Disabled parking permits of the United States explained

In the United States, reserved spaces are mandated by the Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines.[1]

Disabled placards

The following table, current as of 2020, shows the state agency responsible for issuing disabled parking placards, expiration of permanent/temporary placards, fees (if applicable), and supplementary notes.

State agencyExpiration of permanent placardsExpiration of temporary placardsFeesNotes
Department of Revenue5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Administration5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation (ADOT)None6 monthsNo costPreviously permanent handicap placards expired after 5 years but as of April 2019, these placards do not expire after the passage of a new state law.[2]
Department of Finance and Administration4 years3 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor Vehicles2 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $6 for temporary
Department of Revenue3 years3 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor VehiclesExpires at the same time as drivers license/ID card6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $5 for temporary
Department of TransportationExpires at the same time as drivers license/ID cardAt doctor's discretionNo costExpiration of temporary permits is determined by length of time doctor puts on application
Division of Motor Vehicles3 years3 monthsNo cost
Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $15 for temporary
Department of Revenue4 years6 monthsNo cost
Disability and Communication Access Board6 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $12 for temporaryHawaii has delegated issuance of disabled permits to the City and County of Honolulu, as well as the counties of Hawaii, Kauai and Maui.
Transportation DepartmentNone6 monthsNo cost
Secretary of StateNoneVaries (see notes)No costTemporary permits expire after 3 months if issued by local municipality or 6 months if issued by the Secretary of State.
Bureau of Motor VehiclesNoneVaries (see notes)No cost for permanent; $5 for temporaryTemporary permits expire either after date given by doctor on application or 1 year (whichever is shorter).
Department of Transportation5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue5 years6 monthsNo cost
Transportation Cabinet6 years3 monthsNo costRenewals or replacement of lost or stolen placards cost $10.[3]
Office of Motor Vehicles4 years1 year$3
Secretary of State4 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of TransportationNone6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation5 yearsAt doctor's discretionNo costExpiration of temporary permits is determined by length of time doctor puts on application
Secretary of State4 years6 monthsNo costRenewals or replacement of lost or stolen placards cost $10.
Department of Public Safety6 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $5 for temporary
Department of Revenue5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $2 for temporary
Department of Justice3 years6 monthsNo costPermanent placards issued prior to October 1993 do not require renewal.
Department of Motor Vehicles6 yearsVaries (see notes)No costTemporary placards expire after either 3 or 6 months as determined by doctor's discretion
Department of Motor Vehicles10 yearsVaries (see notes)No costTemporary placards in Nevada come in two varieties: temporary (valid for 6 months) and moderate (valid for up to 2 years)
Department of Safety5 years6 monthsNo costPermanent placards expire at the same time as drivers license or ID card, so first placard may expire in less than 5 years but subsequent placards will expire in 5 years.
Motor Vehicles Commission3 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $4 for temporary
Motor Vehicles Department4 years12 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor VehiclesSee notes6 monthsNo costPermanent placards expire at the discretion of the issuing agency (village, town, city).
Department of Transportation5 years6 months$5 each for permanent and temporary (limited to 2 placards)
Department of Transportation3 years3 monthsNo cost for permanent; $3 for temporary
Bureau of Motor Vehicles5 years6 months$5 for permanent and temporary
Department of Motor Vehicles5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor Vehicles8 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation (PennDOT)5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue3+ yearsVaries (see notes)No costIn Rhode Island, temporary placards come in two varieties: temporary (valid up to 12 months) and long-term (valid from 1-3 years)
Department of Motor Vehicles4 years12 months$1 for permanent and temporary
Department of Transportation5 years12 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue2 years6 months$26.50 and $3 renewal for permanent and $10 and $10 renewal for temporaryNo charge for permanent placard if vehicle registration is in applicant's name, however $3 renewal charge still applies; $2 charge for replacement placards
Department of Transportation4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $5 for temporary
State Tax Commission2 years6 monthsNo cost
Agency of Transportation4 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor Vehicles5 years6 months$5 for permanent and temporary$5 for replacement placards
Department of Licensing5 years12 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation (WisDOT)4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $6 for temporary
Department of Transportation (WYDOT)10 years6 monthsNo cost

Disabled plates

The following table, current as of 2020, shows the state agency responsible for issuing disabled plates, length of validity of registration for plates and/or any renewal requirements (if applicable), fees (either regular automotive registration fees and/or any fees charged beyond regular automotive registration fees), fee amounts if assessed beyond regular automotive registration fees (if applicable), and supplementary notes.

