalist zone.[23] Defeatism was treated as offence; on January 8 a well-known writer Eduardo Zamacois was sentenced to 6 years in prison for the spirit of derrotismo in his novels.[24] To introduce a more serene tone, on January 6 the president declared amnesty for all prisoners above 60 years of age.[25]

Nationalist troops were reporting taking hundreds of prisoners every day[26] and strength of the Republicans was dwindling dramatically.[27] On January 5 the Republican Ministry of Defence issued a decree which broadened conscription to males born in 1901 ("quinta de 1922") and these who complete 18 years of age in the first quarter of 1939, even though they had not undergone any military training at all; they would form part of a theoretical "quinta de 1942".[28] It is not clear how many new conscripts were pressed into line, yet it is known that many of these called defaulted or went into hiding, usually in premises of their relatives.[29] For these who did show up there were not many rifles available, as even frontline units reported shortages of arms and munitions. The Nationalist intelligence estimated that Republican human reserves in Catalonia were 45.000 men aged 37–41 and 34.000 men aged 41–44.[30] Around January 10 the situation at the front became so dire that the Republican command started to fear total breakdown and collapse of organised military resistance. On January 12 the government broadened the conscription even further, to "reemplazos de 1915 a 1921", effectively calling to arms men in their mid-40s.[31] All war-related industry was declared militarised, rearguard units were to be subject to review to send all fit men to frontline units, Batallones de Obras y Fortificaciones were dissolved and their members incorporated into infantry. Retired governmental employees were called to service in public sectors with shortages of labour force.[32] Trade unions called women to fill in vacancies created by males departing for the front.[33] Young activists, e.g. from JSU, roamed the streets and called to arms, e.g. interrupting music in cafeterias[34] or showings in cinemas.[35]

In early January it was clear to Republican officials that the Nationalist advance was not a local offensive to gain some territory, but an attempt to overrun the entire Catalonian enclave. All active political forces represented in Barcelona seemed united behind the governmental policy of resistance and there were no official voices of dissent heard, e.g. about commencing talks on truce or surrender. On January 8 the Barcelona CNT-UGT liaison committee recommended mobilising all industry workers except these who were absolutely necessary to ensure military production.[36] The Communists focused on recruitment to army units, the Anarchists talked rather about their own militia.[37] PSUC declared all their members mobilised under the military discipline.[38] Some propaganda squabbles between the Communist and the Anarchist press continued.[39] On the other hand, on January 13 the executive committees of the Socialist UGT and the Anarchist CNT had their first ever joint sitting; both declared total support for governmental efforts.[40]

Last days of Republican Barcelona

Sunday, January 15

The Nationalists seized one of 3 Catalan provincial capitals still controlled by the Republicans, Tarragona, located some 80 km away from Barcelona. At that moment the closest point to Barcelona they controlled was Santa Coloma de Queralt, already some 65 km away from the capital.[41] The news was made public the same day and made enormous impact among the population. Until the day some tended to trust the official propaganda and though probably very few if any believed in Republican victory, they might have calculated that it was months before the Nationalists might reach Ciudad Condal, or even that the Republican resistance might lead to some kind of truce. The fall of Tarragona marked a dramatic change and most residents realized that Barcelona was now under direct threat. In some political groups, e.g. within the Catalanist ERC, the idea that the fall of Catalonia was not only inevitable but also imminent, started to take roots.[42]

For the first time parties and unions began to talk not about defending Catalonia, but rather about the need to fortify the city, anticipating the expected siege of the Catalan capital. Both civilian (Negrín) and military (Rojo) leaders started to consider mounting an ultimate defence line along the Llobregat river, in its lower section flowing directly at the outskirts of Barcelona.[43] However, in parallel and still rather as contingency, in utmost secrecy Negrín commenced works on schemes of evacuation.[44] Newspapers doubled their propaganda efforts. The Nationalists were usually referred to as foreign invaders on Spanish soil, with focus on Moroccan, Italian and German units. The local Republican advance in Extremadura, commenced on January 5 some 800 km away, was put on equal footing with the Nationalist one in Catalonia and at times even occupied more space in the papers.[45] Following a few months of no arms supplies from the USSR, on January 15 the first Soviet ship with additional deliveries, requested by Negrín's envoy to Moscow Hidalgo de Cisneros in early December, arrived in Bordeaux; some weapons would reach Catalonia before its fall, but it is not clear whether they would reach Barcelona.

Monday, January 16

The government declared all males between 17 and 55 subject to military discipline; a separate decree declared all males above 55 who were entitled to any financial benefits, including pension, subject to mandatory public service if called.[46] Political parties, trade unions and other organisations supported the measures and kept manifesting their will to fight;[47] specific organisations declared creating their own combat battalions, including batallón de ametralladoras,[48] yet this remained clear fiction as machine-guns were few and missing even in frontline machine-gun platoons. Though nationwide Anarchist congress, held in Valencia, voiced their disagreement with decrees of mobilisation, claiming that they paralysed labor union and political life, in Catalonia neither CNT nor FAI upheld this claim.[49]

At mobilisation points and in the barracks a rather moderate inflow of males called to arms continued. New recruits, about to be pressed into military, were missing uniforms, equipment and arms; they were hardly undergoing any training and some preparations boiled down to propaganda addresses by political commissars. Though seemingly scarcely enthusiastic, when interrogated by superiors the recruits declared they were prepared and determined to fight "hasta el final",[50] yet later Rojo wrote that "for the spirit of resistance there had been substituted the idea of salvation. Everyone was afraid of being cut off".[51] Revolutionary tribunals, set up in 1936–1937, continued operating at least until this day, as the last sentence against supposed anti-Republican subversives documented in archives is dated January 16.[52]

