Dunans Castle Explained

Dunans Castle
Map Type:Scotland Argyll and Bute
Status:Fire damaged ruin
Building Type:Mock castle
Location:Glendaruel, Cowal Peninsula, Argyll and Bute
Location City:Colintraive
Location Country:Scotland, United Kingdom
Coordinates:56.0725°N -5.1496°W, National
Destruction Date:-->
Owner:Charles Selwyn Dixon-Spain & Sadie Michaela Dixon-Spain
Unit Count:-->

Dunans Castle [1] is an historic structure located in Glendaruel, on the Cowal peninsula, Argyll and Bute, Scotland. The property is owned by Charles and Sadie Dixon-Spain. A property at Dounens was shown on maps in 1590; Dunans House was elaborated into its present mock castle form in 1864. Once part of a much larger estate the property presently includes 16acres of ground and in 2001 was ruined by fire.[2] [3] [4]

History

For over two centuries Dunans was home to the Fletcher Clan who moved to the site between 1715 and 1745 carrying with them the door of their previous home at Achallader Castle (the door was used for the private chapel and was reported missing in 1999).[5] The original mansion-style house (to the left in the picture) was extended into its present dramatic Franco-baronial "castle" form by the architect Andrew Kerr with the additions consisting of four main apartments and 6 bedrooms. The building passed out of Fletcher hands in 1997 when the entire 3000 acre Dunans estate was sold off by Colonel Archibald Fletcher's heirs and subsequently split up.[6] Following a number of financial problems,[7] the Category B listed castle was gutted by fire on 14 January 2001 while being run as a hotel and the building was left as a ruin.[8] The fire began in the attic space of the castle section and destroyed three floors with only the pre Victorian west wing surviving undamaged. The owner Ewa Lucas-Gardener had ignored fire safety experts warnings that the building's fireplaces were unsafe and abandoned the building after the insurers refused to pay out.[9] Now under new ownership,[10] [11] the site, including a Victorian path network, has undergone some restoration supported by the Dunans Charitable Trust.[12] The castle was reported to have three resident ghosts.[13]

Present day

Dunans Castle Limited, which runs the ScottishLaird.com website, published the Conservation Plan for Dunans in April 2014.[14] Written by conservation architect Robin Kent,[15] the book outlines the programme for the restoration of the castle and the bridge.

The regional blog ForArgyll.com is run from the site as is the Walking Theatre Company. The building remains in the at-risk category of the Buildings at Risk Register and is described as being in very poor condition.[16]

Bridge and mausoleum

Leading to the castle is Dunans Bridge, an A-listed structure, designed by Thomas Telford in 1815 and constructed to commemorate the battle of Waterloo by John Fletcher.[17]

Once part of the Dunans estate, but still in the ownership of the Fletchers is the Fletcher of Dunans Mausoleum, a grade C listed structure located in the gardens of the neighbouring Stronardron house.

Further buildings once part of the estate but now privately owned include Dunans Lodge, the original gate house to the estate and Dunans Cottage, two workers' cottages combined into one dwelling.

Scottish Laird fundraiser

The current owners operate a scheme whereby individuals can be given or can purchase "Laird or Lady packages" which entitle them to "own" a square foot of land in the grounds of Dunans Castle in Scotland and use the decorative title "Laird of Dunans" or "Lady of Dunans". The profits from the sale of these packages are used to restore this private property.

The Court of the Lord Lyon states that “ownership of a souvenir plot of land is not sufficient to bring a person otherwise ineligible within the jurisdiction of the Lord Lyon for seeking a coat of arms”, and indicated if these souvenir plots were being purchased for this purpose then they were as good as meaningless.[18] [19] The Scottish Land Register also does not recognise individual ownership of such small plots,[20] meaning purchase of these titles holds no legal entitlement to ownership of the land nor use of it: they are simply decorative.

