Eastman memos explained

Attempts to overturn the 2020 United States presidential election
Date:November 4, 2020[1] – January 7, 2021[2]
Place:Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Washington, D.C.
Causes:Fabricated claims of electoral fraud[3] [4] [5]
Result:Failure to overturn election; Joe Biden inaugurated January 20, 2021

The Eastman memos, also known as the "coup memo",[6] [7] are documents by John Eastman, an American law professor retained by then-President Donald Trump advancing the fringe legal theory that a U.S. Vice President has unilateral authority to reject certified state electors. This would have the effect of nullifying an election in order to produce an outcome personally desired by the Vice President, such as a result in the Vice President's own party's favor, including retaining himself as Vice President, or if the Vice President is himself the presidential candidate, then to unilaterally make himself president.

Trump and Eastman used the memos in an unsuccessful campaign to pressure then-vice president Mike Pence into preventing or nullifying the 2021 United States Electoral College vote count, and eventually overturning the 2020 United States election of Joe Biden, so that Trump could retain power.

The Trump campaign engaged Eastman with a formal retainer agreement signed December 5 for services in litigating the election outcome.[8] [9] The memos have been described as an instruction manual for a coup d'état.

Overview

After the 2020 United States presidential election in which Joe Biden prevailed, then-incumbent Donald Trump, as well as his campaign, his proxies, and many of his supporters, pursued an aggressive and unprecedented effort[10] [11] to deny and overturn the election[12] by means of a legalistic soft coup (or self-coup).

In late December 2020, Trump and some of his supporters, such as former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn, began to promote the idea of the Pence Card, a legal theory by which then-Vice President Mike Pence had unilateral authority to reject electoral votes from states deemed to be fraudulent.[13] [14] [15] The theory originated with a two-page proposal tweeted to Trump by Flynn associate Ivan Raiklin on December 22.[16]

In that context, John C. Eastman tried to convince then-Vice President Mike Pence that he could overturn the election results on January 6, 2021 (when Congress counted the Electoral College votes) by throwing out electors from "7 states"presumably Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, along with either New Mexico or the federal district Washington, D.C. Slates of electors declaring Trump the winner were submitted from the seven states, but the National Archives did not accept the unsanctioned documents and they did not explicitly enter the deliberations.[17] [18] [19] Under Eastman's scheme, Pence would have declared Trump the winner with more Electoral College votes after the seven states were thrown out, at 232 votes to 222.[20] [21]

According to a news report in The Washington Post on October 23, 2021, the Willard Hotel was a "command center" for the White House plot, that included Eastman, to overturn the results of the 2020 election. According to The Guardian, Eastman was part of a legal team at the Willard that Trump called the night before the January 6 attack on the Capitol and asked them to find ways to stop Biden's certification the next day.[22] Further related details of the effort to deny and overturn the election have been reported,[23] [24] [25] [26] [27] including a meeting between election deniers and Trump administration official Robert Destro at the State Department on January 6.[28] Also, in October 2021, Richard Painter said that the former president could be blocked from running again in 2024, due to his activities associated with the January 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol.[29]

The memos are undated. The first memo was prepared in late 2020 following a December 24, 2020 request by a Trump aide.[30] The second and longer memo was likely prepared in early 2021 as it cites a December 31, 2020 court filing.

First memorandum

The first memo described the constitutional and statutory process for opening and counting of electoral votes under the Twelfth Amendment and Electoral Count Act, alleging that the Electoral Count Act was unconstitutional. The memo further claimed that the Vice President, who also serves as President of the Senate and presides over the joint session of Congress, "does the counting, including the resolution of disputed electoral votes... and all the Members of Congress can do is watch." The memo refers to the actions of John Adams and Thomas Jefferson during the presidential elections of 1796 and 1800 as evidence for this claim; some supporters of President Trump, such as Congressman Louie Gohmert, had falsely claimed that Jefferson's counting of Georgia's electoral votes in 1800 indicated that the Vice President could unilaterally accept or reject electoral votes.[31]

The memo then laid out a six-step plan for Pence to overturn Biden's election:[32]

Second memorandum

The second memo laid out a more extensive plan with multiple scenarios for Pence to take to overturn Biden's election:[33] The first section outlined alleged illegal conduct by election officials in six states (Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin). The second section again alleged that the Electoral Count Act was unconstitutional, and that Pence had the power to unilaterally accept or reject electoral votes. The third section referred to "7 states" and outlined various alternatives for Pence to take to overturn Biden's election:

Rejection by Vice President Pence

Gregory Jacob, chief legal counsel to then-Vice President Pence, wrote a memo on December 8, 2020 to the vice-president regarding the January 6 Process for Elector Vote Count, outlining the constitutional issues at stake in the Twelfth Amendment and the Electoral Count Act of 1887.[34]

