Vermont Golden Dome Book Award Explained

The Vermont Golden Dome Book Award (formerly the Dorothy Canfield Fisher Children's Book Award) annually recognizes one new American children's book selected by the vote of Vermont schoolchildren. It was inaugurated in 1957.

The award is co-sponsored by the Vermont State PTA and the Vermont Department of Libraries and was originally named after the Vermont writer Dorothy Canfield Fisher. In 2020, it was temporarily renamed the "VT Middle-Grade Book Award" before schoolchildren voted to officially call it the "Vermont Golden Dome Book Award".

Selection process and award

Each spring a committee of eight adults selects a "Master List" of thirty books first published during the previous calendar year. The list is announced at the annual Dorothy Canfield Fisher Conference, usually in May, and is available at Vermont school and public libraries for children who wish to participate over the next eleven months. The following spring, those children who have read at least five of the thirty books are eligible to vote for the award, with a deadline in mid-April. The award ceremony is scheduled after the end of the school year, usually late June. Thus the award is always for books published two years previously.

The winning writer is invited to visit Vermont to speak with children about the experience of writing for children.[1]

Awards in other categories

Vermont sponsors two other statewide book awards determined by the votes of younger and older students.

The Red Clover Book Award recognizes a picture book published two years earlier. Voters are children in grades K–4 who have read, or heard read aloud, all 10 books on the list. The Red Clover BA was established by 1997–98, if not earlier, and its 2014 winner was announced by May. It is the centerpiece of a one-day conference in October.

The Green Mountain Book Award is voted by high school students (grades 9–12, routinely ages 14–18) either through a school library or individually online, deadline May 31. Students are asked to vote only once and to read at least 3 from a list of 15 books (for 2014, published 2008–2012; for 2015, published 2011–2013). The Green Mountain BA was inaugurated in 2006.

Winners

One book by a single writer has won the Vermont Golden Dome Book Award every year since 1957.

Award winners!Year!Author!Title!Ref.
1957Old Bones, the Wonder Horse
1958Fifteen
1959Comanche of the Seventh
1960Double or Nothing
1961Captain Ghost
1962City under the Back Steps
1963
1964Bristle Face
1965Rascal
1966Ribsy
1967
1968
1969Two in the Wilderness
1970Kävik the Wolf Dog
1971Go to the Room of the Eyes
1972Flight of the White Wolf
1973Never Steal a Magic Cat
1974Catch a Killer
1975
1976
1977
1978Summer of Fear
1979Kid Power
1980Bones on Black Spruce Mountain
1981Bunnicula
1982
1983Tiger Eyes
1984
1985Dear Mr. Henshaw
1986
1987
1988Wait Till Helen Comes
1989Hatchet
1990Where It Stops, Nobody Knows
1991Number the Stars
1992Maniac Magee
1993Shiloh
1994Jennifer Murdley's Toad
1995
1996Time for Andrew
1997Mick Harte Was Here
1998
1999Ella Enchanted
2000Holes
2001Bud, Not Buddy
2002Because of Winn-Dixie
2003Love That Dog
2004Loser
2005
2006
2007Flush
2008Diary of a Wimpy Kid
2009Rules
2010
201111 Birthdays
2012Smile
2013
2014Wonder
2015Escape from Mr. Lemoncello's Library
2016El Deafo
2017 and Mac Barnett[2]
2018Projekt 1065[3]
2019Refugee[4]
2020Small Spaces

Multiple awards

Several writers have won more than one DCF Award: Beverly Cleary in 1958, 1966, and 1985; Mary Downing Hahn in 1988, 1996, and 2006; Jerry Spinelli and Kate DiCamillo and Alan Gratz twice each.

Seven times from 1985 to 2005, and no others, the schoolchildren selected the winner of the annual Newbery Medal (dated one year earlier, established 1922). That award by the Association for Library Service to Children recognizes the year's "most distinguished contribution to American literature for children". The first agreement of Vermont children with U.S. children's librarians was their 1985 selection of Dear Mr. Henshaw by Cleary and there were six more such agreements during the next twenty years to 2005.[5]

Controversy and renaming

In 2018, there was a call from the Vermont Library Board to change the name of the award to no longer honor Dorothy Canfield Fisher, following a report that she had ties to Vermont's eugenics movement.[6] [7] In April 2019, the Vermont Department of Libraries announced that the award would be renamed in 2020.[8] It was temporarily renamed the "VT Middle-Grade Book Award".[9] [10] In November 2020, it was officially renamed the "Vermont Golden Dome Book Award" after a vote by Vermont elementary school students.[11] [12]

Notes and References

  1. Bang-Jensen . Valerie . A Children's Choice Program: Insights into Book Selection, Social Relationships, and Reader Identity . Language Arts . 87 . 3 . 169–76 . 2010 .
  2. Web site: Winners of the Dorothy Canfield Fisher Book Award . libraries.vermont.gov.
  3. News: Noyes . Amy Kolb . April 30, 2018 . 'Projekt 1065' Wins 2018 Dorothy Canfield Fisher Book Award . Vermont Public Radio . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20200627202553/https://www.vpr.org/post/projekt-1065-wins-2018-dorothy-canfield-fisher-book-award . June 27, 2020.
  4. News: Noyes . Amy Kolb . June 4, 2019 . Dorothy's List: Alan Gratz Wins Dorothy Canfield Fisher Book Award For Second Straight Year . Vermont Public Radio . live . https://web.archive.org/web/20190607141526/https://www.vpr.org/post/dorothys-list-alan-gratz-wins-dorothy-canfield-fisher-book-award-second-straight-year . June 7, 2019.
  5. Web site: Welcome to the Newbery Medal Home Page!. Association for Library Service to Children. American Library Association. 2014-04-20.
  6. News: Vermont Considers Dumping Dorothy Canfield Fisher Over Ties to Eugenics Movement. Walsh. Molly. 2017-06-21. Seven Days. 2018-04-13. en.
  7. News: Library Board Pushes to Rename Dorothy Canfield Fisher Award. Walsh. Molly. 2018-01-11. Seven Days. 2018-04-13. en.
  8. Web site: Dorothy Canfield Fisher Book Award To Be Renamed In 2020. Noyes. Amy Kolb. VPR.org. en. 2019-07-20.
  9. Web site: VT Middle-Grade Book Award . Vermont Department of Libraries . https://web.archive.org/web/20200627204858/https://libraries.vermont.gov/services/children_and_teens/book_awards/vtmgba . June 27, 2020 . dead.
  10. Web site: Library News . Essex Westford School District . https://web.archive.org/web/20200627211821/https://www.ewsd.org/site/default.aspx?PageType=14&DomainID=563&PageID=1092&ModuleInstanceID=8214 . June 27, 2020 . dead.
  11. Web site: Vermont Golden Dome Book Award . Vermont Department of Libraries . November 11, 2021 . https://web.archive.org/web/20211027063919/https://libraries.vermont.gov/services/children_and_teens/book_awards/vtgdba . October 27, 2021 . live.
  12. Web site: Vermont students select new middle-grade book award . VTDigger . November 11, 2021 . Press release . November 12, 2020.