Owners

Name(s)Ownership periodNotesSources
Archibald Fletcher, 9th Chief circa 1745-1763Recorded as resident in 1745, though the date of arrival could be any time between 1715 and 1745[21]
Angus Fletcher, 10th Chief 1763-1807
John Fletcher, 11th Chief 1807-1822Commissioned the bridge from Thomas Telford
Angus Fletcher, 12th Chief1822-1875Commissioned the gothic elaboration from Andrew Kerr
Harriet Fletcher
Bernard James Cuddon-Fletcher
1875-1889Cuddon took his wife's name, as did their children, keeping the estate in the Fletcher name[22]
Bernard James Cuddon-Fletcher1889-1934Cuddon-Fletcher kept the estate in his own right between his wife's death and his own demise
Andrew William Fletcher
Ian Archibald Fletcher
1934Shared between the previous owners 3rd and 4th sons
Ian Archibald Fletcher1934-1962Bought out his brother after the estate was left to them both
Colonel Archibald Ian Douglas "Archie" Fletcher1962-1997Upon his death his heirs sold the castle out of the Fletcher line
Jonathan Irving Hyslop
Pranee Hyslop
1997-1999[23]
Robert David Lucas-Gardiner
Ewa Jheresa Lucas-Gardiner
1999-2003[24]
Charles Selwyn Dixon-Spain
Sadie Michaela Dixon-Spain
2003-Bought the ruin for £230,000[25]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Charles Dixon-Spain . Charles Recommends our "The Conservation Plan for Dunans" by Robin Kent for all Lairds and Ladies . . 8 June 2023 . en.
  2. News: Police probe castle fire . BBC News . 2001-01-14 . 2011-12-23.
  3. News: Rebecca McQuillan . Highland hideaway destroyed by fire Forensic teams and firefighters search ruins for cause. Herald Scotland . 2001-01-15 . 2011-12-23.
  4. News: Lord and lady of manor hailed from Hull . Herald Scotland . 2001-01-15 . 2011-12-23.
  5. https://web.archive.org/web/20140611135235/http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-60357649.html Missing door is 700 years old. (News) - Daily Record (Glasgow, Scotland), September 23, 1999
  6. News: Slice of family history changes hands . Herald Scotland . 1999-09-09 . 2011-12-23.
  7. Web site: Hughes. Lorna. FAKE LORD AND LADY OWE US ALL A PILE; Taxman and Customs chasing cash from couple in the castle. - Free Online Library . Thefreelibrary.com . 2000-10-01 . 2011-12-23.
  8. News: In Depth | Photo Gallery | Your Pictures: 25 Oct-31 Oct . BBC News . 2003-10-31 . 2011-12-23.
  9. https://web.archive.org/web/20140611135242/http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-18809967.html Gutted castle's future bleak as couple flee - The Scotsman, James Doherty, December 10, 2001
  10. News: Sue Tranter . In a class of their own Home front Designs on a dream retreat? Here are four that were built as one-offs and guarantee exclusivity, says Sue Tranter . Herald Scotland . 2002-05-11 . 2011-12-23.
  11. News: On the market: Lancashire, Somerset, Argyll . https://web.archive.org/web/20140601232354/http://www.telegraph.co.uk/property/propertyadvice/propertymarket/3302620/On-the-market-Lancashire-Somerset-Argyll.html . dead . 2014-06-01 . The Daily Telegraph . 2002-05-25 . 2012-01-12.
  12. Web site: Dunans Heritage Project . Dunanscastle.org . 2011-04-26 . 2012-05-25.
  13. Web site: Castle Weddings-Madonna, Skibo Castle . Lovetripper.com . 2012-10-13 . https://web.archive.org/web/20140827062026/http://www.lovetripper.com/PRESS/scottishcastlewedding.html . 2014-08-27 . dead .
  14. Web site: The Conservation Plan for Dunans, Lairds and Ladies edition is Published!. 2014-06-24.
  15. Web site: Robin Kent architecture . 2014-06-24.
  16. Web site: Dunans Castle, Glendaruel | Buildings at Risk Register for Scotland . Buildingsatrisk.org.uk . 2012-10-13.
  17. Web site: News Archive . Dunoon-observer.com . 2012-01-10 . 23 September 2015 . https://web.archive.org/web/20150923220923/http://www.dunoon-observer.com/archive/arcmay2017.html . dead .
  18. Web site: Caution the souvenir hunters . The Journal Online . 2018-12-22.
  19. News: Cramb . Auslan . How to lord it over your friends for only £29.99 . The Daily Telegraph . 2004-12-11 . 2012-05-31.
  20. Web site: Terms . https://web.archive.org/web/20140503230044/http://www.scots-titles.com/images/Terms-Laird-Dunans-Castle.pdf . dead . 2014-05-03 . PDF . 2012-10-13.
  21. Web site: The Fletchers of Dunans, The Fletcher of Glenorchy, An Ancient Scottish Clan . Spaceless.com . 2012-10-13.
  22. Web site: Dunans: The Fletcher of Glenorchy - An Ancient Scottish Clan . https://web.archive.org/web/20041021044738/http://www.spaceless.com/fletcher/flet4_pedigree.htm . 2004-10-21 . Web.archive.org . 2004-10-21 . 2012-10-13.
  23. Web site: Judgement of Scottish Law Courts.
  24. https://web.archive.org/web/20140610193740/http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-18781146.html "The countess, her castle, and the fake Faberg eggs", The Scotsman, John Woodcock, January 20, 2001
  25. https://web.archive.org/web/20140610193739/http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1P2-13050638.html "Mill conversion would 'destroy' value of castle", The Scotsman, John Ross, August 2, 2004