Tuesday, January 17

The Ministry of Interior issued a decree which envisioned sealing of private-held radio receivers. The measure was officially explained as a response to a flood of rumours, including the most wild ones, which were often repeated after the Nationalist radio broadcasts; it was also intended to prevent a would-be panic. Owners were supposed to present their receivers in specified points of the city within 4 days, yet it is not clear how many inhabitants complied.[53] The prime minister Negrin called the president Manuel Azaña and given the pace of Nationalist advance suggested the president leaves his residence, some 30 km north-west of Barcelona, and moves to a safer place.

As during the previous few days, a number of rallies were organised by various organisations and informal groupings; speakers assured their audiences that Republican resistance was insurmountable and that the enemy stood no chance of taking Barcelona, though they also called for mobilisation and total support for the war effort.[54] Messages of support from abroad, usually from various Communist parties, were read.[55] It is not clear how many inhabitants indeed believed these statements. Many preferred to believe various rumours which started to circulate, especially that France was going to intervene and send its troops, establishing sort of a protectorate. Elaborate details were being added, e.g. that colonial Senegalese units would be deployed in Catalonia. The possibility of a would-be French intervention was considered also in diplomatic circles.[56]

Wednesday, January 18

During the cabinet meeting some members expressed hope that in the forthcoming session of the French parliament the prime minister Leon Blum would declare the non-intervention policy abandoned; this in turn would lead to a major change in policy of the great powers towards the Spanish civil war, possibly including sort of a military engagement.[57] During the same sitting, with president of the autonomous government of Catalonia invited, Lluís Companys criticised the central government for alleged marginalisation of the Catalan autonomous government. No one opposed the policy of resistance, but neither were any meaningful decisions taken.[58]

A number of well-known personalities, including Martínez Barrio, Ramón Lamoneda, Nicolau d'Olwer, Antonio Machado, Manuel Irujo, and Margarita Nelken signed an open letter to the international audience; it falsely claimed that in Santa Coloma de Queralt the Nationalists machine-gunned hundreds of people. The signatories called the international community not to allow the same, but on much larger scale, to happen in Barcelona; it was one more attempt to reach out to international observers in hope to trigger some sort of intervention.[59]

During the evening general Rojo spoke over the radio; unlike in the case of top politicians, it was an exceptional measure, as the supreme army commander had never done it before. The content did not differ much from other broadcasts and was a general call for resistance, yet to most listeners it delivered the sense of urgency and immediate threat.[60]

Thursday, January 19

On the central section of the frontline the avant-garde Nationalist units entered the villages of Pontons and La Llacuna, while along the Mediterranean coastline they approached Vilanova i la Geltrú; all these locations were some 50 km away from Barcelona. Though in the north large parts of the Lleida province and the entire Girona province remained controlled by the Republicans, in the south the Nationalists were now descending into the Foix valley, with Serra d'Ordal as the last major natural obstacle separating them from the Llobregat.

Though January 19 was a usual working week Thursday, there were some 100 rallies held across the city, organised by parties, trade unions and other organisations. Groups of young people, especially females from JSU, toured institutions and working places calling males to join armed units and ridiculing or stigmatizing these who did not intend to.[61] Newspapers published numerous manifestos, declarations and calls to arms; accounts from frontlines featured stories about heroism and sacrifice, highlighting episodes and personalities iconic for Republican advantages.[62] During evening hours it became clear that the French parliament was not likely to take decisions related to the Spanish war soon, and hopes as to a foreign intervention subsided.

Friday, January 20

Nationalist troops, so far most advanced on coastal and central sectors of the front, progressed also north-west of Barcelona, reaching the slopes of Serra de Castelltalat and the outskirts of Calaf, which was taken the same day; they were starting to near approaches to Igualada and Manresa. President Azaña in his residence noted having heard very distant artillery fire.

During the day news from Paris was urgently awaited, as talks in the French parliament continued; eventually they were suspended until Tuesday, January 24. The Barcelona press clung to any signs of hope, e.g. referring calls to convene the House of Commons in London or to discuss war atrocities in the League of Nations headquarters in Geneva.[63]

The Catalan president played a secondary role during the first days of 1939. The Generalitat kept issuing decrees which usually repeated official governmental measures, e.g. these related to conscription or militarisation of industry. On January 20 Companys spoke over the radio; he declared Catalonia "an impenetrable fortress" and called the Catalans not to allow the enemy to desecrate the tomb of Francesc Macià.[64] The following day his address was either quoted or extensively referred in the morning papers.

