Extended emission-line region explained

An extended emission-line region (EELR) is a giant interstellar cloud ionized by the radiation of an active galactic nucleus (AGN) inside a galaxy or photons produced by the shocks associated with the radio jets. An EELR can appear as a resolved cloud in relative nearby galaxies and as narrow emission lines in more distant galaxies.EELRs were first discovered in radio galaxies. Usually the clouds emitting the narrow emission lines are restricted to a few kiloparsecs within the AGN, but some galaxies have narrow emission lines that extend a few kiloparsec to over 100 kiloparsecs. These clouds where therefore called extended emission-line regions (EELRs) and usually have a large doubly ionized oxygen [O III]/Hβ ratio, as well as a strong ionized helium He II/Hβ ratio (oxygen line at 5007 Å, helium line at 4686 Å). In some cases these EELRs show highly ionized species, such as calcium [Ca V] and iron [Fe VII] [Fe X]. Another common highly ionized species is the emission of neon [Ne V] (main line at 3426 Å). This high level of ionization shows that the EELRs must be ionized by a mechanism related to the nucleus of the galaxy. HII regions do not show this high level of ionization.[1] The first [O III] images of EELRs were around galaxies, such as 3C 79,[2] 4C 37.43,[3] NGC 3516[4] or NGC 4151.[5]

In 2009 a large cloud was discovered that had similar spectral features as EELRs, but had no ionizing AGN nearby. It was concluded that the nearby galaxy IC 2497 hosted an AGN in the past. Today this AGN faded into inactivity. The hard ionizing radiation did however need time to travel the thousands of lightyears towards a cloud, which would later become Hanny's Voorwerp. This makes Hanny's Voorwerp the first EELR associated with a fading AGN. Previously EELRs were commonly first discovered via spectroscopy and required high-resolution imaging to further resolve the EELRs. Hanny's Voorwerp was however discovered in broad band imaging from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey.[6] This prompted a search for more EELRs in broad-band imaging surveys by galaxy zoo volunteers, who also discovered Hanny's Voorwerp. EELRs are called "Voorwerpjes" by the galaxy zoo members.[7] EELRs that are ionized by the AGN of a companion galaxy were also discovered. This type of ionization is called cross-ionization.

In broad-band images the [O III] emission lines usually lie at the g-band. The true color of an EELR would be dominated by the [O III] emission, which is a cyan color. In astronomical imaging slightly false-color images that transform g, r and i bands into RGB-images are more common. Sometimes the i-band is replaced with a z-band image. The EELRs appear as blue (g-band) objects in these survey images. Sometimes the H-alpha line is redshifted enough to lie at the i-band, which can make the EELR appear as a blue-violet object in these survey images. Sometimes the [O III] is redshifted enough that this line overlaps with the r-band or i-band, which makes them green or red in survey images of the Hyper Suprime-Cam.[8] At around 0.1 < z < 0.38 the 5006.843 Å [O III] line is redshifted to the r-band and at 0.38 < z < 0.68 it is redshifted to the i-band. A team of researchers detected a resolved EELR at a high redshift of 4.54 in a galaxy protocluster with JWST.

Another related type of cloud is a extended narrow-line region (ENLR). The EELRs usually have dynamically chaotic structures and high velocities and are probably the result of mergers. ENLRs on the other hand follow the disk structure of the galaxy and have a low velocity.

