Emotion classification explained

Emotion classification, the means by which one may distinguish or contrast one emotion from another, is a contested issue in emotion research and in affective science. Researchers have approached the classification of emotions from one of two fundamental viewpoints:

1. that emotions are discrete and fundamentally different constructs
2. that emotions can be characterized on a dimensional basis in groupings

Emotions as discrete categories

In discrete emotion theory, all humans are thought to have an innate set of basic emotions that are cross-culturally recognizable. These basic emotions are described as "discrete" because they are believed to be distinguishable by an individual's facial expression and biological processes.^[1] Theorists have conducted studies to determine which emotions are basic. A popular example is Paul Ekman and his colleagues' cross-cultural study of 1992, in which they concluded that the six basic emotions are anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, and surprise.^[2] Ekman explains that there are particular characteristics attached to each of these emotions, allowing them to be expressed in varying degrees in a non-verbal manner.^{[3] [4]} Each emotion acts as a discrete category rather than an individual emotional state.

Simplicity debate

Humans' subjective experience is that emotions are clearly recognizable in ourselves and others. This apparent ease of recognition has led to the identification of a number of emotions that are said to be basic, and universal among all people. However, a debate among experts has questioned this understanding of what emotions are. There has been recent discussion of the progression on the different views of emotion over the years.^[5]

On "basic emotion" accounts, activation of an emotion, such as anger, sadness, or fear, is "triggered" by the brain's appraisal of a stimulus or event with respect to the perceiver's goals or survival. In particular, the function, expression, and meaning of different emotions are hypothesized to be biologically distinct from one another. A theme common to many basic emotions theories is that there should be functional signatures that distinguish different emotions: we should be able to tell what emotion a person is feeling by looking at his or her brain activity and/or physiology. Furthermore, knowledge of what the person is seeing or the larger context of the eliciting event should not be necessary to deduce what the person is feeling from observing the biological signatures.^[6]

On "constructionist" accounts, the emotion a person feels in response to a stimulus or event is "constructed" from more elemental biological and psychological ingredients. Two hypothesized ingredients are "core affect" (characterized by, e.g., hedonic valence and physiological arousal) and conceptual knowledge (such as the semantic meaning of the emotion labels themselves, e.g., the word "anger"). A theme common to many constructionist theories is that different emotions do not have specific locations in the nervous system or distinct physiological signatures, and that context is central to the emotion a person feels because of the accessibility of different concepts afforded by different contexts.^[7]

Dimensional models of emotion

For both theoretical and practical reasons, researchers define emotions according to one or more dimensions. In his philosophical treatise, The Passions of the Soul, Descartes defines and investigates the six primary passions (Wonder, love, hate, desire, joy, and sadness). In 1897, Wilhelm Max Wundt, the father of modern psychology, proposed that emotions can be described by three dimensions: "pleasurable versus unpleasurable", "arousing or subduing", and "strain or relaxation".^[8] In 1954, Harold Schlosberg named three dimensions of emotion: "pleasantness–unpleasantness", "attention–rejection" and "level of activation".^[9]

Dimensional models of emotion attempt to conceptualize human emotions by defining where they lie in two or three dimensions. Most dimensional models incorporate valence and arousal or intensity dimensions. Dimensional models of emotion suggest that a common and interconnected neurophysiological system is responsible for all affective states.^[10] These models contrast theories of basic emotion, which propose that different emotions arise from separate neural systems. Several dimensional models of emotion have been developed, though there are just a few that remain as the dominant models currently accepted by most. The two-dimensional models that are most prominent are the circumplex model, the vector model, and the Positive Activation – Negative Activation (PANA) model.^[11]

Circumplex model

The circumplex model of emotion was developed by James Russell.^[12] This model suggests that emotions are distributed in a two-dimensional circular space, containing arousal and valence dimensions. Arousal represents the vertical axis and valence represents the horizontal axis, while the center of the circle represents a neutral valence and a medium level of arousal. In this model, emotional states can be represented at any level of valence and arousal, or at a neutral level of one or both of these factors. Circumplex models have been used most commonly to test stimuli of emotion words, emotional facial expressions, and affective states.^[13]

Russell and Lisa Feldman Barrett describe their modified circumplex model as representative of core affect, or the most elementary feelings that are not necessarily directed toward anything. Different prototypical emotional episodes, or clear emotions that are evoked or directed by specific objects, can be plotted on the circumplex, according to their levels of arousal and pleasure.^[14]

Vector model

The vector model of emotion appeared in 1992.^[15] This two-dimensional model consists of vectors that point in two directions, representing a "boomerang" shape. The model assumes that there is always an underlying arousal dimension, and that valence determines the direction in which a particular emotion lies. For example, a positive valence would shift the emotion up the top vector and a negative valence would shift the emotion down the bottom vector. In this model, high arousal states are differentiated by their valence, whereas low arousal states are more neutral and are represented near the meeting point of the vectors. Vector models have been most widely used in the testing of word and picture stimuli.