Saturday, January 21

The Nationalists seized Vilafranca del Penedes and Vilanova i la Geltrú in the south and Saint Joan de Mediona and Sant Pere Sacarrera in the centre; all these places were some 40–45 km from Barcelona.[65] President Azaña left his residence near Terrasa and moved some 30 km east, north-east of Barcelona. Some departments of the central government commenced preparations for evacuation; works began on orders of Negrín. Negrín also called Companys and made a veiled suggestion that Generalitat prepare for evacuation, which Companys started to implement.[66] To avoid panic, these activities were kept secret,[67] but since all drivers in service of autonomous government were told to gather at specified points in the city on Monday, January 23,[68] news started to spread. First official vehicles began to appear on roads leading from Barcelona northbound.[69] Frederic Escofet, head of the auxiliary public order force Esquadres de Catalunya, on explicit orders from Companys told his men to leave the city the following day.[70]

Head of the Economy Department in autonomous government, Joan Comorera from PSUC, was outraged by preparations for evacuation. He issued an order which suspended all industrial and commercial activities in Barcelona for the week starting Monday, January 23; the declared purpose was to enable all employees to take part in fortification works.[71] Legality of his decrees was highly dubious, yet no-one decided to challenge him. Some scholars claim that Comorera was becoming the de facto mayor of Barcelona, if not president of the entire Generalitat;[72] as there were first signs of power vacuum gradually emerging in the city, it was reportedly being filled by energetic, resolute and determined individuals like Comorera.[73]

Sunday, January 22

It was Sunday with offices, shops and working places closed, yet in some places the spirit of resistance seemed to rule. The CNT-UGT liaison committee decided to support Comorera.[74] Also heads of some departments of the Catalan government ordered their employees to abandon daily work and present in the nearest military command centre.[75] A plan to plant explosives along metro lines and all major installations of the city emerged among some Anarchists; they were to inflict massive losses at advancing Nationalist troops if they make it to the city, even at the cost of disastrous damage to urban infrastructure. The suggestions were immediately quashed by Negrín.[76] The spirit of resistance was enhanced when some 1.900 International Brigades volunteers arrived in the port of Barcelona, transported by ships from Valencia.[77]

However, many thought the city was not defendable. Quoting "les poques possibilitats de vencer les tropes franquistes" Escofet ordered also Mossos d'Esquadra, the regional police of some 1.000 people, to leave the city and move north.[78] Members of Esquadres and Mossos started to disappear from city streets. Another sign of crumbling Republican administration was suspension of postal services (officially only reduced), due to males having been in military service.[79] Evacuation works in offices of both central and autonomous governments were ongoing, for the time being reduced to selection, packing and loading documentation; however, some cars were already heading out of the city towards the north. Among those who left there was Largo Caballero, Antonio Machado and Luis Araquistaín.[80] As usual on Sunday, cafes and cinemas remained opened.[81] During the day Nationalist soldiers were seen in Monistrol d'Anoia and Sant Sadurní d'Anoia, 30 km from Plaça de Catalunya.

Monday, January 23

The cabinet meeting – as it would turn out, the last one in Barcelona – was concluded a few hours after midnight. Negrín passed on the information, just received from Rojo, that attempts to mount a last line of resistance along the Llobregat failed and most likely counter-action of Republican troops would be reduced to manoeuvrable defence on the right and the left bank of the river. The government decided to release a declaration claiming the cabinet stays in Barcelona. However, just when it was being published over the radio (in Spain newspapers usually did not go out on Mondays), Negrín ordered to begin evacuation of all government offices.[82] The order was implemented immediately, and scramble for available vehicles began.

In line with Comorera's decree, all workplaces were closed, though probably rather few of employees reported to fortification works. Trams ceased to circulate.[83] Convoys of vehicles were loaded with chests containing documentation, while smoke of burning papers started to emerge from some official buildings.[84] Starting early afternoon all institutions, organizations and entities with any vehicles and petrol available – from Institució de les Lletres Catalanes to fábrica aeronáutica Elizalde - were already busy preparing for evacuation, and some inhabitants with improvised means appeared on roads leading north of Barcelona.[85]

CNT, FAI and Juventudes Libertarias staged a plenary session; they decided to move to Figueres,[86] but stuck to the idea of defending the city and entrusted García Oliver – who attended briefly – with this task. He ordered a dedicated staff meeting for later in the day, and when no-one showed up, in the evening he left Barcelona.[87] At the time young Anarchist militants were roaming the city mobilising whoever they found to join the defenders.[88] Some PCE members like Sánchez Arcas or Hidalgo de Cisneros also left, alike members of the Basque government, e.g. José Antonio Aguirre and Manuel Irujo. Executive committees of PSOE and UGT decided to evacuate.[89] Having rejected plans to destroy all goods stored in harbour warehouses, the undersecretary for supplies Antonio Cordón decided to distribute foodstuffs among residents; the order was delayed by bombing raid of 45 German and Italian aircraft. Some attempts were made to organise departure of hospitals with wounded combatants; it is estimated there were some 20.000 of them in the city.[90] However, little or nothing has been done. Director general de la Sanidad, Josep Puche, managed to organise transport of few hundred, but most were left in their beds, taken care of by who remained of the sanitary personnel.[91] Rojo gave new defensive dispositions; commanders of both armies and their divisions moved headquarters to the left bank of the Llobregat.[92] In the afternoon Rojo advised Negrín to leave the city; the prime minister left in the evening.[93] By that time the Nationalists seized Garraf, Vallcarca, Gelida, and Sant Esteve de Sesrovires, some of these locations 25 km from Plaça de Catalunya.[94]

Tuesday, January 24

During the night, around 3 AM, Catalan president Lluís Companys left the site of Generalitat and drove north;[95] he would return to Barcelona 21 months later, as a prisoner to be executed. The minister of interior Paulino Gómez ordered Guardia de Asalto to evacuate towards Girona;[96] at this point the city was left with no forces of order. However, SIM remained on duty; its units were evacuating prisoners, e.g. 600 inmates from Modelo were moved out,[97] among them bishop Polanco and Domingo Rey d'Harcourt; no killings took place. Many inmates were left in their cells until arrival of the Nationalists, some with the intention to hand them out for slaughter.[98] In chaos some, like the POUM leader Julián Gorkin, managed to escape.[99] POUM leaders who remained on liberty met; most opted to flee, though some decided to remain and fight.[100]