List of resolved EELRs

This is a list of EELRs with resolved [O III] images or other emission-lines

!Name Host galaxy!Image EELR!Distance to nucleus (kpc)!Date/Reference
MR 2251-17830-501990[9]
Centaurus Aouter and inner filaments7 & 161991[10]
IC 5063221991[11]
3CR 368451991[12]
3C 35215.61992[13]
NGC 41511.161993
NGC 351641995
3C 27314.41996[14]
PKS 2250–4140-651997[15]
NGC 56431.81997[16]
PKS 2356–61251998[17]
NGC 525672000[18]
NGC 4388352002[19]
4C 37.43202002[20]
3C 17152003[21]
PKS 1932–461002007[22]
3C 792008
IC 2497402009
3C 482009[23]
Mrk 10142009
3C 249.12009
Ton 6162009
Ton 2022009
PKS 2251+11 2009
Mrk 78162012
SDSS J095559.88+395446.9102012
SDSS J100507.88+283038.5132012
IC 2637112012
NGC 3758172012
UGC 7342382012
NGC 5252212012
Mrk 273192012
Mrk 463162012
Teacup galaxy182012
SDSS J151004.01+074037.1102012
CGCG 077-117(SDSS J152412.58+083241.2)192012
NGC 5972332012
Mrk 1498212012
Mrk 883372012
UGC 11185112012
SDSS J220141.64+115124.3162012
3C 3052012[24]
3C 381382013[25]
NGC 725242013[26]
PGC 043234102016[27]
ShaSS 073212018[28]
J023106−034513302018
J083823+015012292018
J090254+001116102018
J091113+032604102018
J092203−004443 132018
J155143+434758112018
J162913+441442152018
J220347+020443122018
J220440+00523282018
J224027+00434792018
3C 1710.52019[29]
3C 18132019
3C 336.32019
3C 6330.12019
3C 318.111.72019
3C 3278.12019
3C 35312.72019
3C 3864.22019
3C 40311.32019
3C 4242.42019
3C 44232019
3C 445172019
3C 45880.22019
3C 459692019
SDSS J002944.89+001011.1 2019[30]
SDSS J005754.03+012013.82019
SDSS J083902.96+470756.32019
Z 180–92019
NGC 33412019
UGC 60812019
SDSS J120149.74-015327.52019
SDSS J121418.25+293146.72019
Arp 239 (NGC 5278/NGC 5279)2019
SDSS J135429.05+132757.22019
Mrk 1172142021[31]
NGC 235262022[32]
NGC 5514752022
3C 9862022[33]
3C 13531.62022
3C 18059.82022
3C 196.19.32022
3C 19832.62022
3C 22746.12022
3C 30017.22022
2MASS J08001609+29281722023[34]
Z 119–122023
2MASX J13020015+27465792023
2MASS J08152577+37202582023
2MASX J09515536+03290062023
UGC 59412024
Markarian 9506.52024
J1000+0234>8.62024[35]
GSN 0699.22024[36]
RXJ13012.82024
eRO-QPE24.62024