Positive activation – negative activation (P.A.N.A.) model

The positive activation – negative activation (P.A.N.A.) or "consensual" model of emotion, originally created by Watson and Tellegen in 1985, suggests that positive affect and negative affect are two separate systems. Similar to the vector model, states of higher arousal tend to be defined by their valence, and states of lower arousal tend to be more neutral in terms of valence. In the P.A.N.A. model, the vertical axis represents low to high positive affect and the horizontal axis represents low to high negative affect. The dimensions of valence and arousal lay at a 45-degree rotation over these axes.^[16]

Plutchik's model

Robert Plutchik offers a three-dimensional model that is a hybrid of both basic-complex categories and dimensional theories. It arranges emotions in concentric circles where inner circles are more basic and outer circles more complex. Notably, outer circles are also formed by blending the inner circle emotions. Plutchik's model, as Russell's, emanates from a circumplex representation, where emotional words were plotted based on similarity.^[17] There are numerous emotions, which appear in several intensities and can be combined in various ways to form emotional "dyads".^{[18] [19] [20] [21] [22]}

PAD emotional state model

See main article: PAD emotional state model. The PAD emotional state model is a psychological model developed by Albert Mehrabian and James A. Russell to describe and measure emotional states. PAD uses three numerical dimensions to represent all emotions.^{[23] [24]} The PAD dimensions are Pleasure, Arousal and Dominance.

• The Pleasure-Displeasure Scale measures how pleasant an emotion may be. For instance, both anger and fear are unpleasant emotions, and score high on the displeasure scale. However, joy is a pleasant emotion.
• The Arousal-Nonarousal Scale measures how energized or soporific one feels. It is not the intensity of the emotion—for grief and depression can be low arousal intense feelings. While both anger and rage are unpleasant emotions, rage has a higher intensity or a higher arousal state. However boredom, which is also an unpleasant state, has a low arousal value.
• The Dominance-Submissiveness Scale represents the controlling and dominant nature of the emotion. For instance, while both fear and anger are unpleasant emotions, anger is a dominant emotion, while fear is a submissive emotion.

Criticisms

Cultural considerations

Ethnographic and cross-cultural studies of emotions have shown the variety of ways in which emotions differ with cultures. Because of these differences, many cross-cultural psychologists and anthropologists challenge the idea of universal classifications of emotions altogether. Cultural differences have been observed in the way in which emotions are valued, expressed, and regulated. The social norms for emotions, such as the frequency with or circumstances in which they are expressed, also vary drastically.^{[25] [26]} For example, the demonstration of anger is encouraged by Kaluli people, but condemned by Utku Inuit.^[27]

The largest piece of evidence that disputes the universality of emotions is language. Differences within languages directly correlate to differences in emotion taxonomy. Languages differ in that they categorize emotions based on different components. Some may categorize by event types, whereas others categorize by action readiness. Furthermore, emotion taxonomies vary due to the differing implications emotions have in different languages. That being said, not all English words have equivalents in all other languages and vice versa, indicating that there are words for emotions present in some languages but not in others.^[28] Emotions such as the schadenfreude in German and saudade in Portuguese are commonly expressed in emotions in their respective languages, but lack an English equivalent.

Some languages do not differentiate between emotions that are considered to be the basic emotions in English. For instance, certain African languages have one word for both anger and sadness, and others for shame and fear. There is ethnographic evidence that even challenges the universality of the category "emotions" because certain cultures lack a specific word relating to the English word "emotions".

Lists of emotions

Emotions are categorized into various affects, which correspond to the current situation.^[29] An affect is the range of feeling experienced.^[30] Both positive and negative emotions are needed in our daily lives.^[31] Many theories of emotion have been proposed,^[32] with contrasting views.^[33]

Basic emotions

• William James in 1890 proposed four basic emotions: fear, grief, love, and rage, based on bodily involvement.^[34]
• Paul Ekman identified six basic emotions: anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness and surprise.^[35] Wallace V. Friesen and Phoebe C. Ellsworth worked with him on the same basic structure.^[36] The emotions can be linked to facial expressions. In the 1990s, Ekman proposed an expanded list of basic emotions, including a range of positive and negative emotions that are not all encoded in facial muscles. The newly included emotions are: amusement, contempt, contentment, embarrassment, excitement, guilt, pride in achievement, relief, satisfaction, sensory pleasure, and shame.
• Richard and Bernice Lazarus in 1996 expanded the list to 15 emotions: aesthetic experience, anger, anxiety, compassion, depression, envy, fright, gratitude, guilt, happiness, hope, jealousy, love, pride, relief, sadness, and shame, in the book Passion and Reason.^{[37] [38]}
• Researchers^[39] at University of California, Berkeley identified 27 categories of emotion: admiration, adoration, aesthetic appreciation, amusement, anger, anxiety, awe, awkwardness, boredom, calmness, confusion, craving, disgust, empathic pain, entrancement, excitement, fear, horror, interest, joy, nostalgia, relief, romance, sadness, satisfaction, sexual desire and surprise.^[40] This was based on 2185 short videos intended to elicit a certain emotion. These were then modeled onto a "map" of emotions.^[41]

Contrasting basic emotions

A 2009 review^[42] of theories of emotion identifies and contrasts fundamental emotions according to three key criteria for mental experiences that:

1. have a strongly motivating subjective quality like pleasure or pain;
2. are a response to some event or object that is either real or imagined;
3. motivate particular kinds of behavior.