In the early hours of January 24 Rojo issued his last defence orders, particularly anxious to prevent encirclement by Nationalist troops advancing north of Barcelona; this would cut off evacuation routes leading towards Girona. He ordered to destroy all bridges on the Llobregat, confirmed Saravia as commander of GERO, Modesto as commander of troops holding the frontline and José Riquelme as commander of Barcelona.[101] Rojo left the city shortly afterwards. Riquelme held a staff meeting,[102] but the same day later he was dismissed by Negrín, already in Figueres. José Brandaris, new commander of Barcelona called from Menorca, was unfamiliar with Catalan frontline; he voiced his concerns and eventually was re-nominated the commander of Olot. Command in Barcelona fell on colonel Jesús Velasco Echave, so far head of coastal defence; he has never managed to assume new duties.[103]

Throughout the day Barcelona started to look like a ghost city. When Andre Malraux visited the Comissariat de Propaganda, a huge building previously bustling with various activities, the only person present was a porter.[104] CNT headquarters was also empty.[105] Various accounts provide recollections of empty offices with floors covered in papers and telephones ringing incessantly,[106] no-one there to take calls. Offices, shops, factories were either closed or empty; public transport including metro was not operating, shortages in electricity supply caused shutdown in entire quarters. Most high officials have already left, but there were exceptions. Comorera insisted on execution of his decrees and tried to organise contingents of workers to dig trenches west of the city.[107] Zugazagoitia and Cordón were still at their posts.In the very late hours general Saravia, commander of what was left of GERO, gathered members of the press corps in his office. He informed them that Barcelona would be declared open city, with no combat envisioned on its streets; he asked the journalists present the make the news public in their afternoon editions.[108] The reservation was rather pointless, as on January 25 almost no newspapers, except La Vanguardia, would be issued. When he was making his statement, the Nationalists controlled almost the entire right bank of the Llobregat, from Manresa in the north to Martorell, Sant Andreu de la Barca, Pallejà, Sant Vicenç dels Horts, Sant Boi de Llobregat, to El Prat on the Mediterranean coast.[109] They were at the outskirts of the city, in some points merely 8 km from Plaça de Catalunya.

Wednesday, January 25

Since morning hours first Nationalist patrols appeared on Serra de Collserola, hills immediately west of the city; Tagueña urgently had to move the staff of his XV corps from Sant Pere Martir[110] to Sant Adrià de Besòs, north-east of Barcelona. His superior and commander of all frontline troops, Modesto, drove from his HQ in Vallvidrera to see Saravia; he met also fellow PCE heavyweights Uribe, Delicado, Mije, and Carrillo. When Modesto returned to Saravia few hours later, he found the premises empty; the general had already left for Girona.[111] Comorera, Antón and Carrillo kept discussing deployment of particular combat groups, their objectives and possible scenarios, but this had no tangible impact on military developments.[112] A last-minute initiative was this of general Asensio, who suggested that command of the city be transferred from the military to the Anarchists; Negrín – contacted over the phone - refused.[113] Around mid-day the mayor, Hilari Salvadó i Castell, left the city.[114]

First cases of looting took place already on January 23, but two days later it was widespread. Magazines in the Barcelona harbour, warehouses and large storage deposits came first, then looting started to affect high street shops, cafeterias (all closed by the time), empty institutions or any places where robbers expected to find any valuables. The usual booty in the city, which for months was suffering from food shortages and rationing, were foodstuffs: canned meat, chocolate, coffee, flour, oil, vinegar, sugar, beans and others, though people were seen carrying also rolls of textile, paper, domestic or office machinery and other goods. Fights between individuals or groups competing for the same prize were breaking out.[115] They ceased only during bombing raid, as 6 German He-111s and 3 Italian SM-79s again targeted the port facilities. A British destroyer,[116] anchored in Barcelona, took aboard last British citizens and set sail towards Marseille, though the captain intended to return.[117] Press staff left the city among the last ones, and the news agency Fabra closed later during the day. La Vanguardia, the only newspaper which appeared on the street this morning, ran a huge headline El Llobregat puede ser el Manzanares de Barcelona, a reference to rebel troops having been defeated at the gates of Madrid in late 1936. The daily assumed a somewhat nationalist tone when in sub-header it announced that Spanish troops heroically contain attacks of Italo-fascist divisions. Groups of youths from JSU were constructing street barricades in spots indicated by Tagueña. It is not clear when the discharged commander of Barcelona Riquelme left the city. During late evening hours Andre Malraux, Max Aub (who both worked in the local film studio on a documentary movie)[118] and Palmiro Togliatti left the city.[119] When the night fell, except Modesto and Tagueña there were no high military commanders in place.