The Jacob memo provided a basis for Vice President Mike Pence's deferral on January 6 to the U.S. Constitution and to the States, in opposition to the direct request from a sitting president.[8]

Jacob's memo accepted a key legal claim made by Eastman, that there was a precedent set by Jefferson (and possibly Adams) for a vice president to choose which electoral college votes to count. The claim originated in a series of articles by Bruce Ackerman that then-Vice President Thomas Jefferson had in 1800 counted electoral college votes that he should not have done. By implication, this raised the notion that choosing which votes to count was an inherent right of the vice president under the Constitution. Ackerman first put this theory forward, with David Fontana, in 2004.[35] He repeated it in 2020 in a op-ed for the Los Angeles Times that was widely shared that fall.[36]

On December 31, 2020, Ackerman's claim was debunked in an article published on the Backbencher, then republished in the Washington Monthly on January 5, 2021.[37] [31] Another published article further debunked Eastman and Ackerman's claim that Vice Presidents had the right to choose which electoral college votes to count.[38]

On January 5, 2021, J. Michael Luttig tweeted a response to Holly Brewer, the article writer and legal historian at the University of Maryland. Luttig reaffirmed Brewer's historical scholarship and attributed its influence to the January 5, 2021 political and constitutional history.[39]

The Trump administration's Attorney General William Barr rejected the legal theory presented in the Eastman memos, submitting his resignation on December 14.[40] In an interview, Barr stated that Eastman's claim that Pence could change things was "crazy," but that "there's nothing inherently wrong with naming an alternative slate of electors".[41]

Further legal analysis

On September 27, 2021, Laurence Tribe, American legal scholar and University Professor Emeritus of constitutional law at Harvard University, and colleagues, fully described the legal background of the attempt to overturn the 2020 election, as well as possible ways of averting the use of such a legal strategy or similar approach in the future.[42]

The Eastman memos have been described as an instruction manual for a coup d'état.[43] [44] [45] [46]

Disciplinary action

In October 2021, serious complaints that could lead to disbarment were officially submitted against Eastman and related attorney Jeffrey Clark regarding their conduct in attempting to overturn the 2020 election.[47] [48] In March 2022, the State Bar of California confirmed that it had been investigating Eastman since September 2021.[49] Also in March 2022, Reuters reported that two U.S. Justice Department officials, Jeffrey A. Rosen and Richard Donoghue, had cooperated with the D.C. Bar's Office of Disciplinary Counsel in its investigation of Jeffrey Clark's possible misconduct in his alleged efforts to help Trump overturn the results of the 2020 election.[50]

Electoral Count Reform of 2022

See main article: Electoral Count Reform and Presidential Transition Improvement Act of 2022. In December 2022 president Biden signed into law the Electoral Count Reform and Presidential Transition Improvement Act of 2022, which clarified that the Vice President's role in the counting of the electoral votes is "solely ministerial," with no power to "determine, accept, reject, or otherwise adjudicate or resolve disputes over the proper list of electors, the validity of electors, or the votes of electors". Also, the bill states that any objection made by a senator or representative during the counting of the electoral votes must be made in writing and signed by at least one-fifth of the Senators and one-fifth of the Members of the House of Representatives. Previously, an objection required the signatures of only one member of each chamber.