The combination of these attributes distinguishes emotions from sensations, feelings and moods.

Kind of emotion	Positive emotions	Negative emotions
Related to object properties	Interest, curiosity, enthusiasm	Indifference, habituation, boredom
	Attraction, desire, admiration	Aversion, disgust, revulsion
	Surprise, amusement	Alarm, panic
Future appraisal	Hope, excitement	Fear, anxiety, dread
Event-related	Gratitude, thankfulness	Anger, rage
	Joy, elation, triumph, jubilation	Sorrow, grief
	Patience	Frustration, restlessness
	Contentment	Discontentment, disappointment
Self-appraisal	Humility, modesty	Pride, arrogance
Social	Charity	Avarice, greed, miserliness, envy, jealousy
	Sympathy	Cruelty
Cathected	Love	Hate

Emotion dynamics

Researchers distinguish several emotion dynamics, most commonly how intense (mean level), variable (fluctuations), inert (temporal dependency), instable (magnitude of moment-to-moment fluctuations), or differentiated someone's emotions are (the specificity of granularity of emotions), and whether and how an emotion augments or blunts other emotions.^[43] Meta-analytic reviews show systematic developmental changes in emotion dynamics throughout childhood and adolescence and substantial between-person differences.

HUMAINE's proposal for EARL

The emotion annotation and representation language (EARL) proposed by the Human-Machine Interaction Network on Emotion (HUMAINE) classifies 48 emotions.^[44]

• Negative and forceful
  • Anger
  • Annoyance
  • Contempt
  • Disgust
  • Irritation
• Negative and not in control
  • Anxiety
  • Embarrassment
  • Fear
  • Helplessness
  • Powerlessness
  • Worry
• Negative thoughts
  • Doubt
  • Envy
  • Frustration
  • Guilt
  • Shame
• Negative and passive
  • Boredom
  • Despair
  • Disappointment
  • Hurt
  • Sadness
• Agitation
  • Stress
  • Shock
  • Tension
• Positive and lively
  • Amusement
  • Delight
  • Elation
  • Excitement
  • Happiness
  • Joy
  • Pleasure
• Caring
  • Affection
  • Empathy
  • Friendliness
  • Love
• Positive thoughts
  • Pride
  • Courage
  • Hope
  • Humility
  • Satisfaction
  • Trust
• Quiet positive
  • Calmness
  • Contentment
  • Relaxation
  • Relief
  • Serenity
• Reactive
  • Interest
  • Politeness
  • Surprise

Parrott's emotions by groups

A tree-structured list of emotions was described in Shaver et al. (1987),^[45] and also featured in Parrott (2001).^[46]

Primary emotion	Secondary emotion	Tertiary emotion
Love	Affection	AdorationFondnessLikingAttractionCaringTendernessCompassionSentimentality
	Lust/Sexual desire	DesirePassionInfatuation
	Longing	Longing
Joy	Cheerfulness	AmusementBlissGaietyGleeJollinessJovialityJoyDelightEnjoymentGladnessHappinessJubilationElationSatisfactionEcstasyEuphoria
	Zest	EnthusiasmZealExcitementThrillExhilaration
	Contentment	Pleasure
	Pride	Triumph
	Optimism	EagernessHope
	Enthrallment	EnthrallmentRapture
	Relief	Relief
Surprise	Surprise	AmazementAstonishment
Anger	Irritability	AggravationAgitationAnnoyanceGrouchyGrumpyCrosspatch
	Exasperation	Frustration
	Rage	AngerOutrageFuryWrathHostilityFerocityBitternessHatredScornSpiteVengefulnessDislikeResentment
	Disgust	RevulsionContemptLoathing
	Envy	Jealousy
	Torment	Torment
Sadness	Suffering	AgonyAnguishHurt
	Sadness	DepressionDespairGloomGlumnessUnhappinessGriefSorrowWoeMiseryMelancholy
	Disappointment	DismayDispleasure
	Shame	GuiltRegretRemorse
	Neglect	AlienationDefeatismDejectionEmbarrassmentHomesicknessHumiliationInsecurityInsultIsolationLonelinessRejection
	Sympathy	PityMono no awareSympathy
Fear	Horror	AlarmShockFearFrightHorrorTerrorPanicHysteriaMortification
	Nervousness	AnxietySuspenseUneasinessApprehension (fear)WorryDistressDread

Plutchik's wheel of emotions

In 1980, Robert Plutchik diagrammed a wheel of eight emotions: joy, trust, fear, surprise, sadness, disgust, anger and anticipation, inspired by his Ten Postulates.^{[47] [48]} Plutchik also theorized twenty-four "Primary", "Secondary", and "Tertiary" dyads (feelings composed of two emotions).^{[49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55]} The wheel emotions can be paired in four groups:

Primary dyad = one petal apart = Love = Joy + Trust

Secondary dyad = two petals apart = Envy = Sadness + Anger

Tertiary dyad = three petals apart = Shame = Fear + Disgust

Opposite emotions = four petals apart = Anticipation ∉ Surprise

There are also triads, emotions formed from 3 primary emotions, though Plutchik never describes in any detail what the triads might be.^[56] This leads to a combination of 24 dyads and 32 triads, making 56 emotions at 1 intensity level.^[57] Emotions can be mild or intense;^[58] for example, distraction is a mild form of surprise, and rage is an intense form of anger. The kinds of relation between each pair of emotions are:

Emotions and opposites!Mild emotion!Mild opposite!Basic emotion!Basic opposite!Intense emotion!Intense opposite

Serenity	Pensiveness, Gloominess	Joy, Cheerfulness	Sadness, Dejection	Ecstasy, Elation	Grief, Sorrow
Acceptance, Tolerance	Boredom, Dislike	Trust	Disgust, Aversion	Admiration, Adoration	Loathing, Revulsion
Apprehension, Dismay	Annoyance, Irritation	Fear, Fright	Anger, Hostility	Terror, Panic	Rage, Fury
Distraction, Uncertainty	Interest, Attentiveness	Surprise	Anticipation, Expectancy	Amazement, Astonishment	Vigilance

Dyads (Combinations)!Human feelings!Emotions!Opposite feelings!Emotions

Optimism, Courage	Anticipation + Joy	Disapproval, Disappointment	Surprise + Sadness
Hope, Fatalism	Anticipation + Trust	Unbelief, Shock	Surprise + Disgust
Anxiety, Dread	Anticipation + Fear	Outrage, Hate	Surprise + Anger
Love, Friendliness	Joy + Trust	Remorse, Misery	Sadness + Disgust
Guilt, Excitement	Joy + Fear	Envy, Sullenness	Sadness + Anger
Delight, Doom	Joy + Surprise	Pessimism	Sadness + Anticipation
Submission, Modesty	Trust + Fear	Contempt, Scorn	Disgust + Anger
Curiosity	Trust + Surprise	Cynicism	Disgust + Anticipation
Sentimentality, Resignation	Trust + Sadness	Morbidness, Derisiveness	Disgust + Joy
Awe, Alarm	Fear + Surprise	Aggressiveness, Vengeance	Anger + Anticipation
Despair	Fear + Sadness	Pride, Victory	Anger + Joy
Shame, Prudishness	Fear + Disgust	Dominance	Anger + Trust

Opposite combinations!Human feelings!Emotions

Bittersweetness	Joy + Sadness
Ambivalence	Trust + Disgust
Frozenness	Fear + Anger
Confusion	Surprise + Anticipation

Similar emotions in the wheel are adjacent to each other.^[59] Anger, Anticipation, Joy, and Trust are positive in valence, while Fear, Surprise, Sadness, and Disgust are negative in valence. Anger is classified as a "positive" emotion because it involves "moving toward" a goal,^[60] while surprise is negative because it is a violation of someone's territory.^[61] The emotion dyads each have half-opposites and exact opposites:^[62]

Anticipation, Joy, Surprise, Sadness!+!Sadness!Joy

Anticipation	Pessimism	Optimism
Surprise	Disapproval	Delight

Joy, Trust, Sadness, Disgust!+!Disgust!Trust

Joy	Morbidness	Love
Sadness	Remorse	Sentimentality

Trust, Fear, Disgust, Anger!+!Fear!Anger

Trust	Submission	Dominance
Disgust	Shame	Contempt

Fear, Surprise, Anger, Anticipation!+!Surprise!Anticipation

Anger	Outrage	Aggressiveness
Fear	Awe	Anxiety

Trust, Surprise, Disgust, Anticipation!+!Surprise!Anticipation

Trust	Curiosity	Hope
Disgust	Unbelief	Cynicism

Joy, Fear, Sadness, Anger!+!Fear!Anger

Joy	Guilt	Pride
Sadness	Despair	Envy

Six emotion axes

MIT researchers published a paper titled "An Affective Model of Interplay Between Emotions and Learning: Reengineering Educational Pedagogy—Building a Learning Companion" that lists six axes of emotions with different opposite emotions, and different emotions coming from ranges.^[63]

Emotional flow!Axis!-1.0!-0.5!0!0!+0.5!+1.0

Anxiety – Confidence	Anxiety	Worry	Discomfort	Comfort	Hopeful	Confident
Boredom – Fascination	Ennui	Boredom	Indifference	Interest	Curiosity	Intrigue
Frustration – Euphoria	Frustration	Puzzlement	Confusion	Insight	Enlightenment	Epiphany
Dispirited – Encouraged	Dispirited	Disappointed	Dissatisfied	Satisfied	Thrilled	Enthusiastic
Terror – Enchantment	Terror	Dread	Apprehension	Calm	Anticipatory	Excited
Humiliation – Pride	Humiliated	Embarrassed	Self-conscious	Pleased	Satisfied	Proud

They also made a model labeling phases of learning emotions.