References

  1. Robinson . A. . Binette . L. . Fosbury . R. A. E. . Tadhunter . C. N. . 1987-07-01 . Emission-line activity in radio galaxies. . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 227 . 97–114 . 10.1093/mnras/227.1.97 . free . 1987MNRAS.227...97R . 0035-8711.
  2. Fu . Hai . Stockton . Alan . 2008-04-01 . The Host Galaxy and the Extended Emission-Line Region of the Radio Galaxy 3C 79 . The Astrophysical Journal . 677 . 1 . 79–91 . 10.1086/529015 . 0712.4145 . 2008ApJ...677...79F . 0004-637X.
  3. Fu . Hai . Stockton . Alan . 2007-09-01 . Integral Field Spectroscopy of the Extended Emission-Line Region of 4C 37.43 . The Astrophysical Journal . 666 . 2 . 794–805 . 10.1086/520530 . 0705.4365 . 2007ApJ...666..794F . 0004-637X.
  4. Golev . V. . Yankulova . I. . Bonev . T. . Jockers . K. . 1995-03-01 . New narrow-band imaging of the extended emission-line region in the Seyfert galaxy NGC 3516 . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 273 . 1 . 129–138 . 10.1093/mnras/273.1.129 . free . 1995MNRAS.273..129G . 0035-8711.
  5. Yoshida . Michitoshi . Ohtani . Hiroshi . 1993-06-01 . A Study of the Extended Emission-Line Region of the Seyfert Galaxy NGC 4151 by Means of Narrow-Band Imaging Observations . Publications of the Astronomical Society of Japan . 45 . 407–420 . 1993PASJ...45..407Y . 0004-6264.
  6. Lintott . Chris J. . Schawinski . Kevin . Keel . William . van Arkel . Hanny . Bennert . Nicola . Edmondson . Edward . Thomas . Daniel . Smith . Daniel J. B. . Herbert . Peter D. . Jarvis . Matt J. . Virani . Shanil . Andreescu . Dan . Bamford . Steven P. . Land . Kate . Murray . Phil . 2009-10-01 . Galaxy Zoo: 'Hanny's Voorwerp', a quasar light echo? . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 399 . 1 . 129–140 . 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.15299.x . free . 0906.5304 . 2009MNRAS.399..129L . 0035-8711.
  7. Keel . William C. . Chojnowski . S. Drew . Bennert . Vardha N. . Schawinski . Kevin . Lintott . Chris J. . Lynn . Stuart . Pancoast . Anna . Harris . Chelsea . Nierenberg . A. M. . Sonnenfeld . Alessandro . Proctor . Richard . 2012-02-01 . The Galaxy Zoo survey for giant AGN-ionized clouds: past and present black hole accretion events . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 420 . 1 . 878–900 . 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.20101.x . free . 1110.6921 . 2012MNRAS.420..878K . 0035-8711.
  8. Sun . Ai-Lei . Greene . Jenny E. . Zakamska . Nadia L. . Goulding . Andy D. . Strauss . Michael A. . Huang . Song . Johnson . Sean D. . Kawaguchi . Toshihiro . Matsuoka . Yoshiki . Marsteller . Alisabeth A. . Nagao . Tohru . Toba . Yoshiki . 2018-10-01 . Imaging extended emission-line regions of obscured AGN with the Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam Survey . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 480 . 2 . 2302–2323 . 10.1093/mnras/sty1394 . free . 1803.07241 . 2018MNRAS.480.2302S . 0035-8711.
  9. Macchetto . F. . Colina . L. . Golombek . D. . Perryman . M. A. C. . di Serego Alighieri . S. . 1990-06-01 . The Structure and Ionization of the Extended Emission-Line Filaments Surrounding the QSO MR 2251-178 . The Astrophysical Journal . 356 . 389 . 10.1086/168847 . 1990ApJ...356..389M . 0004-637X.
  10. Morganti . R. . Robinson . A. . Fosbury . R. A. E. . di Serego Alighieri . S. . Tadhunter . C. N. . Malin . D. F. . 1991-03-01 . The nature of the optical filaments in Centaurus A. Evidence for a beamed ionizing continuum. . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 249 . 91–112 . 10.1093/mnras/249.1.91 . free . 1991MNRAS.249...91M . 0035-8711.
  11. Colina . L. . Sparks . W. B. . Macchetto . F. . 1991-03-01 . IC 5063: A Merger Remnant with a Hidden Luminous Active Nucleus . The Astrophysical Journal . 370 . 102 . 10.1086/169795 . 1991ApJ...370..102C . 0004-637X.
  12. Hammer . F. . Le Fevre . O. . Proust . D. . 1991-06-01 . Deep Spectroscopy under High Spatial Resolution of the High-Redshift Radio Source 3CR 368: The Monster Elucidated . The Astrophysical Journal . 374 . 91 . 10.1086/170099 . 1991ApJ...374...91H . 0004-637X.
  13. Hippelein . Hans . Meisenheimer . Klaus . 1992-10-01 . The extended line-emission from 3C 352. . Astronomy and Astrophysics . 264 . 472 . 1992A&A...264..472H . 0004-6361.