State agencyLength of validity on platesFeesAdditional fees beyond regular registration?Notes
Department of Revenue5 years renewal$23-105, depending on type of vehicle registeredN/A
Department of Administration5 yearsNo cost (see notes)N/AFirst set of plates is free, but additional set of plates (or commercial plates) cost $100 in registration fees plus applicable motor vehicle registration taxes.
Department of Transportation (ADOT)Valid as long as renewed regularly (either 1 or 2 years depending on driver's choice)Payment of regular registration feesN/A
Department of Finance and Administration1 yearPayment of regular registration feesN/A
Department of Motor VehiclesValid as long as renewed regularlyPayment of regular registration feesN/A
Department of Revenue3 years3 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor VehiclesExpires at the same time as drivers license/ID card6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $5 for temporary
Department of TransportationExpires at the same time as drivers license/ID cardAt doctor's discretionNo costExpiration of temporary permits is determined by length of time doctor puts on application
Division of Motor Vehicles3 years3 monthsNo cost
Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $15 for temporary
Department of Revenue4 years6 monthsNo cost
Disability and Communication Access Board6 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $12 for temporaryHawaii has delegated issuance of disabled permits to the City and County of Honolulu, as well as the counties of Hawaii, Kauai and Maui.
Transportation DepartmentNone6 monthsNo cost
Secretary of StateNoneVaries (see notes)No costTemporary permits expire after 3 months if issued by local municipality or 6 months if issued by the Secretary of State.
Bureau of Motor VehiclesNoneVaries (see notes)No cost for permanent; $5 for temporaryTemporary permits expire either after date given by doctor on application or 1 year (whichever is shorter).
Department of Transportation5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue5 years6 monthsNo cost
Transportation Cabinet6 years3 monthsNo costRenewals or replacement of lost or stolen placards cost $10.[4]
Office of Motor Vehicles4 years1 year$3
Secretary of State4 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of TransportationNone6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation5 yearsAt doctor's discretionNo costExpiration of temporary permits is determined by length of time doctor puts on application
Secretary of State4 years6 monthsNo costRenewals or replacement of lost or stolen placards cost $10.
Department of Public Safety6 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $5 for temporary
Department of Revenue5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $2 for temporary
Department of Justice3 years6 monthsNo costPermanent placards issued prior to October 1993 do not require renewal.
Department of Motor Vehicles6 yearsVaries (see notes)No costTemporary placards expire after either 3 or 6 months as determined by doctor's discretion
Department of Motor Vehicles10 yearsVaries (see notes)No costTemporary placards in Nevada come in two varieties: temporary (valid for 6 months) and moderate (valid for up to 2 years)
Department of Safety5 years6 monthsNo costPermanent placards expire at the same time as drivers license or ID card, so first placard may expire in less than 5 years but subsequent placards will expire in 5 years.
Motor Vehicles Commission3 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $4 for temporary
Motor Vehicles Department4 years12 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor VehiclesSee notes6 monthsNo costPermanent placards expire at the discretion of the issuing agency (village, town, city).
Department of Transportation5 years6 months$5 each for permanent and temporary (limited to 2 placards)
Department of Transportation3 years3 monthsNo cost for permanent; $3 for temporary
Bureau of Motor Vehicles5 years6 months$5 for permanent and temporary
Department of Motor Vehicles5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor Vehicles8 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation (PennDOT)5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue3+ yearsVaries (see notes)No costIn Rhode Island, temporary placards come in two varieties: temporary (valid up to 12 months) and long-term (valid from 1-3 years)
Department of Motor Vehicles4 years12 months$1 for permanent and temporary
Department of Transportation5 years12 monthsNo cost
Department of Revenue2 years6 months$26.50 and $3 renewal for permanent and $10 and $10 renewal for temporaryNo charge for permanent placard if vehicle registration is in applicant's name, however $3 renewal charge still applies; $2 charge for replacement placards
Department of Transportation4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $5 for temporary
State Tax Commission2 years6 monthsNo cost
Agency of Transportation4 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Motor Vehicles5 years6 months$5 for permanent and temporary$5 for replacement placards
Department of Licensing5 years12 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation5 years6 monthsNo cost
Department of Transportation (WisDOT)4 years6 monthsNo cost for permanent; $6 for temporary
Department of Transportation (WYDOT)10 years6 monthsNo cost

Disabled parking space requirements

According to the Americans With Disabilities Act Handbook, "Accessible parking spaces should be at least 96 in (2440 mm) wide. Parking access aisles shall be part of an accessible route to the building or facility entrance..."[5]

Disabled parking permits generally take the form of either specially marked license plates or a placard that hangs from the rear-view mirror. Plates are generally used for disabled drivers on their personal vehicle, while the portable disability placard can be moved from one vehicle to another with the disabled person, both when driving or when riding with another driver.