	Negative Affect	Positive Affect
Constructive Learning	Disappointment, Puzzlement, Confusion	Awe, Satisfaction, Curiosity
Un-learning	Frustration, Discard, Misconceptions	Hopefulness, Fresh research

The Book of Human Emotions

Tiffany Watt Smith listed 154 different worldwide emotions and feelings.^[64]

• A
  • Abhiman
  • Acedia
  • Amae
  • Ambiguphobia
  • Anger
  • Anticipation
  • Anxiety
  • Apathy
  • L’appel du vide
  • Awumbuk
• B
  • Bafflement
  • Basorexia
  • Befuddlement
    • • Bewilderment Boredom
  • Brabant
    • Broodiness C
  • Calm
  • Carefree
  • Cheerfulness
  • Cheesed (off)
    • • Claustrophobia Collywobbles, the
  • Comfort
  • Compassion
  • Compersion
  • Confidence
  • Contempt
  • Contentment
  • Courage
  • Curiosity
  • Cyberchondria
• D
  • Delight
  • Dépaysement
  • Desire
  • Despair
  • Disappear, the desire to
  • Disappointment
  • Disgruntlement
  • Disgust
  • Dismay
  • Dolce far niente
  • Dread
• E
  • Ecstasy
  • Embarrassment
    • • Empathy Envy
  • Euphoria
  • Exasperation
  • Excitement
• F
  • Fago
  • Fear
  • Feeling good (about yourself)
  • Formal feeling, a
  • Fraud, feeling like a
  • Frustration
• G
  • Gezelligheid
    • • Gladsomeness Glee
  • Gratitude
  • Greng jai
  • Grief
  • Guilt
• H
  • Han
  • Happiness
  • Hatred
  • Heebie-Jeebies, the
  • Hiraeth
  • Hoard, the urge to
  • Homefulness
  • Homesickness
  • Hopefulness
  • Huff, in a
  • Humble, feeling
  • Humiliation
  • Hunger
  • Hwyl
• I
  • Ijirashi
  • Ikstuarpok
  • Ilinx
  • Impatience
  • Indignation
  • Inhabitiveness
  • Insulted, feeling
  • Irritation
• J
  • Jealousy
  • Joy
• K
  • Kaukokaipuu
• L
  • Liget^[65]
  • Litost
  • Loneliness
  • Love
• M
  • Malu
  • Man
  • Matutolypea
  • Mehameha
  • Melancholy
  • Miffed, a bit
  • Mono no aware
  • Morbid curiosity
  • Mudita
• N
  • Nakhes
  • Nginyiwarrarringu
  • Nostalgia
• O
  • Oime
  • Overwhelmed, feeling
• P
  • Panic
  • Paranoia
  • Perversity
  • Peur des espaces
  • Philoprogenitiveness
  • Pique, a fit of
  • Pity
  • Postal, going
  • Pride
  • Pronoia
• R
  • Rage
  • Regret
  • Relief
    • • Reluctance Remorse
  • Reproachfulness
  • Resentment
  • Ringxiety
  • Rivalry
  • Road rage
  • Ruinenlust
• S
  • Sadness
  • Satisfaction
  • Saudade
  • Schadenfreude
  • Self-pity
  • Shame
  • Shock
  • Smugness
  • Song
  • Surprise
  • Suspicion
• T
  • Technostress
  • Terror
  • Torschlusspanik
  • Toska
  • Triumph
• U
  • Umpty
  • Uncertainty
• V
  • Vengefulness
  • Vergüenza ajena
  • Viraha
  • Vulnerability
• W
  • • • Wanderlust Warm glow
  • Wonder
  • Worry
• Z
  • Żal

Mapping facial expressions

Scientists map twenty-one different facial emotions^{[66] [67]} expanded from Paul Ekman's six basic emotions of anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, and surprise:

	Fearful	Angry	Surprised	Disgusted
Happy				Happily Surprised	Happily Disgusted
Sad		Sadly Fearful	Sadly Angry	Sadly Surprised	Sadly Disgusted
Appalled			Fearfully Angry	Fearfully Surprised	Fearfully Disgusted
Awed				Angrily Surprised	Angrily Disgusted
Hatred					Disgustedly Surprised

See also

• Aesthetic emotions
• Affect measures
• Affective neuroscience
• Alexithymia
• Emotion and memory
• Emotional granularity
• List of virtues
• Mood (psychology)
• Moral emotions
• Social emotions
• Unipolar emotions