  14. Hippelein . H. . Meisenheimer . K. . Roeser . H. J. . 1996-12-01 . An emission line region associated with 3C 273. . Astronomy and Astrophysics . 316 . 29–32 . 1996A&A...316...29H . 0004-6361.
  15. Clark . N. E. . Tadhunter . C. N. . Morganti . R. . Killeen . N. E. B. . Fosbury . R. A. E. . Hook . R. N. . Siebert . J. . Shaw . M. A. . 1997-04-01 . Radio, optical and X-ray observations of PKS 2250-41: a jet/galaxy collision? . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 286 . 3 . 558–582 . 10.1093/mnras/286.3.558 . free . 1997MNRAS.286..558C . 0035-8711.
  16. Simpson . Chris . Wilson . A. S. . Bower . Gary . Heckman . T. M. . Krolik . J. H. . Miley . G. K. . January 1997 . A One-sided Ionization Cone in the Seyfert 2 Galaxy NGC 5643 . The Astrophysical Journal . 474 . 1 . 121–128 . 1997ApJ...474..121S . 10.1086/303466 . free.
  17. Koekemoer . Anton M. . Bicknell . Geoffrey V. . 1998-04-01 . Dynamics and Excitation of Radio Galaxy Emission-Line Regions. I. PKS 2356-61 . The Astrophysical Journal . 497 . 2 . 662–680 . 10.1086/305490 . astro-ph/9711229 . 1998ApJ...497..662K . 0004-637X.
  18. Ishigaki . Tsuyoshi . Yoshida . Michitoshi . Aoki . Kentaro . Ohtani . Hiroshi . Sugai . Hajime . Hayashi . Tadashi . Ozaki . Shinobu . Hattori . Takashi . Ishii . Motomi . 2000-02-01 . Tridimensional Spectrophotometric Study of the Extended Emission-Line Regions of the Infrared-Luminous Merger Markarian 266 . Publications of the Astronomical Society of Japan . 52 . 185–207 . 10.1093/pasj/52.1.185 . 2000PASJ...52..185I . 0004-6264.
  19. Yoshida . Michitoshi . Yagi . Masafumi . Okamura . Sadanori . Aoki . Kentaro . Ohyama . Youichi . Komiyama . Yutaka . Yasuda . Naoki . Iye . Masanori . Kashikawa . Nobunari . Doi . Mamoru . Furusawa . Hisanori . Hamabe . Masaru . Kimura . Masahiko . Miyazaki . Masayuki . Miyazaki . Satoshi . 2002-03-01 . Discovery of a Very Extended Emission-Line Region around the Seyfert 2 Galaxy NGC 4388 . The Astrophysical Journal . 567 . 1 . 118–129 . 10.1086/338353 . astro-ph/0110473 . 2002ApJ...567..118Y . 0004-637X.
  20. Stockton . Alan . MacKenty . John W. . Hu . Esther M. . Kim . Tae-Sun . 2002-06-01 . The Extended Emission-Line Region of 4C 37.43 . The Astrophysical Journal . 572 . 2 . 735–745 . 10.1086/340432 . astro-ph/0205040 . 2002ApJ...572..735S . 0004-637X.
  21. Hardcastle . M. J. . 2003-02-01 . Probing the extended emission-line region in 3C 171 with high-frequency radio polarimetry . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 339 . 2 . 360–366 . 10.1046/j.1365-8711.2003.06102.x . free . astro-ph/0209612 . 2003MNRAS.339..360H . 0035-8711.
  22. Inskip . K. J. . Tadhunter . C. N. . Dicken . D. . Holt . J. . Villar-Martín . M. . Morganti . R. . 2007-11-01 . PKS1932-46: a radio source in an interacting group? . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 382 . 1 . 95–108 . 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2007.12378.x . free . 0708.2848 . 2007MNRAS.382...95I . 0035-8711.
  23. Fu . Hai . Stockton . Alan . 2009-01-01 . Extended Emission-Line Regions: Remnants of Quasar Superwinds? . The Astrophysical Journal . 690 . 1 . 953–973 . 10.1088/0004-637X/690/1/953 . 0809.1117 . 2009ApJ...690..953F . 0004-637X.
  24. Hardcastle . M. J. . Massaro . F. . Harris . D. E. . Baum . S. A. . Bianchi . S. . Chiaberge . M. . Morganti . R. . O'Dea . C. P. . Siemiginowska . A. . 2012-08-01 . The nature of the jet-driven outflow in the radio galaxy 3C 305 . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 424 . 3 . 1774–1789 . 10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21247.x . free . 1205.0962 . 2012MNRAS.424.1774H . 0035-8711.
  25. Reynaldi . V. . Feinstein . C. . 2013-04-01 . Searching for evidence of jet-cloud interaction in radio galaxies. First results for 3C 381 . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 430 . 3 . 2221–2231 . 10.1093/mnras/stt042 . free . 1301.2216 . 2013MNRAS.430.2221R . 0035-8711.
  26. Schweizer . François . Seitzer . Patrick . Kelson . Daniel D. . Villanueva . Edward V. . Walth . Gregory L. . 2013-08-01 . The [O III] Nebula of the Merger Remnant NGC 7252: A Likely Faint Ionization Echo ]. The Astrophysical Journal . 773 . 2 . 148 . 10.1088/0004-637X/773/2/148 . 1307.2233 . 2013ApJ...773..148S . 0004-637X.