The medical requirements to obtain a permit vary by state, but are usually confined to specific types of disabilities or conditions. These as a general rule include the use of any assistive device such as a wheelchair, crutches, or cane, as well as a missing leg or foot. Some states also include certain cardiovascular, pain, or respiratory conditions. About half of US states (26) include blindness as a qualifying disability enabling the person to obtain a disability parking permit for use as a passenger, and 14 states include a disabled hand as a qualifying disability. Four states include deafness (Georgia, Kentucky, Virginia, Wyoming), and two states (Virginia and New York) include mental illness or developmental disabilities as qualifying disabilities.[6] [7]

Disability parking placards come in various colors with the significance varying from state to state. The most common are red for temporary placards and blue for permanent ones.

The availability of specially reserved parking spaces is regulated by both federal and state laws. Generally at least one space is available at any public parking location, with more being required based on the size of the parking lot and in some cases the type of location, such as a health care facility. Parking spaces reserved for disabled people are typically marked with the International Symbol of Access, though in practice, the design of the symbol varies widely.[8] Often, the parking space is delineated with blue lines instead of the white or yellow lines used elsewhere in the lot. Anyone parking in such reserved spaces must have their disability plate or mirror placard displayed, or else the car can be ticketed for illegal parking. In some major US cities, local law also allows such vehicles to park for free at city parking meters and also exempts from time limits on time parked. In the US states of California, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, and Virginia, holders of a Disabled parking permit are exempt from parking meter fees (in Illinois, only disabled drivers who meet specific criteria are eligible for free parking). In some states (including Virginia) accessible-designated parking meters exist, which, unless the permit holder is exempt, must be paid at the same rate as non-designated meters. One will also be subject to receiving a violation ticket if a valid disability license plate or placard is not displayed on the vehicle. Fraudulent use of another person's placard is heavily fined.

If traveling from other countries, requirements to obtain a parking permit vary from state to state. Some states will honor other country permits, while others require application as a visitor/tourist.[9]

Canada's provinces will honor a US state issued disabled plate or placard since US states will honor Canadian disabled plates and placards.

In all types of dwellings, United States federal law states that it is unlawful and discriminatory to refuse services that may assist in making reasonable accommodations for those with disabilities. This includes any services or facilities that are necessary in order for the occupant to inhabit their dwelling as deemed standard.[10] [11]

Integration with electric vehicle charging

In California alone, there are over 27,000 Plug in Electric Vehicles (PEV) with about 2,000 being added every month. While most PEV charging is done at home, the public charging infrastructure is also expanding, with 6,218 public charging stations as of July 2013.[12] Although the number of PEVs is still a small portion of the cars on the road, and the number of PEVs with Handicap placards is much smaller still, the needs of handicap PEV drivers must be integrated with public charging spaces. Guidelines are that 1 in 25 PEV Charging Stations be made ADA space compliant.[13] Although not intuitively obvious, it's important to recognize that a PEV charging station is not parking space, rather a charging service, in the same manner that gas station fill up spots are not parking spaces. Electric vehicle charging stations that meet the ADA space requirements are not to be reserved exclusively for the use of persons with disabilities,[14] they are shared by any PEV needing to charge. Further more any PEV charging space, ADA space compliant or not, cannot be used by non-PEV vehicles, including those with handicap placards. Recommended signage, along with common courtesy, ask that ADA space compliant charging stations are to be used last.

Abuse

The abuse and misuse of disabled parking permits has been identified as a major problem in the US, with some estimates indicating the majority seen on the street are used or obtained fraudulently.[15] The substantial privilege and convenience granted by a permit provides a major incentive to use one illegally or obtain one fraudulently, and medical privacy law often confounds attempts to identify truly disabled individuals from abuses. In 1999, for example, 19 of UCLA's current and former football players were charged with abuse of disabled parking placards.[16] [17] [18] In 2013 a news program in Los Angeles filmed people using disabled parking placards outside a health club, including one of the health club's celebrity instructors and young adults with the placard of a 77-year-old.[19]

Abuse occurs under the following circumstances:

A related issue is physician approval of permits for medical conditions that do not actually qualify under that jurisdiction's requirements. Often this is simply an error on the physician's part due to not fully understanding the law. A common example is cognitive, psychiatric, or developmental conditions (such as autism), which in all but two states do not qualify for a permit. Such permits are still legal and valid, and most recipients honestly believe they have a qualifying disability. The result is far more permits than existing parking spaces can usually support, which often leaves more severely disabled individuals without a place to park.[22]

Disabled persons who hold parking permits but have invisible disabilities may be difficult to tell apart from fraudulent permit users.[23] [24] On occasion, suspicion of fraud has led to hostility against legitimate permit holders.[25] [26] [27]

New York City

Disabled drivers from outside New York City who possess state-issued disability parking permits have claimed illegal discrimination and civil rights violations on the part of New York City. In 1991 a disabled elderly man from New Jersey was issued a ticket while parking in Brooklyn while displaying his New Jersey-issued disability parking placard.[28] In 1997 a woman with multiple sclerosis using a wheelchair was similarly issued a ticket while parking in New York City for displaying a non-NYC issued disability parking placard.[29] Both drivers maintain that failure to recognize non-NYC disability parking placards is a violation of their civil rights.