Thursday, January 26

According to many accounts the night from Wednesday January 25 to Thursday 26 was a bizarre, unique and unforgettable experience.[120] The great city of 1 million residents looked uninhabited; empty littered streets were covered in darkness and almost total silence. In some spots small groups were loading items on makeshift vehicles hoping for late evacuation, in others rare patrols of armed men were walking in unclear direction, while single individuals with bags or cases on their backs, most likely booty from looting – were sneaking around. In few places groups of youths were busy erecting barricades, at times until after dawn and until they were informed that Nationalist soldiers have already been seen behind their backs.[121] Distant fire from small arms was heard from time to time, with echos reverberating across empty, silent streets.[122]

Among last organized Republican activities there was transport of prisoners; some departed from Barcelona during the very early hours of the day.[123] The only municipal service operational was fire brigade; one of its last interventions was in the JSU headquarters during the morning, when following attempt to burn documentation the fire got out of control and engulfed the entire building.[124] At the time Modesto nominated Tagueña – both residing in makeshift headquarters in Sant Adriá de Besos - as the one responsible for holding the frontline from Montjuïc to Serra de Collserola. However, this was of little relevance. Since early morning Carlist patrols[125] from the Navarrese Corps of general Solchaga started to descend from Vallvidrera and Tibidabo hills to the Sarrià district. Somewhat later, but still prior to mid-day, sub-units of Cuerpo de Marruecos of colonel Yagüe moved east of Esplugues. The resistance of Republican soldiers in trenches dug a few days earlier was overcomed, and appeared in the district of Sants.[126] Minor and isolated fightings took place in the hills west of Barcelona, mostly around Tibidabo.Around mid-day Nationalist patrols started to penetrate the Diagonal, while grouplets of Republican defenders – at times insulted by women – fled to the north. Some looting continued.[127] Tagueña was still in Sant Adriá; he lost contact with whatever Republican units remained operational. Comorera was warned about Nationalist soldiers nearby when still in Hotel Ritz.[128] In early afternoon first white flags started to appear on balconies and windows.[129] In few cases minor shootout occurred where isolated groups of defenders – e.g. Mossos d'Esquadra at Plaça Borràs – offered resistance. In late afternoon the Nationalists started to occupy major buildings, e.g. the town hall. Last organized defenders, including Tagueña and Comorera, left towards Besos. In the evening there were more and more people appearing on the streets, cheering the Nationalists. Among what the Nationalist press later dubbed as scenes of indescribable enthusiasm, instances of frenetic hysteria were by no means rare, with males and females on their knees kissing the rojigualda standards, uniform sleeves of Nationalist soldiers or even horses of the cavalry.[130] Republican supporters preferred to stay at home. When the night fell there were no islands of resistance and Barcelona was entirely controlled by the Nationalists.

Aftermath

Administration

The minister of interior, Ramón Serrano Suñer, nominated the new mayor and the city council already on January 23, this is 3 days before Nationalist troops entered the city.[131] The alcaldia went to Miguel Mateu Pla, entrepreneur and member of high Catalan bourgeoisie, not associated with any particular party before the war; he headed the ayuntamiento until 1945. The post of civil governor of the Barcelona province went to Wenceslao González Oliveros, a non-Catalan academic associated earlier with Alfonsism; after almost 2 years, in late 1940, he was replaced by a zealous Falangist and also non-Catalan, Antonio Correa Veglison, who would serve until the mid-1940s. The third most important civilian post in the province, jefatura of FET y de las JONS, was assumed by a Catalan lawyer and old-shirt Falangist, Mariano Calviño de Sabucedo,[132] and the fourth, presidency of provincial diputacion, by a Catalan Alfonsist, Josep Maria Milà Camps, However, during first few months the key authority in Barcelona was Eliseo Álvarez-Arenas Romero, head of Servicios de Ocupación; it was a particular body, did not set up anywhere else, which operated until July 1, 1939.[133] The political amalgam emergent in early Francoist Barcelona was dominated by a coalition of Falangists and generic right-wing politicians, including the conservatives and the monarchists;[134] the Carlists, who attempted to re-institutionalize their fairly strong pre-war network, were quickly marginalised by administrative means.[135] Autonomy of Catalonia has been abolished already in April 1938,[136] and the region was incorporated into the uniform national administrative structure; Catalan was driven out of public space.

Demography

The first Nationalist statistics revealed that there were 1.085.951 people registered as living in the city in 1939;[137] this did not differ much from pre-war figure of 1.062.157, yet was massive change compared to 1.311.335 registered in late 1938.[138] The difference resulted from 2 factors. A large number of refugees from other parts of Spain, who sought shelter in Barcelona during the war, returned - or at times were forced to return - to their native locations. Some 60.000 citizens fled to France before the Nationalist takeover, though around 30.000 returned in course of the following months.[139] The birth rate, which during the war declined from monthly average of 1.410 in 1936 to 1.133 in 1938, 937 in January 1939 and the record low of 597 in July 1939, recovered quickly; in February 1940 it was already 1.533 and kept growing; similar trend marked marriages.[140] In the post-war period enormous peak was recorded in statistics of baptisms; with religious services resumed, children born during 30 months of wartime Republican rule were christened.[141] Mortality rate dropped; while it stood at some 1.250 per month in the mid-1930s, it grew to over 2.500 in last months of 1938 and reached the record high of 3.546 in January 1939 (combat-related deaths excluded); in the second half of 1939 the figure dropped to an average of 1.180.[142] Economic growth attracted increased influx of migrants from other regions of Spain; Catalonia was the region with the second largest immigration figures, and in the 1950s immigration to Catalonia would exceed this to Madrid; Catalan share of the overall national population was growing from 11% in 1940 to reach above 15% in late Francoism.[143] However, in terms of quality of life Catalonia's advantage over other regions decreased, from 170% in 1930 to 159% in 1955.[144]