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. News: Chalfant . Morgan . Samuels . Brett . Trump prematurely declares victory, says he'll go to Supreme Court . 18 June 2021 . . 4 November 2020.
  2. Web site: Liptak . Kevin . Stracqualursi . Veronica . Malloy . Allie . Trump publicly acknowledges he won't serve a second term a day after inciting mob . . 13 May 2021 . 7 January 2021.
  3. Web site: Fact Check: Trump Fabricates Election Corruption. Calvin . Woodward . Maryclaire . Dale . November 6, 2020 .
  4. News: Trump's False Election Fraud Claims Split Republicans . Michael . Crowley . . November 6, 2020 . November 6, 2020 . November 16, 2020 . https://web.archive.org/web/20201116035304/https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/06/us/politics/trump-election-republicans.html . live.
  5. Web site: Dozens of claims about election fraud, debunked . November 20, 2020 . . Daniel . Funke . . 12 May 2024 .
  6. News: Bort . Ryan . 2022-06-16 . 'Coup Memo' Author Knew About Secret Supreme Court Election Tension ... Somehow . en-US . 2022-06-17.
  7. News: 2022-06-16 . 'Coup memo' author asked for pardon and lobbied VP to overturn election after riot . en . The Independent . Gustaf . Kilander . 2022-06-17.
  8. Web site: Inside Pence-world's preparation for a Jan. 6 legal showdown . 2022-06-10 . . March 30, 2022 . en . Betsy Woodruff . Swan . Kyle . Cheney.
  9. Web site: Trump . Donald J. . Crate . Bradley T. . Eastman . John Charles . Re: Engagement Letter for Legal Services . New York City . Donald J. Trump for President, Inc. . courtlistener.com . December 5, 2020 . 12 May 2024 .
  10. Web site: Anita . Kumar . Gabby . Orr . Inside Trump's pressure campaign to overturn the election . Politico . December 21, 2020 . Trump's efforts to cling to power are unprecedented in American history. While political parties have fought over the results of presidential elections before, no incumbent president has ever made such expansive and individualized pleas to the officials who oversee certification of the election results. . 12 May 2024 .
  11. Web site: David E. . Sanger . Trump's Attempts to Overturn the Election Are Unparalleled in U.S. History . The New York Times . November 19, 2020 . President Trump's attempts to overturn the 2020 election are unprecedented in American history and an even more audacious use of brute political force to gain the White House than when Congress gave Rutherford B. Hayes the presidency during Reconstruction..
  12. News: Lozada . Carlos . Adam Schiff points to a second insurrection — by members of Congress themselves - In his memoir [''"Midnight In Washington: How We Almost Lost Our Democracy and Still Could"''], the House Intelligence Committee chair argues America barely passed Trump's 'stress test' of American democracy ]. October 8, 2021 . . October 9, 2021 .
  13. Web site: Can Veep Play the 'Pence Card' and Reject US Election Results? . Dan . Evon . December 23, 2020 . Snopes.com . 12 May 2024 .
  14. News: Why is the so-called 'Pence Card' a canard?. December 24, 2020 . statutesandstories.com . Adam . Levinson . January 11, 2021 .
  15. News: Alemany . Jacqueline . Brown . Emma . Hamburger . Tom . Swaine . Jon . Ahead of Jan. 6, Willard hotel in downtown D.C. was a Trump team 'command center' for effort to deny Biden the presidency . October 23, 2021 . . October 23, 2021 .
  16. News: The military-intelligence veterans who helped lead Trump's campaign of disinformation . . December 15, 2021. Ram Roston. Brad Heath. John Shiffman. Peter Eisler . 12 May 2024 .
  17. News: Broadwater . Luke . Feuer . Alan . Jan. 6 Panel and State Officials Seek Answers on Fake Trump Electors - Pressure is mounting on the Justice Department to investigate bogus electors who claimed that Donald J. Trump defeated Joseph R. Biden Jr. in their states. . January 21, 2022 . . January 22, 2022 .
  18. Web site: American Oversight Obtains Seven Phony Certificates of Pro-Trump Electors. March 2, 2021. American Oversight. 16 January 2022.
  19. News: Eggert . David . Michigan AG asks feds to investigate fake GOP electors . January 14, 2022 . . January 17, 2022 .
  20. News: Gangel . Jamie . Herb . Jeremy . Memo shows Trump lawyer's six-step plan for Pence to overturn the election . September 20, 2021 . . September 30, 2021 .
  21. News: The Editorial Board . Jan. 6 Was Worse Than We Knew . October 2, 2021 . . October 3, 2021 .
  22. Web site: Lowell. Hugo. Trump called aides hours before Capitol riot to discuss how to stop Biden victory. . 12 May 2024 . November 30, 2021 .
  23. News: Dawsey . Josh . Alemany . Jacqueline . Swaine . Jon . Brown . Emma . During Jan. 6 riot, Trump attorney told Pence team the vice president's inaction caused attack on Capitol . October 29, 2021 . . October 30, 2021 .
  24. News: Kaczynski . Andrew . Steck . Em . Trump lawyer John Eastman said 'courage and the spine' would help Pence send election to the House in comments before January 6 . October 30, 2021 . . October 30, 2021 .
  25. News: Stracqualursi . Veronica . Washington Post: Trump lawyer John Eastman blamed Pence for January 6 violence by refusing to block 2020 election certification . October 30, 2021 . . October 30, 2021 .