Bibliography

• Ekman, P. (1972). Universals and cultural differences in facial expression of emotion. In J. Cole (Ed.), Nebraska Symposium on Motivation. Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press: pp. 207–283.
• 10.1080/02699939208411068 . Ekman . P. . 1992 . An argument for basic emotions . Cognition and Emotion . 6 . 3. 169–200 . 10.1.1.454.1984 .
• Ekman, P. (1999). Basic Emotions. In T. Dalgleish and T. Power (Eds.) The Handbook of Cognition and Emotion Pp. 45–60. Sussex, U.K.: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
• 10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.02024.x . Fontaine . J. . Scherer . 2007 . KR . Roesch . EB . Ellsworth . PC . The world of emotions is not two-dimensional . Psychological Science . 18 . 12. 1050–1057 . 18031411 . 10.1.1.1031.3706 . 1779061 .
• 10.1016/j.plrev.2015.03.001 . Koelsch . S. . Jacobs . AM. . Menninghaus . W. . Liebal . K. . Klann-Delius . G. . von Scheve . C. . Gebauer . G. . 2015 . The quartet theory of human emotions: An integrative and neurofunctional model. . Phys Life Rev . 13. 1–27 . 25891321. 2015PhLRv..13....1K .
• Prinz, J. (2004). Gut Reactions: A Perceptual Theory of Emotions. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
• Sugu . Dana . Chaterjee . Amita . 2010 . Flashback: Reshuffling Emotions . International Journal on Humanistic Ideology . 3 . 1 . 2010-11-11 . 2011-04-30 . https://web.archive.org/web/20110430041037/https://sites.google.com/site/sugudana/articles-1 . dead .
• 10.1037/0022-3514.37.3.345 . Russell . J.A. . 17557962 . 1979 . Affective space is bipolar . . 37 . 3. 345–356 .
• Russell . J.A. . Culture and the categorization of emotions . . 110 . 3 . 426–50 . 1991 . 1758918 . 15 December 2015 . 10.1037/0033-2909.110.3.426 . https://web.archive.org/web/20160304190605/https://www2.bc.edu/~russeljm/publications/psyc-bull1991.pdf . 2016-03-04 . dead .