Repression

The role of public force of order was assumed by Columna de Orden Público y Policía de Ocupación, some 1.200 volunteers from Aragon above the usual conscription age;[145] gradually they were being replaced by standard services. Institutionalized repression was aimed at former Popular Front supporters or these deemed supportive of the Republican rule during the war. In entire Catalonia the number of executions, both juridical and extrajuridical, amounted to 4,000;[146] comparison to scale of Republican terror in Barcelona is hardly possible, as estimates of the number of its fatal victims range from 2.400 to 21.000.[147] The category of "violent deaths", which apart from victims of accidents or crime comprised also war-related deaths and rearguard terror, was 2.542 for 1939, down from 4.213 in 1938 (attributed usually to Italian bombardments of Barcelona) and up from 1.373 in 1937 and 1.927 in 1936.[148] The number of incarcerated in the province in 1940 was 27,300 (14,500 in Barcelona),[149] the number of prosecution cases was 110,000 and the number of individuals prosecuted was 146,000;[150] within this figure there were some 25,000 prosecuted by Tribunal of Political Responsibilities.[151] At least 135 academics have been purged from universities;[152] the respective number for town hall officials, fired until 1940, was 1.450 (and all employees of the dissolved Generalitat).[153] Personal sanctions affected various categories, including artists like the architect Josep Lluís Sert or the musician Pau Casals,[154] though other recognized Catalan artists like Salvador Dalí or Eugenio d'Ors supported the new regime. The most symbolic case of repression was this of the former president of autonomous Catalonia, Companys, who in October 1940 was trialed by the Barcelona military tribunal and executed in Montjuïc shortly afterwards.

Recovery

Except some harbour facilities, heavily bombed by Nationalist aviation, the city infrastructure did not suffer major losses during the war; out of 60.000 buildings in the municipal inventory, only 3.000 were listed as damaged.[155] Some 0.6m cubic metres of rubble had to be removed[156] (in comparison, there were 22m removed from Warsaw in 1945–1949).[157] Most damage was repaired by the early 1940s, though in some cases new streets - e.g. what is now Carrer de l'Almirall Cervera - were delineated in destroyed quarters.[158] In some cases removing the damage took longer, e.g. the zoological garden re-opened in the mid-1940s.[159] Municipal and provincial services resumed service almost immediately, e.g. metro was re-opened on February 2, 1939[160] and train connections 3 days later.[161] Much effort was dedicated to restoration of churches, almost all damaged or otherwise vandalised, with priority given to the Catedral, la Sagrada Família, el Tibidabo and Pedralbes; in cases of totally destroyed temples, religious service was held in the open until full reconstruction.[162] Economically the city recovered fairly quickly from the wartime period. The provincial industrial output exceeded this of 1935 already in 1941. Catalonia developed faster than other regions, e.g. Barcelona consistently consumed more cement - a usual indicator to measure dynamics of construction business - than Madrid or Valencia, and at times even twice as much.[163]