  26. News: Blake . Aaron . The most shocking new revelation about John Eastman - He and Trump were not just pressing forward despite the mob; they apparently were trying to leverage it. . October 30, 2021 . . October 30, 2021 .
  27. News: Broadwater . Luke . Trump Lawyer Blamed Pence for Violence as Rioters Stormed Capitol - John Eastman, the author of a memo that some in both parties liken to a blueprint for a coup, sent a hostile email to the vice president's chief counsel as the mob attacked. . October 30, 2021 . . October 31, 2021 .
  28. News: Helderman . Rosalind S. . Senior Trump official at State met with election denial activists Jan. 6 . 18 May 2022 . The Washington Post . 17 May 2022.
  29. News: Kilander . Gustaf . Trump could be blocked from running again, former White House ethics boss says - 'We should not have to deal with his candidacy in 2024' . October 5, 2021 . . November 4, 2021 .
  30. News: Schmidt . Michael S. . Haberman . Maggie . The Lawyer Behind the Memo on How Trump Could Stay in Office . . 2 October 2021 . 11 February 2022 .
  31. News: No, Thomas Jefferson Didn't Rig the 1800 Vote Count . January 5, 2021 . Holly . Brewer . April 16, 2024 . Washington Monthly .
  32. Web site: READ: Trump lawyer's memo on six-step plan for Pence to overturn the election . September 21, 2021 . . September 30, 2021.
  33. Web site: John Eastman's second memo on 'January 6 scenario' . 2024-07-03 . Washington Post . en.
  34. Web site: January 6 Process For Electoral Vote Count . Gregory . Jacob . Gregory Jacob . . December 8, 2020. Politico. 12 May 2024 .
  35. Web site: Fontana . Bruce . Ackerman . David . 2004-03-01 . How Jefferson Counted Himself In . 2023-05-31 . The Atlantic . en.
  36. Web site: Ackerman . Bruce . Khanna . Ro . 2020-09-13 . Op-Ed: Claims of a rigged election? Here's how Congress could save our democracy from vote-count chaos. . 2023-05-31 . Los Angeles Times . en-US.
  37. Web site: Brewer . Holly . December 31, 2020 . No, Jefferson didn't rig the 1800 vote count . Backbencher . 12 May 2024 .
  38. Web site: Brewer . Holly . More on this Jefferson nonsense . Backbencher . January 5, 2021 . 12 May 2024 .
  39. Luttig . J. Michael . Professor, your fascinating articles about Jefferson and the election of 1800 are brilliant expositions of the episode. Your historical — and historic — scholarship took its rightful place in political and constitutional history on January 5, 2021, where it will remain forever. . judgeluttig . 1589018782835834881 . 5 November 2022 . 16 April 2024 .
  40. Barr . William P. . en . Attorney General William P. Barr's resignation letter . President Donald J. Trump . 2020-12-14 . Washington, DC . Office of the Attorney General . Wikimedia Commons . https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:AG-Barr-resignation-letter.pdf&page=1 . 2022-06-10.
  41. Lauren Windsor . Lauren . Windsor . EXCLUSIVE: Last night, I asked Trump AG Bill Barr if he had spoken w/ coup memo author John Eastman. . lawindsor . 1519036868620218368 . 2022-06-10 . en.
  42. News: Tribe . Laurence H. . Buchanan . Neil H. . Dorf . Michael C. . How to prevent the legal strategy that nearly undid the last election from ending democracy - Congress needs to act and the executive branch needs to step up. . September 27, 2021 . . September 30, 2021 .
  43. News: Sullivan . Margaret . A Trump lawyer wrote an instruction manual for a coup. Why haven't you seen it on the news? . September 30, 2021 . . September 30, 2021 .
  44. News: Benen. Steve. Steve Benen. Trump lawyer outlined plan to overturn election in newly disclosed memo.The newly disclosed Eastman Memo sketched out a six-step scenario to overturn the election and keep Trump in power. It effectively outlined a coup. September 21, 2021 . . October 1, 2021 .
  45. News: Bookman. Jay. Eastman memo shows how close Georgia GOP chair came to enabling Trump coup. September 27, 2021 . ohiocapitaljournal.com. October 1, 2021 .
  46. News: Parton . Heather Digby . Trump's coup plot was worse than anyone knew - Republicans are trying their best to make attempted coups now normal politics in America . October 8, 2021 . . October 8, 2021 .
  47. News: Stern . Mark Joseph . The Legal Architects of Trump's Failed Coup May Finally Face Real Consequences . 5 October 2021 . . 5 October 2021 .
  48. News: Benner . Katie . Report Cites New Details of Trump Pressure on Justice Dept. Over Election - A Senate panel fleshed out how Donald Trump pursued his plan to install a loyalist as acting attorney general to pursue unfounded reports of fraud. . October 6, 2021 . . October 7, 2021 .
  49. Web site: . March 1, 2022 . California bar investigating Trump lawyer for ethic breaches . https://web.archive.org/web/20220302002218/https://www.abc10.com/article/news/local/california/california-bar-investigating-trump-lawyer-for-ethic-breaches-john-eastman/103-ec31b73b-e648-450f-afdb-cc9d9683b3b8 . 2 March 2022 . live . 2022-05-28 . abc10.com . en-US.
  50. News: Lynch . Sarah N. . 2022-03-29 . EXCLUSIVE Two former U.S. officials help ethics probe of Trump ally Clark, source says . en . Reuters . 2022-05-28.

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "Eastman memos".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.