The city does recognize valid placards from other jurisdictions for marked disabled parking spaces, all of which are in off-street lots.[30]

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. Web site: 4.6 Parking and Passenger Loading Zones. 14 December 2016. ADA Accessibility Guidelines for Buildings and Facilities (ADAAG). United States Access Board.
  2. Web site: Permanent disability placards no longer require renewals. 5 April 2019. 7 November 2019. Associated Press.
  3. Web site: Latek. Tom. 27 July 2018. New law changing handicap parking placards effective Sept. 17. 20 July 2020. Kentucky Today.
  4. Web site: Latek. Tom. 27 July 2018. New law changing handicap parking placards effective Sept. 17. 20 July 2020. Kentucky Today.
  5. Book: U.S. Department of Justice. Americans with Disabilities Act Handbook. October 1991. Equal Opportunity Commission and the U.S. Department of Justice. 25.
  6. Web site: Disabled Parking Placards or License Plates Application. 19 December 2009. Virginia Department of Motor Vehicles.
  7. Web site: Application for a Parking Permit or License Plates, for Persons with Severe Disabilities. 19 December 2009. New York State Department of Motor Vehicles.
  8. Web site: www.youcantparkhere.com (A gallery of accessible parking symbols). 19 December 2009.
  9. Web site: Disabled Parking Permits For Visitors to the United States. 26 January 2019. U.S. Department of State.
  10. Web site: Are condo associations required to allocate handicap parking?.
  11. Web site: Q&A: How to handle handicapped/Reserved parking? - Q&A: How to handle handicapped/Reserved parking?.
  12. http://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/electricity_locations.html Electric Vehicle Charging Station Locations
  13. Web site: Interim Disabled Access Guidelines for 97-03 Electrical Vehicle Charging Stations.
  14. Web site: State of California Governor's Office of Planning and Research, Plug-In Electric Vehicles: Universal Charging Access Guidelines and Best Practices.
  15. Web site: Shoup. Donald. Ending the Abuse of Disabled Parking Placards. dead. https://web.archive.org/web/20140724115905/http://www.uctc.net/access/39/access39_almanac.pdf. 24 July 2014. 4 October 2012.
  16. Web site: Peters. Justin. 27 August 2013. Handicapped-Parking Fraud Is Just About the Jerkiest Crime Imaginable. 13 February 2017. Slate.
  17. News: Berthelsen. Christian. 29 July 1999. College Football; 9 Enter Pleas in U.C.L.A. Parking Case. The New York Times . The New York Times. 13 February 2017.
  18. News: Wharton. David. 14 September 1999. Five More Charged in Parking Scandal. Los Angeles Times. 13 February 2017.
  19. News: 31 January 2013. CBS2 Investigation Looks Into Use of Disabled Parking Placards. CBS2 Los Angeles.
  20. Web site: Chirbas. Kurt. 29 July 2015. California DMV cracks down on misuse of disability parking placards. 27 February 2017. Los Angeles Times.
  21. Web site: TEGNA. One out of every 8 California drivers now has a disabled parking placard. 27 February 2017. KPNX. They also charged some drivers with fraud after they discovered forged doctor signatures on applications..
  22. Web site: Chirbas. Kurt. 29 July 2015. California DMV cracks down on misuse of disability parking placards. 27 February 2017. Los Angeles Times. "It brings to mind there are doctors out there who might be over-prescribing," said R. Michael Paravagna, a member of the Commission on Disability Access. "Maybe they are handing them out like candy.".
  23. News: Bernstein. Sharon. 6 May 2003. Handicap That Allows Parking Isn't Always Obvious. Los Angeles Times. 13 February 2017.
  24. Web site: Ayres. Ian. 10 January 2011. How Can We Stop Handicap Fraud?. 13 February 2017. Freakonomics.
  25. Web site: Invisible Disabilities Association. 2004. Looks Can be Deceiving. 30 January 2013.
  26. Web site: Cline. Katie. People with invisible disabilities face discrimination while using parking passes. 13 February 2017. The Red & Black.
  27. Web site: Fleshler. David. Parking lot vigilantes abuse woman with 'invisible' disability. 13 February 2017. Sun Sentinel. 2 January 2015 .
  28. News: Hanley. Robert. 5 June 1991. New York Urged to Broaden Handicapped-Parking Rights. The New York Times.
  29. News: Page. Jeffrey. 5 December 1997. ENCOUNTERING THE WOODEN HEART OF LITTLE OLD N.Y.. The Record.
  30. Web site: NYC DOT. nyc.gov.