Notes and References

1. Colombetti. Giovanna. From affect programs to dynamical discrete emotions. Philosophical Psychology. August 2009. 22 . 4. 407–425. 10.1080/09515080903153600. 10.1.1.728.9666. 40157414.
2. Ekman. Paul. Facial Expressions of Emotion: New Findings, New Questions. Psychological Science. January 1992. 3 . 1. 34–38. 10.1111/j.1467-9280.1992.tb00253.x. 9274447.
3. Bąk . Halszka . 2023-12-01 . Issues in the translation equivalence of basic emotion terms . Ampersand . 11 . 100128 . 10.1016/j.amper.2023.100128 . 2215-0390. free .
4. Elfenbein . Hillary Anger . Ambady . Nalini . 2003-10-01 . Universals and Cultural Differences in Recognizing Emotions . Current Directions in Psychological Science . en . 12 . 5 . 159–164 . 10.1111/1467-8721.01252 . 262438746 . 0963-7214.
5. Gendron. Maria. Barrett. Lisa Feldman. Reconstructing the Past: A Century of Ideas About Emotion in Psychology. Emotion Review. October 2009. 1. 4. 316–339. 10.1177/1754073909338877. 20221412. 2835158.
6. Ekman. Paul. An Argument for Basic Emotions. Cognition and Emotion. 1992. 6. 3/4. 169–200. 10.1080/02699939208411068. 10.1.1.454.1984.
7. Barrett. Lisa Feldman. Solving the Emotion Paradox: Categorization and the Experience of Emotion. Personality and Social Psychology Review. 2006. 10. 1. 20–46. 10.1207/s15327957pspr1001_2. 16430327. 7750265.
8. W.M. Wundt, Outlines of Psychology. (1897). In: Classics in the history of psychology. http://psychclassics.asu.edu/index.htm, York University 2010, Toronto.
9. Schlosberg . H. . 27914497 . 1954 . Three dimensions of emotion . . 61 . 2. 81–8 . 10.1037/h0054570. 13155714 .
10. Posner. Jonathan . Russell, J.A. . Peterson, B. S.. The circumplex model of affect: An integrative approach to affective neuroscience, cognitive development, and psychopathology. Development and Psychopathology. 2005. 17. 3 . 715–734. 10.1017/s0954579405050340. 16262989. 2367156.
11. Rubin. D. C.. Talerico, J.M.. A comparison of dimensional models of emotion. Memory. 2009. 17. 8. 802–808. 10.1080/09658210903130764. 19691001. 2784275.
12. Russell. James. A circumplex model of affect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1980. 39. 6. 1161–1178. 10.1037/h0077714. 10983/22919. free.
13. Remington. N. A.. Fabrigar, L. R. . Visser, P. S. . Re-examining the circumplex model of affect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2000. 79. 2. 286–300. 10.1037/0022-3514.79.2.286. 10948981.
14. Russell. James. Feldman Barrett, Lisa. Core affect, prototypical emotional episodes, and other things called emotion: dissecting the elephant. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1999. 76. 5. 805–819. 10.1037/0022-3514.76.5.805. 10353204.
15. Bradley. M. M.. Greenwald, M. K. . Petry, M.C. . Lang, P. J. . Remembering pictures: Pleasure and arousal in memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition. 1992. 18. 2. 379–390. 10.1037/0278-7393.18.2.379 . 1532823.
16. Watson. D.. Tellegen, A.. Toward a consensual structure of mood. Psychological Bulletin. 1985. 98. 2. 219–235. 10.1037/0033-2909.98.2.219. 3901060.
17. News: The Nature of Emotions . https://web.archive.org/web/20010716082847/http://americanscientist.org/articles/01articles/Plutchik.html . July 16, 2001 . American Scientist . Plutchik . R . Robert Plutchik . 14 April 2011 . unfit .
18. Book: Plutchik, Robert. The Emotions. 16 September 1991. University Press of America. 16 September 2017. Google Books. 110. 9780819182869.
19. News: The Nature of Emotions . American Scientist . Plutchik . R . Robert Plutchik . 14 April 2011 . unfit . https://web.archive.org/web/20010716082847/http://americanscientist.org/articles/01articles/Plutchik.html . July 16, 2001 .
20. Web site: Robert Plutchik's Psychoevolutionary Theory of Basic Emotions . Adliterate.com . 2017-06-05.
21. Book: Jonathan Turner. On the Origins of Human Emotions: A Sociological Inquiry Into the Evolution of Human Affect. 1 June 2000. Stanford University Press. 978-0-8047-6436-0. 76.
22. A Fuzzy Inference System for Synergy Estimation of Simultaneous Emotion Dynamics in Agents. International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research. 2. 6. June 2011. Atifa Athar. M. Saleem Khan. Khalil Ahmed. Aiesha Ahmed. Nida Anwar.
23. Book: Mehrabian, Albert . Basic dimensions for a general psychological theory . 1980 . 978-0-89946-004-8 . 39–53 . Oelgeschlager, Gunn & Hain . registration .
24. Book: Bales, Robert Freed . Social interaction systems: theory and measurement . 2001 . 978-0-7658-0872-1 . 139–140 . Transaction Publishers .
25. Mesquita. Batja. Nico Frijda. Cultural variations in emotions: a review. Psychological Bulletin. September 1992. 112. 2. 179–204. 10.1037/0033-2909.112.2.179. 1454891.
26. Russell. James. Culture and Categorization of Emotions. Psychological Bulletin. 1991. 110. 3. 426–450. 15 December 2015. 10.1037/0033-2909.110.3.426. 1758918. https://web.archive.org/web/20160304190605/https://www2.bc.edu/~russeljm/publications/psyc-bull1991.pdf. 2016-03-04. dead.
27. Eid. Michael. Ed Diener. Norms for experiencing emotions in different cultures: Inter- and intranational differences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. November 2001. 81. 5. 869–885. 10.1037/0022-3514.81.5.869 . 11708563.
28. Wierzbicka. Anna. Human Emotions: Universal or Culture-Specific?. American Anthropologist. September 1986. 88. 3. 584–594. 10.1525/aa.1986.88.3.02a00030. 679478.
29. Solving the Emotion Paradox : Categorization and the Experience of Emotion. Lisa Feldman Barrett. Personality and Social Psychology Review. 2006. 10. 1. 20–46. 7750265. 10.1207/s15327957pspr1001_2. 16430327.
30. Web site: Emotions and Moods. Catalogue.pearsoned.co.uk. 20 October 2017. 8 January 2020. https://web.archive.org/web/20200108054918/http://catalogue.pearsoned.co.uk/samplechapter/0132431564.pdf. dead.
31. Book: Parrott, W. Gerrod. The Positive Side of Negative Emotions. 27 January 2014. Guilford Publications. 9781462513338. 19 December 2018. Google Books.