  27. Prieto . J. L. . Krühler . T. . Anderson . J. P. . Galbany . L. . Kochanek . C. S. . Aquino . E. . Brown . J. S. . Dong . Subo . Förster . F. . Holoien . T. W. -S. . Kuncarayakti . H. . Maureira . J. C. . Rosales-Ortega . F. F. . Sánchez . S. F. . Shappee . B. J. . 2016-10-01 . MUSE Reveals a Recent Merger in the Post-starburst Host Galaxy of the TDE ASASSN-14li . The Astrophysical Journal . 830 . 2 . L32 . 10.3847/2041-8205/830/2/L32 . free . 1609.00013 . 2016ApJ...830L..32P . 0004-637X.
  28. Merluzzi . Paola . Busarello . Giovanni . Dopita . Michael A. . Thomas . Adam D. . Haines . Chris P. . Grado . Aniello . Limatola . Luca . Mercurio . Amata . 2018-01-01 . An Interacting Galaxy Pair at the Origin of a Light Echo . The Astrophysical Journal . 852 . 2 . 113 . 10.3847/1538-4357/aa9fff . free . 1801.01005 . 2018ApJ...852..113M . 0004-637X.
  29. Balmaverde . B. . Capetti . A. . Marconi . A. . Venturi . G. . Chiaberge . M. . Baldi . R. D. . Baum . S. . Gilli . R. . Grandi . P. . Meyer . E. . Miley . G. . O'Dea . C. . Sparks . W. . Torresi . E. . Tremblay . G. . 2019-12-01 . The MURALES survey. II. Presentation of MUSE observations of 20 3C low-z radio galaxies and first results . Astronomy and Astrophysics . 632 . A124 . 10.1051/0004-6361/201935544 . 1903.10768 . 2019A&A...632A.124B . 0004-6361.
  30. Keel . William C. . Bennert . Vardha N. . Pancoast . Anna . Harris . Chelsea E. . Nierenberg . Anna . Chojnowski . S. Drew . Moiseev . Alexei V. . Oparin . Dmitry V. . Lintott . Chris J. . Schawinski . Kevin . Mitchell . Graham . Cornen . Claude . 2019-03-01 . AGN photoionization of gas in companion galaxies as a probe of AGN radiation in time and direction . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 483 . 4 . 4847–4865 . 10.1093/mnras/sty3332 . free . 1711.09936 . 2019MNRAS.483.4847K . 0035-8711.
  31. Lassen . Augusto . Riffel . Rogério . Chies-Santos . Ana L. . Johnston . Evelyn . Haeussler . Boris . Dutra . Daniel R. . Azevedo . Gabriel M. . 2021-01-01 . An Extended Emission Line Region around Mrk 1172 . Galaxy Evolution and Feedback Across Different Environments. Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union . 359 . 438–440 . 10.1017/S1743921320004299. 2021IAUS..359..438L .
  32. Keel . William C. . Moiseev . Alexei . Kozlova . D. V. . Ikhsanova . A. I. . Oparin . D. V. . Uklein . R. I. . Smirnova . A. A. . Eselevich . M. V. . 2022-03-01 . The TELPERION survey for distant [O III] clouds around luminous and hibernating AGN . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . 510 . 3 . 4608–4625 . 10.1093/mnras/stab3656 . free . 2112.07084 . 2022MNRAS.510.4608K . 0035-8711.
  33. Balmaverde . B. . Capetti . A. . Baldi . R. D. . Baum . S. . Chiaberge . M. . Gilli . R. . Jimenez-Gallardo . A. . Marconi . A. . Massaro . F. . Meyer . E. . O'Dea . C. . Speranza . G. . Torresi . E. . Venturi . G. . 2022-06-01 . The MURALES survey. VI. Properties and origin of the extended line emission structures in radio galaxies . Astronomy and Astrophysics . 662 . A23 . 10.1051/0004-6361/202142823 . 2204.00528 . 2022A&A...662A..23B . 0004-6361.
  34. French . K. Decker . Earl . Nicholas . Novack . Annemarie B. . Pardasani . Bhavya . Pillai . Vismaya R. . Tripathi . Akshat . Verrico . Margaret E. . 2023-06-01 . Fading AGNs in Poststarburst Galaxies . The Astrophysical Journal . 950 . 2 . 153 . 10.3847/1538-4357/acd249 . free . 2023ApJ...950..153F . 0004-637X. 2304.10419 .
  35. Solimano . M. . A hidden AGN powering bright [O III] nebulae in a protocluster core at z=4.5 revealed by JWST . 2024-07-17 . González-López . J. . Aravena . M. . Pampliega . B. Alcalde . Assef . R. J. . Béthermin . M. . Boquien . M. . Bovino . S. . Casey . C. M. . A&A . 2407.13020.
  36. Wevers . T. . French . K. D. . Zabludoff . A. I. . Fischer . T. C. . Rowlands . K. . Guolo . M. . Dalla Barba . B. . Arcodia . R. . Berton . M. . Bian . F. . Linial . I. . Miniutti . G. . Pasham . D. R. . 2024-07-01 . X-Ray Quasi-periodic Eruptions and Tidal Disruption Events Prefer Similar Host Galaxies . The Astrophysical Journal . 970 . 1 . L23 . 2406.02678 . 2024ApJ...970L..23W . 10.3847/2041-8213/ad5f1b . free . 0004-637X.