See also

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. when the Nationalists commenced the Catalonia offensive, the overall Republican troops in the enclave were some 220,000. This force dwindled significantly. On January 22 the Nationalists claimed 39,000 POWs from the beginning of the campaign (Heraldo de Aragon 24.01.1939), apart from desertions, WIAs and KIAs. Also, only some of surviving Republican units were tasked with defending Barcelona. The French government in mid-1939 estimated the number of Spanish military internees at 200,000, see Campos de refugiados, [in:] Cultura service of the Spanish government. It is likely that 90% of these internees were soldiers who crossed from Catalonia in January–February 1939, so arithmetic leaves only few tens of thousands as possible defenders of Barcelona
  2. on December 23, 1938, the Nationalists commenced the Catalonia offensive with 320,000 troops. They suffered rather minor losses. One month later, around January 23, Barcelona was approached by 3 corps: Cuerpo de Ejército del CTV (originally 55,000), Cuerpo de Ejército de Navarra (39,000) and Cuerpo de Ejército Marroquí (40,000), Carles López Rovira, La conquesta de Catalunya: diari d'operacions de l'exércit del nord (desembre de 1938 – febrer 1939) [PhD thesis UAB], Barcelona 2010, p. 229. One propagandistic text claims that "el 26 de enero de 1939 unos 90.000 soldados del ejército franquista entraban en Barcelona", see Barcelona 1939. La oscura noche del franquismo, [in:] FemTurismeCat service, but it is not clear where the figure comes from
  3. „había bastante desacuerdo entre "Terminus" [codename for Franco headquarters] y "Escala" [codename for general staff headquarters], en lo reference a la orientación futura de la guerra", López Rovira 2010, p. 1
  4. López Rovira 2010, pp. 1-3
  5. López Rovira 2010, p. 10
  6. López Rovira 2010, p. 27
  7. López Rovira 2010, p. 219
  8. the entire campaign was to consist of 5 phases: 1) frontline battle; 2) breakout into operational space; 3) advance and consolidation to final offensives; 4) envelopment and seizure of Barcelona; 5) envelopment and seizure of Girona and province, López Rovira 2010, p. 200
  9. López Rovira 2010, p. 5
  10. Xavier Hernàndez, Francesc Riart, Pere Català, Història militar de Catalunya. Aproximació didàctica, vol. IV, Barcelona 2004, ISBN 8423206734, p 258
  11. López Rovira 2010, p. 26
  12. López Rovira 2010, p. 99
  13. Jordi Catalan, La industria entre la guerra y la revolución, 1936-39, [in:] Pablo Martín Aceña, Elena Martínez Ruiz (eds.), La economía de la Guerra Civil, Santiago de Compostela 2005, pp. 23, 30
  14. Catalan 2005, p. 27. Catalan metalworking output was at 30% of pre-war production, Stanley G. Payne, The Spanish Revolution, New York 1970, ISBN 97803930988853, p. 257
  15. e.g. in case of the Pirelli factory in Manresa, the last shipment took place on January 14, when the Nationalists were some 40 km from the city and 10 days before they entered Manresa, Catalan 2005, p. 31
  16. Payne 1970, p. 359
  17. see opinions referred in Payne 1970, p. 359
  18. Francisco González Ledesma, Expediente Barcelona, Barcelona 2014, ISBN 9788490185254, p. 65
  19. or 564% compared to the year of 1913, Payne 1970, p. 258
  20. Solidad Obrera 05.01.1939
  21. Higinio Polo, Los últimos días de la Barcelona republicana [PhD thesis Universitat de Barcelona], Barcelona 1989, pp. 595-599
  22. "lack of general interest in responding to the emergency call for volunteers to build fortifications was painfully clear from the start", Payne 1970, p. 359
  23. Polo 1989, p. 600
  24. Polo 1989, p. 605
  25. Polo 1989, p. 595. At the time there were 24 POUM leaders incarcerated in Barcelona prisons, and some, like Teodoro Sanz Hernández, would arrive slightly later, transported from minor local prisons. Also some 250 members of International Brigades remained behing bars, Agustín Guillamón, El terror estalinista en Barcelona, Valencia 2018, pp. 132, 153
  26. during the Catalan campaign the Nationalists took 60,000 prisoners, Payne 1970, p. 360, which given duration of the campaign translates to an average of some 1,500 POWs taken every day
  27. up to 900 daily, López Rovira 2010, p. 88
  28. Polo 1989, p. 590
  29. Polo 1989, p. 591
  30. López Rovira 2010, p. 3
  31. Polo 1989, p. 609
  32. Polo 1989, pp. 609-610
  33. Polo 1989, p. 611
  34. Polo 1989, pp. 616-617
  35. Polo 1989, p. 633
  36. Polo 1989, pp. 603-604
  37. Polo 1989, pp. 595-597
  38. Polo 1989, p. 599
  39. Polo 1989, p. 606
  40. Polo 1989, p. 612
  41. Polo 1989, p. 615
  42. Polo 1989, p. 627
  43. Polo 1989, p. 623
  44. Polo 1989, pp. 623, 625
  45. Polo 1989, p. 607
  46. Polo 1989, p. 619
  47. Polo 1989, pp. 620-622
  48. Polo 1989, pp. 643-644
  49. Polo 1989, p. 643
  50. Polo 1989, p. 620
  51. Payne 1970, p. 359
  52. Pelai Pages i Blanch, La justícia revolucionaria i popular a Catalunya (1936–1939), [in:] Ebre 38 2 (2004), p. 48. Between March 1938 and January 1939 the Barcelona tribunals sentenced 211 people to death, 219 to 30 years incarceration, 95 to 20 years, 71 to 10 years, 160 to 6 years and others to shorter terms, Pages i Blanch 2004, p. 47
  53. Polo 1989, p. 640
  54. Polo 1989, pp. 628-630
  55. Polo 1989, pp. 630-631
  56. Polo 1989, pp. 631-632
  57. Polo 1989, p. 635
  58. Polo 1989, p. 634
  59. Polo 1989, pp. 636-637
  60. Polo 1989, p. 638
  61. Polo 1989, pp. 640-641
  62. like Garcia Moreno or Ascaso, compare Solidaridad Obrera 19.01.1939
  63. Solidaridad Obrera
  64. Polo 1989, pp. 646-647
  65. Polo 1989, p. 647
  66. Polo 1989, p. 652
  67. Polo 1989, p. 651
  68. Polo 1989, p. 666
  69. Polo 1989, p. 653
  70. Polo 1989, p. 653
  71. Polo 1989, p. 653
  72. Polo 1989, pp. 657-658
  73. Polo 1989, p. 659
  74. Polo 1989, p. 661
  75. Polo 1989, p. 649
  76. Polo 1989, p. 664
  77. however, they were not deployed at defensive perimeter of the city. Instead, former IB volunteers were moved north, to Les Planes and Els Hostalets de Llers, Polo 1989, p. 656
  78. Polo 1989, p. 653
  79. Solidaridad Obrera 22.01.1939
  80. Polo 1989, p. 667
  81. Solidaridad Obrera 22.01.1939
  82. Polo 1989, p. 681
  83. Polo 1989, p. 707
  84. Polo 1989, pp. 682-684