32. Comparing The 5 Theories of Emotion – Brain Blogger. Mind. 1884. os-IX. 34. 188–205. 10.1093/mind/os-IX.34.188. 23 November 2017.
33. Book: Candland, Douglas. Emotion. 23 November 2017. iUniverse. 9780595270262. 23 November 2017. Google Books.
34. Book: James, William. The Principles of Psychology. 1 April 2007. Cosimo, Inc.. 9781602063136. 20 October 2017. Google Books.
35. Web site: Classification of Emotions. Handel. Steven. 2011-05-24. 30 April 2012.
36. Web site: Are There Basic Emotions?. Paulekam.com. 20 October 2017.
37. Book: Passion and Reason: Making Sense of Our Emotions. Lazarus. Richard S.. Lazarus. Bernice N.. 23 September 1996. Oxford University Press. 9780195104615. 23 September 2017. Google Books.
38. Web site: Emotional Competency – Recognize these emotions. Emotionalcompetency.com. 23 September 2017.
39. Self-report captures 27 distinct categories of emotion bridged by continuous gradients. Cowen. Alan S.. Keltner. Dacher. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2017. 114. 38. E7900–E7909. 10.1073/pnas.1702247114. 28874542. 5617253. 2017PNAS..114E7900C . free.
40. Web site: Psychologists Identify Twenty Seven Distinct Categories of Emotion – Psychology. Sci-news.com. 23 November 2017.
41. Web site: The Emotions Evoked by Video. 2017-09-11.
42. Web site: Brain function, mental experience and personality. Robinson, D. L.. 2009. The Netherlands Journal of Psychology. 152–167. 64.
43. Reitsema, A.M. . 2022 . Emotion dynamics in children and adolescents: A meta-analytic and descriptive review . Emotion . 22 . 2 . 374–396 . 10.1037/emo0000970 . 34843305 . 244748515.
44. Web site: HUMAINE Emotion Annotation and Representation Language. Emotion-research.net. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20080411092724/http://emotion-research.net/projects/humaine/earl. April 11, 2008. June 30, 2006.
45. Shaver, P.. Schwartz, J.. Kirson, D.. O'connor, C.. 1987. Emotion knowledge: further exploration of a prototype approach. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 52. 6. 1061–86. 10.1037/0022-3514.52.6.1061. 3598857.
46. Book: Emotions in Social Psychology. Parrott, W.. Psychology Press. 2001. 978-0863776830. Key Readings in Social Psychology. Philadelphia.
47. Web site: Basic Emotions—Plutchik. Personalityresearch.org. 1 September 2017.
48. News: The Nature of Emotions. Plutchik. R. 14 April 2011. unfit. https://web.archive.org/web/20010716082847/http://americanscientist.org/articles/01articles/Plutchik.html. July 16, 2001. American Scientist. Robert Plutchik.
49. Web site: Robert Plutchik's Psychoevolutionary Theory of Basic Emotions. Adliterate.com. 2017-06-05.
50. Book: On the Origins of Human Emotions: A Sociological Inquiry Into the Evolution of Human Affect. Jonathan Turner. 1 June 2000. Stanford University Press. 978-0-8047-6436-0. 76.
51. Atifa Athar. M. Saleem Khan. Khalil Ahmed. Aiesha Ahmed. Nida Anwar. June 2011. A Fuzzy Inference System for Synergy Estimation of Simultaneous Emotion Dynamics in Agents. International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research. 2. 6.
52. Book: TenHouten, Warren D.. Alienation and Affect. 1 December 2016. Taylor & Francis. 9781317678533. 25 June 2019. Google Books.
53. Book: Entertainment Computing - ICEC 2015: 14th International Conference, ICEC 2015, Trondheim, Norway, September 29 - October 2, 2015, Proceedings. Chorianopoulos. Konstantinos. Divitini. Monica. Hauge. Jannicke Baalsrud. Jaccheri. Letizia. Malaka. Rainer. 24 September 2015. Springer. 9783319245898. 25 June 2019. Google Books.
54. Book: Plutchik, Robert. The Emotions. 25 June 1991. University Press of America. 9780819182869. 25 June 2019. Google Books.
55. Book: O'Shaughnessy, John. Consumer Behaviour: Perspectives, Findings and Explanations. 4 December 2012. Macmillan International Higher Education. 9781137003782. 25 June 2019. Google Books.
56. Book: Plutchik, Robert. The Emotions. 31 December 1991. University Press of America. 9780819182869. 31 December 2018. Google Books.
57. Book: Izard, Carroll Ellis. The face of emotion. 31 December 1971. Appleton-Century-Crofts. 9780390478313. Google Books. 31 December 2018.
58. Web site: The Nature of Emotions. Emotionalcompetency.com. 2017-09-16.
59. Book: Plutchik, Robert. The Emotions. 16 September 1991. University Press of America. 9780819182869. 110. 16 September 2017. Google Books.
60. Book: TenHouten, Warren D.. Emotion and Reason: Mind, Brain, and the Social Domains of Work and Love. 23 June 2014. Routledge. 9781317580614. Google Books. 10 December 2019.
61. Book: TenHouten, Warren D.. A General Theory of Emotions and Social Life. 22 November 2006. Routledge. 9781134229079. Google Books. 10 December 2019.
62. Book: TenHouten, Warren D.. A General Theory of Emotions and Social Life. 22 November 2006. Routledge. 9781134229086. Google Books. 10 December 2019.
63. Book: Proceedings IEEE International Conference on Advanced Learning Technologies. Kort. B.. Reilly. R.. Picard. R.W.. 2001. 0-7695-1013-2. 43–46. An affective model of interplay between emotions and learning: Reengineering educational pedagogy-building a learning companion. 10.1109/ICALT.2001.943850. 9573470. https://www.academia.edu/568626. Academia.edu.
64. Web site: The Book of Human Emotions: An Encyclopedia of Feeling from Anger to Wanderlust . Tiffany Watt Smith . Anarchiveforemotions.com . 2017-05-28 . https://web.archive.org/web/20210418032350/http://anarchiveforemotions.com/files/DisOrder_uploads/images/TheBookOfHumanEmotions.pdf . 18 April 2021 . dead.
65. News: Invisibilia: A Man Finds An Explosive Emotion Locked In A Word. NPR.org. 2017-12-29.
66. News: 31 March 2014 . Happily disgusted? Scientists map facial expressions for 21 emotions . The Guardian .
67. Web site: Jacque Wilson . 2014-04-04 . Happily disgusted? 15 new emotions ID'd . 2017-07-16 . KSL.com.