  85. Polo 1989, pp. 686-688
  86. his colleagues were already on their way, some – like Montseny – left all their belongings at home, as they were anxious to leave in secrecy and "no dar sensación de derrotismo", Polo 1989, p. 697
  87. Polo 1989, p. 696
  88. Polo 1989, p. 698
  89. Polo 1989, pp. 684-686
  90. Polo 1989, p. 691
  91. Polo 1989, p. 692
  92. Polo 1989, p. 701
  93. Polo 1989, p. 701
  94. Polo 1989, p. 700
  95. J. M. Poblet, Vida i mort de Lluís Companys, Barcelona, 1976, p. 471. In historiography there are different dates given as to Companys' departure from Barcelona. Some authors claim January 23, see e.g. David Barreira, Companys, del exilio, [in:] El Español 23.12.2018, the opinion maintained also e.g. by Josep Solé i Sabaté, Introducció, p. XVII. Some claim January 25 or even 26, see e.g. J. Sariol Badía, Petita historia de la guerra civil. Vint-i-tres testimonis informen, Barcelona, 1977, p. 35
  96. Polo 1989, p. 715
  97. Polo 1989, p. 639
  98. the SIM commander Santiago Garcés, having received the call from prison director to transport inmates north, snarled: "no trucks for the POUM leadership. Let the fascists finish the bastards off", referred Burnett Bolloten, The Spanish Civil War, London 2015, ISBN 9781469624471, p. 893
  99. Polo 1989, pp. 693-694
  100. Polo 1989, p. 707
  101. Polo 1989, p. 709
  102. Polo 1989, p. 705
  103. Polo 1989, p. 713
  104. Polo 1989, p. 689
  105. Polo 1989, p. 690
  106. Polo 1989, p. 732
  107. Polo 1989, pp. 704-705
  108. Polo 1989, p. 716
  109. Polo 1989, p. 704
  110. Polo 1989, p. 730
  111. Polo 1989, p. 732
  112. Polo 1989, pp. 732-733
  113. Polo 1989, p. 733
  114. Polo 1989, p. 717
  115. Polo 1989, p. 720-721
  116. reportedly named "Grey John", Polo 1989, p. 719; however, no other source confirms existence of such a British destroyer
  117. Polo 1989, p. 719
  118. Polo 1989, p. 718
  119. Polo 1989, p. 731
  120. Polo 1989, pp. 725-726, Jaume Fabre Fornaguera, La contrarevolució de 1939 a Barcelona [PhD thesis UAB], Barcelona 2002, pp. 17-25
  121. Polo 1989, p. 744-745
  122. Polo 1989, p. 725-726
  123. Polo 1989, p. 694
  124. Polo 1989, p. 738
  125. ironically, the only Catalan Carlist battalion, Terç de Requetès de la Mare de Déu de Montserrat, was transferred from the Ebro bend to Extremadura in mid-December 1938, just when the Catalan offensive was about to begin. Some authors claim that the Francoist regime was bent on preventing the Terç from entering the Catalan territory; the motive would have been to make any Carlist political demonstrations impossible, Robert Vallverdú i Martí, La metamorfosi del carlisme català: del "Déu, Pàtria i Rei" a l'Assamblea de Catalunya (1936–1975), Barcelona 2014, ISBN 9788498837261, pp. 31-32
  126. Polo 1989, pp. 738-789
  127. people with huge bags on their backs, often females, crossed the streets, Polo 1989, pp. 740, 746
  128. Polo 1989, p. 745
  129. Polo 1989, p. 742
  130. Polo 1989, pp. 751-752
  131. Polo 1989, p. 716
  132. Joan Maria Thomàs, Els orígens del franquisme a Barcelona, [in:] Terme 8 (1993), p. 40
  133. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 15
  134. see e.g. the composition of Comision Gestora, which acted in place of the ayuntamiento, Fabre Fornaguera 2002, pp. 39-40
  135. see Vallverdú i Martí 2014, also Javier Tébar Hurtado, La Barcelona azul de posguerra: reflexiones sobre una indagación biográfica, [in:] Gerónimo de Uztáriz 28-29 (2012–2013), Javier Tébar Hurtado, Barcelona, anys blaus: el governador Correa Veglison: poder i política franquistes (1940–1945), Barcelona 2011, ISBN 9788496495463
  136. following the Nationalist takeover of the first Catalan provincial capital, Lleida, on April 5, 1938, Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 34
  137. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 59
  138. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 671
  139. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 89
  140. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 60-61
  141. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, pp. 63-64
  142. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 68
  143. BBVA 153
  144. Julio Martínez Galarraga, New Estimates of Regional GDP in Spain, 1860-1930, [in:] Working Papers on Economics 177 (2007), p. 15
  145. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 45
  146. Conxita Mir, The Francoist Repression in the Catalan Countries, [in:] Catalan Historical Review 1 (2008), p. 138;
  147. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 72
  148. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 71
  149. Mir 2008, p. 139
  150. Mir 2008, p. 139
  151. Mir 2008, p. 140
  152. Mir 2008, p. 142
  153. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 54
  154. Mir 2008, p. 141
  155. Aram Montfort i Coll, Barcelona 1939: ocupacio i represio militar [PhD thesis UAB], Barcelona 2007, p. 46; other sources claim 1.500 buldings damaged, Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 93
  156. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 104
  157. Zgruzowstanie Warszawy 1945-1949, [in:] Muzeum Warszawy service
  158. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 115. Some monuments (Doctor Robert, Rafael Casanova) were removed already in April, the same month some new ones were erected (victims of Montjuïc executions, to Dos de Mayo), Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 145-154. Numerous street names were changed, e.g. Passeig de Pi i Margall to Paseo del General Mola, Plaça de Catalunya to Plaza del Ejército Español, or Via Durruti to Vía José Antonio, Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 162
  159. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 108
  160. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, pp. 129-130
  161. though following rushed reconstruction, already on February 11, 1939, a railway disaster at Sant Gervasi station produced 32 deaths, Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 130
  162. Fabre Fornaguera 2002, p. 175
  163. Lino Camprubi, How the Catalan Economy Benefited under Franco—and What This Means for the Ongoing Stalemate, [in:] Max-Planck-Institut fur Wissenschaftgeschichte service 25.10.2017